Weighing Advantages and Disadvantages of Smart Cities
Weighing Advantages and Disadvantages of Smart Cities
Shazada Mommayev
Department of Petroleum and Natural Gas Engineering, Middle East Technical University
January 2, 2023
2
Nowadays, technology plays an excessive role in the development of many aspects of our
society. The structure of cities is not an exception, and the concept of "smart cities" recently
emerged in the city and regional planning systems. Smart cities could be defined as the cities
within which innovative technology is applied to make their citizens’ lives more prosperous.
While this approach assists in many aspects of society, some obstacles such as privacy concerns
and social exclusion should not go unnoticed. Therefore, prior to investing in smart cities, these
obstacles need to be taken into consideration and dealt with properly so that the exclusion of
To begin with, many researchers and articles indicate that there are considerable advantages of
this technology in many aspects of the service industry that consequently improve the quality of
life. According to Albash (2023), the whole system of smart cities is mainly facilitated by the
Internet of Things (IoT). This is technology that assists in improving the management of the city
by collecting and assessing an enormous quantity of data. This means that, with the assistance of
the system, traffic issues, and crime rates can be decreased, and some upcoming natural
disasters can be warned and prevented. This system assures that an immense amount of
collected data is secured and obeys privacy rules. However, it raises particular concerns
regarding privacy and misuse of this information. The research held by de Montjoye et al. (2015,
as cited in Green, 2019) in which solely anonymous personal IDs were included 90% of real
personal identities were identified by analyzing the data collected by the IoT system. One may
claim that there are ways not to be tracked by not using particular services. With the
development of this system, more services become online. Consequently, one who opts not to
be tracked would most likely be excluded from transportation when the ticket system turns
online platform. Another instance of this could be experienced in the health care system, lately,
more doctor appointments are held online. Even staying connected with your close ones can
become a challenge if communication shifts to a particular phone application. Another point that
3
is worth mentioning is that according to Green (2019) even without using any service provided
by IoT and mobile applications, the surveillance system of smart cities would make it a
challenging experience. As a result, one who decides not to be tracked may not achieve it even
without using any of the services mentioned above. This can lead to an ethical issue such as
exclusion from social participation and more importantly fundamental privacy rights.
Consequently, it can lead to creating or worsening existing social gaps. Thus, minorities could
face discrimination by the use of information collected from surveillance cameras which are also
Conclusively, while smart cities would improve the life satisfaction of most of its residents,
obstacles such as privacy concerns and misuse of the collected data should be properly dealt
with. Consequently, we can build cities that serve its citizens and not exclude any of them.
4
References
Albaş, Ö. (2023). From science fiction to reality: How smart cities are revolutionizing urban life.
In Ö. Albaş, & E. Aksoy, The forefront: Achieving academic success 1 (2nd ed., pp. 70-73).
Pelikan Publishing
Green, B. (2023). The responsible city: Avoiding technology’s undemocratic social contracts. In Ö.
Albaş, & E. Aksoy, The forefront: Achieving academic success 1 (2nd ed., pp. 79-81).
Pelikan Publishing. (Adapted from The smart enough city: Putting technology in its place
to reclaim our urban future, pp. 91-116, by B. Green, 2019, MIT Press)