TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION

Prepared by:
Date :
Le Dinh Ly
PACKAGE: PROVISION SERVICES FOR RENTAL CRAWLER CRANE Reviewed by:
TBE No: GLF3-WHP-TBE-001
FOR CONSTRUCTION 02 JACKET KA & JA Le Dinh Ly
Approved by:
TBE Rev: 0
Tran Van Tuan

REQUIREMENT DATA Vendor 1 Evaluation Remarks

A BIDDER INFORMATION
1 Bidder Name: Duc Huynh Transport & Construction Co.,LTD
2 Contact Point: Nguyen Van Huynh
3 Tel.: 0913 139 181
4 E-Mail: [email protected]
B BIDDER EXPERIENCE & CAPABILITIES
1 Prequalification
1.1 Bidder have to prepare and submit together with his proposal, the
prequalification documents following
Company profile:
1.1.1 Bidder to provide the Business Registeration of Head Office and Branch Bidder to Provided Passed
Office for Foreigner Company
Financial information (last three (3) years):
1.1.2 Last 3 years 2018 Last 2 years 2019 Last year 2020
Bidder to provide the evidence and fill in the table
Revenue: 44.190.040.202 28.814.099.852 11.926.248.676 Passed
Gross Profit: 1.893.597.446 3.505.399.886 2.055.304.089 Passed
Net Income: 1.476.043.082 2.723.211.911 1.483.816.115 Passed
Assets: 83.237.124.154 70.372.742.162 61.332.899.376 Passed
Work Experience and Project Reference for registered work category.
Un-priced similar contract to be provided for further evaluation.
The Bidder shall submit a list of 02 similar works executed by the Bidder Passed
1.1.3 Value Unit Location
over past
Operators must have at least 05 years of experience within the scope of
quotation and perform at least 2 projects of similar nature.
History completed contract:
Provided Crawler Crane 600T for VJG - Vnd Long Son, BRVT Passed
Provided Crawler Crane 600T, 250T at Dinh Co gas processing plant - Vnd Dinh Co, BRVT Passed
Provided Crawler Crane 600T for DKI-P5,P6 project and other project - Vnd PVC-MS, BRVT Passed
Provided Crawler Crane 1250T for Installing 08 columns for Vietnam's Passed
- Vnd Ha Noi, VN
National Assembly house
C GENERAL REQUIREMENTS

Page 1 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Vendor 1 Evaluation Remarks
Bidder shall confirm its full compliance with all technical and commercial Passed
1 Bidder to confirm
terms and conditions stipulated in ITB documents.
2 Bidder shall confirm that price quotation shall be fully complied with the Passed
Bidder to confirm
SOW provided in ITB.
Bidder shall confirm that any deviation shall be listed in deviation list.
3 Any deviation listed outside the deviation list shall be not accepted and Bidder to confirm Passed
deem to be comply with the requirement
Work schedule for the Contract: Passed
4 Bidder to confirm
Bidder to confirm, and comply with the project requirements
5 Organization chart
Bidder to provide Organization Chart Bidder to Provided Passed
Curriculum Vitae (CV) for key personnel (i.e. name, qualification, Passed
Bidder to Provided
experience, background, age, length of service in his company, etc.).
6 Manpower & Equipment Mobilization
Bidder to provide Equipment Mobilization Plan to cap with the preliminary Passed
Bidder to Provided
project schedule.
RESULT Passed
D SCOPE OF WORK/ SUPPLY
I GENERAL
1 Material Supply
Bidder will be provide Fuel diesel and Lubricant for Crawler Crane Bidder to Provided Passed
2 Labor
Operators must have at least 05 years of experience within the scope of Passed
Bidder to Provided
quotation and perform at least 2 projects of similar nature.
3 Equipment machinery
Mobilization & Demobilization of transport equipment & personnel under Passed
- Bidder to Provided
this provision
- Lifting Capacity required by Client Bidder to Provided Passed
- auxiliary lifting lever required by Client Bidder to Provided Passed
- Counter weight required by Client Bidder to Provided Passed
- valid accreditation Bidder to Provided Passed
- Loadtest Bidder to Provided Passed
4 Safety and security
Bidder will comply with all safety requirements of Passed
- Bidder confirmed compliance
PVC-MS/PTSC-MC/NOC during the execution of work at PVC-MS site.
- Safety control & management Bidder to Provided Passed
Safety devices & equipment (helmets, working clothes, safety shoes,
- safety harness, eye protection equipment, gloves, id card, safety sign Bidder to Provided Passed
boards and fire extinguishers and other safety instrument)
- Injury report and records Bidder to Provided Passed
- Safety and loss prevention plan Bidder to Provided Passed

Page 2 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Vendor 1 Evaluation Remarks
- Fire protection and security control plan at site Bidder to Provided Passed
Medical treatment /surfical operation at hospital in the city for the Bidder's Passed
- Bidder to Provided
employees
- Medical expenses Bidder to Provided Passed
- First aid training for Bidder's employees Bidder to Provided Passed
- First aid treatment in site clinic Bidder to Provided Passed
3 Insurance
Insurance Bidder to Provided Passed
4 Transportation system for bidder’s
Transportation system for subcontractor’s personnel (including driver and Passed
Bidder to Provided
fuel)
5 Tax and duty
Tax and duty Passed
6 Visa fee for bidder
Visa fee for bidder Passed
7 Permits
- Works permits Bidder confirmed compliance Passed
- All permits from various authorities to peform the work Bidder confirmed compliance Passed
8 Other
- Environment check during construction Bidder to Provided Passed
- All required document for project Bidder to Provided Passed
II TECHNICAL DATA

1. Crawler Crane LR1750: 125 MT at 56m in radius, mainboom

63m and SDBW configuration which is 100% lifting capacity in
according with the manufacturer load chart.
2. Crawler Crane LR1600: 115 MT at 56 m in radius, mainboom
60m and SDB configuration which is 100% lifting capacity in
Bidder is requested to carry out load testing and issue load certification
according with the manufacturer load chart. Passed
1 for your two proposed Crawler Cranes on the port of PVCMS as below:
In case higher load tests are required by Client, Bidder has 200 MT
Crawler Crane LR1750, Crawler Crane LR1600/2
of counterweight blocks that can be used as testing load but tray,
lifting gear (shackles, sling, spreader bar, etc.) and testing load
exceeding that point shall be provided by Client.
With the load test as proposed above, Bidder confirms that the
cost of Load test certificate is included in Bidder’s price.

Page 3 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Vendor 1 Evaluation Remarks

LR1750:
+ Boom length: L= 63m
+ Lifting Radius: R = 14 m
+ Pallete radius: R' = 20 m
+ Pallete weight P0 = 250 Tons
+ Hook block weight P1 = 16 Tons
+ Base machine weight P2 = 73.4 Tons
+ Carbody weight P3 = 31 Tons
+ Counter weight P4 = 220 Tons
+ Pallete weight P4a = 95 Tons Passed
+ Crawlers weight P5 = 44 Tons
+ Mast boom length = 31.5 m
+ Mast boom weight P6 = 37.7 Tons
+ Boomweight = 87.6Tons
+ Crawler width = 1.5 m
+ Crawler length = 10.6 m
+ Max distance to neutral axis: as per the crane specification
+ Max distance to neutral axis: follow cranes specification
+ Size & quantity Wooden Mats 5m x 1m x 200mm x 40 pcs
The information of 2 Cranes Liebherr LR 1750 and Liebherr LR 1600/2
2 matching to the points in the chart of the drawing "JA JACKET ROLL UP
ROW-B TIPICAL DRAWING"
LR1600-2:
+ Boom length: L= 60 m
+ Lifting Radius: R = 14 m
+ Pallete radius: R' = 18 m
+ Pallete weight P0 = 300 Tons
+ Hook block weight P1 = 15 Tons
+ Base machine weight P2 = 65 Tons
+ Carbody weight P3 = 27 Tons
+ Counter weight P4 = 150 Tons
+ Pallete weight P4a = 65 Tons Passed
+ Crawlers weight P5 = 33 Tons
+ Mast boom length = 36 m
+ Mast boom weight P6 = 48.5 Tons
+ Boomweight = 64 Tons
+ Crawler width = 1.5 m
+ Crawler length = 9.89 m
+ Max distance to neutral axis
+ Max distance to neutral axis
+ Size & quantity of Steel Mats : 4m x 1.5m x 250mm x 26 pcs

IX OTHERS

Page 4 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Vendor 1 Evaluation Remarks
1 Project requirements Bidder to confirm Passed
RESULT
E AREA OF CONCERN
To be highlighted based on Bidder's proposal if any.
F FINAL RESULT
G RECOMMENDATION

Page 5 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Evaluation Remarks
A BIDDER INFORMATION
1 Bidder Name:
2 Contact Point:
3 Tel.:
4 E-Mail:
B BIDDER EXPERIENCE & CAPABILITIES
1 Prequalification
1.1 Bidder have to prepare and submit together with his proposal, the
prequalification documents following
Company profile:
1.1.1 Bidder to provide the Business Registeration of Head Office and Branch Office Passed
for Foreigner Company
Financial information (last three (3) years):
1.1.2 Last 3 years_2018 Last 2 years_2019 Last year _ 2020
Bidder to provide the evidence and fill in the table
Revenue: 44.190.040.202 28.814.099.852 11.926.248.676 Passed
Gross Profit: 1.893.597.446 3.505.399.886 2.055.304.089 Passed
Net Income: 1.476.043.082 2.723.211.911 1.483.816.115 Passed
Assets: 83.237.124.154 70.372.742.162 61.332.899.376 Passed
Work Experience and Project Reference for registered work category. Un-priced
similar contract to be provided for further evaluation.
The Bidder shall submit a list of 02 similar works executed by the Bidder over Passed
1.1.3 Value Unit Location
past
Operators must have at least 05 years of experience within the scope of
quotation and perform at least 2 projects of similar nature.
History completed contract:
Project 1 - Vnd Long Son, BRVT Passed
Project 2 - Vnd Dinh Co, BRVT Passed
Project 3 - Vnd PVC-MS, BRVT Passed
Project 4 - Vnd Ha Noi, VN Passed
C GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Bidder shall confirm its full compliance with all technical and commercial terms Passed
1
and conditions stipulated in ITB documents.
2 Bidder shall confirm that price quotation shall be fully complied with the SOW Passed
provided in ITB.
Bidder shall confirm that any deviation shall be listed in deviation list. Any
3 deviation listed outside the deviation list shall be not accepted and deem to be Passed
comply with the requirement
Work schedule for the Contract: Passed
4
Bidder to confirm, and comply with the project requirements
5 Organization chart

Page 6 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Evaluation Remarks
Bidder to provide Organization Chart Passed
Curriculum Vitae (CV) for key personnel (i.e. name, qualification, experience, Passed
background, age, length of service in his company, etc.).
6 Manpower & Equipment Mobilization
Bidder to provide Equipment Mobilization Plan to cap with the preliminary project Passed
schedule.
RESULT Passed
D SCOPE OF WORK/ SUPPLY
I GENERAL
1 Material Supply
Bidder will be provide Fuel diesel and Lubricant for Crawler Crane Passed
2 Labor
Operators must have at least 05 years of experience within the scope of Passed
quotation and perform at least 2 projects of similar nature.
3 Equipment machinery
Mobilization & Demobilization of transport equipment & personnel under this Passed
-
provision
- Lifting Capacity required by Client Passed
- auxiliary lifting lever required by Client Passed
- Counter weight required by Client Passed
- valid accreditation Passed
- Loadtest Passed
4 Safety and security
Bidder will comply with all safety requirements of PVC-MS/PTSC-MC/NOC Passed
- Bidder confirmed compliance
during the execution of work at PVC-MS site.
- Safety control & management Passed
Safety devices & equipment (helmets, working clothes, safety shoes, safety
- harness, eye protection equipment, gloves, id card, safety sign boards and fire Passed
extinguishers and other safety instrument)
- Injury report and records Passed
- Safety and loss prevention plan Passed
- Fire protection and security control plan at site Passed
Medical treatment /surfical operation at hospital in the city for the Bidder's Passed
-
employees
- Medical expenses Passed
- First aid training for Bidder's employees Passed
- First aid treatment in site clinic Passed
3 Insurance
Insurance Passed
4 Transportation system for bidder’s

Page 7 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Evaluation Remarks

Transportation system for subcontractor’s personnel (including driver and fuel) Passed
5 Tax and duty
Tax and duty Passed
6 Visa fee for bidder
Visa fee for bidder Passed
7 Permits
- Required gate pass (or site access) from the authorities Passed
- Works permits Passed
- All permits from various authorities to peform the work Passed
8 Other
- Environment check during construction Passed
- All required document for project Passed
II TECHNICAL DATA

IX OTHERS
1 Project requirements Passed
RESULT
E AREA OF CONCERN
To be highlighted based on Bidder's proposal if any.
F FINAL RESULT
G RECOMMENDATION

Page 8 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Evaluation Remarks
A BIDDER INFORMATION
1 Bidder Name:
2 Contact Point:
3 Tel.:
4 E-Mail:
B BIDDER EXPERIENCE & CAPABILITIES
1 Prequalification
1.1 Bidder have to prepare and submit together with his proposal, the
prequalification documents following
Company profile:
1.1.1 Bidder to provide the Business Registeration of Head Office and Branch Office Passed
for Foreigner Company
Financial information (last three (3) years):
1.1.2 Last 3 years_2018 Last 2 years_2019 Last year _ 2020
Bidder to provide the evidence and fill in the table
Revenue: 44.190.040.202 28.814.099.852 11.926.248.676 Passed
Gross Profit: 1.893.597.446 3.505.399.886 2.055.304.089 Passed
Net Income: 1.476.043.082 2.723.211.911 1.483.816.115 Passed
Assets: 83.237.124.154 70.372.742.162 61.332.899.376 Passed
Work Experience and Project Reference for registered work category. Un-priced
similar contract to be provided for further evaluation.
The Bidder shall submit a list of 02 similar works executed by the Bidder over Passed
1.1.3 Value Unit Location
past
Operators must have at least 05 years of experience within the scope of
quotation and perform at least 2 projects of similar nature.
History completed contract:
Project 1 - Vnd Long Son, BRVT Passed
Project 2 - Vnd Dinh Co, BRVT Passed
Project 3 - Vnd PVC-MS, BRVT Passed
Project 4 - Vnd Ha Noi, VN Passed
C GENERAL REQUIREMENTS
Bidder shall confirm its full compliance with all technical and commercial terms Passed
1
and conditions stipulated in ITB documents.
2 Bidder shall confirm that price quotation shall be fully complied with the SOW Passed
provided in ITB.
Bidder shall confirm that any deviation shall be listed in deviation list. Any
3 deviation listed outside the deviation list shall be not accepted and deem to be Passed
comply with the requirement
Work schedule for the Contract: Passed
4
Bidder to confirm, and comply with the project requirements
5 Organization chart

Page 9 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Evaluation Remarks
Bidder to provide Organization Chart Passed
Curriculum Vitae (CV) for key personnel (i.e. name, qualification, experience, Passed
background, age, length of service in his company, etc.).
6 Manpower & Equipment Mobilization
Bidder to provide Equipment Mobilization Plan to cap with the preliminary project Passed
schedule.
RESULT Passed
D SCOPE OF WORK/ SUPPLY
I GENERAL
1 Material Supply
Bidder will be provide Fuel diesel and Lubricant for Crawler Crane Passed
2 Labor
Operators must have at least 05 years of experience within the scope of Passed
quotation and perform at least 2 projects of similar nature.
3 Equipment machinery
Mobilization & Demobilization of transport equipment & personnel under this Passed
-
provision
- Lifting Capacity required by Client Passed
- auxiliary lifting lever required by Client Passed
- Counter weight required by Client Passed
- valid accreditation Passed
- Loadtest Passed
4 Safety and security
Bidder will comply with all safety requirements of PVC-MS/PTSC-MC/NOC Passed
- Bidder confirmed compliance
during the execution of work at PVC-MS site.
- Safety control & management Passed
Safety devices & equipment (helmets, working clothes, safety shoes, safety
- harness, eye protection equipment, gloves, id card, safety sign boards and fire Passed
extinguishers and other safety instrument)
- Injury report and records Passed
- Safety and loss prevention plan Passed
- Fire protection and security control plan at site Passed
Medical treatment /surfical operation at hospital in the city for the Bidder's Passed
-
employees
- Medical expenses Passed
- First aid training for Bidder's employees Passed
- First aid treatment in site clinic Passed
3 Insurance
Insurance Passed
4 Transportation system for bidder’s

Page 10 of 11
 REQUIREMENT DATA Evaluation Remarks

Transportation system for subcontractor’s personnel (including driver and fuel) Passed
5 Tax and duty
Tax and duty Passed
6 Visa fee for bidder
Visa fee for bidder Passed
7 Permits
- Required gate pass (or site access) from the authorities Passed
- Works permits Passed
- All permits from various authorities to peform the work Passed
8 Other
- Environment check during construction Passed
- All required document for project Passed
II TECHNICAL DATA

IX OTHERS
1 Project requirements Passed
RESULT
E AREA OF CONCERN
To be highlighted based on Bidder's proposal if any.
F FINAL RESULT
G RECOMMENDATION

Page 11 of 11