Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

UNIT-I
Industrial Relations (IR)
Concept of IR:

Basically, IR sprouts out of employment relation. Hence, it is broader in meaning and wider in
scope. IR is dynamic and developing socio-economic process. As such, there are as many as
definitions of IR as the authors on the subject. Some important definitions of IR are produced
here.

Characteristics of Industrial Relations

1. Dynamic and Developing Concept: The concept of “Industrial Relations” is a dynamic

and developing concept. It is described as a relationship between employee and management of the
enterprise and the employees or among employees and their organizations or Employers, Employees
and their trade unions and the government. Like

• Introduction of Flexible Work Arrangements: As technology advanced, especially with

the widespread adoption of the internet and communication tools, employers began exploring
flexible work options such as telecommuting, flextime, and compressed workweeks.

• Shift in Employee Expectations: Millennials and Gen Z entering the workforce brought
with them new expectations for work-life balance and flexibility. They value autonomy and
seek workplaces that offer flexible arrangements to accommodate personal needs.

• Legal and Regulatory Changes: Governments around the world have responded to these
shifts by updating labor laws and regulations to support flexible work arrangements, ensuring
protections for workers engaging in remote work or non-traditional hours.

2. It is a set of functional: Industrial relations do not constitute a simple relationship, but they
are set functional, inter-dependent complexities involving various factors or various variables such as
economic, political, social, psychological, legal factors or variables.

Negotiation:
• Example: Collective Bargaining
Conflict Resolution:
• Example: Grievance Handling
Communication:
• Example: Employee-Management Meetings
Compliance:
• Example: Compliance with Labor Laws and Regulations
Employee Welfare:
• Example: Employee Benefits and Welfare Programs

1
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

3. Employee-employers relationship: Without the existence of the minimum two parties, industrial
relationship cannot exist such as: Industrial Relations-

❖ Workers and their organizations.

❖ Employer or Management of respective enterprise.
❖ Government/state as a third parties/participant in the industrial relations.

Industrial relations, when viewed as the relationship between employees (workers) and employers
(management), encompasses a wide range of interactions, agreements, and conflicts that occur
within the workplace. This relationship is crucial for the functioning of organizations and has
significant implications for productivity, job satisfaction, and overall economic stability. Here are
some key aspects of industrial relations as the employee-employer relationship:

• Mutual Interests and Goals:

• Employers and employees share common interests and goals within the workplace.
Employers seek profitability, efficiency, and organizational success, while employees
typically desire job security, fair compensation, career development, and a safe working
environment.

• Rights and Responsibilities:

• Industrial relations encompass the rights and responsibilities of both employers and
employees. Employers have the responsibility to provide fair wages, safe working
conditions, and opportunities for advancement. Employees, in turn, have the
responsibility to perform their job duties effectively, adhere to company policies, and
contribute to organizational goals.

• Communication and Engagement:

• Effective communication is essential in the employee-employer relationship. Open

channels of communication foster mutual understanding, trust, and collaboration.
Regular feedback sessions, performance reviews, team meetings, and employee surveys
are examples of mechanisms used to facilitate communication and engagement.

• Conflict Management:

• Conflicts may arise in any workplace due to differences in expectations, goals, or

misunderstandings. Industrial relations involve strategies and processes for managing
and resolving conflicts constructively. This can include formal grievance procedures,
mediation, arbitration, or negotiation between parties to find mutually acceptable
solutions.

• Legal Framework and Compliance:

• The relationship between employers and employees operates within a legal framework
that includes labor laws, regulations, and collective agreements. Industrial relations
ensure that both parties comply with legal requirements, such as minimum wage laws,
working hour limits, health and safety standards, and non-discrimination policies.

2
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

4. It is a product: Industrial relations are the product of economic, social and political system
arising out of the employment in the industrial field.

• Components and Inputs: Industrial relations are formed from the interactions between labor
unions, management teams, government policies, and economic conditions.

• Production Process: Industrial relations develop through negotiations, collective bargaining,

dispute resolution mechanisms, and the enforcement of labor laws.

• Quality and Output: The quality of industrial relations can impact workplace harmony,
productivity, and overall economic stability. Positive industrial relations often result in higher
job satisfaction, lower turnover rates, and improved worker morale.

• Market Dynamics: Industrial relations can be influenced by external factors such as global
competition, technological advancements, and shifts in consumer demand, similar to how
market forces affect product development and sales.

• Feedback and Improvement: Like products, industrial relations are subject to feedback
loops where parties involved learn from past experiences, adapt strategies, and seek continuous
improvement in workplace relations.

• End Users: Employees and employers are the primary "consumers" of industrial relations.
Their satisfaction and engagement with the process can determine the effectiveness and
sustainability of the industrial relations "product."

5. Development of healthy labour management: The important purpose of industrial relations is

development of healthy labour-management or employee-employer relations, maintenance industrial
peace, avoidance of industrial strife, development and growth of industrial democracy etc.

• Mutual Trust and Respect: Healthy industrial relations are built on a foundation of mutual
trust and respect between employers and employees. This involves recognizing each other's
rights, responsibilities, and contributions to the organization.

• Effective Communication: Open and effective communication channels are essential for
fostering positive industrial relations. Clear communication helps in addressing concerns,
resolving conflicts, and ensuring that all stakeholders are informed and involved in decision-
making processes.

• Conflict Resolution: Industrial relations involve mechanisms for resolving conflicts and
disputes that may arise between employers and employees. This could include grievance
procedures, mediation, arbitration, or collective bargaining, aimed at achieving fair outcomes
for both parties.

• Compliance with Laws and Regulations: A healthy labor management relationship ensures
compliance with relevant laws, regulations, and employment standards. This includes fair
wages, safe working conditions, non-discriminatory practices, and adherence to labor rights.

3
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

• Promotion of Productivity and Efficiency: Positive industrial relations contribute to

increased productivity and efficiency within organizations. When there is cooperation and
collaboration between labor and management, it can lead to smoother operations, reduced
absenteeism, and improved overall performance.

• Development of Policies and Practices: Organizations develop policies, practices, and

procedures that govern labor relations to promote fairness, transparency, and consistency.
These frameworks help in managing expectations, promoting fairness, and ensuring a
conducive work environment.

• Continuous Improvement: Healthy industrial relations involve a commitment to

continuous improvement and adaptation to changing circumstances. This includes learning
from past experiences, adopting best practices, and addressing emerging challenges in labor
management.

Scope of IR:

Based on above definitions of IR, the scope of IR can easily be delineated as follows:

1. Labour relations, i.e., relations between labour union and management.

2. Employer-employee relations i.e. relations between management and employees.

3. The role of various parties’ viz., employers, employees, and state in maintaining industrial
relations.

4. The mechanism of handling conflicts between employers and employees, in case conflicts
arise.

The main aspects of industrial relations can be identified as follows:

1. Promotion and development of healthy labour — management relations.
2. Maintenance of industrial peace and avoidance of industrial strife.
3. Development and growth of industrial democracy.

Objectives of IR:

The primary objective of industrial relations is to maintain and develop good and healthy
relations between employees and employers or operatives and management. The same is
subdivided into other objectives. Thus, the objectives of IR are designed to:
1. Establish and foster sound relationship between workers and management by safeguarding
their interests.
2. Avoid industrial conflicts and strikes by developing mutuality among the interests of
concerned parties.
3. Keep, as far as possible, strikes, lockouts and gheraos at bay by enhancing the economic
status of workers.

4
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

4. Provide an opportunity to the workers to participate in management and decision-making

process.
5. Raise productivity in the organisation to curb the employee turnover and absenteeism.
6. Avoid unnecessary interference of the government, as far as possible and practicable, in the
matters of relationship between workers and management.
7. Establish and nurse industrial democracy based on labour partnership in the sharing of profits
and of managerial decisions.
8. Socialize industrial activity by involving the government participation as an employer.

Importance of Industrial Relation for Employees and Employers

Industrial relations usually imply good and positive relations between the employees and
employers. The good IR help run an industry effectively and successfully, i.e., the desideratum
of the day. The importance of IR can be imbued with multiplicity of justifications. To mention,
good IR help:

1. Foster Industrial Peace:

Under the mechanism of IR, both employees and managers discuss the matter and consult
each other before initiating any actions. Doubts, if any, in the minds of either party are
removed. Thus, unilateral actions that prop confusion and misunderstanding disappear from
the scene. In this way, IR helps create a peaceful environment in the organisation. Peace, in
turn, breeds prosperity. Fostering industrial peace is a critical goal in industrial relations (IR),
as it contributes to a stable and productive work environment. Here are several strategies and
practices that can help in promoting industrial peace:

a) Effective Communication
Open Dialogue: Maintain open and transparent communication channels between management
and employees. Regular meetings, feedback sessions, and open-door policies can help address
concerns before they escalate along with Information Sharing, Provide employees with timely
and relevant information about company policies, changes, and decisions that may affect them.
This helps in reducing uncertainty and building trust.
b) Strong Leadership
Demonstrate Fairness: Leaders should exhibit fairness and consistency in decision-making
and treatment of employees. Fairness fosters respect and trust, which are crucial for industrial
peace.
Conflict Resolution Skills: Managers should be trained in conflict resolution techniques to
handle disputes effectively and diplomatically.
c) Fair Employment Practices
Equitable Policies: Implement and enforce fair employment policies regarding wages,
working conditions, promotions, and disciplinary actions. Ensure that these policies are applied
consistently.
Anti-Discrimination Measures: Establish and maintain strong anti-discrimination policies to
ensure a respectful and inclusive workplace.
d) Effective Dispute Resolution Mechanisms
Grievance Procedures: Develop clear and accessible grievance procedures that allow
employees to raise issues and seek resolution without fear of retaliation.
Mediation and Arbitration: Use mediation and arbitration as tools to resolve disputes
amicably. Neutral third parties can help facilitate fair resolutions when internal mechanisms are
insufficient.

5
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

e) Collective Bargaining
Constructive Negotiations: Engage in constructive collective bargaining with employee
representatives or unions to address and resolve workplace issues. Aim for agreements that
benefit both parties.
Clear Agreements: Ensure that collective bargaining agreements are clear, comprehensive,
and understood by all parties. Well-drafted agreements help in minimizing conflicts and
misunderstandings.
f) Employee Involvement
Participative Management: Involve employees in decision-making processes that affect their
work. Participative management can enhance commitment and reduce resistance to changes.
Feedback Mechanisms: Establish regular feedback mechanisms where employees can voice
their opinions and suggestions for improving workplace conditions.
g) Training and Development
Skills Development: Offer training programs that improve employees' skills and knowledge,
which can lead to greater job satisfaction and reduced workplace stress.
Conflict Management Training: Provide training for both managers and employees on
conflict management and resolution techniques.
h) Work-Life Balance
Flexible Work Arrangements: Implement flexible working arrangements, such as
telecommuting or flexible hours, to help employees balance their professional and personal
lives.
Support Programs: Offer support programs such as counseling services, wellness programs,
and family support initiatives to help employees manage stress and maintain well-being.
i) Recognition and Rewards
Acknowledge Contributions: Regularly recognize and reward employees for their hard work
and contributions. Recognition can boost morale and reduce dissatisfaction.
Incentive Programs: Develop incentive programs that align with company goals and motivate
employees to perform well and contribute positively to the workplace.
j) Proactive Change Management
Communicate Changes: Clearly communicate any organizational changes and involve
employees in the change process. Providing explanations and involving them in planning can
reduce resistance and uncertainty.
Manage Transitions Smoothly: Ensure that changes are implemented smoothly and with
minimal disruption to the workforce.
k) Monitoring and Evaluation
Regular Assessments: Regularly assess the effectiveness of IR practices and workplace
conditions. Use surveys, feedback, and other tools to gauge employee satisfaction and identify
areas for improvement.
Continuous Improvement: Continuously refine and improve IR strategies based on
assessments and changing organizational needs.
l) Legal and Ethical Compliance
• Adhere to Laws: Ensure compliance with labor laws and regulations to avoid legal disputes
and maintain a lawful and ethical workplace.
• Ethical Practices: Promote and adhere to ethical practices in all aspects of employment
relations to build a culture of trust and integrity.

2. Promote Industrial Democracy:

Industrial democracy means the government mandated worker participation at various levels
of the organisation with regard to decisions that affect workers. It is mainly the joint
consultations that pave the way for industrial democracy and cement relationship between

6
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

workers and management. This benefits the both. The motivated workers give their best and
maximum to the organisation, on the one hand, and share their share of the fruits of
organisational progress jointly with management, on the other.

• Employee Participation in Decision-Making

• Collaborative Work Environment
• Transparent Communication
• Employee Representation and Governance
• Equitable Compensation and Benefits
• Professional Development Opportunities: Like training and development.

Benefits of Industrial Democracy

• Enhanced Employee Satisfaction: Employees feel more engaged and satisfied when they
have a say in their workplace.
• Increased Innovation: Diverse perspectives and collaborative efforts lead to more creative
solutions.
• Improved Performance: A motivated workforce is generally more productive and
committed.
• Stronger Company Culture

3. Benefit to Workers:

IR benefits workers in several ways. For example, it protects workers against unethical
practices on the part of management to exploit workers by putting them under inhuman
working conditions and niggardly wages. It also provides a procedure to resolve workers’
grievances relating to work.

Improved Working Conditions

a) Health and Safety: Effective industrial relations help ensure that workplace health and
safety standards are maintained. Workers benefit from safer working environments and
better protection from occupational hazards.
Fair Work Practices: Through collective bargaining and negotiations, workers can secure
fair work practices, including reasonable working hours and breaks.
b) Better Compensation
Wages and Salaries: Industrial relations facilitate negotiations for fair and competitive
wages. Workers are better positioned to achieve salary increases and benefits through
collective bargaining.
Additional Benefits: Besides direct compensation, industrial relations can help workers
gain access to additional benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and paid leave.
c) Job Security
Employment Protection: Strong industrial relations often involve negotiating for job
security measures. Workers are more likely to have protection against arbitrary dismissal
or layoffs.
Contracts and Agreements: Clear agreements and contracts can provide workers with
more stability and predictability regarding their employment status.
d) Fair Treatment

7
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

Dispute Resolution: Effective industrial relations mechanisms include fair processes for
resolving disputes and grievances. Workers have a structured way to address issues with
their employers.
Anti-Discrimination Policies: Industrial relations can help in establishing and enforcing
policies against discrimination and harassment, ensuring a more equitable workplace.
e) Worker Participation
Voice in Decision-Making: Through unions or worker councils, employees often have a
greater say in workplace decisions that affect them, from working conditions to company
policies.
Involvement in Policy Formation: Workers may have the opportunity to participate in
shaping workplace policies and practices through industrial relations structures.
f) Skill Development and Training
Training Opportunities: Industrial relations can help in negotiating for better training and
development programs, which enhance workers' skills and career prospects.
Career Advancement: Access to training and development often translates into better
opportunities for promotions and career growth.
g) Work-Life Balance
Flexible Arrangements: Through negotiations, industrial relations can lead to the
establishment of flexible working arrangements, such as telecommuting or flexible hours,
which help workers balance their work and personal lives.
h) Enhanced Workplace Relations
Better Communication: Strong industrial relations foster better communication between
employers and employees, which can lead to a more harmonious and productive workplace.
Team Cohesion: When workers feel their rights are respected and they are fairly treated,
it can lead to improved morale and team cohesion.
i) Economic and Social Stability
Income Stability: Fair industrial relations practices contribute to economic stability for
workers, reducing the risk of income volatility and poverty.
Social Justice: By advocating for fair treatment and equality, industrial relations support
broader social justice goals, benefiting workers and their communities.

4. Benefit to Management:

IR protects the rights of managers too. As and when workers create the problem of indiscipline,
IR provides mangers with a system to handle with employee in the organisation. Here are some
of the key advantages:

a) Improved Workplace Harmony

Reduced Conflicts: Strong IR practices help in resolving disputes and grievances in a
structured manner, reducing the likelihood of conflicts escalating into strikes or work
stoppages.
Better Labor-Management Relations: Constructive dialogue and negotiation foster positive
relationships between management and employees, leading to a more cooperative and less
adversarial environment.
b) Increased Productivity
Motivated Workforce: A well-managed industrial relations environment often leads to higher
employee satisfaction, which can translate into increased motivation and productivity.
Efficient Problem-Solving: Effective IR practices enable quicker resolution of workplace
issues, minimizing disruptions and maintaining operational efficiency.
c) Enhanced Employee Retention
Reduced Turnover: Positive IR practices contribute to a more satisfied workforce, which can
lead to lower employee turnover and reduced costs associated with recruitment and training.

8
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

Career Development: Access to training and development through IR can improve employee
skills and career satisfaction, fostering long-term loyalty.
d) Lower Costs and Risks
Reduced Legal Costs: By maintaining good IR practices, management can minimize the risk
of legal disputes, thereby reducing potential legal costs and penalties associated with labor law
violations.
Avoidance of Strikes: Proactive IR strategies can help avoid strikes and work stoppages, which
can be costly for operations and damage the company’s reputation.
e) Enhanced Compliance and Governance
Regulatory Compliance: Effective IR helps ensure compliance with labor laws and
regulations, reducing the risk of non-compliance and associated legal issues.
Governance and Standards: Well-structured IR practices contribute to higher standards of
workplace governance, improving the organization’s overall management and operational
standards.
f) Improved Communication
Feedback Mechanisms: Effective IR facilitates better communication channels between
management and employees, allowing for constructive feedback and more informed decision-
making.
Transparency: Transparent IR practices help in clarifying company policies and expectations,
reducing misunderstandings and fostering trust.
g) Stronger Organizational Culture
Positive Work Environment: Good IR practices help in building a positive organizational
culture where employees feel valued and respected, enhancing overall workplace morale.
Employee Engagement: Engaged employees who feel their voices are heard are more likely
to contribute positively to organizational goals and values.
h) Strategic Flexibility
Adaptive Strategies: Management can use IR frameworks to adapt labor strategies in response
to changing business conditions, such as restructuring or implementing new technologies.
Negotiation Leverage: Effective IR allows management to negotiate terms that align with
strategic business objectives while maintaining worker satisfaction.
i) Enhanced Reputation
Employer Brand: Organizations known for good IR practices are often seen as desirable
places to work, enhancing their reputation and attractiveness to top talent.
Public Perception: Positive IR outcomes can improve the company's public image, showing it
as a fair and responsible employer.
j) Legal and Ethical Standards
Ethical Practices: Adhering to strong IR principles ensures that the company operates
ethically, which can be important for maintaining a positive public image and fulfilling
corporate social responsibilities.
Avoiding Discrimination: By implementing fair IR practices, management can avoid issues
related to discrimination and ensure equitable treatment of all employees.
In summary, effective industrial relations benefit management by creating a stable and productive work
environment, reducing costs, improving employee retention and satisfaction, and enhancing the
organization’s overall efficiency and reputation.

5. Improve Productivity:

Similar other success stories abound in the country. As reported by V.S.P. Rao, Sundaram
Fasteners (A TVS group company which begged the prestigious GM award for the fourth
successive year in 1999 as a quality supplier of radiator caps) is well known for zero
breakdowns, zero accidents and zero defects. Company did not lose even a single day due to

9
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

strike. The per-employee productivity is comparable to the best in the world. One study rates
the company among the 20 most competitive companies in the Asia.

Factors Affecting Industrial Relations: -

The industrial relations system of an organisation is influenced by a variety of factors. They

are: -
1. Institutional factors
2. Economic factors
3. Social factors
4. Technological factors
5. Psychological factors
6. Political factors
7. Enterprise-related factors
8. Global factors

These interrelated and interdependent factors determine the texture of industrial relations in
any setting. In fact, they act, interact, and reinforce one another in the course of developing the
industrial relations.

1. Institutional Factors:

Under institutional factors are included items like state policy, labour laws, voluntary codes,
collective bargaining agreements, labour unions, employers’ organisations / federations etc.

2. Economic Factors:

Under economic factors are included economic organisations, (socialist, communist, capitalist)
type of ownership, individual, company whether domestic or MNC, Government, cooperative
ownership) nature and composition of the workforce, the source of labour supply, labour
market relative status, disparity of wages between groups, level of unemployment, economic
cycle. These variables influence industrial relations in myriad ways.

3. Social Factors:

Under social factors items like social group (like caste or joint family) creed, social values,
norms, social status (high or low) — influenced industrial relations in the early stages of
industrialisation. They gave rise to relationship as master and servant, haves and have-nots,
high caste and low caste, etc. But with the acceleration of industrialisation, these factors
gradually lost their force but one cannot overlook their importance.

4. Technological Factors:

Under technological factors fall items like work methods, type of technology used, rate of
technological change, R&D activities, ability to cope with emerging trends, etc. These factors

10
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

considerably influence the patterns of industrial relations, as they are known to have direct
influence on employment status, wage level, collective bargaining process in an organisation.

5. Psychological Factors:

Under psychological factors fall items pertaining to industrial relations like owners’ attitude,
perception of workforce, workers’ attitude towards work, their motivation, morale, interest,
alienation; dissatisfaction and boredom resulting from man-machine interface. The various
psychological problems resulting from work have a far-reaching impact on workers’ job and
personal life, that directly or indirectly influences industrial relation system of an enterprise.

6. Political Factors:

The political factors are political institutions, system of government, political philosophy,
attitude of government, ruling elite and opposition towards labour problems. For instance, the
various communist countries prior to the adoption of new political philosophy, the industrial
relations environment was very much controlled by the Government ever since change has
altered considerably like other capitalist economics. There too, unions are now at the helm of
labour activities, the industrial relations and is marked by labour unrest. Most of the trade
unions are controlled by political parties, so here the industrial relations are largely shaped by
the gravity of involvement of political parties in trade union activities.

7. Enterprise-Related Factors:

Under enterprise-related factors, fall issues like style of management prevailing in the
enterprise, its philosophy and value system, organisational climate, organisational health,
extent of competition, adaptability to change and the various human resources management
policies.

8. Global Factors:

Under global factors, the various issues included are international relations, global conflicts,
dominant economic-political ideologies, global cultural milieu, economic and trading policies
of power blocks, international trade agreements and relations, international labour agreements
(role of ILO) etc.

Thus, the industrial relations can be viewed as a “Complex System” formed by the interaction
of the industry, the government and the labour which are monitored by the existing and
emerging social economic, institutional and technological factors.

Participants in Industrial Relations:-

There are three participants in industrial relations. They are:

Employer and their Associations: Employer plays an important role in industrial relations.
He hires the employees, pay them wages, provides allowances, he regulates the working
relations through various rules, regulations and laws and at same time expects the workers to

11
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

follow them. The bargaining power of the employers is weakened in comparison to that of trade
unions, though they have high bargaining power when compared to that of employees. So, they
form into associations to equate their bargaining power with trade union, and these associations
protect the employer by putting pressure on government and trade unions. Its main components
are:
Employer:
Management: This includes senior executives, managers, and supervisors who are responsible
for making decisions about the company’s operations, policies, and employee relations.
Human Resources (HR) Departments: HR professionals handle recruitment, employee
benefits, compensation, training, and grievance management. They often play a key role in
implementing and managing industrial relations policies.
Employers' Associations
• Industry Associations: These organizations represent the interests of employers within
specific industries. They may engage in collective bargaining on behalf of their members or
provide guidance on labor practices.
Eg: National Association of Software and Service Companies (NASSCOM); Indian Banks'
Association (IBA); The Indian Pharmaceutical Alliance (IPA).
• Business Associations: Broader associations that include a range of business sectors,
providing support and advocacy for employer interests in industrial relations.
Eg: FICCI (Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry); Confederation of
Indian Industry (CII); Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India
(ASSOCHAM)

Workers and their Associations: Workers plays a crucial role in industrial relation. Worker
as a whole includes his working age, Educational background, Social and family background,
Psychological traits, Talents, Skills, Culture, Attitude towards others work. Workers form into
their associations called “Trade Unions” to get their problems solved.
The trade unions work for workers economic interest through collective bargaining by bringing
the pressure on the management through economic and political strategies. Its main
components are:
Employees
• Individual Workers: Employees are directly affected by industrial relations practices.
Their concerns include wages, working conditions, job security, and work-life balance.
• Employee Representatives: These individuals, often chosen by their peers, may
include informal leaders or spokespersons who communicate employee concerns to
management.
Trade Unions
• Union Representatives: These are elected officials or appointed representatives who
advocate on behalf of union members. They negotiate collective bargaining agreements
and represent members in disputes with management.
Eg: All India Railwaymen's Federation; All India Station Masters' Association of
Indian railways.
• Union Leaders: High-level officials or executives within a trade union who strategize
on broader labor issues, negotiate major agreements, and represent the union in
significant negotiations or disputes.

12
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

Government: Government plays a balancing role in industrial relations. Government has its
influence on industrial relations through industrial relations policy, Labour policy, Labour law
implementation, Acting as a mediator in the process of conciliation and adjudication.
Government regulates the behaviour of both the employer association and workers
organizations. Its main components are:

Government Agencies:
• Labor Departments: Government bodies responsible for enforcing labor laws and
regulations, providing guidance on employment practices, and mediating disputes
between employers and employees.
• Regulatory Bodies: Agencies that oversee specific aspects of labor relations, such as
occupational health and safety, equal employment opportunity, and minimum wage
compliance.
Labor Relations Boards and Tribunals
• Arbitration Boards: Bodies that provide a formal mechanism for resolving disputes
between employers and employees, often through binding arbitration.
• Industrial Relations Commissions: Government or quasi-government entities that
adjudicate labor disputes, oversee union recognition, and ensure compliance with labor
laws.
Legal and Advisory Professionals
• Labor Lawyers: Attorneys specializing in employment and labor law who provide
legal advice to both employers and employees on matters such as contract disputes,
discrimination claims, and compliance with labor laws.
• Consultants: Specialists who advise organizations on best practices for industrial
relations, help in negotiating collective agreements, and assist in conflict resolution.
Academic and Research Institutions
• Researchers: Academics who study industrial relations, labor economics, and related
fields. Their research can influence policy, practice, and understanding of labor
dynamics.
• Training Providers: Institutions and organizations that offer training programs for
both employers and employees on various aspects of industrial relations, including
negotiation skills and conflict resolution.

Approaches to Industrial Relations:

Approaches to Industrial Relation – Top 3 Approaches:

1. Unitary Approach,
2. Pluralistic Approach and
3. Marxist Approach

Unitary Approach: The unitary approach believes in Unity among the workers and the
management and bringing together efforts for teamwork and to achieve a common goal. This
theory believes that conflicts arise due to improper organizational management. These conflicts
are nonpermanent and solved quickly, and that’s why these are temporary. In this, the base of
strikes is useless and destructive.
Objectives of the unitary approach:

13
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

1. Create a productive, harmonious, and effective environment.

2. Develop a reliable, open communication and fair and transparent work culture among
workers.
3. Restrict the role of the tribunal: The unitary approach believes if you increase the involvement
of the tribunal, other governments, and trade unions, Then they will never be able to build a
trustworthy organization. Negotiating directly with the management rather than involving any
trade union or employer association would be best. Eg:

• Google: Google emphasizes a shared vision and corporate culture that promotes
alignment between management and employees. The company invests in open
communication channels, employee well-being programs, and a supportive work
environment to foster harmony.
• Tata Group: Tata Group aims to create a unified corporate culture across its diverse
businesses. The group's values and ethical practices are designed to align employee
interests with organizational goals, reducing the likelihood of conflicts and promoting
collaboration.

Pluralistic approach: This approach is different from the Unitary approach, and in this
approach, the ideology believes that Conflict between management and employees is rational
and inevitable(compulsory, mandatory). You can take action to prevent the Conflict or settle it.
As per this approach, work based only on Unity was only possible.
Ideology in Pluralist Approach:
• The pluralistic approach opposes the unitary system and believes that the trade union must
be recognized and be there. Their presence is significant because they protect the interest
of employees. Management will handle and resolve any concern with the trade union if it
arises.
• This approach suggests that stability in IR comes when the party’s management and union
compromise. Both parties comply with each other.
• As per this approach, Conflict is natural, but the best way to resolve it is through Collective
bargaining (implementing one side seam of the trade union and on the other side
management as a team to communicate with each other and compromise on what will be
the possibilities.

Objectives:

• To acknowledge and manage the existence of diverse and often conflicting interests
among different groups (e.g., management and unions).
• To facilitate negotiations and collective bargaining to resolve conflicts.
• To balance power and interests between employers and employees through formal
structures.

Examples:

• British Airways: British Airways engages in regular negotiations with trade unions to
address employee concerns and resolve disputes. The company recognizes the role of
unions and seeks to achieve balance through collective bargaining and compromise.
• Indian Railways: Indian Railways interacts with various employee unions to address
grievances and negotiate terms of employment. The pluralist approach helps in
managing conflicts and achieving balanced outcomes in the context of a large and
diverse workforce.

14
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

Marxist Approach: Like the pluralist approach, the Marxist approach believes that Conflict
is inevitable, a common factor in both. Here is a difference between both approaches pluralist
belief s that disputes must be in every organization, whether it is a small or big size industry,
but the Marxist believes that Conflict arises only in capitalist societies (those organizations
which are capitalist means that management tries to exploit the workers and try to take more
work for fewer wages. In this type of working condition, conflicts arise. The Marxist approach
focuses on society rather than organizational functions.
Marxist approach ideology-
• Trade union act as a means of social change. They work to improve the working condition
of the workers.
• In this approach, all strikes are political, not organization related.
• Marxists believe that tribunals, government support, and court are all for management’s
interest and always support those in power.
• He believes these legislations, tribunals, and courts always support management rather than
workers as per this approach.

Objectives:

• To highlight and address the power imbalances and conflicts between capital (employers)
and labor (employees).
• To analyze and challenge the exploitation and inequalities inherent in the capitalist system.
• To advocate for systemic changes to address labor grievances and promote workers' rights.

Examples:

• Historical Labor Movements: The labor movements in India during the early 20th
century, such as the Textile Workers' Strike in Mumbai (1930s), reflected Marxist
principles by addressing exploitation and advocating for labor reforms.
• Trade Unions with Marxist Influence: Some Indian trade unions, like the Centre of
Indian Trade Unions (CITU), adopt Marxist principles in their advocacy for workers' rights
and systemic reforms, focusing on class struggle and labor exploitation.

Approach # 4 M K Gandhi – The Gandhian Approach:

Gandhiji can be called one of the greatest labour leaders of modern India. His approach to
labour problems was completely new and refreshingly human. He held definite views regarding
fixation and regulation of wages, organisation and functions of trade unions, necessity and
desirability of collective bargaining, use and abuse of strikes, labour indiscipline, and workers
participation in management, conditions of work and living, and duties of workers.

The Ahmedabad Textile Labour Association, a unique and successful experiment in Gandhian
trade unionism, implemented many of his ideas. Gandhiji had immense faith in the goodness
of man and he believed that many of the evils of the modern world have been brought about
by wrong systems and not by wrong individuals. He insisted on recognising each individual
worker as a human being. He believed in nonviolent communism, going so far as to say that
“if communism comes without any violence, it would be welcome.”

15
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

Gandhiji laid down certain conditions for a successful strike. These are – (a) the cause of the
strike must be just and there should be no strike without a grievance; (b) there should be no
violence; and (c) non-strikers or “blacklegs” should never be molested. He was not against
strikes but pleaded that they should be the last weapon in the armory of industrial workers and
hence, should not be resorted to unless all peaceful and constitutional methods of negotiations,
conciliation and arbitration are exhausted. His concept of trusteeship is a significant
contribution in the sphere of industrial relations.

According to him, employers should not regard themselves as sole owners of mills and factories
of which they may be the legal owners. They should regard themselves only as trustees, or co-
owners. He also appealed to the workers to behave as trustees, not to regard the mill and
machinery as belonging to the exploiting agents but to regard them as their own, protect them
and put to the best use they can.

In short, the theory of trusteeship is based on the view that all forms of property and human
accomplishments are gifts of nature and as such, they belong not to any one individual but to
society. Thus, the trusteeship system is totally different from other contemporary labour
relations systems. It aimed at achieving economic equality and the material advancement of
the “havenots” in a capitalist society by non-violent means.

Gandhiji realised that relations between labour and management can either be a powerful
stimulus to economic and social progress or an important factor in economic and social
stagnation. According to him, industrial peace was an essential condition not only for the
growth and development of the industry itself, but also in a great measure, for the improvement
in the conditions of work and wages.

At the same time, he not only endorsed the workers’ right to adopt the method of collective
bargaining but also actively supported it. He advocated voluntary arbitration and mutual
settlement of disputes.

He also pleaded for perfect understanding between capital and labour, mutual respect,
recognition of equality, and strong labour organisation as the essential factors for happy and
constructive industrial relations. For him, means and ends are equally important.

5. Human Resource Management Approach:

The term, human resource management (HRM) has become increasingly used in the literature
of personnel/industrial relations. The term has been applied to a diverse range of management
strategies and, indeed, sometimes used simply as a more modern, and therefore more
acceptable, term for personnel or industrial relations management.

Some of the components of human resource management are –

(a) human resource organisation

(b) human resource planning

16
Industrial Relation & Labour Laws BBA V Sem

(c) human resource systems

(d) human resource development

(e) human resource relationships;

(f) human resource utilization

(g) human resource accounting

(h) human resource audit.

This approach emphasises individualism and the direct relationship between management and
its employees. Therefore, it questions the collective regulation basis of traditional industrial
relations.

6. Psychological Approach to Industrial Relations:

According to psychologists’ issues to industrial relations have the differences in the perception
of management, unions and rank and file of workers. The perpetual differences arise due to
differences in personalities, attitudes, etc. Similarly, factors like motivation, leadership, group
versus individual goals, etc., are responsible for industrial conflicts.

7. Sociological Approach to Industrial Relations:

Industry is a social world in miniature, organisations are communities of individuals and groups
with differing personalities, educational and family backgrounds, emotions, sentiments, etc.,
these differences in individuals create problems of conflict and competition among the
members of industrial societies.

17