Air Pollition - Ayushi Bhatt - WIT Conference - 12 May
Air Pollition - Ayushi Bhatt - WIT Conference - 12 May
ABSTRACT
Transport is widely recognised to be a significant and increasing source of air pollution worldwide.
An efficient transport sector is important for economic development and for the wellbeing of people.
Urban mobility is rapidly becoming one of the greatest challenges facing developed and developing
countries alike. Transport is estimated to be responsible for nearly a quarter of global energy-related
CO2. There are also rising concerns about its impact on the quality of urban life, including social
inequities, and about the effects of its pollution on health and buildings. The global vehicle fleet is set
to multiply three or four-fold in the next few decades, with most of this growth set to occur in
developing countries. In 2050, two-thirds of the global vehicle fleet is expected to be in non-OECD
countries. In Indian context, during the last two decades has seen an unprecedented economic growth.
The number of urban centres in the country has risen sharply. There are now 53 million plus cities in
the country which accommodates its residents in relatively smaller regions. Air pollution generated by
human activities has adversely affected the lives of millions of people and caused great economic
damage to ecosystems and society in India. Rural to urban migration, growth in mobility demands,
demands for power and industrial production has led to deterioration of air quality in urban centres.
More than 80% of cities in India where air quality is monitored do not meet the standard of air quality
prescribed by the Government of India. Keeping the aforesaid knowledge in mind, Bhimavaram,
Vijayawada City, Andhra Pradesh State, India has been chosen as study region for further detailed
investigation on vehicular traffic pollution. The study begins by analysing the pollutants emitted by
vehicular traffic, compares the applicability of different types of air pollution dispersion models and
explored the California Line Source Dispersion Model (CALINE4). The researchers have tried to
quantify the vehicular emissions for different receptor locations and to evolve location specific
recommendations. The carbon absorption capacity of different types of vegetation were analysed to
establish their association with road infrastructure towards air pollution. Based on the findings,
finally, the study concludes with a conceptual design of an arterial road in Bhimavaram, integrated
landscaping to reduce overall air pollution. The results of the study demonstrate that landscaping can
serve as a nature-based solution and to suggest mitigating measures to minimize the vehicular traffic
pollution in urban system.
Keywords: Urban mobility; Air Pollution; Landscape; CALINE4 Model
1 INTRODUCTION
Automobile traffic is growing rapidly on the urban roads of India during the recent decades.
In fact, by 2030, it is expected that the vehicular population may increase by four or five
times. The global rise in the usage of vehicles has negatively affected the environment due
to high road traffic emissions. These emissions comprise of different pollutants like PM2.5,
PM10, CO, NOx etc., which can negatively impact Air quality Index of region and have
high health hazards on human health. The significant impact of these emissions on urban
populations all over the world has motivated research on methods to reduce exposure to
these pollutants. While vehicle emission control techniques and programs directly reduce
pollutants emitted to the air from transportation sources, these programs often take a long
time to fully implement and may be offset by increases in vehicle activity. Thus, other
mitigation options like road side landscaping, is needed to fully and comprehensively
reduce air pollution exposures for these urban populations. [1]
To provide better solutions for Air Pollution, it is important to understand the by-
products of this phenomenon. This can be done through Air Pollution Dispersion
Modelling. This study gives a comparison between applicability of different types of Air
Pollution Dispersion modelling tools and gives a critical analysis of how CALINE4
(California Line Source Dispersion Model) is a suitable tool for the selected study area.
Quantification of the vehicular emission for different Receptor Locations can give a spatial
representation of Pollution and further help in Identifying suitable proposals according to
the existing context of the location (ex. Land use, Road hierarchy etc.). [2]. Thus,
Objectives of this study can be stated as following:
According to NAAQS (National Ambient Air Quality Standards), Air pollution of any area
or city can be quantified through Air Quality Index. To calculate AQI, concentration of
minimum 3 Pollutants is needed, that are responsible for degradation of Air quality (shown
in Table 1: ).
Table 1: Types of air pollutants specifically affecting air quality index, (Source: CBCB,
India)
Pollutants Source
Particulate Matter Particulate matter contains microscopic solids or liquid droplets
(PM) that can cause serious health problems by getting into your
bloodstream. Out of these, PM2.5 poses the greatest risk to health.
Carbon From internal combustion engines of cars, resulting in serious
Monoxides (CO) respiratory problems.
Nitrogen Oxides Nitrogen Oxides are a family of highly reactive gases. emitted by
(NOx) automobiles, trucks and various non-road vehicles (e.g.,
construction equipment, boats, etc.
Air pollution dispersion is the dispersal of air pollution into the atmosphere in the form of
particles, biological molecules, or other toxic elements that can harm humans, other living
organisms. The main goal of the modelling process is to determine the concentration of a
pollutant at predefined receptor locations using the fundamental data about the pollutant's
source and the meteorological data [4]. Understanding dispersion can help in locating and
reducing pollution by identifying concentration of pollutants generated by different
pollution sources, such as private motorised vehicles.
There are various Air pollution dispersion models available today, developed by
different countries with different input requirements, scale of function and varying
complexity. In this study, a comparative analysis of all the relevant models is done in order
to identify a suitable model for the given study area, as shown in Table 2. In the given
table, ‘P,’ ‘L’ and ‘Pu’ stands for the type of source for which the model works. ‘P’ denotes
Point sources of Air Pollution like Industrial units, etc. ‘L’ denotes sources that move in a
line like Traffic. Lastly, ‘Pu’ denotes the emissions that comes out of puff sources like
accidental plumes. Thus, all the traffic-based Air pollution dispersion models are compared
against each other based on their mathematical concept, scale of function and the type of
source for which the pollution is modelled. For this study, CALINE4 Model is found
suitable to perform Air Pollution Dispersion due to simplicity, scale and feasibility for line
sources. The data requirements of this model are discussed in detail in next section.
CALINE4 model is the one of the most often used models for predicting traffic pollution
along highways and roads. It is simple to use and requires minimum input data (Figure 1: ),
which makes it suitable for screening. It is a line source Gaussian-based dispersion model
developed by the California Department of Transportation for estimating air pollutant
concentrations. It has features like prediction of CO, NO2 and modelling at signalized
intersections. [4]. Four main categories of data are required to run the model in a dispersion
modelling analysis, and they are as follows [5]:
Site characteristics Traffic characteristics Meteorological data Road geometry Receptor location
Temperature
2.4 Evaluation of Air quality for Bhimavaram in Andhra Pradesh state of India
In this study, the selected case area is Bhimavaram, a small town near Vijayawada,
Andhra Pradesh. It is a selection grade municipality in West Godavari district of Andhra
Pradesh, with an area of 25.64 sq.km. and population of 1.4 Lakh according to census 2011.
It has about 50,000 floating population due to presence of higher education government and
private institutes in the region. It has become an important commercial centre especially
due to exponential growth in Aqua culture in late 90's. Since then, it has started attracting
people from its surrounding villages to migrate. The study area has two major State
Highways running perpendicular to each other, cutting across the centre as shown in Figure
2:
For running the model, various geographical locations are selected in a study area,
where pollutant concentration is calculated for each location. These locations are called
Receptor locations. These locations are chosen at every 500 meters, as per the data
availability and on the basis of fulfilment of all criteria of CALINE4 model. After selection
of locations, Traffic volume count survey is conducted accordingly. In the case of
Bhimavaram, locations are selected with respect to the core CBD area or the central activity
core, i.e., Bhimavaram railway junction. Following locations are selected:
Figure 2: Case area of Bhimavaram, showing road hierarchy and Receptor Locations
(Source: Generated by Authors)
Most of these locations lie on the National highway 165. This is because it is the main
arterial road for Bhimavaram with which all the major activities are connected together.
The first step in the model requires basic input information about technical
specifications of the pollutant whose concentration is to be calculated. The second step
requires X and Y coordinates of geo location of the receptor points chosen for calculating
pollutant concentration. X1 and Y1 are the coordinates of starting receptor of a link and X2,
Y2 are the coordinates of ending receptor of a link. Along with that, the mixing zone width
i.e. road width is also required of each link in this step. The third step requires input of
meteorological data of the case area like wind speed, wind direction, ambient temperature
etc. as shown in Figure 3: The fourth step requires input of coordinates of each receptor
location in Bhimavaram for which pollutant concentration needs to be calculated. (Figure 3:
b)
Figure 3: (a) Meteorological input parameters in CALINE4 model (b) Coordinates of each
receptor location in CALINE4 Model (Source: Generated by Authors)
The fifth step requires input of Traffic Volume Count of each receptor location and
weighted emission factor for the specific pollutant in the year of 2041. The weighted
emission factor of each pollutant is the average emission per unit square kilometre by
vehicles. It is one of the inputs that is required in CALINE4 model to calculate pollutant
concentration. The formula to calculate WEF is as follows:
Table 3: Emission factors of each pollutant for each vehicle type (Source: CRRI, India)
Table 4: Population for each vehicle type in the case area (Source: RTO, Bhimavaram)
a1 a2 a3 a4
Population for
each vehicle 205288 11915 13383 80
Table 5: Calculated Weighted emission factor for case area (Source: RTO, Bhimavaram)
Table 6: Concentration of each pollutant through CALINE4 model and Final Air quality
Index (Source: Generated by Authors)
From Table 6: , it can be inferred that Air quality Index for Bhimavaram city lies under
moderate condition. The similar values, when projected for future may result in poor Air
Quality Index, due to which immediate mitigation measures are required. Keeping in view
this knowledge, Landscaping is adopted as a mitigation measure to reduce the impact of
vehicular emissions on Air Quality Index.
One of the popular and feasible solutions being used in India to mitigate Air Pollution is
Landscaping. Although, Indian Road congress (IRC: SP:99-2013) does provide some
insight on application of Landscaping and Tree Plantation for Environmental and Social
Aspects, it only discusses the issue of change in drainage patterns due to loss of vegetation
cover during construction of expressways and Highways. According to the IRC Guidelines
for landscaping on highways, they primarily focus on designing elements for the roadways,
such as obstacles, markings, signs, geometric design, and sight distance, etc., but they do
not include landscaping as a design element or its carbon absorption quality for highway
design or It does the applicability of Landscaping to mitigate Air pollution due the traffic
on those Highways. This study is an attempt to cover that gap by calculating carbon
absorption capacity of different plantations, which is discussed in detail in the Data analysis
section.
Landscaping can be used as science of modifying land areas by organization of natural,
cultivated, or constructed elements in a comprehensive and analytical manner. It can be
utilised for various functions like absorbing carbon dioxide and other pollutants, which can
be quantified in a manner that can result in a cleaner air quality of its surrounding areas,
enhancing liveability of high-density developments. Thus, it can be integrated with the road
infrastructure to act as a remedy towards air pollution by improving overall Air quality
Index of a city. [6]
Just like any other city, Air Pollution in Bhimavaram is expected to increase in the next
20 years due to rise in Traffic congestion on the existing road network. In order to change
this scenario, After Modelling Pollutant concentration and Air quality index at different
Receptor Locations, as a second step, Quantification is done for carbon absorption capacity
of different types of vegetation that can be used in Bhimavaram. These locally sourced
Plantations are then used on the proposed and upcoming Ring roads/ Expressways (Master
Plan 2041) in a planned manner to reduce the overall Air pollution. These reductions are
also quantified for a small Conceptual design of an Arterial Road in Bhimavaram with
integrated Landscaping, which can be used for both existing and upcoming Road
Infrastructure.
The proposals given for controlling the air pollution at Bhimavaram are based on the
site's current physical features, soil, temperature, and plant types (trees, bushes, etc). Use of
Earthen berms and buffer zones between neighborhood and highway road, which helps to
reduce the effect of air pollution. The typical layout of the highway with details of different
vegetation types is shown in the Figure 4: below:
Figure 4: Conceptual design of an arterial road in Bhimavaram, (Source: Generated by
authors)
For Median 1: Width is 2m, one row of shrubs and ornamental plants are proposed
For Median 2 & 3: Width is 3m, Shaded trees and flowering trees will be planted
at a spacing of 12 m in between.
One row of shrubs will be planted on median 2 & 3.
Turfing with grass in the median
Each vegetation has its own physical and technical specifications according to which it
is analyzed how much carbon absorption is achieved through them. It also helps us arrive at
a number of trees that are to be planted on a particular road stretch to decrease carbon
concentration in air. Figure shows the carbon absorption levels of proposed locally sourced
trees in Bhimavaram city.
Calculation-
CO2 Emission Concentration = 46.78 ppm
Total Carbon Absorption = 40.40 ppm
CO2 Concentration = (46.78 – 40.40) ppm = 6.38 ppm
In landscaping, each type of vegetation is used such as shrubs, trees, hedges, and decorative
plants, has unique characteristics, life spans, water requirements, heights, leaves and other
physical characteristics. For each type of vegetation planted on Highways, the Green
Highway Plantation Policy (2015), has certain additional specifications. The technical
specifications for planting are displayed in Table 9: .
2 Peepal Ficus Religiosa 0.2 7.5 0.038 600 22.93 5.98 28.89 0.29 16 4.62
Cocos Nucifera
3 Coconut 0.16 10 0.033 500 16.31 4.24 20.55 0.21 20 4.11
(L.)
Polyalthia
4 Ashoka 0.18 8 0.033 730 24.10 6.29 30.37 0.30 18 5.47
Longifolia
5 Weeping Fig Ficus Benjamina 0.21 7 0.039 650 25.56 6.65 32.21 0.32 12 3.86
Alstonia
6 Blackboard tree 0.15 6 0.017 620 10.66 2.77 13.43 0.13 16 2.15
Aungustifolia
Cassia Fistula
7 Amaltas 0.25 9.5 0.076 710 53.70 13.96 67.66 0.88 21 14.21
Linn.
8 Bougainvillea Bougainvillea 0.025 0.45 0.000 200 0.01 0.00 0.01 0.00 30 0.00
9 Gulmohar Delonix Regia 0.13 4.5 0.010 600 5.81 1.51 7.32 0.07 12 0.88
10 Jungle Flame Ixora Dwarf Red 0.05 1.5 0.000 280 0.13 0.03 0.17 0.00 28 0.05
3 SUMMARY
Figure 5: Mapping of Carbon Monoxide in Case area through Kriging Method (Source:
Generated by Authors)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The study was carried out as a part of the project ‘‘Comprehensive Mobility Plan 2022,
Bhimavaram’’ in 2022. We thank Ms. Naina Gupta, assistant professor at School of
Planning and Architecture, Vijayawada for her assistance on the subject and software
application. We also would like to express our appreciation to the batch of Masters in
Transport planning, 2021-23 at School of Planning and Architecture, Vijayawada, for
assistance in data collection process.
REFERENCES
[1] R. Baldauf, "Roadside vegetation design characteristics that can improve local, near-
road air quality," Transportation Research Part D, vol. 354, no. 361, p. 52 , 2017 .
[2] T. K. D. N. Elizabeth Ann Yura, "Using CALINE dispersion to assess vehicular
PM2.5 emissions," Atmospheric Environment , vol. 41, p. 8747–8757, 2007.
[3] C. Central pollution control Board, "National ambient air quality staus and trends,"
Ministry of environment, forest and limate change, 2020.
[4] R. D. &. N. Sharma, "Vehicular pollution dispersion modelling along roads," Int. J.
Environmental Technology and Management, vol. 21, no. 2018, p. 20, 2018.
[5] N. S. Rajni Dhyani, "Vehicular pollution dispersion modelling along roads," Int. J.
Environmental Technology and Management, vol. 21, no. 2, 2018.
[6] T. E. T. U. S. N. a. O. C. A. Ejikeme Johnson, "Landscaping as a strategy for curbing
Air Pollution and Environmental degradation in Enugu Metropolis," International
Journal of Advanced Scientific Research and Management, vol. III, no. 1 JAN, 2018,
p. 12, 2018.
[7] W. T. M. J. F. D. K. H. S. G. P. A. F. V. Gayle S.W. Hagler, "Model evaluation of
roadside barrier impact on near-road air pollution," Atmospheric Environment, vol. 45,
no. 15, pp. 2522-2530, 2011.
[8] P. Benson, "CALINE4-A Dispersion Model for Prediction Air Pollutant
Concentrations Near Roadways. California," California Department of
Transportation, Sacramento, CA, 1984.
[9] M. A. A. S. DHANAKUMAR*, "VEHICULAR POLLUTION AND ITS
IMPLICATIONS," Poll Res. 38 (3) : 634-647 (2019), p. 14, 2019.
[10] A. C. M. N. B. G. Vlachokostas C, "Multicriteria methodological approach to manage
urban air pollution," Atmos Environ 45(25):4160–4169, 2011.
[11] E. P. T. C. A. B. A. O. B. D. Woodcock J, "Public health benefits of strategies to
reduce," Lancet 374(9705):1930–1943, 2009.
[12] W.-. W. H. Organization, "Health aspects of air pollution with particulate matter,
ozone andnitrogen dioxide," WHO Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen., 2003.
[13] W.-. W. H. Organisation, "Air Quality Health," Air Management Information System
AMIS3.0. World Health Organization, Geneva, 2001.
[14] V. H. G. H. S. Ashish Verma, "Evolution of Urban Transportation Policies in India: A
Review," Transportation in Developing Economies , vol. 7:25, p. 15, 2021.