CRS \Closeout Status

Subject: Owner's Comments Total Comments 23

Project Title: 2000MW Haden PV Project Open 9

Document No.: SAU1001-W100-AHQ-&EED-00001-3 Document Title: MV Cable and Accessories Calculations Closed 14

Approval Status: AWC CRS Rev. No.: 3.0 Closeout Progress 61%

Comment
Comment # Section/Page Chapter/Topic Doc Rev Date Doc Rev. No. Owner's Comments Owner Date EPC's Response EPC Date Comment Status
Owner

EPC shall follow the sequence of documentation to avoid rejection,

This document Subjected to submission of below documents
01-Overall Layout of PV Plant
30-Sep-24 0 02-MV Cables routing layout 5-Oct-24 Noted, all this document will be submited to TP system. 24-Oct-24
03-PV plant Area MV AC Single line diagram
04-Vendor document of MVPS (medium voltage power station )
1 OE GEN Closed
29/10/2024 1 MV Cables routing layout for all PV plant not submitted yet 2-Nov-24 The rest of the plant will be submitted soon 28-Nov-24
MV Cables routing layout for all PV plant not submitted yet, we can't give final approval to Calculation document while its
01/12/2024 2 Noted, the layout will be submitted during this week 9-Dec-24
linked with all PV plant MV Cable trenches
Agreed in workshop and meetings that have explained the problems facing in construction
01/12/2024 3 Noted, the layout will be submitted during this week 9-Dec-24
01- For Soil thermal resistivity 1,2 K·m/W ( LAP Report is required )
As per OTS: All certificates and test reports shall be emitted by an authorized and reputable testing institution or ILAC
30-Sep-24 0 accredited laboratory in the testing standards according to IEC/ISO 17025. The Contractor shall provide all valid certificates 5-Oct-24 Noted, the EPC will provide the reports. 24-Oct-24
and test reports requested by the Owner to demonstrate such compliance.

2 OE page 10 Closed
29/10/2024 1 comment remain open till provide 2-Nov-24 Noted, the EPC will provide the reports once is ready. 28-Nov-24
comment remain open till provide
01/12/2024 2 Noted, EPC Construction quality team will provided the report for soil resistivity. 9-Dec-24

Agreed in workshop
3

30-Sep-24 0 please use 40 deg c ground temperature for all cable sizing. 5-Oct-24 Noted, the report is updated with this requirement in the new version. 24-Oct-24
on page 14, please correct and proccide the new values at 40

This is the temperature value that the vendor gives the ampacity indicated, which we then
3 OE page 10 29/10/2024 1 2-Nov-24 28-Nov-24 Closed
correct to the design temperature of 40 ºC ground temperature.

01/12/2024 2 noted
All mentioned short-circuit current Values mentioned subjected to approval of Grid impact study approval
For short circuit /loading level please provide the approved short circuit study report Noted, the Grid impact study is in progress and that, once completed, it will be forwarded to
30-Sep-24 0 5-Oct-24 24-Oct-24
4 OE page 11 the TP. Closed

29/10/2024 31-Dec-99 noted 2-Nov-24

The F3 derating factor Soil thermal resistivity Shall be calculated for the average between native soil 2.7 and supplied soil 1.2

IEC does not consider mixed soil resistivities, obtaining the resistivity with the average of
the two resistivities is not a methodology that is included in IEC 60502-2, the calculation will
be performed with the resistivity of the uniform soil with the resistivity of the improved soil
4.3.3 Soil 1.25.
30-Sep-24 0 5-Oct-24 24-Oct-24
5 OE Thermal Closed
Resistivity (F3) To check that the calculation is valid, we use the cymcap software, validated software for
cable calculation according to IEC standard, which is able to calculate the cable conditions
for soils of different resistivities.

29/10/2024 31-Dec-99 noted 2-Nov-24

4.3.4 Grouping of Circuits (F4), why the EPC isn't consider The most restrictive Case of no of circuits mentioned "The most From EPC feedback trench with 16 MV circuit will be eliminated since the dimensions of the
4.3.4 Grouping 30-Sep-24 0 restrictive case is Sixteen (16) MV cables" in page 12 5-Oct-24 trench would complicate a lot the works around it, the trenches that exceed 10 circuits will 24-Oct-24
6 OE why consider 12 group factor ? be split in two. Closed
of Circuits (F4)
29/10/2024 31-Dec-99 noted 2-Nov-24
Depth: 0.70 m (bottom of the cable). on CYMCAP Trench depth 0.8m
As per the OTS : The depth of the trench shall be dug deep enough to provide a minimum ground cover above the
top of the pipe/cable and a ground bed of at least 150mm in depth below the bottom of the pipe/cable.
30-Sep-24 0 5-Oct-24 Noted, the report is updated with this requirement in the new version. 24-Oct-24
7 OE page 17 So please correct and consider the requirements of the OTS Closed

29/10/2024 31-Dec-99 noted 2-Nov-24

# Public
 *LEGEND:
APP Approved
AWC Approved With Comments
REJ Rejected

# Public
 0
561 0.85 1 0.88 0.72
302.13216 0.53856