design_1735973315
design_1735973315
A Design Guide
Urban Minded
How can the design of urban spaces contribute to the
mental well-being of teenage girls?
A Design Guide
2023
Project Team
Maya Shpiro/ Advisor R&D, Social Sustainability
Trine Relster/ Process Consultant
Dorte Buchardt Westergaard / Associate Design Director
Lea Uguen / Landscape Architect
Frederik Schou-Juul / PhD fellow, Principle Investigator
Marie Eva Berg / Research Assistant
Illustrations
Paweł Floryn ([email protected])
Expert Group
Camilla Van Deurs, Kaya Roessler, Cecilie Nørgaard, Laura Bendix Pedersen,
Carsten Friberg, Marie Astrup, Natasja Lund, Signe Højbjerre Larsen,
Katrine Rich Madsen, Kristine Sejr, Mikkel Hjort
Urban Minded 5
A Consequential Reading Guide
Point of Departure
The design of our cities can have a
significant effect on our well-being
and mental health. This design
guide explores this relationship
by presenting design strategies
to approach this complex subject,
with a focus on the particular
perspectives, preferences, and
needs of teenage girls.
As a pillar of the socially sustainable city, the Resulting in a nuanced grasp of teenage girls This Design Guide is the second of two Whether municipalities exploring urban
well-being of urban residents is incredibly aged 14-16 and their needs within the city, booklets that are the product of Henning development, designers working on
important to generating social impact and the project bridges early user involvement Larsen’s research and design project masterplans, or consultants engaged in
deconstructing social structures that limit and intersectional perspectives to inform ‘Urban Minded’. The two publications can urban strategies - we hope these booklets
certain groups. And while the mental health design strategies that are aimed at inclusive be read separately or together, with the can support anyone wanting to promote
of girls and young women continues to public urban spaces. second building upon the first. The first inclusive spaces.
decrease(1), the link between the design of booklet focuses on the project’s approach,
our urban environments and the promotion Having translated the collected data from research design, and methodology, while the Enjoy reading!
of mental health amongst this group remains our research, the booklet you have in front one you have in your hands presents design
unclear. As a result, the diverse needs of girls of you is the result of a multidisciplinary proposals informed by the study.
and young women are, at best, generalized collaboration between landscape architects, Reading guide:
within the field of urban design – an issue urban designers, and anthropologists at These booklets are intended for anyone
that this project has set out to address. Henning Larsen. interested in reimagining public urban ‘Findings boxes’ presenting some
spaces or anyone who works with urban of our findings from the project.
A collaboration between Henning Larsen design and planning.
and the Danish National Institute of Public Quotes from our expert group that
Health, with the support of the Ramboll support the findings and concepts.
Foundation, ‘Urban Minded’ is a research
project that was carried out in Copenhagen Quotes from girls who participated
over the course of several months in 2022 in the project.
and 2023.
(1)
Agenda Alliance, Women’s Mental Health Facts, https://www.agendaalliance.org/our-work/projects-and-cam-
paigns/womens-mental-health-facts/
Urban Minded 7
Process Guide
at a Glance
1
excitement, interest, discomfort, etc.
With the question of ‘how the design of How do we make urban
urban spaces contribute to the mental spaces more attractive Sense of Safety IN BETWEENESS
health and well-being of teenage girls?’ for girls? Condition of feeling secure, feeling that
as our point of departure, and the following one is not in harms way or in danger of
three challenges (listed to the right) guiding physical/emotional hurt, injury, loss, etc.
2
us throughout, we set out to gather the lived
How can we design
experiences of 25 teenage girls in relation Visibility & Recognition
to their urban environments through
urban spaces in ways Seeing and being seen, understanding
interviews, video diaries, and workshops. that contributes to and being understood, recognizing and
teenage girls' mental being recognized.
When processing our data, we drew upon well-being? TO FLOW in the city
a framework that identifies 6 psychological Levels of Privacy
3
needs within one’s spatial experience to Varying states of being apart from
approach the complex matter of mental How do we company or observation of others.
health and well-being. Combining these with avoid falling into
our nuanced collected data, we were able to stereotypes? Social Interaction
identify several key focus areas that were Processes of reciprocal influence of TO BE in the city
then translated into design drivers to guide individuals over one another during
the design process. social encounter.
Urban Minded 9
Unfolding our
Design Drivers
User engagement provided us with Extracted from the interviews, workshops Inbetween-ness
a lot of inspiring data to process and talks with both the girls and the experts, An experience of straddling childhood and adulthood
and analyze, exemplifying how the three design drivers, along with the simultaneously. This notion envelopes our findings,
diverse lived experiences and principle of inbetween-ness, are all here to acting as an important concept and consistent red
needs actually play out within an guide us in designing elements and spaces thread throughout the project.
urban environment. that orbit around the lived experiences,
preferences and spatial needs of teenage
A key finding in our research and central girls. To FLOW in the city
concept to understanding the experiences Being part of the flow of the city is both central to the
and perspectives of this user group, is a girls’ urban experiences and a basic aspect of using the
notion of ‘inbetween-ness’. Inbetween-ness city. Far beyond simply ‘getting around’, this includes
acts as an overarching principle in our notions of exploration, discovery, observations of
design strategies and proposal. urban life, and more.
Urban Minded 11
Getting Creative,
Together
Feedback
Urban Minded 13
Disclaimer:
Design Alone Won’t But more things need to be
free, or at least it helps if
Economy
Urban Minded 15
Abstract Vision -
Concrete Actions
Homes, schools, stations,squares, Cities are sites that combine the old and
boulevards, parks, plazas... these the new, the traditional and the fresh. That
are all elements that can be found is why these design solutions can all be
in most of the urban contexts integrated in existing urban landscapes,
around us. Using a representation between buildings, and in leftover
of an abstract city as the backdrop, spaces, but they can also be part of new
the following pages will dive into developments or transformed spaces. THE CITY IS
our design drivers in greater detail. NOW
Combined they showcase a vision
of a city - a city designed and
While the presented design solutions focus
on the perspectives of teenage girls, they
OUR PLAYGROUND !
informed by the perspectives and embody truly exciting potentials within LETS GET TO WORK...
preferences of teenage girls! inclusive design, with benefits that extend
far beyond this user group.
Exploring each of the design drivers - ‘To
FLOW’, ‘To BE’, and ‘To PLAY’ - separately, That said, these design solutions aim to
each section will start by unfolding the inspire and bring light to some important
significance of each driver as well as its principles and ideas, but should not be seen
relation to mental health (through the as generic solutions to apply in any setting.
psychological needs corresponding to it). They are informed by the involvement of
To follow, we show the diverse ways in teenage girls in a particular context that
which each concept could present itself as a is tied to its geography, culture, climate,
strategy in the broad context of this abstract etc., and so, they evidence the potential of
city (using the words and perspectives of the unfolding similar projects elsewhere.
girls we engaged with).
Urban Minded 17
How does this relate to
their psychological needs?
as a teenager
surprises that can help with orientation, girls’ (and their guardians’)
of discovery and adventure, stimulation, and a growing feeling of perceptions of safety and
embarking on some of their first ownership as the city becomes increasingly boost their sense of freedom to
independent urban journeys. familiar. explore.
Urban Minded 19
TO FLOW IN THE CITY I don’t really stop and sit
too much. There’s just so
That big tower over there
helps me find my way when I
TEENAGE GIRLS’ SENSITIVE MAPS
much movement in the don’t want to use my phone.
street and I like being I like feeling that I know my
It’s so nice when a bridge part of it instead of just way around the ctiy.
I like the anonymity of or a bike lane gives you watching it...
the city. I like that most enough space to also
people don’t know me. have some fun on the
I could be anyone. I could way.
even be much older.
I love running in this park.
Some paths feel a bit hidden
and I like that because it can
We just pass by here on feel like an adventure, like a
the way, we have some secret run in nature, almost
quick fun here and then like being in a forest.
we keep moving on. It’s
just a nice place to stop
through on our way to
meeting our friends!
I often choose the way that is I like that in the city you
the most lit, not necessarily can get small glimpses into
because something will people's lives. I'll do this
happen, it is just something thing where I look at people
I’m used to doing... and then I imagine stories
about their lives.
Urban Minded 21
Offer flexible space that
is easily connected to
the main flow axis for Diversity of activities &
temporary events like flea open ground floors invite Colorful paths and
markets, food markets, social interactions and bikelanes highlight easy
and more. offer lively stimulation and fun ways to move in
along the way. the city, away from car
Space in Artistic wayfinding
Active & Lively traffic.
Transition Notable Paths elements along the main
Streets axis highlight gathering
& Bike Lanes points and evoke curiosity.
PLACES Invitation for
TO FLOW
Discoveries
1 Engaging journeys
Bridges as
Experiences
Shapes, materiality and Playful & Obvious Active & Illuminated
heights can turn bridges Crossings Transport Stations
into playful elements and Clear & Wide Colors or materiality create Metro and bus stations act
allow you to see the city Bike Lanes easily identifiable crossings as active gathering and
from a different angle Extra-wide bike lanes make between the main axis and orienting points in the city
while on your way. the journey safer and also lanes, increasing the feeling landscape.
give friends the opportunity of safety and strengthen the
to talk or cycle side-by-side. identity of the place.
Urban Minded 23
Lighting elements
as urban landmarks
Safe & clear paths through strengthen a place’s
parks and natural spaces identity & create Stepping stones or
offer a sense of escape as safe and enjoyable paths to play with
Art installations
well as calming sensory atmospheres. your balance offer
along the way can
stimulation. Creative some quick and low
act as orientation
Alternative & Lighting stakes fun along your
points and engaging
way.
Sensory Paths elements in the city.
Gravity Paths Orienting &
Engaging Art
PLACES
TO FLOW
2 Surprises
along the way
Surprises, or physical elements
that might seem out of the
ordinary can enrich personal
experiences and relationships
with our urban surroundings.
Whether colorful walls, fun roads
and paths, creative lighting,
or unexpected and exciting
materials - surprises offer intrigue
and showcase the liveliness of a
dynamic city.
Urban Minded 25
How does this relate to
their psychological needs?
a teenager
between connected and
providing spaces to meet the isolated spaces.
changing needs of the girls.
BEing alone, BEing together, BEing Levels of Privacy
able to escape, BEing discreet, Privacy can be about being
BEing visible, BEing active, BEing away from the gaze of parents
lazy... There needs to be room and teachers. Varying scales
for us in the city! allow you to decide how visible
Design solutions informed by the spatial That’s really important to be and with how many
experience of BEing, aim to rethink and that we can always find people.
diversify the free and open spaces that a at least one space that’s
city has to offer. By making them more Identity
right for us.
welcoming and better suited to teenage Providing the experience of
girls, urban spaces can encourage a sense of finding “your” place in the city,
ownership fostering the notion that the city a place to relate to and identify
is in fact theirs. with.
Urban Minded 27
TO BE IN THE CITY We just need some grass,
a good bench under some
Sometimes you’re really
stressed out and you want
to scream but you can’t just
TEENAGE GIRLS’ SENSITIVE MAPS trees, and we are good to go. scream randomly so we come
For me, it’s nice to be in a place I could spend hours like that here and go on the rides so
that you can feel part of, and at with my best friend. we can scream as much as we
the same time you can isolate a
want.
We like to gather where we can have as bit with your best friend and have
many people as we want and where we your own space too .
can also organise the space as we want...
it’s good because everything about the
situation can change all the time.
I like this hidden corner
in the library where I can
move the furniture around
and just read.
I’m usually really busy so
sometimes I just want to be
on my own. If the weather’s
good, I’ll get an iced-coffee
and bring my headphones
and find a bench in my
favorite park. Sometimes, I just need to be
in nature or by the water. It
helps clear my mind, if I am
stressed or tense...
THINGS NEED
TO BE FREE !
Urban Minded 29
Small outdoor
‘decompression’ spaces
give room for moments
between destinations,
whether after school or Whether under a tree, or
Offer more than one
before an activity. Free & flexible spaces near next to a river, the value
way to seat together
Inbetween common gathering points or alone, by giving
of spaces connecting with
for teens, like a cheap kiosk natural elements cannot be
Moments or shop.
different shapes,
undermined.
viewpoints and
Free & atmospheres. Among the
Flexible Differing Elements
Views
PLACES
TO BE
1 Finding
the right places
Finding the right place at the
right time is a tough task, at any
age. Diversity, flexibility, and
accessibility of places are key to
encourage and attract teenage
girls to public urban spaces, while
never losing sight of sense of
safety and comfort!
More
Public Toilets
Access to free & clean
public toilets is essential
to accommodating the
needs of teenage girls
and encouraging them to
spend time in public urban Hydration Points Common Watch Me
spaces.
Teenagers, active or not, Tables Closer
depend on free facilities to Tables allow for (Re)use of
Seating areas integrated into
be able to enjoy outdoor spontaneous
existing sport areas, like
Leftover Spaces
spaces throughout the day. interactions, Utilizing spaces in the
skateparks and basketball
picnics or even existing and sometimes
courts, connect between players
outdoor study dense urban context, can
& observers by mixing the roles.
sessions. provide the varying levels
of privacy that teens seek.
Urban Minded 31
An elevated point in a
plaza or a park offers More seating places along
space to isolate in without the main active streets or
disconnecting from the boulevards allow teens
Integrate simple and city’s rhythm. the sense of being part of
city life just by observing
natural based material into Urban others.
spaces to hang out in the Lighthouse
park, the more grass and People Watching
wooden surface, the better.
Invitation to
Nature
PLACES
TO BE
2 Intrigue
through shapes
& materiality
Varying shapes, materiality,
Find Your Bubble
dimensions, and atmospheres
Seating bubbles or pods
create a sense of intrigue in for one or two people,
public spaces and offer a range where the shape provides
of experiences. A swing that fits a sense of protection and
creates intimate spaces in
you and your friends together, the the city.
ability to lie down or to play with
gravity, a circular form to invite
social gatherings... integrated next Make Your
to existing facilities or spread out Own Space
as small interventions along your Flexible furniture can be
adjusted according to the
way, these provide diverse ways number of people and the
of being and enjoying urban space, need for shade or sun.
while also making it your own.
Sensory &
Aromatic
Experiences
Sharing table Smells can stimulate
Invitation to feelings of comfort in an
An oversized table
Dream Reinterpreting outdoor space, especially
invites people to
extend the habits of Lighting & art installations
the Swing when natural elements
provide spaces that With materials & heights are incorporated.
home into the city.
allow you to dream and that make you play with
stimulate your creativity gravity, simply sitting
or emotions. becomes an engaging
activity.
Urban Minded 33
How does this relate to
their psychological needs?
a teenager
means inviting them into
expectation. spaces through representation.
I love it when I get a chance
Between playgrounds for young children, Stimulation
to be silly and joke around. It makes
outdoor exercise equipment for adults, and To feel welcome in an active
traditional sports facilities predominantly me feel like a child again! urban space, it’s important to
used by boys, where can teenage girls shake I think a lot of people really miss offer stimuli that differs from
their urban encounters with age and gender that feeling... and not just people the ‘spatial codes’ (physical
barriers to really be active and play in public my age, also adults. or social) that can keep
space? We don’t have to be responsible individuals away.
and mature all the time.
At an age when playing might seem childish Identity
and your self-consciousness can keep Introducing diverse ways
you somewhat restrained, designing for to be active and diverse
the spatial experience of PLAY is about representations of interests
integrating elements throughout the city that or hobbies in public spaces
encourage playful attitudes and activities can signal to users that their
for all! identity is welcomed and
supported by the city.
Design solutions informed by this driver
must acknowledge the barriers that keep Social Interactions
individuals from being active in public Mixing ways to be active
spaces. They aim to expand the notion outside can encourage
of PLAY by going beyond conventions to interactions, between teenage
encourage curiosity, creativity, imagination girls, but also with other
and playfulness at any age. generations and user groups.
Urban Minded 35
I like sitting on these swings and
seeing the skaters over there
TO PLAY IN THE CITY doing all their tricks. It’s so cool.
They’re so good at it and I like
TEENAGE GIRLS’ SENSITIVE MAPS that they also look out for each
other. Like helping each other up
after a fall.
It would be nice to have
a place that feels like a stage, but It would be so cool to have like a
that is also not officially one... Then tunnel or something, or just a wall
we could do theater, or dance, or play where you could paint whatever you
music. Maybe I would read out my want. I would love that.
Sometimes it just feels like things poetry... could be nice, just a space Like a place where you can be
are for younger kids, like there’s an to express ourselves. creative every day and it changes
age restriction. Like if I were to go every day !
on those swings, there would be no
one around my age. It’s like I’m too
old for that. I like to feel that the place has
been used by many people before
me, that it has a past.... It makes
me more relaxed about making
something there, like we won’t
make it look more or less worn by
using it.
There doesn’t have to be an
activity for us to start doing
something. We can come up
with a game ourselves...
Urban Minded 37
Create fields mixing Spread out playful
sports and non-sport elements in the city, along
activities, to encourage the main pedestrian or Playing with the
people to take part, bike paths. The city topography of a plaza
without the pressure of Spread & place any
is a playground! allows spontaneous &
being any good at it. playful elements along
Pieces of unamed activities to take
the main flow axes of
Just Fun, Playground place. A stone hill becomes
teenagers, mapping their
No Pressure a temporary stage, or
main gathering points &
perhaps a skating ramp...
favorite paths.
Active &
Connecting Open up skateparks &
Open Plaza
PLACES Flow & Play facilities to invite others to
take part, whether skating,
TO PLAY
observing, or using the
space in other ways.
Open-Up
What is There
1 Infinite ways
to be active
Once the notion of play is
expanded and urban spaces are
arranged to support this, the city
in its entirety becomes a site for
playful experiences!
By creating unconventional
opportunities or invitations to
use spaces freely, and by having
diverse activities and hobbies
visibly represented, we can spread
PLAY beyond the playground,
extending it far beyond early
childhood.
Active Geology
Invite to a climbing
Play with Water experience through small
Playful water features bouldering walls and
for warm days. Water adapted floors.
Expression walls Curiosity invites everyone closer.
Add small activities on Cabinet
Provide free or cheap
existing walls with simple
rental equipment.
signs, graffiti, wall-tennis,
Ping-pong paddles, dance
dance... be active with your
equipment, balls, frisbee,
body and imagination.
and more...
Urban Minded 39
Open & free spaces Sometimes to allow
Provide flexible
allow users to be as yourself to play, be active,
urban elements along
Integrate simple & loud as they want, creative, & fully express
waterfronts or rivers,
natural materials to create whether playing with a yourself, you need to be
whether fishing spots, Adjusted heights &
spaces to hang out in the band, singing with your hidden from the eyes of
viewpoints, jumping & shapes allow teens to
park. The more grass and friends, or screaming to others...
swimming areas.. use playful elements
wooden surface, the
Playful simply by being better
release frustration. Hide & Play
better! suited to their bodies. Soundbox
Invitation to Interface
With Water Scale-Up
nature
PLACES
TO PLAY
2 Creative shapes
Active
Artful Watching
Create opportunites for
Active Lines Playground different activities by
Simply marking the floor Let art in public space
Take Hobbies with lines, colorful or not, act as an unamed
simply offering another
point of view of the city
Outdoors can spark the imagination and unexpected you live in.
Update existing or new for more activities and playground, whether
playground installations games to happen. for teenage girls,
by adding other hobbies adults or anyone!
that are often missing, like
painting, dancing, boxing,
and more.
Urban Minded 41
Next Steps
Having read through this design manual So, what are the next steps?
(whether you’re a designer, municipality, If you’re feeling inspired by this project, do
consultant, foundation, social organization, get in touch to share your ideas, continue the
developer, or anything else), we imagine discussion, and find ways to work together
that, like us, you are interested in improving to make these ambitions an urban reality,
urban spaces for girls and young women, step by step!
and making our cities more inclusive for all!
AND secondly, let us continue to seek
A first step in opening up the imagination opportunities to design our cities with care
for design solutions informed by the and consideration for the lived experiences
needs, preferences and lived experiences of diverse user groups.
of teenage girls, this guide has shown how
these could be implemented in an abstract We’re looking forward to crafting a more
urban setting. These concepts and design inclusive urban future, we hope you are too!
ideas are not meant to be adopted as generic
solution for any context, instead they
demand to be adapted through a return to
user engagement, and to be tailored to both
the spatial and cultural contexts, resources,
and stakeholders involved.
Yalda Pilehchian
Senior Strategic Urban Designer
([email protected])
Urban Minded 43