hw3soln
hw3soln
Enthalpy
Given: Table of properties for two substances
b) Gas
For an ideal gas, p RT ; so density should be roughly proportional to pressure for a gas.
Since density is nearly independent of pressure for substance B, it is unlikely to be a gas.
For substance A, the first two conditions show that the density is proportional to pressure
when the temperature is held constant. So substance A is likely to be a gas.
c) Calorically perfect
To be calorically perfect, we would expect a gas to have c v~constant or cp~constant. Since
we have a number of values for constant pressure, let’s look at cp=h/T|p. Approximating this
from our table of data,
h 253 83.8 kJ kg
e.g., c p 0.85 kJ kg K
T 500 300K
Implications:
1) For a gas (substance A), enthalpy is mostly a function of temperature, not pressure.
2) For other substances (like B) where density is nearly constant (i.e., an incompressible
substance) with changes in pressure, enthalpy is a stronger function of pressure.
3) For high density substances (like B), enthalpies are much less than for for a low
density substance at the same internal energy.
4) Whether a substance can be considered calorically perfect depends on the size of the
error introduced relative to the “acceptable” error.
-2-
Problem 2. Gas Storage
Given: 50.0 kg of N2 initially in closed, rigid T1= 5C=278K T2=45C=318K
container that eventually is heated to p1=65.0 bar V2=V1
conditions shown in figure. m=50.0 kg
Find: (a) V1min
(b) p2
(c) Estimate of V error due to ideal N2 N2
gas assumption
Assume: ideal gas for parts (a) and (b), at
equilibrium Q
Analysis:
a) Volume
We know our initial state because we know (p,T), so we can use a state equation to find other
state variables. In this case, use ideal gas state eqn. pV mRT
Verror
mRT p 1 1 1
mRT p Z Z
To find Z, we first need to find the critical temperature and pressure for N2.
-3-
From Appendix H of Black and Hartley or from the web, e.g.,
http://encyclopedia.airliquide.com, we get Tcrit=126K, pcrit=34 bar.
So we have for the reduced temperature and pressure:
278 K 65bar
Tr 2 .2 pr 1 .9
126 K 34 bar
Examining Figure E.3 of the text (or from many places on the web), we find Z0.98.
1
So Verror 1 0.02 or the ideal-gas-based volume will be a few % LARGER than the
0.98
necessary volume.
ALTERNATIVELY,
We can calculate the N2 specific volume (or density from an EOS like the Beattie-
Bridgeman EOS given in Table H.2 in the textbook – or using an online calculator like
http://www.peacesoftware.de/einigewerte/stickstoff_e.html. Using the latter, we find
79.99 kg m3
which means our ideal gas density was 1.6% too low (or – again - our volume calculated
from the ideal gas EOS was about 2% too high).
Implications:
1) If our storage tank was a sphere, it would have a diameter of ~1 m. So it takes a pretty
big tank to hold 50 kg of a gas, even at high pressure.
2) Even though the gas is being stored at a pressure almost twice the critical pressure,
the fact that the temperature is well above the critical temperature means the gas is
still nearly ideal.
-4-
Problem 3. Work & Energy Change
Given: 10.lbm of ideal gas with p1=2.0 atm p2=3 p1
MW=60.1, =1.23 T1=140.F=600.R v2= v1
m1=10. lbm m2=m1
Find: (a) U12 (kJ)
(b) H12 (kJ)
(b) W12 p 2
p2 3p 3 p RT
T2 v2 1 v1 1 1 3T1 or T2 T1 3T1 T1 2T1
R R R p1
=0.033 BTU/lbmR
BTU lbm
1.986 60.1
So U 12 10.lbm lbmolR lbmol 2600.R 1730BTU
1.23 1
b) H12
BTU
So H12 1730BTU 10lbm 0.033 1200R 2120BTU
lbm R
or we could have gotten there even more simply for our TPG/CPG …
H12 mcp T2 T1 mcv T2 T1 U12 1.231730BTU 2120BTU
-5-
2
W12 pdV 0 since there is no change in volume in our assumed path. There could also
1
be other kinds of work being done, but we assumed there was none.
Implications:
1) In this case the internal energy increases without NET work being done to the system
– this suggests there must have been some heat transfer to raise the temperature
2) Note that if we had not had V stay constant
during the complete process (for example look at
the path shown in the figure), then there WOULD p 2
have been net compression work done to the gas
in the vessel. (In the example path shown, the
work done in the third part of the path to the gas
would be greater than the work done by the gas
as it expanded in the first part of the path.) 1
3) So if we had NOT assumed a fixed volume for
the whole path and NOT assumed that v
compression work was the only possible work,
then we could not have provided an answer for part c. Without knowing the process
involved in going from state 1 to state 2, you can’t figure out how much work was
required.
-6-
Problem 4. Ideal Gases – U and H
T T2=1000. K
Given: Simple compressible substance, H2 or H2O p2=10.0 atm
undergoing change shown in figure.
Find: h12 and u12 for
(a) calor. perfect (with room T values) T1=350. K
(b) polynomial fits from D.11 p1=1.0 atm
(c) tables (D.4 and D.7)
Assume: Ideal gases
p
Analysis: We can use the following for thermally perfect gases:
h12 c p dT and (1)
u12 cv dT (2)
cv c p R c p R MW (3)
h2 h1 u2 u1 RT2 T1
or
u12 h12
R
T2 T1 (4)
MW
a) For calor. perfect assumption, specific heats are constants. So eq (1) gives:
h12 c p dT c p T2 T1 and u12 cv T2 T1
From Table D.9 cp,H2=14.31 kJ/kgK, cp,H2O =1.865 kJ/kgK,
cv,H2=10.19 kJ/kgK, cv,H2O =1.404 kJ/kgK
and T2 T1 =650K.
kJ kJ
So h12, H 2 9300 , h12, H 2O 1210
kg kg
kJ kJ
u12, H 2 6620 , u12, H 2O 913
kg kg
b) From Table D.11, (T in Kelvin)
H2 H 2O
a 3.057 4.07
cp b 2.677 10 3 1.108 10 3
a bT cT dT eT
2 3 4
with
R c 5.180 10 6 4.152 10 6
d 5.521 10 9 2.964 10 9
e 1.812 10 12 8.07 10 13
Ra bT cT
T2
From eq (1), h12 c p dT dT 3 eT 4 dT
2
T1
1000
R T2 T3 T4 T5
h12 aT b c d e
MW 2 3 4 5 350
kJ kJ
So using the values from above h12, H 2 10340 , h12, H 2O 1350
kg kg
u12, H 2 7660 kJ kg
8.314 kJ kJ
Similarly u12, H 2O 1350 650. 1050
18.02 kg kg
For H2O, these are essentially the same numbers obtained from the polynomial fits to cp
in part b, BUT NOT for the H2 results.
Implications:
1) The results for H2 using the table data are close (within ~2-3%) to the ones we
found using the simpler calorically perfect gas assumption (case a) meaning H2 is
close to being calorically perfect from 350-1000K.
2) HOWEVER for H2O, the change in the values are somewhat larger (~10-13%)
comparing the (room T) constant specific heat calculation to the more accurate table
data. Therefore, we can conclude that the calorically perfect assumption is less
valid for H2O from 350-1000K.
3) The polynomial fit data for the H2O specific heat provides essentially the same
answer as the table data, BUT the polynomial fit given for H 2 produces significantly
different results from the table data. This suggests the H 2 polynomial may be a poor
fit to its actual cp/R values.
For example, another source (NASA tables) suggests the following polynomial
values for H2’s cp/R:
a B c d e
3.337279 -4.94024710-05 4.99456810-07 -1.79566410-10 2.00255410-14
Problem 5. Liquid Methane – Compression and Heating
Given: 525 kg of liquid methane stored at 120 K
Find: (a) Volume of container for p=2.5 MPa
(b) V/V for p changed to 0.5 MPa (but same T=120K)
(c) T required for same V/V with p still 2.5 MPa
(d) H(5.0MPa,120K) - H(0.5MPa,120K) vs H(2.5MPa,125K) - H(2.5MPa,120K)
Assume: none
Analysis:
a) Volume
We want to know
V 0.5MPa,120 K V 2.5MPa,120 K 1 CH 4 0.5MPa,120 K
1
V 2.5MPa,120 K 1 CH 4 2.5MPa,120 K
V 1 410.25
1 0.0053
V 1 412.42
To get the same fractional volume change, we need to find the temperature such that
CH 2.5MPa,T CH 0.5MPa,120K 410.25 kg m3
4 4
We can use the 2ndtable given in this problem (properties for p=2.5MPa) and interpolate,
e.g., using a linear approximation between temperatures. From the table, we can see that
the temperature will be between 120 and 125K. Using the linear approximation:
125K 120 K
T 120 K T 120K
125K 120 K
T 120K
or T 120K 5K
125K 120K
Inserting values from the table
410.25 412.42
T 120 K 5K 121.4 K
404.81 412.42
d) Enthalpy Changes
Since our tables give the specific internal energy, not the specific enthalpy, we can use the
general expression h u pv u p . So for example
kJ 0.5 106 N m 2
hCH 4 0.5MPa,120K 28.599
kJ J kJ
3
28.599 1219 29.82
kg 410.25 kg m kg kg kg
Using a similar approach for the other specific enthalpy values, and with H=mh, we find
Implications:
1) Liquid methane under the conditions given can be well approximated as a nearly
incompressible substance. The volume or density change only increase by ~0.5%
as the pressure is raised from 5 bar to 25 bar.
2) Even though this liquid can be considered incompressible, that does not mean its
density can’t change. Just a 1 K change in the temperature causes the same
density to drops as much as a 5 pressure decrease at these conditions. The
density of an incompressible substance can change with temperature.
3) Similar to the findings for density, a large change in pressure produces a smaller
(but not negligible) change in a (nearly incompressible) liquid’s enthalpy compared
to a small change in temperature. This has implications if we were to want to pump
(i.e., compress) a liquid.
Problem 6. Water - Energy Change and Work
Given: Closed piston/cylinder (Vconst)
undergoing p=constant process and initial
conditions shown p2=p1
T2
Find: (a) T2 if V2=0.40 ft3
V2
(b) h2-h1 if V2=0.40 ft3
(c) h2-h1 if T2=600.F
(d) W 12 if T2=600.F m=0.50 lbm
T1=300. F
Assume: process slow enough to be quasi- p1=500. psia
equil.
Analysis:
a) T2 p
At state 2, we know
p2=p1=500.psia
and v2=V2/m=0.4 ft3/0.50lbm=0.8 ft3/lbm
2
we have from B.1E that at 500 psia 1 2
vf=0.01975 ft3/lbm and vg=0.92806 ft3/lbm. T
b) h2-h1
To find h1, we need to find the initial state. Since T1 300F Tsat 500 psia , the initial
state is a compressed liquid. From Table B.4E,
To find h2, we can find the quality at state 2. From Table B.2E at 500 psia,
x2
v2 v f
0.80 0.019749 ft 3 lbm
0.859
3
v fg 0.90831 ft lbm
Then
h2 h f 500 psia h fg x2 449.47 BTU lbm 755.50.859 BTU lbm 1098.5 BTU lbm
At our new state 2 (let’s call it 2), we now have p2=500.psia and T2=600.F.
Since T2' Tsat 500 psia 467F , state 2 is a superheated vapor. From Table B.3E,
d) W12
To calculate the work in the expansion process 12 (with our quasi-equil. assumption)
we can use
2'
W12 pdV p1 V2' V1
1
since pressure is constant during the whole process.
So
W12' pmv2' v1
lb f 144in 2 ft 3
500. 2 0.50lbm 1.1580 0.017415
in ft 2 lbm
52.8BTU 55.7kJ
1BTU
4.11 10 4 ftlb f 4.11 10 4 ftlb f
778 ftlb f
Implications:
1) Work is done BY the water as it expands from a liquid to a gas, and since most of
the volume change occurs as it evaporates (liquid to gas), that is where most of the
work is done
2) Comparing the work done in this process (52.8 BTU or 105.6 BTU/lbm) to the enthalpy
change (1027 BTU/lbm), we get the idea that the energy change in the process is MUCH
greater than the work done (this implies the process requires a lot of heat transfer into the
water, much more than the work done).