Instant Notes in Analytical Chemistry(sec 1)
Instant Notes in Analytical Chemistry(sec 1)
0111
Analytical Chemistry
0111
0111
0111
0
11
ii Section K – Lipid metabolism
Series editor
B.D. Hames
School of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK
Animal Biology
Biochemistry 2nd edition
Chemistry for Biologists
Developmental Biology
Ecology 2nd edition
Genetics
Immunology
Microbiology
Molecular Biology 2nd edition
Neuroscience
Plant Biology
Psychology
Forthcoming titles
Bioinformatics
Analytical Chemistry
Inorganic Chemistry
Medicinal Chemistry
Organic Chemistry
Physical Chemistry
11
Analytical Chemistry
0111
D. Kealey
School of Biological and Chemical Sciences
Birkbeck College, University of London, UK
0111
and
Department of Chemistry
University of Surrey, Guildford, UK
and
0111
P. J. Haines
Oakland Analytical Services,
Farnham, UK
0111
0
11
© BIOS Scientific Publishers Limited, 2002
“To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s
collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.”
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted, in any form or
by any means, without permission.
A CIP catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Distributed exclusively in the United States, its dependent territories, Canada, Mexico, Central
and South America, and the Caribbean by Springer-Verlag New York Inc, 175 Fifth Avenue,
New York, USA, by arrangement with BIOS Scientific Publishers, Ltd, 9 Newtec Place,
Magdalen Road, Oxford OX4 1RE, UK
C ONTENTS
11
Abbreviations vii
Preface ix
0
11
P REFACE
Analytical chemists and others in many disciplines frequently ask questions such as: What is this
substance?; How concentrated is this solution?; What is the structure of this molecule? The answers to
these and many other similar questions are provided by the techniques and methods of analytical
chemistry. They are common to a wide range of activities, and the demand for analytical data of a
chemical nature is steadily growing. Geologists, biologists, environmental and materials scientists,
physicists, pharmacists, clinicians and engineers may all find it necessary to use or rely on some of the
techniques of analysis described in this book.
If we look back some forty or fifty years, chemical analysis concentrated on perhaps three main areas:
qualitative testing, quantitative determinations, particularly by ‘classical’ techniques such as titrimetry
and gravimetry, and structural analysis by procedures requiring laborious and time-consuming calcu-
lations. The analytical chemist of today has an armoury of instrumental techniques, automated systems
and computers which enable analytical measurements to be made more easily, more quickly and more
accurately.
However, pitfalls still exist for the unwary! Unless the analytical chemist has a thorough understand-
ing of the principles, practice and limitations of each technique he/she employs, results may be inaccu-
rate, ambiguous, misleading or invalid. From many years of stressing the importance of following
appropriate analytical procedures to a large number of students of widely differing abilities, backgrounds
and degrees of enthusiasm, the authors have compiled an up-to-date, unified approach to the study of
analytical chemistry and its applications. Surveys of the day-to-day operations of many industrial and
other analytical laboratories in the UK, Europe and the USA have shown which techniques are the most
widely used, and which are of such limited application that extensive coverage at this level would be
inappropriate. The text therefore includes analytical techniques commonly used by most analytical
laboratories at this time. It is intended both to complement those on inorganic, organic and physical
chemistry in the Instant Notes series, and to offer to students in chemistry and other disciplines some guid-
ance on the use of analytical techniques where they are relevant to their work. We have not given extended
accounts of complex or more specialized analytical techniques, which might be studied beyond first- and
second-year courses. Nevertheless, the material should be useful as an overview of the subject for those
studying at a more advanced level or working in analytical laboratories, and for revision purposes.
The layout of the book has been determined by the series format and by the requirements of the
overall analytical process. Regardless of the discipline from which the need for chemical analysis arises,
common questions must be asked:
● How should a representative sample be obtained?
● What is to be determined and with what quantitative precision?
● What other components are present and will they interfere with the analytical measurements?
● How much material is available for analysis, and how many samples are to be analyzed?
● What instrumentation is to be used?
● How reliable is the data generated?
These and related questions are considered in Sections A and B.
Most of the subsequent sections provide notes on the principles, instrumentation and applications of
both individual and groups of techniques. Where suitable supplementary texts exist, reference is made
to them, and some suggestions on consulting the primary literature are made.
We have assumed a background roughly equivalent to UK A-level chemistry or a US general
chemistry course. Some simplification of mathematical treatments has been made; for example, in the
sections on statistics, and on the theoretical basis of the various techniques. However, the texts listed
under Further Reading give more comprehensive accounts and further examples of applications.
x Preface
We should like to thank all who have contributed to the development of this text, especially the many
instrument manufacturers who generously provided examples and illustrations, and in particular Perkin
Elmer Ltd. (UK) and Sherwood Scientific Ltd. (UK). We would like also to thank our colleagues who
allowed us to consult them freely and, not least, the many generations of our students who found
questions and problems where we had thought there were none!
DK
PJH
Section A – The nature and scope of analytical chemistry
Key Notes
Definition Analytical chemistry is a scientific discipline used to study the chemical
composition, structure and behavior of matter.
Purpose The gathering and interpretation of qualitative, quantitative and structural infor-
mation is essential to many aspects of human endeavor, both terrestrial and
extra-terrestrial. The maintenance of, and improvement in, the quality of life
throughout the world, and the management of resources rely heavily on
the information provided by chemical analysis. Manufacturing industries use
analytical data to monitor the quality of raw materials, intermediates and
2 Section A – The nature and scope of analytical chemistry
Scope and Analytical data are required in a wide range of disciplines and situations that
applications include not just chemistry and most other sciences, from biology to zoology, but
the arts, such as painting and sculpture, and archaeology. Space exploration and
clinical diagnosis are two quite disparate areas in which analytical data is vital.
Important areas of application include the following.
● Quality control (QC). In many manufacturing industries, the chemical
composition of raw materials, intermediates and finished products needs to
be monitored to ensure satisfactory quality and consistency. Virtually all
consumer products from automobiles to clothing, pharmaceuticals and food-
stuffs, electrical goods, sports equipment and horticultural products rely, in
part, on chemical analysis. The food, pharmaceutical and water industries in
particular have stringent requirements backed by legislation for major compo-
nents and permitted levels of impurities or contaminants. The electronics
industry needs analyses at ultra-trace levels (parts per billion) in relation to the
manufacture of semi-conductor materials. Automated, computer-controlled
procedures for process-stream analysis are employed in some industries.
● Monitoring and control of pollutants. The presence of toxic heavy metals
(e.g., lead, cadmium and mercury), organic chemicals (e.g., polychlorinated
biphenyls and detergents) and vehicle exhaust gases (oxides of carbon,
nitrogen and sulfur, and hydrocarbons) in the environment are health hazards
that need to be monitored by sensitive and accurate methods of analysis, and
remedial action taken. Major sources of pollution are gaseous, solid and liquid
wastes that are discharged or dumped from industrial sites, and vehicle
exhaust gases.
● Clinical and biological studies. The levels of important nutrients, including
trace metals (e.g., sodium, potassium, calcium and zinc), naturally produced
chemicals, such as cholesterol, sugars and urea, and administered drugs in the
body fluids of patients undergoing hospital treatment require monitoring.
Speed of analysis is often a crucial factor and automated procedures have been
designed for such analyses.
● Geological assays. The commercial value of ores and minerals is determined
by the levels of particular metals, which must be accurately established.
Highly accurate and reliable analytical procedures must be used for this
purpose, and referee laboratories are sometimes employed where disputes
arise.
● Fundamental and applied research. The chemical composition and structure
of materials used in or developed during research programs in numerous
disciplines can be of significance. Where new drugs or materials with potential
commercial value are synthesized, a complete chemical characterization may
be required involving considerable analytical work. Combinatorial chemistry
is an approach used in pharmaceutical research that generates very large
numbers of new compounds requiring confirmation of identity and structure.
Section A – The nature and scope of analytical chemistry
A2 A NALYTICAL PROBLEMS
AND PROCEDURES
Key Notes
Analytical Any chemical analysis can be broken down into a number of stages that
procedures include a consideration of the purpose of the analysis, the quality of the
results required and the individual steps in the overall analytical
procedure.
Analytical The most important aspect of an analysis is to ensure that it will provide useful
problems and reliable data on the qualitative and/or quantitative composition of a material
or structural information about the individual compounds present. The analyt-
ical chemist must often communicate with other scientists and nonscientists to
establish the amount and quality of the information required, the time-scale for
the work to be completed and any budgetary constraints. The most appropriate
analytical technique and method can then be selected from those available or new
ones devised and validated by the analysis of substances of known composition
and/or structure. It is essential for the analytical chemist to have an appreciation
of the objectives of the analysis and an understanding of the capabilities of the
various analytical techniques at his/her disposal without which the most appro-
priate and cost-effective method cannot be selected or developed.
A3 A NALYTICAL TECHNIQUES
AND METHODS
Key Notes
Analytical methods A method is a detailed set of instructions for a particular analysis using a
specified technique.
Analytical There are numerous chemical or physico-chemical processes that can be used to
techniques provide analytical information. The processes are related to a wide range of
atomic and molecular properties and phenomena that enable elements and
compounds to be detected and/or quantitatively measured under controlled
conditions. The underlying processes define the various analytical techniques.
The more important of these are listed in Table 1, together with their suitability for
qualitative, quantitative or structural analysis and the levels of analyte(s) in a
sample that can be measured.
Atomic and molecular spectrometry and chromatography, which together
comprise the largest and most widely used groups of techniques, can be further
subdivided according to their physico-chemical basis. Spectrometric techniques
may involve either the emission or absorption of electromagnetic radiation over
a very wide range of energies, and can provide qualitative, quantitative and
structural information for analytes from major components of a sample down
to ultra-trace levels. The most important atomic and molecular spectrometric
techniques and their principal applications are listed in Table 2.
Chromatographic techniques provide the means of separating the compo-
nents of mixtures and simultaneous qualitative and quantitative analysis, as
required. The linking of chromatographic and spectrometric techniques, called
hyphenation, provides a powerful means of separating and identifying
unknown compounds (Section F). Electrophoresis is another separation tech-
nique with similarities to chromatography that is particularly useful for the
separation of charged species. The principal separation techniques and their
applications are listed in Table 3.
冧
Thin-layer chromatography Qualitative analysis of mixtures
Differential rates of migration of
Gas chromatography Quantitative and qualitative
analytes through a stationary phase
determination of volatile compounds
by movement of a liquid or gaseous
High-performance liquid mobile phase Quantitative and qualitative
chromatography determination of nonvolatile
compounds
Electrophoresis Differential rates of migration of Quantitative and qualitative
analytes through a buffered medium determination of ionic compounds
Method validation Analytical methods must be shown to give reliable data, free from bias and suit-
able for the intended use. Most methods are multi-step procedures, and the
process of validation generally involves a stepwise approach in which optimized
experimental parameters are tested for robustness (ruggedness), that is sensi-
tivity to variations in the conditions, and sources of errors investigated.
A common approach is to start with the final measurement stage, using cali-
bration standards of known high purity for each analyte to establish the perfor-
mance characteristics of the detection system (i.e. specificity, range, quantitative
response (linearity), sensitivity, stability and reproducibility). Robustness in
terms of temperature, humidity and pressure variations would be included at
this stage, and a statistical assessment made of the reproducibility of repeated
identical measurements (replicates). The process is then extended backwards in
sequence through the preceding stages of the method, checking that the optimum
conditions and performance established for the final measurement on analyte
calibration standards remain valid throughout. Where this is not the case, new
conditions must be investigated by modification of the procedure and the process
repeated. A summary of this approach is shown in Figure 1 in the form of a flow
diagram. At each stage, the results are assessed using appropriate statistical tests
(Section B) and compared for consistency with those of the previous stage. Where
unacceptable variations arise, changes to the procedure are implemented and the
assessment process repeated. The performance and robustness of the overall
method are finally tested with field trials in one or more routine analytical
laboratories before the method is considered to be fully validated.
A3 – Analytical techniques and methods 9
Key Notes
Representative A representative sample is one that truly reflects the composition of the
sample material to be analyzed within the context of a defined analytical
problem.
Sample storage Due to varying periods of time that may elapse between sample
collection and analysis, storage conditions must be such as to avoid
undesirable losses, contamination or other changes that could affect the
results of the analysis.
Sample preparation Samples generally need to be brought into a form suitable for
measurements to be made under controlled conditions. This may involve
dissolution, grinding, fabricating into a specific size and shape,
pelletizing or mounting in a sample holder.
2
2 2
1 3 1 3 1 3
4 4
4
Fig. 1. A diagrammatic representation of coning and quartering (quarters 1 and 3, or 2 and 4 are discarded each time).
12 Section A – The nature and scope of analytical chemistry
Sample storage Samples often have to be collected from places remote from the analytical labora-
tory and several days or weeks may elapse before they are received by the labo-
ratory and analyzed. Furthermore, the workload of many laboratories is such that
incoming samples are stored for a period of time prior to analysis. In both
instances, sample containers and storage conditions (e.g., temperature, humidity,
light levels and exposure to the atmosphere) must be controlled such that no
significant changes occur that could affect the validity of the analytical data. The
following effects during storage should be considered:
Sample pre- Samples arriving in an analytical laboratory come in a very wide assortment of
treatment sizes, conditions and physical forms and can contain analytes from major
constituents down to ultra-trace levels. They can have a variable moisture content
and the matrix components of samples submitted for determinations of the same
analyte(s) may also vary widely. A preliminary, or pre-treatment, is often used to
condition them in readiness for the application of a specific method of analysis or
to pre-concentrate (enrich) analytes present at very low levels. Examples of pre-
treatments are:
A5 C ALIBRATION AND
STANDARDS
Key Notes
Calibration With the exception of absolute methods of analysis that involve chemical reac-
tions of known stoichiometry (e.g., gravimetric and titrimetric determinations), a
calibration or standardization procedure is required to establish the relation
between a measured physico-chemical response to an analyte and the amount or
concentration of the analyte producing the response. Techniques and methods
where calibration is necessary are frequently instrumental, and the detector
response is in the form of an electrical signal. An important consideration is the
effect of matrix components on the analyte detector signal, which may be
supressed or enhanced, this being known as the matrix effect. When this is
known to occur, matrix matching of the calibration standards to simulate the
gross composition expected in the samples is essential (i.e. matrix components
are added to all the analyte standards in the same amounts as are expected in the
samples).
There are several methods of calibration, the choice of the most suitable
depending on the characteristics of the analytical technique to be employed, the
nature of the sample and the level of analyte(s) expected. These include:
● External standardization. A series of at least four calibration standards
containing known amounts or concentrations of the analyte and matrix
components, if required, is either prepared from laboratory chemicals of guar-
anteed purity (AnalaR or an equivalent grade) or purchased as a concentrated
standard ready to use. The response of the detection system is recorded for
each standard under specified and stable conditions and additionally for a
blank, sometimes called a reagent blank (a standard prepared in an identical
16 Section A – The nature and scope of analytical chemistry
fashion to the other standards but omitting the analyte). The data is either
plotted as a calibration graph or used to calculate a factor to convert detector
responses measured for the analyte in samples into corresponding masses or
concentrations (Topic B4).
● Standard addition.
● Internal standardization.
The last two methods of calibration are described in Topic B4.
Instruments and apparatus used for analytical work must be correctly main-
tained and calibrated against reference values to ensure that measurements are
accurate and reliable. Performance should be checked regularly and records kept
so that any deterioration can be quickly detected and remedied. Microcomputer
and microprocessor controlled instrumentation often has built-in performance
checks that are automatically initiated each time an instrument is turned on.
Some examples of instrument or apparatus calibration are
● manual calibration of an electronic balance with certified weights;
● calibration of volumetric glassware by weighing volumes of pure water;
● calibration of the wavelength and absorbance scales of spectrophotometers
with certified emission or absorption characteristics;
● calibration of temperature scales and electrical voltage or current readouts
with certified measurement equipment.
Chemical Materials or substances suitable for use as chemical standards are generally
standard single compounds or elements. They must be of known composition, and high
purity and stability. Many are available commercially under the name AnalaR.
Primary standards, which are used principally in titrimetry (Section C) to
standardize a reagent (titrant) (i.e. to establish its exact concentration) must be
internationally recognized and should fulfil the following requirements:
● be easy to obtain and preserve in a high state of purity and of known chemical
composition;
● be non-hygroscopic and stable in air allowing accurate weighing;
● have impurities not normally exceeding 0.02% by weight;
● be readily soluble in water or another suitable solvent;
● react rapidly with an analyte in solution;
● other than pure elements, to have a high relative molar mass to minimize
weighing errors.
Primary standards are used directly in titrimetric methods or to standardize
solutions of secondary or working standards (i.e. materials or substances that do
not fulfill all of the above criteria, that are to be used subsequently as the titrant in
a particular method). Chemical standards are also used as reagents to effect
reactions with analytes before completing the analysis by techniques other than
titrimetry.
Some approved primary standards for titrimetric analysis are given in Table 1.
Reference Reference materials are used to demonstrate the accuracy, reliability and com-
material parability of analytical results. A certified or standard reference material (CRM
or SRM) is a reference material, the values of one or more properties of which
have been certified by a technically valid procedure and accompanied by a trace-
able certificate or other documentation issued by a certifying body such as the
A5 – Calibration and standards 17
A6 Q UALITY IN ANALYTICAL
LABORATORIES
Key Notes
Quality control Quality control (QC) is the process of ensuring that the operational
techniques and activities used in an analytical laboratory provide results
suitable for the intended purpose.
Quality assurance Quality assurance (QA) is the combination of planned and systematic
actions necessary to provide adequate confidence that the process of
quality control satisfies specified requirements.
Accreditation This is a system whereby the quality control and quality assurance
system procedures adopted by a laboratory are evaluated by inspection and
accredited by an independent body.
Quality control Analytical data must be of demonstrably high quality to ensure confidence in the
results. Quality control (QC) comprises a system of planned activities in an
analytical laboratory whereby analytical methods are monitored at every stage to
verify compliance with validated procedures and to take steps to eliminate the
causes of unsatisfactory performance. Results are considered to be of sufficiently
high quality if
● they meet the specific requirements of the requested analytical work within
the context of a defined problem;
● there is confidence in their validity;
● the work is cost effective.
To implement a QC system, a complete understanding of the chemistry and
operations of the analytical method and the likely sources and magnitudes of
errors at each stage is essential. The use of reference materials (Topic A5) during
method validation (Topic A3) ensures that results are traceable to certified
sources. QC processes should include:
● checks on the accuracy and precision of the data using statistical tests (Section
B);
● detailed records of calibration, raw data, results and instrument performance;
● observations on the nature and behavior of the sample and unsatisfactory
aspects of the methodology;
● control charts to determine system control for instrumentation and repeat
analyses (Topic B5);
A6 – Quality in analytical laboratories 19
Quality assurance The overall management of an analytical laboratory should include the provision
of evidence and assurances that appropriate QC procedures for laboratory activ-
ities are being correctly implemented. Quality assurance (QA) is a managerial
responsibility that is designed to ensure that this is the case and to generate
confidence in the analytical results. Part of QA is to build confidence through the
laboratory participating in interlaboratory studies where several laboratories
analyze one or more identical homogeneous materials under specified condi-
tions. Proficiency testing is a particular type of study to assess the performance
of a laboratory or analyst relative to others, whilst method performance studies
and certification studies are undertaken to check a particular analytical method
or reference material respectively. The results of such studies and their statistical
assessment enable the performances of individual participating laboratories to be
demonstrated and any deficiencies in methodology and the training of personnel
to be addressed.
Accreditation Because of differences in the interpretation of the term quality, which can be
system defined as fitness for purpose, QC and QA systems adopted by analyical labora-
tories in different industries and fields of activity can vary widely. For this
reason, defined quality standards have been introduced by a number of organi-
zations throughout the world. Laboratories can design and implement their own
quality systems and apply to be inspected and accredited by the organization for
the standard most appropriate to their activity. A number of organizations that
offer accreditation suitable for analytical laboratories and their corresponding
quality standards are given in Table 1.
B1 E RRORS IN ANALYTICAL
MEASUREMENTS
Key Notes
Measurement errors All measurement processes are subject to measurement errors that affect
numerical data and which arise from a variety of sources.
Absolute and An absolute error is the numerical difference between a measured value
relative errors and a true or accepted value. A relative error is the absolute error divided
by the true or accepted value.
Determinate errors Also known as systematic errors, or bias, these generally arise from
determinate or identifiable sources causing measured values to differ
from a true or accepted value.
Indeterminate errors Also known as random errors, these arise from a variety of uncontrolled
sources and cause small random variations in a measured quantity when
the measurement is repeated a number of times.
Measurement The causes of measurement errors are numerous and their magnitudes are vari-
errors able. This leads to uncertainties in reported results. However, measurement
errors can be minimized and some types eliminated altogether by careful exper-
imental design and control. Their effects can be assessed by the application of
statistical methods of data analysis and chemometrics (Topic B5). Gross errors
may arise from faulty equipment or bad laboratory practice; proper equipment
maintenance and appropriate training and supervision of personnel should
eliminate these.
Nevertheless, whether it is reading a burette or thermometer, weighing a
sample or timing events, or monitoring an electrical signal or liquid flow, there
will always be inherent variations in the measured parameter if readings are
repeated a number of times under the same conditions. In addition, errors may
go undetected if the true or accepted value is not known for comparison
purposes.
Errors must be controlled and assessed so that valid analytical measurements
can be made and reported. The reliability of such data must be demonstrated so
that an end-user can have an acceptable degree of confidence in the results of
an analysis.
22 Section B – Assessment of data
Absolute and The absolute error, EA, in a measurement or result, xM, is given by the equation
relative errors
EA = xM - xT
where xT is the true or accepted value. Examples are shown in Figure 1 where a
200 mg aspirin standard has been analyzed a number of times. The absolute
errors range from -4 mg to +10 mg.
The relative error, ER, in a measurement or result, xM, is given by the equation
ER = (xM - xT)/xT
Often, ER is expressed as a percentage relative error, 100ER. Thus, for the aspirin
results shown in Figure 1, the relative error ranges from -2% to +5%. Relative
errors are particularly useful for comparing results of differing magnitude.
Aspirin (mg)
195 200 205 210
–5 0 5 10
Absolute error (EA; mg)
–2.5 0 2.5 5
Relative error (ER; %)
Fig. 1. Absolute and relative errors in the analysis of an aspirin standard.
Determinate There are three basic sources of determinate or systematic errors that lead to a
errors bias in measured values or results:
● the analyst or operator;
● the equipment (apparatus and instrumentation) and the laboratory environ-
ment;
● the method or procedure.
It should be possible to eliminate errors of this type by careful observation and
record keeping, equipment maintenance and training of laboratory personnel.
Operator errors can arise through carelessness, insufficient training, illness or
disability. Equipment errors include substandard volumetric glassware, faulty
or worn mechanical components, incorrect electrical signals and a poor or
insufficiently controlled laboratory environment. Method or procedural errors
are caused by inadequate method validation, the application of a method to
samples or concentration levels for which it is not suitable or unexpected varia-
tions in sample characteristics that affect measurements. Determinate errors that
lead to a higher value or result than a true or accepted one are said to show a
positive bias; those leading to a lower value or result are said to show a nega-
tive bias. Particularly large errors are described as gross errors; these should be
easily apparent and readily eliminated.
B1 – Errors in analytical measurements 23
21
Copper found (%)
Positive
bias
20
True value
19
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7
Sample size (g)
Fig. 2. Effect of a proportional error on the determination of copper by titration in the
presence of iron.
Indeterminate Known also as random errors, these arise from random fluctuations in
errors measured quantities, which always occur even under closely controlled condi-
tions. It is impossible to eliminate them entirely, but they can be minimized by
careful experimental design and control. Environmental factors such as temper-
ature, pressure and humidity, and electrical properties such as current, voltage
and resistance are all susceptible to small continuous and random variations
described as noise. These contribute to the overall indeterminate error in any
24 Section B – Assessment of data
2.5
0.5
0
0 10 20 30
Size of titer (cm3)
– 0 +
Deviation from mean, µ
Accumulated Errors are associated with every measurement made in an analytical procedure,
errors and these will be aggregated in the final calculated result. The accumulation or
propagation of errors is treated similarly for both determinate (systematic) and
indeterminate (random) errors.
Determinate (systematic) errors can be either positive or negative, hence some
cancellation of errors is likely in computing an overall determinate error, and in
some instances this may be zero. The overall error is calculated using one of two
alternative expressions, that is
● where only a linear combination of individual measurements is required to
compute the result, the overall absolute determinate error, ET, is given by
ET = E1 + E2 + E3 + …….
E1 and E2 etc., being the absolute determinate errors in the individual
measurements taking sign into account
● where a multiplicative expression is required to compute the result, the
overall relative determinate error, ETR, is given by
ETR = E1R + E2R + E3R + …….
E1R and E2R etc., being the relative determinate errors in the individual measure-
ments taking sign into account.
The accumulated effect of indeterminate (random) errors is computed by
combining statistical parameters for each measurement (Topic B2).
Section B – Assessment of data
B2 A SSESSMENT OF ACCURACY
AND PRECISION
Key Notes
Accuracy and Accuracy is the closeness of an experimental measurement or result to
precision the true or accepted value. Precision is the closeness of agreement
between replicated measurements or results obtained under the same
prescribed conditions.
Standard deviation The standard deviation of a set of values is a statistic based on the normal
error (Gaussian) curve and used as a measure of precision.
Pooled standard A standard deviation can be calculated for two or more sets of data by
deviation pooling the values to give a more reliable measure of precision.
Variance This is the square of the standard deviation, which is used in some
statistical tests.
Confidence interval This is the range of values around an experimental result within which
the true or accepted value is expected to lie with a defined level of
probability.
Accuracy and These two characteristics of numerical data are the most important and the most
precision frequently confused. It is vital to understand the difference between them, and
this is best illustrated diagrammatically as in Figure 1. Four analysts have
each performed a set of five titrations for which the correct titer is known to be
20.00 cm3. The titers have been plotted on a linear scale, and inspection reveals
the following:
● the average titers for analysts B and D are very close to 20.00 cm3 - these two
sets are therefore said to have good accuracy;
● the average titers for analysts A and C are well above and below 20.00 cm3
respectively - these are therefore said to have poor accuracy;
● the five titers for analyst A and the five for analyst D are very close to one
another within each set – these two sets therefore both show good precision;
● the five titers for analyst B and the five for analyst C are spread widely
within each set - these two sets therefore both show poor precision.
B2 – Assessment of accuracy and precision 27
Correct
result
D
19.70 20.00 20.30
Titer (cm3)
It should be noted that good precision does not necessarily produce good
accuracy (analyst A) and poor precision does not necessarily produce poor
accuracy (analyst B). However, confidence in the analytical procedure and the
results is greater when good precision can be demonstrated (analyst D).
Accuracy is generally the more important characteristic of quantitative data to
be assessed, although consistency, as measured by precision, is of particular
concern in some circumstances. Trueness is a term associated with accuracy,
which describes the closeness of agreement between the average of a large
number of results and a true or accepted reference value. The degree of accuracy
required depends on the context of the analytical problem; results must be shown
to be fit for the purpose for which they are intended. For example, one result may
be satisfactory if it is within 10% of a true or accepted value whilst it may be
necessary for another to be within 0.5%. By repeating an analysis a number of
times and computing an average value for the result, the level of accuracy will be
improved, provided that no systematic error (bias) has occurred. Accuracy
cannot be established with certainty where a true or accepted value is not known,
as is often the case. However, statistical tests indicating the accuracy of a result
with a given probability are widely used (vide infra).
Precision, which is a measure of the variability or dispersion within a set of
replicated values or results obtained under the same prescribed conditions, can
be assessed in several ways. The spread or range (i.e. the difference between the
highest and lowest value) is sometimes used, but the most popular method is to
estimate the standard deviation of the data (vide infra). The precision of results
obtained within one working session is known as repeatability or within-run
precision. The precision of results obtained over a series of working sessions is
known as reproducibility or between-runs precision. It is sometimes necessary
to separate the contributions made to the overall precision by within-run and
28 Section B – Assessment of data
Standard This is the most widely used measure of precision and is a parameter of the
deviation normal error or Gaussian curve (Topic B1, Fig. 4). Figure 2 shows two curves for
the frequency distribution of two theoretical sets of data, each having an infinite
number of values and known as a statistical population.
Frequency of occurrence
sd = s2
of each deviation
s1 > s2
sd = s1
– m +
Deviation from mean
Fig. 2. Normal error or Gaussian curves for the frequency distributions of two statistical
populations with differing spreads.
The maximum in each curve corresponds to the population mean, which for
these examples has the same value, m. However, the spread of values for the
two sets is quite different, and this is reflected in the half-widths of the two
curves at the points of inflection, which, by definition, is the population stan-
dard deviation, s. As s2 is much less than s1, the precision of the second set is
much better than that of the first. The abscissa scale can be calibrated in
absolute units or, more commonly, as positive and negative deviations from the
mean, m.
In general, the smaller the spread of values or deviations, the smaller the
value of s and hence the better the precision. In practice, the true values of m
and s can never be known because they relate to a population of infinite size.
However, an assumption is made that a small number of experimental values or
a statistical sample drawn from a statistical population _ is also distributed
normally or approximately so. The experimental mean, x, of a set of values x1,
x2, x3,…….xn is therefore considered to be an estimate of the true or population
mean, m, and the experimental standard deviation, s, is an estimate of the true
or population standard deviation, s.
A useful property of the normal error curve is that, regardless of the magni-
tude of m and s, the area under the curve within defined limits on either side of
m (usually expressed in multiples of ±s) is a constant proportion of the total
area. Expressed as a percentage of the total area, this indicates that a particular
percentage of the population will be found between those limits.
Thus, approximately 68% of the area, and therefore of the population, will be
B2 – Assessment of accuracy and precision 29
found within ±1s of the mean, approximately 95% will be found within ±2s and
approximately 99.7% within ±3s. More practically convenient levels, as shown
in Figure 3, are those corresponding to 90%, 95% and 99% of the population,
which are defined by ±1.64s, ±1.96s and ±2.58s respectively. Many statistical
tests are based on these probability levels.
80% 90%
frequency (y/N)
frequency (y/N)
Relative
Relative
–1.29s +1.29s –1.64s +1.64s
95% 99%
frequency (y/N)
frequency (y/N)
Relative
Relative
莦
冪
i=N
冱 (x − m) i
2
i=1
s= (1)
N
where xi represents any individual value in the population and N is the total
number of values, strictly infinite. The summation symbol, S, is used to show
that the numerator of the equation is the sum for i = 1 to i = N of the squares of
the deviations of the individual x values from the population mean, m. For very
large sets of data (e.g., when N >50), it may be justifiable to use this formula as
the difference between s and s will then be negligible. However, most analytical
data consists of sets of values of less than ten and often as small as three.
Therefore, a modified formula is used to calculate an estimated _ standard
deviation, s, to replace s, and using an experimental mean, x, to replace the
population mean, m:
莦
冪
i=N _
冱 (x − x) i
2
i=1
s= (2)
N−1
30 Section B – Assessment of data
Note that if N were used in the denominator, the calculated value of s would be
an underestimate of s.
Estimated standard deviations are easily obtained using a calculator that
incorporates statistical function keys or with one of the many computer soft-
ware packages. It is, however, useful to be able to perform a stepwise arithmetic
calculation, and an example using the set of five replicate titers by analyst A
(Fig. 1) is shown below.
Example 1
xi /cm3 (xi − x) (xi − x)2
20.16 -0.04 1.6 × 10-3
20.22 +0.02 4 × 10-4
20.18 -0.02 4 × 10-4
20.20 0.00 0
20.24 +0.04 1.6 × 10-3
 101.00 4 ¥ 10-3
_
x 20.20
冪莦 4 莦
−3
4 × 10
s = 0.032 cm 3
Relative The relative standard deviation, RSD or sr, is also known as the coefficient of
standard variation, CV. It is a measure of relative precision and is normally expressed as
deviation a percentage of the mean value or result
_
sr (s/x) × 100 (3)
It is an example of a relative error (Topic B1) and is particularly useful for
comparisons between sets of data of differing magnitude or units, and in calcu-
lating accumulated (propagated) errors. The RSD for the data in Example 1 is
given below.
Example 2
0.032
sr × 100 = 0.16%
20.20
B2 – Assessment of accuracy and precision 31
Pooled standard Where replicate samples are analyzed on a number of occasions under the same
deviation prescribed conditions, an improved estimate of the standard deviation can be
obtained by pooling the data from the individual sets. A general formula for the
pooled standard deviation, spooled, is given by the expression
莦莦莦莦
冪
i=N1 _ _i=N2 _ i=N3_ i=Nk
冱 (x − x ) + 冱 (x − x ) + 冱 (x − x ) + ... + 冱 (x − x )
i 1
2
i 2
2
i 3
2
i k
2
_ _
where N1, N2, N3…Nk are the numbers of results in each of the k sets, and x1, x2,
_ _
x3, . . . xk, are the means for each of the k sets.
Variance The square of the standard deviation, s2, or estimated standard deviation, s2, is
used in a number of statistical computations and tests, such as for calculating
accumulated (propagated) errors (Topic B1 and below) or when comparing the
precisions of two sets of data (Topic B3).
Overall precision Random errors accumulated within an analytical procedure contribute to the
overall precision. Where the calculated result is derived by the addition or
subtraction of the individual values, the overall precision can be found by
summing the variances of all the measurements so as to provide an estimate of
the overall standard deviation, i.e.
兹冢s
苶 苶 2苶
soverall = 1 + s2 + s3 + . . .
2 2
冣
Example
In a titrimetric procedure, the buret must be read twice, and the error associated
with each reading must be taken into account in estimating the overall preci-
sion. If the reading error has an estimated standard deviation of 0.02 cm3, then
the overall estimated standard deviation of the titration is given by
soverall =
兹苶
冢0.02 苶
+ 0.02苶冣 0.028 cm
2 2 3
Note that this is less than twice the estimated standard deviation of a single
reading. The overall standard deviation of weighing by difference is estimated
in the same way.
If the calculated result is derived from a multiplicative expression, the overall
relative precision is found by summing the squares of the relative standard devia-
tions of all the measurements, i.e.
sr(overall) =
兹苶
冢s + s苶
+s 苶
+ . . .冣
2 2 2
r1 r2 r3
confidence interval, CI, and the upper and lower limits of the range as confi-
dence limits, CL. Confidence limits can be calculated using the standard devia-
tion, s, if it is known, or the estimated standard deviation, s, for the data. In
either case, a probability level must be defined, otherwise the test is of no
value.
When the standard deviation is already known from past history, the confi-
dence limits are given by the equation
_ zs
CL(m) = x ± (5)
兹N
苶
where z is a statistical factor related to the probability level required, usually
90%, 95% or 99%. The values of z for these levels are 1.64, 1.96 and 2.58, respec-
tively, and correspond to the multiples of the standard deviation shown in
Figure 3.
Where an estimated standard deviation is to be used, s is replaced by s,
which must first be calculated from the current data. The confidence limits are
then given by the equation
_ ts
CL(m) = x ± (6)
兹N苶
where z is replaced by an alternative statistical factor, t, also related to the prob-
ability level but in addition determined by the number of degrees of freedom
for the set of data, i.e. one less than the number of results. It should be noted
that (i) the confidence interval is inversely proportional to 兹N 苶, and (ii) the
higher the selected probability level, the greater the confidence interval becomes
as both z and t increase. A probability level of 100 percent is meaningless, as the
confidence limits would then have to be ±•.
The following examples demonstrate the calculation of confidence limits
using each of the two formulae.
Example 3
The chloride content of water samples has been determined a very large number
of times using a particular method, and the standard deviation found to be
7 ppm. Further analysis of a particular sample gave experimental values of
350 ppm for a single determination, for the mean of two replicates and for the
mean of four replicates. Using equation (5), and at the 95% probability level,
z = 1.96 and the confidence limits are:
1.96 × 7
1 determinations CL(m) = 350 ± = 350 ± 14 ppm
兹1苶
1.96 × 7
2 determinations CL(m) = 350 ± = 350 ± 10 ppm
兹2苶
1.96 × 7
4 determinations CL(m) = 350 ± = 350 ± 7 ppm7
兹4苶
Example 4
The same chloride analysis as in Example 3, but using a new method for which
the standard deviation was not known, gave the following replicate results,
mean and estimated standard deviation:
B2 – Assessment of accuracy and precision 33
B3 S IGNIFICANCE TESTING
Key Notes
Significance tests These are statistical tests used to compare individual values or sets of
values for significant differences.
F-test The F-test enables the precisions of two sets of data to be compared using
their variances.
Analysis of variance F-tests can be applied to several sets of data to assess and compare
different sources of variability.
Separate tabular values for some significance test factors have been compiled
for what are described as one-tailed and two-tailed tests. The exact purpose of
the comparison that is to be made determines which table to use.
● The one-tailed test is used EITHER to establish whether one experimental
value is significantly greater than the other OR the other way around.
● The two-tailed test is used to establish whether there is a significant differ-
ence between the two values being compared, whether one is higher or
lower than the other not being specified.
The two-tailed test is by far the most widely used. Examples are given below.
Outliers Inspection of a set of replicate measurements or results may reveal that one or
more is considerably higher or lower than the remainder and appears to be outside
the range expected from the inherent effects of indeterminate (random) errors
alone. Such values are termed outliers, or suspect values, because it is possible
that they may have a bias due to a determinate error. On occasions, the source of
error may already be known or it is discovered on investigation, and the outlier(s)
can be rejected without recourse to a statistical test. Frequently, however, this is
not the case, and a test of significance such as the Q-test should be applied to a
suspect value to determine whether it should be rejected and therefore not included
in any further computations and statistical assessments of the data.
Q-test Also known as Dixon’s Q-test, this is one of several that have been devised to
test suspected outliers in a set of replicates. It involves the calculation of a ratio,
Qexptl, defined as the absolute difference between a suspect value and the value
closest to it divided by the spread of all the values in the set:
Qexptl = suspect value − nearest value /(largest value − smallest value)
Qexptl is then compared with a tabulated value, Qtab, at a selected level of proba-
bility, usually 90% or 95%, for a set of n values (Table 1). If Qexptl is less than Qtab,
then the null hypothesis that there is no significant difference between the
suspect value and the other values in the set is accepted, and the suspect value
is retained for further data processing. However, if Qexptl is greater than Qtab, then
the suspect value is regarded as an outlier and is rejected. A rejected value
should NOT be used in the remaining calculations.
Table 1. Critical values of Q at the 95% (P = 0.05) level for a two-tailed test
Sample size Critical value
4 0.831
5 0.717
6 0.621
7 0.570
8 0.524
Example 1
Four replicate values were obtained for the determination of a pesticide in river
water
0.403, 0.410, 0.401, 0.380 mg dm-3
36 Section B – Assessment of data
Example 2
If, in Example 1, three additional values of 0.400, 0.413 and 0.411 mg dm-3 were
included, 0.380 mg dm-3 is still a possible outlier.
Qexptl = 0.380 - 0.400 /(0.413 - 0.380) = 0.020/0.033 = 0.61
Qtab = 0.57 for seven values at the 95% probability level
Now, as Qexptl is greater than Qtab, 0.380 mg dm-3 is an outlier at the 95% level and
should be rejected. Note that because the three additional values are all around
0.4 mg dm-3, the suspect value of 0.380 mg dm-3 appears even more anomalous.
F-test This test is used to compare the precisions of two sets of data which may origi-
nate from two analysts in the same laboratory, two different methods of analysis
for the same analyte or results from two different laboratories. A statistic, F, is
defined as the ratio of the population variances, s12/s22, or the sample variances,
s12/s22, of the two sets of data where the larger variance is always placed in the
numerator so that F ≥1.
If the null hypothesis is true, the variances are equal and the value of F will be
one or very close to it. As for the Q-test, an experimental value, Fexptl, is calcu-
lated and compared with a tabulated value, Ftab, at a defined probability level,
usually 90% or 95%, and for the number of degrees of freedom, N - 1, for each
set of data. If Fexptl is less than Ftab, then the null hypothesis that there is no
significant difference between the two variances and hence between the preci-
sion of the two sets of data, is accepted. However, if Fexptl is greater than Ftab,
there is a significant difference between the two variances and hence between
the precisions of the two sets of data.
Some values of Ftab at the 95% probability level are given in Table 2. The
columns in the table correspond to the numbers of degrees of freedom for the
numerator set of data, while the rows correspond to the number of degrees of
freedom for the denominator set. Two versions of the table are available,
depending on the exact purpose of the comparison to be made: a one-tailed F-
test will show whether the precision of one set of data is significantly better than
the other, while a two-tailed F-test will show whether the two precisions are
significantly different.
Table 2. Critical values of F at the 95% (P = 0.05) level for a two-tailed test
n1 5 7 9
n2
5 7.146 6.853 6.681
7 5.285 4.995 4.823
9 4.484 4.197 4.026
Example 3
A proposed new method for the determination of sulfate in an industrial waste
effluent is compared with an existing method, giving the following results:
Fexptl
⁄
s2existing
s2
new
(3.38)2
2 5.08
(1.50)
The two-tailed tabular value for F with 7 degrees of freedom for both the
numerator and the denominator is
F7,7 = 5.00 at the 95% probability level
As Fexptl is greater than Ftab, the null hypothesis is rejected; the two methods are
giving significantly different precisions.
t-test This test is used to compare the experimental means of two sets of data or to
compare the experimental mean of one set of data with a known or reference
value. A statistic, t, is defined, depending on the circumstances, by one of three
alternative equations.
_ _
Comparison of two experimental means, xA and xB
_ _
冢 冣
1
(xA − xB) NM ⁄2
t= × (1)
spooled N+M
where spooled is the pooled estimated standard deviation (Topic B2) for sets A and
B, and N and M are the numbers of values in sets A and B respectively. If N = M,
1
then the second term reduces to (N/2) ⁄ . A simplified version of equation (4),
2
Topic B2, can be used to calculate spooled as there are only two sets of data.
冦冤 冥冤 冥冧
1
⁄2
spooled = (N − 1)s2A + (M − 1)s2B / N + M − 2 (2)
In some circumstances, the use of equation (1) may not be appropriate for the
comparison of two experimental means. Examples of when this may be the case
are if
● the amount of sample is so restricted as to allow only one determination by
each of the two methods;
● the methods are to be compared for a series of samples containing different
levels of analyte rather than replicating the analysis at one level only;
● samples are to be analyzed over a long period of time when the same experi-
mental conditions cannot be guaranteed.
It may therefore be essential or convenient to pair the results (one from each
method) and use a paired t-test where t is defined by
38 Section B – Assessment of data
_
x
t = d × N ⁄
1
2
(3)
sd
_
xd being the mean difference between paired values and sd the estimated
standard deviation of the differences.
Table 3. Critical values of t at the 95% and 99% (P = 0.05 and 0.01) levels for a
two-tailed test
Number of degrees of freedom 95 percent level 99 percent level
2 4.30 9.92
5 2.57 4.03
10 2.23 3.10
18 2.10 2.88
Example 1
Two methods for the determination of polyaromatic hydrocarbons in soils were
compared by analyzing a standard with the following results:
No. of determinations by each method: 10
No. of degrees of freedom: 18
_
UV spectrophotometry: x_ = 28.00 mg kg-1 s = 0.30 mg kg-1
Fluorimetry: x = 26.25 mg kg-1 s = 0.23 mg kg-1
Do the mean results for the two methods differ significantly?
Equation (2) is first used to calculate a pooled standard deviation:
spooled N+M
For 18 degrees of freedom, the two-tailed value of ttab at the 95% probability
level is 2.10, and at the 99% level it is 2.88.
B3 – Significance testing 39
As texptl is greater than ttab at both the 95 and 99% probability levels, there is a
significant difference between the means of the two methods.
Example 2
A new high performance liquid chromatographic method for the determination
of pseudoephedrine in a pharmaceutical product at two different levels was
compared with an established method with the following results:
Pseudoephedrine per dose (mg)
Method 1 Method 2
59.9 58.6
59.3 58.3
60.4 60.5
30.7 29.4
30.2 30.4
30.1 28.9
sd
For 5 degrees of freedom, the two-tailed value of ttab at the 95% probability level
is 2.57. As texptl is greater than ttab, there is a significant difference between the
means of the two methods. (Note: using equation (1) would give a texptl value of
0.08 and an incorrect conclusion.)
Example 3
A method for the determination of mercury by atomic absorption spectrometry
gave values of 400, 385 and 382 ppm for a standard known to contain 400 ppm.
Does the mean value differ significantly from the true value, or is there any
evidence of systematic error (bias)?
_
x = 389 ppm s = 9.64 ppm m = 400 ppm
Using equation (4) to evaluate texptl
_
(x − m) (389 − 400)
texptl = × N ⁄ = × 3 ⁄ = 1.98
1 1
2 2
s 9.64
For 2 degrees of freedom, the two-tailed ttab value is 4.30 at the 95% probability
level. As texptl is less than the two-tailed value of ttab, the mean is not significantly
different from the true value. There is, therefore, no evidence of a systematic
error, or bias.
Analysis of Analysis of variance, also known as ANOVA, is a statistical technique for inves-
variance tigating different sources of variability associated with a series of results. It
enables the effect of each source to be assessed separately and compared with
the other(s) using F-tests. Indeterminate or random errors affect all measure-
ments, but additional sources of variability may also arise. The additional
sources can be divided into two types:
40 Section B – Assessment of data
Key Notes
Calibration Calibration is the process of establishing a relation between a detection or
measurement system and known amounts or concentrations of an analyte
under specified conditions.
Correlation The coefficient is used to assess the degree of linearity between two
coefficient variables, e.g. an instrument response and an analyte mass or
concentration.
Linear regression Calculations to define the best straight line through a series of calibration
points represented graphically are described as linear regression.
Limit of detection The smallest mass or concentration of an analyte that can be measured
quantitatively at a defined level of probability defines a limit of detection.
Internal This is a calibration procedure where the ratio of the instrument response
standardization for an analyte to that of an added standard is measured for a series of
analyte standards and samples.
25
Detector response
20
Sample response
15
10
5 Interpolated sample
mass/concentration
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Analyte mass/concentration
Fig. 1. A typical calibration graph.
Correlation The correlation coefficient, r, indicates the degree of linearity between x and y
coefficient and is given by the expression
B4 – Calibration and linear regression 43
i=N _ _
冱 {(x − x)(y − y)}
i i
i=1
r = (2)
冦冤 冥冤 冥冧
i=N _ i=N _ ⁄ 1
i=1 i=1
_ _
where x1y1; x2y2; x3y3;….xn,yn are the co-ordinates of the plotted points, x and y
are the means of the x and y values respectively, and  indicates sums of terms
(see standard deviation equations (1), (2) and (4), Topic B2).
The range of possible values for r is -1 £ r £ +1. A value of unity indicates a
perfect linear correlation between x and y, all the points lying exactly on a
straight line, whilst a value of zero indicates no linear correlation. Values may
be positive or negative depending on the slope of the calibration graph. These
alternatives are illustrated in Figure 2 (a) to (c).
Most calibration graphs have a positive slope, and correlation coefficients
frequently exceed 0.99. They are normally quoted to four decimal places. (Note
that graphs with a slight curvature may still have correlation coefficients
exceeding about 0.98 (Fig. 2(d)), hence great care must be taken before
concluding that the data shows a linear relation. Visual inspection of the plotted
points is the only way of avoiding mistakes.)
Linear When inspection of the calibration data and the value of the correlation coeffi-
regression cient show that there is a linear relation between the detector response and the
(a) (b)
10 10
Detector response
Detector response
8 8
6 r = +1 6 r = –1
4 4
2 2
0 0
0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10
Analyte mass/concentration Analyte mass/concentration
(c) (d)
10 10
Detector response
Detector response
8 8
r = 0.9850
6 r=0 6
4 4
2 2
0 0
0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10
Analyte mass/concentration Analyte mass/concentration
Fig. 2. Examples of correlation coefficients. (a) Perfect positive correlation; (b) perfect negative correlation; (c) no
correlation, and (d) curved correlation.
44 Section B – Assessment of data
i=1
1.2
1
Absorbance at 325 nm
0.4
0.2
Intercept = 0.0686
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Concentration (mg cm–3)
Fig. 3. Calibration graph, regression line, slope and intercept values for the UV spectrophoto-
metric determination
_ _ of an active ingredient in a sun cream. ——— = regression line; 䡩 =
centroid, x, y; ----------- = confidence limits lines at the 99 percent level; 䊴——䊳 = confidence
limits for sample concentration of 30 mg cm-3. Inset: Illustration of y-residuals.
B4 – Calibration and linear regression 45
Example
A calibration graph was prepared as part of a validation procedure for a new
method to determine an active constituent of a sun cream by UV spectrophoto-
metry. The following data were obtained:
The data is first checked for linearity by calculation of the correlation coefficient,
r, and visual inspection of a plotted curve. Some calculators and computer soft-
ware can perform the computation from the raw data, but it is instructive to
show the full working, for which tabulation is preferable.
_ _ _ _ _ _
xi yi (xi − x ) (xi − x )2 (yi − y) (yi − y )2 (xi − x )(yi − y)
0 0.095 −60 3600 −0.5004 0.2504 30.024
20 0.227 −40 1600 −0.3684 0.1357 14.736
40 0.409 −20 400 −0.1864 0.0347 3.728
60 0.573 0 0 −0.0224 0.0005 0
80 0.786 20 400 0.1906 0.0363 3.812
100 0.955 40 1600 0.3596 0.1293 14.384
120 1.123 60 3600 0.5276 0.2784 31.656
the detector response and the mass or concentration of the analyte more
complex curvilinear or logarithmic regression calculations are required.
Limit of For any analytical procedure, it is important to establish the smallest amount of
detection an analyte that can be detected and/or measured quantitatively. In statistical
terms, and for instrumental data, this is defined as the smallest amount of an
analyte giving a detector response significantly different from a blank or back-
ground response (i.e. the response from standards containing the same reagents
and having the same overall composition (matrix) as the samples, where this is
known, but containing no analyte). Detection limits are usually based on esti-
mates of the standard deviation of replicate measurements of prepared blanks.
A detection limit of two or_ three times the estimated standard deviation of the
blanks above their mean, xB, is often quoted, where as many blanks as possible
(at least 5 to 10) have been prepared and measured.
This is somewhat arbitrary, and it is perfectly acceptable to define alternatives
provided that the basis is clear and comparisons are made at the same proba-
bility level.
Standard Where components of a sample other than the analyte(s) (the matrix) interfere
addition with the instrument response for the analyte, the use of a calibration curve
based on standards of pure analyte may lead to erroneous results. Such matrix
interference effects can be largely if not entirely avoided by preparing calibra-
tion standards where known amounts of pure analyte are added to a series of
equal sized portions of the sample, a procedure known as spiking. In addition,
one portion of sample is not spiked with analyte. (Note: if spiking sample solu-
tions with analyte changes the volume significantly, volume corrections must be
applied.)
The effects of the matrix on measurements of the analyte in both the spiked
and unspiked samples should be identical. The instrument responses are then
used to construct a calibration graph where the x-axis values are the added
amounts of analyte and the response for the unspiked sample is at x = 0 (i.e., the
curve does NOT pass through the origin). The regression line is calculated and
extrapolated back to give a negative intercept on the x-axis at y = 0, which corre-
sponds to the amount of analyte in the sample (Fig. 4).
The less reliable procedure of extrapolation rather than interpolation is
outweighed by the advantage of eliminating or minimizing matrix interference.
The method of standard addition is widely used, particularly when the
composition of the sample matrix is variable or unknown so that the response of
a reagent/matrix blank would be unreliable. At least three and preferably more
spiked samples should be prepared, but if the amount of sample is limited, as
few as one sample must suffice. It is especially useful with such analytical tech-
niques as flame and plasma emission spectrometry and potentiometry (Topics
E4, E5 and C8).
Example
The calcium level in a clinical sample was determined by flame emission
spectrometry using a standard addition method, which gave the following data:
Spiked calcium (ppm) 0 10 20 30 40 50
Emission intensity 0.257 0.314 0.364 0.413 0.468 0.528
at 423 nm
B4 – Calibration and linear regression 47
0.7
0.4
Spiked samples
0.3
Unspiked
sample
0.2
Sample concentration
48 ppm
0.1
Intercept = 0.2569
0
–60 –50 –40 –30 –20 –10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Calcium (ppm)
Fig. 4. Standard addition calibration graph, regression line, slope and intercept values for the
flame emission determination of calcium in a clinical sample.
Detailed calculations of the correlation coefficient, r, and the slope and intercept
values have not been given, but should be set out as in the previous example if a
suitable calculator or computer program is not available.
The amount of calcium in the sample can be read from the extrapolated graph
or calculated from the slope, b, and the intercept, a
Calcium concentration in sample = a/b = 0.2569/0.005349 = 48 ppm
Internal For some purposes, only the relative amounts of the analytes in a multicomponent
normalization mixture are required. These are normalized to 100 or 1 by expressing each as a
48 Section B – Assessment of data
Example
Figure 5 is a chromatographic record (chromatogram) of the separation of a 5-
component mixture. The measured peak areas (using electronic integration with
a computing-integrator, computer and chromatography data processing software
or geometric construction such as triangulation, 1⁄2 ¥ base ¥ height) and percent-
ages by internal normalization, which must total 100 percent, are given in Table 1
(e.g., for component 1, relative percent = (167.8/466.94) ¥ 100 = 35.9 percent).
1
Inject
4
5
2
0 3 6 9 12 15 18
Time (min)
Key Notes
Control charts Graphical representations of quantitative data from an ongoing series of
measurements can be used to monitor the stability of a system for quality
control (QC) purposes.
Collaborative testing Schemes have been devised to compare results for the analysis of
homogeneous samples or standard materials from groups of analytical
laboratories to test specified methods of analysis.
Control charts The purpose of a control chart is to monitor data from an ongoing series of
quantitative measurements so that the occurrence of determinate (systematic)
errors (bias), or any changes in the indeterminate (random) errors affecting the
precision of replicates can be detected and remedial action taken. The predomi-
nant use of control charts is for quality control (QC) in manufacturing industries
where a product or intermediate is sampled and analyzed continually in a
process stream or periodically from batches. They may also be used in analytical
laboratories, such as those involved in clinical or environmental work, to
monitor the condition of reagents, standards and instrument components,
which may deteriorate over time.
Shewart charts consist of a y-axis calibrated either in the mass, concentration
or range of replicated results of an analyte or in multiples of the estimated stan-
dard deviation, s, of the analytical method employed, and the sample number
along the x-axis. An averages or X-chart, the most common type, is pre-
prepared with a series of five parallel horizontal lines, the centre one being posi-
tioned along the y-axis to correspond to the true, accepted or target value for the
analyte (Fig. 1). The other four lines are positioned in pairs on either side of the
target value line and act as critical levels that, when exceeded, indicate probable
instability in the system. The inner pair are defined as warning levels and the
outer pair as action levels.
An averages chart is used to monitor the level of an analyte either as single
values or as means of N replicates to check for determinate errors (bias) in the
results. Chart criteria and decisions are based on the following:
● plotted values have a Gaussian or normal distribution (Topic B2);
● warning lines are positioned to correspond to a selected probability level
50 Section B – Assessment of data
3s/N1/2
2s/N1/2
Mass or concentration
of analyte, x x
2s/N1/2
3s/N1/2
0 5 10 15 20
Sample number
冨
xi − m
z=
s 冨
where m is the true or accepted mass or concentration of the analyte and s is a
value for the standard deviation for the method selected by the organizers of the
study (strictly an estimated value, s). A typical chart of z-scores for a collabora-
tive study involving 22 laboratories is shown in Figure 2.
Results that have z-scores of between +1.96 and -1.96 are considered to have
acceptable accuracy, as these values correspond to confidence limits at the 95%
probability level (Topic B2, Fig. 3). In the example, only laboratories 12 and 18
1
z-score
–1
–2
–3
19 13 21 22 20 10 5 15 16 1 11 8 6 14 2 17 7 4 9 3 12 18
Laboratory number
50
Coefficient of variation (%)
40
30
20
10
0
10% 1% 0.1% 0.01% 10 ppm 1 ppm 0.1 ppm 0.01 ppm 1 ppb
Analyte concentration (log scale)
Note that values of less than 1% should be attainable for major components of
a sample, whilst at ppb (parts per billion) levels, over 50% is acceptable.
Pattern recognition
Sets of measurements characterizing a sample, e.g. the position of prominent
infrared absorption bands (Topic H4), significant mass spectral fragments,
levels of particular analytes, and selected physical properties, are described as
patterns. These can be used to classify substances or to identify unknowns by
pattern matching. Figure 4 shows the distribution of trace levels of copper and
manganese in twelve geological samples where three clusters are evident. Just
B5 – Quality control and chemometrics 53
50
40
Manganese (ppm) 30
20
10
0
0 5 10 15
Copper (ppm)
Fig. 4. Copper and manganese distribution in geological samples showing three clusters with
differing proportions of each metal.
Multivariate modeling
Quantitative analysis for one or more analytes through the simultaneous
measurement of experimental parameters such as molecular UV or infrared
absorbance at multiple wavelengths can be achieved even where clearly defined
spectral bands are not discernible. Standards of known composition are used to
compute and refine quantitative calibration data assuming linear or nonlinear
models. Principal component regression (PCR) and partial least squares (PLS)
regression are two multivariate regression techniques developed from linear
regression (Topic B4) to optimize the data.
54 Section B – Assessment of data
C1 S OLUTION EQUILIBRIA
Key Notes
Solvents The major component of a solution is referred to as the solvent, and there
is a wide range of inorganic and organic solvents used in analytical
chemistry. Their properties determine their use.
Ions in solution Some substances form ions, which are species possessing a charge. These
behave in a distinct way in solution. They may attract molecules of
solvent, may associate together, and may react with other species to form
complexes or a precipitate.
The pX notation Since concentrations vary over a very wide range, they are often
represented by the logarithmic pX notation where pX = - log(X), where X
is the concentration or activity of an ion, or an equilibrium constant.
Solvents The use of solvents for analytical work is determined by their properties, as
shown in Table 1.
Solvents with high dielectric constants (er > 10), for example, water and
ammonia, are referred to as polar and are ionizing solvents, promoting the
formation and separation of ions in their solutions, whereas those where er is
about 2, such as diethyl ether, tetrachloromethane and hexane are nonpolar and
are nonionizing solvents. There are also many solvents whose behavior is inter-
mediate between these extremes.
The solution process in a liquid may be represented by a general equation:
A(l) + B = B(sol)
solvent solute solution
The action of solution changes the properties of both solute and solvent. The
solute is made more mobile in solution, and its species may solvate by attraction
56 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
to the solvent. The solvent structure is also disrupted by the presence of species
different in size, shape and polarity from the solvent molecules.
Ideally, the behavior should depend on the concentration m (in molarity,
mole fraction or other units), but often this must be modified and the activity, a,
used:
a = m g = p/pn
where g is called the activity coefficient. The vapor pressure of the solution is p,
and that in the standard state is pn. Activities are dimensionless.
Solvents, such as water, with high dielectric constants (or relative permittivi-
ties) reduce the force F between ions of charges z1e and z2e a distance r apart:
F = z1z2 e2/eoer r2
where eo is the permittivity of free space. Also, they will solvate ions more
strongly and thus assist ion formation and separation.
Hexane, diethyl ether and tetrachloromethane (CCl4) all have low dielectric
constants and are nonpolar. They are very poor at ionizing solutes. However,
they are very good solvents for nonpolar substances.
Solubility The equilibrium amount of solute which will dissolve in a given amount of
solvent at a given temperature and pressure is called the solubility. The solu-
bility may be quoted in any units of concentration, for example, mol m-3,
molarity, mole fraction, mass per unit volume or parts per million (ppm).
There is a general ‘rule of thumb’ that ‘like dissolves like’. For example, a
nonpolar hydrocarbon solvent such as hexane would be a very good solvent for
solid hydrocarbons such as dodecane or naphthalene. An ester would be a good
solvent for esters, and water or other polar solvents are appropriate for polar
and ionic compounds.
● Gases dissolve in solvents according to Henry’s Law, provided they do not
react with the solvent:
p B = xB K
where xB is the mole fraction of solute gas B which dissolves at a partial pres-
sure pB of B, and K is a constant at a given temperature. This is analytically
important for several reasons. For example, nitrogen is bubbled through
solutions to decrease the partial pressure of oxygen in electrochemical experi-
ments. Similarly, air is removed from liquid chromatography solvents by
C1 – Solution equilibria 57
a = p/pn = x
H : OCOCH3 [ H+ + -OCOCH3
where I is the ionic strength = 1⁄2 S (ci zi2) for all the ions in the solution.
For more concentrated ionic solutions, above 0.1 M, no general theory exists,
58 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
but additional terms are often added to the Debye-Hückel equation to compen-
sate for the change in the activity.
The pX notation The concentration of species in solution may range from very small to large. For
example in a saturated aqueous solution of silver chloride, the concentration of
silver ions is about 10-5 M, while for concentrated hydrochloric acid the
concentration of hydrogen and chloride ions is about 10 M. For convenience,
a logarithmic scale is often used:
pX = -log (X)
where X is the concentration of the species, or a related quantity. Thus, for the
examples above, pAg = 5 in saturated aqueous silver chloride and pH = -1 in
concentrated HCl.
Since equilibrium constants are derived from activities or concentrations as
noted below, this notation is also used for them:
pK = -log (K)
Equilibria in Most reactions will eventually reach equilibrium. That is, the concentrations of
solution reactants and products change no further, since the rates of the forward and
reverse reactions are the same.
From the above arguments concerning solutions, and from the laws of
thermodynamics, any equilibrium in solution involving species D, F, U and V:
D+F[U+V
will have an equilibrium constant , KT, at a particular temperature T given by:
KT = (aU . aV)/(aD . aF)
where the activities are the values at equilibrium. It should be noted that KT
changes with temperature. The larger the equilibrium constant, the greater will
be the ratio of products to reactants at equilibrium.
There are many types of equilibria that occur in solution, but for the impor-
tant analytical conditions of ionic equilibria in aqueous solution, four examples
are very important.
(i) Acid and base dissociation. In aqueous solution, strong electrolytes (e.g.,
NaCl, HNO3, NaOH) exist in their ionic forms all the time. However, weak
electrolytes exhibit dissociation equilibria. For ethanoic acid, for example:
HOOCCH3 + H2O [ H3O+ + CH3COO-
Ka = (aH . aA)/(aHA . aW) = 1.75 ¥ 10-5
where HA, W, H and A represent each of the species in the above
equilibrium. In dilute solutions the activity of the water aW is close to 1.
For ammonia:
NH3 + H2O [ NH4+ + OH-
Kb = (aNH4+ . aOH-)/(aNH3 . aW) = 1.76 ¥ 10-5
Water behaves in a similar way:
2 H2O [ H3O+ + OH-
KW = (aH3O+ . aOH-) = 10-14
C1 – Solution equilibria 59
Summary
For ionic equilibria in solution, which are widely used in analytical chemistry,
a large equilibrium constant for the reaction indicates that it will proceed
practically to completion. If the equilibrium constant is of the order of 1010,
then the ratio of products to reactants will be much greater than 1000 to 1. For
example:
60 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
C2 E LECTROCHEMICAL
REACTIONS
Key Notes
Electrochemical Reactions involving charged species in solution are important in many
reactions analyses. Their chemistry and the laws governing them must be known.
Electrochemical cells The construction of an electrochemical cell using two electrodes allows
the study of the cell reaction, changes in concentration, and electrolysis.
Electrode potentials The potential difference between electrodes depends on the properties of
the electrodes and the concentrations in the solution.
Electrolysis If the cell reaction is driven by applying an external voltage supply, then
useful chemical reactions may occur.
Electrochemical Important electrochemical reactions have already been noted in Topic C1, for
reactions example:
● acid-base reactions, where the acid donates a proton to the base;
● precipitation reactions, where the reactants form an insoluble product;
● complexation reactions, where a ligand coordinates to an acceptor;
● oxidation-reduction reactions, where the oxidizing agent gains electrons
from the reducing species.
All of these reactions involve charged species and all may be studied by electro-
chemical methods and used for analysis.
platinum. Consider a cell set up with a zinc electrode dipping into a zinc sulfate
solution, and connected through a porous disc to a copper sulfate solution in
contact with a copper electrode, as shown in Figure 1.
The cell is conventionally written as:
ZnÔZn2+ SO42-ÔCu2+ SO42-ÔCu
The cell reaction will result in simultaneous reduction or addition of electrons to
a species in solution at the one electrode and oxidation, or removal of electrons
at the other.
Cu2+ + 2e- = Cu reduction (note: ‘reduction on the right’)
- 2+
Zn - 2e = Zn oxidation (note: ‘oxidation on the left’)
Adding these gives the cell reaction (excluding the sulfate anions).
Cu2+ + Zn = Cu + Zn2+
If the cell reaction is allowed to take place, by connecting the copper and zinc
electrodes electrically, then it acts as a galvanic cell or battery, and does work. If
the potential difference is measured with no current flow, it is defined as the
electromotive force, or emf, E, and this is equivalent to reversible conditions. If
an external voltage is applied to the cell it can cause electrolysis, driving the cell
reaction.
In order to prevent the zinc sulfate and the copper sulfate mixing, a porous
disc, or a conducting salt bridge of potassium sulfate in a tube, or a wick can be
used to connect the solutions. This helps to reduce the liquid junction
potential, which occurs when two solutions of unequal concentration, or
containing dissimilar ions are placed in contact. Because of the different rates of
diffusion of the ions, a liquid junction (or diffusion) potential, EL , is set up and
this affects the total cell emf. For example, between a solution of 0.1 M HCl and
a solution of 0.01 M HCl, EL is about 38 mV.
By using a third solution, which must not react, and in which the cation
and anion have similar mobilities and diffusion characteristics, to connect the
two electrode solutions the liquid junction potential may be minimized.
Concentrated potassium chloride, about 4 M, is often used, since K+ and Cl- ions
have almost the same mobility (see Topic C10). Potassium nitrate or ammonium
nitrate is also suitable if chloride ions react. Use of a salt bridge reduces the
effective EL to about 1 mV.
The laws of thermodynamics, which are described in detail in textbooks of
physical chemistry, provide the connection between the chemical reaction and
the electrochemical quantities that are measured in analysis.
Meter
The free energy G depends on the activity (or approximately the concentra-
tion) of the reactants and products. For a general reaction:
Ox1 + Red2 = Red1 + Ox2
n
DG = DG + RT ln [(a(Ox2).a(Red1))/(a(Ox1).a(Red2))]
where the superscript, n, means that it applies to the standard state. For gases,
this is 1 atmosphere pressure; for liquids and solids it is less than 1 atmosphere
pressure for the pure material; and for solutions, it is an activity of 1.
The electromotive force measures the free energy change under reversible
conditions when n Faradays of electrical charge occur in the cell reaction and is
related to it by the equation:
DG = -nFE
For example, in the Daniell cell reaction, 2 moles of electrons are transferred,
and the cell emf is about 1.1 V. Therefore:
DG = -2 ¥ 96485 ¥ 1.1 = -212.3 kJ mol-1
Combining the above equations, for the Daniell cell:
E = En + (RT/2F) ln [(a(Zn2+).a(Cu))/(a(Zn).a(Cu2+))]
This is often referred to as the Nernst equation for the cell. (Note: the value of
En measures the cell emf and relates to the free energy change under standard
state conditions, while the value of E relates to the free energy change under
other, specified conditions. It is important to recognize that these equations
apply at any temperature, not just a standard temperature.)
Electrode In order to establish any scale it is necessary to have a reference point. Since
potentials measurement of emf is made using a cell, one electrode must be taken as a
reference electrode. The standard hydrogen electrode (SHE) has been chosen as
the primary reference.
A hydrogen electrode may be constructed using a platinum metal plate as
contact, and bubbling hydrogen gas through so that it makes contact with both
solution and platinum. When the gas is at 1 atmosphere pressure and the solu-
tion has an activity of hydrogen ions of 1, this is a standard hydrogen electrode
(SHE).
By convention, the standard hydrogen electrode is assigned an electrode
potential of 0.000 V and all other electrode potentials are compared to it.
A cell can be constructed with a copper electrode in copper sulfate and a
standard hydrogen electrode, as shown in Figure 2.
Sintered disk
Solution with Copper sulfate solution
H+ (a=1)
the copper electrolysis cell has two electrodes placed in an acidified aqueous
solution of a copper salt.
Example
If a current of 0.123 amps is passed through a copper electrolysis cell for one
hour, how much copper will deposit?
0.123 A = 0.123 C s-1
Since 1 hour = 3600 s, therefore, It = 442.8 C are passed.
1 mole of copper is 63.5 g, which requires 2F = 2 ¥ 96485 C, so 442.8 C deposit
63.5 ¥ 442.8/(2 ¥ 96485) g = 0.1457 g.
It is possible to deposit metals onto an electrode quantitatively, using the
technique of electrogravimetry, although this is not often used. Electrolysis may
also be used to generate reagents to react with analytes, and this is referred to as
coulometry.
Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
C3 P OTENTIOMETRY
Key Notes
Indicator electrodes The indicator electrode makes electrical contact with the solution and acts
as a sensor, which responds to the activity of particular ions in solution
and acquires a potential dependent on the concentration of those ions.
Selectivity The ideal electrode should respond to a single ion, but this is not often
the case. The effectiveness of any indicator electrode is determined by its
selectivity.
Cells When a cell is set up, but not connected to any outside circuit, no reaction
should take place. If the cell is now ‘shorted out’ by connecting the electrodes on
right and left, electrons will flow and the cell reaction will occur. This reaction
changes the concentrations of the original solutions. Therefore, to measure the
original sample concentrations within the cell, a device must be used that does
not allow current, and hence electrons, to flow. While older systems used a
potentiometer, where the potential difference was balanced by adjusting an elec-
trical circuit so that an external source gave exactly the same potential difference
detected by the null-point of a galvonometer, modern potentiometry uses
digital voltmeters (DVM), where the current used to take the measurement is
extremely small. A suitable experimental arrangement is shown in Figure 1.
If a check is needed on the correctness of the measured value for an experi-
mental cell, a standard cell, such as the Weston cadmium cell, may be used as a
calibration, since the value of its emf is accurately known over a range of
temperatures. The electrode potential is defined using the standard hydrogen
electrode as reference, as described in Topic C2.
Indicator There are many types of indicator electrode used in analyses to construct electro-
electrodes chemical cells. They may be classified as shown in Table 1.
When two electrodes are combined in a cell, the measured emf may be sepa-
rated into ‘half-cell emfs’ that relate to the individual electrodes. For a Daniell
cell discussed in Topic C2:
C3 – Potentiometry 67
Digital voltmeter
Electrode A Electrode B
Class 1 electrodes
These are the simplest electrodes, but not necessarily the easiest to use. A metal
rod is immersed in a solution of ions of the same metal, for example silver with
a solution containing silver ions. With some ions it is important to prevent
hydrolysis or complexation taking place.
Ag+ (solution) + e- = Ag(solid)
E(Ag+/Ag) = En(Ag+, Ag) + RT/F ln (a (Ag+)/(a (Ag))
if a pure silver rod is used, a(Ag) = 1, so we may write:
E(Ag+/Ag) = En(Ag+, Ag) + RT/F ln (a (Ag+))
This is therefore an electrode reversible to silver ions. An example of the use
of this electrode is given later. En(Ag+, Ag) = 0.800 V at 25∞C is the standard
electrode potential of the silver electrode.
Class 2 electrodes
When an insoluble salt of a metal (see also Topic C8) is present, the concentra-
tion of the metal ion depends on the concentration of the anion and on the
68 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
Fill hole
AgCl/Ag
Hg/Hg2Cl2 electrode
paste
KCI solution
Buffer solution
Fig. 2. (a) Calomel reference electrode; (b) glass electrode; (c) solid-state electrode.
70 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
If the sample solution might react with chloride ions, for example silver or
lead salts, then a double junction reference electrode may be used, with an
additional liquid junction of KNO3.
Redox electrodes
If an inert wire, usually platinum, is placed into a solution containing both
oxidized and reduced species, it will take up an equilibrium potential depen-
dent on the ratio of their concentrations:
Ox + ne- = Red
E(Ox, Red) = En(Ox, Red) + (RT/nF) ln (a(Ox)/a (Red))
Leads to meter
(a) (b)
Ag electrode
Reference
Liquid organic electrode
ion exchanger
Internal
solution
Fig. 3. (a) Liquid ion exchange membrane electrode for M2+ ions. (b) Gas sensing electrode
using glass ISE.
72 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
Gas-sensing electrodes
If gases such as CO2 or NH3 are allowed to diffuse into the solution surrounding
a pH electrode, they will alter the pH. The construction is shown in Figure 3(b).
The pH electrode, often incorporating a reference electrode as well, is separated
from the sample solution by a microporous hydrophobic membrane, which
will allow gases but not water to diffuse through rapidly. For CO2 the overall
equilibrium occurs in 3 stages:
(i) carbon dioxide gas diffuses from the outer solution through the membrane
until inner and outer solutions are at the same concentration;
(ii) the solution of CO2 forms the acid H2CO3, which dissociates to form
hydrogen ions:
CO2 + 2H2O = H2CO3 + H2O = H3O+ + HCO3-
K = a(H3O+). a(HCO3-)/(p(CO2 (sample)))
(iii) if the internal solution within the membrane has a constant activity of
HCO3-, for example sodium hydrogen carbonate, then the pH may be
calculated:
pH = -log (H3O+) = log (K. p (CO2 (sample)))
so that by measuring the pH we can find the concentration of CO2.
Similar arguments apply with an ammonia-sensing electrode.
Selectivity The ideal electrode should respond only to changes in concentration of a single
ion i. This is rarely true and the response of a real electrode system can be
described by the Nikolsky-Eisenmann equation:
Ei = Eni + S log[a(1) + SKpot1,2 (a(2))(z1/z2)]
where S is the slope of the emf -log(a) plot, which for Nernstian behavior
should be 0.0592/z(1) at 25∞C, a(1) is the activity of the ion selected of charge
z(1), a(2) is the activity of the interfering ion of charge z(2) and Kpot1,2 is the selec-
tivity coefficient for ion 1 with respect to ion 2. The smaller the value of this
selectivity coefficient, the smaller the interference by the second ion.
150
100
50
–50
–100
–7 –6 –5 –4 –3 –2 –1 0
log (a)
Fig. 4. Electrode potential response for a copper ISE. (a) Against activity (solid line); (b)
against concentration (dashed line).
This graph shows that over the concentration range 10-1 to 10-5 M the calibra-
tion is linear with a slope of 0.029 V/log (a(Cu2+)). Below about 10-6 M the line
curves, since the solubility of the crystal becomes significant. Interferences from
Cu(I), Ag(I) and Hg(II) are troublesome.
If a calibration curve is constructed, direct measurement of solution concen-
trations within that range may be made.
Example
Calibration performed with a ISE selective to Mg2+ ions gave a value of S =
0.0296, and E = 0.411 V for a solution of a(Mg2+) = 1.77 ¥ 10-3 M.
What is the activity of Mg2+ ions when E = 0.439 V?
Substitution gives a(Mg2+) = 1.998 ¥ 10-4 M.
The method of standard additions (Topic B4) has the advantage that comparison
is made in the same matrix solution, so that interferences and other effects are
the same for the unknown and for the standard.
Potentiometric titrations are discussed in Topic C5.
Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
Key Notes
Definition of pH Since the concentrations of ions in aqueous solution vary over an
enormous range from greater than 1 molar down to 10-14 molar or less, it
is convenient to use a logarithmic function to describe them. For
hydrogen ions in aqueous solution, denoted by H3O+, often called the
hydronium ion, this is defined as:
pH = -log(a(H3O+)) ⬇ -log(c( H3O+)/mol dm-3)
The pH scale Pure water contains equal amounts hydrogen ions and hydroxyl ions
OH-, at a concentration of 10-7 molar. Therefore, the pH of neutral water
is -log (10-7) = 7. Acids have pH values less than 7, down to less than 1,
while for alkalis, the pH is greater than 7, up to 13 or more.
Definition of pH The acidity or alkalinity of a reaction mixture is most important. It can control
the rate of reaction, the nature of the species present and even subjective proper-
ties such as taste. The original definition of pH (Sorensen, 1909) related it to the
concentration of hydrogen ions. Two facts should be recognized. First, like
many ions in solution, the hydrogen ion does not exist in aqueous solutions as a
‘bare’ H+ species, but as a variety of hydrated ions, such as H3O+. Second, the
determination of pH is often carried out by methods that measure the activity of
the hydrogen ions, a(H3O+)
a(H3O+) = c(H3O+)g± or pH = -log[a(H3O+)]
where c(H3O+) is the molar concentration of hydrogen ions, and g± is the mean
ionic activity coefficient of the ions in solution (see Topic C1).
At low concentrations (<10-2 molar), g± is close to 1, and the difference
between concentration and activity is small for uni-univalent electrolytes.
C4 – pH and its control 75
The pH scale In all aqueous solutions, pH values may range between about 0 and 14 or more
as shown in Figure 1. Molar solutions of strong mineral acids, such as HCl,
HNO3 or H2SO4 have pH values less than 1. Weak acids, such as ethanoic or
citric acid in decimolar solution have a pH of around 3.
A useful standard is 0.05 M potassium hydrogen phthalate which, at 15∞C has
a pH of 4.00. Although pure water is neutral and has a pH of 7.00, freshly
distilled water rapidly absorbs carbon dioxide from the air to form a very dilute
solution of carbonic acid, and therefore has a pH of around 6.
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Buffers As many reactions depend greatly upon the concentration of hydrogen ions in
the solutions being used, it is important to control the pH. This is usually
achieved by using a solution which has a pH that is accurately known and that
resists any change in pH as solvent for the experiment. Such solutions are called
buffers.
The equilibria that govern the reactions of weak acids or bases in aqueous
solution will resist attempts to change them. This is known as Le Chatelier’s
principle. For example, the dissociation of ethanoic acid obeys the equation:
76 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
Example 1
For a mixture of 50 cm3 of 0.1 M HAc with 40 cm3 of 0.1M NaAc, giving a total
volume of 90 cm3,
c(H3O+) = 1.75 ¥ 10-5 ¥ [(50 ¥ 0.1/90)/(40 ¥ 0.1/90)]
= 2.19 ¥ 10-5 M, so that
pH = 4.66
Addition of acid to this buffer shifts the above equilibrium to the left and most
of the added hydrogen ion combines with the anion. Adding 10 cm3 of 0.1 M
HCl lowers the pH only to about 4.45. If this amount of acid were added to
90 cm3 of water, the pH would be 2.0. Similarly, when alkali is added, the
hydroxyl ions react with the acid to produce more salt. 10 cm3 of 0.1 M NaOH
will raise the pH only to around 4.85. If this amount of alkali were added to
90 cm3 of water, the pH would rise to 12.
Weak bases and their salts behave in much the same way. For example,
ammonia and ammonium chloride:
NH3 + H2O [ NH4+ + OH-
Kb = c(OH-) ¥ c(NH4+)/c(NH3) = 1.75 ¥ 10-5
or, rewriting the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation:
pOH = pKb + log[c (salt)/c(base)]
or, since pH + pOH = 14.0
pH = 14.0 - pKb - log[c(salt)/c(base)]
For a mixture of equal amounts of 0.1 M ammonia and 0.1 M ammonium
chloride
pH = 14.0 - 4.75 = 9.25
A most useful range of buffers is obtained by using salts of a dibasic (or
tribasic) acid such as phosphoric acid, H3PO4 - for example, potassium
dihydrogen phosphate, KH2PO4, and disodium hydrogen phosphate, Na2HPO4.
The equilibrium involved here is:
H2PO4- [ H3O+ + HPO42-
For this equilibrium, the second dissociation constant of phosphoric acid, Ka2, is
close to 1 ¥ 10-7, or pKa2 = 7. Figure 2 shows the effect of adding acid or alkali on
C4 – pH and its control 77
pH measurement Two important methods exist for pH measurement: visual, using indicators,
and potentiometric, by means of electrochemical cells.
Indicators for pH measurement are weak acids (or bases) where the color of
the acid form is different from that of the salt.
10
8
pH
4
–4 –3 –2 –4 0 1 2 3 4
Millimoles of acid (+) or alkali (–)
Fig. 2. The effect of adding acid (+) or alkali (-) to a phosphate buffer mixture, originally at
pH 7.
–SO
3 NH N N(CH3)2+ = –SO
3 N N N(CH3)2 + H+
Example 2
With the indicator bromocresol green, where KIn = 1.6 ¥ 10-5, or pKIn = 4.8 and
color 1 (acid) is yellow, while color 2 (salt) is blue, a solution of pH 4.0 will give:
log [c(In-)/c(HIn)] = log [c(color 2)/c(color 1)] = pH - pKIn = -0.8
Therefore, c(color 2)/c(color 1) = 0.16, which means about 14% blue, 86% yellow,
or visually a very yellowish green. When the pH is equal to the pKIn, there are
equal amounts of each form making a green color.
A wide range of indicators is available for titrations and other purposes and
these are discussed further in Topics C5 and C7.
This provides a useful and rapid method of estimating pH by eye; for
example, using litmus paper which is red below about pH 6 and blue above
pH 8. Both wide range and narrow range indicator papers are available to
enable a rapid estimation of pH. However, to determine the pH accurately using
indicators, careful spectrometric comparison would be needed and this is a
time-consuming method that is rarely used.
The pH meter uses a reference electrode and a glass electrode with a high-
resistance voltmeter and affords a rapid and accurate method of measuring pH
(Fig. 4). The calomel reference electrode is decribed fully in Topic C3.
The glass electrode is an example of a membrane ion-selective electrode and
is described in Topic C3. It responds to hydrogen ions:
E(glass) = E* + (RT/F) ln [a(H3O+)X]
Therefore the complete cell
Pt | Hg | Hg2Cl2 (s) | KCl (sat, aq) || Solution X | glass membrane | AgCl | Ag
has an e.m.f. at 25∞C equal to:
E (cell) = (E* - 0.241) + ( RT/F) ln [a(H3O+)X]
C4 – pH and its control 79
pH meter
Unknown solution
By using one of the standards described above, for example, 0.05 M potassium
hydrogen phthalate, which has a pH at 25oC of 4.008, we may eliminate E* and
measure the activity of hydrogen ions, and hence the pH, in the unknown
solution X.
pH(X) = pH(S) + (ES - EX)/(RT ln(10)/F)
Key Notes
Titrimetry Titrimetry is an analytical technique for the determination of the
stoichiometry of a reaction by the addition of controlled amounts of a
standard reagent.
Equivalence points The theoretical amount of solution that must be added until the reaction
and end points is just complete is the equivalence point and the end point in a titration is
the point at which change is detected accurately. In an ideal case, these
points should be the same.
Indicators In order to detect the end point, a visual indicator may be added.
Instrumental methods may also be used.
Applications The major applications for acid-base reactions are the determination of
the concentrations or amounts of acids or bases.
14
12
10
8
pH
0
0 10 20 30 40 50
Volume of acid/cm3
Fig. 1. Titration of 25 cm3 of 0.1 M NaOH with 0.1 M HCl (pH against volume added).
82 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
Example 1
A 25.00 cm3 aliquot of a solution of a base of known concentration 0.1057 M is
titrated with an acid of unknown concentration. The reaction involved 1 mole of
base and 1 mole of acid. The end point was determined as 24.88 cm3 of acid
added. What is the concentration of the acid?
25.00 cm3 of the base solution contained 25.00 ¥ 0.1057 = 2.6425 mmol base.
From the known reaction, this should be equivalent to 2.6425 mmol of acid.
Since the volume of acid at the end point was 24.88 cm3, the concentration must
be (2.6425/24.88) = 0.1062 M.
In some cases, the end point detected does not correspond exactly with the
equivalence point. This may be due to problems with the reaction, or to the
small amount of reagent needed to react with additional materials (for example,
the added indicator) present in the titrand. In these cases, a blank titration must
be performed, or allowance made for the titration error.
Equivalence The end point of a titration is based upon experimental observation, whereas
points and end the equivalence point is the theoretical value dependent upon the reaction equa-
points tion. In an ideal case, these should be the same, but a check may be needed to
ensure that factors such as blank errors do not affect the results.
In any titration, the end point corresponds to rapid changes in the concentra-
tion of species. This may be detected in many ways. Instrumental methods are
discussed later, and visual indicators are discussed below.
For reactions such as a strong acid neutralizing a strong base (Fig. 1), the
change at the end point is large, and the rate of change with volume is very
great, as shown by the derivative plot in Figure 2(b). In other cases, such as the
reaction of weak acids with weak bases, the titration curve shows a much less
pronounced change, and the derivative plot may be needed to confirm the end
point, as in Figure 2(b). The second derivative plot is also useful, but relies
greatly on very accurate measurements. Plots of the concentration of a species
(for example H+, or OH-), against the volume added, give straight lines inter-
secting at the end point.
If a mixture of acids, or a polybasic acid such as maleic acid, is titrated, then
two end points are obtained. Similarly, for mixtures of two titrands, two end
points will be detected, provided the species have sufficiently different equilib-
rium constants for the reaction (e.g. Ka1 Ka2).
C5 – Titrimetry I: acid–base titrations 83
(a) (b)
12 0.35
0.3
10
0.25
8
0.2
dpH/dV
pH
6
0.15
4
0.1
2 0.05
0 0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Volume of acid (cm3) Volume of acid (cm3)
Fig. 2. (a) Titration of 25.00 cm3 of 0.105 M ammonia with an ethanoic acid solution. (b) Derivative plot of d (pH)/dV
showing the end point as 26.80 cm3.
Indicators In general, indicators have two forms, which possess different colors. Indicators
for acid-base titrations are themselves weak acids or bases where the two forms
differ in color as shown in Figure 3 of Topic C4 for methyl orange.
HIn (color 1) = H+ + In- (color 2)
The choice of indicator depends upon the reaction to be studied. As noted in
Topic C2, the equilibrium constant of the indicator must match the pH range, or
electrode potential range of the species being titrated. Table 1 shows a selection
of indicators for acid-base reactions.
As a general rule it is noted that the color change takes place over the range:
pH = pKIn ± 1
Similarly for other reactions, the concentration at which the indicator changes
must match the concentrations at the end point.
For example, in the titration of the weak dibasic maleic acid with sodium
hydroxide, the first end point, corresponding to sodium hydrogen maleate
occurs at pH = 3.5, while the second end point for disodium maleate is at
pH = 9. Since pKIn = 3.7 for methyl orange, this will change at the first end point,
while phenolphthalein would change color around pH = 9.
Potentiometric The use of electrodes, particularly the glass electrode for pH measurements and
titrations the wide range of other ion selective electrodes (ISE) described in Topic C3,
enables titrations to be studied throughout the addition of titrant, so that small
changes may be detected. It also allows automation of the titration.
To compare potentiometric titrations with those where the end point is
detected visually, it is useful to think of the ion selective electrode as an indi-
cator electrode responding to the ion to be detected, and to remember that it
must be combined with a reference electrode, the potential of which must not
be affected by the titration reactions.
In general, the titration will produce a graph such as Figure 2(a) where pH,
pIon or E(cell) is plotted against the volume of titrant added. The sharp change
at the end point is readily observed. Derivative plots such as Figure 2(b) are an
aid to finding the end point.
Three types of potentiometric titration may be recognized. Detailed discus-
sion of the reactions is given in Topics C6 and C7, but the principles will be
discussed here.
● R, or reagent sensed. A reagent is added, for example, some copper(II)
EDTA complex, which is sensed by a copper ISE. Addition of EDTA to a
solution containing Ca2+ (or Mg2+, Ni2+ etc.) ions gives an abrupt change at the
end point where the excess EDTA reduces the concentration of Cu2+ ions.
● S, or sample sensed. The ISE senses the ion in the solution being titrated. pH
titrations using a glass electrode belong to this type, as do titrations of
fluoride with La3+.
● T, or titrant sensed. The titrant added to the sample is sensed by an ISE
responsive to that ion; for example a silver ion ISE for the titration of halide
ions by silver nitrate.
Potentiometric titrations for complex, precipitation and redox systems are
discussed in Topic C7.
Applications There are many applications for acid-base titrations, several of which are
routinely used analytical methods described in the appropriate topics.
● The determination of the concentration of acid in foods and pharmaceuticals.
● The measurement of acid number (or base number) during the course of a
reaction. For example, in the production of polyester resins by the reaction of
a glycol with maleic and phthalic acids, the total acid remaining is deter-
mined by titration of a weighed sample with potassium hydroxide using
phenolphthalein as indicator.
● The Kjeldahl method for nitrogen determination is a good example of a back
titration. The sample (for example, a food product) is oxidized by concen-
trated sulfuric acid to remove carbonaceous matter. Excess sodium
hydroxide solution is then added, and the ammonia released is carefully
distilled off into a known volume of standard acid, such as 0.1 M boric acid.
The excess acid is then titrated with standard alkali.
Automated titrations are important in producing rapid, reproducible results
in commercial and research laboratories. Samples may be prepared and loaded
using mechanical pipets or direct weighing and dissolution methods. Titrant is
added to the sample titrand solution using peristaltic pumps, or burets driven
by pressure or piston systems. The addition is very reproducible after accurate
calibration. The progress of the titration is most often followed by potentio-
metric measurements, as outlined above (see also Topic H2).
Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
C6 C OMPLEXATION , SOLUBILITY
AND REDOX EQUILIBRIA
Key Notes
Complexation A complex is formed by reactions between two or more species that are
capable of independent existence. Often this is between a metal ion, M
and a coordinating molecule L.
Redox equilibria Where one species is reduced while the other is simultaneously oxidized,
the reactions are termed redox reactions and are useful in many
analytical methods.
M + nL = MLn
bn = c (MLn)/(c (M) . c (L) n)
The overall formation constant is the product of the stepwise formation
constants:
bn = Kf1 . Kf2. … Kfn or log bn = log Kf1 + log Kf2 +…+ log Kfn
When a ligand is used that can bond to several sites, it is referred to as a multi-
dentate ligand. One of the most important examples is ethylenediamine
tetracetic acid (EDTA):
(HOOCCH2)2-N-CH2-CH2-N- (CH2COOH)2
This tetrabasic acid, abbreviated to H4Y, has four acetate group and two nitro-
gens, which may complex to the central metal ion, as shown in Figure 1. It is
important to remember that for a satisfactory titration, the equilibrium constant
K of the reaction must be greater than 1000.
Since the concentrations of the various species containing Y (H4Y, H3Y-, H2Y2-
, HY3-, Y4-) will vary with the pH, a formation constant K MY may be written:
Mn+ + Y4- = MY(n-4)+
KMY = c(MY(n-4)+)/(c(Mn+).c(Y4-))
and c(Y4-) = cL ¥ a4
where a4 depends on the pH and the acid dissociation constants (K1, K2, K3, K4)
of EDTA, as shown in Table 1, and cL is the total concentration of all the ligand
species.
2–
O
C
OO H2CH2
C C
O
N
M CH2
O
N CH2
O C C
H2 O
CH2
C
O
Example
The formation constant KMY for magnesium-EDTA is 5 ¥ 108. Should pH 5, or
pH 10 be used to titrate Mg?
At pH 5, for Mg:
K’MY = 5 ¥ 108 ¥ 3.5 ¥ 10-7 = 1.75 ¥ 102
At pH 10, for Mg:
K’MY = 5 ¥ 108 ¥ 3.5 ¥ 10-1 = 1.75 ¥ 108
Therefore, magnesium could be titrated only at pH 10, as the value of the equi-
librium constant is too small below this.
The fact that EDTA forms a number of ring systems adds considerably to the
stability of the complex. This is called the chelate effect.
Solubility The formation of insoluble compounds by reaction between two soluble species
is discussed in detail in Topic C8, where the amount of an insoluble product is
measured gravimetrically (Table 2).
The solubility equilibrium is described by the solubility product, Ksp:
Mn+(solvated) + An-(solvated) = MA(solid) + solvent
(a)
CH3C CCH3
NOH NOH
(b)
OH
Fig. 2. Reagents for the precipitation of metal ions. (a) Dimethylglyoxime. (b) Oxine.
Redox equilibria In order to establish a scale of oxidative power, it is necessary to have a stan-
dard, and since these reactions involve electrons, measurement of the reduction
electrode potential is a convenient way to do this. The details are given more
fully in Topic C3.
Some standard reduction electrode potentials, where the reagents are at unit
activity, at 25∞C are given in Table 3. These potentials allow the prediction of
which ions will oxidize other ions, under standard conditions, that is when the
concentrations are molar. A more poisitve electrode potential will oxidize a
more negative potential.
It was shown in Topic C2 that the electrochemical cell e.m.f. is related to the
free energy change, and hence to the equilibrium constant:
En = (RT/nF) ln K
Therefore, the larger the cell e.m.f, the larger the equilibrium constant, and the
more complete the reaction.
Example
For the reaction of cerium(IV) ions with iron(II) ions, what is the likely reaction,
and what is the equilibrium constant? Which reagent is the oxidizing agent, and
which the reducing agent?
Cell: Pt | Fe2+ , Fe3+ || Ce4+, Ce3+ | Pt
En (cell) = En (rhs) – En (lhs) = 1.44 - 0.77 = 0.67 V
C7 T ITRIMETRY II:
COMPLEXATION ,
PRECIPITATION AND REDOX
TITRATIONS
Key Notes
Complexation The techniques of titrimetry, using both visual and potentiometric end
titrations point detection, are used to measure species, particularly metal ions, in a
wide range of samples.
Precipitation Reactions producing an insoluble product are valuable analytical tools for
titrations the titrimetric determination of halide and other anions.
Redox titrations Oxidation and reduction titrations may be used to measure many species,
especially metals in high or low valency states, iodine and iodides, and
easily oxidized organic compounds.
Complexation During complexation reactions the concentration of the analyte ion (for
titrations example, a metal ion) changes most rapidly at the end point. As noted in Topic
C6, the most widely used complexing agent is ethylenediaminetetracetic acid or
EDTA, and Table 1 gives a selection of metal EDTA formation constants.
Using the values of a4 given in Topic C6, Table 1, we may calculate the
practical, or conditional, formation constant at a particular pH
K’MY = KMY a4
From the data in the tables, it can be calculated that magnesium could be
titrated at pH 10, but not at low pH. This has already been discussed in Topic
C6.
Example
The calcium and magnesium ions in hard water may be determined. The solution
is adjusted to pH 12 with NaOH, when Mg(OH)2 is precipitated. The calcium is
then titrated with EDTA using calcon carboxylic acid as indicator. Both calcium
and magnesium are then determined in by titrating a sample with EDTA at pH 10
using eriochrome black T, and finding the magnesium by difference.
Precipitation For precipitation reactions, the change in the concentration of either ion
titrations forming the precipitate may be considered. Since the changes often involve
many orders of magnitude of concentration, it is again convenient to use the pX
notation. For example, for the reaction of silver ions with chloride to form an
insoluble silver chloride precipitate
Ag+ + Cl- = AgCl (s)
the concentration may be expressed as:
pAg = -log (a (Ag+)) ~ -log (c (Ag+))
Figure 1 shows the pAg values in the titration of sodium chloride by silver
nitrate as a function of the volume of silver nitrate added. This figure shows
that, before the end point pAg is very high (that is, the concentration of silver
ions is small) and changes little, because there is still an excess of chloride and
the silver is almost completely removed as precipitate. After the end point, there
is an excess of silver ions, the concentration increases and pAg decreases. In the
region around the end point, where the amounts are nearly equal, the change in
pAg with volume added is very large. If a mixture of iodide and chloride ions is
titrated (dashed line), the iodide, which is less soluble, precipitates first and pAg
is even higher than for chloride. Then the chloride precipitates. Both end points
can be found.
As noted in Table 1 of Topic A5, silver nitrate, sodium chloride and potassium
chloride are primary standards for silver halide precipitation reactions. Other
14
12
10
8
pAg
4
(b)
(a)
2
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Volume AgNO3 added
Fig. 1. Silver-halide titrations. (a) Chloride alone (solid line); (b) iodide plus chloride (dashed
line).
C7 – Titrimetry II: complexation, precipitation and redox titrations 93
precipitation titrations (e.g., barium with sulfate, zinc with ferrocyanide) are less
commonly performed.
Indicators for silver-halide precipitation titrations are of two types. The first
react specifically when an excess of titrant becomes present immediately after
the end point - for example, if a small amount of potassium chromate is added,
it will react with excess silver ions to produce deep red silver chromate in
neutral solutions (Mohr’s method). In acid solutions, the silver is titrated with
potassium thiocyanate (KCNS) solution (Volhard’s method). Iron (III) ammo-
nium sulfate solution is added and reacts with an excesss of thiocyanate to
produce a deep red iron thiocyanate species.
Adsorption indicators such as fluorescein adsorb onto the precipitate when
excess silver ions are present and the precipitate takes on a pinkish color.
As with other indicators, the change of color is detectable by eye over a range:
log (c(ion)) = ± 1
A selection of indicators for precipitation titrations is given in Table 3.
Example
An insecticide containing chlorine was digested in nitric acid to convert the
chlorine to soluble chloride. Silver nitrate was added in excess, and the excess
titrated with potassium thiocyanate by Volhard’s method. It is important to
know whether all the chlorine is converted to chloride.
Redox titrations Oxidation-reduction or redox titrations are used for determining metals with
two well-defined oxidation states, and indirect methods for the determination of
organic compounds.
For redox reactions the concentrations both of the oxidized species, Ox, and
of the reduced species, Red, will change simultaneously. Considering a cell with
a redox electrode and a reference electrode:
SCE || a (Ox), a (Red) | Pt
the cell emf is given by:
E = En + (RT/F) ln (a (Ox)/a (Red)) - ESCE
94 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
Therefore, as the reaction proceeds during titration, the ratio of the concentra-
tions will change and the emf will alter. The potentiometric titration curve will
resemble those described in Topic C5. A summary list of redox reagents is given
in Table 3 of Topic C6.
For standard solutions, sodium oxalate and iron(II) ammonium sulfate and
potassium iodate are suitable, but potassium permanganate and iodine solu-
tions decompose on standing and must be standardized before use.
The indicators for redox reactions are reagents whose oxidized and reduced
forms differ in color:
In(Ox) (color 3) + ne- = In(Red) (color 4)
An example of this is 1,10-phenanthroline iron (II)
[Fe (C12H8 N2)3]3+ + e- = [Fe (C12H8 N2)3]2+
oxidized form, pale blue = reduced form, deep red
In several cases, the indicator reaction additionally involves hydrogen ions,
so the change is pH dependent. Table 4 lists commonly used redox indicators.
For a redox indicator where one electron is involved, at 25∞C, the color
change takes place at electrode potentials in the range
E = EIn ± 0.059
One further useful indicator employed in redox titrations involving iodine is
starch, or more synthetic equivalent materials. The starch forms a blue-black
complex with iodine, which is rendered colorless when all the iodine has been
removed.
The applications of redox titrations include the determination of metals, with
two well-defined oxidation states, which are present in metallurgical samples
and ores. In order to dissolve the material, it may be necessary to use oxidative
conditions, for example, concentrated nitric acid. This will convert the majority
of the ions into their higher oxidation state, and in order to titrate them they
must first be reduced quantitatively. This may be done by passing the acidified
solution through a Jones reductor, which contains a zinc-mercury amalgam.
The effluent may then be titrated using a suitable oxidant. Some organic
compounds, such as phenols, may be determined by bromination with a
bromate/bromide mixture, followed by back titration of the excess using
thiosulfate.
Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
C8 G RAVIMETRY
Key notes
Purification The precipitate must be as pure as possible. Substances that are similar
and might precipitate under the same conditions must be removed, and
the analysis must be carried out so that no impurities are co-precipitated.
Drying and heating If precipitation is carried out from solution, the solid precipitate will have
solvent associated with it. This must be removed. Heating near the
boiling point of the solvent will do this, and further heating may be
needed to obtain a more stable compound whose formula is known.
Weighing The procedures of weighing the container initially and with the final
sample are most important.
Gravimetry Gravimetry is one of the ‘classical’ techniques of analysis, and although less
frequently used now, it is of value when an accurate reference method is
required for comparison with an instrumental technique.
If an element is present in a mixture, for example, silver in a sample of nickel,
one way of separating it is to dissolve the metal completely in a suitable solvent.
In this example, the metal mixture could be dissolved in concentrated nitric acid
and a reagent added that would react with the silver to produce a precipitate,
which for silver might be a sodium chloride solution:
Ag(s) + Ni(s) + HNO3(sol) = AgNO3(sol) + Ni(NO3)2(sol)
AgNO3(sol) + NaCl(sol) = AgCl(s) + NaNO3(sol)
The silver chloride is precipitated completely, and may be filtered off since both
nickel nitrate and nickel chloride are very soluble in water. The precipitate will
be wet and may contain traces of nickel in solution, so must be thoroughly
washed and dried, as discussed below.
Since weighing may be carried out readily and accurately in almost all labora-
tories, gravimetry is often used as a reference method. Analysis of major compo-
nents of metal samples such as steel, and of minerals and soils may be carried
out by gravimetric methods, but they often involve lengthy separations and are
96 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
Precipitation As noted in Topic C1, many elements will form compounds insoluble in water
or other solvents. Provided the compound is stable, or may be converted into a
stable compound easily, these insoluble precipitates may be used for analysis.
The technique for obtaining a precipitate may be summarized as follows:
(i) The sample should be dissolved as completely as possible in a suitable
solvent. Any residue that does not dissolve (for example, silica present in
the metal sample of the above example), may be filtered off at this stage.
(ii) Unless there are undesirable changes when the sample is heated, the solu-
tions should be warmed. This speeds up reactions and helps to form a more
granular precipitate.
(iii) The precipitating reagent must be chosen to give as insoluble a precipitate
as possible. Preferably, a reagent that will produce the largest mass of
precipitate should be used. For example, aluminum may be precipitated
and heated to give the oxide, Al2O3 when 10.0 mg of aluminum will
produce 18.9 mg precipitate. If ‘aluminon’ (8-hydroxyquinoline, C9H6ON) is
used, 170.0 mg of precipitate results.
(iv) The precipitating reagent should be added slowly, with stirring to the
warm solution. To check whether precipitation is complete, the precipitate
is allowed to settle, and more reagent added. If further precipitate does not
form, the reaction is complete. If the solution appears cloudy, it is possible
that a colloidal form of the solid is present. This may be coagulated by
further warming or adding more reagent.
(v) The reaction mixture is filtered. Various means may be used for this. The
simplest is a quantitative filter paper (ashless), which has been dried and
weighed previously. These may be dried, or burnt (‘ashed’).
Another useful filter is a sintered glass or porcelain crucible, dried and
weighed as before. Glass will withstand heating to about 300∞C and porcelain to
over 800∞C.
Purification The precipitate should be washed to remove traces of solution. This may cause
difficulties, as the washing may redissolve the solid. Using a wash liquid with a
common ion reduces the solubility.
For example, if 0.18 g of a precipitate of lead sulfate is washed with 1 dm3 of
distilled water, it will dissolve 0.046 g of precipitate or 25%, as the solubility
product is Ksp = 2.3 ¥ 10-8 (mol dm-3)2. If the precipitate is washed with 1 dm3 of
0.01 M sulfuric acid, then the amount dissolved is much less, 0.7 mg or 0.4%.
Drying and Drying can be done in stages. To remove water, the filtered solid in its container
heating is placed in a desiccator and left for a few hours. A vacuum desiccator is even
more efficient for removing solvents at low temperature. Heating in ovens,
furnaces or directly with burners will raise the temperature to remove materials
or to decompose the precipitate to a more stable form. For example, ‘basic
aluminum succinate’ is a good precipitate for aluminum, but must be ignited to
constant weight at about 1200∞C to convert to aluminum oxide.
The stages involved in drying and decomposition can be studied using
thermogravimetry (see Topic G1).
C8 – Gravimetry 97
Weighing Modern balances can readily weigh samples directly, and masses from several
grams down to a few micrograms can be weighed accurately and quickly. It is
important that the conditions are the same for the initial weighing (crucible,
filter paper) as for the final weighings. Temperature is especially important and
hot samples should never be placed directly onto a balance pan.
Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
C9 V OLTAMMETRY AND
AMPEROMETRY
Key Notes
Principles Voltammetry is the study of the variation of current with applied
potential in an electrolysis cell where the reactions are controlled by the
diffusion of the sample species. The current is proportional to the
concentration of the electroactive species and amperometric methods
involve current measurement.
Applications These methods are used qualitatively to determine the nature of metal
and organic species and their reactions, and quantitatively to measure
trace levels of metals and organic compounds.
Potentiostat
V A
Working
electrode Reference electrode
Auxillary electrode
Sample
solution Stirrer
As the cadmium plates out, the layer around the electrode is depleted and
more cadmium ions must diffuse in from outside through the diffusion
layer of thickness d. This will cause a current, I, to flow, which depends on
the concentration gradient between the bulk solution and the surface.
Eventually, the surface concentration becomes zero, and the limiting diffu-
sion current is reached:
Id = constant (c(bulk))/d = kS (c(bulk))
The constant, kS, depends on the number of electrons transferred, the diffu-
sion coefficient of the ion in the solution, and the characteristics of the
cathode.
(iii) If the potential is increased further, the current does not increase unless
other reducible ions are present. These three regions are shown in Figure 2.
The potential difference, E, across the cell at any stage is:
E = ESCE - EDME or
n
E = ESCE - (E Cd + (RT/2F) ln [(a(Cd2+, surface)/a(Cd(Hg))]
From the equations above, the concentrations may be substituted by the
currents, since the concentration of reduced species in the mercury depends on
the current I and the diffusion constant in the amalgam, kA
I = kA(c(Cd(Hg))
E = ESCE - (EnCd + (RT/2F) ln (kA/kS)) + (RT/2F) ln [(Id - I)/I]
When I = 1⁄2 Id, that is at the half-wave position, the DME has the half-wave
potential, E ⁄ 1
2
The half-wave potential is usually quoted relative to the SCE, and, like the
standard electrode potential, is characteristic of the electrode reaction. Typical
values are shown in Table 1.
Limiting current
Current, I
Id
Residual current
E1/2
+ -
H2O2 + 2H + 2e = H2O E ⁄ = -0.9 V
1
2
(ii) The reduced species (that is, the metal) is then oxidized out of the film by
making the electrode increasingly anodic. A peak appears on the current-
potential plot, and the peak current can be shown to be:
Ip = k(cB n t)
where the constant k includes the diffusion and other constants, and n is the
rate of increase of the anodic potential. The peak potential at which an
active species is oxidized is characteristic of that species, and is close to its
half-wave potential.
Applications Polarographic techniques may be used in both qualitative and quantitative modes.
Since the half-wave potential is characteristic of the particular reaction that is
occurring at that potential, it is possible to identify the species involved. A
simple case is shown in Figure 3 where a mixture of metal ions was analyzed.
The two reduction waves for copper occur at –0.1 and –0.35 V, cadmium at
–0.69, nickel at -1.10 and zinc at –1.35 V. This illustrates an analysis that may
identify the species qualitatively and, by using a standard addition method, can
also determine the ions quantitatively.
Organic substances may be determined either in an aqueous or a nonaqueous
medium. For example, the concentration of nitrobenzene in commercial aniline
may be found by studying the reaction:
C6H5NO2 + 4H+ + 4e- = C6H5NHOH + H2O
The oxygen electrode is based on voltammetric principles and depends on
the diffusion and reduction of oxygen. It is also called the Clark sensor.
The cell has a lead anode and a silver cathode set close together in an alkaline
solution, often 1M KOH. At the anode, the reaction is
Pb(s) + 4OH- (aq) = PbO22- (aq) + 2H2O + 2e-
The silver cathode is inert, unless oxygen or another reducible species can
diffuse to it. A semipermeable membrane through which only oxygen can
diffuse surrounds the electrodes, and then the reduction reaction takes place.
O2(aq) + 2H2O + 4e- = 4OH-
Current, I
Since the current depends on the diffusion of the oxygen to the electrode from
the external solution, and this diffusion is proportional to the concentration of
oxygen in the external solution, this electrode may be used to measure dissolved
oxygen.
Amperometric titrations are used to determine substances by measuring the
limiting diffusion current of a species as a function of the volume of a reagent
added to react with that species. Since Id is proportional to the concentration, it
will decrease as a species is used up, or increase as the excess of a species
becomes greater. For example, for the determination of Pb2+ with Cr2O72-:
2Pb2+ + Cr2O72- + H2O = 2PbCrO4 + 2H+
At an applied potential of 0.0 V, and at pH4, dichromate is reduced, but Pb2+ is
not, giving the graph shown in Figure 4.
Applications of anodic stripping voltammetry, are chiefly for the determina-
tion of trace amounts of amalgam-forming metals (Fig. 5), while cathodic strip-
ping voltammetry is used for determining species that form insoluble salts with
mercury. The preconcentration stage allows determination in the concentration
range 10-6 to10-8 M.
12
10
8
Current I (µA)
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Volume dichromate added (ml)
Cu
Pb
Cd
C10 C ONDUCTIMETRY
Key Notes
Movement of ions Ions in solution or in molten ionic solids will move when an electric field
is applied. The speed of movement will depend on the size and charge of
the ion.
Conductance In ionic solutions, the ions carry the current, but Ohm’s law still applies.
Increasing the number of ions increases the conductance.
Conductimetric If the number or nature of ions present in a cell change, then the
titrations conductance will change. This is useful for many types of titration,
including some in nonaqueous media.
Movement of ions When an electric field is applied across a solution, a force is exerted on the ions
that will cause them to move. Positive ions will move toward the more negative
electrode, negative ions toward the more positive, but each will carry current.
The speed with which the ions move usually depends on:
(i) the electric field strength (V m-1);
(ii) the charge z on the ion;
(iii) the size of the ion in solution; and
(iv) the viscosity of the solvent.
In water, the hydrogen ion, H3O+, and the hydroxyl ion, OH-, are small, and
move most rapidly by a very fast exchange with the molecules of water. In
dilute solutions, the ions move independently of each other.
For an electric field of 1 V m-1, the ionic speed is called the mobility, ui. Table
1 gives the ionic size and mobility of selected ions in aqueous solutions at 25∞C.
It is worth noting that despite their larger size in crystals, hydrated potassium
ions are smaller than hydrated sodium ions when in solution and move faster.
Similar rules apply to anions. Also, potassium ions and chloride ions have very
similar mobilities. This is useful when ‘salt bridges’ are needed (see Topic C2).
If ions are present in other solvents, such as liquid ammonia, they will
conduct in a similar way, but their mobilities will be different.
Conductance Ohm’s law still applies to relate the current, I, to the applied voltage, E, and the
resistance, R, or to the conductance, G = 1/R.
I = E/R = EG
G is related to the concentration of ions and has units of ohms-1 or siemens (W-1
or S).
In order to measure the conductance of a solution, a conductance cell is used.
It has two electrodes, often platinum, coated with platinum black, separated by
a fixed distance. Connecting these to a conductance meter, or more simply to a
Wheatstone bridge, the conductance may be measured directly. In order to
prevent electrolysis (see Topics C2, C9) taking place, which would change the
concentrations in the solution, the bridge uses alternating current. Plastic and
flow-through conductance cells are also available
In any conductor, the conductance depends on the cell dimensions and on the
characteristics of the conducting medium. For a cell with electrodes of area A,
set a distance l apart:
G = k/(l/A)
where k is called the conductivity of the solution with units of W-1 m-1 or S m-1.
So that the results from different cells and solutions may be compared, the cell
constant, K = (l/A) is measured using a solution of known conductivity, often
0.1 M aqueous potassium chloride, which has a conductivity k =1.288 W-1 m-1
at 25∞C.
Example
When immersed in a 0.1 M aqueous solution of KCl at 25∞C, a conductance cell
had G = 8.59 ¥ 10-3 W-1. For 0.1 M HCl, using the same cell, the conductance was
measured as 2.57 ¥ 10-2 W-1. Calculate the conductivity and molar conductivity
of the HCl.
For the KCl calibration:
k = G(l/A) = 8.59 ¥ 10-3 ¥ (l/A) = 1.288 W-1m-1
Thus (l/A) = 149.9 m-1 and for HCl, k = 3.85 W-1 m-1
106 Section C – Analytical reactions in solution
Conductimetric Whenever titrations of ionic solutions are carried out, the number and nature of
titrations the ions change throughout the entire titration. If a strong base, say NaOH, is
titrated with a strong acid, HCl, the reaction
Na+ + OH- + H+ + Cl- = Na+ + Cl- + H2O
will first of all remove the OH- as nonconducting water, so the conductance will
decrease until the end point. Then excess HCl will increase the conductance.
This gives a ‘V’ shaped graph of conductance versus titer. If a mixture of acids is
used, they will be titrated in the order of their strength. Figure 1(a) shows the
conductimetric titration of a mixture of HCl, boric acid and ammonium chloride
using NaOH.
For precipitation reactions:
Ag+ + NO3- + Na+ + Cl- = AgCl(s) + Na+ + NO3-
The sodium and silver ions have similar conductivities, so adding NaCl solution
does not change the conductance much until the end point is reached. Then the
conductance rises with excess NaCl. This is shown in Figure 1(b). The titrant is
often about ten-times more concentrated than the sample solution, to avoid
dilution errors.
C10 – Conductimetry 107
(a) (b)
1.4 4
12 3.5
1000 x conductance
3
1
Conductance
2.5
0.8
2
0.6
1.5
0.4
1
0.2 HCl HB NH4Cl 0.5
0 0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0 1 2 3 4 5
Volume added (cm3) Volume added (cm3)
Fig. 1. (a) Conductimetric titration of mixed acids with 1.0 M NaOH. (b) Conductimetric titration of 0.1 M AgNO3 with
1.0 M KCl.
Key Notes
Extraction techniques Solvent and solid-phase extraction are two techniques for separating
mixtures of substances, either by selective transfer between two
immiscible liquid phases or between a liquid and a solid phase.
Solvent extraction Procedures are based on the extraction of nonpolar, uncharged species
from an aqueous solution into an immiscible organic solvent, or the
extraction of polar or ionized species into an aqueous solution from an
organic solvent.
Solid-phase Sample solutions are passed through the sorbent under conditions where
extraction either the analyte(s) are retained and matrix components washed through
or the reverse. Retained analytes are removed with an alternative solvent
before completing the analysis.
Example 1
If an aqueous solution containing iodine and sodium chloride is shaken with a
hydrocarbon or chlorinated hydrocarbon solvent, the iodine, being a covalent
molecule, will be extracted largely into the organic phase, whilst the completely
ionized and hydrated sodium chloride will remain in the aqueous phase.
Example 2
If an aqueous solution containing a mixture of weakly polar vitamins or drugs
and highly polar sugars is passed through a hydrocarbon-modified silica
sorbent which has a nonpolar surface, the vitamins or drugs will be retained on
the surface of the sorbent whilst the sugars pass through.
where (CS) represents the total concentration of all forms of the distributing
solute S in each phase. If no interactions involving S occur in either phase, then
D and KD would be identical. However, the value of D is determined by the
experimental conditions and it can be adjusted over a wide range to suit the
requirements of the analytical procedure.
A distribution ratio can also be defined for solid phase extraction, i.e.
(CS)sorb
D(CS)liq (3)
where the numerator represents the solute concentration in the solid sorbent
and the denominator the solute concentration in the liquid phase.
Solutes with large values of D (e.g. 104 or more) will be essentially quantita-
tively extracted into the organic phase or retained by the sorbent, although the
nature of an equilibrium process means that 100% extraction or retention can
never be achieved.
D1 – Solvent and solid-phase extraction 111
Extraction The efficiency of an extraction depends on the value of the distribution ratio, D.
efficiency and For solvent extraction, it also depends on the relative volumes of the two liquid
selectivity phases and for solid-phase extraction on the surface area of the sorbent. With
solvent extraction, the percentage of a solute extracted, E, is given by the expres-
sion
100D
E (4)
[ (Vaq/Vorg)]
D +
where Vaq and Vorg are the volumes of the aqueous and organic phases, respec-
tively.
For solutes with small values of D, multiple extractions will improve the
overall efficiency, and an alternative expression enables this to calculated
n
(Caq)n = Caq[Vaq/(DVorg Vaq)] (5)
where Caq and (Caq)n are the amounts of solute in the aqueous phase initially and
remaining after n extractions, respectively.
The following example demonstrates the use of these formulae.
Example 1
A water sample contains 10 mg each of a halogenated pesticide and an ionic
herbicide which are to be separated by extraction of the pesticide into methyl-
benzene. Given that the pesticide distribution ratio, D, for methylbenzene/
water is 50, calculate the extraction efficiency for
(i) one extraction of 20 cm3 of water with 10 cm3 of methylbenzene
(ii) one extraction of 20 cm3 of water with 30 cm3 of methylbenzene
(iii) three extractions of the same 20 cm3 of water with 10 cm3 portions of
methylbenzene (30 cm3 in total)
(i) Substitution of the values for D, Vaq and Vorg in equation (4) gives
100 ¥ 50
E
[50 (20/10)] = 96.15%
(ii) Substitution of the values for D, Vaq and Vorg in equation (4) gives
100 ¥ 50
E
[50 (20/30)] = 98.68%
(iii) Substitution of the values for D, Vaq, Vorg, Caq and (Caq)n in equation (5) gives
two solutes with distribution ratios D1 and D2, a separation or selectivity factor,
b, is defined as
b = D1/D2 where D1 >D2 (6)
4 5
Selectivity factors exceeding 10 or 10 (logb values exceeding four or five) are
necessary to achieve a quantitative separation of two solutes, as for most prac-
tical purposes, a separation would be considered complete if one solute could be
extracted with greater than 99% efficiency whilst extracting less than 1% of
another. The extraction of many solutes can be enhanced or supressed by
adjusting solution conditions, e.g. pH or the addition of complexing agents (vide
infra).
Solvent extraction Solvent extraction (SE) is used as a means of sample pre-treatment or clean-up
to separate analytes from matrix components that would interfere with their
detection or quantitation (Topic A4). It is also used to pre-concentrate analytes
present in samples at very low levels and which might otherwise be difficult or
impossible to detect or quantify. Most extractions are carried out batchwise in a
few minutes using separating funnels. However, the efficient extraction of
solutes with very small distribution ratios (<1) can be achieved only by continu-
ously exposing the sample solution to fresh solvent that is recycled by refluxing
in a specially designed apparatus.
Broad classes of organic compounds, such as acids and bases, can be sepa-
rated by pH control, and trace metal ions complexed with organic reagents can
be separated or concentrated prior to spectrometric analysis (Topic E10).
Only the undissociated form, [HA], can be extracted into a nonpolar or slightly
polar solvent such as diethyl ether, the distribution or partition coefficient, KD,
being given by
[HA]ether
KD [HA]aq (9)
However, the distribution ratio takes account of both the dissociated and
undissociated forms of the acid in the aqueous phase and is given by
[HA]ether
D
([HA]aq [A-]aq) (10)
Re-arrangement of equation (8) and substitution for [A-]aq in equation (10) gives
D1 – Solvent and solid-phase extraction 113
[HA]ether
D
[HA]aq (1 Ka/[H]aq) (11)
Equation (12) shows that at low pH, when the acid is undissociated, it is
extracted with the greatest efficiency as D @ KD, whereas as the pH is increased
the value of D decreases until at high pH the acid is completely dissociated into
the anion A-, and none will be extracted. This is shown graphically in Figure 1 as
pH versus E plots for two weak acids (curves 1 and 2) with different acid dis-
sociation constants (Ka or pKa values), curve 1 being for the stronger of the two
acids. For a weak organic base, such as an amine, protonation occurs at low pH
according to the equation
RNH2 + H+ = RNH3+ (13)
The relation between pH and the distribution ratio for a weak base (curve 3) is
therefore the opposite of a weak acid so that it is possible to separate acids from
bases in a mixture either by extracting the acids at low pH or the bases at high
pH. Separating mixtures of acids or mixtures of bases is possible only if their
dissociation or protonation constants differ by several pK units.
Extraction of metals
Metal ions in aqueous solutions are not themselves extractable into organic
solvents, but many can be complexed with a variety of organic reagents to form
extractable species. Some inorganic complex ions can be extracted as neutral
ionic aggregates by association with suitable ions of opposite charge (counter
ions). There are two principal metal extraction systems:
∑ Uncharged metal chelate complexes (ring structures that satisfy the
coordination requirements of the metal) with organic reagents
e.g. 8-hydroxyquinoline (oxine)
acetylacetone (AcAc)
100
1 2 3
80
Percent extracted (E)
60
40
20
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
pH
Fig. 1. Solvent extraction curves for two organic acids having different pKa values (curves 1
and 2) and a base (curve 3). Curve 1 represents the acid with the larger Ka (smaller pKa).
114 Section D – Separation techniques
1-(2-pyridylazo)-2-naphthol (PAN)
sodium diethyldithiocarbamate (NaDDTC)
(see also Table 1);
∑ Electrically neutral ion-association complexes
e.g. Cu(neocuproine)2+, NO3-
(C6H5CH2)3NH+, GaCl4-
[(C2H5)2O]3H+, FeCl4-
(see also Table 1).
The Nernst distribution law applies to metal complexes, but their distribution
ratios are determined by several interrelated equilibria. As in the case of organic
acids and bases, the efficiency of extraction of metal chelates is pH dependent,
and for some ion-association complexes, notably oxonium systems (hydrogen
ions solvated with ethers, esters or ketones), inorganic complex ions can be
extracted from concentrated solutions of mineral acids.
Reagents that form neutral metal chelate complexes (5- or 6-membered ring
structures) are weakly acidic and contain one or more additional co-ordinating
sites (O, N or S atoms). Protons are displaced according to the general equation
Table 1. A selection of reagents and extraction systems for the solvent extraction of
metals
Reagent Type of metal complex
8-Hydroxyquinoline (oxine) Neutral metal chelate complexes,
Di-alkyldithiocarbamates extractable into organic solvents. Intense
e.g. sodium diethyldithiocarbamate color of many facilitates colorimetric
(NaDDTC) determinations.
1,10-Phenanthroline (o-phen) Ion-association complexes. Metals as
2,9-Dimethyl-1,10-phenanthroline cationic or anionic chelated complexes
(neocuproine) extracted with suitable counter ion.
Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA)
Oxonium systems: Ion-pairs with anionic metal halide or
i.e. protons solvated with alkyl ethers, thiocyanate complexes. Chloride complexes
ketones, esters or alcohols extractable from strong HCl solutions.
D1 – Solvent and solid-phase extraction 115
Solid-phase These are generally either silica or chemically-modified silica similar to the
sorbents bonded phases used in high-performance liquid chromatography (Topics D6
and D7) but of larger particle size, typically 40–60 mm diameter. Solutes interact
with the surface of the sorbent through van der Waals forces, dipolar interac-
tions, H-bonding, ion-exchange and exclusion. The four chromatographic sorp-
tion mechanisms described in Topic D2 can be exploited depending on the
sorbent selected and the nature of the sample. Sorbents can be classified
according to the polarity of the surface. Hydrocarbon-modified silicas are
nonpolar, and therefore hydrophobic, but are capable of extracting a very wide
range of organic compounds from aqueous solutions. However, they do not
extract very polar compounds well, if at all, and these are best extracted by
unmodified silica, alumina or Florisil, all of which have a polar surface. Ionic
and ionizable solutes are readily retained by an ion-exchange mechanism using
cationic or anionic sorbents. Weak acids can be extracted from aqueous solu-
tions of high pH when they are ionized, and weak bases from aqueous solutions
of low pH when they are protonated. It should be noted that this is the opposite
way around compared to solvent extraction into non-polar solvents. However,
by suppressing ionization through pH control, extraction by hydrocarbon-
modified silica sorbents is possible. Sorbents of intermediate polarity, such as
cyanopropyl and aminopropyl modified silicas may have different selectivities
to nonpolar and polar sorbents. Some SPE sorbents are listed in Table 2 along
with the predominant interaction mechanism for each one.
Conditioning Retention
Conditioning the sorbent prior to sample Adsorbed isolate
application ensures reproducible retention Undesired matrix constituents
of the compound of interest (the isolate) Other undesired matrix components
Rinse Elution
Rinse the columns to remove undesired Undesired components remain
matrix components Purified and concentrated isolate ready
for analysis
Fig. 2. Diagrammatic representation of a cartridge-based solid phase extraction procedure.
very small volumes of sample and solvents rapidly, and having the advan-
tage of allowing flow in both directions if required.
● Well plates containing upwards of 96 individual miniature sample-
containers in a rectangular array and fitted with miniature SPE packed beds
or disks. Well plates are used in xyz liquid handlers for processing large
numbers of samples prior to the transfer of aliquots to analytical instruments,
particularly gas and liquid chromatographs and mass spectrometers.
● Solid-phase microextraction (SPME) is an important variation of SPE that
allows trace and ultra-trace levels of analytes in liquid or gaseous samples to
be concentrated. The sorbent is a thin layer of a polymeric substance such as
polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) coated onto a fused-silica optical fibre about
1 cm long and attached to a modified microsyringe (Fig. 3). The fibre is
exposed to the sample and then inserted directly into the injection port of a
gas or liquid chromatograph to complete the analysis. An advantage of
SPME over SPE is the avoidance of solvents, but good precision for quantita-
tive determinations is more difficult to achieve, and automated systems are
only just being developed. SPME is finding particular use in water analysis,
the analysis of fragrances and volatiles in foodstuffs by headspace sampling
(Topic D5), the detection of drugs and their metabolites in urine, blood and
breath samples, and the monitoring of air quality in working environments.
D2 P RINCIPLES OF
CHROMATOGRAPHY
Key Notes
Solute migration Solutes migrate through a stationary phase at rates determined by their
and retention relative affinities for each phase, and are characterized by defined
retention parameters.
Peak profiles and Individual solutes migrating through a stationary phase develop an
peak broadening approximately symmetrical band or peak profile which becomes broader
as a function of time and distance travelled.
Peak asymmetry Peak profiles are fundamentally symmetrical but can become
asymmetrical, or skewed, as solutes migrate, due to changes in sorption
behavior.
Solute migration The rate of migration of a solute through a stationary phase is determined by its
and retention distribution ratio, D, which in turn is determined by its relative affinity for the
two phases. In the context of chromatography, D is defined as the ratio of the
total solute concentration, CS, in the stationary phase to that in the mobile phase,
CM, i.e.
CS
D
CM (1)
Thus, large values of D lead to slow solute migration, and small values of D
lead to rapid solute migration. Solutes are eluted in order of increasing distribu-
tion ratio. The larger the differences between the distribution ratios of the
solutes in a mixture, the more easily and quickly they can be separated. Because
the interaction of solutes with the stationary phase slows down their rate of
migration relative to the velocity of the mobile phase, the process is described as
retardation or retention.
● Column separations (GC and LC). For the separation of mixtures on
columns, solutes are characterized by the length of time they take to pass
through, i.e. their retention time, tR, or by a retention factor, k, that is directly
proportional to D. The retention time and the retention factor are related by
the expression
tR = tM(1 + k) (2)
where tM (sometimes written as t0 and known as the dead time) is the time
taken by a nonretained solute to pass through the column. A nonretained
solute migrates at the same velocity as the mobile phase, having a distribu-
tion ratio and retention factor of zero; hence tR = tM. Solutes whose D and k
values are greater than zero are proportionately retarded, having retention
times longer than tM, e.g.
if k = 1, tR = 2 tM
if k = 2, tR = 3 tM etc.
Chromatographic conditions are generally adjusted so that k values are
less than about 20, otherwise retention times become unacceptably long.
Practical values of k are easily calculated using a re-arranged equation (2)
(tR - tM)
k= tM (3)
冢 冣
VS
VR VM 1 D (4)
VM
or VR VM DVs (5)
where D has been substituted for k using the relation
冢 冣
VS
kD (6)
VM
and the volumes of the stationary and mobile phases in the column are VS
and VM, respectively.
Equation (5) is regarded as a fundamental equation of column chromato-
graphy as it relates the retention volume of a solute to its distribution ratio.
● Planar separations (PC and TLC). Separations are normally halted before the
mobile phase has travelled completely across the surface, and solutes are char-
acterized by the distance they have migrated relative to the leading edge of the
mobile phase (solvent front). A solute retardation factor, Rf, is defined as
1
Rf
1k (7)
Sorption Sorption is the process whereby solute species are transferred from the mobile
processes to the stationary phase, desorption being the reverse process. These processes
occur continually throughout a chromatographic separation, and the system is
therefore described as being in a state of dynamic equilibrium. A solute is
repeatedly re-distributed between the phases as the mobile phase advances, in
an attempt to maintain an equilibrium corresponding to its distribution ratio, D.
There are four basic sorption mechanisms, and it is common for two or more
to be involved simultaneously in a particular mode of chromatography, viz:
adsorption; partition; ion-exchange; exclusion.
● Adsorption is a surface effect, not to be confused with absorption, which is
a bulk effect. Surface adsorption involves electrostatic interactions such as
hydrogen-bonding, dipole–dipole and dipole-induced dipole attractions.
Solute species compete with the mobile phase for a limited number of
polar sites on the surface of the adsorbent of which silica gel is the most
widely used. Its surface comprises Si-O-Si and Si-OH (silanol) groups, the
latter being slightly acidic as well as being polar, which readily form
hydrogen bonds with slightly-polar to very-polar solutes. Water in the
atmosphere can de-activate an adsorbent surface by itself being adsorbed,
thereby blocking adsorption sites. This can be overcome by drying the
adsorbent if a more active material is required, although reproducibility
may be difficult to achieve unless ambient temperature and humidity are
carefully controlled. Some common adsorbents are listed in Table 2. Suitable
D2 – Principles of chromatography 123
mobile phases for TLC and HPLC are to be found listed in Table 1, Topic
D6.
The more polar the solute, the more tenaciously it will be adsorbed onto
the surface of an adsorbent. Nonpolar solutes (e.g. saturated hydrocarbons)
have little or no affinity for polar adsorbents, whilst polarizable solutes (e.g.
unsaturated hydrocarbons) have weak affinities arising from dipole/induced
dipole interactions. Polar solutes, especially those capable of hydrogen-
bonding, are adsorbed strongly and require fairly polar mobile phases to
elute them. An approximate order of increasing polarity and therefore order
of elution (increasing distribution ratio) among classes of organic solutes is
alkanes<alkenes<aromatics<ethers<esters<ketones and
aldehydes<thiols<amines and amides<alcohols<phenols<acids
Adsorption-based chromatography is particularly useful for separating
mixtures of positional isomers such as 1,2-, 1,3- and 1,4-di-substituted
aromatic compounds with polar substituents, whereas members of a homolo-
gous series have similar polarities and cannot generally be separated at all.
Chiral chromatography, a mode of HPLC, depends on differences in the
adsorptive interactions of two or more enantiomers of a compound with a
chiral stationary phase. Gas solid chromatography (GSC) is an adsorption-
based mode of GC.
● Partition is a sorption process analogous to solvent extraction (Topic D1),
the liquid stationary phase being thinly coated or chemically bonded onto
an inert solid. Where the liquid is bonded to the supporting solid, it is
debateable as to whether it behaves as a liquid and whether the sorption
process should be described as modified partition, because adsorption may
also be involved. In true partition, solutes are distributed according to their
relative solubilities in the mobile and stationary phases, but the exact
mechanism for bonded phases is not clear. The use of bonded phases has
become widespread in all forms of chromatography, and a pure partition
mechanism probably occurs only in gas liquid chromatography (GLC)
where the stationary phase is not chemically bonded to the column wall
(Topic D4).
Bonded phases are described in more detail in Topics D4 and D6.
● Ion-exchange is a process whereby solute ions in the mobile phase can
exchange with counter-ions carrying the same charge and associated with
oppositely charged groups chemically bound to the stationary phase. The
stationary phase is a permeable polymeric solid, such as an insoluble organic
resin or a chemically modified silica, containing fixed charge groups and
124 Section D – Separation techniques
Peak profiles and During a chromatographic separation, individual solutes develop a symmetrical
band broadening or Gaussian concentration profile (Topic B2) in the direction of flow of the
mobile phase. The profiles, known as bands or peaks, gradually broaden and
often become asymmetrical as the solutes continue to migrate through the
stationary phase. The principal underlying reasons accounting for the peak
shapes and the observed broadening can be summarized as follows:
● continual sorption and desorption of a solute between a mobile and a
stationary phase inherently produces a Gaussian concentration profile which
broadens as the solute migrates further. (This can be demonstrated by a math-
ematical treatment of a solvent extraction procedure to separate mixtures,
developed in 1952, and known as Craig Countercurrent Distribution);
● solute species travel slightly different total distances through a particulate
stationary phase, causing concentration profiles to broaden symmetrically,
this being known as the multiple-path effect;
● solute species spread by diffusion in all directions when they are in the
mobile phase. Diffusion in both the direction of flow of the mobile phase and
directly counter to it (longitudinal or axial diffusion) contributes to the
symmetrical broadening of the peak profile;
● sorption and desorption, or mass transfer, between the stationary and
mobile phases, are not instantaneous processes, and are sometimes kineti-
cally slow. Because the mobile phase moves continuously, a true equilibrium
distribution of a solute is never established, and the concentration profile in
the stationary phase lags slightly behind that in the mobile phase causing
further peak broadening. Slow desorption can also result in the peak
becoming asymmetrical or skewed (vide infra);
D2 – Principles of chromatography 125
● variations in the distribution ratio of a solute with its total concentration also
leads to asymmetrical or skewed peaks (vide infra).
Figure 1 illustrates the symmetrical nature of a chromatographic peak and
symmetrical broadening. Figure 2 illustrates the mutiple-path, longitudinal
diffusion and mass transfer effects.
Flow
Mobile phase
Interface
Stationary phase
Equilibrium concentration
Actual concentration
Fig. 1. The symmetrical nature and broadening of a chromatographic peak.
SP
Mobile phase
(b) Concentration
profile of band Forward and backward
diffusion in mobile phase
as band moves along
Mobile phase
Analyte band
Fig. 2. Illustration of the three principal causes of band broadening: (a) multiple-path effect; (b) longitudinal diffusion
effect; (c) mass-transfer (non-equilibrium) effect. Reproduced from A. Braithwaite & F.J. Smith, Chromatographic
Methods, 5th edn, 1996, first published by Blackie Academic & Professional.
126 Section D – Separation techniques
CS CS CS
CM CM CM
t t t
Fig. 3. Sorption isotherms and the resulting peak profiles. (a) Linear isotherm, symmetrical
peak. (b) Curvature towards the CM axis, tailing peak. (c) Curvature towards the CS axis,
fronting peak.
Efficiency and Two means of assessing the quality of a chromatographic separation are to
resolution measure the extent of band broadening of individual solute peaks (efficiency)
and the degree of separation of adjacent peaks (resolution).
For column chromatography, a plate number, N (based on the theoretical
plate concept of distillation columns), is used as a measure of efficiency.
Assuming a Gaussian peak profile, N is defined in terms of the solute retention
time, tR, and the peak width as given by the standard deviation, st (Fig. 4), i.e.
冢 冣
tR 2
N (8)
st
In practice, it is much easier to measure either the baseline width of a peak,
Wb, or the width at half height, Wh/2, and two alternative expressions derived
from equation (8) are
冢 冣
tR 2
N 16 (9)
Wb
and
D2 – Principles of chromatography 127
tR
Concentration axis
Peak height
Injection
Wh/2
One-half
peak height
Wb
(4s)
Time axis
Fig. 4. Measurement of chromatographic efficiency from a Gaussian peak.
冢 冣
tR 2
N 5.54 (10)
Wh/2
Some laboratories favor the use of eqn. (9), but some favour eqn. (10) on the
grounds that peak width at half height can be measured with greater accuracy
than the base width. To make valid comparisons, the same formula should
always be used.
An alternative measure of efficiency, which is independent of the length of a
chromatographic column, is the plate height, H (or Height Equivalent of a
Theoretical Plate, HETP), and given by
L
H
N (11)
As in the case of the efficiency formulae, Gaussian peaks are assumed and all
measurements must be in the same units as RS is a dimensionless number.
Values of RS approaching or exceeding 1.5, which is defined as baseline resolu-
tion, are deemed satisfactory for most purposes.
The following is an example of the calculation of efficiency and resolution
using the above formulae:
128 Section D – Separation techniques
tR,1 tR, 2
DtR
Concentration axis
W1 W2
Time axis
Calculate (a) the plate numbers, using both plate number formulae, for each
solute, (b) the plate heights, and (c) the resolution between adjacent pairs of
solutes.
冢 冣 冢 冣
tR 2 tR 2
(a) plate numbers N 16 N 5.54
Wb Wh/2
冢 225
11 冣
N 5.54冢 冣 7296
225
2 2
benzene N 16 6694
6.2
10 000
(b) plate heights H N
cyclohexane H = 1.0 mm H = 0.95 mm
t-butanol H = 1.15 mm H = 1.06 mm
benzene H = 1.49 mm H = 1.37 mm
2DtR
(c) resolution RS
(W1 W2)
2DtR
cyclohexane/t-butanol RS
(W1 W2) = 20/17 = 1.2
D2 – Principles of chromatography 129
2DtR
t-butanol/benzene RS
(W1 W2) = 30/20 = 1.5
Note that (i) The plate numbers are slightly higher when half-height peak
widths are used to calculate them due to peak tailing increasing
Wb, hence comparisons of efficiencies are valid only if the same
formula is used throughout.
(ii) The cyclohexane and t-butanol peaks are not fully resolved
(RS = 1.2), but the t-butanol and benzene peaks have baseline
resolution (RS = 1.5).
Qualitative and There are three approaches to qualitative chromatographic analysis, viz
quantitative
● Comparison of retention data for unknown solutes with corresponding data
analysis
for standards (known substances) obtained under identical conditions.
For planar chromatography (PC and TLC), retardation factors, Rf values,
for standards and unknowns are compared by chromatographing them
simultaneously so as to eliminate variations in laboratory materials and
conditions. For column separations, retention times, tR, or volumes, VR, are
compared by chromatographing standards and unknowns sequentially
under stable conditions with as little time between runs as possible.
● Spiking samples with known solutes.
For column separations where samples are known to contain certain
solutes, a comparison is made between two or more chromatograms run
under identical conditions. The first is of the original sample, and subsequent
ones are obtained after adding a spike of one of the known solutes. Any peak
in the original chromatogram that is of increased size in a subsequent one
can then be identified as the corresponding spiked solute. However,
unambiguous identifications may not be possible.
● Interfacing the chromatograph with a spectrometer (Section F).
For column separations, this provides spectral information for each sepa-
rated solute in addition to retention data. Spectra of unknown solutes can be
compared with those in computerized library databases or interpreted
manually, even when pure standards are not available.
Comparisons of retention data alone are not always reliable as many
substances can have identical chromatographic behavior. Two or more
comparisons made under different chromatographic conditions, e.g. different
stationary or mobile phases, reduce the chances of making an incorrect identifi-
cation.
For quantitative chromatographic analysis, in addition to ensuring stable
and reproducible conditions for sample preparation and chromatography,
further specific requirements must also be met viz:
● the analyte (solute) must be identified and completely separated from other
components in the chromatogram;
● standards of known purity must be available;
● a recognized calibration procedure must be used.
For planar chromatography, solute spot areas or densities can be measured
in situ, or the solute spots can be removed, dissolved and measurements made
by another analytical technique such as UV spectrometry (Topic E9).
For column separations, quantitation can be by peak area, peak height or
130 Section D – Separation techniques
peak height ¥ retention time. Integrated peak areas are directly proportional to
the amount of analyte chromatographed when working within the linear range
of the detector, and are the most reliable. They can be measured by computing-
integrators, by triangulation (1/2-base ¥ height of the triangle that approximates
to the Gaussian peak profile) or by cutting out and weighing peaks drawn by a
chart recorder. Detector responses for an analyte are established by the prepara-
tion of a calibration graph using chromatographed standards, with or without
the addition of an internal standard, by standard addition or by internal
normalization. These calibration procedures are described in Topics A5 and B4.
Section D – Separation techniques
D3 T HIN - LAYER
CHROMATOGRAPHY
Key Notes
Mobile phase Single solvents or blends of two or more solvents having the appropriate
overall polarity necessary to achieve the required separation are used as
mobile phases. They range from nonpolar hydrocarbons to polar
alcohols, water, and acidic or basic solvents.
Solute detection Methods of visualizing solutes include spraying the surface of the thin-
layer plate with a chromogenic reagent, or viewing it under a UV lamp if
the sorbent has been treated with a fluorescent indicator.
stand for several minutes to allow the atmosphere in the tank to become
saturated with the solvent vapor;
● small volumes of liquid samples and standards, or solutions, are spotted
onto the sorbent surface of a TLC plate along a line close to and parallel with
one edge (the origin). The plate is then positioned in the tank with this edge
in contact with the mobile phase and the cover replaced (Fig. 1(a));
● the mobile phase is drawn through the bed of sorbent from the edge of the
plate, principally by capillary action, and this development process is halted
shortly before the solvent front reaches the opposite side of the plate. Sample
components and standards migrate in parallel paths in the direction of flow
of the mobile phase, separating into discrete zones or spots;
● the plate is removed from the development tank, dried in a current of warm
air, and solute spots located by appropriate methods (vide infra);
● each solute is characterized by the distance migrated relative to the solvent
front, i.e. its Rf value, which will lie between 0 and 1 (Topic D2), and
unknowns are identified by comparisons with standards run simultaneously.
Figure 1(b) illustrates a developed and visualized TLC plate with Rf values
shown alongside. Note that the shapes of some spots have become slightly
elongated in the direction of flow of the mobile phase, which is an example of
tailing (Topic D2). This is caused by slow desorption as the solute migrates, or
saturation of adsorption sites by high concentrations of the solute leading to a
convex sorption isotherm, and is most likely to occur where adsorption is the
principal chromatographic sorption mechanism (Topic D2).
Stationary phase Stationary phases used in TLC are microparticulate sorbents with particle
diameters of between 10 and 30 mm. The smaller the mean particle size and the
narrower the size range, the better the chromatographic performance in terms of
band spreading (efficiency) and resolution (Topic D2). Thin-layer chromatog-
raphy plates are prepared by coating sorbents onto rectangular plastic,
aluminum or glass sheets in adherent uniform layers approximately 250 mm
(b)
Rf
1.00
(a)
Lid
TLC plate
Developing 0.59
coated with
absorbent tank
Fig. 1. TLC plates (a) during and (b) after development and visualization; Rf values are 0
shown alongside. a, Reproduced from R.J. Hamilton & S. Hamilton, Thin-Layer
Chromatography, 1987. b, Reproduced from R.M. Smith, Gas and Liquid Chromatography
in Analytical Chemistry, 1988. © John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Reproduced with permission.
D3 – Thin-layer chromatography 133
Mobile phase The range of mobile phases used in TLC is extremely wide and they are often
selected empirically. Blends of two solvents are common because the solvent
strength, or eluting power, can be easily adjusted to optimize a separation by
altering solute distribution ratios. Some general guidelines in selecting and
optimizing the composition of a mobile phase are
● Solvents should be of the highest purity as TLC is a very sensitive analytical
technique;
● Mobile phase eluting power should be adjusted so that solute Rf values fall
between 0.2 and 0.8 so as to maximize resolution;
● For separations on silica gel and other polar adsorbents, the overall polarity
of the mobile phase determines solute migration rates and hence their Rf
values; small additions of a slightly polar solvent, such as diethyl ether, to a
nonpolar solvent, such as methylbenzene, will significantly increase Rf
values;
● Polar and ionic solutes are best separated using a blend of a polar organic
solvent, such as n-butanol, with water; the addition of small amounts of
ethanoic acid or ammonia to the water increases the solubilities of basic and
acidic solutes, respectively.
A helpful guide to solvent strength in adsorption and partition-based separa-
tions is an eluotropic series, an example of which is given for HPLC in Table 1
of Topic D6. The solvents are listed in order of increasing solvent strength for
adsorption-based separations. The order for partition-based separations is
broadly similar.
134 Section D – Separation techniques
Solute detection Solutes separated by TLC remain on the surface of the plate after development.
As the majority of solutes are colorless, their spots must be located using a
chemical or physical means of visualization. Chemical methods include:
● Spraying the plate with a locating, or chromogenic reagent that reacts chemi-
cally with all solutes or those containing specific functional groups or struc-
tural features to give colored spots. The plates sometimes need to be warmed
to accelerate the chromogenic reaction and intensify the spots. Examples are
given in Table 2;
● Viewing the plate under a UV lamp set at an emission wavelength of 254 nm
or 370 nm to reveal the solutes as dark spots or bright fluorescent spots on a
uniform background fluorescence. Commercial plates can be purchased with
an insoluble fluorescent substance incorporated into the stationary phase to
provide the background fluorescence, or the plate can be sprayed with a
fluorescent reagent after development;
● Spraying the plate with concentrated sulphuric or nitric acid and heating to
oxidize and char organic solutes which are revealed as brown to black spots;
● Exposing the plate to iodine vapor in a sealed chamber when many organic
solutes develop dark brown colorations;
● Scanning across the surface of the plate with a densitometer, an instrument
that measures the intensity of radiation reflected from the surface when irra-
diated with a UV or visible lamp. Solutes that absorb radiation are recorded
as peaks on a recorder trace or VDU screen;
● Radiolabelled solutes can be detected by autoradiography (blackening of a
photographic film sensitive to X-rays), liquid scintillation counting on
scraped-off areas of the stationary phase, or monitoring the surface of the
plate with a Geiger-Müller tube.
Alternative TLC Variations of the basic development procedure and new stationary phases
procedures aimed at improving resolution, sensitivity, speed, reproducibility and selectivity
have been developed from time to time. Two of the more significant and useful
ones are:
● Two-dimensional TLC. This is a means of improving resolution in samples
where the component solutes have similar chemical characteristics and hence
D3 – Thin-layer chromatography 135
Rf values, e.g. amino acids. A single sample is spotted close to one corner of
the plate and, after development, there is a partial separation of the solutes
along one edge. The plate is dried, turned through 90∞ and developed a
second time, but using a different mobile phase composition for which the
solutes have different distribution ratios compared to those for the first
mobile phase. This results in the partially-separated solutes separating
further because of changes to their migration rates. Visualization gives a 2-D
map or fingerprint of the sample components. The procedure for the separa-
tion of 14 amino acids is shown diagrammatically in Figure 2.
● High-performance plates (HPTLC). These are coated with a thinner layer
(100 mm thick) of a 5 mm particle diameter stationary phase with a very
narrow range of sizes. Sensitivity and resolution are improved because solute
spots are compact, development is much faster, partly because smaller plates
can be used, and solvent consumption is reduced. HPTLC plates with silica
and bonded-phase silicas are commercially available.
Applications of TLC is applicable to a very wide range of mainly organic solutes. It is used
TLC primarily in the biochemical, pharmaceutical, clinical and forensic areas for
qualitative analysis by the comparison of Rf values of sample solutes with those
of standards run on the same plate. It is especially useful for checks on purity, to
monitor the course of reactions and production processes, and to characterize
complex materials such as natural products. The screening of samples for drugs
LEU
VAL Ph-ALA
a-ABA Solvent 1 n-butanol/acetic
GLU acid/water (12:3:5)
GLY THR ALA PRO-OH
PRO
Solvent 2 Phenol/H2O
Fig. 2. Two-dimensional TLC of a mixture of 14 amino acids. Top panel, reproduced from R.J. Hamilton & S. Hamilton,
Thin-Layer Chromatography, 1987. © John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Reproduced with permission. Bottom panel, reproduced from
A. Braithwaite & F.J. Smith, Chromatographic Methods, 5th edn, 1996, first published by Blackie Academic & Professional.
136 Section D – Separation techniques
in clinical and forensic studies, and testing for the presence or absence of
specific substances (limit tests) are additional applications. Tables 1 and 2 include
further examples.
Quantitative TLC by the measurement of spot areas or by computerized
scanning reflectance densitometry (Topic E8) is possible, but, unless HPTLC
plates are used, the relative precision attainable is generally only 5–10%. The
principal source of error is in applying sample spots to the plate, although auto-
mated systems can reduce this.
TLC has a number of advantages over GC and HPLC:
● the ability to run 10–20 or more samples simultaneously for immediate and
direct comparison with standards, which represents a considerable saving in
time;
● the basic technique is very cheap, versatile and quick;
● all solutes, including those that do not migrate from the origin, are detectable.
Disadvantages are the limited reproducibility of Rf values due primarly to
changes in the composition of the mobile phase during development of the
plate, and increasing spot diffusion (band broadening) because the flow rate of
the mobile phase slows as it travels across the plate.
Section D – Separation techniques
D4 G AS CHROMATOGRAPHY:
PRINCIPLES AND
INSTRUMENTATION
Key Notes
Principles Gas chromatography is a technique for the separation of volatile
components of mixtures by differential migration through a column
containing a liquid or solid stationary phase. Solutes are transported
through the column by a gaseous mobile phase and are detected as they
are eluted.
Mobile phase The mobile phase is an inert gas, generally nitrogen or helium, supplied
from a cylinder via pressure and flow controls, and passing through
purification cartridges before entering the column.
Sample injection Gaseous, liquid and solid samples are introduced into the flowing mobile
phase at the top of the column through an injection port using a
microsyringe, valve or other device.
Column and Columns are either long, narrow, capillary tubes with the stationary
stationary phase phase coated onto the inside wall, or shorter, larger diameter tubes
packed with a particulate stationary phase. Stationary phases are high-
boiling liquids, waxes or solid sorbents.
Solute detection Solutes are detected in the mobile phase as they are eluted from the end
of the column. The detector generates an electrical signal that can be
amplified and presented in the form of a chromatogram of solute
concentration as a function of time.
pressures and hence their boiling points. Solutes are therefore generally eluted
in order of increasing boiling point, except where there are specific interactions
with the stationary phase. The gaseous mobile phase elutes the solutes from the
end of the column where they pass through a detector that responds to each
one. An elevated temperature, usually in the range 50–350∞C, is normally
employed to ensure that the solutes have adequate volatility and are therefore
eluted reasonably quickly.
There are two modes of gas chromatography:
∑ Gas-liquid chromatography (GLC), which employs a liquid stationary phase
in which solutes can dissolve, the sorption process being partition. Specific
interactions of solutes with the stationary phase may alter the order of
elution from that of increasing boiling points. GLC is by far and away the
more widely used mode of GC, the large number of alternative stationary
phases enabling many types of sample to be analyzed.
∑ Gas-solid chromatography (GSC) employs a solid, sometimes polymeric,
sorbent as the stationary phase, the sorption process being surface adsorp-
tion. GSC has limited specialist applications, being used mainly for
analyzing mixtures of gases or solvents with relatively low relative molecular
masses.
A schematic diagram of a gas chromatograph is shown in Figure 1. It consists of
five major components:
Microliter syringe
(or autosampler,
sample valve)
Sample
Gas flow control system
Injector
Makeup flow
Capillary column
Split flow
Column oven
Chromatogram
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of a capillary column gas chromatograph. Reproduced from D.W. Grant, Capillary Gas
Chromatography, 1996. © John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Reproduced with permission.
D4 – Gas chromatography: principles and instrumentation 139
Mobile phase The mobile phase is known as the carrier-gas because its sole purpose is to
transport solutes through the column, thus not contributing to chromatographic
selectivity. It should be inert, non toxic, non flammable and preferably cheap.
Helium and nitrogen are invariably used routinely, the former with capillary
(open tubular) columns and the latter with packed columns (vide infra). Helium
gives better chromatographic efficiency (reduced band broadening) due to faster
mass transfer (Topic D2). The carrier gas must be purified by passing it through
suitable adsorbents so as to avoid undesirable chemical changes to sample
components and stationary phases, or adverse effects on detector performance.
The most common contaminants and the means of removing them are:
● Air or oxygen at levels above about 10 ppm, which can oxidize sample
components and liquid stationary phases, especially at high column tempera-
tures. These can be removed by a cartridge containing molecular sieve.
● Hydrocarbons, which affect detector performance by contamination or
producing a large and constant background signal. These can be removed by
a cartridge containing activated carbon.
● Water vapor, which can affect some solid and bonded-liquid stationary
phases, and the performance of some detectors. This can also be removed
with molecular sieve.
The carrier gas is supplied from a cylinder via a pressure-reducing valve at
10–45 psi (0.7–3 bar) which provides flow rates of between 1 and 50 cm3 min-1
depending on the type of column in use. A mass-flow controller ensures
constant flow rates regardless of back-pressure and temperature (the viscosity of
gases increases with temperature).
Sample injection Samples should preferably be injected into the flowing mobile phase rapidly so
as to occupy the smallest possible volume when vaporized. This ensures a
narrow initial sample band that maximizes column efficiency and resolution.
There are a number of methods of injection and designs of injection port
available, and the choice is determined by the type of column in use and the
nature of the sample. Small volumes of liquids or solutions (0.1–10 ml) are gener-
ally injected into a heated injection port, through which the carrier gas continu-
ously flows, from a calibrated microsyringe used to pierce a self-sealing
silicone-rubber septum. Gases are introduced via a gas sampling valve or gas
syringe, and solids with volatile components as solutions. Septa must be
replaced regularly to avoid leakage and can be a source of contamination by
previously injected samples or the bleeding of plasticizers into the gas stream,
especially when operating at very high temperatures. A separate septum-purge
gas stream vented to the atmosphere, or septumless valves can overcome the
latter problem. Capillary (open tubular) columns require specially designed
injection ports to prevent overloading them with samples, which can severely
impair efficiency and resolution.