A simulation-based model for evaluating the performance of ready mixed concrete production process rmc
A simulation-based model for evaluating the performance of ready mixed concrete production process rmc
R.H. Crawford and A. Stephan (eds.), Living and Learning: Research for a Better Built Environment: 49 International
Conference of the Architectural Science Association 2015, pp.658–667. ©2015, The Architectural Science Association
and The University of Melbourne.
Abstract: The development of the infrastructure sector and the rise in the per capita consumption of
cement and concrete over the years have triggered the rapid increase in the use of ready-mixed
concrete (RMC) in India. The assured quality of concrete, accuracy in the mix proportions, faster
construction, less workforce and improved workspace utilization make RMC advantageous over site-
mixed concrete. This industry is turning out to be one of the most promising in terms of income and
revenue that efforts have to be made to ensure that the RMC production processes are carried out in a
timely and cost-effective manner. With the growing concern over the environmental impacts due to
construction, its sustainability perspective should also be taken into consideration. This study presents a
discrete-event simulation model to evaluate alternate RMC production scenarios and to assess its
performance in terms of equipment (batching plant and truck) utilization rate, energy use and carbon
emissions. A detailed review on the functioning of the RMC production processes is presented. Finally,
this study presents a set of recommendations for improving the performance of the RMC industry.
1. Introduction
The arrival of liberalization principles into the Indian economy paved the way for large-scale investments
in the industrial, infrastructural and agricultural sectors of the country. This led to the increased pace in
the mechanisation of the construction industry and also to the advent of the usage of RMC in India (Jain,
2002).The use of RMC in the construction industry is significantly advantageous because of many
reasons which include good quality concrete, precise mix proportions, faster construction, less number
of labourers, reduced congestion at the worksite and improved workspace utilization (Indian Cement
Review, 2014).
The size of the RMC industry has grown from USD 2.39 billion in 2009-2010 to USD 6.02 billion in
2014-2015 (Goyal, 2012). As per the earliest efforts to count the number of RMC plants in India, the
total number of plants accounted to 27 in the year 2000. This was mainly concentrated to the major
A simulation-based model for evaluating the performance of ready-mixed concrete (RMC) production 659
processes
metropolitan cities of India (Jain, 2000). In 2001, this increased to 47 (Jain, 2002) and further increased
to 147 by 2005 (Ranganath, 2005). In 2013, the all India commercial count of RMC plants amounted to a
total of 857 and the latest statistics as per January 2015 show that the total number of RMC plants is
1135 (Manjunathal et al. 2015).
Most of the plants have been set up in the major cities of India and they account for 30 - 60 % of the
total concrete used in these cities. Its use is rapidly increasing in spite of the 12 - 20% higher cost as
compared to site-mixed concrete (Alimchandani, 2007). On an average, the total concrete market in
India is estimated at about 300 million cubic meters annually. Out of this, the RMC production is about
35 million cubic meters (Goyal, 2012), which is around 12 % of the total concrete production.
Since the country is witnessing a rapid increase in the use of RMC, a comprehensive framework must
be set up to address the relevant issues relating to the production and environmental performance of
RMC (Misra and Varsney, 2011). This study aims to present an understanding on the functioning of the
RMC production processes and to develop a simulation-based model for evaluating alternate RMC
production scenarios.
2. Literature review
As a large number of RMC plants are being set up in the country, the industry is turning out to be one of
the most promising in terms of revenue and profit. Thus, this also means that the supply, delivery and
in-house operations of an RMC plant have to be carried out in a timely and cost-effective manner (Park
et al. 2011). To get the maximum cost and time benefit, proper vehicle scheduling and dispatching of
the ready-mixed concrete should be maintained. Thus, the project management perspective of RMC has
been quite a challenge for its suppliers.
One of the main factors that should be taken into consideration for this aspect is the lifetime
restriction of concrete. Concrete is a material which possesses the perishable characteristic that it
cannot be stored or produced much in advance. It hardens within a few hours (1 to 1.5 hours) and
hence, it has to be delivered from the plant to the site within this time limit (Masten and Sherkow,
2012). This characteristic increases the complexity of the scheduling and dispatching of concrete (Zhang
et al. 2011). The production process also depends largely on the distance between the RMC batching
plant and the site (Park et al. 2011).
Furthermore, life cycle cost (LCC) has emerged as a significant element in assessing the economic
performance of the industry in the long term (Hong et al. 2012). Life cycle cost is the total cost incurred
in all the different stages of construction. With this concept, the project management perspective is
slowly and steadily merging with the sustainability perspective of construction. There is immense
pressure on the world’s environmental performance today that measures have to be taken to conserve
the natural resources for tomorrow. It has been shown that humans are exploiting natural resources at
a rate of about 20 – 25 % more than the rate at which the earth can replenish them (Gardiner &
Theobald, 2014). This applies to the construction sector too as a large amount of raw materials are
being used in this industry. Hence, there is an increasing demand in the construction sector, to
understand and imbibe the concepts of sustainability in practice.
Many countries have made efforts to reduce the environmental impacts that take place due to
construction (Hong et al. 2012). In India, almost 24 % of the total CO2 emissions is due to the activities
occurring in the construction sector (Parikh et al. 2009). It has also been found out that transportation is
one of the most significant components which results in the emissions of green-house gases. The
660 A.G. Nellickal, A.V. Rajendra and S. Palaniappan
transportation sector contributes to about 23 % of the world’s total green-house gas emissions (IPCC,
2008). The transportation of ready-mixed concrete to site represents a major component of energy use
and emissions during the on-site construction phase (Palaniappan et al. 2009).
The construction industry consists of complicated, dynamic and interactive processes and like most
of the construction processes, the supply and delivery of RMC is stochastic. Thus, the production of RMC
cannot be modelled deterministically using average input data. However, it can be efficiently modelled
by means of discrete-event simulation (DES). Discrete-event simulation keeps track of the changes of
the state of the system occurring at discrete points in time and builds up a logical model of the system
to experiment with it on a computer (Lu and Lam, 2009). A lot of work has been done by means of DES
to analyse the time, cost and sustainability aspects of earthmoving (Ahn et al. 2009) and road
construction operations (Gonzalez and Echaveguren, 2012). In the context of ready-mixed concrete, the
use of DES was undertaken in some studies to evaluate the production performance. A brief review of
these studies is summarized in Table 1:
state in India. A detailed understanding of the RMC processes was developed. The field visits helped in
demarcating the RMC processes into five phases and to assess the environmental performance. This was
made possible through observations at the plant and interviews with the plant manager and other staff
members of each RMC plant. The input for the simulation model was obtained from the analysis of data
provided by the RMC suppliers. The RMC production processes are grouped into five major phases from
the manufacturing of raw materials to site operations. The disposal of concrete is not considered in the
scope of this study. Each phase consumes resources such as water, fuel, electricity, consumables,
equipment, vehicles, instruments and human workforce. The details of these five phases are described
below (Nellickal et al. 2015):
4. Simulation model
The discrete-event simulation (DES) model takes into consideration the various activities and resources
that are part of the RMC production processes. It is developed such that it runs for a period of one day,
to deliver concrete from the batching plant to one site. The components of the model and its input and
output parameters are shown in Figure 1.
The simulation model was tested for four scenarios by varying the quantity of concrete required per
day, distance to site, number of trucks and the speed of the truck. The output parameters are batching
plant utilization rate, truck utilization rate, energy use and emissions. Table 2 presents the input data
used for simulation. This is based on the information gathered from several field visits. The energy use
and emissions are calculated from factors which have been obtained from the field analysis. Energy use
is calculated using the factor 6.35 MJ / cum / km one-way distance, whereas emissions is calculated
using 0.48 kgCO2 / cum / km one-way distance.
Table 2: Input for the simulation model based on data gathered from RMC suppliers.
Parameter No. of Mean Minimum Maximum
samples
Quantity of concrete transported per day (cum/day) 176 100.7 3 342
One-way distance travelled per trip per truck (km/trip) 364 18.2 2.7 66.2
Average number of trips per day per truck (trips/day) 364 2.2 0 8
Waiting time at site for transit mixers (minutes) 268 150.7 0 397
The batching plant component in the model represents the pan mixer in which the various raw
materials are mixed to produce the ready-mixed concrete. The capacity of the pan mixer is 1 cum per
batch or 45.8 cum per hour. It usually runs for an average of 10 hours per day. Materials represent the
storage of the raw materials which needs to be loaded into the pan mixer. The produced concrete is
then loaded into the transit mixer trucks which have a maximum capacity of 6 cum. It takes
approximately 8 minutes to complete one cycle of mixing the concrete and loading it into one transit
mixer. The transportation to the site depends on the speed of truck and the distance of the site from the
batching plant. The average speed of the truck is assumed to be 40 kmph over a mean one-way distance
of 20 km. The transit mixer waits at the site depending on the availability of the pump and the time
required for pumping. Pumping of concrete represents the unloading of concrete at the site by the
transit mixer. The time required for pumping is assumed to be 15 minutes. Once the concrete is
unloaded, the transit mixer truck returns to the batching plant, where they are cleaned prior to its next
trip. The cleaning time is considered as 5 minutes. Based on the data gathered, there are about 8 to 14
A simulation-based model for evaluating the performance of ready-mixed concrete (RMC) production 663
processes
transit mixer trucks owned by the supplier company. Their utilization depends on the amount of
concrete required to be supplied on that particular day. The average quantity of concrete supplied per
day is 100 cum.
5. Results
The results of the four scenarios tested using the discrete-event simulation model are shown in Figure 2.
5.2. Scenario - 2: variation of distance between the batching plant and site
The distance to the site is varied from 10 to 70 km and the number of trucks is kept constant at 10 in this
scenario. The quantity of concrete required is also kept at a constant value of 100 cum. It was observed
that as the distance to the site increases, the batching plant utilization rate decreases. This means that
the plant has more idle time when the distance to site increases. The rate varies from 0.731 to 0.561 as
the distance increases from 10 km to 70 km. However, it was observed that the truck utilization rate
increases from 0.53 to 0.772 as the distance is varied from 10 km to 70 km. The energy use and
emissions increase as the distance to site increases. Energy use varies from 12693 MJ to 88852 MJ as
distance varies from 10 km to 70 km. Similarly, the emissions increase from 968 kgCO 2 to 6779 kgCO2.
Batching Concrete
plant pump
3,5 6,7 9
Loading of Trasportation Truck Pumping of
Materials
concrete to site waiting concrete
4
10 6,7
Transit
Return to batching
mixer Cleaning of trucks
plant
truck
1. Quantity of concrete supplied per day 6. Speed of concrete delivery by transit mixer A. Batching plant utilization rate
2. Pan mixer running hours trucks B. Truck utilization rate
3. Time for mixing and loading of concrete into 7. Distance of the site from batching plant C. Energy use due to transportation of transit
transit mixers 8. Number of concrete pumps for placing concrete mixer trucks
4. Number of transit mixer trucks 9. Time required for pumping concrete D. Emissions due to transportation of transit
5. Capacity of transit mixer trucks 10. Time required for cleaning transit mixer trucks mixer trucks
b. Scenario – 2: Number of trucks = 10; Concrete produced per day= 100 cum
A simulation-based model for evaluating the performance of ready-mixed concrete (RMC) production 665
processes
c. Scenario – 3:One-way distance = 20 km; Concrete produced per day= 100 cum
d. Scenario – 4: Number of trucks = 10; Concrete produced per day= 100 cum; One-way distance = 20 km
Figure 2: Results of the simulation model (note: the energy use and emissions are related to the
transportation of concrete from the batching plant to site).
6. Conclusion
This study evaluated the RMC batching plant utilization rate, transit truck utilization rate, energy use
and emissions using a simulation model. The following recommendations are presented to improve the
production and the environmental performance of the RMC production processes: a) Proper monitoring
of the transportation of the transit mixer trucks such that truck dispatching from the batching plant is in
accordance to minimise the idle time at the plant and truck waiting time at the customer site; b)
Integrate lean concepts into RMC production processes to eliminate the non-value adding activities and
wastage at the plant and site; c) As transportation is one of the major sources of energy use and
emissions, the determination of the optimal number of transit mixer trucks for efficient concrete
666 A.G. Nellickal, A.V. Rajendra and S. Palaniappan
delivery can reduce the total impact on the environment; and d) Use of locally available or recycled raw
materials such that the total embodied energy is reduced. This would be useful to improve the decision
making processes of the RMC suppliers in terms of project management and sustainability metrics.
Further studies can focus on considering the supply of concrete to multiple construction sites per day
and the determination of the optimal scenario. Also, the effect of the truck speed on fuel mileage can be
studied.
Acknowledgements
The financial support provided by IC & SR, IIT Madras through research grant ERP/13-14/012/RESF/SIVK
is gratefully acknowledged. The study was made possible by the continuous support from the ready-
mixed concrete suppliers who have participated in this work.
References
Ahn, C., Rekapalli, P. V., Martinez, J. C. and Pena-Mora, F. A. (2009) Sustainability analysis of earthmoving
operations, Proceedings of the 2009 Winter Simulation Conference, U.S.A.
nd
Alimchandani, C. R. (2007) The Indian experience of Ready Mixed Concrete (RMC), 32 Conference on Our World in
Concrete & Structures, Singapore.
Arioz, O., Arslan, G. Tuncan, M. and Kivrak, S. (2006) Web based quality control of ready-mixed concrete, Building
and Environment, 42, 1465 – 1470.
Azambuja, M. and Chen, X. (2014) Risk assessment of a ready-mic concrete supply chain, Construction Research
Congress, 1695 – 1703.
Dunlop, P. G. and Smith, S. D. (2002) Simulation analysis of the UK concrete delivery and placement process: - A tool
th
for planners, 18 Annual ARCOM Conference, U.K.
Gardiner & Theobald, (2014) Business case studies: sustainable development in the construction industry: a case
study. Available from: <http://businesscasestudies.co.uk/gardiner-theobald/sustainable-development-in-the-
construction-industry/introduction.html#axzz36D96f8ZY> (accessed 1 July 2014).
Gonzalez, V. and Echaveguren, T. (2012) Exploring the environmental modelling of road construction operations
using discrete-event simulation, Automation in Construction, 24, 100 – 110.
Goyal, C. R. (2012) Concrete :Ready-Mixed Concrete- readies itself to take over the industry, The Masterbuilder,
India.
Hong, T., Ji, C. and Park, H. (2012) Integrated model for assessing the cost and CO2 emission (IMACC) for sustainable
structural design in ready-mix concrete, Journal of Environmental Management, 103, 1–8.
Indian Cement Review, (2014) Ready-mixed concrete India sector, Available from: Open Source Repository
<http://www.indiancementreview.com/News.aspx?news=Ready-Mix-Concrete-India-
Sector&nid=oQru6pPQGJYexnRHE+cMng==> (accessed 3 December 2014).
IPCC (2008) Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, National greenhouse gas programme, Available from:
Open Source Repository < http://www.ipcc.ch/ipccreprts/ar4-wg3htm> (accessed 4 December 2014).
th
Jain, A.K. (2002) Ready-mixed concrete growth prospects in India, 27 Conference on Our World in Concrete &
Structures, Singapore.
Lu, M. and Lam, H. (2009) Simulation-optimisation integrated approach to planning ready mixed concrete
production and delivery: validation and applications, Proceedings of the 2009 Winter Simulation Conference,
U.S.A.
Manjunathal, L. R., Ravishankar, M. and Aswath, M. U. (2015) Growth and development of ready-mixed concrete
industry in India, Seminar Document: Quality Assurance and Innovations in Ready-Mixed Concrete, Bangalore,
99 – 106.
Masten, M. and Sherkow, S. (2012) Extending the Delivery Time of Concrete Mixtures. Technical Summary: Local
Road Research Board, Concrete Delivery Time Study, 1 – 3.
A simulation-based model for evaluating the performance of ready-mixed concrete (RMC) production 667
processes
Nellickal, A. G., Rajendra, A. V. and Palaniappan, S. (2015) A conceptual lean-based framework for improving the
th
environmental performance of ready-mixed concrete production processes, Proceedings of the 4 World
Construction Symposium 2015: Sustainability and Development in Built Environment, Sri Lanka.
Palaniappan, S., Bashford, H., Fafitis, A., Li, K. and Stecker, L. (2009) Carbon emissions based on transportation for
post-tensioned slab foundation construction : A production home building case study in the Greater Phoenix
Arizona area, International Journal of Construction Education and Research, 5, 236 – 260.
Parikh, J., Panda, M., Kumar, M. G. and Singh, V. (2009) CO2 emissions structure if Indian economy, Energy, 34, 1024
– 1031.
Park, M., Kim, W. Y., Lee, H. S. and Han, S. (2011) Supply chain management model for ready mixed concrete,
Automation in Construction, 20(1), 44 – 55.
Ranganath, R. V. (2015) Ready-Mixed Concrete, BMS College of Engineering, Available from: Open Source
Repository <http://elearning.vtu.ac.in/12/enotes/Adv_Conc_Stru/Unit5-RVR.pdf> (accessed 10 March 2015).
Smith, S. D. (1999) Modelling and experimentation of the concrete supply and delivery process, Civil Engineering
and Environmental Systems, 16(2), 93 – 114.
Talin, J. (2013) Optimization of the concrete delivery and placement process using a simulation, Slovak Journal of
Civil Engineering, 2, 1 – 6.
Zayed, T. M. and Minkarah, I. (2004) Resource allocation for concrete batch plant operation: case study, Journal of
Construction Engineering and Management, 130, 560 – 569.
Zayed, T. M. and Halpin, D. (2001) Simulation of concrete batch plant production, Journal of Construction
Engineering and Management, 127, 132 – 141.
Zhang, J. (2011) Empirical study and risk assessment on ready-mixed concrete industry, Proceedings of International
Conference on Business Management and Electronic Information, China.
Zhang, Y., Li, M. and Liu, Z. (2011) Vehicle scheduling and dispatching of ready mixed concrete: Proceedings of 4th
International Workshop on Advanced Computational Intelligence IWACI 2011, China.