project 1
project 1
org © 2023 IJCRT | Volume 11, Issue 7 July 2023 | ISSN: 2320-2882
Abstract:
Banks play a very important role in any Financial System. It is the backbone of the Indian Financial System.
The Rising NPA’s of the Banks in India for the last 5 years has really posed a threat to the Indian financial
system. Recently Standard & Poor Global Rating agency has expected the NPA’s of Indian banks to remain
elevated at 3.9 %. NPA helps to measure the Performance of any bank. It is quite evident that the Recent
Covid Pandemic has badly hit not only India but the entire world to a greater extent. The Public and Private
sector banks in India both have been adversely affected by the Rising NPA. Through this research, it has
been observed that public sector banks are more adversely affected than Private sector banks. This Study
Focus on the Trend & Differences in the Non-Performing Assets of the Selected Indian Public and Private
Sector Banks.
Introduction:
The Indian banking sector is the backbone of the country. It reflects the financial health and economic
conditions of the country. The bank's main role is to finance various sectors such as agriculture, industry,
housing and homebuilding, and to accept deposits from retail, industrial and institutional customers.
Accepting deposits is generally risk-free, as the banker is obligated to repay the deposit at any time upon
demand. On the other hand, loans always carry a high degree of risk, as there is no certainty that they will be
repaid. Recently, banks have become very cautious about lending out of fear of an increase in non-
performing assets. If the borrower fails to pay the principal and interest within 90 days, the borrower's
mortgage asset becomes NPA. Assets like this bring neither income nor profit to the bank.
Types of NPAs:
Gross NPAs are the sum of all loan assets that are classified as NPAs as RBI guidelines as on balance
sheet date.
Net NPAs are those type of NPAs in which the bank has deducted the provision for uncertain and unpaid
debts.
Net NPAs is obtained by reducing the provision from gross NPAs and show the actual burden of
banks. It can be calculated by following:
1. Sub-standard Assets
2. Doubtful Assets
3. Loss Assets
Sub-standard Assets: A sub-standard asset of NPA for a period less than or equal to 12 months.
Doubtful Assets: A Doubtful asset is asset of NPA for more than 12 months.
Loss Assets: A loss asset is type of asset of NPA which losses has been identified by the bank
authority, auditors, or the RBI but the loss amount has not been written off fully.
Review of Literature
Prashanth K Reddy (2002) examines bank NPAs in an international context, with an emphasis on
economic variables, in Asian countries, India, China, Thailand, Korea, and Japan. He conducted a
comparative study using gross and net NPA over nine years. He jointly explained the similarities, differences
and remedies of NPAs in the international context
MRS. Asha Singh (2013) analyzed the gross and net NPA of Indian commercial banks over a ten-year
period. He said the NPA reflects the bank's performance. The scope of NPAs is relatively broader for public
sector banks. According to their research, NPA is considered the main indicator of credit risk. Therefore,
NPAs should be organized according to the right approach in order to increase their effectiveness and profits.
It is absolutely impossible to own an NPA with zero shares. However, at a minimum, Indian banks should be
careful to ensure that they are providing loans to responsible customers.
Krishna Murali (2014) found 39 bank NPAs. Based on this study, it was found that the management of
NPAs in public banks in India has improved significantly. This is due to the decrease in the volume ratio of
total NPA to total upfront payments. This study finally, it noted that the prudence and provisioning standards
and initiatives taken by regulators put pressure on banks to improve their performance, resulting in a
reduction in NPAs.
N.A Kavitha, M. Muthu Meenakshi (March 2016) investigated relatively high levels of NPAs in public
sector banks. Although the government has taken various measures. NPA will be reduced, but there is still
much work to be done to curb this problem. To improve efficiency and profitability, you need to plan your
NPA. The government has taken some steps. to reduce NPA. They also found in the study that the issue of
NPAs needs a lot of serious work, otherwise NPAs will continue to hurt banks' profitability, which is not at
all good for the growing Indian economy. I also mentioned no.
Dr. Kapil K Dave (2016) a comparative study of NPAs for public and private sector banks concludes that
each bank should have its own independent rating agency to assess the financial performance of borrowers
prior to loan facilities. An effective board of financial experts with extensive knowledge in the field can be
set up to manage the NPA. NPA is considered an important rating factor for any bank. Need to assess the
customer's financial situation on a regular basis.
Abid Husain, G. Kadiu, Dr. Rasikbhai, I. Prajapati (February 2020) There is a difference between NPAs
in both public and private sector banks. This study shows that bank type and sector NPA do not have a
compounding effect on a bank's overall NPA. The findings show that higher NPAs were observed for public
sector banks in both the priority and non-priority categories. All selected private sector banks have an
average NPA of less than 5% over the sample period, and all selected large public sector banks have an
average NPA of more than 5% over the sample period. The study finds that private sector banks have better
asset quality and debt coverage efficiencies than public sector banks. Compared to private banks, public
sector banks recorded higher NPAs.
Gilnara Mona Ramesh Bhai (July 2020) participated in the NPAs investigation of 5 public and 5 private
banks. This research paper examined data from public and private sector banks over the last five years. This
research paper attempts to evaluate different NPA ratios based on secondary data. This research paper
provides conceptual insight into the meaning of NPA, various indicators related to NPA, and compares her
NPA of public and private sector banks. By comparison, we can see that her NPA for public sector banks is
higher compared to private sector banks. The gross and Net NPA of public sector banks are higher than those
of private sector banks. We found that increasing the number of NPA had a negative impact on bank
profitability.
Research Gap:
Even though there has been a lot of study done in this field, the comparison of two public sector banks (SBI,
BOI) and two private sector banks (HDFC, ICICI Banks) during the course of the 2017-2022 fiscal year has
not yet been completed. I have performed a comparison analysis here by trashing these particular
institutions. Additionally, they examined the connection between important bank metrics and NPAs.
With the changing times, the definition of the police agency is also changing. Therefore, his NPA in India is
increasing gradually and at an accelerating rate. It is considered one of the key indicators for evaluating a
bank's financial performance. Therefore, it is very important to explore the NPA dynamic changes in the
Indian banking sector. This can be better understood by conducting a comparative analysis of public and
private sector banks in India. There are two public sector banks here. SBI and BOI, and two private banks.
ICICI Bank and HDFC Bank were selected for research purposes as they are the most prominent in their
particular field and the best in their category. The study focused on various factors such as total NPA %, net
NPA %, and return on investment %, net NPA, and net profit to explore both public and private banks.
Objectives:
1. To study the relationship between NPA with the key parameters of selected banks.
2. To find out the impact of NPA on profit and Return on Assets (ROA) of the selected banks.
Scope of the Study: The scope of the study is comparative analysis of 2 public sectors banks and 2
private sectors banks in India for the duration of 2017 to 2022.
Methodology of Study:
1. Sources of Data: The present study based on secondary data. These data have been collected from
different sources such as:
Mean has been calculated to know the average performance and to know the stability in the
performance of the banks to find out the relationship between NPA and other key parameters of bank.
Tabel-1
YEAR Trend of NPAs of SBI, BOI, HDFC and
ICICI Bank from 2011-12 to-2021-22 in Crores of Rupees
BANKS
SBI BOI HDFC BANK ICICI BANK
2011-12 15818.85 3656.42 352.33 1860.84
2012-13 21956.48 5947.31 468.95 2230.56
2013-14 31096.07 7417.23 820.03 3297.96
2014-15 27590.58 13517.57 896.28 6255.53
2015-16 55807.02 27996.39 1320.37 13296.75
2016-17 58277.38 25305.05 1843.99 25451.03
2017-18 110854.7 28207.27 2601.02 27886.27
2018-19 65894.74 19118.95 3214.52 13577.43
2019-20 51871.3 14320.1 3542.36 10113.86
2020-21 36809.72 12262.03 4554.82 9180.2
2021-22 27466.64 9851.93 4407.68 6960.89
Graphical Representation of Net Profit & Net NPAs of SBI and BOI Banks
60000
50000
Net NPA value in Cr.
40000
30000
20000
10000
0
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
SBI 15819 21956 31096 27591 55807 58277 0 65895 51871 36810 27467
BOI 3656.4 5947.3 7417.2 13518 27996 25305 28207 19119 14320 12262 9851.9
HDFC BANK 352.33 468.95 820.03 896.28 1320.4 1844 2601 3214.5 3542.4 4554.8 4407.7
ICICI BANK 1860.8 2230.6 3298 6255.5 13297 25451 27886 13577 10114 9180.2 6960.9
Interpretation:
Table-1 Revels the trend of NPAs in public scoter banks and private sector banks, here Net NPAs of selected
public sector banks (SBI, BOI) and private sector banks (HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank) in India. The SBI and
BOI is increased and even positive figure in the year of 2017-18 and rest of the years fluctuated. These are
the public sector, and the private sector also forms a trend in NPAs in banking. These are HDFC Bank and
ICICI Bank, here the Net NPA of HDFC is ₹4554.82 Cr in the year of 2020-21 and remaining is ICICI Bank
is more than HDCF Bank because of its value of ₹27886.27 Cr. In the above Table or Graph SBI is more
NPAs in the Span of 10 years.
Table-2
%Gross NPA of selected public and private sector banks in India
from 2017 to 2022
YEAR PUBLIC SECTOR PRIVATE SECTOR
BANKS BANKS
%Gross NPA %Gross NPA
SBI BOI HDFC BANK ICICI
BANK
2017-18 10.91 16.58 1.3 8.84
2018-19 7.53 15.84 1.36 6.7
2019-20 6.15 14.78 1.26 5.53
2020-21 4.98 13.77 1.32 4.96
2021-22 3.97 9.98 1.17 3.6
MEAN 6.708 14.19 1.282 5.926
Graphical Representation of Net Profit & Net NPAs of SBI and BOI Banks
15
10
0
2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22
PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS %Gross NPA SBI PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS %Gross NPA BOI
PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS %Gross NPA HDFCBANK PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS %Gross NPA ICICI BANK
Interpretation:
Table-2 reveals the % of Gross NPA of selected public sector and private sector banks in India. BOI has
highest Mean ratio of 14.19%, followed by SBI with 6.708%. HDFC has lowest Mean ratio of 1.280%.
ICICI Bank have 5.926% Mean ratio. This shows that there is a consistency in Gross NPA to Gross advances
ratio or % Gross NPA ratio.
Table-3
Net Profit and Net NPA of selected public sector banks in India from 2017 to 2022
Graphical Representation of Net Profit & Net NPAs of SBI and BOI Banks
2020-21
2019-20
2018-19
2017-18
BOI Net NPA (in Cr.) BOI Net Profit (in Cr.) SBI Net NPA (in Cr.) SBI Net Profit (in Cr.)
Interpretation:
Table-3 shows that the Net Profit (in Cr.) and Net NPA (in Cr.) of 2 public sector banks. Such as SBI and
BOI. The data of BOI Bank indicates that the Net profit and Net NPA are fluctuating over the 5years initially
decreased and increased. But in SBI bank the Net Profit and Net NPA are initially increased then again
decreased and then increased then decreased so on rate over the 5 years. The Mean value of Net profit is
highest in SBI with ₹12177.87 Cr. and Mean value of NPA is highest in BOI Bank i.e., ₹-1796.5 Cr.
TABLE-4
YEAR HDFC BANK ICICI BANK
Net Profit Net NPA Net Profit Net NPA
(in Cr.) (in Cr.) (in Cr.) (in Cr.)
2017-18 17486.75 2601.02 6777.42 27886.27
2018-19 21078.14 3214.52 3363.3 13577.43
2019-20 26257.32 3542.36 7930.81 10113.86
2020-21 31116.53 4554.82 16192.68 9180.2
2021-22 36961.33 4407.68 23339.49 6960.89
MEAN 26580.01 3664.08 11520.74 13543.73
Graphical Representation of Net Profit & Net NPAs of SBI and BOI Banks
2021-22
2020-21
2019-20
2018-19
2017-18
ICICI BANK NET NPA (in Cr.) ICICI BANK NET PROFIT (in Cr.)
HDFC BANK NET NPA (in Cr.) HDFC BANK Net Profit (in Cr.)
Interpretation:
Table-4 shows that the Net Profit (in Cr.) and Net NPA (in Cr.) of 2private sector banks. Such as ICICI Bank
and HDFC Bank. The data of ICICI Bank indicates that the net profit and Net NPA are fluctuate over the
5years.Initially increased then decreased then again increased then again decreased and so on. But in HDFC
bank the Net Profit and Net NPA are increases at increasing rate over the 5 years. The Mean value of Net
profit is highest in HDFC Bank with ₹26580.01 Cr. and Mean value of NPA is highest in ICICI Bank i.e.,
₹11520.74 Cr.
Table-5
Return on Assets (ROA) and Net NPA % of selected public sector banks in India from 2017 to
2022
YEAR Public Sector Banks Private sector Banks
0
ROA% Net NPA% ROA% Net NPA% ROA% Net NPA% ROA% Net NPA%
-2 SBI BOI HDFC BANK ICICI BANK
Public Sector Banks Private sector Banks
Interpretation:
The table-5 shows the data of Return on Assets ROA % and Net NPA % of selected public sector and private
sector banks in India from the year 2017 to 2022.The ROI% of SBI decreased and even negative figure in
the year 2017-18 and Net NPA% are fluctuated over the years. In BOI, initially the NPA% is increased from
the year 2017 to 2018 and then started to decrease. The ROI% of BOI show in negative figures in the year
2017- 18 and 2019-20 and the rest of year it shown positive figures.
Mean value is lowest in SBI as 0286%. HDFC has more ROA% mean value i.e., 1.968% over the year. The
mean value of Net NPA % is more in BOI i.e., 4.688%.
Findings:
Conclusion:
Here, I get the conclusion from this that NPA is a crucial parameter for determining the financial stress of
any Indian bank. NPA is among the main problems facing the banking industry. Although eradicating all
banks NPA is challenging, we should endeavour to do it in some significant measure. Following the
comparison, it was shown that public sector banks, such as Bank of India (BOI) in India, have higher NPA
rates. As a result, BOI's net NPA and net profit have a negative, which has hurt the banks' profitability.
HDFC Bank has a lower NPA% and a higher ROI%. This comparison of a few Indian public and private
sector banks reveals that while eliminating a significant amount of the NPA from banks is challenging, we
should endeavour to do so.
Bank Non-payment. As a result, it is a significant problem for both the government and public sector banks.
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has now been given more authority to take steps against NPA in banks.
Every public sector bank in India needs to pay more attention to its NPA. The bank must enhance both their
credit and repayment structures in order to eliminate NPA. It also emphasizes the strategy for reducing
default risk. The bank must adhere to all governmental credit policies and act swiftly to address NPA. The
bank also made improvements to its NPA management system.
Secondary data provide the foundation of this study. I have just reached a conclusion based on an analysis of
data gathered during the previous five years, from 2017 to 2022. The statistical theory employed is
constrained. The researcher can conduct additional research on this subject by using data from the previous
ten years, other statistical tools, and additional key indicators such as CASA%, ROCE%, Cost of Income%,
etc. and examining their effects on bank NPAs.
References:
Journals:
Prasanth K Reddy. (2002). “A Comparative Study of Indian Troubled Assets in a Global Context –
Similarities and Differences, Remedies”. SSRN Journal Volume 02. Issue 09.
Mrs. Asha Singh. (2013),”Non-Performing Assets (NPAs) Performance in Indian Commercial
Banks,” IJMFSMR Journal, Band No.9.
Murali Krishna. (2014), Comparative assessment of bad assets of Indian banks: A survey of public
and private sector banks. AJRBF Journal. Vol.4, Issue 5.
Kavitha N and Muthu Meenakshi. (2016), “Comparative Study of Non-performing Assets of
Public and Private Banks”, IJMTST Journal, Vol. 2, No. 03.
Dr. Kapil K Dave. (2016), “A comparative study of Non-performing assets in public sector and
private sector banks in India. IJSR Journal. Vol. 5, Issue 8.
Mr. Abid Hussain G. Kadiwala Rasikbai I. Prajapati. (2020), “Comparative Sectorial Analysis of
Non-performing Assets of selected private and public sector banks in India”, IGCRT Journal, Vol.
No. 08, Issue No. 04.
Websites:
1. https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/AnnualPublications.aspx?head=Statistical%20Tables%20Relating%20
to%20Banks%20in%20India
2. https://www.moneycontrol.com/financials/statebankofindia/results/yearly/SBI/2#SBI
3. https://www.moneycontrol.com/financials/bankofindia/results/yearly/BOI
4. https://www.moneycontrol.com/financials/hdfcbank/results/yearly/HDF01
5. https://www.moneycontrol.com/financials/icicibank/results/yearly/ICI02/2#ICI02
6. Annual Report of RBI
7. Annual Report of SBI
8. Annual Report of BOI
9. Annual Report of HDFC Bank
10. Annual Report of ICICI Bank
11. Press Release of SBI Bank
12. Press Release of BOI
13. Press Release of HDFC Bank
14. Press Release of ICICI Bank
15. Reserve Bank of India,’’ Report on trend and Progress of banking in India, Various issues,’’.