Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION

PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
IRIGA CITY POLICE DISTRICT
IRIGA CITY CRIME LABORATORY
Iriga City, Philippines

FIREARMS IDENTIFICATION BRANCH REPORT NO. IRIGACPS 05-2024

CASE: Murder SUSPECT: UNIDENTIFIED
Victim : JOSHUA E. ANDALIS

TIME &DATE RECEIVED : 9:10 AM; MAY 24, 2024

REQUESTING PARTY / UNIT : PO3 ANTHONY B. VELASCO
Investigation, station 2, ICCPO

SPECIMENS SUBMITTED:
1. Four (3) bullets recovered from the body of the victim marked ICC 6/11/24
2. Six (6) Cartridge case recovered from the crime scene marked EAA-2, EAA-3,
EAA-4, EAA-5, EAA-6, EAA-7 5/19/24
3. One (1) caliber 45 recovered from the crime scene marked EAA-1 5/19/24

PURPOSE OF LABORATORY EXAMINATION:

 Determine whether or not the 3 specimens have the congruency of striations or
the same individual characteristics.
 Determine whether or not the 3 specimens were discharge from one firearm.

FINDINGS:
 Preliminary examination of 6 cartridge cases revealed that they have two
firearms use for the different land marks and twist of rifling.
 Microscopic comparison revealed that the specimens 1 which has 5 bullets
possess matching individual characteristics as manifested by the ballistics marks
found in each bullet. The comparison between the specimens 1 and specimen 2,
they found out that cartridge cases marked EAA-2, EAA-3, EAA-4 and the bullets
recovered from the body of the victim has a the same individual characteristics.
The specimen 2, cartridge cases marked EAA-2, EAA-3 EAA-4, EAA-5, EAA 6
and the specimen 3 has a same individual characteristics.

CONCLUSION:
 Specimen 1 and specimen 2 that marked EAA-2, EAA-3, EAA-4, were discharge
in the same firearms with an unidentified gun. The specimen 2 marked EAA-2,
EAA-3, EAA-3 EAA-4 EAA-5and specimen 3 were discharge in the same
firearms. Overall they found out that two firearm was discharge at the crime
scene.

REMARKS:
 Time and date completed – 11:00 AM; MAY 24, 2024
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
IRIGA CITY POLICE DISTRICT
IRIGA CITY CRIME LABORATORY
Iriga City, Philippines

 The three specimens were released to PO3 ANTHONY B. VELASCO on June

10,2024
 A search for the suspect firearms, most probably revolver, must be conducted to
have a basis in establishing the particular gun where the bullets and cartridge
were fired.

EXAMINED BY:
PO1 ROD KENNETH FERMANTE

APPROVED:

P/INSP JHON MARK B. TIBI

NOTED:

CHIEF MC LOWEL OVILIDOR

 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
IRIGA CITY POLICE DISTRICT
IRIGA CITY CRIME LABORATORY
Iriga City, Philippines

DOCUMENTATION IN CRIME LABORATORY

 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
IRIGA CITY POLICE DISTRICT
IRIGA CITY CRIME LABORATORY
Iriga City, Philippines

FIREARMS IDENTIFICATION BRANCH REPORT NO. IRIGACPS 05-2024

CASE: Murder SUSPECT: UNIDENTIFIED
Victim : JOSHUA E. ANDALIS

TIME &DATE RECEIVED : 9:10 AM; MAY 24, 2024

REQUESTING PARTY / UNIT: PO3 ANTHONY B. VELASCO
Investigation, station 2, ICCPO
SPECIMENS SUBMITTED:
1. Four (3) bullets recovered from the body of the victim marked ICC-1,2,3, 6/11/24
2. Six (6) Cartridge case recovered from the crime scene marked EAA-2, EAA-3,
EAA-5, EAA-6, EAA-7, EAA-8 6/11/24
3. One (1) caliber 45 recovered from the crime scene marked EAA-1 6/11/24

PURPOSE OF LABORATORY EXAMINATION:

 Determine the marks or land and twist rifling of the specimens.

FINDINGS:
1. In the examination of empty shell that found in the crime scene.
i. Cartridge case (marked 2 evidence) they found a 1 firing pin mark on the
primer cup at the central area of the base the cartridge. 1 Shearing mark
marks found at the primer near in firing pin mark. 1 extractor marks that
found in extracting grooves. 2 chamber marks found at the body of the
fired cartridge case.
ii. Cartridge case (marked 3 evidence) they found a 1 firing pin mark on the
primer cup at the central area of the base the cartridge.1 shearing marks
found at the primer near in firing pin mark. 1 extractor marks that found in
extracting grooves. 2 chamber marks found at the body of the fired
cartridge case.
iii. Cartridge case (marked 5 evidence) they found a 1 firing pin mark on the
primer cup at the central area of the base the cartridge. 1 extractor marks
that found in extracting grooves. 4 chamber marks found at the body of
the fired cartridge case.
iv. Cartridge case (marked 6 evidence) they found a 1 firing pin mark on the
primer cup at the central area of the base the cartridge. 1 extractor marks
that found in extracting grooves. 4 chamber marks found at the body of
the fired cartridge case.
v. Cartridge case (marked 7 evidence) they found a 1 firing pin mark on the
primer cup at the central area of the base the cartridge. 1 extractor marks
that found in extracting grooves. 4 chamber marks found at the body of
the fired cartridge case.
vi. Cartridge case (marked 8 evidence) they found a 1 firing pin mark on the
primer cup at the central area of the base the cartridge. 1 extractor marks
 Republic of the Philippines
NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
IRIGA CITY POLICE DISTRICT
IRIGA CITY CRIME LABORATORY
Iriga City, Philippines

that found in extracting grooves. 4 chamber marks found at the body of

the fired cartridge case.

2. In the examination of bullets that recovered from the body of the victims.
i. Bullet marked ICC-1 they found a 6 lands and right twist rifling from the
firearms with a caliber 38.
ii. Bullet marked ICC-2 they found a 6 lands and right twist rifling from the
firearms with a caliber 38.
iii. Bullet marked ICC-3 they found a 6 lands and right twist rifling from the
firearms with a caliber 38.

CONCLUSION:
 specimen 2 that marked EAA-2, EAA-3, EAA-4, were discharge in the same
firearms. The specimen 2 marked EAA-2, EAA-3 EAA4 EAA5 EAA6 EAA7 and
specimen 3 were discharge in the same firearms. The specimen 1 marked ICC-
1,2,3 and 4 has the same result.

REMARKS:
 Time and date completed – 11:00 AM; June 10, 2024
 The three specimens were released to PO3 ANTHONY B. VELASCO on JUNE
10,2024
 A search for the suspect firearms, most probably revolver, must be conducted to
have a basis in establishing the particular gun where the bullets and cartridge
were fired.
EXAMINED BY:
PO1 ROD KENNETH FERMANTE

APPROVED:

P/INSP JHON MARK B. TIBI

NOTED:
CHIEF MC LOWEL OVILIDOR