Community Diagnosis
Community Diagnosis
DIAGNOSIS.
BY
CHERUIYOT JOSPHAT K.
(BScN.)
OBJECTIVES.
1. Describe concept and purpose of community
diagnosis.
2. Explain how to plan for community
diagnosis
3. Describe how to develop and pretest tools
for data collection
4. Explain how to execute a survey
5. State how to write and disseminate a
community diagnosis report and plan
community action.
CONCEPT AND PURPOSE
OF COMMUNITY
DIAGNOSIS.
OBJECTIVES.
▣ Describe the concept of community diagnosis
▣ Explain the difference between patient and
community diagnosis
▣ Explain the purpose of community diagnosis
▣ Describe the terminologies used in community
diagnosis.
Community diagnosis.
▣ A process through which health workers and
community members identify community’s
priority health problem, and together make
plan of action and implement them.
▣ A community’s full participation depends on
the concept of PHC or the 4As:
1) Acceptability
2) Accessibility
3) Affordability
4) Availability.
▣ Community have the ability to help themselves
if they are given facilitation or guidance
▣ Community want to be independent and self
reliance
▣ Community cherish and for what they have
acquired through a struggle.
▣ Such involvement empowers individuals and
make them resourceful and self reliant.
▣ Community diagnosis therefore stresses that the
community must identify its problem, prioritize
them, and draw a plan to resolve the problems.
PATIENT DIAGNOSIS VERSUS
COMMUNITY DIAGNOSIS.
Steps in making patient diagnosis.
1. Collecting information or history taking
2. Planning a program diagnosis
3. Implementing or treatment.
4. Follow up and evaluation.
Steps for community
diagnosis.
▣ Same as patient diagnosis except the amount
of data is much greater and requires more
lengthy analysis and processing.
▣ You collect information about:
1. Local people and their environment
2. Number of people and their distribution
3. The diseases the local people suffer from
4. The organization of local health services.
Tools used for patient
dignosis.
▣ Sphygmomanometer
▣ Stethoscope
▣ Weighing scale
▣ Thermometer
▣ Chairs
▣ Record books
Tools used in community
diagnosis
▣ Maps
▣ Weighing scale
▣ Specimen bottles
▣ questionnaires
Purpose of community
diagnosis is to collect the
following.
▣ Demographic data plus all the vital health statistics
▣ Utilization of health services especially of
maternal and child health clinics
▣ The causes of morbidity and mortality
▣ State of nutrition, diet, weaning patterns and the
growth of preschool and school-going children.
▣ Pattern of leadership and communication within
the community.
▣ State of the environment including water, housing,
and disease vector.
Assignment.
▣ Read and make notes on the following
terminologies.
1. Community health
2. Prevalence
3. Infant mortality
4. Crude birth rate
5. Crude death rate
6. Rate of natural increase
7. Dependency ratio.
8. Indicators
9. variables
Ethical consideration.
▣ Consider the following:
1. Obtaining permission to enter into
community boundaries
2. Obtain informed consent before interviewing
patient
3. Establish rapport before exploring sensitive
areas
4. Ensure confidentiality
5. Select good interviewers
6. Train interviewers.
PLANNING A COMMUNITY
DIAGNOSIS.
OBJECTIVES.
▣ Describe the process of community diagnosis
▣ Explain how to conduct initial exploration and
Interaction with the community
▣ Explain how to plan a community diagnosis
survey
▣ Describe how to select a representative sample
for the survey
The process of community
diagnosis.
▣ Requires careful planning.
▣ Is made up of the following:
1. Exploration
2. Planning of the survey
3. Developing and pretesting survey tool
4. Execution of the survey and data analysis
5. Report writing, dissemination, and
community action.
EXPLORING THE COMMUNITY/
INVENTORY.
▣ Means mapping out of a community in order
to learn or discover about it.
▣ Exploration phase is made up of:
1. Seeking permission and informing the various
leaders
2. Seeking reactions of members of community
3. Gathering background data about the
community.
▣ All the above place at the same time.
Seeking permission and
information authorities in the
community.
▣ Channel the request through official hierarchy
of administration in that community:
1. Health personnel e.g. MOH in charge
2. Government official e.g. chiefs, D.O.s
3. Community leaders e.g. Village health
committee
▣ Approach these people, introduce yourself,
and clearly state the objective of the survey
and your plan of action.
Gathering the background
data.
▣ Can be gathered during the initial phase from
e.g. MOH incharge will give you an overview
the health profile of the district, district
commissioner will give you boundaries, the
population, and maps of areas e.t.c.
▣ You can get other information by looking at
other government reports regarding climate,
weather conditions, water sources, and the
road network.
▣ The older people of the community can also be
used to get a lot of information.
Gather information by:
▣ Questioning
▣ Observing
▣ Smelling
▣ Listening.
Planning the survey.
▣ Attempt to answer the following question
1. Why is the study being done?
2. Where will it take place?
3. Who will be interviewed?
4. when will the survey take place?
5. What will be covered in the survey?
▣ Some specific area the survey addresses include:
1. Screening people for diseases
2. Seeking to understand and identify ways of getting
rid of negative cultural beliefs and practices
3. Assessing the utilization of available health services.
Other questions that is
addressed by survey:
▣ Why certain variables included and others left
out?
▣ What instruments will be used to measure the
community’s health status?
▣ How will data be collected and with what
resources?
▣ How do we select and train the official
interviewers?
Qualities of interviewers to be
trained.
1. Be literate and well known to the community
2. Have the ability to display the right attitude and
opinions
3. Be able to explain the questionnaire effectively to
the community.
4. Be able to use the tools in your package
5. Be able to establish good rapport with individuals,
families, or groups they will meet.
6. Be good listeners and sensitive towards other
peoples' feelings
7. Be able to relate well to the community members.
WHEN TRAINING
INTEWRVIEWRS EXPLAIN THE
FOLLOWING:
▣ Purpose of the survey
▣ The method to record the various expressions
used by people to answer particular question.
▣ The procedure they should follow to get
cooperation from the people being surveyed.
▣ Hold mock interviews with interviewers so
that you can ensure that each one of them can
handle the assignment.
Interviewers should:
1. Establish rapport by greeting and introducing
themselves.
2. Explain carefully why they have come and what
is the purpose of the survey
3. Ask if they are welcomed to interview the family
and if it is convenient at that time.
4. Explain that they will be recording the
information they collect.
5. Emphasize that all information collectected is
confidential
6. Give them a chance to ask questions for
clarification.
Sampling for a survey.
▣ Is a process of selecting a number of
individuals or units of study population in
such a way that the individuals selected
represent the larger group from which they are
selected.
▣ when sampling give equal chance for each
person of the population to be included in the
sample.
Study population.
▣ Entire group of individuals, events or objects
that have common observable characteristics.
▣ Can be divided into two main groups:
1. Accessible population- a group of individuals,
objective and events with characteristics
comparable to the large population and
relevant to the study.
2. The representative sample- group from the
study population, which has all the
important/ relevant characteristics of the total
population.
SAMPLING METHODS.
▣ Have been grouped in to two main techniques:
1. Probability sampling- looks at entire group of
individuals, events or objects that have common
observable characteristics. Accurate for a large
study population.
▣ Commonly used methods are:
a) Simple random sampling
b) Systematic sampling
c) Stratified sampling
d) Cluster sampling
e) Multi-stage sampling.it involves all the other
method of propability sampling
2. Non probability sampling
methods.
▣ Used when researcher is not interested in
selecting a sample that is representative of the
population.
▣ Mainly used in qualitative studies where the
focus is on in-depth information rather making
generalization.
▣ Techniques are:
1. Convenient sampling
2. Quota sampling
3. Purposive sampling.
Assignment.
▣ Read and make notes on:
1. Bias
2. Sampling errors.
DEVELOPING
AND
PRETESTING
TOOL FOR DATA
COLLECTION.
OBJECTIVES.
1. NAME TOOLS USED IN DOING
COMMUNITY DIAGNOSIS
2. EXPLAIN HOW TO DEVELOP A
QUESTIONAIRE
3. DESCRIBE HOE TO ORGANIZE A FOCUS
GROUP DISCUSSION
4. DESCRIBE HOW TO PRETEST THE
SURVEY INSTRUMENT.
TOOLS USED TO MEASURE
COMMUNITY HEALTH
PROBLEM.
1. Questionnaire
2. Focus discussion group
3. Measurements, physical examination,
laboratory test
4. Key informant interviews.
▣ Recruit participants
▣ Encourage the group to speak more
freely without fear of those
perceived to be superior.
▣ Participants should have prior
knowledge that they can come
prepared.
2. Physical arrangement.
▣ Make sitting arrangement that make
participants see each other.
▣ Circular sitting is the best.
▣ Room well lit, and ventilated and has a
minimum or no disturbance so that the
participants can concentrate on the discussion.
▣ Environment should encourage/promote
talking and sharing.
3. Preparing and discussion
guide.
▣ Prepare a set of question that will help guide
discussion.
▣ Questions should allow free flow from one aspect
of the topic to the next in a relevant fashion.
▣ Helps participant logically and build out topic you
are investigating.
▣ Have a mixture of general and specific questions.
▣ Have a variety of follow up “probe” for each of
your questions whenever you need clarification.
4. The discussion.
Note.
-the respondent has the right to refuse to
participate in an interview/experiment/
medication.
Reasons for refusal to
participate.
1. If people were not informed of the
survey, its objective, and when it
would be performed.
2. If for some reasons the person to
be interviewed is temporarily
away from home.
3. Lack of interest in co-operating or
active opposition to the survey.
STAGE TWO: DATA
COLLECTION
▣ Use Pencil When Filling Out
Forms.
▣ Do not erase a wrong response.
▣ If mistake is made, cross it out and
mark the correct response above it.
▣ Fill response at the time they are
given.
▣ Ensure you have all tools required e.
g. anthropometric measurements
tools and laboratory specimen
containers.
▣ Handle specimen collected correctly.
▣ Fill all forms and recheck to avoid
mistakes and to be sure that all
relevant information is satisfactorily
filled in the appropriate space
provided.
▣ Ensure safety storage of specimen.
▣ At the end of the day, all forms be
checked thoroughly by someone other
than the interviewer.
▣ You may need to begin tallying results
at the stage so that when the analysis
begins all you have to do is add up the
tallies instead of going through all the
forms since the first interview
▣ During Data collection, it is very
important to ensure that there is quality
control so that you do not end up with
false or misleading conclusion.
TO ENSURE QUALITY DATA
YOU SHOULD.
1. Avoid bias when designing the
questionnaire
2. Provide an institution sheet on how to
ask certain questions and how to
record answers.
3. Select interviewers with care.
4. Select and train the assistants carefully
in all the procedures together with
interviewers.
5. Involve them in the pre-testing
phase.
6. Limit the number of interviews
that interviewers can conduct in
a day so that they do not
become too exhausted.
7. Identify assistant to carry out
quality checks everyday.
Check data for completeness
and organise it for analysis
1. Qualitative analysis
2. Quantitative analysis
a) Qualitative analysis