Chap 2 RRL
Chap 2 RRL
The extraction and processing of non-renewable resources, particularly for insulation materials,
poses significant environmental challenges. This includes habitat destruction and increased greenhouse gas
emissions associated with fossil fuel energy sources. The production of synthetic insulation materials often
involves the use of harmful blowing agents, which release potent greenhouse gases. Additionally, improper
disposal practices and limited recycling options exacerbate waste management issues. To mitigate these
impacts, the industry must prioritize sustainable sourcing, energy-efficient manufacturing processes, and
enhanced recycling initiatives. Transitioning to eco-friendly insulation can yield substantial benefits across
various sectors, including construction and cold chain logistics, by improving energy efficiency and reducing
operational costs.
In the construction sector, adopting eco-friendly insulation materials leads to lower energy
consumption due to reduced heat transfer and air leakage. This not only results in cost savings on energy bills
but also contributes to a lower environmental footprint. High-performance insulation enhances thermal comfort
and indoor air quality while minimizing noise transmission, thereby creating healthier living and working
environments. Furthermore, these materials' durability supports longer-lasting buildings, reducing maintenance
needs and waste generation. As a result, construction projects can align with sustainability certifications and
meet growing market demands for environmentally responsible practices.
Aerogel has emerged as a groundbreaking insulation material due to its exceptional properties,
including low thermal conductivity and lightweight structure. Its nanoporous design minimizes heat transfer
while being versatile enough for various applications in the construction, aerospace, and automotive industries.
Aerogel's moisture resistance and fireproof qualities further enhance its appeal as a sustainable option. As global
trends increasingly prioritize sustainability, energy efficiency, and health-conscious building practices, aerogel
stands out as a leading solution that meets these demands while supporting the transition towards net-zero
economies. Businesses can also adopt green policies that improve their financial performance through energy
efficiency improvements, waste reduction strategies, and sustainable supply chain practices.
https://biopharmaapac.com/opinion/25/3186/insulations-environmental-impact-a-call-for-sustainable-
innovation.html
Natarajan, G. et al., (2023)
The building industry faces increasing scrutiny regarding its environmental impact,
particularly concerning insulation materials. Currently, plastic-based insulation, such as expanded and extruded
polystyrene, is the most widely used option due to its affordability and effective thermal properties. However,
the production of these materials is highly energy-intensive, requiring about 39.75 MJ per kilogram, which is
significantly more than the energy needed for producing iron or glass. Additionally, plastic insulation
contributes to substantial carbon emissions, approximately 3.4 kg CO2 equivalent per kilogram produced.
While inorganic options like fiberglass and stone wool are less common, they also have high energy demands
and generate notable emissions, making them less favorable in terms of insulation performance and cost.
The carbon emissions associated with insulation materials largely originate from the energy
sources used during their manufacturing processes, particularly in heating and melting. Historically, insulation
manufacturers relied on chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) and hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) as blowing
agents, but due to their negative impact on ozone depletion and global warming, regulations have restricted their
use. Currently, there are also growing restrictions on hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) blowing agents in various
countries. In response, manufacturers are exploring alternative blowing agents with lower global warming
potential (GWP), such as hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs), carbon dioxide, butane, and pentane, which could further
reduce carbon emissions in the future.
The emissions linked to insulation manufacturing are also influenced by the energy mix
utilized by manufacturers. Many still depend on fossil fuels like coal for high-temperature processes, which can
reach around 1500°C. Transitioning to electricity and incorporating renewable energy sources on-site could
significantly lower these emissions. Companies like Knauf are investigating the use of biogas and hydrogen to
reduce their carbon footprints over the next two decades. Similarly, Rockwool has made strides by using
entirely electric energy in its new factory in Qingyuan, China, and has switched from coal to natural gas in its
Mississippi facility.
As the building industry continues to seek sustainable solutions, the focus is shifting
towards reducing carbon emissions associated with insulation materials. This includes not only the development
of low-GWP blowing agents but also a broader transition to renewable energy sources for manufacturing
processes. The ongoing efforts by companies to adopt cleaner technologies reflect a commitment to minimizing
environmental impacts while meeting regulatory demands. As sustainability becomes increasingly critical in
construction and manufacturing, these innovations are essential for aligning with global climate goals and
enhancing the overall environmental performance of insulation materials.
https://oneclicklca.com/en/resources/articles/ecodesign-in-practice-insulation-whole-life-carbon#:~:text=The
%20carbon%20emissions%20associated%20with,particularly%20in%20the%20heating%20or
Tsikos, M. (2024)
The extraction and processing of non-renewable resources, particularly for insulation materials,
poses significant environmental challenges. This includes habitat destruction and increased greenhouse gas
emissions associated with fossil fuel energy sources. The production of synthetic insulation materials often
involves the use of harmful blowing agents, which release potent greenhouse gases. Additionally, improper
disposal practices and limited recycling options exacerbate waste management issues. To mitigate these
impacts, the industry must prioritize sustainable sourcing, energy-efficient manufacturing processes, and
enhanced recycling initiatives. Transitioning to eco-friendly insulation can yield substantial benefits across
various sectors, including construction and cold chain logistics, by improving energy efficiency and reducing
operational costs.
In the construction sector, adopting eco-friendly insulation materials leads to lower energy
consumption due to reduced heat transfer and air leakage. This not only results in cost savings on energy bills
but also contributes to a lower environmental footprint. High-performance insulation enhances thermal comfort
and indoor air quality while minimizing noise transmission, thereby creating healthier living and working
environments. Furthermore, these materials' durability supports longer-lasting buildings, reducing maintenance
needs and waste generation. As a result, construction projects can align with sustainability certifications and
meet growing market demands for environmentally responsible practices.
Aerogel has emerged as a groundbreaking insulation material due to its exceptional properties,
including low thermal conductivity and lightweight structure. Its nanoporous design minimizes heat transfer
while being versatile enough for various applications in the construction, aerospace, and automotive industries.
Aerogel's moisture resistance and fireproof qualities further enhance its appeal as a sustainable option. As global
trends increasingly prioritize sustainability, energy efficiency, and health-conscious building practices, aerogel
stands out as a leading solution that meets these demands while supporting the transition towards net-zero
economies. Businesses can also adopt green policies that improve their financial performance through energy
efficiency improvements, waste reduction strategies, and sustainable supply chain practices.
https://biopharmaapac.com/opinion/25/3186/insulations-environmental-impact-a-call-for-sustainable-
innovation.html
Soghrati, E. et al., (2023)
The benefits of eco-friendly insulation extend beyond environmental considerations; they also
enhance energy efficiency in various sectors such as construction and cold chain logistics. By utilizing materials
with high thermal resistance, businesses can significantly reduce energy consumption for heating and cooling,
leading to lower operational costs and improved indoor comfort. In construction, these materials not only
contribute to sustainability certifications but also help create healthier living environments by improving air
quality and reducing noise transmission. Furthermore, innovative insulation materials like aerogel present
opportunities for enhanced performance due to their lightweight nature and exceptional thermal properties,
making them suitable for diverse applications across industries.
As global trends push towards sustainability and energy efficiency, the insulation sector is
adapting to meet these demands through innovative practices and technologies. Companies are encouraged to
implement green policies that not only support environmental goals but also result in cost savings. Strategies
such as improving energy efficiency, optimizing supply chains for sustainability, and engaging employees in
eco-friendly initiatives can lead to significant operational benefits. Additionally, government incentives can
further facilitate the transition towards greener practices. By integrating sustainability into core business
strategies, companies can enhance their competitiveness while contributing positively to the environment amid
growing concerns about climate change and resource depletion.
https://ds-a.co.uk/the-benefits-of-sustainable-insulation-for-uk-homes-commercial-properties-and-new-builds/
#:~:text=Many%20traditional%20insulation%20materials%2C%20such,energy%20consumption%20as
%20newer%20alternatives.
Despite its environmental challenges, fiberglass offers several benefits. It is made from
abundant raw materials like silica sand and provides excellent thermal insulation properties, which can help
reduce energy consumption in buildings. Additionally, fiberglass is lightweight, facilitating easier transport and
installation. However, its non-biodegradable nature poses disposal challenges at the end of its life cycle. While
some claims suggest that fiberglass can be recycled, the reality is complex due to the petrochemical resins used
in its composition, which are not biodegradable.
To mitigate the environmental impact of fiberglass, proper recycling and disposal methods
are essential. Innovations in recycling technologies could enhance material recovery and reduce waste.
Furthermore, the industry is increasingly focusing on sustainability practices to lower the carbon footprint
associated with fiberglass production. By improving manufacturing processes and investing in recycling
infrastructure, it is possible to balance the positive attributes of fiberglass with its environmental drawbacks.
https://www.greenmatch.co.uk/blog/fibreglass-environmental-impact#:~:text=This%20process%20is%20energy
%2Dintensive,substantial%20amounts%20of%20fossil%20fuels.
Ukpanah, I. (2024)
Non-Cost-Effective
Air leakage through a home's envelope, which includes the outer walls, windows, and doors,
can lead to significant energy waste and increased utility costs. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
estimates that homeowners can save an average of 15% on heating and cooling expenses by properly sealing air
leaks and adding insulation, particularly in attics, crawl spaces, and basements. Insulation not only enhances
energy efficiency but also contributes to overall comfort by maintaining stable indoor temperatures throughout
the year. Proper insulation installation can help mitigate common issues such as external noise intrusion,
humidity control, and the risk of ice dams in colder climates.
Most homes in the United States are under-insulated and suffer from considerable air leaks,
with approximately 90% lacking sufficient insulation. Addressing these issues through air sealing and insulation
upgrades is one of the most cost-effective methods to improve energy efficiency and comfort. By implementing
both strategies, homeowners can maximize their comfort levels while potentially saving up to 10% on their
annual energy bills. This dual approach not only reduces energy consumption but also enhances the overall
living environment by creating a more controlled and pleasant atmosphere.
The benefits of improved insulation extend beyond energy savings; they also contribute to
better indoor air quality by reducing the entry of pollen, dust, and pests. Furthermore, effective insulation helps
maintain consistent humidity levels within the home. Given that many homes have numerous leaks equivalent
to keeping a window open year-round, sealing these gaps is crucial for optimizing energy use. Ultimately,
investing in proper insulation and sealing techniques can lead to substantial long-term savings on utility bills
while enhancing the comfort and health of living spaces.
https://www.energystar.gov/saveathome/seal_insulate/why-seal-and-insulate#:~:text=Air%20that%20leaks
%20through%20your,and%20increases%20your%20utility%20costs.
The concept of diminishing returns highlights that while investing in insulation can lead to
long-term savings on energy bills, there is a point where further insulation becomes superfluous and financially
wasteful. Homeowners should focus on achieving adequate insulation levels rather than excessive amounts.
Proper insulation not only improves energy efficiency but also contributes positively to environmental
sustainability by reducing overall energy consumption. However, over-insulating can negate these benefits by
consuming resources without providing a proportional environmental offset.
While proper insulation has numerous advantages, including reduced energy costs and
improved indoor comfort, over-insulation can diminish these gains. The production of insulation materials
involves energy use and potential greenhouse gas emissions, which must be considered in the context of
environmental impact. Homeowners are encouraged to use environmentally friendly materials and practices to
maximize the positive effects of insulation while minimizing negative consequences. Ultimately, achieving the
right amount of insulation is crucial for balancing comfort, cost-effectiveness, and environmental responsibility
in home energy management.
https://reenergizeco.com/too-much-insulation/
The choice of insulation material significantly affects overall costs. For example,
fiberglass insulation is one of the most affordable options, costing between $0.30 and $1.50 per square foot,
while wood fiber insulation can be much pricier, ranging from $4.25 to $6.75 per square foot due to its
sustainable sourcing and higher R-value efficiency. Other materials like cellulose, polystyrene, mineral wool,
and their respective costs vary based on their thermal resistance and installation complexities. Additionally, the
square footage of the area to be insulated directly correlates with total expenses, making it essential for
homeowners to consider both material and area size when budgeting.
Labor and site preparation also contribute significantly to insulation costs. Labor rates
typically range from $40 to $80 per hour, with more complex installations increasing overall expenses. Site
preparation may involve additional costs for repairs or mold removal, which can add up to $900 depending on
the extent of work needed. Furthermore, insulating existing homes tends to be more expensive than new
constructions due to accessibility issues and potential disposal fees for old insulation materials. By factoring in
all these considerations—material choice, location within the home, labor complexity, and site prep—
homeowners can better navigate the costs associated with insulation installation.
https://www.angi.com/articles/how-much-does-insulation-cost.htm#:~:text=Most%20of%20your%20insulation
%20expenses,%2C%20site%20prep%2C%20and%20labor
Simms, D. (2024)
The “Illustrated Guide to Insulation Materials” serves as a resource for architects and
designers to make informed choices about insulation based on their GWP and other environmental indicators.
The guide analyzes various thermal insulation materials, emphasizing the importance of considering their entire
life cycle, from manufacturing emissions to end-of-life impacts. By focusing on materials with lower embodied
carbon, such as natural and recycled options, the construction industry can significantly reduce its overall
carbon footprint. This approach aligns with broader goals of achieving net-zero emissions in building operations
and materials.
In addition to material selection, thermal performance plays a critical role in the effectiveness
of insulation in reducing heat loss across various building components, including walls, roofs, and floors. The
choice of insulation material must consider local climate conditions and regulatory requirements to ensure
optimal thermal comfort. Furthermore, the study underscores the need for awareness regarding the health
impacts of certain building materials, advocating for healthier alternatives that minimize harmful emissions
indoors. By integrating these considerations into design practices, architects can contribute to creating buildings
that are not only energy-efficient but also promote occupant well-being and environmental sustainability.
https://2050-materials.com/blog/thermal-insulation-choosing-healthy-and-low-carbon-materials/
The extraction and processing of non-renewable resources for insulation, such as minerals,
pose significant environmental challenges, including habitat destruction and increased greenhouse gas
emissions. Additionally, the production of synthetic insulation materials often involves energy-intensive
processes and the use of harmful blowing agents that contribute to climate change. Improper disposal and
limited recycling options for these materials further exacerbate waste management issues. To mitigate these
problems, the industry must focus on sustainable sourcing, energy-efficient manufacturing practices, and
enhanced recycling initiatives.
The construction and built environment sector within the European Union contributes
significantly to greenhouse gas emissions, accounting for approximately 5-12% of total emissions related to
material extraction and product manufacturing. Research indicates that adopting more efficient materials could
potentially reduce CO2 emissions by up to 80%. Sustainable building practices extend beyond mere insulation
improvements; they also encompass the embodied energy of materials, emphasizing the importance of utilizing
alternative resources such as recycled and plant-based materials. However, a notable gap exists in integrated
management strategies across sectors, particularly concerning non-traditional materials, highlighting the need
for the construction industry to explore new materials and supply chains.
This chapter focuses on insulating products derived from plant-based and recycled materials,
providing a comparative analysis of their thermal performance alongside a SWOT analysis. By encouraging the
construction sector to experiment with innovative materials, there is potential for substantial advancements in
sustainability. The study also proposes a practical application scenario specifically for school buildings in Italy,
which constitute a significant portion of the existing building stock. Implementing these sustainable practices in
educational facilities can have a considerable impact on achieving the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
by 2030.
The exploration of eco-friendly insulation options aligns with broader trends towards
sustainability and environmental responsibility in construction. By prioritizing materials that reduce carbon
footprints and enhance energy efficiency, the industry can contribute to climate change mitigation while also
improving indoor environmental quality. As awareness grows around the benefits of using recycled and plant-
origin materials, there is an increasing opportunity for the construction sector to lead in sustainable practices,
ultimately fostering a healthier built environment.
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-031-24942-6_17
Cucchiella, F. et al., (2023)
If space above the ceiling is limited or if the roof needs replacement, continuous exterior
insulation can be applied instead. This method utilizes rigid insulation materials, such as polyisocyanurate
(poly-iso), which offer a higher R-value per inch (around 6.5) and eliminate thermal breaks caused by wood
framing. Insulating the walls of a rowhouse can be more complex due to narrow spaces, but using batt
insulation made from materials like Roxul—recycled stone and rock—can enhance soundproofing and fire
resistance while achieving an R-value of about 4 per inch. This approach helps maintain indoor comfort and
reduces energy consumption.
In addition to insulating walls and roofs, insulating under the house is essential for preventing
heat loss to the ground. The best opportunity for this is during concrete slab installation when rigid under-slab
insulation can be added. However, air sealing is equally important; without it, insulation cannot perform
effectively. Homeowners should look for drafts around doors, windows, and outlets and use caulk or
weatherstripping to seal these gaps. For larger projects, advanced air-sealing products that allow moisture
control while blocking airflow can further enhance energy efficiency. By focusing on these strategies, rowhouse
owners can significantly improve their home's energy performance while contributing to sustainability efforts in
urban environments.
https://www.buckminstergreen.com/rowhouse-remodeling/2024/5/16/rowhouse-insulation
When selecting an insulation product, it is crucial to recognize that no single type of
insulation is inherently superior; rather, all insulation performs comparably when properly installed and air
sealed. The primary goal should be to maximize the R-value per dollar spent, as all materials with the same R-
value will provide equal thermal performance. Factors such as air filtration, product settling, UV stability, and
sound insulation capabilities also play significant roles in determining the best insulation choice. For instance,
fiberglass and mineral wool insulations maintain their R-values over time and are UV stable, while spray foam
can degrade with UV exposure.
Health impacts and moisture management are also vital considerations in insulation selection.
Fiberglass and mineral wool are not classified as carcinogens by major health organizations, while spray foam
contains isocyanates that can trigger asthma and other health issues. Furthermore, fiberglass and mineral wool
do not absorb moisture or promote mold growth, unlike cellulose insulation, which can retain significant
moisture levels. Lastly, sustainability is a key factor; fiberglass often contains recycled content, whereas spray
foam lacks significant recyclability. By weighing these various factors—thermal performance, sound insulation,
fire safety, health impacts, moisture resistance, and sustainability—homeowners can make informed decisions
that align with their energy efficiency goals and environmental values.
https://insulationinstitute.org/im-a-building-or-facility-professional/commercial/comparing-insulation-types/
This thesis investigates energy efficiency in space heating for new single-family detached
homes in Regina, Saskatchewan, and Vancouver, British Columbia. It is premised on the notion that the current
energy efficiency of new housing is inadequate, particularly given the long lifespan of these buildings and the
uncertainty surrounding future energy supplies. The study examines the interactions between housing
consumers, builders, and government regulations to identify barriers to achieving higher energy efficiency.
Interviews with seventeen builders, architects, and building inspectors provide insights into the challenges faced
in enhancing energy performance in residential construction.
The thesis outlines Canada's energy context and emphasizes the need for improved energy
conservation measures. It reviews government initiatives aimed at promoting energy efficiency in new housing
and discusses various techniques available to builders for enhancing the energy efficiency of building
envelopes. The economic aspects of residential energy conservation are also explored, including cost-
effectiveness analyses that highlight the financial constraints limiting investments in energy-efficient
technologies. The study reveals that without stringent government regulations on energy efficiency standards,
builders tend to construct homes based on consumer preferences influenced by factors such as energy prices and
climate conditions.
The findings indicate significant regional variations, with Regina exhibiting a stronger
consumer demand for energy-efficient practices due to a harsher climate and more active government
participation compared to Vancouver. The research identifies several market inadequacies and obstacles,
including a lack of recognition for energy-saving features in resale markets and insufficient information
available to both builders and consumers regarding energy-efficient techniques. Ultimately, the thesis argues for
comprehensive government intervention to address these issues, enhance residential energy efficiency, and
protect the economic interests of future homeowners while contributing to broader social welfare goals related
to resource conservation.
https://open.library.ubc.ca/soa/cIRcle/collections/831/831/items/1.0095122
Weidner, H. (1981)
In hot climates, inadequate insulation can lead to higher indoor temperatures than those
experienced outside, resulting in thermal stress that negatively impacts health. Many homeowners resort to air
conditioning to cope with extreme heat, which can be costly—sometimes reaching $25 per day in remote areas
during summer. A project aimed at modifying existing houses across various climates seeks to reduce reliance
on active heating and cooling systems by improving passive design elements. This approach focuses on keeping
homes cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter, thereby minimizing the number of days air conditioning
is necessary.
Several factors contribute to homes being excessively hot, particularly poor orientation, lack
of insulation, and inadequate shading or ventilation. For instance, many houses lack sufficient wall and roof
insulation, while others do not have adequate roof eaves or verandahs to block direct sunlight. Additionally,
insufficient ventilation and a lack of shade or windbreaks exacerbate the problem. In some surveyed areas, a
significant percentage of homes had no cooling systems installed, highlighting the challenges faced by residents
in managing indoor temperatures effectively.
To address these issues, passive heating and cooling strategies can be employed, which do
not rely on mechanical systems. These strategies include proper building orientation to protect from summer
sun while allowing winter sunlight to warm interiors, as well as incorporating thermal mass materials that store
heat during the day and release it at night. By focusing on passive design principles, homeowners can
significantly enhance their comfort while reducing energy consumption and costs associated with active heating
and cooling systems.
https://www.healthabitat.com/research-development/temperature-control-inside-the-house-cool-houses-in-hot-
climates/
The quality of housing significantly impacts public health, particularly for individuals living
in substandard conditions. Research indicates that improvements to housing, such as insulation, could
potentially prevent health issues, especially in vulnerable populations. Despite the known benefits, there is a
notable lack of studies that draw causal inferences regarding the relationship between housing quality and
health outcomes. A cluster randomized trial was conducted to assess the effects of insulating existing houses in
low-income communities, aiming to enhance indoor environments and provide evidence for public policy
formulation.
The study highlights that poorly constructed and older homes are often difficult and costly to
heat, leading to inadequate warmth that can adversely affect occupants' health. Cold and damp living conditions
are linked to increased physiological stress, particularly for older adults, infants, and individuals with pre-
existing health conditions. The research emphasizes that insufficient heating not only contributes to discomfort
but can also result in higher energy expenditures, which detracts from funds available for other essential needs
like food. Furthermore, cold homes are often associated with dampness and mold growth, which can exacerbate
respiratory issues.
Findings from the insulation study revealed significant health improvements among
occupants of insulated homes compared to those in uninsulated houses. Insulation led to warmer indoor
temperatures and reduced humidity levels, which correlated with lower instances of respiratory symptoms and
fewer visits to healthcare providers. Participants reported improved self-rated health and reduced days off work
or school due to illness. The results underscore the potential of housing interventions, particularly insulation
retrofitting, as cost-effective strategies for enhancing health and well-being while addressing broader social
inequalities related to housing quality.
https://www.bmj.com/content/334/7591/460.short
Matheson, A. et al., (2007)
The Philippine residential building sector is experiencing significant growth due to the
country's dynamic economy and the increasing demand for improved living conditions. This paper aims to
evaluate the sector's contributions to construction, energy consumption, and the technologies used in
households. It highlights that detached houses dominate residential construction, with a wide range of designs
and sizes reflecting the diverse income levels across the population. The prevalent use of glass and concrete in
building materials affects indoor thermal environments, while various energy sources are utilized based on
economic factors.
As the economy and standard of living rise, energy consumption in households is expected
to increase, prompting a search for new energy sources and technologies to mitigate this growth. The study
emphasizes the necessity for innovative solutions to reduce energy consumption in residential buildings. Patents
and research findings presented in the paper suggest potential advancements in building technologies that could
enhance energy efficiency and reduce reliance on traditional energy sources. These developments are crucial for
addressing the challenges posed by rising energy demands.
In conclusion, the Philippine residential building sector faces both opportunities and
challenges as it adapts to changing economic conditions. With a focus on improving energy efficiency and
integrating new technologies, there is potential for significant advancements in reducing household energy
consumption. The findings underscore the importance of developing sustainable building practices that not only
meet the growing demand for housing but also promote environmental responsibility and economic viability
within the sector.
https://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/ben/eng/2017/00000011/00000001/art00009
Enteria, N. et al., (2017)