Dissertation Synopsis 2
Dissertation Synopsis 2
Chitraksh Mahajan
(500071415, R730218113)
HYPOTHESIS
In the current situation, everyone is attempting to acquire an advantage by
any means possible. Not only in sports, but in life as a whole, few individu-
als will refuse an opportunity to gain an unjust advantage for their own
benefit. As doping constitutes cheating, this unjust advantage in sports can
lead to a variety of disputes between countries and athletes. For an athlete
to contend at a high level, years of effort and sacrifice are necessary. The
athlete's hopes, ambitions, and sense of self-worth are dashed when he or
she loses to an enhanced athlete who does not face any consequences.
Therefore, the hypothesis for the purpose of this study is that lack of or in-
sufficient awareness among athletes and the absence of stringent doping
laws are the primary reasons why athletes commit doping violations.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
Why are doping offences increasing daily?
What laws currently regulate drug, and what else needs to be done?
The proliferation of e-doping in e-sports
LITERATURE REVIEW
➢ “Scientific, Philosophical and legal considerations of doping in
sports” by Massimo Nergo, Natale Marzullo and Giuseppe D Antona1
CONSIDERATION IS GIVEN TO THE SUBJECT OF WHETHER
OR NOT AN ATHLETE SHOULD BE PERMITTED TO DO
WHATEVER HE DESIRES TO IMPROVE HIS PERFORMANCE.
DOPING AFFECTS NOT ONLY HEALTH, BUT ALSO THE ETHICS
OF SPORTS, AND IT IS EMPHASISED THAT THIS
CONTRADICTION AND PARADOX SHOULD BE GIVEN
PHILOSOPHICAL CONTEMPLATION. IN SPORTS,
CONSIDERATION MUST BE GIVEN NOT ONLY TO THE USE OF
DRUGS, BUT ALSO TO DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS THAT CAN
1 Nergo, M., Marzullo, N., & D'Antona, G. (2018). Scientific, philosophical and legal considerations of doping in
sports. Journal of Human Sport and Exercise, 13(1), 81-93.
ENHANCE BOTH PHYSICAL AND MENTAL PERFORMANCE.
WHEN ADDRESSING THE ISSUE OF DOPING, SCIENTIFIC,
LEGAL, AND PHILOSOPHICAL CONSIDERATIONS SHOULD BE
TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT. DOPING SHOULD BE VIEWED NOT
ONLY AS A SUBSTANCE THAT CAN NEGATIVELY IMPACT
HEALTH, BUT ALSO AS A COMPLEX ISSUE INVOLVING
SCIENTIFIC, LEGAL, AND PHILOSOPHICAL FACTORS.
2 Murak, J., Slepicka, P., & Slepickova, I. (2017). Sports motivation and doping in adolescent athletes. Journal of
Human Sport and Exercise, 12(2), 459-466.
➢ “Development of doping in sports: Overview and Analysis” by
Francesca Della and Gaetano Raiola3
DOPING IS PREVALENT NOT ONLY AMONG ELITE ATHLETES BUT
ALSO AMONG AMATEUR ATHLETES, IT IS EMPHASISED.
EVERYONE HAS A DESIRE TO SUCCEED, AND IN ORDER TO
ENHANCE THEIR PHYSICAL PERFORMANCE, THEY ENGAGE IN
THESE ILLEGAL, DANGEROUS, AND UNHEALTHY PRACTISES.
ATHLETES SHOULD BE MADE AWARE OF THE HARMFUL
EFFECTS THESE SUBSTANCES CAN HAVE ON THEIR BODIES AND
HEALTH, ACCORDING TO ONE OF THE PROPOSED SOLUTIONS.
THE MINISTRY OF HEALTH SHOULD EMPLOY PREVENTATIVE
MEASURES, AND LABORATORIES SHOULD MAKE EVERY EFFORT
TO IDENTIFY NEW SUBSTANCES.
3 Della Corte, F., & Raiola, G. (2019). Development of doping in sports: Overview and analysis. Journal of Hu-
man Sport and Exercise, 14(1), 1-9.
4 Sharma, S., & Meenon, P. (2019). A comparative study of the application of strict liability principle in sports:
Critiquing anti-doping policies examining illicit crowd chanting and match-fixing. Journal of Legal, Ethical and
Regulatory Issues, 22(1), 1-9.
THIS ISSUE? IT IS EMPHASISED THAT STRICT LIABILITY
PRINCIPLES ARE APPLIED IN CASES OF DOPING AND MATCH-
FIXING, AND THAT VICARIOUS LIABILITY IS APPLIED TO THE
ENTIRE TEAM. THE SOLUTIONS PROPOSED IN THIS PAPER ARE
THAT RIGOROUS LIABILITY SHOULD BE EXAMINED PROPERLY
AND PRECISELY, AND NO ATHLETE SHOULD FACE
CONSEQUENCES AS A RESULT; THEREFORE, THERE SHOULD BE
A PROPER BALANCE OF POWER BETWEEN ATHLETES AND
WADA, AND PROPER VIGILANCE SHOULD BE MAINTAINED IN
SPORTS.
HISTORY OF DOPING
Contrary to popular belief, the use of performance-enhancing drugs to gain an advantage
in competition dates back to the ancient Greek Olympics in the third century BC. Greek
olympic athletes5 were professionals who competed not only for honour but also for siz-
able cash prizes, much like modern-day professional athletes. These monetary prizes
served as incentives for the greek athletes to experiment with a variety of performance-
enhancing drugs. At the time of the Roman Empire, it was legal for athletes to use perfor-
mance-enhancing drugs. Rome's populace was enthralled by sporting events held in the
magnificent Coliseum 6, which can hold up to 50,000 spectators. People paid to watch
chariot races, animal fights, and gladiator battles, with gamblers placing bets on the out-
come.
19th and early 20th century, when modern medicine emerged, many endurance athletes in
swimming, cycling, and long-distance running used special doping recipes to gain a com-
petitive advantage. These recipes included brandy, caffeine, cocaine, and heroin to reduce
fatigue, improve mental focus, suppress hunger, and lessen the pain of physical exertion.
Until the mid-1920s, the Sports Federation deemed the use of these doping recipes ac-
5 A brief history of doping, FIFA.com, May 3 2007 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.fifa.com/who-we-
are/news/amp/brief-history-doping-514062.
6 Mark Cartwright, Roman Games, Chariot Races & Spectacle, World History Encyclopaedia (December 4,
2013, 10:18 AM), https://www.ancient.eu/article/roman-games-chariot-races-spectale.
ceptable. However, after a few prominent athletes nearly perished during competition, the
government moved to restrict drugs. By 1928 the governing body for track and field
called the International Association of Athletes Federation 7 became the first sports Asso-
ciation to prohibit the use of performance enhancing drugs.
In 1919, a Japanese chemist synthesised methamphetamine as a more potent and easier-
to-manufacture version of earlier methamphetamine drugs derived from the Chinese plant
Mao hung. At moderate doses, methamphetamine elevates mood, increases mental focus,
reduces appetite, increases energy, and induces weight loss. At higher doses, the drug can
cause psychosis, seizures, muscle loss, and naturally violent behaviour. The American,
German, British and Japanese militaries thought it would be a good idea to give metham-
phetamine tablets to their soldiers during World War II, the crossover of metham-
phetamine from the military to athletic competition occurred in the 1950s when Italian
and Dutch cyclists began using the drug as a substitute for cocaine to overcome fatigue in
grooming multi stage races unfortunately the first casualty of methamphetamine abuse
during competition came in the 1960s with the death of Tommy Simpson 8 a British Cy-
cling champion who was leader of the British National team during the 1967, Tour de
France Simpson collapsed and died on the 13th stage of the race, the autopsy revealed
that Simpson had methamphetamine in alcoholic stimulants in his system the official
cause of death was heart failure due to exhaustion. Anabolic steroids are naturally occur-
ring antigens, such as testosterone, that increase muscle mass and induce masculine sex
characteristics in both men and women. Anabolic steroids, despite their shady reputation
in the world of sports, play an important role in healthcare, with physicians routinely pre-
scribing them for conditions such as cancer.
Testosterone was first isolated and synthesised from cholesterol in 1935 by a German
chemist named Leopold Ruzicka, who was later awarded the Nobel Prize in chemistry for
his work on sex hormones. During World War II, it was rumoured that the Nazis experi-
mented with testosterone injections in an attempt to create an army of aggressive and
fearless supersoldiers to combat the allies. Early in the 1950s, athletes discovered the ex-
traordinary performance-enhancing effects of anabolic steroids, and for the first time
since World War II, several synthetic derivatives became available. Soviet Union was
suspected of being the first country to experiment with steroids by giving them to their
athletes in the 1952 Olympic Games in Helsinki 9. In an effort to prove the superiority of
the communist system, the Soviets and East Germans administered anabolic steroids to
their athletes as part of a coordinated doping programme, allowing them to dominate
Olympic events such as track and field, weightlifting, wrestling, and swimming. As a
physician for the American weightlifting team, John Ziegler travelled to Vienna in 1954
in quest of explanations for the extraordinary athletic performance of the Soviet team.
Doctor Ziegler shared a few drinks with the Soviet team doctor in a local pub, and when
7 Møller, V., & Kanitscheider, B. (2011). Performance-enhancing substances: History and impact on athletic
performance. In P. H. Seitz, K. B. Kauer & L. P. C. Verstappen (Eds.), Equine sports medicine and science: 5. The
athletic horse (pp. 471-480). Saunders Ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-7020-3429-9.00032-5
8 Petroczi, A., & Nepusz, T. (2011). Methodological considerations regarding doping surveys. Substance abuse
treatment, prevention, and policy, 6(1), 15. https://doi.org/10.1186/1747-597X-6-15
9 Yesalis, C. E., & Bahrke, M. S. (2000). History of doping in sport. In M. S. Bahrke & C. E. Yesalis (Eds.), Perfor-
mance-enhancing substances in sport and exercise (pp. 3-18). Human Kinetics.
he inquired as to what he was giving his athletes, the Soviet doctor casually admitted to
administering testosterone. Doctor Ziegler10 hurried home to America and began experi-
menting with testosterone injections on himself and other members of the US weight lift-
ing team they all gained more muscle mass and strength in less time than any previous
training programme but unfortunately the injections also came with unwanted side effects
determined to find a synthetic anabolic solution with less side effects and testosterone.
Doctor Ziegler collaborated with the Swiss pharmaceutical company Ciba Pharmaceuti-
cals to develop Methandrostenolone, which was later renamed Dianabol. Dianabol's per-
formance enhancing effects were so impressive that once it became commercially avail-
able in the United States in 1958, word spread like wildfire among US Olympic teams
and professional athletes. However, Doctor Ziegler eventually gave up experimenting
with Dianabol after he became disillusioned by the drug's side effects. Doctor Ziegler ex-
pressed his contrition for introducing steroids to American athletes by stating, "I wish to
God I'd never done it; I'd like to rewrite that entire chapter.” The International Olympics
Committee implemented their first drug testing programme 11 at the 1968 Winter
Olympics in Grenoble France as well as the Summer Olympics in Mexico in the same
year but because reliable testing for the presence of anabolic steroids had yet to be devel -
oped these drugs were not placed on the banned substance list, the use of anabolic
steroids amongst athletes continued unabated. The 70s and 80s even after the drugs were
officially banned from competition by the International Olympic Committee in 1975 once
valid testing for anabolic steroids was developed it then became a game of cat and mouse
between the IOC lab testers and athletes using performance enhancing drugs. The biggest
Olympic doping scandal to bring anabolic steroids out into the spotlight was Canadian
sprinter Ben Johnson testing positive for a drug called Stanozolol 12 at the 1988 Summer
Olympics in Seoul South Korea.Two days later, Johnson was disqualified for testing posi-
tive for a banned substance and stripped of his gold medal in world record. In response to
the Ben Johnson scandal, the United States Congress classified anabolic steroids as a
schedule three controlled substance in 1990. The World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA)
was founded in 1999 as an initiative of the International Olympic Committee to promote,
coordinate, and oversee the struggle against all forms of doping in sports. WADA is re-
sponsible for enforcing the world anti-doping code, which is adopted by more than 600
sports organisations, including international sports federations, national anti-doping or-
ganisations, the International Olympic Committee, and the international Paralympic com-
mittee. WADA define Gene Doping back in 2008 13 as the non-therapeutic use of cells that
change genetic elements or modulation of gene expression having the capacity to enhance
performance although gene doping is still in the experimental stages and the science of
gene doping is fraught with unpredictable results but if gene doping ever does become a
10 Wilson, J. D. (2008). Androgens. In L. J. De Groot (Ed.), Endocrinology (5th ed., pp. 3057-3070). Elsevier.
https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-012373972-5.00277-3
11 Franke, W. W., & Berendonk, B. (1997). Hormonal doping and androgenization of athletes: A secret pro-
gram of the German Democratic Republic government. Clinical Chemistry, 43(7), 1262-1279.
https://doi.org/10.1093/clinchem/43.7.1262
12 "Ben Johnson Stripped of Gold Medal." The New York Times, September 28, 1988, accessed April 15, 2023,
https://www.nytimes.com/1988/09/28/sports/ben-johnson-stripped-of-gold-medal.html.
13 WADA. (2008). The World Anti-Doping Code: The 2008 Prohibited List International Standard. Retrieved
from https://www.wada-ama.org/sites/default/files/wada_2008_ist_prohibited_list_en.pdf
viable therapy, athletes will be the first in line to alter their DNA to become bigger faster
and stronger.
When anabolic steroids are consumed, the body breaks them down into smaller molecules
that can enter cells and bind to androgen receptors. This normally binds to testosterone,
but anabolic steroids can also bind to it.
Once the androgen receptor is activated, the body begins to produce more proteins during
the anabolism process. As a result, skeletal muscle cells begin to replicate and muscles
begin to develop and become stronger.
Anabolic steroids help athletes train harder and recover faster by shortening catabolism,
the process by which proteins are broken down into amino acids. However, not all effects
of anabolic acids are positive; they can cause acne, high blood pressure, and baldness in
both men and women, they can cause men's testicles to shrink, decrease sperm count, and
increase the risk of prostate cancer, and women who use anabolic steroids can develop fa-
cial hair, a deeper voice, and their periods may become irregular
Creatine is produced by the body in order to liberate energy from muscles. It can produce
strength and stamina; weightlifters and sprinters take these supplements.Creatine causes
stomach and muscle discomfort, as well as weight gain.
Athletes use stimulants to increase blood pressure, stimulate the brain, and increase the
pulse rate; this increases endurance power, reduces appetite, and alleviates fatigue. Caf-
feine is a common stimulant that is consumed in large volumes by athletes in their energy
drinks. This increases their alertness and aggression.
Stimulants cause cardiac diseases, dehydration, insomnia, addictions, and weight loss.
Diuretics are preferred by athletes because they cause the body to lose water, thereby re-
ducing weight. Diuretic side effects include dehydration, dizziness, cramps, and occasion-
ally mortality.
Erythropoietin is used to enhance endurance because it increases oxygen flow to muscles
by increasing red blood cell production in the body. In the 1990s, 18 cyclists died due to
erythropoietin. Heart assaults and pulmonary artery occlusion are erythropoietin's nega-
tive effects.
Human Growth Hormone increases sprinting capacity by up to 4 percent and also stimu-
lates muscle growth.Human growth hormone is associated with joint pain, muscle weak-
ness, diabetes, hypertension, and eye difficulties.
Blood doping: The purpose of blood doping is to increase the number of oxygen-carrying
red blood cells in the blood. This is typically accomplished through blood transfusions or
injections of erythropoietin, a molecule that stimulates the production of more red blood
cells. The basic idea behind blood doping is that the more oxygen that can reach the
body's muscles, the greater the endurance. The side effects of blood doping include heart
disease, as it becomes more difficult for the heart to pump
Varieties of assessment
There are two categories of tests administered for doping.
Urine analysis
Blood examination
Urine analysis
The sample must be collected under the supervision of a coach or physician, as well as in
the presence of an official of the same gender, and it must be divided and sealed by the
athlete. The officials are responsible for providing the code. Following sampling, the ath-
lete will complete a medical declaration.
If samples prove positive, the athlete is notified. Samples are sent to registered labware.
The athlete or his authorised representative may be present during the unsealing and test-
ing of samples.
Blood examination
Blood tests are used to detect EPO or synthetic oxygen carriers.
Two samples are collected and sealed in the presence of an official and the athlete. The
procedure for both tests is identical.
The testing period for an athlete competing in an event begins 12 hours prior to the event.
In competitive testing, international and national standards are applied.
The International Olympic Committee conducts testing for the Olympic Games, the Inter-
national Federation conducts testing for the Vault World Championships, and the Na-
tional anti-doping organisation conducts testing at the national level.
Extracurricular assessment.
It is the testing of an athlete outside of competition, but associated with his or her partici-
pation in the event, and it is initiated and directed by both international and national anti-
doping organisations. WADA may conduct random tests anywhere and at any time, with
or without prior notice.
Ten violations of anti-doping rules applicable to athletes, team management, and officials.
Complicity
Prohibited Association associating with a person such as a coach after our physiotherapist
has been convicted of a doping violation will result in a two-year suspension.
Major instances
In 2005, Jose Canseco published a book about the rise of baseball in which he named a
number of current and former baseball players, including himself, who had used steroids
during their careers. Canseco was one of the first players to openly discuss his struggles
with steroid use, and his book is now regarded as the impetus for the subsequent major
steroid scandal that shook the baseball world.
Justin Gatlin tested positive for a prohibited substance; the American sprinter's two-year
suspension for testing positive for amphetamines in 2001 was reduced to one year follow-
ing an appeal. In 2006, he tested positive for testosterone, resulting in an eight-year sus -
pension that was reduced to four years after an appeal. In 2017, he was again discovered
doping and is now permanently banned from all athletic competitions.
The 2000 Summer Olympics in Sydney, Australia, established Marion Jones as one of the
most accomplished female athletes. However, CJ Hunter, a fellow Olympian, admitted
that he'd seen Jones's then-wife injecting herself with steroids prior to competing in the
Sydney games. Jones initially denied the allegations and claimed that she was completely
innocent, but in 2007 she admitted that she had used performance enhancing drugs[28]
and that her medals were revoked.
Ben Johnson, a Canadian sprinter, was poised to win gold at the 1988 Summer Olympics
in Seoul. He was coming off a record-setting performance at the 1987 World Champi-
onships in athletics and had won two bronze medals at the previous Olympic Games. No
one was surprised when he won the 100-meter dash in a ridiculous time of 9.79 seconds;
however, Johnson had been doping. After a few days, it was disclosed that Johnson had
tested positive for steroids, and his medals were subsequently taken away.
Maria Sharapova had taken meldonium prior to the 2016 tournament. As a result, the In-
ternational Tennis Federation initially suspended Sharapova for two years, but later re-
duced the suspension to fifteen months.
In the 2000s, Alex Rodriguez won three American League Most Valuable Player awards
while playing for the Rangers and Yankees, as well as a World Series title in 2009. How-
ever, like many of his contemporaries, Rodriguez was hiding a secret that would forever
tarnish his reputation. In 2009, the shortstop admitted to using performance-enhancing
drugs, but that was only the beginning of a rod's doping saga.
Lance Armstrong was the envy of the sports world; he won the Tour de France seven
times in a row and was a survivor of a fatal testicular cancer; however, he is now synony-
mous with doping. The infamous former cyclist had long been accused of taking steroids
with doping allegations dating back to his first Tour de France victory in 1999; however,
it wasn't until a 2013 interview that Armstrong finally admitted his guilt.
In 2017, Yusuf Pathan tested positive for terbutaline in Delhi, resulting in a five-month
suspension from the BCCI.
Before the 2016 Olympics, Narsingh Yadav tested positive for methandienone use. De-
spite the fact that he claimed it was a plot against him, he was banished for four years.
Ranjith Mahesh wary, a triple, was prohibited for four years by the Athletics Federation
of India following a positive urine test for ephedrine.