1What is relation between language and the human mind
1What is relation between language and the human mind
Put simply, one cannot understand the human brain without understanding the
contributions of language, both in the moment of thinking and as a formative force
during earlier learning and experience. When we study language, we are getting a
peek at the very essence of human nature. Languages—these deeply structured
cultural objects that we inherit from prior generations—work alongside our
biological inheritance to make human brains what they are.
Nativists argue that a human infant must have some kind of genetically transmitted
language faculty in order to acquire language as rapidly and successfully as it does.
If that is the case, then we can expect the human brain to be different in structure
from those of primates not capable of language. Of course, evidence of differences
between human brains and those of other species does not necessarily prove the
nativist case. We might approach the issue from the opposite (cognitivist) angle
and suggest that differences in the operation of the human brain are what enabled
us to evolve language when other species could not. Here are some comparisons
between the brains of human beings and those of other primates:
The cortex is much more extensive in human beings. Human pre-frontal areas are
up to six times bigger than those of chimpanzees (in relation to body size).
The brains of other species are divided into two hemispheres. Like human beings,
a number of species (birds, rodents and other primates) have a left hemisphere
which is more developed. In monkeys, the left hemisphere dominates in the pro
cessing of rapid auditory stimuli.
In human beings, a greater proportion of the motor area is given over to the
control of mouth, tongue and jaw.
The human cerebellum is very much larger, relative to brain size, than in other
species. The motor areas in the human cortex appear to exercise a high degree of
control over the larynx, which regulates the passage of air in breathing and speech.
In other species, the operation of the larynx is mainly or entirely controlled by the
lower parts of the brain.
4 Discuss the localization issue in relation to language and the brain . Attempts to
locate language in the brain have a long history. Added impetus was given to the
issue when Noam Chomsky (1965) and others drew attention to the fact that every
normal child successfully acquires a first language, no matter what its intelligence
or learning style. This suggested to some commentators that language must be an
independent faculty and not part of our general powers of thought and reason.
Evidence
supporting this hypothesis comes from accounts of individuals who have serious
learn ing difficulties but in whom the language faculty appears to be spared. It is
therefore of interest to find how language relates to the other operations performed
by the brain.
5 Discuss the lateralization issue in relation to language and the brain . Early
evidence suggested that damage to the left side of the brain impaired language in a
way that damage to the right did not. Where the damage occurred before the age
of about five, the sufferer would sometimes fully recover their powers of speech.
Hence a theory (Lenneberg 1967) that, in infancy, the relationship between the
two parts of the brain is flexible enough for language to relocate itself on the right
when neces
sary. This led to much discussion as to whether the periodcof flexibility constitutes
a Critical Period for learning a first language, after which a child is not be able to
achieve full competence.
The upper surface of the brain consists of 'grey matter' (that is its colour when
exposed to air) known as the cortex (or cortical area). It deals with many of the
more com plex operations, including making connections with stored information,
analysing input and controlling sophisticated muscular movements. Below it is the
sub-cortex of 'white matter', which is mainly nerve cell fibres. In general, the
lower parts of the brain are responsible for reflex actions, controlling functions
such as breathing and heart beats. The cerebellum at the base of the brain has a
delicate role in co-ordinating a ,range of muscular movements which have become
highly automatic.
2 Left vs right
The brain divides into two hemispheres, one on the left (from the perspective of the
owner of the brain) and one on the right. They are joined by a complex web of
nerve connections known as the corpus callosum. The left hemisphere controls
movement
and sensation on the right side of the body while the right hemisphere is linked to
the left side. Generalising enormously, the left hemisphere in most individuals is
associated with analytic processing and symbolisation, while the right is associated
with perceptual and spatial representation.
3 Front vs back temporal lobe running from front to back and the occipital and
parietal lobes at the back. Frontal lobe