Sensitive #_x000D_

WASTE WATER TREATMENT PLANT (WWTP3- Phase1)

Contract Ref# QPMO-410-CT-02274
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE B - Approved with Comments OVERALL STATUS Orange

Document Ref. No. QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-ARC-00-B03-00001 Comments Issued on Response Date: 29-Jul-24

Document Title B03 - Pretreatment Unit - Detailed Design BIM Package Submission Document Type Technical - Comment Resolution Sheet B - Approved with Comments

Date Received Lead Reviewer Mahmoud ElShanawani

Originator WETICO CRS Rev. 0A CRS Ref.: QRXU120100-WTC-TEC-CRS-BIM-00-B03-00002
Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code Status

Purgeable Elements
1 WETICO Review all Purgeable & un-assigned element from models. 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Refer to attached model check report.

Dimension Styles
Comply with QIC DSB Dimension styles in the model, purge un-used styles, adjust styles naming
2 WETICO convension. 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Refer to attached model check report.

Line Patterns
3 WETICO Comply with QIC styles in the model, purge un-used patterns. 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Refer to attached model check report.
Fill Patterns
4 WETICO Remove all un-used fill patterns. 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Refer to attached model check report.

General Materials Naming Convension

1- Review all materials naming convension, to comply with QIC DSB naming convension.
5 WETICO 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
2- Remove all un-used materials
Refer to attached model check report.

Warnings
6 WETICO Review all Models Warning messages 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Refer to attached model check report.
For all discplines (Refer to the approved design drawings with comments) to implement the all
technical comments
This revision grants conditional approval to implement any changes of the referenced design
comments provided during the IFC stage.
7 WETICO Final approval is contingent upon Wetico's implementation of the design comments within the BIM 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
model.

8 WETICO Apply all general notes mentioned for ARC model. 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange

QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-ARC-00-B03-00001 Levels and Grids NOT pinned in place

9 WETICO Ensure all levels & Grids are pinned in place. 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Refer to attached model check report.
10 WETICO Apply all general notes mentioned for ELE model. 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Generic Models
11 WETICO Review generic model elements. 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Refer to attached model check report.
Splash Screen
QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-ELE-00-B03-00001 Adjust splash screen 3D view.

12 WETICO 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange

13 QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-FPR-00-B03-00001 WETICO Apply all general notes mentioned for FPR model. 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
14 QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-HVC-00-B03-00001 WETICO Apply all general notes mentioned for HVC model. 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
15 WETICO Apply all general notes mentioned for STR model. 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange

QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-STR-00-B03-00001 Duplicate Modeled Elements

16 WETICO Review all modeled elements that are duplicates at the same location. 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Refer to attached model check report.
17 WETICO Apply all general notes mentioned for SWD model. 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Generic Models
18 WETICO Review generic model elements. 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
Refer to attached model check report.

QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-SWD-00-B03-00001

Page 1 of 13 CRS_Rev. 2
Sensitive #_x000D_

WASTE WATER TREATMENT PLANT (WWTP3- Phase1)

Contract Ref# QPMO-410-CT-02274
TECHNICAL - COMMENTS RESOLUTION SHEET

OVERALL REVIEW CODE B - Approved with Comments OVERALL STATUS Orange

Document Ref. No. QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-ARC-00-B03-00001 Comments Issued on Response Date: 29-Jul-24

Document Title B03 - Pretreatment Unit - Detailed Design BIM Package Submission Document Type Technical - Comment Resolution Sheet B - Approved with Comments

Date Received Lead Reviewer Mahmoud ElShanawani

Originator WETICO CRS Rev. 0A CRS Ref.: QRXU120100-WTC-TEC-CRS-BIM-00-B03-00002
Catogary Cat 4: Major Comment Cat 3: Technical Comment Cat 2: Non-Technical Comment Cat 1: Important for Future Submissions Cat 0: Minor Technical Comments

No. Section/ Page/ Drawing No. Originator Comments Doc. Rev. Cat. By Entity Response By Review Code Status

Splash Screen
QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-SWD-00-B03-00001 Adjust splash screen 3D view.

19 WETICO 0C Cat. 1 MAS B Orange

20 QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-PIP-00-B03-00001 WETICO Apply all general notes mentioned for PIP model. 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
21 WETICO Apply all general notes mentioned for PWR Model. 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange
QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-PWR-00-B03-00001 Layouts
22 WETICO Provide the reference drawings. 0A Cat. 1 MAS B Orange

Refer to the Reference tab for the Technical comments, It's comnditional approval with comments to
23 QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-BIM-00-B03-00001 WETICO 0C Cat. 4 MAS B Orange
be implemented on this stage and refelct all design changes

Solve all Active and Reviewed Clashes

24 QRXU120100-WTC-MOD-3DM-BIM-00-B03-00001 WETICO Review clash detection matrix & models sets, refer to DSB 0C Cat. 3 MAS B Orange

Producing Comments Responding to Comments

Lead Reviewer: Approved By: Response By: Approved By:
Name: Mahmoud ElShanawani Name: Irshad Ahmad Wani Name: Mohamed Ayman Name: Abdelhamid Mahmoud
Designation: BIM Manager Designation: PM Designation: BIM Coordinator/Piping Team Leader Designation:
Sign: IAW
Sign: M.SH. Sign: Sign:

Date: 29.07.2024 Date: 29-Jul-2024 Date: 23/07/2024 Date: 23/07/2024

Status

Closed
Agree to Close
Open

Page 2 of 13 CRS_Rev. 2
Technical Comments
Adjust the Arch wall bricks with the structural beams HVAC ducts for electrical room is not reaching to the ro

Pretreatment outlet chamber is not considered in this b

Electrical Room door is shown as roller shutter door, and since considerations in all building the wall is downstre
commented earlier that shall be normal door. the chamber.

Cable trays and their supports are shown

inside the wall. Cable trays clashing with light fixtures
Supports drawings are not approved yet with proper calculations. Hence, it isn`t final.
Handrails and ladders are not fully considered.
rical room is not reaching to the room itself. MOC for proposed materials, manholes, etc. are not addressed in th

chamber is not considered in this building, Contractor to clarify

in all building the wall is downstream the chamber not upstream Supports drawings are not approved yet with proper c

HVAC drainpipe supports are not shown. HVAC opening is show

with light fixtures Clashes between supports and drain line
s. Hence, it isn`t final.
. are not addressed in this submission.

ed yet with proper calculations. Hence, it isn`t final.

HVAC opening is shown without neck for proper insulation, there is clearance shown without cover/filling.
Sensitive #_x000D_

Requestor Name Sender Entity Overall Status Code Medium

CLOSED Original
OPEN Source File
Hard Copy
CD/DVD
Other
Sensitive #_x000D_

Code Status Over All Code

Red A A - Approved
Orange B B - Approved with Comments
Green C C - Revise and Resubmit
D D - Rejected
E E - Review Not Required

Consent to Submissions

The Engineer's Decision on documents submitted for his consent shall follow the
classification below:

Decision A Consented to as submitted, the contractor may proceed with

the Proposal
Decision B

Consented to subject to noted comments. The Contractor may

proceed with the proposal provided the work is performed in
accordance with the reviewer's comments. The reviewer may at
his discretion require the submission by the Contractor of
revised drawings, calculations, documents, etc. which
incorporate the conditions attached to the Decision "B" consent.
Such Submission shall be made within 7 days of request.
Provided that the conditions in the Decision "B" consent have
been fully incorporated and adhered to, the reviewer shall treat
such submitted documentation as being for information only.

Decision C Major comments. Resubmit for Review.

Decision D Rejected. NOT Consented to for the reasons noted in the CRS.
Related design or construction may not continue.
The Contractor shall make a new submission in accordance with
the reviewer's comments. The new submission shall not
proceed until the reviewer's comments have been fully satisfied.
Sensitive #_x000D_

Category
Cat. 0
Cat. 1
Cat. 2
Cat. 3
Cat. 4