1

(SINGLE BENCH)
MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR
BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE M.G.GIRATKAR : VICE-CHAIRMAN
(“COURT HALL A” ) (TIME – 11:00 A.M.) (DATE- 18.02.2025)

PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER
1. O.A.833/24 A.D. Maske State & 3 Ors. Transfer
Adv. R.M. Fating P.O. for R/1 to 3
Adv. A.P. Sadavarte for
R/4
ORDER MATTERS
1. M.C.A.45/18 in Dr. G.N. Patil State & 3 Ors. Fixation of Pay For Cond. of delay
M.C.A 46/18 in P.O. for R/1 to 3 For Restoration
O.A. 674/2010 Adv. S.R. Gajbhiye,
S.S. More Adv. D.A. Sonawane
for R/4
2. M.C.A.47/18 in Dr. G.N.Patil State & 4 Ors. Interest For Cond. of delay
M.C.A.48/18 P.O. for R/1 to 3 For Restoration
O.A.612/2011 Adv. S.R. Gajbhiye,
V.N. Kolte, S.Ghatole, Adv. D.A. Sonwane
S.S. More for R/4

3. O.A.598/21 (C) P.B. Vyas State & 3 Ors. Time Bound R/2 to 4 await
P.O. Promotion service
Adv. S.N. Gaikwad
For Reply
4. C.A.73/25 in P.A. Raut State & Ano. Higher pay scale with For Disposal of O.A.
P.O. for R/1 Interest For Reply
O.A.865/23 Adv. R.V.Shiralkar,
A.B. Darekar, Amey Adv. U.A. Patil,
Motlag K.A.Patil, Abhishek
Deshpande for R/2
5. O.A. 1189/23 H.P. Phaurkar & Ano. State & Ano. Appointment on For Reply
P.O. Compassionate
Adv. P.S. Kshirsagar
Ground
6. O.A. 1235/23 N.P. Balbudhe & 9 State & 73 Ors. Challenging R/34, 57, 61, 68 & 73
Ors. P.O. for R/1 to 5 Appointment of Police await service
Adv. D.M. Kakani, Patil Post
Adv. P.M. Sinha, S.S.
Chourasia (Leave Upto 18/02
/2025 to
21/02/2025)
G.K. Bhuasari for/ 6
to 33, 35 to 56 , 58
to 60, 62 to 67, 69
to 72 & 74
R/34, 57, 61, 68 &
73 (Pvt. Respdts.)
7. O.A.438/23 N.V. Dhande State & Ano. Transfer For Reply
Adv. G.G.Bade, P.P. P.O.
Khaparde

8. O.A. 06/24 A.B. Ingole State & 3 Ors. Absorption For Reply
(Connected with Adv. N.R. & Mrs. K.N. P.O. (Van Major)
H.P.at Sr. No.35 ) Saboo
 2

9. R.A.11/24 in C.J. Chavan State & 2 Ors. R.A. For Reply

O.A.67/19 Adv. N.B.Rathod P.O.

10. O.A.134/24 (C) N.A.Gadling State & 3 Ors. Posting/ Transfer R/2 to 4 await
P.O. service
Adv. R.L. Kadu, Kunal
Dhoble, Alpesh
Deshmukh
11 O.A.355/24 (C) N.A. Gadling State & 4 Ors. Posting R/2 to 5 await
P.O. service
Adv. R.L. Kadu
Objection :
Page No. 22 is not
legible
12 O.A.167/24 R.B. Thakre State & 3 Ors. Time Bound For Reply to R/1 to 3
P.O. Promotion
Adv. R.M. Fating
13 O.A.274/24 (C) Smt. Jubeda A.S. State & 2 Ors. Regularization from For Reply
Sheikh & 3 Ors. P.O. date of Joining &
Retirement Benefits
Adv. I.G. Meshram,
with Pension
U.I. Dhawade
(Van Majoor)
14 O.A.311/24 (C) M.R. Bhoyar State & 3 Ors. Absorption / Count For Reply to R/2 & 3
P.O. the service & Pension Objection :
Adv. H.R. Meshram
with pensionery Point of limitation
Benefits
(Muster Assistant)
15 O.A.664/24 G.U.Sonaskar State & 2 Ors. Recovery For Reply
Adv. Sagar Katkar P.O. Objection :
Page No. 13 is not
legible
16 O.A.763/24 (C) A.B. Lanjewar State & 3 Ors. Appointment on For Reply
P.O. Compassionate Objection :
Adv. Sunita Kulkarni
Ground 1.Page No. 17 & 18
are not legible
17 O.A.806/24 S.V.Patil State & Ano. Transfer For Reply
Adv.H.G.Korade, P.O.
With M.S.Range
18 O.A.807/24 G.H.Nishitkar State & Ano. Transfer For Reply
Adv.H.G.Korade, P.O.
With M.S.Range

19 O.A.808/24 N.F.S.A.Sayyad State & Ano. Transfer For Reply

Adv.H.G.Korade, P.O.
With M.S.Range
20 O.A.809/24 P.A.Awasthi State & Ano. Transfer For Reply
Adv.H.G.Korade, P.O.
M.S.Range

21 C.A.427/24 in S.B. Meshram State & Ano. Transfer Pursis for withdraw
P.O. for R/1 the O.A.
O.A.841/24 (C) Adv. D.M.Kakani
Adv. T.U. Tathod For Intervene in the
(Leave Upto 18/02 O.A. as applicant
/2025 to
for R/2
21/02/2025) Adv. A.Z. Jibhkate,
P.A. Jibhakate for
& M.M. Ghatode
Proposed
Intervenor
 3

22 C.A.525/24 in V.B. Rajput State & 2 Ors. Suspension For Direction

O.A.983/24 Adv. P.A. Kadu P.O. For Reply

23 O.A.992/24 Jamil K.J.K.Pathan State & 4 Ors. Retirement benefits as For Reply to R/1 to 4
P.O. per last drawn pay
Adv. J.S.Wankhede
24 O.A.1026/24 D.S.Mandhre State & 3 Ors. Recovery For Reply to R/1, 3 &
P.O. 4
Adv.I.N.Choudhari,
A.K.Khobragde
25 O.A.1114/24 J.A. Durge State &Ano. Transfer For Reply
Adv. Alpesh P.O.
Deshmukh, Tejas
Deshpande
26 O.A.1131/24 (C) Dr. V. N. Anantwar State & 3 Ors. Refund the Recovery For Reply
P.O. amount
Adv. R.M. Fating
27 O.A.1169/24 R.R. Kekatpure State &Ano. Interest on delayed For Reply
P.O. Payment
Adv.BharatKulkarni,
Sunil Pande
28 O.A.1176/24 Dr. P.B.Waghmare& Sate & 2 Ors. Release the Annual For Reply
8 Ors. P.O. increments & Other
service benefits
Adv. N.R. & Mrs. K.N.
Saboo T.N. Ahemad
29 O.A.1207/24 S.U. Ingle State & Ano. Unpaid Salary/ Time For Reply
Adv. Preeti Rane, P.O. Bound Promotion
Himani Kavi
30 O.A.1234/24 G.S. Patil State & 2 Ors. Release the Regular For Reply
P.O. pension & Arrears of Objection :
Adv. N.D. & T.N.
difference of Regular Page No. 48 & 49 are
Thombre
pension not legible

31 O.A.1241/24 R.M.Choudhari State & 3 Ors. Recovery of amount For Reply

P.O. from Retirement
Adv. V.R.Borkar
benefits

32 O.A.1243/24 D.M. Ghuge State & 4 Ors. Recovery of amount For Reply
P.O. from Retirement
Adv. V.R. Borkar
benefits
33 O.A.34/25 B.G. Borekar State & 4 Ors. Recovery from For Reply
P.O. pension
Adv. V.R. Borkar

34 O.A.1252/24 U.B. Tol State & 3 Ors. Recovery For Reply

Adv. J.R. Kidilay P.O.

35 O.A.16/25 Y.B. Sharma State & 3 Ors. Grant Notional Annual For Reply
P.O. Increment due on Objection :
Adv. R.M. Fating
01/01/2023 Page No. 23, 24 are
not legible
 4

36 O.A.17/25 Dr. P. C. Bhagat State & 3 Ors. Pay fixation as per 7th For Reply
P.O. Pay Commission Objection :
Adv. N.D. & T.N.
Thombre 1.Page No. 52 is not
legible
2.Not make
signature on
synopsis
37 O.A.19/25 N.P. Gawai State & 4 Ors. Not Join Applicant to R/2 to 5 await
P.O. post of kotwal service
Adv. G. G. Bade, P.P.
Khaparde
38 O.A.92/25 Dr. T. K. Bhagwat State & 4 Ors. Joining the service R/2 to 5 await
P.O. service
Adv. S.D. Chande,
O.D. Kale
39 O.A. 1240/23 A.J. Gaur State & 3 Ors. Pension For Reply
Adv. M.Z. & Z.Z. Haq, P.O.
S.M. Gaidhane, S.D.
Songade & R.J.
Shinde, P.P. Sarise,
P.P. Mishra
40 C.A.28/25 in H.U. Rawat & 42 Ors. State & 7 Ors. Pay Fixation For Early Hearing
O.A.1337/23 Adv. S.U. Bhuyar P.O.

ADMISSION MATTERS
1. R.A. 07/24 in M.P.Landge State & 3 Ors. R.A.
C.A. 357/19 in Adv. R.L.Kadu, Kunal P.O.
O.A.St. 1872/19 Dhoble
(C)
2. O.A.356/24 S.P. Bijwe State & 4 Ors. Minor Punishment Objection :
Adv. A.S. Dhore, Y.S. P.O. Point of limitation
Bangale, K.D. Bhende
3. O.A.1066/24 R.N. Behare State & 2 Ors. Suspension period Objection :
P.O. treat as duty period Relief Sought No. 1 &
Adv. G.N. Khanzode,
Renuka Gosavi, A.G. 2 are same in O.A.
Kahnzode No. 510/17 (Rajan N.
Behare Vs. State ) is
already disposed of
as Unconditionally
withdraw vide order
dtd. 27.09.2023
4. O.A.71/25 (C) P.R. Chavhan State & 2 Ors. Monitory Benefits New O.A.
Adv. Anand P.O.
Deshpande, G.R.
Bhake
5. O.A.126/25 (C) G.M. Kodape State & 2 Ors. Correction in Date of New O.A.
P.O. Birth
Adv. S.S. Dhengale,
K.N. Jain
6. O.A.140/25 (C) B.M. Madavi State & Ano. Regularization New O.A.
Adv. N.R. & Mrs. K.N. P.O. Objection :
Saboo 1.Point of limitation
 5

2.Page No. 41 is not

legible
3. Not make T.C. to
Documents
4.Paging has not
been done properly
7. O.A.141/25 (C) S.R. Ramteke State & Ano. Regularization New O.A.
Adv. N.R. & Mrs. K.N. P.O. Objection :
Saboo 1. Not make T.C. to
Documents
2.Annexure are not
marked A-5
8. O.A.178/25 (C) S.V. Raut State & 3 Ors. Punishment New O.A.
P.O. Objection :
Adv. S.N. Gaikwad
Point of limitation
9. O.A.185/25 (C) S.V. Sonule State & Ano. Transfer New O.A.
Adv. N.R. & Mrs. K.N. P.O.
Saboo, T.N. Ahemad
10 O.A.186/25 (C) V.J. Dhadse State & Ano. Transfer New O.A.
Adv. N.R. & Mrs. K.N. P.O.
Saboo, T.N. Ahemad
HEARING PARTY MATTERS
1. O.A.215/2017 M.R.Sanap State & 2 Ors. Punishment & Time Bound Matter/
P.O. Recovery High Court Direction
Adv.P.V.Thakre
Matter
2. O.A.370/23 S.S. Dewajwar & Ano. State & Ano. Regularization and Remand Back/High
P.O. Retirement benefits Court Direction
Adv.S.P. Palshikar
Matter
3. O.A. 119/23 P.C. Giri State & 2 Ors. Punishment & P.H.
Adv. S.P. Palshikar P.O. Recovery
4. O.A. 706/23 U.J. Maske & Ano. State & 3 Ors. Suspension P.H.
Adv. S.D. Shukla, P.O.
Abhijeet Barahate
5. O.A.23/18 D.R. Shipne State & 5 Ors. Suspension
Adv. S.M. & G.S. P.O.
Bhagde
6. O.A. 304/19 K.P. Bhangale State & 7 Ors. Recovery
Adv. S.R. Charpe P.O.

7. O.A.473/19 (C) M.R. Landge State & 3 Ors. Recovery

With Adv. I.N. Choudhari P.O.

8. O.A.474/19 (C) B.M. Walde State & 3 Ors. Recovery

Adv. I.N. Choudhari P.O.

9. O.A.1040/19 M.B. Makde State & 2 Ors. Suspension

Adv. V.D. & A.V. P.O.
Muley
10 O.A.1075/19 Dr. A.N. Bhingare State & 2 Ors. Condonation of Objection:
P.O. Breaking service & Pages 33 & 34 not
Adv.B.J. Lonare
Grant of increment legible.
 6

11 O.A.638/20 D.D. Raut State & Ano. Suspension

Adv. M.R. Khan P.O.

12 O.A. 486/21 (C) J.P. Gedam State & 5 Ors. Time Bound
P.O. for R/1 to 5 Promotion
with Adv. S.N. Gaikwad
M.B. Giri, R/6

13 O.A. 487/21 R.B. Pachare State & 4 Ors. Time Bound

P.O. Promotion
Adv. S.N. Gaikwad

14 O.A.1072/21 (C) J.D. Zine State & Ano. Time Bound

P.O. Promotion
Adv.N.R. Saboo, A.P.
Barahate, Miss A.S.
Lanjewar
15 O.A.79/22 (C) B.K. Chavan State & 2 Ors. Grant of leave
P.O.
Adv.N.R. & Mrs.K.N.
Saboo
16 O.A.529/22 Dr. D.M. Wankhede State & 4 Ors. Pay Scale
Adv. P.C. & V.P. P.O.
Marpakwar,
R.P.Deshpande
17 O.A.857/22 Smt. S.A. Mankar State & 3 Ors. Count the past service,
P.O. Pension & Pensionery
Adv. K.S.Malokar
Benefits
18 O.A.1124/22 A.B. Basari State & Ano. Police Patil
Adv. S.B. Tiwari P.O.

19 O.A. 59/23 (C) Dr. S.S. Ghangle State & 3 Ors. Recovery
P.O.
Adv. S.S. Sanyal,
Shiba Thakur
20 O.A.92/23 V.S. Aghav State & 3 Ors. Time Bound
Adv. R.A. Joshi, V.D. P.O. Promotion
Awchat
21 O.A.98/23 M.M. Kusneniwar State & 3 Ors. Time Bound
P.O. Promotion/Pay Scale
Adv. S.U Bhuyar
as per G.R. dt.2/3/19
22 O.A.355/23 (C) S.B. Chavan State & 3 Ors. Recovery
Adv. D.R. P.O.
Rupnarayan
23 O.A.876/23 (C) V.B. Pise State & 4 Ors. Release the amount of
Adv. J.S. Wankhede, P.O. Surrender leave and
R.D. Narkhede Pay fixation
24 O.A.1032/23 (C) R. W. Ghughre State & 3 Ors. Recovery from
P.O. Retirement Benefits
Adv. D.R.
Rupnarayan
25 O.A. 1160/23 S.B. Meshram State & 3 Ors. Challenging
P.O. for R/1 to 3 Appointment of R/4
Adv. Vivek Awchat
Adv. D.R. Bhoyar on the Post of Kotwal
for R/4
 7

26 O.A.103/24 R. M. Kodape State & 3 Ors. Release the Salary &

Adv. A.P. Modak, P.O. Deduction the Amount
K.R.Bhise

27 O.A. 12/24 (C) A. N. Kendhe State & 5 Ors. Time Bound

P.O. Promotion
Adv. R.M. Fating
28 O.A.40/24 S.V. Khorge State & 2 Ors. Police
P.O. for R/1 & 2 Patil/Challenging
Adv. S.B. Tiwari, P.B.
Adv. P.S. & K.P. Appointment of R/3
Mishra
Wathore, A.A.
Wankhade for R/3
29 O.A. 60/24 (C) P.M. Gulhane State & 2 Ors. Time Bound Objection :
P.O. Promotion & Page No. 34, 40, 43,
Adv. S.N. Gaikwad
Suspension Period 80 to 81 are not
treat as duty period legible
30 O.A.145/24 M.S.Kharia State & 2 Ors Recovery Objection :
P.O. Not make T.C.to
Adv.N.R.Saboo, Documents in
K.N.Saboo, Annexures A-1 To A-
T.N.Ahemad 11&A-13
31 O.A. 308/24 Dr. A. R. Tarale State & 2 Ors. Transfer Objection :
P.O. 1.Page No. 35 is not
Adv. N.R & Mrs. K.N.
Saboo, T.N. Ahemad legible
2.Black Shading of
Page No. 37
32 O.A. 629/24 R.P. Jadhao State & 2 Ors. Transfer
Adv. G.G.Bade P.O. for R/1 & 2
S.M. Mehtre, R/3
33 O.A.665/24 S.K. Sawsakde State & 5 Ors. Recovery, Release the
P.O. Retirement benefits
Adv. N.S. & P.N.
Warulkar, S. K.
Bhattacharya
34 O.A.942/24 V.C. Patil & Ano. State of Mah. Selection Grade Scale
P.O. as per G.R. dtd.
Adv. R.M. Fating
28.03.2023
35 O.A. 08/24 S.D. Bhagat State & 3 Ors. Absorption
(Connected with Adv. N.R. & Mrs. K.N. P.O. (Van Major)
O.M. at Sr. No. 8 ) Saboo

kds Deputy Registrar,

Checked by:- Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur
 8

(DIVISION BENCH)

MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR

BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE VINAY JOSHI : MEMBER (J)
AND HON’BLE SHRI NITIN GADRE : MEMBER (A)

(“COURT HALL B”) (TIME – 11:00 A.M.) (DATE – 18.02.2025)

PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER
1. O.A. 510/21 R.B. Thakur State & Ano. Challenging order
Adv.S.P. & A.S. Bhandarkar, P.O. dtd.25/02/21 for
M. Shuklaa, G. Mate, R.V. & temporary
N.R. Shiralkar, Amey Motlag appointment for
11 months

2. O.A.330/24 C.H. Parate State & Ano. Removal from

P.O. Service
Adv. R.S. & P.R. Parsodkar

ORDER MATTERS
1. O.A.287/24 A.V. Deshmukh State & Ano. Selection Process High on Board
P.O. / Appointment For Reply
with Adv. N.B. Rathod, R.G.
Waghmare, Kajal Bhagat Objection :
Page No. 84 is not
legible
2. O.A.288/24 S.V. Padwe State & Ano. Selection Process High on Board
with P.O. / Seeking For Reply
Adv. N.B. Rathod, R.G.
Appointment
Waghmare, Kajal Bhagat
3. O.A.289/24 N.V. Tirmare State & Ano. Selection High on Board
with P.O. Process/Seeking For Reply
Adv. N.B. Rathod, R.G.
Appointment Objection :
Waghmare, Kajal Bhagat
Page No. 78 A &
82 are not legible

4. O.A.290/24 V.C. Chellirwar State & Ano. Selection Process High on Board
with P.O. / Seeking For Reply
Adv. N.B. Rathod, R.G.
Appointment
Waghmare, Kajal Bhagat

5. O.A.291/24 P.S. Pangul State & Ano. Selection Process High on Board
with P.O. / Seeking For Reply
Adv.N.B. Rathod, R.G.
Appointment Objection :
Waghmare, Kajal Bhagat
Page No. 85 is not
legible

6. O.A.292/24 J.M. Chopkar State & Ano. Selection Process High on Board
P.O. / Seeking For Reply
Adv. N.B. Rathod, R.G.
Appointment
Waghmare, Kajal Bhagat

7. C.A.493/17 in B.A. Ganvir State & 2 Ors. Remove from the For Cond. of delay
P.O. service/ Reinstate
O.A. St. 2666/17 Adv. G.G. Bade, P.P.
the service
Khaparde, W.N. Nayse
 9

8. C.A.05/25 in Smt.V.S.Dhakne State & Ors. Promotion For Final Disposal

P.O. for R/1 & 2 of the O.A.
O.A.133/17 Adv.I.A. Fidvi & A.A. Potnis
Adv.S.P.Palshikar
for R/3

9. C.A.542/17 in N.H.S.Baba State & 3 Ors. R.A. For Reply

Rev.St.2916/17 Adv. Abdul Subhan P.O.
in O.A.920/10

10. C.A.207/23 in A.G. Dalal State & 4 Ors. Challenging For Direction
P.O. G.R.dtd. For issuing
C.A. 93/25 in Adv. Ms. Preeti Rane,
Punam Kale 21.12.2019 necessary
O.A.58/20 condition No. 1 Direction
(Connected (b) Objection :
with H.P. at Sr.
Page No.40 is not
No. 6 ,7, 8 & 9 )
legible
With
11. C.A.210/23 & G.W. Walekar State & 4 Ors. Challenging For Direction
P.O. G.R.dtd. For issuing
C.A.69/25 in Adv. Ms. Preeti Rane,
Punam Kale 21.12.2019 necessary
O.A.60/20 condition No. 1 Direction
With (b) P.H.
Objection :
Page No.16 & 18
are not legible
12. C.A. 86/25 in Sau.U.R.Sorte State & 3 Ors. Challenging G.R. For issuing
P.O. dtd. 21/12/2019 necessary
O.A.62/20 Adv.Ms.P.Rane & Punam
condition No. 1(b) Direction
with Kale
Objection :
Page No.46 & 47
are not legible
13. O.A.117/20 P.D. Taikar State & 3 Ors. Challenging Order C.F. applicant has
P.O. dtd. 28.12.2019 not comply
Adv. Preeti Rane & Punam
for Appointment Tribunal order
Kale
of 11 months dated 05.02.2025
period For Bringing legal
hears on record
14. O.A. 1311/23 M.G. Wath State & 3 Ors. Re-check the For Reply
P.O. paper and Objection :
Adv.G.G. Bade, P.P.
Exemption from Page No. 49 is not
Khaparde
passing of legible
departmental
examination
15. R.A.10/24 Javed Z. Khan State & 3 Ors. R.A. For Reply R/1, 2
P.O. &4
O.A.1121/21 Adv. S.P.Palshikar

16. O.A.57/25 Y.S. Jumde State & 2 Ors. Challenging For Reply
With P.O. Communication
Adv. S.P. Palshikar
dtd. 20.09.2024 &
06.01.2025
17. C.P.32/24 in Y.S. Jumde State & Ano. C.P. For Reply
O.A. 949/21 Adv. S.P. Palshikar P.O.
 10

18. C.A. 144/ 24 in A.P. Rapartiwar & 3 Ors. State & 6 Ors. Challenging For Amendment
P.O. for R/1 to 7 Circulation of For Reply
O.A.258/24 Adv. A.A. Dhawas, S.N.
Adv. Abhay Selection/
Gaikwad, K.R. Bhise, S.V.
Sambhre for R/8 Termination
Dhore, S.A. Dhawas
19. O.A.705/24 Y.K. Bhoyar State & Ano. Selection Process/ For Comply the
P.O. Appointment Tribunal order
Adv. R.V. & N.R. Shiralkar,
dated 21.01.2025
Amey Motlag
20. O.A.22/25 S.P.Jogi & Ano. State & 11 Ors. Promotion For Reply
Adv.A.S.Dhore, Y.Bangale P.O. for R/1 to 6 to
11
Adv. N.R. & Mrs.
K.N. Saboo for R/7
& 10
Adv. S.N. Gaikwad,
Kalyani Daware for
R/12
21. C.A. 104/25 in S.B. Urkute State & 3 Ors. Selection Process/ For Amendment
P.O. Appointment on C.F. applicant has
O.A.164/25 Adv.S.N. Gaikwad
post of class IV not carried out
order amendment as
per Hon.Tribunal
order dtd.
11.02.2025
Objection :
Page No. 19 is not
legible
22. O.A.957/24 (C) A.M. Bange State & 6 Ors. Cancellation of For Reply
P.O. for R/1 to 6 Appointment Objection :
Adv. S.S. Shingane
Adv. A.R. Rishi, for 1.Page No. 27 is
R/7 not legible
2. Page No. 41 is
Black shading
23. R.A.17/19 in R.B. Dapkar & 6 Ors. State & 4 Ors. R.A. Await service to
P.O. R/2 to 5.
O.A.793/17 (Rev. Applicants.) Objection :
& A.S. Nandekar & 3 Ors. 1.Page No. 9-C, 15,
Adv. N.R. & Mars. K.N. 19 are not legible
Saboo 2.Copy not served
to C.F. original
applicant
3.Rev. applicants
not applicant and
not respondent in
O.A. No. 793/2017
ADMISSION MATTERS
1. O.A. 118/25 C.N. Yarewar State & Ano Seeking Objection :
P.O. Appointment 1.Not make T.C. to
Adv. M.R. Khan, Ashok
documents in 2nd
Kambani
set
2.Defict Court fees
of Rs. 40/- is found
in O.A.
3.Page No. 27 & 28
not annex in 2nd
set
 11

2. O.A.119/25 R.B. Kawale State & 2 Ors. Seeking

P.O. Appointment
Adv. M.R. Khan, Ashok
Kambani
3. O.A.132/25 (C) N.R. Sidam State & 2 Ors. Promotion with New O.A.
P.O. Deem date of
Adv. G.G.Bade,
Promotion
P.P.Khaparde
4. O.A.179/25 S.N. Chavhan State & 21 Ors. Challenging New O.A.
P.O. Selection list & Objection :
Adv. A.B. Mirza
Time Bound 1.Page No. 71 is
Promotion not legible
2.Black Shading
of Page No. 37

HEARING PARTY MATTERS

1. O.A.29/23 I.P. Masram State & 3 Ors. Dismissal from High On Board
P.O. Services P.H.
Adv. S.P. Palshikar
2. O.A.148/24 G.D. Dahikar State & Ano. Advertisement/ High On Board
P.O. Accept the Objection :
Adv. R.V. & N.R. Shiralkar ,
application Page No. 21 is not
A.M.Motlag
legible

3. O.A.72/17 S.K. Pawar State & 2 Ors. Dismissal

Adv. S.P. Palshikar P.O.

4. O.A.490/17 B.S. Ahmed State & 2 Ors. Termination

Adv. S.N. Gaikwad P.O.

5. O.A.213/18 R.C. Nagdeve State & 3 Ors. Promotion

P.O.
Adv. A.Z. & P.A. Jibhkate
6. O.A.59/20 D.V. Ninave State & 4 Ors. Challenging G.R. For Direction
P.O. dtd. 21.12.2019
With Adv. Ms. Preeti Rane,
Punam Kale condition No. 1
C.A.208/23 (b)
(Connected
with O.M. at Sr.
No. 10, 11, 12
& 13)
With
7. O.A.61/20 N.K. Gokhe State & 4 Ors. Challenging For Direction
P.O. G.R.dtd. Objection :
With Adv. Ms. Preeti Rane,
Punam Kale 21.12.2019 Page No.40 & 41
C.A.211/23 condition No. 1 are not legible
With (b)
8. O.A.63/20 V.V.Kolhe State & 4 Ors. Challenging G.R. Objection :
P.O. dtd. 21/12/2019 Page No.18 to 22
With Adv.Ms.Preeti Rane &
condition No. 1 are not legible
Punam Kale
(b)
9. O.A.288/20 Meena Y. Bajirao State & 3 Ors. Challenging G.R. For Direction
with P.O.
(Sau. Meena P. Ninawe)
C.A.205/23 Adv. Preeti Rane
 12

10. O.A.213/20 Ku. R.D. Wagh State & 3 Ors. Challenging For Direction
P.O. order dtd.
With (Sau. R.G. Ingle)
11.03.2020
C.A.206/23 Adv. Preeti Rane

11. O.A.553/22 S.D.Idhole State & 2 Ors. Dismissal form

Adv. S.P. Palshikar Service
P.O.

12. O.A.954/22 G.R. Rathod State & Ano. Charge sheet &
With Adv.Bharat Kulkarni, P.O. D.E.
S.Pande

13. O.A.955/22 N.M. Bassi State & Ano. Charge sheet &
Adv.Bharat Kulkarni, P.O. D.E.
S.Pande

14. O.A.785/22 P.B. Wankhede& 10 Ors. State & 2 Ors. Promotion

Adv.R.V. & N.R. Shiralkar, A. P.O.
Motlag

15. O.A.986/22 A.J. Badade State & Ano. Charge Sheet/ D.E.
Adv. Vilas Dongre, R.V. P.O.
Shiralkar

16. O.A.1171/22 V.K.Khobragade State & 4 Ors. Compulsory

Adv. S.P. Palshikar P.O. Retirement

17. O.A.280/23 R.P. Kilbile State & 3 Ors. Challenging Objection :

P.O. Charge-sheet Page No. 14 to 18
Adv.S.N. Gaikwad
are not legible
18. O.A.1286/23 Dr. M. U. Gurjar State & Ano. Selection Process
Adv. P.A. Kadu P.O.

19. O.A.69/24 P.J.Bhad State & 4 Ors. Challenging

P.O. for R/1 & 2 Promotion of R/3
Adv. Sachin Khandekar
U.R. Shevgavkar, to 5 and Seeking
R/3 Promotion with
deemed date of
D.R. Pawar, R/4
Promotion
M.V. Rokade, R/5

20. O.A.157/24 Dr. M.S. Chilkar State & Ano. Challenging Objection :
P.O. Charge Sheet and Point of limitation
With Adv. D.G. Paunikar, G.S.
Departmental
Kidambi, A.I. Raqit, A.S.
Enquiry & Release
Sirsikar
the Pension
21. O.A.455/24 Dr. A.K. Bhavsar State & 4 Ors. Challenging
P.O. for R/1 to 3 Charge sheet &
Adv.G.S. Kidambi, A.I. Ragit
Adv. J.Y. Ghurde, Departmental
V.B. Bhise, Abhay Enquiry & Release
Gashe for R/4 & 5 the provisional
pension
 13

22. O.A.192/24 A.A.Dewalkar State & 2 Ors. Promotion

Adv.P.D. Meghe, A. Singh, P.O. for R/1 & 2
K.Roy Adv. U.A. & K.A.
Patil, A. Deshpande
for R/3

23. O.A.259/24 S. V. Darekar State & Ano. Promotion Objection :

Adv. S.D. Shukla, Abhijit P.O. Page No. 56 is not
Barahate legible

kds Deputy Registrar,

Checked by:- Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur
 14

( OBJECTION BOARD )

MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR

BOARD OF UNREADY MATTER BEFORE THE REGISTRAR
(“REGISTRAR CHAMBER”) ( TIME:-11.30 to 03.30 PM ) (DATE – 18.02.2025)

ORDER MATTERS
1. O.A.1139/23 Ranjit. B.Badar & 74 Ors State & 2 Ors Release the two Objection :
P.O. advance 1. Page No. 32,
Adv. S.N.Gaikwad
increment 38,44,49,56,59,
s 78,82,92,97,100,1
18,119,128,130,b
131,138,140,162,
195,206,207,216,
256,257,331,345,
347,368,381,383,
384,386 to
388,395, to
398,406,417,418,
461,512
2. Point of
jurisdiction
applicant No. 5 to
24,26 to 28,30 to
32,35 to 37, 39 to
41, 43 to 46, 49 to
51, 53 to69
3. Incomplete
address of
applicant No.
1,2,4,6,9,13,16,18,
20,22,23,26 to 30
, 32, 37, 40, 44, 46
to 54, 56 to 58, 60
to 61, 67, 70, 72 &
74

2. O.A.1262/23 D.M. Tale & 3 Ors. State & 2 Ors. Advance Objection :
P.O. Increments 1.Page No. 23, 48,
Adv. S.N. Gaikwad
84, 85 & 147 are
not legible
2.Point of
Jurisdiction of
applicant No. 5 to
26

3. O.A.141/24 I.S. Chaudhari State & Ano. Transfer Objection :

Adv. S.S. Ghate, D.T. P.O. Page No. 38 & 39
Sukhadev are not legible

4. O.A.156/24 S.S. Kersunge State & 3 Ors. Challenging Objection :

P.O. appointment of Page No. 42 is not
Adv. Kanak Mandpe
R/4 for the post of legible
Police Patil
 15

5. C.A.224/24 in B.P. Aarakh State & Ano. Pay Scale/ Time For Cond. of delay
P.O. Bound Promotion Objection :
O.A. St. 1048/24 Adv. S.M. Vaishnav
1.Page No. 14, 16
& 20 are not
legible
2.Delay days not
mentioned in C.A.
6. C.P.111/23 in K.B. Chormale & 7 Ors. State & 5 Ors. C.P. R/2 to 6 await
P.O. service
O.A.529/21 Adv. S.N. Gaikwad
Objection :
1.Page No. 12 is
not legible
2.Certify copy of
order dated
28.06.2023 is not
annexes
7. O.A.575/23 P.V.Kene State & 2 Ors Cancellation of C.F. Applicant has
P.O. Selection & not collected
Adv.A.R.Patil,
Seeking Hamdast for R/2
N.A.Waghmare
Appointment &3
8. O.A.424/24 R.M. Halmare State & 2 Ors. Selection Process/ Objection :
P.O. Seeking Page No. 39 & 40 ,
Adv.H.M. Bobade, Vijay
Appointment 42 in 2nd set &
Mishra, Mahesh Zhore
Page No. 43 1st &
2nd set are not
legible

kds Deputy Registrar,

Checked by:- Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur