Consumption, Saving and Investment.
Consumption, Saving and Investment.
Main Contents
8.1 CONSUMPTION
8.2 SAVING
8.3 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CONSUMPTION AND SAVING
8.4 INVESTMENT
Unit Summary
Review Exercise
Y
S
+
C
=
Y
d
(C = Yd)
C
Grade 11 Economics
284
INTRODUCTION
The main purpose of every economic activity is consumption, whatever the type
of economy. Most people spend the major part of their income on the consumption
of goods and services. The balance of income which is not used for consumption
is saved.
8.1 CONSUMPTION
At the end of this section, you will be able to:
define the concept of consumption; and
asses the basic determiners of consumption.
Start-up Activity
List down material consumptions you made in the previous week. Then compare
your level of consumption with that of your friend. Are they similar or different? Why
do you think they are similar or different?
8.1 CONSUMPTION
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
285
As we know household consumption expenditure is one of the major components
of aggregate demand or aggregate expenditure in an economy. We also know
that households spend their income (apart from savings) on consumption of final
goods and services for the satisfaction of their basic wants. Consumption may
thus be defined as the expenditure by households on final goods and services.
The main elements of household consumption are expenditures on food, housing,
clothing, transportation, medical care, etc.
Table 8.1 also clearly shows that the relationship between income and consumption
expenditure is always positive or direct.
8.1 CONSUMPTION
Grade 11 Economics
286
Determinants of Consumption Expenditure
The previous section discussed consumption expenditure at the individual
(household) level. Adding together individual consumption expenditures gives us
national consumption expenditure. As discussed earlier, consumption expenditure
as a macroeconomic variable (national consumption expenditure) is crucial to
any economy’s performance.
C = f (Yd) (8.1)
Where C = consumption expenditure, and
Yd = personal disposable income.
8.1 CONSUMPTION
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
287
C = a + bYd, where a is autonomous consumption, b is percentage
of income for consumption, and bYd is induced consumption.
Example: Consider a consumer with a consumption function given by
C = 110 + 0.75Yd, and disposable income of Birr 4,800. Calculate
the consumer’s:
a autonomous consumption
b induced consumption
c total consumption
d saving
Solution: Given: Consumption function C = 110 + 0.75Yd
Disposable income = 4,800
a Autonomous consumption is the level of consumption when income
is zero. Thus,
Autonomous consumption = 110 + 0.75 × 0 = 110
b Induced consumption is = Total consumption
– Autonomous consumption
Induced consumption = 0.75 × 4,800 = 3,600
c Total consumption = Autonomous consumption
+ Induced consumption
= 110 + 3,600 = 3,710
d Saving = Yd – C = 4,800 – 3,600 = 1,200
S = Yd – bYd
Note that propensity to consume does not mean desire to consume. It means the
actual consumption that takes place, or is expected to take place, out of varying
levels of income. A distinction may be made here between consumption and
consumption function. Consumption refers to the amount of income which is
spent upon the purchase of goods and services at a given level of income, but
consumption function refers to the whole of a schedule that shows consumption
expenditure at various levels of income.
S
+
C
=
0 50
Y
d
C
50 75
(C = Yd)
100 100
150 125
200 150 C
250 175
300 200
Figure 8.1: Consumption function
curve
Consider the preceding Table 8.2 and Figure 8.1 for the hypothetical situation,
and note the following facts:
Consumption increases with increase in income. When income level
is zero, the minimum level of consumption is Birr 50 million in our
hypothetical situation. When income is Birr 100 million, consumption
is also Birr 100 million. When income exceeds Birr 100 million,
consumption also increases, but it lags behind the increase in income.
Consumption (i.e., autonomous consumption) can never be zero, even
if income is zero, because a minimum level of consumption must be
maintained for survival. That is why the consumption function curve
starts from point C and not from zero. In such a situation, the economy
draws on past savings in the absence of current income. In the figure,
OC is the minimum level of consumption.
The 45° line Yd = C + S is called the expenditure equals income line.
Its significance is that each point on this line shows expenditure equal
to income. Comparing the consumption function curve with the 45° line
for any point tells us whether consumption is equal to, greater than or
less than income level.
The point at which the consumption function Note:
curve intersects the 45° line is known as the
break-even point. It indicates equality between The amount of dissaving
or positive saving is
consumption and income. Above the 45° line, measured by the vertical
consumption spending is more than income distance between the
(indicating dissaving), whereas below this line consumption curve and
consumption expenditure is less than income the 45° line.
(indicating positive saving).
8.1 CONSUMPTION
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
289
Line CC represents the consumption function curve, which is also
simply called the consumption curve.
The relationships between consumption and income (propensity to consume)
are expressed in the following ways. The next sections describe their numerical
expressions.
i Average Propensity to Consume (APC)
ii Marginal Propensity to Consume (MPC)
Thus the value of APC may be greater than 1, because when income is at a very
low level, consumption exceeds income to meet the very basic necessities. (Then
saving becomes negative).
Consumption APC
Income (in million Birr) C
(in million Birr)
(Yd)
(C) Yd
200 150 0.75
250 175 0.7
300 200 0.66
8.1 CONSUMPTION
Grade 11 Economics
290
Y
8.1 CONSUMPTION
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
291
(i.e., MPC > 0), but the entire increase in income is not spent on consumption
(i.e., MPC < 1).
MPC
Income (in Change Consumption Change in
million Birr) in Income (in million birr) Consumption ∆C
(Yd) (ΔYd) (C) (ΔC) ∆Yd
150 — 100 — —
250 100 150 50 0.5
350 100 175 25 0.25
Table 8.4 shows that, with increase in income, consumption also increases but
by less than the increase in income. In the hypothetical situation, when income
increased from Birr 150 million to 250 million, consumption increased from Birr
100 million to Birr 150 million. Therefore,
ΔC 50
MPC = = = 0.50
ΔYd 100
Yd
Yd Yd1
8.1 CONSUMPTION
Grade 11 Economics
292
Properties of MPC
The following are the main properties of MPC.
MPC is greater than zero but less than one This is because, with an
increase in income, consumption expenditure also increases. But the
entire increase in income is not spent — part of it is saved. Thus,
MPC > 0, but MPC < 1.
MPC falls with increase in income As the community becomes richer,
it tends to consume a smaller percentage of each increment to its
aggregate income.
MPC of the poor class is higher than those of other classes: In the case
of poor people, most of their basic needs remain unfulfilled. As a result,
an additional increment to income leads to greater consumption.
MPC is stable in the short run: This is because it depends upon
psychological factors which do not change in the short run.
Activity 8.1
1 Suppose a given family has an income of Birr 10,000 and saves only Birr 500.
What is its average propensity to consume? Can you tell from this information
about the MPC of the family?
2 Assume for the above example that the income of the family rises to Birr 12,000
and, as a result, the family increases the amount that it saves to Birr 700. What is
the marginal propensity to consume?
3 Suppose that a given family spends Birr 2,000 at zero income and then, as its
income increases, it spends 80 per cent of it on consumption over and above
the Birr 2,000. What is the family’s total consumption spending when its income
is Birr 20,000?
4 Answer the following:
a Can the value of APC be greater than one? Give reasons for your answer.
b Can the value of MPC be greater than one? Give reasons for your answer.
c Copy and complete the following tabulation. Its values are in million Birr.
8.1 CONSUMPTION
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
293
5 In your economics workgroup, discuss the relationship between income and
consumption.
6 In your economics workgroup, discuss and answer this question: How does
MPC affect the level of national income?
8.2 SAVING
At the end of this section, you will be able to:
explain what saving is; and
identify the determinant of saving.
Start-up Activity
Comment on the saving habits of your family members.
The part of income which is not spent on consumption is called savings. This
is because income is either consumed or saved. Thus, we may say ‘Savings is
an excess of income over consumption expenditure’. By deducting consumption
expenditure (C) from income (Yd), we get savings (S). Symbolically:
S = Yd – C (8.4)
Determinants of Saving
The major determinants of saving at the individual and national levels are:
Level of Income: As stated above, as income increases, saving also
increases. But the rate of increase in saving is higher than the rate
8.2 SAVING
Grade 11 Economics
294
of increase in income. This is because, with an increase in income,
consumption increases but by less than the increase in income.
Distribution of Income: Saving increases when income inequality
increases. This is because the tendency to save is greater for rich people
than poor people.
Expectation Future for the: If prices are expected to fall in the future,
present consumption is less, and hence saving is more. This principle
also acts inversely. Similarly, an expected future increase in income,
reduces present saving, and the inverse.
Rate of Interest: A higher rate of interest induces greater saving. This
principle also acts inversely.
Level of Wealth: A lower wealth level leads to a lower saving level.
This principle also acts inversely.
Level of Direct Taxes: A higher level of direct taxes produces a lower
level of personal disposable income and hence reduced savings. This
principle also acts inversely.
Individual Nature: Saving is directly related to the nature of the
individual. For example, a miser saves more than a spendthrift.
Saving Function
The functional relationship between saving and income is called saving function
(or propensity to save). The saving function is the proportion of income which is
saved. Thus saving (S) is a function (f) of income (Yd). Symbolically:
S = f (Yd) or S = Yd – C (8.5)
The saving function shows the tendency of households to save at given levels of
income. Thus the saving function is a corollary or reciprocal of the consumption
function.
8.2 SAVING
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
295
Table 8.5: Hypothetical Saving Function Schedule (in million Birr)
Table 8.6 shows that saving (S) tends to increase with income (Yd). When income
is zero, saving is negative because consumption exceeds income. When income
in our hypothetical schedule increases beyond Birr 100 million, saving increases
faster than income. Figure 8.4 also shows that saving is negative until income
reaches Birr 100 million. After Birr 100 million, saving increases with every
increase in income.
Y
8.2 SAVING
Grade 11 Economics
296
function, and Part B shows the saving function. Observe from the figure that the
saving function is the mirror image of the consumption function.
(Yd)
8.2 SAVING
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
297
S 75
APS = = = 0.3 or 30% = 0.3 or 30%
Yd 250
Table 8.7 demonstrates APS estimations, using a hypothetical situation.
Table 8.6: Hypothetical APS estimation
APS
Income (in million Birr) Saving (in million Birr) S
(Yd) (S)
Yd
200 50 0.25
250 75 0.3
300 100 0.33
∆S
MPS = (8.7)
∆Yd
8.2 SAVING
Grade 11 Economics
298
For example, if a country’s national income increases from Birr 200 million to
Birr 250 million, and saving increases from Birr 50 million to Birr 75 million,
then
∆S 25
MPS = = = 0.50
∆Yd 50
Table 8.7 shows MPS estimation, using a hypothetical situation.
Table 8.7: Hypothetical MPS estimation
MPS
Income (in million Birr) Saving (in million Birr) ∆S
∆Yd ∆S
(Yd) (S)
∆Yd
150 – 50 – –
250 100 100 50 0.50
350 100 175 75 0.75
Table 8.7 shows that, when income increases, saving also increases. When income
increases in the hypothetical situation from Birr 150 million to Birr 250 million,
saving increases from Birr 50 million to Birr 100 million. Therefore,
∆S 50
MPS = = = 0.50
∆Yd 100
Yd
Yd Yd1
In Figure 8.7, when income is OYd = 150, saving is AYd = 50. When income
increases to OYd1 = 250, saving increases to BYd1 = 100. Thus ΔYd = 100 and
ΔS = 50. Therefore MPS at point B,
8.2 SAVING
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
299
ΔS BC 50
B= = = = 0.50
ΔYd AC 100
Properties of MPS
The main properties of MPS are:
Value of MPS lies between 0 and 1. In other words, 0 < MPS < 1.
MPS increases with increase in income.
The MPS of the poor is lower than that of the rich.
Start-up Activity
What is your personal opinion of this statement? “Many Ethiopian families do not
know how to balance their consumption and saving levels for their households.”?
As you already know, the consumption function and the saving function are
interrelated and counterparts of each other. Consumption and saving both depend
on income, and their sum total is equal to total income i.e., C + S = Yd. From this,
it also follows that the concepts of APC and MPC are respectively related to the
concepts of APS and MPS.
Relationship between APC and APS
We know Yd = C + S, dividing both sides by Yd, we get
Yd C S
= +
Yd Yd Yd
1 = APC + APS
Note that the value of APS is negative when consumption expenditure is greater
than income.
∆Yd ∆C ∆S
= +
∆Yd ∆Yd ∆Yd
∆C ∆S
1= +
∆Yd ∆Yd
1 = MPC + MPS
We may conclude: the sum of MPC and MPS is always equal to unity (1). The
following list shows this inter-relationship:
APC + APS = 1
APS = 1 – APC
APC = 1 – APS
MPC + MPS = 1
MPS = 1 – MPC
MPC = 1 – MPS
Activity 8.2
1 Can the value of APS be negative? If so, when? Give an example in support of
your answer.
2 What is the maximum possible value of MPS?
3 What is the value of MPC when MPS = 0?
5 If disposable income is Birr 1000, and consumption expenditure is Birr 700, what
is the average propensity to save? Can you use this information to calculate the
marginal propensity to save?
6 Calculate MPS from the following data:
Income (Birr) Saving (Birr)
100 60
200 100
7 In your economics work group, discuss the relationship between income and
saving. Create a diagram that interprets the result of your discussion.
8.4 INVESTMENT
At the end of this section, you will be able to:
define investment;
state the determinants of investment; and
appreciate about the impact of investment on economic growth.
Start-up Activity
What type of investment activities are occurring in your locality? Comment the overall
activities of such investments.
Meaning of Investment
In economics, the meaning of investment is quite different from its common use
by an ordinary person who speaks of ‘investing’ when he or she purchases a
piece of land, an old house, securities, debentures, etc. In economic analysis,
these transactions are simply the transfer of ownership rights from one person
to the other and, as such, result in no increase in income and employment. In
economics, investment means an addition, during a predefined ‘current period’,
8.4 INVESTMENT
Grade 11 Economics
302
to national resources such as:
existing stock of physical (or real) assets for example, the building of
new factories, new machines or equipment;
existing stock of finished goods or raw materials.
Induced Investment
Induced investment is investment which is made with the motive of earning a
profit as in the private sector. Induced investment depends directly upon profit
expectations. It is income-elastic. If national income goes up, induced investment
also goes up – an increase in income induces investment. This occurs because
an increase in national income leads to an increase in the demand for goods
and services, which increases investor interest in meeting that demand, and
therefore leads to investment. Thus, we can say that induced investment takes
place when levels of income and demand in the economy go up. That is why the
induced investment curve, like the supply curve, is positively sloped, as shown in
Figure 8.8.
Y
Yd1 Yd2
Autonomous Investment
Autonomous investment refers to investment which is made irrespective of income
level. This approach is generally taken in the government sector. Autonomous
investment is income inelastic – it is not affected by changes in income level.
8.4 INVESTMENT
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
303
The volume of autonomous investment is the same at all levels of income. That is
why the autonomous investment curve is a straight line, parallel to the X-axis, as
shown in Figure 8.9. Autonomous investment is generally affected by autonomous
factors (other than income) such as public utility works, construction of railways
and roads, changes in the nature of consumer demand, increase in population,
discovery of new resources, new technology, etc. For instance, government
investment in public utilities like the construction of railways, roads, post and
telegraph, electricity, etc., is normally autonomous investment.
Autonomous factors
Figure 8.9: Autonomous factors
Remark: Any investment made for the purpose of compensating for depreciation
caused by production in a current year is not real investment. Rather, it is what is
sometimes known as replacement investment.
Determinants of Investment
The basic motive for any private sector entrepreneur to invest is to earn profits
(which, as you know, is the excess of revenue over production cost). Thus
expectation of profit is the main determinant of the level of investment in an
economy. Here is more information about this factor and about related factors
and determinants of investment.
Profit Expectation: Business investment depends upon the expectations
of the business firms involved. If the business people feel confident that
opportunities for making profits in the future exist, they will be prepared
8.4 INVESTMENT
Grade 11 Economics
304
to undertake investment expenditure. On the other hand, if they do not
expect to make profits, they will not invest.
^ Rate of Interest: After business expectation of profit opportunities
is taken into account, investment depends upon the rate of interest,
on the one hand, and upon the expected rate of return on capital.
This expected rate of return is called marginal efficiency of capital
or marginal efficiency of investment.
^ If investment is to be profitable, then the expected rate of profit
cannot be less than the current rate of interest in the market. For
instance, if an entrepreneur finds out that funds for a project must
be borrowed at a 15% interest rate, then the proposed investment
would be undertaken only if the project’s expected rate of profit
were more than 15%. We thus see that investment depends upon the
marginal efficiency of investment, on the one hand, and upon the
rate of interest, on the other.
Corporate Tax: Taxes are imposed by governments on corporations. A
corporation uses part of its revenues to pay these taxes. The higher the
tax rate is, the more that paying taxes reduces revenues and, in turn,
reduces profits. Therefore, we can say that a decrease in the rate of
corporate tax induces investment. This principle also acts inversely.
Level of National Income: If national income goes up, induced
investment also goes up. The reason is that an increase in national
income leads to an increase in the demand for goods and services
and in investors’ interest in supplying them, which leads to increased
investment. Therefore, we can say that a higher level of national output
induces investment. This principle also acts inversely.
Activity 8.3
In your economics work group, discuss and answer this question: How does induced
investment depend upon the market rate of interest? Create a graphic presentation
of the results of your discussion.
Practical Work
1 Answer each of these questions and then consider the solutions.
a If APS is 0.6, how much is APC?
Solution: APC = 1 – APS = 1 – 0.6 = 0.4
8.4 INVESTMENT
Grade 11 Economics
306
b If APC is 0.7, how much is APS?
Solution: APC + APS = 1, therefore APS = 1 – 0.7 = 0.3
c If MPC is 0.75, what is MPS?
Solution: MPS = 1 – MPC = 1 – 0.75 = 0.25
d If APC is 0.75, how much is APS?
Solution: APS = 1 – APC = 1 – 0.75 = 0.25
e If MPS = 1, how much is MPC?
Solution: MPC = 1 – MPS = 1 – 1 = 0
f From the following income consumption schedule, calculate:
i saving
ii average propensity to consume
iii marginal propensity to consume
Solution:
APC MPC
Consumption Saving (S) C ∆C
Income (Yd)
(C) (Y d− C) Yd ∆Yd
0 60 –60 ∞ —
100 110 –10 1.10 0.50
200 150 50 0.75 0.40
300 180 120 0.60 0.30
400 200 200 0.50 0.20
8.4 INVESTMENT
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
307
Solution:
APS MPS
Income Savings S ∆S
(Yd) (S)
Yd ∆Yd
100 20 0.20 —
200 80 0.40 0.60
300 150 0.50 0.70
Solution:
8.4 INVESTMENT
Grade 11 Economics
308
Unit Review
UNIT SUMMARY
Consumption refers to the amount of income which is spent by
households to purchase final goods and services.
Autonomous consumption is consumption when income is zero.
Induced consumption is consumption which varies with income.
Determinants of induced consumption are:
^ Money income ^ Expectations of the
^ Distribution of income future price
^ Level of direct taxes ^ Rate of interest
^ Level of wealth
Consumption function shows the relationship between consumption
level and income level C = f (Yd) C = a + b Yd
The break-even point is the point in income level at which consumption
expenditure is exactly equal to income and there is no saving.
Average propensity to consume (APC) is the ratio between total
consumption and total income.
C
APC =
Yd
Marginal propensity to consume (MPC) is the ratio of change in
consumption to change in income.
∆C
MPC =
∆Yd
Savings is that part of income which is not spent on consumption S = Yd – C.
Determinants of savings are:
Level of income Rate of interest
Distribution of income Level of wealth
Future expectations of Level of direct taxes
price Individual nature
The saving function shows the relationship between saving level
and income level S = f(Y). Consumption and saving functions are
complementary.
Average propensity to save (APS) is the ratio between total saving and
total income.
S
APS =
Yd
Unit Review
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
309
Marginal propensity to save (MPS) is the ratio between change in
saving and change in income.
∆S
MPS =
∆Yd
MPS value lies between 0 and 1. APC + APS = 1. MPC + MPS = 1.
Investment means the expenditure by people or business firms on the
purchase or production of new capital goods such as machinery,
factories, tools, houses, etc., which leads to the addition to the stock
of capital in the economy. Investment also includes additions to the
inventories of consumer goods and raw materials.
Induced investment is investment made with the motive of earning
profits.
Autonomous investment is investment which is made irrespective of
income level.
Determinants of investment are:
Profit expectations Corporate tax
Rate of interest Level of national income.
Unit Review
Grade 11 Economics
310
11 What do you mean by private investment and public investment?
12 Explain the concept of induced investment and autonomous investment.
13 “Autonomous investment is income-inelastic”. Explain this statement,
using an example.
14 Describe the main determinants of investment.
15 Explain the role of investment in economic growth.
II Distinguish between the following:
16 Private investment and public investment
17 Induced investment and autonomous investment
18 Average propensity to consume and marginal propensity to consume
19 Average propensity to save and marginal propensity to save
20 Marginal propensity to consume and marginal propensity to save
III For each of the following statements, indicate whether it is
‘True’ or ‘False’.
21 The relationship between disposable income and consumption is known as
propensity to consume.
22 Investment is the part of income which is used for the creation of new
capital assets.
23 Demand for investment continues increasing as rate of interest increases.
24 At the break-even point, consumption is more than income.
25 The value of APC can be greater than 1.
26 MPC increases with increase in income.
27 As income increases, saving also increases.
28 The tendency to save is less for rich people than for poor people.
29 A lower level of wealth leads to a lower level of saving.
30 A higher level of direct taxes leads to increased saving.
IV For each of the following, four choices are given, but only one
out of them is correct. Choose the correct one.
31 At the break-even point:
A disposable income is equal to consumption
B income is less than consumption
C income is more than consumption
D none of the above.
Unit Review
Unit 8: CONSUMPTION, SAVING AND INVESTMENT
311
32 Important considerations for making investments are:
A safety of funds
B rate of interest
C return on investment
D all of the above
33 The consumption function is a relationship between:
A level of consumption and investment
B level of income and consumption
C level of income and saving
D level of consumption and saving
34 The saving function is a relationship between:
A level of saving and investment
B level of saving and consumption
C level of saving and income
D none of the above
35 Autonomous investment is:
A income-inelastic
B income-elastic
C dependent upon rate of interest
D dependent upon rate of corporate tax
Unit Review
Grade 11 Economics
312
VI Write very short answers to the following.
40 Can consumption be greater than income?
41 What type of relationship is found between consumption and income?
42 What is the relationship between MPC and MPS?
43 What is the relationship between APC and APS?
44 What is the value of MPS when MPC = 0?
45 How much is MPS in an economy in which MPC = 0.6?
46 How much is MPC in an economy in which MPS = 0.2?
47 If APC = 0.65, how much is APS?
48 If APS = 0.26, how much is APC?
49 If disposable income is Birr 1200, and consumption expenditure is Birr
800, what is APS?
50 If disposable income is Birr 2000, and saving is Birr 500, what is APC?
51 Mention two factors that determine the level of investment in an economy.
52 Mention two factors that determine the level of saving in an economy.
53 Consumption at zero level of income is known by what name?
54 What is the impact of an increase in the rate of corporate tax on the level of
investment in an economy?
55 If the consumption function of a given individual is given as
C = 44 + 0.86Yd, and the individual’s disposable income for a specific
period was Birr 3600, then calculate the:
a autonomous consumption
b induced consumption
c total consumption
d saving
e APC and APS
Unit Review