8. NOI Extra Questions and answers
8. NOI Extra Questions and answers
These three types of suffering are inherent to the material world and are
experienced by all living beings to varying degrees. They arise due to the
conditioned nature of existence and the interactions between the material
elements, living entities, and higher powers. The purpose of spiritual practice, such
as Krishna consciousness, is to transcend these material sufferings and attain a
state of eternal bliss and spiritual realization.
From the first paragraph in the Purport up to the paragraph starting, "According to
nature's arrangement..." we see Srila Prabhupada presenting a brilliant description
of the material phenomenon. Can you summarize this, put it in a more rigid linear
order?
Srila Prabhupada discusses various aspects of material attachments and bodily
demands. He explains that unrestricted attachment and anger arising from
frustration are the two divisions of the agitations of the bickering mind. Adherence
to certain philosophies and materialistic desires lead to these agitations. The
demands of the body are categorized into the tongue, belly, and genitals. Srila
Prabhupada suggests that by controlling the tongue and limiting its activities to
eating prasada (food offered to Krishna), one can automatically control the urges of
the belly and genitals. He quotes a verse by Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura that
emphasizes the difficulty of conquering the tongue but acknowledges the help of
Krishna in providing prasada to overcome this challenge. Srila Prabhupada also
mentions the different tastes (rasas) that can agitate a person and lead to
uncontrolled eating for sense gratification. He advises Krishna conscious individuals
to give up eating for sense pleasure and instead accept only remnants of food
offered to Krishna. Additionally, he mentions the proper foods to offer to the Lord
and warns against indulging in substances and activities that fulfill illicit demands.
How does SB 1.2.9, "dharmasy hi apavargasya..." cites in this Purport related to the
Text?
This verse emphasizes that everything within the universe is controlled and owned
by the Lord, and one should live peacefully by following the principle of plain living
and high thinking. The verse criticizes materialists who misuse their intelligence to
accumulate material possessions and exploit others for sense gratification. It
suggests that when society gives up these faults and follows the principles of
devotional service, enmity and problems of economic and political instability will
cease. This verse highlights the importance of understanding the complete
arrangement of the Lord and living in harmony with it.
What is "The first step in human civilization"? How is this related to the word
dharma? How does this control atyhara?
The first step in human civilization, as mentioned in the provided document,
consists of occupational engagements performed according to the scriptural
injunctions. This means that individuals should engage in their respective duties and
responsibilities according to the principles and guidelines set forth in religious
scriptures. This is related to the word dharma because dharma refers to one's duty
or righteous path in life. By following the principles of dharma, individuals can lead
Classified
complicated machine, and his brain, as well as the ingredients, were supplied by
Kṛṣṇa.
Que: Discuss the importance for all devotees, of applying the dadati principle in
relation to spending at least fifty percent of one's income in the service of the Lord
and His devotees
Ans: This principle serves as an example for all devotees to follow. By dedicating a
significant portion of their income to the service of the Lord and His devotees,
devotees can fulfill the demands of dadati and actively contribute to the
propagation of Krishna consciousness.
Que: Discuss ways in which you can improve facilitating the six kinds of
loving exchanges between devotees.
Ans: In order to improve facilitating the six kinds of loving exchanges between
devotees, one can focus on the following:
Creating a welcoming and inclusive environment: Ensure that all devotees feel
accepted and valued within the community. Encourage open communication,
respect for diversity, and a spirit of cooperation.
Organizing regular gatherings and events: Arrange programs, festivals, and
gatherings where devotees can come together to engage in devotional activities,
such as kirtan, bhajans, and discourses. These events provide opportunities for
Classified
Overall, the relevance of this statement for members of the Krishna consciousness
movement lies in preserving the purity of the movement, protecting one's
consciousness, utilizing contributions effectively, and maintaining association with
like-minded devotees. By adhering to these principles, devotees c
Q: Discuss the significance of the verse 'Nitya-siddha Krsna Prema...' (CC
Madhya 22.107 NOI text 4) in relation to spreading the Krsna
consciousness movement.
This verse states that pure love for Krishna is eternally established in the hearts of
living entities and is not something to be gained from an external source. When the
heart is purified by hearing and chanting, the dormant Krishna consciousness within
the living entity is awakened.
This verse highlights the inherent nature of Krishna consciousness within every
living being. It emphasizes that everyone should be given the opportunity to hear
about Krishna and engage in the process of hearing and chanting the holy name. By
engaging in these devotional practices, one's heart is cleansed of mundane
contamination, and their original Krishna consciousness is awakened.
In the context of spreading the Krishna consciousness movement, this verse
underscores the importance of providing opportunities for people to hear and chant
about Krishna. By spreading the message of Krishna consciousness and facilitating
the process of hearing an
Que: How does Srila Prabhupada use the verse, "Nitya siddha Krsna
Prema..." in the context of these six loving exchanges?
Ans: He explains that pure love for Krishna is eternally established in the hearts of
living entities and is not something to be gained from an external source.
In the context of the six loving exchanges mentioned earlier in the document, Srila
Prabhupada uses this verse to highlight the transformative power of hearing and
chanting the holy name of Krishna. He states that by engaging in the process of
hearing and chanting, one's heart is directly purified, and their dormant Krishna
consciousness is awakened.
By associating with devotees and participating in the six kinds of loving exchanges,
an ordinary person can fully revive their dormant Krishna consciousness. Srila
Prabhupada emphasizes that Krishna consciousness is already present within every
living entity to some extent, and by engaging in devotional practices, such as
hearing and chanting, one can awaken and nourish that inherent Krishna
consciousness.
Therefore, Srila Prabhupada uses the verse "nitya-siddha Krishna-Prema 'Sadhya'
kabhu Naya" to emphasize the importance of providing opportunities for people to
associate with devotees, hear about Krishna, and engage in devotional activities.
Through these processes, individuals can purify their hearts, awaken their dormant
Krishna consciousness, and experience the transformative power of the Krishna
consciousness movement.
Classified
Que: What happened when Lord Chaitanya gave the Holy Names,
Sankirtan, as a gift in the Jharkhand Forest?
Ans: The tigers, snakes, deer, and all other animals present in the forest abandoned
their natural animosity towards each other and began chanting and dancing in
sankirtan, the congregational chanting of the holy names of the Lord. This incident
demonstrated the transformative power of the holy names of Krishna.
The animals, who are considered to be in lower species of life, were purified and
prepared to become fully Krishna conscious simply by hearing the transcendental
vibration of the Hare Krishna mantra. Lord Chaitanya's presence and the chanting of
the holy names had such a profound effect that even the animals were able to
experience spiritual awakening and engage in devotional activities.
This incident serves as an example of the potency of the holy names and the
universal nature of Krishna consciousness. It shows that the chanting of the holy
names has the power to purify and uplift not only human beings but also all living
entities, regardless of their species. It highlights the all-encompassing nature of the
Krishna consciousness movement and its ability to bring about spiritual
transformation and unity among all beings.
It is important to note that while we may not have the same ability as Lord
Chaitanya to enchant animals and make them chant and dance, we can still follow
in His footsteps by spreading the holy names of Krishna and sharing the teachings
of Krishna consciousness with others. By doing so, we can help people from all
walks of life, including animals, to awaken their dormant love for Krishna and
experience the spiritual bliss that comes with it.
Que: Can we make the animals Krsna conscious by giving the charity of
the Holy Names? Explain
Ans: it is mentioned that even the souls embodied in lower animals, insects, trees,
and other species of life can become purified and prepared to become fully Krishna
conscious simply by hearing the transcendental vibration of the Hare Krishna
mantra. It is explained that the chanting of the holy names is so powerful that even
if one chants in the remotest parts of the jungle, the trees and animals will advance
in Krishna consciousness simply by hearing the vibration.
While we may not have the ability to directly make animals Krishna conscious, the
document suggests that by chanting the holy names of the Lord, we can contribute
to the spiritual well-being of all living entities, including animals. The vibration of the
holy names has a purifying effect on the consciousness of all beings, and it can
create a positive spiritual influence in their lives. The example of Sri Caitanya
Mahaprabhu passing through the forest of Jharikhanda, where the animals
abandoned their natural animosity and began chanting and dancing in sankirtana,
illustrates the transformative power of the holy names.
Therefore, by regularly chanting and spreading the holy names of Krishna, we can
indirectly contribute to the spiritual awakening of animals and other living entities.
The vibration of the holy names has the potential to purify their hearts and awaken
their dormant love for Krishna. While we may not be able to directly influence
animals to chant or dance, our sincere and dedicated practice of Krishna
Classified
consciousness can create a positive spiritual atmosphere that can benefit all beings,
including animals, in their spiritual journey.
Que: What distinguishes animal society from human society? Cite the
verse,"sa via pumsam..." to help explain this.
The verse "sa vai pumsam paro dharmo yato bhaktir adhoksaje" from Srimad
Bhagavatam (1.2.6) distinguishes human society from animal society. The verse
states that the highest duty or occupation for human beings is to engage in
devotional service to the Supreme Lord, Adhoksaja.
This verse highlights the unique potential of human beings to cultivate a loving
relationship with the Supreme Lord. Unlike animals, who are primarily driven by
instinctual needs and survival, human beings have the capacity for self-realization
and spiritual growth. They possess the intelligence and free will to understand their
spiritual nature and engage in devotional activities.
By engaging in devotional service, humans can transcend the limitations of material
existence and attain a higher spiritual purpose. They can develop a loving
relationship with the Supreme Lord, which is the ultimate goal of human life. This
verse emphasizes that the true essence of human society lies in the cultivation of
devotion to the Supreme Lord.
In contrast, animal society is primarily concerned with fulfilling basic material needs
and instincts. Animals are not capable of engaging in conscious devotional service
or understanding higher spiritual truths. They operate on a more instinctual level,
driven by survival, reproduction, and basic needs.
Therefore, the verse "sa vai pumsam paro dharmo yato bhaktir adhoksaje"
highlights the unique opportunity and responsibility of human beings to engage in
devotional service and realize their spiritual potential. It distinguishes human
society from animal society by emphasizing the importance of cultivating a loving
relationship with the Supreme Lord and engaging in activities that promote spiritual
growth and self-realization.
Que: Is it O.K. to offer bread cooked in the general market if there is no
meat, fish or eggs in it? Explain using the cited verse, "visayera anna
koila...". How do you see this applied amongst ISKCON devotees including
yourself?
No, it’s not ok to offer outside food except what is naturally extracted from plants
like grains and fruits. The phrase "viṣayīra anna khāile duṣṭa haya mana" translates
to "By eating food prepared by worldly people, one's mind becomes wicked." This
statement is a warning given by Śrī Caitanya Mahāprabhu, emphasizing the
importance of being cautious about the food we consume and the association we
keep. It suggests that if we partake in food prepared by those who are
materialistic and not engaged in spiritual practices, it can have a negative
influence on our consciousness and lead to a degraded state of mind.
Therefore, it is advised to be mindful of the source and quality of the food
we consume, as well as the company we keep. Amongst ISKCON devotees we
only consume food prepared by devotees and offered to the lord i.e. Prasadam and
Classified
avoid eating out at other places. SP has created Govinda's restaurant keeping in
mind that Devotees may need to eat out sometimes.
Que: How does the program given to us by Srila Prabhu pada help elevate
candidates from neophyte to Madhyama platform?
This program includes the following elements:
Accepting Diksha: The candidate must be serious about accepting diksha, which
involves initiation into the spiritual path. They must be prepared to practice
austerity, celibacy, and control of the mind and body.
Approaching a Spiritual Master: The candidate should approach a bona fide spiritual
master who can guide them in their spiritual journey. The spiritual master imparts
transcendental knowledge and initiates the candidate into the chanting of the holy
names of Krishna.
Following Instructions: It is essential to follow the instructions of the spiritual master
without deviation. The candidate should be inquisitive and eager to learn from the
bona fide spiritual master, asking inquiries that pertain to transcendental science.
Classified
Chanting the Holy Names: The candidate should chant the Hare Krishna maha-
mantra offenselessly, carefully avoiding the ten offenses. By chanting the holy
names, one gradually elevates their consciousness and develops a deeper
understanding of the Lord and His transcendental nature.
Service to the Lord: The candidate should seriously engage in the service of the
Lord. By dedicating oneself to devotional service, one develops a loving relationship
with the Lord and progresses in Krishna consciousness.
By diligently following this program, gradually increasing one's rounds of chanting,
and sincerely serving the Lord, a neophyte devotee can elevate themselves to the
madhyama-adhikari platform, which is a higher level of spiritual advancement.
Que: Refute misconceptions regarding the gosvami title with reference to
Srila Prabhupada's statements in this regard in NOI text 6 purport
The gosvami title is not hereditary: Srila Prabhupada explains that the gosvami title
is not based on material considerations, caste, or heredity. It is the monopoly of
pure devotees who have attained mastery over their senses through devotional
service.
Rupa Gosvami and Sanatana Gosvami: Srila Prabhupada gives the example of Rupa
Gosvami and Sanatana Gosvami, who were born in Muslim families and had
changed their names. However, Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu Himself made them
gosvamis, emphasizing that the title is not based on birth or family background.
Devotees should not be discriminated against: Srila Prabhupada emphasizes that
devotees coming from other families should not be discriminated against. Whether
they come from a family of previous acaryas or an ordinary family, they should be
treated equally.
American gosvamis are nondifferent: Srila Prabhupada addresses the undercurrent
of protest against awarding the title gosvami to American Vaisnavas. He states that
an American gosvami and a gosvami in a family of acaryas are nondifferent
according to the statements of Srila Rupa Gosvami.
Jealousy and material pride: Srila Prabhupada warns against jealousy and material
pride. He explains that as soon as one becomes materially puffed up, he falls down.
The Krishna consciousness movement is meant for paramahamsas who are
completely free from all jealousy.
Offense at the lotus feet of a Vaisnava: Srila Prabhupada emphasizes the
seriousness of committing an offense at the lotus feet of a Vaisnava. He compares it
to the mad elephant offense, which can create a disaster. One should be careful not
to commit any offense against a Vaisnava and should be ready to take instructions
from a superior Vaisnava.
By referring to Srila Prabhupada's statements in this purport, it becomes clear that
the gosvami title is not based on birth
Que: Explain the term 'empowered Vaisnava' and describe the appropriate
attitude toward dealing with an 'empowered Vaisnava'. (NOI text 6)
Recognizing the empowerment: Srila Prabhupada emphasizes that an empowered
Vaisnava is not an ordinary person. They have received special empowerment from
the Supreme Lord or His representative to execute important missions. It is
Classified
"...it is stated that unless one is empowered by Kṛṣṇa, one cannot spread the Kṛṣṇa
consciousness movement all over the world." What is the text Srila Prabhupada is
citing here?
An empowered person who is actually engaged in the confidential service of the
Lord should not be treated as an ordinary human being, for it is stated that unless
one is empowered by Kṛṣṇa, one cannot spread the Kṛṣṇa consciousness movement
all over the world. 2nd last para Text 6
Que: Once we are liberated and come to the Paramahamsa platform, is I
possible to fall-down? Explain including history of the falldown of
Maharaja Bharata.
The Paramahamsa platform refers to the highest stage of spiritual realization, where
one has attained complete liberation and is fully absorbed in pure devotional
service to the Supreme Lord.
While it is theoretically possible for someone on the Paramahamsa platform to fall
Classified
down, it is extremely rare. The example of Maharaja Bharata is often cited in this
context. Maharaja Bharata was an advanced devotee who became overly attached
to a deer and lost his focus on his spiritual practices. As a result, he had to take
birth again to complete his spiritual journey.
The story of Maharaja Bharata serves as a cautionary tale to remind practitioners to
remain vigilant and not become complacent in their spiritual practices, even at
advanced stages. It highlights the importance of maintaining a sincere and steady
commitment to devotional service, avoiding distractions and attachments that may
divert one's focus from the ultimate goal of Krishna consciousness.
engage in activities that are not in accordance with the principles of dharma or
righteousness.
The similarity between karmis and vikarmis is that they both engage in materialistic
activities for their own sense enjoyment. However, the difference lies in the fact
that karmis, although attached to fruitive activities, are faithful to the directions of
the Vedas and perform sacrifices for the satisfaction of Lord Vishnu. They are
considered superior to vikarmis who act without Vedic knowledge and disregard the
principles of dharma.
Que: Is Raga-Anuga Bhakti introduced here? Give pro/con evidence. How
does it fit into the list of different levels of people?
Ans: Yes, raga-bhakti, or devotional service in spontaneous love, is introduced in this
Text 8.
Based on the provided context, the document discusses the process of devotional
service (bhakti) and the different levels or stages of practitioners. Here is a
breakdown of the information:
Neophyte Stage: In this stage, one is advised to give up all material desires and
engage in regulative devotional service according to scriptural directions. The focus
is on following rules and regulations and developing attachment to Krishna's name,
form, qualities, etc.
Rāga-bhakti: When a practitioner develops spontaneous love and attachment for
Krishna, they can engage in devotional service without strictly following the
regulative principles. This stage is called rāga-bhakti or devotional service in
spontaneous love.
Rāgānuga-bhakti: In this stage, the practitioner follows in the footsteps of one of
Krishna's eternal associates in Vrindavan. They aspire to have a similar relationship
with Krishna and engage in devotional service accordingly. This can be in different
rasas or relationships such as śānta (peaceful), dāsya (servitude), sakhya
(friendship), vātsalya (parental affection), or mādhurya (conjugal love).
In terms of pro/con evidence, it is important to note that the provided context does
not explicitly discuss the pros and cons of these different stages of devotional
service. The document primarily focuses on explaining the stages and the
recommended practices for each stage, rather than presenting a comparative
analysis.
Closed Book Essay Questions
Que9: Discuss the analogy of jaundice/sugar candy in relation to (the
importance of?) preaching Krsna consciousness. (NOI text 7)
Ans: The analogy of jaundice and sugar candy in relation to preaching Krishna
consciousness emphasizes the transformative power of chanting the holy names of
Krishna. Just as a person suffering from jaundice cannot taste the sweetness of
sugar candy and finds it bitter, a person afflicted by ignorance (avidya) cannot fully
relish the transcendental nature of Krishna and His pastimes. However, by regularly
and attentively chanting the holy name of Krishna, one's ignorance is gradually
destroyed, and their ability to taste the sweetness of Krishna consciousness is
Classified
Que: How would you answer the comment that in the NOI-11 it says that if
one bathes in Radha Kunda even once he can develop his love for Krsna in
the mood of the Gopis, but I bathed there several times when I was in
India but did not develop love in the mood of the Gopis.
Ans: Bathing in Radha-Kunda is considered a sacred and purifying activity, but the
true development of love in the mood of the gopis requires a sincere and dedicated
practice of devotional service, including cultivating the qualities of selflessness,
surrender, and deep absorption in Krishna's pastimes. It involves a deep
understanding and realization of the mood and emotions of the gopis, their selfless
love, and their complete dedication to Krishna.
While physical bathing in Radha-Kunda is a significant part of the devotional
practice, it is not the sole factor that determines the development of love in the
mood of the gopis. It is a gradual process that involves a sincere and heartfelt
connection with Krishna, a deep study and contemplation of the teachings of the
great acharyas, and the guidance of a bona fide spiritual teacher.
It is also important to remember that spiritual progress is individual and can vary
from person to person. Just because one has bathed in Radha-Kunda multiple times
does not guarantee an immediate realization of love in the mood of the gopis. It
requires a sincere and dedicated practice of devotional service over an extended
period.
Therefore, it is recommended to continue one's devotional practice with sincerity,
humility, and patience. By engaging in the process of devotional service, cultivating
a genuine desire to develop love for Krishna, and seeking the guidance of advanced
devotees, one can gradually progress towards the realization of love in the mood of
the gopis.
Que: How would you answer that it says in NOI-11 we should bath in
Radha Kunda, but we have heard that Srila Prabhu pada said that we
should not bath in RK?
While it is true that Srila Prabhu pada expressed caution regarding bathing in
Radha-Kunda, it is because of the need for proper understanding and reverence for
such a sacred place. Srila Prabhu pada emphasized the importance of approaching
Radha-Kunda with the proper mood of devotion and understanding of its
significance.
Srila Prabhu pada taught that the highest perfection of devotional service is to
develop a deep connection with Radha-Kunda and to serve Srimati Radharani under
the guidance of the gopis. This service is not limited to physical bathing but involves
cultivating a deep love and devotion for Radha and Krishna, understanding the
mood of the gopis, and engaging in devotional practices with sincerity and purity of
heart.
Srila Prabhu pada also emphasized the need for proper spiritual qualification and
realization before fully engaging in the service of Radha-Kunda. He advised
devotees to approach Radha-Kunda with humility, respect, and a deep
understanding of the spiritual significance of the place.
Therefore, while the statement in NOI-11 highlights the importance of Radha-Kunda
and its role in the perfection of devotional service, it is crucial to approach Radha-
Classified
We can help Lord Caitanya in His mission by actively participating in the Krishna
consciousness movement.
1.chanting the Hare Krishna mantra
2.studying and distributing Krishna conscious literature
3.engaging in devotional activities
4. associating with devotees
5. spreading the teachings of Lord Caitanya to others.