nt-using-load-cells-e-0122
nt-using-load-cells-e-0122
Using
load cells
Technology
Operating principle
Implementation
Page 2/78 NT-USING LOAD CELLS-E-0122
Table of Contents
1. Introduction............................................................................................................................... 4
2. Principle of load cells ............................................................................................................... 5
2.1. About load cells ............................................................................................................................. 5
2.2. Basics of strain gauges .................................................................................................................. 5
2.3. Wheatstone Bridge circuit ............................................................................................................ 6
2.4. Application to load cells............................................................................................................... 6
3. Type of cell loads ..................................................................................................................... 8
3.1. Single point load cells ................................................................................................................... 8
3.2. Bending beam load cells ........................................................................................................... 10
3.3. Shear beam load cells ................................................................................................................ 12
3.4. S-type load cells........................................................................................................................... 16
3.5. Column compression load cells................................................................................................. 17
3.6. Low profile compression load cells ........................................................................................... 20
3.7. Load pins ...................................................................................................................................... 23
4. Load cell specifications ......................................................................................................... 26
4.1. Legal metrology specifications .................................................................................................. 26
4.2. Capacity specifications .............................................................................................................. 28
4.3. Metrological specifications ........................................................................................................ 29
4.4. Electrical specifications .............................................................................................................. 30
4.5. Environmental protection level .................................................................................................. 31
5. Designing a weighing system ............................................................................................... 32
5.1. Compression versus tension ....................................................................................................... 32
5.2. Compression mounting kits ........................................................................................................ 33
5.3. Weighing system performance.................................................................................................. 38
5.4. How many load cells?................................................................................................................. 39
5.5. Weighing system capabilities ..................................................................................................... 40
5.6. Determination of the accuracy of the system......................................................................... 41
5.7. Load cell location ........................................................................................................................ 44
5.8. Load introduction ........................................................................................................................ 46
5.9. Structural integrity ........................................................................................................................ 47
5.10. Lift-off prevention devices .......................................................................................................... 50
5.11. Stabilisation devices .................................................................................................................... 51
5.12. Pivoted weighing system ............................................................................................................ 54
5.13. Piping connections ...................................................................................................................... 56
5.14. Environmental factors ................................................................................................................. 58
5.15. Calibration .................................................................................................................................... 63
6. Electrical wiring ...................................................................................................................... 66
6.1. General considerations .............................................................................................................. 66
6.2. 4-wire/6-wire load cells ............................................................................................................... 66
6.3. Multiple load cells connection .................................................................................................. 67
6.4. Cable extension ........................................................................................................................... 68
6.5. Grounding and shielding ............................................................................................................ 68
7. Load cell troubleshooting ...................................................................................................... 69
7.1. In general ..................................................................................................................................... 69
7.2. Load cell test procedure ............................................................................................................ 70
8. Appendices ............................................................................................................................ 73
8.1. DOs & DON’Ts of load cells ........................................................................................................ 73
8.2. Protection according to EN60529 ............................................................................................. 74
8.3. Protection class IP69K according to DIN40050 ........................................................................ 74
8.4. Corrosion resistance chart .......................................................................................................... 75
8.5. Safety instructions ........................................................................................................................ 76
Notes ............................................................................................................................................... 77
The purpose of this guide is to give you an overview of different types of load cells and assist you in
designing the most efficient and effective weighing system for your specific requirements.
Load cells are designed to sense force or weight under a wide range of adverse conditions; they are not
only the most essential part of an electronic weighing system, but also the most vulnerable.
In order to get the most benefit from a load cell, the user must have a thorough understanding of the
technology, construction and operation of this unique device. In addition, the user must be able to select the
load cell suited to the application in hand and maintain the load cell throughout its lifetime.
Load cell selection, for trouble free operation, mainly involves choosing the right capacity, accuracy class
and environmental protection. it should also be recognised that a particular measuring principle might offer
distinct advantages in terms of overload capabilities or ease of mounting.
If, at any time during the designing stages of your weighing system, you have any questions, please feel
free to call us for assistance. At SCAIME, we’re committed to providing you exactly with what you need, when
you need it.
• Warns of a potentially dangerous situation: failure to comply with instructions could lead to property
damage and/or physical injury.
• Indicates useful information: Means that advice or important information about the product or its
handling is being given.
Strain gauges are able to measure small deformations and are actually only used in the elastic range.
Deformation or “stretching” is defined as follows:
∆𝒍
𝒆=
𝒍𝟎
With:
- l0 being the initial gauge length
- Δl being the variation in length when a load is applied
This relative “stretching” is considered as the deformation. As the deformation values are very low, they
are expressed as 𝝁𝒅𝒆𝒇 = 𝒆 × 𝟏𝟎𝟔
By replacing one of the resistors of a Wheatstone bridge with a strain gauge, we can easily measure the
change in VOUT and use it to assess the applied force
The load cell capacities can range from a few grams to hundreds of tonnes. The metal piece is machined
so that it remains in the elastic range of the material for a deformation equivalent to the load cell’s overload
capacity.
The excitation voltage of the load cells is in the range of 3 to 15 Volts. The signal output from the load cell
depends on the load cell itself, but is usually in the range of 0 to 50 mV.
The signal output of the load cells is expressed in milliVolts per Volt (mV/V). What this means is that for
every excitation volt applied to the load cell, it will output so many milliVolts at full scale. This value is called the
load cell’s sensitivity. The typical sensitivity ranges from 1mV/V to 3 mV/V.
In this example:
• A load cell has a capacity of 2kg and a sensitivity of 2mV/V.
• The weight indicator has an excitation voltage of 5V.
The output signal when a 2kg weight is applied on the load cell is 10mV.
• The AVX model, made of stainless steel and hermetically welded for an IP68/IP69K protection, for use in
wash down or corrosive environment.
• Install and adjust the appropriate overload stops to protect the load cell.
• Platform size must be less than the “Maximum platform size” (see datasheet).
• The load cell must be clamped in at the mounting holes, as a cantilever beam.
• The load cell must be fixed following the recommended tightening torques on a
solid metallic base that won’t flex under a load. The surface of this base must be
machined and perfectly flat.
• If the body of the load cell does not incorporate the offset that allows some
flexibility when the load is applied, place shims at the load cell mounting points
(generally > 1 mm).
3.2.1. Principle
Bending as a measuring principle offers excellent linearity. Bending beams generate high strain levels at
relatively low forces with greater deformation compared to other measuring principles. This in turn means that
although the bending beam load cell is subjected to greater static overload, mechanical stops are more
feasible. The dynamic overload capabilities are excellent because of this typically high deformation.
Bending beam load cells can be used in platform scales, weighing systems in small hoppers, continuous
belt weighing and weight feeders and other high precision applications.
Bending beam load cells are often used for capacities ranging from 5 kg to 500 kg.
• The load cell and especially the thin-walled bellows must be handled with care.
• Do not overload the load cell, not even for a short time. When handling and mounting load
cells with small rated capacities, permissible limit values will be quickly reached.
• The load cell seating must be horizontal, on a flat, hard and perfectly clean surface, as the
load cell base.
• Never load in a direction opposite to the load direction specified (see datasheet).
• Load cells are to be clamped tightly to the mounting components. Refer to the datasheet
for the recommended tightening torques.
SCAIME offers different mounting components for various mounting situations in order to minimise the
adverse effects due to load introduction or environmental factors.
Selection guide for mounting kits for bending beam load cells
Main characteristics
Construction Nickel plated steel Galvanised steel Stainless steel Galvanised steel
Stainless steel Stainless steel
Functions
Shear beam load cells are often used for capacities ranging from 300 kg to 5,000 kg.
Selection guide for mounting kits for shear beam load cells
Main characteristics
Functions
3.4.1. Principle
S-type load cells are most commonly used in tension (but can be used in compression). This type of load
cell uses bending or shear as a measuring principle. It must be installed so that the force applied passes
vertically through the centre of the load cell.
S-type load cells are used for vessel weighing, tensile testers, torque restraints and other applications.
S-type load cells are commonly used in capacities from 25 kg to 5,000 kg.
3.5.1. Principle
Although conceptually simple, the column compression load cell has a number of specific characteristics
which makes these load cell types difficult to design and produce. The column itself should be long enough,
with respect to its cross section, to provide a uniform deformation field. Column load cells are inherently non-
linear while deforming under load. This non-linearity is compensated with specific semiconductor gauges.
For this type of cell load, the amount of movement accumulated is less important than with beam load
cells. Therefore, their overload capabilities are excellent. However, the relatively small deflection makes this
load cell type more sensitive to shock loading.
Column load cells offer high accuracy, so they are often used in weighbridges and vessel weighing when
high accuracy is required.
SCAIME offers different mounting components in order to minimise the adverse effects due to load
introduction or environmental factors.
Selection guide for mounting kits for compression column load cells
Main characteristics
Construction Nickel plated steel Nickel plated steel Nickel plated steel Galvanised steel
Stainless steel Stainless steel
Functions
Height adjustment - - - -
Vibration damping - - - -
• The base and load plates should be seated on a steel plates. These mounting surfaces must have a
flatness < 2/1000 and an horizontality < 4/1000.
• The load cells must be placed in an upright position and on the same horizontal
level.
• The maximum permissible lateral displacement or slope must not be exceeded.
• The plates should be aligned in such way that the flat part of the rotation-stop device is parallel to the
main traffic direction on the weighbridge.
• To protect the bearing surfaces from wear, tear, and dirt, clean and grease the elements.
• To avoid clogging the rotation-stop device, place the rotation-stop in a high position.
Low profile compression load cells are used in capacities from 5t to 1000t.
Silo weighing
Selection guide for mounting kits for low profile compression load cells
Main characteristics
Construction Nickel plated steel Stainless steel Galvanised steel Galvanised steel
Stainless steel Stainless steel
Functions
Height adjustment - - - -
Vibration damping - - - -
To meet this requirement, SCAIME has had its quality system certified according to standard EN1090 in
execution class EXC2. This class implies that the entire process, from product design to delivery, is taken into
account within a qualified and documented system.
Load measuring pins are designed for many diverse applications as direct replacements for clevis or pivot
pins. Their main advantage is that they do not normally require any change to the structure being monitored.
M16
A load pin needs to be locked into position in order to set its direction. For an accurate measurement,
the load pins must be set to avoid any axial and rotational movement.
A standard load pin is designed to measure the force in one direction only. Be careful with the load pin
mounting position to avoid measurement errors.
The load pin must be free to bend in its support. To do so, the following must be checked:
Accuracy class of Verification scale interval (e) Number of verification scale intervals (n = Max/e)
an instrument
Min Max
For commercial weighing applications or for checking manufacturing processes, class III, from 500 to
10 000 intervals, is the most commonly used.
C - Medium 10 000
D - Ordinary 1000
A load cell is classified by a letter (from A to D) and by its maximum number of intervals (nmax), expressed in
units of 1000. For example, C3 represents class C with 3000 OIML intervals.
Load cells with strain gauges easily achieve an accuracy class of C or D. They therefore allow the
construction of class III or IIII weighing instruments suitable for industrial and commercial weighing
applications.
These load cells are generally cost-effective, accurate, reliable with a long service life. In addition,
they require little space for mounting and are therefore easy to install.
• Ultimate overload
This is the maximum load that can be applied without physically destroying the load cell.
• Non-linearity: The deviation of the increasing load cell calibration curve from a perfect curve which
passes through zero and through the load cell output voltage at the rated capacity.
• Hysteresis: The difference between load cell output values for the same applied load, one reading
obtained by increasing the load from minimum load and the other by decreasing the load from
nominal capacity.
• Temperature effect on zero: This is the change in minimum dead load output signal due to a change
in ambient temperature. In legal metrology, this change in signal must be PLC xVmin for a
temperature variation of 5°C within the compensated temperature range.
• Compensated temperature range: Without taking into account the temperature effects on Zero, the
temperature range in which the output signal is compensated so as not to be affected by an error
greater than the mpe.
• A common mistake is to think that the load cell signal remains in the mpe over the entire
compensated temperature range, without a zero reset.
• The temperature variation of Zero is well compensated over the entire compensated
temperature range, but only remains in the mpe (VminXPLC) for a variation of 5°C within the
full range.
• Service temperature range: The temperature range in which the load cell can be operated without
permanent changes to its properties.
Potted IP64/IP65
Enclosed IP67
The following paragraphs show these systems for the main SCAIME mounting kits.
STABIFLEX for F60X load cell STABIFLEX with restraint device for SK30X load cell
The STABIFLEX mounting kit is a self-centring mounting system which includes a ball and cup device that
offers the best weighing results for a wide variety of applications.
The kit is also equipped with two stops limiting vertical and horizontal movements of the upper plate
(load receptor). These devices act as a lift-off prevention tool and as a protection against accidental
horizontal forces.
The STABIFLEX kit can be used for static or dynamic applications, in the presence of horizontal
forces, flexible pipe connections, with thermal contraction/expansion, and when the application
requires high accuracy.
Load plate
Base plate
RUBBERKIT for F60X load cell ISOFLEX for SK30X load cell
RUBBERKIT and ISOFLEX mounting kits are rigid mounting kits. The load transmission device is a swivelling bolt
connection between the load receptor and the load cell. These kits include elastomer for damping shocks and
vibrations.
The RUBBERKIT and ISOFLEX kits can be used for static or dynamic applications, in the presence
of horizontal forces, pipe connections but with a low thermal contraction/expansion.
Swivelling rigid
mounting device
The QUICKFIT mounting kit is a self-centring mount providing a precise load input for high accuracy in a
wide variety of applications.
The load transmission device is a pillar with a spherical end held and hinged in the load cell. This pillar is
bolted onto a height adjustable load plate incorporating an elastomer system to absorb side forces.
The QUICKFIT kit can be used for static or dynamic applications, in the presence of horizontal
forces, pipe connections with thermal contraction/expansion.
Height adjustment
device
Self-centring device,
pillar and spherical end
SILOSAFE for R10X load cell SILOSAFE with restraint device for R10X load cell
Optional
restraint
device
Load cell
failure safety
device
Base plate
The Kit can be equipped with one or two restraint devices to avoid unidirectional horizontal
movements. The stay rod includes ball joints with adjustable ends that connect the top plate (load receptor) to
the base plate via the lift-off prevention axis.
Stay rods can be used in three cases:
4. To stabilise a dynamic system when weighing is to take place while a large mixer is in operation.
5. To stabilise a system when stabilisation time is critical.
6. To stabilise a dynamic system and protect against the failure of connected pipes.
5.3.1. Resolution
Resolution is the smallest weight change that a digital weighing system can detect. Resolution is
measured as the number of increments (intervals).
It makes no sense for an analogue load cell, it only depends on the ability of the system’s electronics to
detect a change in the load cell signal.
For many applications requiring measurement processing, such as digital filtering, determining
measurement stability, calculating a weighing result or stopping weight filling, the weighing electronics must be
able to handle a very small resolution, such as 0.01kg. However, this does not mean that the accuracy of the
system is 0.01kg.
In legal metrology, in order not to mislead the user, the displayed result cannot exceed the accuracy.
On the other hand, when processing the measurement and for carrying out various functions, the indicator or
the transmitter uses a much higher internal resolution, generally 10X the display resolution.
Repeatability and accuracy go hand in hand. You can have a repeatable system that is not
accurate, but you cannot have an accurate system unless it is repeatable.
• The load cells should be positioned in such a way that each load cell will bear the
same amount of weight.
𝑸 × (𝑻𝒂𝒓𝒆 + 𝑪𝑳𝑰𝑽𝑬 )
𝑪𝑳𝑪 ≥
𝑵
Where:
- Tare: Tare or dead load (kg)
- Clive: Maximum load applied (kg)
- Q: Safety factor
- N: Number of load cells
The signal by increment calculated must be greater than the minimum allowed for the indicator
(as given in its technical datasheet).
Example
Take a vessel with four 5000 kg load cells (2 mV/V) attached to an eNod4 weighing
transmitter.
You want to be able to weigh up to 15,000 kg at 2 kg increments (7,500 increments
displayed).
Use the formula to determine the signal per increment:
𝟐 𝐤𝐠 × 𝟐 𝐦𝐕/𝐕 × 𝟓 𝐕𝐃𝐂 × 𝟏𝟎𝟎𝟎
= 𝟏 µ𝐕
𝟓𝟎𝟎𝟎 𝐤𝐠 × 𝟒
The minimum acceptable signal for eNod4 is 0.5µV microvolt per increment. Since the
1 µV signal derived from the formula is greater than 0.5 µV, you should be able to display
2 kg increments.
𝑼𝑨𝑳𝑰𝑴
The excitation voltage must provide an intensity: 𝑰𝑨𝑳𝑰𝑴 =
𝒁
Where:
- Uexc is the load cell excitation voltage
Verify that Z > Rmin (Minimum indicator impedance), or Iexc < Imax (Maximum intensity of the
indicator)
To help the designer in this analysis, the assessment guide below summarises the main parameters
to be taken into account for the design of the weighing system, according to the application and
accuracy required.
System data
System accuracy
±0.01 to 0.03 ±0.03 to 0.1 ±0.1 to 0.5 > ±0.5
(% of the capacity)
Weight control
Dosing - Filling
Transfer of material
Load cell
OIML C6, C3 OIML C3 OIML D1, not certified Not certified
certification
Installation parameters
Rigid Rigid
Structure Isolated from Isolated from Rigid Rigid
environmental factors environmental factors
Environmental parameters
Load cell
Within the rated range Within the rated range Within the rated range Within the operating range
temperature range
Within the limits of the Within the limits of the Within the limits of the
Wind, drafts No, indoor application
mounting kit mounting kit mounting kit
Calibration
Test weights,
Test weights, substitution Substitution/transfer of
Procedure substitution/transfer of Theoretical
of material material
material
Electronics
Electronic
OIML 6000d OIML 3000d - -
certification
Advanced digital
Yes If needed If needed No
filter
𝑽𝒎𝒊𝒏(𝒔𝒚𝒔) = 𝑽𝒎𝒊𝒏(𝑳𝑪) × √𝑵
We also calculate the interval for the system in relation to the maximum number of intervals for the load
cells and the weighing capacity of the system:
𝐂𝐋𝐈𝐕𝐄
𝐞 (𝐬𝐲𝐬) =
𝐧𝐦𝐚𝐱
We then check the compatibility of the two results:
If e(sys) Vmin(sys), the result e(sys) (rounded up, multiple of 1, 2 or 5) can be chosen as an interval
for the system
Si e(sys) Vmin(sys), the result Vmin(sys) (rounded up, multiple of 1, 2 or 5) can be chosen as an
interval for the system
Example
Let's take our vessel with a capacity of 15,000 kg with four 5,000 kg load cells
connected to an eNod4 weight transmitter.
The capacity of the vessel is 15,000 kg.
We want to measure the weight according to legal metrology and need the best
possible interval for this system.
The load cell data is: nmax = 3000 and Vmin = 0.5 kg
The calculation for the minimum intervals for the system is as follows:
• Vmin(sys) = 0.5 x√𝟒 = 1 kg
The interval calculation in relation to the maximum number of intervals and the
capacity is:
• e(sys)= 15,000 / 3,000 = 5 kg
If the user prefers using the full capacity of the vessel (15,000 kg), then the best
possible interval for the system will be e(sys) = 5 kg
If the user prefers higher accuracy, the vessel must not be used to its full capacity:
- Intervals of 1 kg for a usable capacity of 3,000 kg
- Intervals of 2 kg for a usable capacity of 6,000 kg
Mounting the device under the legs is perfectly acceptable. However, the second option is the best,
due to the natural stability provided by a low centre of gravity.
• Under these normal weighing conditions, all the load cells should be subjected to a
downward force.
• Restraint devices must be oriented so that undesirable horizontal forces are eliminated,
while allowing thermal expansion for the structure.
Angular loading occurs when a force that is not Eccentric load occurs when a vertical force is
perfectly vertical is applied to a load cell. applied to a load cell at a point other than its
centre line. This problem can be caused by
thermal expansion.
Side and end loading occur when horizontal Torsion occurs when a side force twists a load
forces are applied to the side or end of a load cell. It can be caused by structural deflection,
cell. They can be caused by thermal expansion, system dynamics, thermal movement, or
a misalignment, or by movement due to misalignments.
dynamic loading.
Angular error
Mounting load cells at the centre of the support To reduce the deformation, mount load cells next
beams will cause high deformation at high loads. to vertical posts and support each load cell with
identical beams.
• Figure 1 shows how a support beam can deform when a weighing module is mounted at mid-span. If this
type of layout cannot be avoided, strengthen the support beams to minimise deformation.
• Figure 2 and 3 show typical strengthening methods.
Example of a method used to mount load cells near grounded vertical posts
Vertical post
• Add stiffeners and gussets to prevent the beams from twisting when subjected to a load.
Gusset
Stiffener
• The resistance of the lift-off prevention device must be compatible with the application.
• An external lift-off prevention system must be installed if the mounting kit does not include
such a safety device.
• Static vessel: A static horizontal or vertical vessel, without a mixer, does not require restraint devices.
Restraint devices are not required when the only operation is filling and emptying the vessel.
• Vessel, with low speed mixing : Some vessels are equipped with a low power mixer for mixing liquid.
Restraint devices are not required, even if the mixing takes place at the same time as the weighing.
• Vessel with mixing, static weighing: This type of scales is sometimes subjected to dynamic forces, but
not during the weighing operation. As the mixer does not affect the weighing, restraint devices are not
required.
• Dosing machine: Some dosing machines incorporate vibrators for easier emptying. Opening and
closing the doors can cause additional shocks. As long as these forces do not happen during the
weighing operation, restraint devices are not required on a dosing machine.
• Conveyor, low speed: In low speed (usually high capacity) conveyor weighing applications where
the stabilisation time is not critical, the structure is left to recover after any horizontal impacts. If the
platform is occasionally subjected to severe shocks, mounting kits with integrated side stops are
recommended.
• Do not confuse the lateral stabilisation device and the lateral stop device:
- A restraint device prevents side forces that appear during normal operation.
- A side stop is a safety device which should only be used to prevent occasional strains
or shocks.
• Vessel with a mixer and rigid pipes: When a vessel is equipped with a powerful mixer and rigid pipes,
the tank oscillation can cause pipe fatigue failures. Restraint devices help maintain the vessel static and
prevent damage to the pipes.
• Horizontal mixer: In this system, the mixer rotates in a horizontal vessel. It is used to mix ingredients to
produce a paste. Strong vibrations are too expected for such operations, so the use of restraint devices
is highly recommended.
• High speed conveyor: High speed and high capacity conveyors are uncommon. If stabilisation time
is critical for this type of application, restraint devices should be used to hold the conveyor in place.
For these applications, the mounting kit will be chosen according to:
- The weighing capacity
- The required accuracy
Refer to §3 which provides a description and a guide for choosing the mounting kits.
𝐃 × 𝐅𝐓𝐨𝐭𝐚𝐥
𝐅𝐋𝐂 =
𝐋
• The vessel must be symmetrical about the vertical line passing through the centre of
gravity of the contents.
• The vessel is located indoors and is not subjected to wind.
• The vessel should be resting on only three or four support points
• The distance between the actual load cell and the dummy load cell (L) must be as great
as possible.
𝟎, 𝟔 × (𝐃𝟒 − 𝐝𝟒 ) × 𝚫𝐡 × 𝐄
𝐅=
𝐋𝟑
With:
- D= Outside diameter of pipe (mm)
- d = Inside diameter of pipe (mm)
- E = Young’s modulus (for steel: 210,000 N/mm2,
for copper: E= 110,000 N/mm2)
The pipes must be able to reduce unwanted forces on the vessel. This is even more important that
accuracy requirements are important.
Here you will find general guidelines for designing a piping system:
• Do not attach the piping to a mezzanine, a floor or a structure that moves independently from the tank.
• Instead, attach the piping to the tank’s support structure so that the piping moves along with the tank.
Wind effect
Because of the effect of wind on a weighing system, it
is important to select the right load cell capacity and
determine the best mount to use in outdoor application.
These effects are complex and depend on factors such
as the degree of exposure, local topography and maximum
wind speed.
• Take into account the additional loads when selecting the load cells
• •Mechanical restraints can be applied to maintain the scales’ position.
Wind striking an exposed tank or silo will generate a side force which causes an overturning moment and
a smaller vertical force.
• When the silo is empty: The wind force may be sufficiently strong to overturn the structure.
• When the silo is full: The combination of the overturning force reaction, and the total weight of the
silo, may generate an overloading on the load cells.
Example
Specifications
- V = 30 m/s
- h = 10 m
- d=3m
- A= h x d
𝑭 = 𝟎, 𝟓 × 𝟏, 𝟐𝟗𝟑 × 𝟎, 𝟖 × 𝒉 × 𝒅 × 𝑽𝟐
F = 13960 N
The wind force generates an overturning moment, which will be counterbalanced by a reactive
moment of the load cells.
𝑭×𝒃
𝑭𝑶𝑽 =
𝒂
Where:
- F: Overturning force caused by wind
force
- a: Distance between load cells
- b: height at which the wind force
acts
Using the previously calculated wind force of 13960 N and a value for b equal to half the height of the silo:
𝟏𝟑𝟗𝟔𝟎 × 𝟓
𝑭𝑶𝑽 = = 𝟐𝟑𝟑𝟎𝟎 𝑵 = 𝟐𝟑𝟖𝟎 𝒌𝒈
𝟑
Conclusion
• In case of an empty silo, lift-off protection should be considered if the dead weight of the tank on
each load cell is below2380 kg.
• In case of a full silo, 2380 kg must be added to the calculated load cell capacity.
(𝟏 + 𝟐𝑯) × 𝑲)
𝑾𝟏 × (𝟏 + √ ) + 𝑾𝟐
𝑾𝟏 + 𝑾𝟐
Where:
- W1 = Weight of the object being dropped (kg)
- W2 = Dead weight (kg)
- K = Load cell spring rate: Rated capacity divided by
load cell deflection at rated capacity (kg/m).
- H = Height from which the object has been dropped
5.14.3. Vibration
Caused by the surrounding environment or a mixer, vibrations induce electrical noise on the load cell’s
signal.
Some SCAIME electronics (e.g. eNod) incorporate powerful filtering systems that can eliminate the effects
of vibrations. However, it is important to implement systems to reduce internal or external vibrations that the
electronics cannot eliminate.
Preventative maintenance
Preventive maintenance is often overlooked by load cell users. However, a few checks and simple
maintenance tasks can greatly increase the lifespan of load cells.
Moisture and corrosive substances can physically damage the load cells and cause short circuits in the
electronics. Debris accumulated on the load cells will cause measurement errors by limiting the system’s
vertical mechanical movement.
• Provide adequate drainage away from the load cells.
• Regularly clean accumulated debris. Keep cables clean and in good condition.
• Protect load cells and cables from corrosive materials.
• If required by the environment, regularly clean the load cells to prevent any chemical corrosion
Corrosion resistance
Load cell resistance to corrosion is a complex subject, mainly due to the wide variety of configurations.
As such, the standard corrosion charts are the main reference for load cells. The appendix of this guide
includes the standard corrosion charter, for use only as an indication.
In addition to this indication, the following influencing factors must be taken into account:
• Condition of the surface of the load cell
• Welding quality and thickness for sealed load cells
• Stress levels on the load cells
The environment also plays an important role in the load cell behaviour. Salt water, for example, has very
different corrosive effects depending on the circumstances. Stainless steel in standing salt water will be subject
to corrosion and regular cleaning will be necessary to prevent rapid degradation of the load cell.
EHEDG Certification
• EL type: Equipment cleaned with liquids
• CLASS I AUX: Open equipment (Surfaces are on the
outside of the equipment) which is cleaned without
dismantling
These load cells, made from stainless steel and hermetically sealed, offer a level of protection IP68 and
IP69K ensuring their continuous operation in the most severe environment.
With an hygienic design, cleaning is much easier. A piece of equipment with no horizontal flat surface or
sharp angles ensuring that the Cleaning In Place (CIP) or Sterilisation In Place (SIP) process will remove all debris
from microorganisms.
Calibration error
Incorrect calibration of the weighing equipment will
cause errors in the readings. In the event of a calibration
error, the relationship between weight and load is linear but
incorrect.
This could be due to an error during theoretical
calibration or to the use of a reference weight that was too
low for a physical calibration process.
There are several methods used for calibration that will be described below:
Install brackets, evenly spaced around the tank to hang the test
weights.
• Empty the scale (or vessel), ensure there is no interference with the vessel.
• Set the Zero of the weighing instrument.
• Hang the calibration load (test weights) on the scale.
• Calibrate the weighing instrument, so that it reads the same as the weight applied.
• Remove the test weights and check for a return to zero.
• If you have enough test weights, add the weights to the vessel one by one and check the linearity of
the system. If the system is not linear, check for mechanical interference.
• On the certificate provided with the load cells, read the load cell sensitivity (in mV/V).
• Calculate the theoretical load cell output signal when no load is applied to the scales (the silo is
empty): this is the load cell “zero” sensitivity in mV/V.
• Calculate the theoretical load cell output signal when a maximum load is applied to the scales (the silo
is full): this is the load at maximum sensitivity in mV/V.
• Enter these 2 values in the weighing terminal and carry out the theoretical calibration.
• Electric and magnetic fields often cause interference voltages that are coupled into the
measurement circuit.
• Only use shielded, low capacity measurement cables (measurement cables provided by SCAIME
meet these requirements).
• Do not route these measurement cables along the excitation and control lines. If this is not possible,
protect the measurement cable (e.g. using steel-sheathed pipes).
• Avoid the leakage fields of the transformers, motors and contactors.
• An overload on an individual load cell cannot then be detected from the output signal.
When multiple load cells are connected together in parallel, the current required to supply these load cells
can exceed the maximum output of the indicator.
To calculate the required current output for a given installation, use the following formula:
𝟏
Required current = 𝑽𝑬𝑿𝑪 × ( ) × 𝑵𝑳𝑪
𝑹𝑳𝑪
With:
- VEXC : Excitation voltage
- RLC : Load cell input resistance
- NLC : Number of load cells
• Check the indicator is able to provide the electrical supply to the load cells.
Sometimes, the output from each individual load cell needs to be trimmed to avoid varying readings due
to the position of the load. These differences can be caused by:
- Difference in load cells output resistance.
- Uneven load distribution.
Trimming can be done by adjusting variable resistors (P1…Pn) placed into the excitation paths of the ALCJB.
6.5.1. Grounding
Proper grounding and shielding can be critical to the successful operation of load cells which are
generating extremely low level signals (<5μV/scale division).
Load cell cables are provided with a braided shield which protects the cables from electrostatic
interference when properly used. This shield could be floating (not connected at the load cell body) or
connected to the load cell body (refer to the load cell datasheet).
The load cell body and junction box are grounded via a mechanical attachment to the structure to which
they are mounted.
The braided shield enclosing the load cell cables is grounded at the indicator, which is grounded through
the power supply cable or its body.
• Load cell cables should be kept away from power circuits, with a minimum distance of 1m.
• Power supply cables should be crossed at right angles.
For the best protection, the shielding should be connected on both sides when possible. The load cells
are then protected against high frequency (HF) and low frequency (LF) interference.
If the shielding is only connected on one side, it is only effective for LF interference.
Finally,
- If equipotential grounding is not possible,
- If the conditioner is not equipped with a capacitor to connect to ground
- If a capacitor cannot be added to the shield connection to ground
Then the unconnected shielding will be left on the conditioner side.
7.1. In general
Carefully check the system integrity before evaluating the load cells:
• Check for force shunts (might be caused by dirt, friction or mechanical misalignment).
• Check cable connections to junction box and indicator.
Visually inspect the load cells before performing the tests as described on the following pages. Pay
attention to signs of corrosion and the integrity of the cable.
Analysis:
The insulation resistance must be greater than 1000 MΩ. A lower value indicates electrical loss, which is
often caused by moisture or chemical contamination inside the load cell.
Extremely low values (< 1kΩ) indicate a short circuit rather than moisture ingress. Electrical leakage often
causes load cell or indicator instability. Stability might vary with temperature.
• Some megohmmeters can supply 500 V and could damage the load cell. Do not supply the
load cell with a voltage greater than 50 V.
Analysis:
Changes in bridge resistance or bridge balance are most often caused by a broken wire, an electrical
component failure or internal short circuit.
Page 71/78 NT-USING LOAD CELLS-E-0122
This might result from electrical surges (lightning or welding), physical damage from shock, vibration,
excessive temperature, or from production inconsistencies.
Analysis:
Erratic readings may indicate a failed electrical connection or a damaged glue layer between the
strain gauge and the load cell body as a result of an electrical transient.
8.1.1. DOs
REMINDER: although load cells may look extremely robust, they contain delicate sensing devices and can
be very easily damaged by misuse rendering the unit unusable.
1. Select the right load cell for the application in terms of type and environmental compatibility.
2. Choose the right capacity.
3. Consider the required accuracy class.
4. Consider the environmental effects on accuracy (wind, friction, thermal expansion, wiring or piping
attachment).
5. Design adequate over/under load protection as well as protection from other mechanical
damage (e.g. physical abuse, rodent problems…).
6. Use dummy load cells prior to installation.
7. Beware of shock loadings. These can be very high and, even if they are short, can easily cause
permanent damage.
8. Store and handle load cells carefully prior to and during installation.
9. Use high quality bolts with the recommended torque.
10. Check the surface to which a load cell is to be attached is flat and that the surface finish is
appropriate.
11. Check the cable colour code for the load cells prior to connection.
12. Use good quality connecting terminals/junction boxes.
13. Inspect load cells and weigh system regularly especially after extreme weather conditions
(electrical storms, flooding, seismic activity, etc.) and also before and after the seasons.
14. Check for corrosion damage to the load cell and mounting hardware.
8.1.2. Don’ts
1. Don’t let the load cells operate above their rated capacity.
2. Don’t drop a load cell onto the floor.
3. Don’t hammer a load cell into place. Shock loads can permanently damage some units.
4. Don’t use the load cell as a mechanical connection.
5. Don’t forget to protect the load cell cable.
6. Don’t carry out electric welding near the load cells.
7. Don’t ever carry load cells by their cable.
8. Don’t force bolts or other threaded assemblies.
9. Don’t cut load cell cables unless necessary, performance may be affected.
10. Don’t allow the load cell to be the electrical link between the ground and the metal weighing
structure. Prefer using adequate bonding straps and isolators.
11. Don’t exceed the specified input voltage rating when energising a load cell.
12. Don’t exceed the recommended operating temperature range.
13. Don’t allow the build-up of water/debris around the load cells.
0 No protection
IP 1 st digit
Protected against solid objects up to 50 mm and accidental touch
Protection 1 by hand
against solid
objects Protection against solid objects (> 12.5 mm) and accidental touch
2 with fingers
Protection against solid objects (> 2.5 mm) and accidental contact
3 (tools)
0 No protection
IP 2 nd digit
Protection 1 Protection against vertically falling drops of water
against liquids
Protection against falling drops of water up to a 15° angle from the
2 vertical.
6 Protection against strong water jets in all directions from a fire hose
1 20 ⚫⚫ HCOOH 10 Boiling ⚫
2 60 ⚫⚫ 40 65 ⚫
10 20 ⚫⚫ 25 Boiling ⚫⚫⚫
H2SO4
20 20 ⚫⚫ 30 Boiling ⚫
20 35 ⚫ 34 20 ⚫⚫⚫
NaOH
25 25 ⚫⚫ 34 Boiling ⚫
20 20 ⚫ 50 20 ⚫⚫
2 20 ⚫⚫ <100 20 ⚫⚫⚫
Na2CO3
>2 >20 - 100 820 -
50 60 ⚫⚫⚫ <100 30 ⚫⚫⚫
NaCl
60 20 ⚫⚫⚫ 100 >30 ⚫
65 Boiling ⚫ 10 Boiling ⚫⚫
NH4Cl
>90 Boiling - 25 20 ⚫⚫
50 108 ⚫⚫ 5 20 ⚫⚫⚫
50 Boiling ⚫ (NH4)2SO4 10 20 ⚫⚫
80 ⚫⚫ 1 20 ⚫
FeCl3
80 Boiling - 5 20 -
10 ⚫⚫⚫ K2CO3 30 65 ⚫⚫⚫
10 Boiling ⚫⚫ HBr/HF -
CH3-COOH
80 ⚫⚫⚫ Acetone 100 < Boiling ⚫⚫⚫
In cases where a failure may cause injury to persons or damage to equipment, the user must take
appropriate safety measures (such as fall protection, overload protection, etc.). A safe and trouble-free
operation of the load cells requires proper transportation, correct storage, assembly and mounting as well as
careful operation and maintenance.
It is essential to comply with the relevant accident prevention regulations. More specifically, you should
take into account the limit loads quoted in the specifications.
Qualified staff
These load cells are only to be installed by qualified personnel strictly in accordance with the
specifications and with the safety rules and regulations which follow. Appropriate legal safety regulations
regarding the application concerned will also be complied with. The same applies to the use of accessories.
Qualified personnel means persons entrusted with the installation, fitting, commissioning and operation of
the product which has the appropriate qualifications for their function.
Environmental conditions
In the context of your application, please note that acids and all materials which release chlorides will
attack all the layers of the stainless steel and any welding seams. This may corrode the load cell which can
lead to other failures.
Prohibited modifications
The load cells must not be modified from a design or safety engineering point of view except with our
express agreement. Any modification shall exclude all liability on our part for any damage resulting therefrom.
WWW.SCAIME.COM
WWW.SCAIME.COM
SCAIME SAS
Technosite Altéa
294, Rue Georges Charpak
74100 Juvigny – France
T: +33 (0)4 50 87 78 64
F: +33 (0)4 50 87 78 42
[email protected]
www.scaime.com