05 Chapter 2
05 Chapter 2
2. Review of Literature
==================================================
M&A is an important strategic option that firms can leverage to make necessary
competitive advantage in the market. It can help the firms to obtain higher earnings
per share and a broader customer base and gain to new products and services. At
the same time, mergers are very risky and deals fail, because of the opportunistic
M&As and overpayment to poor integration. M&A have become a company‟s
strategy and organic growth depends on the industry the company operates in and
its market position and its strategy for valuation. M&A can help companies to take
advantage of the scale that result from consolidation and gain access to markets
and products.
1
Asquith, Bruner and Mullins (1983) examine the effect of mergers on the
wealth of acquiring firm‟s shareholders. Acquiring firms gain during the twenty
one days leading to the announcement of each of their merger deals. The results
fail to support the capitalization hypothesis that acquirer‟s gains are captured at the
beginning of merger programs. Deals abnormal returns are positively related to the
relative size of the merger partners, and the gains during the announcement period
are larger for mergers which are successful. Though the gains are larger prior to
1969, merger bids after 1969 also significantly increase the wealth of acquiring
firms' shareholders. The results suggest that the inconclusive findings of the earlier
studies may be due to methodological deficiencies. The findings of this study are
consistent with value-maximizing behavior by the management of bidding firms.
15
Review of Literature
Kyong rock lee and Byung Ihm Leem, (1994)2 in their paper introduced a MPI
using DEA frontier in stata. It measures productivity changes for units between
time periods. The user-written MPI approach in Stata will provide some possible
future extensions of Stata programming in the productivity analysis
Akhil Bhan P (1998) 3has conducted a study into the motives and benefits of the
mergers in Indian banking sector .This is done by examining the eight merger deals
of the banks in India during the period of reforms from 1999 to 2006 . Through the
empirical methods by applying t-test and EVA value calculations the potential of
the mergers has been evaluate to study the efficiencies or benefits achieved due to
the merger .The study has been concluded that the mergers in the banking sector in
the post reform period possessed considerable gains which was justified by the
EVA of the banks in the post merger period.
Simon Feeny and Mark Rogers (1998)4 in their research work entitled
„Profitability in Australian Enterprises‟ analyzes profitability in a sample of larges
Australian companies over the period 1985 to 1996. Various measures of
profitability are used and provide a discussion of the theoretical basis for these
measures. The key issues investigated are a comparison of the profitability
measures, the distribution of profitability between firms, and the persistence of
firm profitability. The results are compared with previous studies on firm
profitability.
16
Review of Literature
myopia hypothesis, i.e. the hypothesis that the market initially overvalues acquirers
if the acquisition increases EPS, ultimately leading to long-run under-performance.
Ping-wen Lin (2002)9 in his findings establishes there is a negative correlation and
statistical significance exists between cost inefficiency index and bank mergers.
The data envelopment analysis found that bank mergers did not improve
significantly cost efficiency of banks. In another study, he found that bank mergers
tend to upgrade the technical efficiency, allocative efficiency, and cost efficiency
of banks. In terms of technical efficiency and allocative efficiency improvement,
the effect of bank mergers was significant, however, in terms of cost efficiency
improvement, the effect was insignificant.
Ramaswamy and Waegelein (2003)10 identified in their study the “Firm Financial
Performance Following Mergers,” that the post-merger financial performance of
162 merged firms that occurred during 1975-1990 in the US. They used industry
adjusted operating cash flow returns on market value of assets as the measure of
performance and used only firms that had not gone in for any merger during the
study period as part of their control sample, since they felt that only that would
make the data incorruptible and the results more robust. The study found a
17
Review of Literature
significant increase of 12.7 per cent in firm performance after the merger had taken
place.
Robert W. Kaps (2004)11 studied the importance of published research in the field
of aviation in the academic environment. Providing a five-part argument supports
the publishing process. The discussion addresses why publishing is important,
through identifying three distinct groups of individuals who may desire and or be
encouraged to publish, while providing the academic community with three
distinct lists of publications where manuscripts may be submitted for
consideration. The article serve as a ready reference for answering the question
where you can publish my research'. This article continues an earlier effort (Truitt
& Kaps, 1995) to identify the number and type of academic publications serving
the field of aviation research.
Jose Manuel Campa & Ignacio Hernando (2005)12, in the research paper “M&A
performance in the European Financial industry”, reports the evidence on
shareholders returns from mergers. Mergers announcements brought positive
returns to the shareholders of the target company around the date of the
announcement. Returns to shareholders of the acquiring firms were essentially zero
around announcement. One year after the announcement, excess returns were not
significantly different from zero for either targets or acquirers. The paper also
gives insight on changes in operating performance for the subsample of mergers
involving banks.
18
Review of Literature
Rajesh Kumar B and Prabina Rajib (2007)14 analyzed in their paper the
distinctive financial characteristics of the acquirer and the target firms during the
period of merger. This study developed a predictive model for target firms based
on different financial and market variables. The study observed that the mergers
have resulted a higher cash flow, PE ratio and lower debt to total assets ratio in
acquirer firms which are statistically significant. The study concludes that smaller
firms with lower price earnings ratio are more likely to be acquired.
C. Lanier Benkard, Aaron Bodoh, John Bajari (2008)15 examined a new method
for studying the medium and long run dynamic effects of mergers. The method
builds on the two step estimator. Using data for 2003-2007.They apply model to
some airline mergers. An airline‟s entry or exit decisions are made jointly across
routes, and depend on features of its own route network as well as the networks of
the other airlines. The model allows for city-specific profitability shocks that affect
all routes out of a given city, as well as route-specific shocks.
Dr. Neena Sinha, Dr. K.P.Kaushik & Ms. Timcy Chaudhary (2010)16 in their research
article on “Measuring Post Merger and Acquisition Performance: An Investigation of
Select Financial Sector Organizations in India”, examines the impact of mergers and
acquisitions on the financial efficiency of the selected financial institutions in India. The
analysis consists of two stages. Firstly, by using the ratio analysis approach, they calculate
the change in the position of the companies during the period 2000-2008. Secondly, they
examine changes in the efficiency of the companies during the pre and post merger periods
by using nonparametric Wilcoxon signed rank test. The result of the study indicate that
M&A cases in India show a significant correlation between financial performance and the
M&A deal, in the long run, and the acquiring firms were able to generate value.
Joe zhu (2011)17 in his paper measured the airline performance using a two stage
process. In the first stage the resources are used to maintain fleet size and load
factor. In the second stage, the fleet size and the load factor generate revenue. The
model is known as the centralized efficiency model. This helps to enable obtaining
insights not available from the standard DEA model.
19
Review of Literature
Shobhana and Deepa N(2011)19 has attempted to conduct a study into the
fulfillment of motives as viewed in the merger deals of the nine select merged
banks. The study uses Summary Statistics, Wilcoxon Matched Paired Signed Rank
Test and t test for analysis and interpretation of data pertaining to the five pre and
post merger periods each. The result indicates that there has been only partial
fulfillment of the motives as envisaged in the merger deals.
20
Review of Literature
dimensions, Cuisines provided, seat comfort safety are the most important
dimension in in-flight service quality.
Mani Arora & Anil kumar (2012)23 studied the concept of Mergers in detail to
find out the major issues associated with the pre and post merging situations with
special emphasize on human aspect. Merger&Acquisition is a phenomenon which
is easy to think but hard to implement. Three phases of mergers via pre merger,
deal phase and the post mergerhave its own advantages as well as difficulties, if
handled with proper care synergies can be withdrawn but a little mistake can spoil
the whole transition. Both management and employees have to work hard at their
own level to make it a successful one because man is the major factor during the
whole deal. Post merger transition phase is the most difficult one as in any
organization whether large or small cultural clashes exist which may turn up a
merger into the failure. Merger& Acquisition is a process which is very essential
nowadays for the growth and survival of the business. Companies are acquiring
more and more firms in order to expand their business and with lots of reasons
which are discussed here. If any company is not adopting this way either they will
not grow or will be acquired by the other major big firm.
N. M. Leepsa & Chandra Sekhar Mishra (2012)24 in the research paper on “Post
Merger Financial Performance: A Study with Reference to Select Manufacturing
Companies in India”, aimed to study the trend in merger and acquisition (M&A)
particularly with reference to manufacturing companies. The study is an attempt to
find out the difference in post-merger performance compared with pre-merger in
terms of profitability, liquidity and solvency. The statistical tools used are
descriptive statistics, paired sample t-test.
21
Review of Literature
David Mc. A Baker (2013)25 in the research of Quality and Customer Satisfaction
in the Airline Industry: A Comparison between Legacy Airlines and Low-Cost
studies the customer satisfaction and service quality with respect to airlines. It
revealed that that the airline industry has been struggling with many challenges
like increasing fuel cost, managing fluctuating demand, keeping up with tight
quality requirements; and satisfies the needs of various customer groups. The
findings indicate that while the traditional carriers are converging toward a higher
level of service quality, using the four measures, there continue to be significant
variation. In this study, over a five year period 2007 to 2011, the service quality of
low cost airlines generally found to be higher than that of traditional legacy
airlines. Implications related to operating costs, market share, infrastructure and
customer service were evident.
22
Review of Literature
paper provides how close or far away the banks are from the efficient frontier. It is
observed that technical efficiency of merged banks deteriorated immediately after
the merger and showed improvement from the third year of post-merger period.
The effect of merger and acquisition on the profitability and operational cost of
merged banks is not significant during the initial phase of merger.
Deitiana, Lionel Greg Habibuw (2015)31 in their study examines the company
performance to describehow individuals in the company try to achieve a goal.
Company performance illustrates the magnitude of the results in a process that has
been achieved compared with the company‟s goal. The study is to find out factors
determining financial performance. The objects of this study are property and real
estate companies listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange during the period of 2007
– 2012. Data for this study stems from secondary data gathered by analyzing
financial statement of the sample companies. The data is then analyzed with
regression Analysis. The research concluded that Variable leverage and Firm age
has an effect on financial performance. Other variables like liquidity, Firm Size,
Managerial Ownership and Block holder Ownership have no effect on financial
performance.
23
Review of Literature
India to determine what establishes the service variables, how the passengers
satisfied with services and how to improve the satisfaction level of customers. The
result shows Air India displayed a good service quality in the assurance,
responsiveness, reliability and technical dimension of the services but the tangible,
empathy dimensions needs a lot of enhancement.
Shah, Bisma Afzal (2016)34 was carried out the study with the aim of assessing
the impact of mergers and acquisitions on the value of listed firms in India. The
study explains the motives behind deals and to determine whether organizations
undertaking the inorganic mode of expansion to achieve the real benefits. The
study examines the impact of merger and acquisition deals have on the operating
performance, financial performance and the shareholders wealth of the sample
firms by comparing the performance before and after deals. It also explains the
extent to which merger and acquisition deals are successful in improving operating
and financial performance and creating shareholders wealth. The research assesses
the success or failure of Indian forms involved in merger deal. It examines the
aggregate performance and firm specific level performance. The study restricted to
Indian domestic firms only.
24
Review of Literature
which is the sixth biggest airport in Turkey. Servqual scale was used to analyses
customer perception and service quality.
Meysam Jafari & Ghasemali Bazaee (2016)36 studied the effect of customer
service quality in international airlines (Mahan airline international). The research
carried out to evaluate the effects of service quality on customers‟ satisfaction in
international airlines. The population comprises of Mahan international flight
passengers. The sample size is estimated 371 using Cochran formula and the
questionnaire reliability has shown to be 0.85 using Cronbach's alpha. The results
indicate that aircraft concrete features have significant effects on customers‟
satisfaction but the significant effect of airport observable features, empathy and
airline image on customers‟ satisfaction was rejected. Multiple Correlation square
coefficient analysis indicated that 83.1% of dependent variable variance (customer
satisfaction) is explained by the model that is indicative of the high capability of
independent variable prediction.
Jia Yan, Xiaowen Fu, Tae Hoon Oum, Kun wang (2016)37 studied the effects of
mergers on airline performance and social welfare found that the effect on airfares
is dependent on the network configurations of merging airlines. Fare increases are
frequently observed on overlapped routes. However, if the networks of two
merging airlines are complementary, the expanded network after the merger leads
to cost savings, increase in travel options, and improvement in service quality.
Therefore, in a deregulated market, with few entry barriers, relaxing merger
regulations is likely to improve welfare. However, most welfare evaluations do not
incorporate quality changes or dynamic competition effects. Empirical
investigations are primarily ex post analysis of mergers that have already passed
antitrust reviews. The relationship between market concentration and welfare
might be nonlinear and market specific. Therefore, airline mergers and alliances
should be reviewed case by case.
Wilfred, Tamilla, Dawna (2016)38 in the study US airways group: A post merger
analysis analyses the post merger performance of the US airways group using
airline operating metrics and financial ratios for the period of 2005-2013. . While
the airline has still a long way to go to improve its leverage and liquidity ratios, its
25
Review of Literature
capital structure and ability to pay its obligations have improved since 2005.
Moreover, although the airline is still inefficient in utilizing its assets, the
efficiency improvements achieved since the merger have resulted in profits and
positive returns to investors. Its share prices have also largely outperformed the
S&P, an indication that investors are pleased with how the merger is developing
over time. In view of the US Airways Group's improving financial and operating
performance, the merger is, essentially, a success.
Tian Luo Thayer (2016)40, provide a detailed assessment of the overall effects of
each of the five major mergers on the passengers‟ welfare as evaluated through
consumer surplus changes, starting with the US airways and West Airlines merger
in 2005 and ending with the American Airlines and US Airways merger in 2013.
They develop discrete choice models with fare, nonstop and one-stop service
frequency, travel time, and other carrier and route attributes as parameters. The
consumer surplus, as a function of these parameters, is calculated for each market
as the measure of passengers‟ welfare. By using the markets not affected by the
mergers as a control group, they are able to separate out the welfare effects of
mergers from those of other extrinsic factors such as oil price changes, changes in
economic conditions. The findings that mergers of legacy network carriers with
significant proportion of overlapping markets are generally accompanied by flight
reallocation and network reorganization, which in turn, contribute to an increase in
passenger welfare. The overall passenger welfare for very small communities
declined after the mergers. Also, overall passenger welfare in markets with many
competitors declined, consistent with the classic economic theory of consolidation-
induced welfare losses. The welfare gain from mergers of legacy network carriers
26
Review of Literature
Parimalendu Banerjee, Bijoy Gupta (2017)41 studied three years pre and post
merger financial performance of the companies taking sample size of seven
different industries undergone merger and acquisitions during 2016-2012. Various
financial ratios applied to assess the profitability and liquidity position. The
analysis is conducted with the help of t test and the findings shows that there is no
improvement in financial performance of acquirer companies after merger. Post
merger profitability and liquidity indicators of sample deteriorate.
27
Review of Literature
used to compare similar firms across the same industry or to compare industries or
sectors in aggregation.
28
Review of Literature
FIGURE 2.1
Airline Merger-Research gap
Operational
Performance
Merger
Performance
in Airline
Industry
REFERENCES
Asquith, P., Bruner, R.F., & Mullins Jr., D. W, (1983). The gains to bidding firms
from merger. Journal of Financial Economics, 11(1-4), 121-139.
Ashford, S. J., Lee, C., and Bobko,(1989) Content, Causes and Consequences of
Job Insecurity: A Theory-based Measure and Substantive Test. Academy of
Management Journal, 32: 803-829.
29
Review of Literature
Hansen R.G, (1987). A Theory for the Choice of Exchange Medium in Mergers
and Acquisitions, Journal of Business,75-95
Howell, R,(1970). Plan to integrate your acquisition. Harvard Business Review, 48,
66-76.
30
Review of Literature
Ivancevich, J.M., Schweiger, D.M., & Power, F.R,(1987). Strategies for managing
human resources during mergers and acquisitions, Human Resource
Planning, 10, 19-35.
Jemison, D.B., & Sitkin, S.B,(1986). Acquisitions: The process can be a problem.
Harvard Business Review, 107-116.
Peter J. Frost, Larry F. Moore, Craig C. Lundberg & Joanne Martin, (1991).
Reframing organizational culture, Sage Publications.
31
Review of Literature
32