Belloli-2004-Modeling_and_characterization_of_active-(published_version)
Belloli-2004-Modeling_and_characterization_of_active-(published_version)
ABSTRACT
' manufacturing of sensors and actuators made of piezo-
The scientific community has put significant efforts in the
ceramic fibers with interdigitated electro.des. These allow for increased conformability and actuation capability
at high field regime. The prediction of their coupled field behavior, however, is so far limited to low field ap-
plications, where the piezoelectric coupling coefficient is assumed to be constant. An appro.ach, which takes
into account the strain driven nonlinearity of a rep'resentative work cycle at high field regime is still lacking.
This study presents a nonlinear Finite Element Model to simulate the free strain properties of Active Fiber
Composites (AFCs) under high electric field conditions. Input data for the fully parametric model are the Rep-
resentative Volume Element (RVE) geometry .and the material properties of its piezoceramic and epoxy resin
components. The high field properties of single PZT fibers under free strain conditions were determined using
a novel characterization :procedure. Free strain properties of the actuators were measured experimentally, and
important geometrical parameters (contact angle between the fiber and the electrode, average spacing between
the fibers) were measured using micrographical imaging. The results of the simulation show good agreement with
the free strain measurements, allowing for prediction of a representative work cycle hysteresis. The influeii.ce
of important geometrical parameters on the actuator properties such as electrode spacing and. electrode-fiber
.contact angle was i~vestigated. both numerically and experimentally.
1. INTRODUCTION
Active ·Fiber Composites (AFCs) originated from work stf:l,rted at MIT in 1992 1 . AFCs are composed of PZT
(lead zirconate titanate) fibers and epoxy resin. Interdigitated electrodes (IDEs) are used for poling and to
direct the electric field along the longitudinally oriented PZT fibers (see Figure 1 ). AFCs achieve greater
actuation energy density by exploiting the d 33 effect along the fibers versus the d 31 actuation used in most
monolithic piezoceramic materials. The use of piezocerarnic fibers maintains the majority of the stiffness and
the bandwidth of pure piezoceramics, by simultaneously achieving high conformability and thus integrability in
complex <:urved structures. Furthermore, they allow for anisotropic actuation. These properties make AFCs
interesting components for applications in different fields, such as shape and vibration control.
Analytical and numerical methods were used to predict the performances of AFCs. In his PhD thesis, Bent 2
proposes an analytical model as summation of parallel and series additions of two phase materials. The resulting
Uniform Fields Model (UFM) is thus a generalization of the well known "Rules of Mixtures;' and assumes the
uniformity of the electric and mechanical fields in each phase. Compatibility and equilibrium are violated at
some interfaces. The UFM simplifies the AFC's complex geometry, thus not taking into account the electric
field distortion under the electrode fingers. Nevertheless, it provides a closed form solution that allows physical
insight into the problem. The AFC geometry (i.e. circular fiber cross sections, electrode configuration) can be
fully modelled with FE, and electric field variations in the single phases can be visualized and quantified. This
is of special interest in the matrix gap between electrode and fiber and in the "dead-zone" under the electrode
finger, where the actuation is supposed to be very small or completely absent.
Send correspondence to A. Belfoli: E-mail: [email protected], Telephone: ++411 632 51 86, Address: IMES-
Centre of Structure Technologies, Lconhardstrasse 27, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland
Smart Structures and Materials 2004: Smart Structures and Integrated Systems,
edited by Alison B. Flatau, Proc. of SPIE Vol. 5390 (SPIE, Bellingham, WA, 2004)
0277-786X/04/$15 · doi: 10.1117112.539871
The influence of configuration parameters on the actuation behavior of AFCs has been investigated by different
authors, however only for low field actuation. According to Rossetti 3 and Bent4 , AFCs with a small electrode
spacing p to fiber diameter d ratio show good actuation at lower voltages, but are less efficient due to the steep
curvature of the electric field in the vicinity of the electrode traces. Alternatively, larger p/d ratios are more
efficient, but require higher drive voltages to achieve actuatiOn at the same field levels. Nelson 5 claims that 80%
of the theoretical maximum strain can be achieved with a p/d ratio greater than 4.' Investigating the influence of
the interdigitated electrode structure on the strain response of a PZT bulk substrate, he identifies an optimum
electrode width to substrate thickness ratio of 0.5.
An approach is still lacking that predicts the strain driven nonlinearity observed in AFCs under free strain
conditions. In the scope of this study, a fully parametric FE model is implemented, which predicts the nonlinear
work cycle of different AFC configurations. A procedure is developed for the experimental characterization of
single PZT fibers. In particular, butterfly loops and work cycles are measured, later required for the model.
Manufacturing and characterization of corresponding AFCs allow for experimental validation of the numerical
results.
2. FE ANALYSIS
In the scope of this study, the response behavior of AFCs is predicted by a FE model. In or.der to minimize
computational requirements, an AFC unit cell is defined, that comprises all relevant parameters. Because of
symmetry, the so called Representative Volume Element (RVE) can be defined as an octant of a single fiber and
its surrounding matrix included between two adjacent electrode fingers (see Figure 1).
L-
-
S"y:rnetry plane
Figure 1. Schematic view of an Active Fiber Composite (AFC). The Representative Volume Element (RVE) is defined
as an octant of a single fiber and its surrounding matrix included in two adjacent electrode fingers.
(1)
where cE is the stiffness matrix. For each substep the electric field and free strain values are computed. Electrical
and mechanical boundary conditions are defined in Table 1.
Figure 3. Geometrical parameters measured using the micrographical imaging technology 6 • Fiber diameter, fiber spacing,
contact angle and electrode thickness are described.
a) b)
Figure 4. Characterization of a PZT-5A piezoelectric ceramic fiber via DMA device. a) Butterfly loop, electric field
±3kV/mm. b) Work cycle for an electric field ranging from -0.9kV/mm to 3kV/mm.
The measured work cycle shows a peak~to-peak actuation of approximately 3100ppm for an electrical field
ranging from -0.9 kV/mm to 3 kV/mm. The typical strain driven nonlinearity can be recognized in Figure 4
(b).
-~·-.~::r~:m-
1356 'l!iSU-3
a) b)
\.'f.C:'lXl'.
.Tm 24 2001
NODAL SOLlJT I Ct: J\N
STEP=l STEP .. l JUN 24 2003
10!23!10
scra =l SUB .. 1 10:36:23
TIME=l T11'!E"'l
EF !:P!'.LZ (AVGI
~LEMo:l245
RS'lS•O
MIN=.2!:12E-OB MX =.401I-ll6
MAX=. CiBCiE+OB Sl'ft-i ..-.003892
SK< =.004622
.. .
· VfC~~"O;..f5,$3Wf}1fU~%"1#:%@¥if¥tn~_~ :._{''.'.-'1='/c;"';:=~"-,";~'.'·<:._.'{< ','~·'-;;X;f
-~92E--{l!J .i~OSllill. '.lQ(:&ilHl .1!.()BICO. .roor•oa
· .7503:~01 ·' .2WE•Oa .3751HOO .~Z5E•08 .~86£•0
c) d)
Figure 5. FE results. a) Potential distribution in the RVE with contact between electrode finger and fiber. b) Electric
field distribution in the RVE . Notice the field peak near the electrode edge and the "dead zone" under the electrode
. surface. Far away from the electrodes, a uniform field distribution can be observed. c) Electric field lines in the RVE.
Notice the field distortion under the electrode. d) Strain distribution in the RVE.
agreement with the numerical prediction. Current AFC manufacturing technology is expected to allow contact
angles up to 80'. Trough-the-thickness electrodes under development 11 will completely enclose the fibers, thus
generating a rotationally symmetric electric field.
2000
s=-
.:!;1500
c
.......Ill
Ill
Gl 1000
!!
IL.
500
Figure 6. Work cycles for an electric field ranging from -1 to 3kV/mm. The numerical prediction slightly overest!mates
the measured free strain response.
.
1.00 i
.
0.90 .
__________ T. _________ T: _________ r·---------r·-----------r·---------T---.----r·---------r·-----------r·----------,
' ' ' ' ' .
: : : : : : : : :
0.80
-----------r---------T---~----T~----------r------------1------------r---------r----------r------------:-----------~
"'"'
~
~m 0.70 ------------1------------1--.--------1------------:------------1------------1------------1------------t·-----------t-----------1
"'.
"'
~
0.60
! • ! 0 ! ! ! !
------------r-----------1------------1------------r------------r-----------1
! ! ! '
----~
i, i i i ! ! +Numerical prediction
0.50
········r·········1···········r···········r········
r···········i 0 "''''m•oral ~'"'~ ----~
0.40
0 20 40 60 80 100. 120 140 160 180 200
Contact angle ( 0 )
Figure 7. AFC performance versus contact angle between.electrode and fiber. Experimentally investigated configurations
show good agreement With the numerical prediction.
i 1500
£'~ 1000
p=07_FEM
p=09_FEM
p=11_FEM
• p=13_FEM
-p=0.7mm_exp
500
:..__ p=0.9mm_exp
-p=1.1mm_elip
-p=1.3mm exp
Figure 8. Work cycles of AFCs manufactured with different electrode spacings. Both experimental and numerical results
predict larger peak-to-peak strains for increasing electrode spacing.
5. CONCLUSIONS
The free strain response behavior of AFCs under high field conditions has been predicted by a nonlinear FE Model.
The rnicrographical imaging technology was chosen for determination of relevant geometrical parameters. This
revealed a direct contact region between electrode fingers and piezoelectric ceramic fibers. Required characteristic
curves for the piezoelectric coefficients have been accurately determined using a novel characterization procedure
for single PZT fibers based on the DMA device~ The numerical simulation accounted for the AFC's geometrical
complexity and gave insight into the .;lectric field and strain distributions. Due to the assumed uniformity of
the piezoelectric coefficients, numerical results slightly overestimate the experimentally determined free strain
response. The typical work cycle has been predicted for AFCs with different electrode configurations, thus
providing a tool for further AFC optimization. Numerical and experimental findings corroborate previously
published results, revealing enhanced actuation performance for increasing electrode spacing to fiber diameter
ratios. Finally, the influence of the contact angle has been investigated, showing interesting potential for further
performance improvements.
440pm/V
-d33/2.38 185pm/V
d33 · l.27 560pm/V
Table 3. Material Properties for PZT5Al Fibers and Epoxy Resin Araldite LY 564/ Aradur 2954
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Support for this research has been provided by a grant from ETH (Zurich) and EMPA (Duebendorf). The
experimental facilities were provided by EN,{PA (Duebendorf). This work is part of the joint project between
EMPA* IFAt and IMEST.
REFERENCES
1. A. A. Bent and N. W. Hagood, "Development of piezoelectric fiber composites for structural actuation,"
in Proc. 34th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS Structures; Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference. AIAA
Paper no. 93-1717, (La ,Jolla, CA), April :).993. .
2. A. A. Bent, Active Fiber Compopifos for St~-uctural Applications. PhD thesis, Massachusetts Institute of
Technology, 1997. .
3. G. A. Rossetti, A. E. Pizzochero, and .A. A. }3ent, "Recent advancP,s in active fiber composites technology,"
in Proc. Jffh IEEE International Symposium on the Application of Ferroelectrics, Vol. 2, pp. 753-757, 2001.
4. A. A. Bent and A. E. Pizzochcro, "Recent advances in active fiber composites for structural control," in
Proc. SPIE Smart Structures and Materials, Industrial and Commercial Applications of Smart Structures
Technologies, SPIE Vol.3991, pp. 244-254, (Newport Beach, CA), March 2000.
5. L . .J. Nelson, C. R. Bowen, R. Stevens, M. Cain, and M. Stewart, "Modelling and measurement of piezoelec-
tric fibres and interdigitated electrodes for the optimisation of piezofibre composites," in Proc. SPIE Smart
Structures and Materials, Active Materials: Behavior and Mechanics, SPIE Vol. 5053, pp. 556-567, (San
Diego, CA), March 2003.
6. B. Castelli and A. Belloli, "Modeling and c;haracterization of active fiber composites," Master's thesis, Centre
of Structure Technologies, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, 2003 .
. 7. "IEEE standard on piezoelectricity." ANSI/IEEE Std 176-1987, 1987.
8. R. Zehnder, B. Castelli, and A. Belloli, "Novel characterization procedure for single PZT fibers," Tech. Rep.
· IMES 04-035, Centre of Structure Technologies, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Februar 2004.
9. X. Kornmann, C. Huber, and A. R. Elsener, "Piezoelectric ceramic fibers for active fiber composites: a com-
parative study," in Proc. SPIE Smart Structures and Materials, Smart Structures and Integrated Systems,
SPIE Vol.5056, pp. 330-337, (San Diego, CA), March 2003.
•www.empa.ch/ plugin/ template/empa/57/
t www.controLethz.. ch
twww.imes.ethz.ch/st/
Smart structures and integrated systems I Smart Structures and Materials 2004, 15-18 March
Titel 2004, San Diego, California, USA ; Alison B. Flatau, chair/ ed.·; spons. and publ. by SPIE - The
International Society for Optical Engineering .,. fetal.]
Impressum Bellingham, Washington : SPIE, 2004
Umfang 598 S. : Ill.
Reihe (Proceedings of SPIE. 2004- ; vol. 53901
Gehe zu Proceedings of SPIE. 2004-
ISBN 0-8194-5307-2
Externe Verbindung ETH Zurich Zugriff Ober: http://spiedl.aip.org/iournals/doc/SPIEDL-home/proc/
Gesamtbestand
Bibliothek
Sacherschliessung
Bestellen: Klicken Sie auf Alie Exemplare oder den Namen der Bibliothek (rechte Spalte}, um zu Exemplaren zu kommen
und ggf. zu bestellen. Bei Zeitschriften konnen Sie auch den Bestand eines Jahres auswahlen.
Klicken Sie auf einen unterstrichenen Begriff in der Titelanzeige, um zu den Suchdiensten zu gelangen.
Klicken Sie auf [i], um die Bibliotheksinfo zu sehen.
Feedback/Anregungen - FAQ
I of 1 28.10.2004 16:23