P. Puspitasari IJE - Volume 33 - Issue 5 - Pages 877-884
P. Puspitasari IJE - Volume 33 - Issue 5 - Pages 877-884
PAPER INFO A B S T R A C T
Paper history: Cobalt ferrite or CoFe2O4 has unique physical and magnetic properties depend on its synthesis method.
Received 18 February 2020 The application of cobalt ferrite as nanomedicine material become more interesting, however analysis
Received in revised form 20 March 2020 on physical and magnetic properties based on synthesis method have not been discussed. The cobalt
Accepted 10 April 2020 ferrite in this research was synthesised using two different methods: the sol-gel with duration sintering
variations of 500℃, 800℃, and 1100℃ and unsintered sonochemical. The phase identification
Keywords: analysis and crystal size used XRD and morphology analysis used SEM, the functional group bond
Phase Identification analysis used FTIR, and magnetic property analysis used VSM. The smallest crystal size from the XRD
Morphology result was 13.25 nm with 57.04% crystallinity. The morphology from the synthesized cobalt ferrite
Hysteresis Curve was mostly agglomerated. The FTIR showed functional group vibration at 601-636 cm-1 that signified
Hyperthermia the spinel structure of the cobalt ferrite. There was a change of hysteresis loop curve from hard
magnetic to soft magnetic, and there was a sample with a paramagnetic curve.
doi: 10.5829/ije.2020.33.05b.20
NOMENCLATURE
D Crystalline diameter (nm) A XRD diagram sample area
k Corrective Constants (0.9) R Remanence Ratio
λ Wavelength (1.5406 Å) Mr Magnetic Remanence (emu/g)
FWHM Full-width half maximum (the peak value in radians) Ms Magnetic Saturation (emu/g)
θ Peak angle (degree) HC Coercivity (Oersted)
It Crystalline peak intensity K1 Constant Anisotropy (erg/g)
Ia Amorphous area intensity μ0 Permeability of Free Space (H/m)
Acr Area of crystalline XRD diagram SLP Specific Loss Power (W/g)
CI Crystallinity Index
Please cite this article as: P. Puspitasari, L. S. Budi, Physical and Magnetic Properties Comparison of Cobalt Ferrite Nanopowder Using Sol-gel
and Sonochemical Methods, International Journal of Engineering (IJE), IJE TRANSACTIONS B: Applications Vol. 33, No. 5, (May 2020) 877-
884
878 P. Puspitasari and L. S. Budi / IJE TRANSACTIONS B: Applications Vol. 33, No. 5, (May 2020) 877-884
is applied as supercapacitor and anode in Li-ion battery glycol and was stirred for 2 hours with rotation speed of
[4]. Cobalt Ferrite can also be used in medical 200 rpm. Then, the solution was stirred and heated at
applications because of the magnetic properties. 80℃ with a rotation speed of 200 rpm until it turned to
Hyperthermia is one of a modality cancer treatments at gel. Gel formation occured in about 16.5 hours. After
elevated temperature between 41 ℃ and 45 ℃ and that, the sample was dried in the microwave oven for 7
treatment time of at least 30 minutes has been paid hours at 100℃. After drying process, the sample was
considerable attention due to its clinical efficacies, such grinded by agate mortar for 1 hour.
as minimizing clinical side effects and can selectively
destroy a localized or a deeply seated cancer tumor by 2. 3. The Sonochemical Method The base material
heating with magnetic field [5]. Well-dispersed cobalt in this research were 2.951 g Cobalt(II) nitrate
nanoparticles in the hyperthermia application give hexahydrate (Co(NO3)·6H2O with 99% purity, 8.08 g
effective and controlled heat generation [6]. Iron(III) nitrate nonahydrate (Fe(NO3)·9H2O with 99%
Cobalt ferrite (CoFe2O4) has unique physical purity that were bought from Merck and dissolved into
and mechanical properties and widely applicated in 100 ml DI Water. The mixture was stirred for 1 hours
nanomedicine [6], supercapacitor and anode in Li-ion with rotation speed of 200 rpm. Then, the solution was
battery [4]. Cobalt ferrite is a hard magnetic material with stirred and heated at 80℃ with the rotation speed of 200
high Curie temperature (520℃), high coercivity of rpm until it turned to gel. After, the sample was sonicated
around 4.3 kOe at room temperature for single domain for 30 minutes and titrated with 100 ml sodium hydroxide
with the size of 40 nm, medium saturation magnetization 10 M, washed with 750 ml distilled water for three times
of 80 emu/g for bulk material at room temperature, high and dried in the microwave oven at 100℃. The sample
anisotropy constant (2.65 x 106 – 5.1 x 106 erg cm-3) and was then grinding by agate mortar for 1 hour.
high magnetostrictive (-225 x 10-6). Besides, cobalt
ferrite shows excellent chemical stability, mechanical 2. 4. Characterization The powder from the sol-gel
hardness, wear resistance, easy to synthesis, and and sonochemical synthesis methods each had yellowish-
electrical isolation. The above properties make cobalt brown and darkish black colour. The cobalt ferrite from
ferrite as one of the promising candidates in various two methods then characterized to find the phase
applications. identification and crystallite size using the X-Ray
The magnetic property of CoFe2O4 depends on the Diffractometer (XRD) PAN Analytical Cu Kα (λ = 1.54
grain size and cation distribution in the form of Å), morphology of CoFe2O4 obtained from Scanning
tetrahedral and octahedral lattice [7]. Several synthesis Electron Microscopy of Phenom, the functional group
methods to produce CoFe2O4 nanomaterial in a right was observed using Fourrier Transform Infrared
nanometric scale are sol-gel and sonochemical [2, 8,9]. (Shimadzu) and the magnetic properties were obtained
To date the researcher still find the best synthesis from Vibrating Sample Magnetometer of OXFORD 1.2H
methods to obtain single phase CoFe2O4 resulted in the at room temperature.
best magnetic properties. This research surprisingly
describe how CoFe2O4 magnetic properties changing
from hard magnetic to soft magnetic material as the 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
sintering temperatures varied and also study the
comparison of two synthesis methods which are sol-gel 3. 1. Phase Characterization The polycrystalline
and sonochemical in term of physical and magnetic material properties depend on the crystal size and this fact
properties.
triggered several decades of research to find the size material until 70.64 nm at sintering temperature
nanomaterial with the best crystal size. Therefore, it is 1100, but it did not happen with the crystallinity in the
essential to measure the crystallite size of the range of 500 to 1100℃ sample. The crystallinity of the
polycrystalline material accurately. The crystallite size sample was saturated for 57% from 500℃ until 1100℃
was calculated using the Scherrer equation [10,11]. but increasing the crystallinity unsintered sample which
𝑘× 𝜆 was 44.17% crystallinity to 57.04%.
𝐷= (1)
𝐹𝑊𝐻𝑀×cos 𝜃
3. 2. Morphological Characterization The
Crystallinity percentage in the samples were taken
observation and comparison of morphology form were
into consideration because crystallinity influences the
conducted using SEM. This analysis aimed to find the
phase and physical property. Crystalinity percentage or
morphological change of CoFe2O4 from different
Segal CI (Crystallinity Index) was found by Segal et al.
synthesis method and different sintering temperature.
[12] and formulated as peak crystalline area divided by
the amorph area as shown below [13]:
𝐼𝑡−𝐼𝑎
𝐶𝐼 = × 100% (2)
𝐼𝑡
Or,
𝐴𝑐𝑟
𝐶𝐼 = × 100% (3)
𝐴
(a)
(b)
Figure 3. Comparison Effect of Sintering CoFe2O4 Samples,
(a) Sintering Temperature and Crsytallite Size, (b) Sintering
Temperature and Crystallinity
Figure 5 shows the comparison of the FTIR spectrum other molecules and thus make the intensity to decrease
from four samples with three main zones analysis. There [19]. Also different methods proved that sol-gel samples
are several peaks based on various treatments in the first had higher water content as seen from the peak intensity
zone, 636 cm-1 for sonochemical method, sol-gel 500℃ of the second zone and the third zone because the
sintering 601 cm-1, sol-gel 800℃ sintering 619 cm-1and synthesis process form sol then followed by liquid
sol-gel 1100℃ sintering 623 cm-1.The first zone was compaction into a gel that will not be separated easily
indicated the area stretching vibration from the metal- from the content of water molecules in it.
oxygen (M–O, where M = Co or Fe) that showed identity 𝑀𝑟
and finger print zone from the CoFe2O4 absorption band 𝑅= (4)
𝑀𝑠
[17].
The difference in the absorption position in the first 3. 4. Magnetic Properties Analysis The magnetic
zone that was the fingerprint of CoFe2O4 due to the property of CoFe2O4 that was synthesized was obtained
crystal size are variated. The variated crystal size will from the VSM test such as magnetic saturation (Ms),
make difference distance between Fe3+-O2- then the magnetic remanence (Mr), and coercivity (Hc) [20]. Ms is
absorption will slightly difference between the samples. the maximum value of magnetization that is received
The second zone compound several peaks based on the from the given magnetic field. The value of Mr can be
samples, there are 1456 cm-1 for sonochemical method, taken from the intersection of curves that intersect with
sol-gel 500℃ sintering 1531 cm-1, sol-gel 800℃ the vertical axis. Hc is the magnetic field intensity needed
sintering 1427 cm-1, sol-gel 1100℃ sintering 1409 cm-1. to make the magnetic sample reach zero magnetization
The second zone indicated bending vibration and after achieving magnetization saturation. Remanence
stretching vibration from the hydroxyl (-OH) functional ratio is the ability of magnetic material to change the
group as one of the characteristics of water absorption curve in the hysteresis loop curve after the magnetic field
bands [18] the adsorbed water is featured by the bands at is removed [21]. The value of parametere above was
1409-1531 cm-1assigned to the δ H-O-H bonding mode described in Table 2. Remanence ratio can be formulated
[19]. From the second zone, we can imply that water [22].
molecules does not get totally remove from the sample
although there are several heat treatments applied to the
samples.
The third zone had several differences, but for the
sonochemical CoFe2O4, peak 3423 cm-1 and 3412 cm-1
could not be observed as well as the spectrum of the
sintered sample at 1100℃. The both peaks have been
assigned to antisymmetric and symmetric O-H stretching
vibration of lattice water. Thus, this situation followed
the sintering process that omits water content because the
sample was sintered at 1100℃.
Meanwhile the sonochemical sample lost the peak
due to the long duration of drying. The second zone
peak’s appeared on all synthesised samples because this
is the water molecule identity. This peak experienced
intensity decrease along with the increasing sintering Figure 5. FTIR Spectra Analysis of CoFe2O4 with Different
temperature that proved the sintering temperature Sintering Temperatur and Methods
reduces water molecule as well as water absorption by
Figure 6 shows the comparison of the hysteresis loop In the application of hyperthermia, it requires several
curve from the synthesized CoFe2O4. The hysteresis loop important parameters, such as high Ms and Hc values so
curve of the sintered sample at 500℃ indicated hard that it can quickly kill cancer cells but dissolved particles
magnetic material, sintered sample at 800℃ indicated must be small in size. Based on reported data by
soft magnetic material, while the sintered sample at Yadavalli et al. [28] nanomaterials CoFe2O4 with
1100℃ and sonochemical sample indicated crystallite size 19.8 nm have Ms and Hc about 59 emu/g
paramagnetic material [23]. The change from hard and ± 300 Oe, which was the best results for their
magnetic into soft magnetic occurred in 500℃ to 800℃ experiment to hyperthermia study. Darwish et al. [29]
sintering temperature. Changes in the curve are thought reported nanomaterials CoFe2O4 with crystallite size
to be due to the sintering temperature which has exceeded 32.46 nm have Ms about 50.61 emu/g with applicate to
its temperature (520℃) [7] thereby reducing Mr and HC; hyperthermia have SLP value about 552 W/g. Rashad et
the change was due to the transition from a single domain al. [30] reported nanomaterials CoFe2O4 with crystallite
to multi-domain [14]. The transition change was caused size 10.7 nm have Ms and Hc about 36.2 emu/g and 513.2
by the critical diameter of CoFe2O4 that was 40 nm Oe with applicate to hyperthermia have SLP value about
according to Figure 7, and thus, after passing the critical 302 W/g. Nam et al. [31] reported nanomaterials
diameter, the coercivity was reduced [24, 25]. CoFe2O4 with crystallite size 11 nm have Ms about 58
With the decrease of Hc, there was an increase of Ms emu/g which is applicable to hyperthermia have SLP
from 89.02 emu/g to 113.5 emu/g following the Brown’s value about 297 W/g. Yasemian et al. [32] also reported
equation as follows [14, 27]: nanomaterials CoFe2O4 having crystallite size 11.1 nm
2𝐾1 have Ms and Hc about 42.94 emu/g and 169.19 Oe with
𝐻𝑐 = (5)
𝜇0𝑀𝑠
5. REFERENCES
(a)
1. Yadav RS, Kuřitka I, Vilcakova J, Havlica J, Kalina L, Urbánek
P, Machovsky M, Skoda D, Masař M, Holek M (2018)
Sonochemical synthesis of Gd3+ doped CoFe 2O4 spinel ferrite
nanoparticles and its physical properties. Ultrason Sonochem,
Vol. 40, 773-783
2. Karthigayan N, Manimuthu P, Priya M, Sagadevan S (2017)
Synthesis and characterization of NiFe2O4, CoFe2O4 and
CuFe2O4 thin films for anode material in Li-ion batteries.
Nanomaterials and Nanotechnology, Vol. 7, 1-5
3. Goswami PP, Choudhury HA, Chakma S, Moholkar VS (2013)
Sonochemical synthesis of cobalt ferrite nanoparticles.
International Journal of Chemical Engineering.
https://doi.org/10.1155/2013/934234
4. Jun G, Liping J, Junjie Z "Crystal formation and growth
mechanism of inorganic nanomaterials in sonochemical
syntheses", Science China Chemistry, Vol. 55, (2012), 2292-
(b) 2310.
Figure 8. Comparison of Sol-Gel CoFe2O4 Samples, (a) 5. Mazario E, Menéndez N, Herrasti P, Cañete M, Connord V,
Crsytallite size and Magnetic Saturation, (b) Crsytallite size Carrey J, "Magnetic hyperthermia properties of
and Coercivity electrosynthesized cobalt ferrite nanoparticles", The Journal of
Physical Chemistry C, Vol. 117, (2013), 11405-11411
6. Amiri S, Shokrollahi H "The role of cobalt ferrite magnetic
applicate to hyperthermia have SLP value about 395 W/g. nanoparticles in medical science", Materials Science
Engineering C, Vol. 33, (2013), 1-8.
Based on the research mentioned above, the cobalt ferrite
7. Zheng JC, Shen XQ, Min CY, Meng XF, Liang QR, "Fabrication
sol-gel with sintering 500℃ with crystallite size 13.25 and characterization of heterostructural CoFe 2O4/
nm have a big potential to applicate to hyperthermia due Pb(Zr0.52Ti0.48)O3 nanofibers by electrospinning", Journal of
the Ms and Hc greater than mentioned before also will be Composite Material, Vol. 44, (2010), 2135-2144
easily dispersed. 8. Ismail W.N.W., Sol–gel technology for innovative fabric
finishing-A Review. Journal of Sol-Gel Science and
Technology, Vol. 78 No. 3, (2016), 698-707.
4. CONCLUSION 9. Rajan Babu D, Venkatesan K, "Synthesis of nanophasic CoFe2O4
powder by self-igniting solution combustion method using mix up
fuels", Journal of Crystal Growth, Vol. 468, (2017), 179-184
The synthesized cobalt ferrite with two methods,
unsintered sonochemical and sintered sol-gel at 500℃, 10. Muniz FTL, Miranda MAR, Morilla Dos Santos C, Sasaki JM
"The Scherrer equation and the dynamical theory of X-ray
800℃, and 1100℃ for 2 hours had cubic spinel structure diffraction", Acta Crystallography Section A, Vol. 72, (2016),
with the smallest crystal size of 13.25 nm and the largest 385-390.
of 70.64 nm following the increasing sintering time, the 11. Sasongko MIN, Puspitasari P, Yazirin C, Tsamroh DI,
lowest crystallinity of 44.16% and the highest of 57.7%. Risdanareni P, "Morphology and phase identification of micron
The SEM results showed that the morphology of cobalt to nanosized manganese oxide (MnO) with variations in sintering
time", AIP Conference Proceedings. (2017),
ferrite was decreasing agglomeration and smaller grain https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5003520
size following the high sintering temperature. The FTIR 12. Nam S, French AD, Condon BD, Concha M, "Segal crystallinity
analysis presented functional group vibration at 601-636 index revisited by the simulation of X-ray diffraction patterns of
cm-1 that signified the spinel structure identity. The VSM cotton cellulose Iβ and cellulose II", Carbohydrate Polymers,
results showed a change in hysteresis loop curve from the Vol. 135, (2016), 1-9
884 P. Puspitasari and L. S. Budi / IJE TRANSACTIONS B: Applications Vol. 33, No. 5, (May 2020) 877-884
13. Ahvenainen P, Kontro I, Svedström K, "Comparison of sample Springer-Scffince+Business Media, B.V. (1991).
crystallinity determination methods by X-ray diffraction for 24. Afshari M, Rouhani Isfahani AR, Hasani S, Davar F, Jahanbani
challenging cellulose I materials", Cellulose, Vol. 23, (2016), Ardakani K "Effect of apple cider vinegar agent on the
1073-1086. microstructure, phase evolution, and magnetic properties of
14. Xavier S, Jiji MK, Thankachan S, Mohammed EM "Effect of CoFe2O4 magnetic nanoparticles", International Journal of
sintering temperature on the structural and electrical properties of Applied Ceramic Technology, Vol. 16, No. 4, (2019), 1612-1621
cobalt ferrite nanoparticles" AIP Conference Proceedings, Vol. 25. Perales-Pérez O, Cedeño-Mattei Y (2017) Optimizing Processing
1576, 98-101 Conditions to Produce Cobalt Ferrite Nanoparticles of Desired
15. Huixia F, Baiyi C, Deyi Z, Jianqiang Z, Lin T "Preparation and Size and Magnetic Properties. Magnetic Spinels-Synthesis,
characterization of the cobalt ferrite nano-particles by reverse Properties and Applications. https://doi.org/10.5772/66842
coprecipitation" Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, 26. Goodarz Naseri M, Saion EB, Abbastabar Ahangar H, Shaari AH,
Vol. 356, (2014), 68-72 Hashim M, "Simple synthesis and characterization of cobalt
16. Sagadevan S, Podder J, Das I "Recent trends in materials science ferrite nanoparticles by a thermal treatment method" Journal of
and applications - Nanomaterials, Crystal Growth, Thin films", Nanomaterials, (2010). https://doi.org/10.1155/2010/907686
Quantum Dots, & Spectroscopy (Proceedings ICRTMSA 2016). 27. El-Okr MM, Salem MA, Salim MS, El-Okr RM, Ashoush M,
189, (2017), 145–152 Talaat HM "Synthesis of cobalt ferrite nano-particles and their
17. Mohamed RM, Rashad MM, Haraz FA, Sigmund W "Structure magnetic characterization", Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic
and magnetic properties of nanocrystalline cobalt ferrite powders Materials, Vol. 323, (2011), 920-926.
synthesized using organic acid precursor method", Journal of 28. Yadavalli T, Jain H, Chandrasekharan G, Chennakesavulu R,
Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, Vol. 322, (2010), 2058- "Magnetic hyperthermia heating of cobalt ferrite nanoparticles
2064 prepared by low temperature ferrous sulfate based method", AIP
18. Pasupong P, Choojun K, Vittayakorn N, Seeharaj P, "Synthesis of Advances, (2016), https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4942951
nanocrystalline cobalt ferrite by the sonochemical method in 29. Darwish MSA, Kim H, Lee H, Ryu C, Lee JY, Yoon J, "Synthesis
highly basic aqueous solution" Key Engineeing Materials Vol. of magnetic ferrite nanoparticles with high hyperthermia
751 KEM, (2017), 368-373 performance via a controlled co-precipitation method",
19. Pauline S, Amaliya a P "Synthesis and Characterization of Highly Nanomaterials, (2019), https://doi.org/10.3390/nano9081176.
Monodispersive CoFe2O4 Magnetic Nanoparticles by 30. Rashad MM, Mahmoud SM, Abdel-Hamid Z, El-Sayed HM,
Hydrothermal Chemical Route", Archives of Applied Science Shalan AE, Khalifa NA, Kandil AT, "Structural, magnetic
Research, Vol. 3, (2011), 213-223 properties, and induction heating behavior studies of cobalt ferrite
20. Sabeeh SH, Sabeeh ZSA (2017) Preparation and Studying nanopowders synthesized using modified co-precipitation
Magnetic Properties of Cobalt Ferrite (CoFe CoFe2O4) Material. method", Particulate Science and Technology, Vol. 36, No. 2,
International Journal of Science Engineering Research Vol. 8, No. (2018), 172-177
3, 332514248 31. Nam PH, Lu LT, Linh PH, Manh DH, Thanh Tam LT, Phuc NX,
21. Kanagesan S, Hashim M, Tamilselvan S, Alitheen NB, Ismail I, Phong PT, Lee IJ, Polymer-coated cobalt ferrite nanoparticles:
Syazwan M, Zuikimi MMM, "Sol-gel auto-combustion synthesis Synthesis, characterization, and toxicity for hyperthermia
of cobalt ferrite and it’s cytotoxicity properties", Digest Journal applications. New Journal of Chemistry, Vol. 42, (2018), 14530-
of Nanomaterials & Biostructures Vol. 8, No. 4, (2013), 1601- 14541.
1610. 32. Yasemian AR, Almasi Kashi M, Ramazani A, "Exploring the
22. Xu S, Ma Y, Geng B, Sun X, Wang M "The remanence ratio in effect of Co concentration on magnetic hyperthermia properties
CoFe2O4 nanoparticles with approximate single-domain sizes", of CoxFe3−xO4 nanoparticles" Materials Research Express, Vol.
Nanoscale Research Letters, Vol. 11, No. 1, (2016), 1-9. 7, (2020), 016113.
23. David Jiles "Introduction to Magnetism and Magnetic Materials"
Persian Abstract
چکیده
استفاده از فریت کبالت به عنوان ماده نانومواد جالب. دارای خواص فیزیکی و مغناطیسی منحصر به فردی هستند که به روش سنتز آن بستگی داردCoFe2O4 فریت کبالت یا
فریت کبالت در این تحقیق با استفاده از دو روش مختلف. اما تجزیه و تحلیل خواص فیزیکی و مغناطیسی بر اساس روش سنتز مورد بحث قرار نگرفته است، تر می باشند
وXRD تجزیه و تحلیل شناسایی فاز و اندازه کریستال. و سونوشیمیایی بدون هدف1100 ℃ و800 ، 500 ژل با مدت زمان تغییرات تغییرات پراکندگی- سل:سنتز گردید
XRD کوچکترین اندازه بلور از نتیجه. استفاده شده استVSM و تجزیه و تحلیل خاصیت مغناطیسی ازFTIR آنالیز پیوند گروهی کاربردی، SEM آنالیز مورفولوژی از
نشان داد که601-636 cm-1 ارتعاش گروه عملکردی را درFTIR . مورفولوژی حاصل از فریت کبالت سنتز شده بیشتر آگلومره بود. بود٪57.04 نانومتر با بلوریت13.25
. تغییری در منحنی حلقه هیسترزیس از مغناطیسی سخت به مغناطیسی نرم وجود دارد و نمونه ای با منحنی پارامغناطیسی وجود دارد.حاکی از ساختار ا سپینل فریت کبالت است