Mfa-pp Topic Wise
Mfa-pp Topic Wise
Question 1
Question 1
Suggested Solution
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 2
Topic: KPIs
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Suggested Solution – Q2
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 3
Suggested Solution – Q3
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 4
Topic: Downsizing
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Suggested Solution to Q4
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 5
Question 6
Question 7
Question 8
Suggested Solution to Q8
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 9
Suggested Solution to Q9
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 10
Topic: Outsourcing
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 11
Topic: Benchmarking
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 12
Question 13
Question 14:
Question 15
Question 16
Question 17
Select the most appropriate option and give reasons for your answer to (i)
(i)
(ii)
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
(i) Option B
(ii) Option D
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 18
Topic: KPIs
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 19
Solution to Q19
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 20
Question 21
Question 22
Question 23
Topic: Outsourcing
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 24
Question 25
Question 26
Question 27
Question 28
Question 29
Question 30
Question 31
Topic: IT risks
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 32
Topic: BCG
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 33
Question 34
Question 35
Topic: IT Controls
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 36
Question 37
Topic: Ethics
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 38
Topic: BCG
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Question 39
Question 40
Question 41
Question 42
Step 3: What are the norms, principles, and values related to the case?
The norms, principles, and values are that auditors are assumed (by shareholders and others active in capital markets) to have
impeccable integrity and to assure that the company is providing a ‘true and fair view’ of its financial situation at the time of the audit.
Auditors are entrusted with the task of assuring a company’s financial accounts and anything that prevents this or interferes with an
auditor’s objectivity is a failure of the auditor’s duty to shareholders.
Step 5: What is the best course of action that is consistent with the norms, principles, and
values identified in Step 3?
The course of action consistent with the norms, principles, and values in Step 3 is to refuse the bribe. The auditor would report the
initial irregular payment and then also probably report the client for offering the second bribe.
Question 43
Big Company is planning to build a new factory in a developing country. Analysis shows that the new factory investment will be more
profitable than alternatives because of the cheaper labour and land costs. The government of the developing country has helped the
company with its legal compliance, which is now fully complete, and the local population is anxiously waiting for the jobs which will,
in turn, bring much needed economic growth to the developing country. The factory is to be built on reclaimed ‘brownfield’ land and
will produce a lower unit rate of environmental emissions than a previous technology.
Required:
Evaluate the situation using Tucker’s Five Question Model
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Is it profitable?
Yes. The investment will enable the company to make a superior return than the alternatives. The case explains that these are
‘because of the cheaper labour and land costs’.
Is it legal?
Yes. The government of the developing country, presumably very keen to attract the investment, has helped the company with its
legal issues.
Is it fair?
As far as we can tell, yes. The only stakeholder mentioned in the scenario is the workforce of the developing country who, we are
told, is ‘anxiously waiting’ for the jobs. The scenario does not mention any stakeholders adversely affected by the investment.
Is it right?
Yes. The scenario explains that the factory will help the developing country with ‘much needed economic growth’, and no
counter-arguments are given.
Some more information has emerged about Big Company’s new factory in the developing country. The ‘brownfield’ land that the
factory is to be built on has been forcefully requisitioned from a community (the ‘Poor Community’) considered as ‘second class
citizens’ by the government of the developing country. The Poor Community occupied the land as a slum and now has nowhere to
live.
CAF-06 with BQ, ACA, FCCA
Solution to Q44
Is it profitable?
Yes. The same arguments apply as before.
Is it legal?
It appears that the government of the developing country has no effective laws to prevent the forced displacement of the Poor
Community and may be complicit in the forced removal. While the investment may not be technically illegal, it appears that the legal
structures in the host country are not particularly robust and are capable of what amounts to the oppression of thePoor Community.
Is it fair?
While the issue of the much needed employment remains important, it must be borne in mind that the jobs are provided at the cost of
the Poor Community’s homes. This apparent unfairness to the Poor Community is a relevant factor in this question. The answer to ‘is
it fair?’ will depend on the decision maker’s views of the conflicting rights of the parties involved.
Is it right?
The new information invites the decision maker to make an ethical assessment of the rights of the Poor Community against the
economic benefits of the investment. Other information might be sought to help to make this assessment including, for example, the
legality of the Poor Community’s occupation of the site, and options for rehousing them once construction on the site has begun.