EE251 Notes0 Power System Models
Uploaded by
Daniel TuqueroEE251 Notes0 Power System Models
Uploaded by
Daniel TuqueroElectrical & Electronics Engineering Institute
University of the Philippines Diliman
EE 251
Fault Studies
Review Notes
Power System Models
Prof. Rowaldo del Mundo The following notes were prepared by the
Electrical Engineering Faculty of the Electrical &
Associate Professor Electronics Engineering Institute of the University
of the Philippines
Power System Models
Transmission & Distribution Lines
Transformers
Generators
Electric Utility (Power Grid)
Two-Port Network
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 2
1
Transmission & Distribution Lines
Sequence Impedance
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 3
Positive Sequence Impedance
For a transposed three-phase transmission line
Z1 Z2 r1 jx1 /mile/phase
r1 = resistance per unit length of one phase
conductor or bundle
x1 = reactance per unit length of one phase
Dm
x1 2.02 x 103 f ln /mile/phase
Ds
f = power frequency (Hertz)
Dm = Geometric Mean Distance (GMD)
Ds = Geometric Mean Radius (GMR)
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 4
2
Geometric Mean Distance
Typical three-phase line configurations
D12 D23
D31
D12
D12 D23
D31
Dm 3 D12D23D31
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 5
Geometric Mean Radius
For a solid conductor with radius r
1
Ds r 4
0.78r
Bundle of Two Bundle of Four
d
d
d
Ds Dscd
Ds 1.09 4 Dscd3
Note: Dsc=GMR of a single conductor
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 6
3
Aluminum Conductors
Aluminum is preferred over copper as a material
for transmission lines due to:
• lower cost
• lighter weight
• larger diameter for the same resistance*
Note: *This results in a lower voltage gradient at
the conductor surface (less tendency for corona)
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 7
Stranded Conductors
Alternate layers of wire of a Steel
stranded conductor are
spiraled in opposite directions
to prevent unwinding and
make the outer radius of one
layer coincide with the inner Aluminum
radius of the next.
The number of strands depends on the number
of layers and on whether all the strands are of
the same diameter. The total number of strands
of uniform diameter in a concentrically stranded
cable is 7, 19, 37, 61, 91, etc.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 8
4
Example: Each conductor of the 345 kV bundled
three-phase line shown is 1272 MCM ACSR 54/19
Pheasant. Assuming complete transposition and a
total length of 80 miles, determine the positive-
sequence impedance of the line. Assume d=45 cm
and D=8 meters.
d
From a table of conductor D D
characteristics, we get
r = 0.0821 /mile @ 50oC
Dsc = 0.0466 ft = 0.0142 m
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 9
We get
Dm 3 8(8)(16) 10.08 m
Ds 0.0142(0.45) 0.08 m
The total resistance per phase
R1 0.0821(80)(0.5) 3.28
The total reactance per phase
10.08
X1 2.02 x 10-3(60)(80) ln 46.9
0.08
The positive (or negative) sequence impedance of
the line
Z1 Z2 3.28 j46.9 / phase
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 10
5
Transmission Line Inductance
The total self-inductance of a cylindrical conductor
consists of an internal inductance and an external
inductance.
Internal Inductance:
c
L int Henry/meter
8
Note: c is the permeability of the conductor.For
a non-ferrous conductor such as copper or
aluminum,
c 4 x 10-7 Henry/meter
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 11
External Inductance:
The external inductance may be approximated by
m 2s
L ext (ln 1) Henry/meter
2 r
where
m = permeability of the medium surrounding
the conductor
r = radius of the conductor
s = length of the conductor
Note: For air, m 0 4 x 10-7 Henry/meter
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 12
6
Self Inductance:
c m 2s
L (ln 1) Henry/meter
8 2 r
For a non-ferrous conductor in air, we get
2s
L 2 x 10-7 (ln 1) Henry/meter
Ds
where Ds is the geometric mean radius of the
conductor
Note: For a solid conductor,
1
Ds r 4
0.78r
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 13
Mutual Inductance:
The mutual inductance between two conductors is
2s
M 2 x 10-7 (ln 1) Henry/meter
Dm
where Dm is the geometric mean distance
between the conductors
Note: For any unit of length,
2s
L k (ln 1) Henry/unit length
Ds
2s
M k (ln 1) Henry/unit length
Dm
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 14
7
Carson’s Line
Carson examined a single overhead conductor
whose remote end is connected to earth.
a
zaa a’
+
Local Remote
Earth
Va Ia zad Earth
-
Fictitious
REF Vd 0 Return
d d’ Conductor
Id zdd
The current returns through a fictitious earth
conductor whose GMR is assumed to be 1 foot (or
1 meter and is located a distance Dad from the
overhead conductor.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 15
The lineis described
by the following
equations:
Vaa' Va Va' zaaIa zadId
Vdd' Vd Vd' zadIa zddId
Note: Ia Id , Vd 0 and Va' Vd' 0.
Subtracting the two equations, we get
Va (zaa zdd 2zad)Ia
or
Va zaaIa
Note: zaa is the equivalent impedance of the
single overhead conductor.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 16
8
Primitive Impedances:
2s
zaa ra jL a ra jk(ln 1)
Dsa
2s
zdd rd jk(ln 1)
Dsd
2s
zad jM jk(ln 1)
Dad
ra, rd = resistances of overhead conductor and
fictitious ground wire, respectively
Dsa, Dsd = GMRs of overhead conductor and
fictitious ground wire, respectively
Note: Dsd is arbitrarily set to 1 unit length
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 17
Earth Resistance:
Carson derived an empirical formula for the earth
resistance.
rd 1.588 x 10-3 f /mile
9.869 x 10-4 f /km
where f is the power frequency in Hz
Note : At 60 Hz,
rd 0.09528 /mile
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 18
9
Equivalent Impedance:
Substitute the primitive impedances into
zaa zaa zdd 2zad
We get 2
D
zaa (ra rd ) jk ln ad
DsaDsd
Note: 1. Dsd=1 unit length
2
D
2. Define De ad
Dsd
We get
De
zaa (ra rd ) jk ln /unit length
Dsa
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 19
The quantity De is a function of frequency and
earth resistivity.
De 2160 / f feet
Typical values of De are tabulated below.
Return Earth Resistivity De
Condition (-m) (ft)
Sea water 0.01-1.0 27.9-279
Swampy ground 10-100 882-2790
Average Damp Earth 100 2790
Dry earth 1000 8820
Sandstone 109 8.82x106
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 20
10
Three-Phase Line Impedances
Extend Carson’s
analysis to a three-phase line
Ia zaa
a a’
Ib zbb zab zca b’
b
+
+ Ic zcc zbc
Va c c’
All wires
- Vb + zad grounded
- Vc zbd here
- zcd
REF
Vd 0
d d’
Id zdd
1 unit length
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 21
The voltage equation describing the line is
Va a' Va Va' zaa zab zac zad I
a
Vbb' V V zba zbb zbc zbd Ib
= b b' =
Vcc' Vc Vc' zca zcb zcc zcd I
c
Vdd' Vd Vd' zda zdb zdc zdd Id
Since all conductors are grounded at the remote
end, we get from KCL
Ia Ib Ic Id 0
or
Id (Ia Ib Ic )
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 22
11
The voltage equation for the fictitious ground
conductor
is
Vd Vd' zadIa zbdIb zcdIc zddId
which can be re-written as
Vd' zadIa zbdIb zcdIc zdd(Ia Ib Ic )
Combining terms, we get
Vd' (zad zdd)Ia (zbd zdd)Ib (zcd zdd)Ic
Following a similar procedure, the voltage
equation
for phase a can be shown to be
Va Va' (zaa zad)Ia (zab zad)Ib
(zac zad)Ic
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 23
Subtracting the the voltage equation of the ground
conductor from the equation of phase a, we get
Va (Va' Vd' ) (zaa 2zad zdd)Ia
(zab zad zbd zdd)Ib
(zac zad zcd zdd)Ic
SinceVa' Vd' 0 , we get
Va (zaa 2zad zdd)Ia
(zab zad zbd zdd)Ib
(zac zad zcd zdd)Ic
or
Va zaaIa zabIb zacIc
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 24
12
We can also subtract the voltage equation of the
ground conductor from the equations of phases b
and c. The resulting matrix equation is
Va zaa zab zac I
a
Vb = zab zbb zbc Ib V/unit length
Vc zac zbc zcc Ic
Self Impedances:
zaa zaa 2zad zdd /unit length
zbb zbb 2zbd zdd /unit length
zcc zcc 2zcd zdd /unit length
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 25
Mutual Impedances:
zab zab zad zbd zdd /unit length
zbc zbc zbd zcd zdd /unit length
zac zac zad zcd zdd /unit length
Primitive Impedances:
2s
zxx rx jk(ln 1) /unit length
Dsx x=a,b,c,d
2s
zxy jk(ln 1) /unit length
Dxy xy=ab,bc,ca,ad,bd,cd
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 26
13
Assumptions:
1. Identical phase conductors
Ds Dsa Dsb Dsc
2. Distances of the overhead conductors to the
fictitious ground conductor are the same
De Dad Dbd Dcd
We get
D
zaa zbb zcc (ra rd ) jk ln e
Ds
De
z xy rd jk ln /unit length
Dxy xy=ab,bc,ca
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 27
Example: Find the equivalent impedance of the
69-kV line shown. The phase conductors are 4/0
hard-drawn copper, 19 strands which operate at
25oC. The line is 40 miles long. Assume an earth
resistivity of 100 -meter.
ra=0.278 /mile @ 25oC 10’ 10’
Dsc=0.01668 ft @ 60 Hz a b c
De
zaa zbb zcc (ra rd ) jk ln
Ds
(0.278 0.095) j0.121 ln 0.01668
2790
0.373 j1.459 /mile
Zaa 14.93 j58.38
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 28
14
zab zbc 0.095 j0.121 ln 2790
10
0.095 j0.683 /mile
Zab 3.81 j27.33
zac 0.095 j0.121 ln 2790
20
Zac 3.81 j23.97
We get
14.93 j58.38 3.81 j27.33 3.81 j23.97
Zabc= 3.81 j27.33 14.93 j58.38 3.81 j27.33
3.81 j23.97 3.81 j27.33 14.93 j58.38
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 29
Line Transposition
Line transposition is used to make the mutual
impedances identical.
Ia
Phase c
Pos.1
Ib
Phase a
Pos.2
Ic
Phase b
Pos.3
s1 s2 s3
Section 1 Section 2 Section 3
Note: Each phase conductor is made to occupy
all possible positions.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 30
15
Voltage equation for Section 1
Va Z111 Z121 Z131 I
a
Vb = Z211 Z221 Z231 Ib volts
Vc Z311 Z321 Z331 Ic
Voltage equation for Section 2
Vc Z112 Z122 Z132 I
c
Va = Z212 Z222 Z232 I volts
a
Vb Z312 Z322 Z332 Ib
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 31
Voltage equation for Section 3
Vb Z113 Z123 Z133 Ib
Vc = Z213 Z223 Z233 I volts
c
Va Z313 Z323 Z333 Ia
The total voltage drop for phase a
Va Z111Ia Z121Ib Z131Ic
Z212 Ic Z222 Ia Z232 Ib
Z313 Ib Z323 Ic Z333 Ia
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 32
16
Va (Z111 Z222 Z333 )Ia
(Z121 Z232 Z313 )Ib
(Z131 Z212 Z323 )Ic
By a similar procedure, we get for phases b and c
Vb (Z211 Z322 Z133 )Ia
(Z221 Z332 Z113 )Ib
(Z231 Z312 Z123 )Ic
Vc (Z311 Z122 Z233 )Ia
(Z321 Z132 Z213 )Ib
(Z331 Z112 Z223 )Ic
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 33
If the line is not transposed and we only have
Section 1, the equation of the line will be
Va Z11 Z12 Z13 I
a
Vb = Z21 Z22 Z23 Ib Volts
Vc Z31 Z32 Z33 Ic
where
D
Z11 Z22 Z33 (ra rd )s jks ln e
Ds
De
Zxy rds jks ln
Dxy xy=ab,bc,ca
S = length of the line
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 34
17
Define f1, f2 and f3 as as the ratios of s1, s2 and s3
to the total length s, respectively. We get
Va (f1Z11 f2Z22 f3Z33)Ia
(f1Z12 f2Z23 f3Z31)Ib
(f1Z13 f2Z21 f3Z32 )Ic
Vb (f1Z21 f2Z32 f3Z13)Ia
(f1Z22 f2Z33 f3Z11)Ib
(f1Z23 f2Z31 f3Z12 )Ic
Vc (f1Z31 f2Z12 f3Z23)Ia
(f1Z32 f2Z13 f3Z21)Ib
(f1Z33 f2Z11 f3Z22 )Ic
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 35
Define:
Zk1 f1Z12 f2Z23 f3Z13
Zk2 f1Z13 f2Z12 f3Z23
Zk3 f1Z23 f2Z13 f3Z12
Zs Z11 Z22 Z33
Substitution gives
Va Zs Zk1 Zk 2 I
a
Vb = Zk1 Zs Zk 3 Ib Volts
Vc Zk 2 Zk 3 Zs Ic
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 36
18
It can be shown that
De
Zs (ra rd )s jks ln
Ds
D D D
Zk1 rds jks f1ln e f2 ln e f3 ln e
D12 D23 D31
D D D
Zk2 rds jks f1ln e f2 ln e f3 ln e
D31 D12 D23
D D D
Zk3 rds jks f1ln e f2 ln e f3 ln e
D23 D31 D12
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 37
Example: Find the equivalent impedance of the
69-kV line shown. The phase conductors are 4/0
hard-drawn copper, 19 strands which operate at
25oC. The line is 40 miles long. Assume s1=8
miles, s2=12 miles and s3=20 miles.
10’ 10’
ra=0.278 /mile @ 25oC
a b c
Dsc=0.01668 ft @ 60 Hz
Section 1
Assuming no transposition, we get
14.93 j58.38 3.81 j27.33 3.81 j23.97
Zabc= 3.81 j27.33 14.93 j58.38 3.81 j27.33
3.81 j23.97 3.81 j27.33 14.93 j58.38
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 38
19
Solving for the mutual impedances, we get
Zk1 f1Z12 f2Z23 f3Z13
0.2(3.81 j27.33) 0.3(3.81 j27.33)
0.5(3.81 j23.97)
3.81 j25.65
Similarly, we get
Zk2 f1Z13 f2Z12 f3Z23 3.81 j26.66
Zk3 f1Z23 f2Z13 f3Z12 3.81 j26.32
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 39
The impedance matrix of the transposed line is
14.93 j58.38 3.81 j25.65 3.81 j26.66
Zabc= 3.81 j25.65 14.93 j58.38 3.81 j26.32
3.81 j26.66 3.81 j26.32 14.93 j58.38
For comparison, the impedance matrix of the
untransposed line is
14.93 j58.38 3.81 j27.33 3.81 j23.97
Zabc= 3.81 j27.33 14.93 j58.38 3.81 j27.33
3.81 j23.97 3.81 j27.33 14.93 j58.38
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 40
20
Example: For the same line assume the
following transposition cycle:
s1=16 miles s2=24 miles s3=0
It can be shown that
14.93 j58.38 3.81 j27.33 3.81 j25.99
Zabc= 3.81 j27.33 14.93 j58.38 3.81 j25.31
3.81 j25.99 3.81 j25.31 14.93 j58.38
Note: Even an incomplete transposition has a
significant effect in reducing the unbalance in the
mutual impedances.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 41
Completely Transposed Line
If s1=s2=s3, the line is completely transposed. We
get
Va Zs Zm Zm I
a
Vb = Zm Zs Zm Ib Volts
Vc Zm Zm Zs Ic
where
De
Zs (ra rd )s jks ln
Ds
De
Zm 13 (Z12 Z23 Z13) rds jks ln
Dm
Ds, Dm = GMR and GMD, respectively
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 42
21
Example: For the same line assume a complete
transposition cycle.
10’ 10’
The GMD is
a b c
Dm 3 10(10)(20) 12.6 feet
We get the average of the mutual impedances.
Zm 3.81 j26.21
The impedance of the transposed line is
14.93 j58.38 3.81 j26.21 3.81 j26.21
Zabc= 3.81 j26.21 14.93 j58.38 3.81 j26.21
3.81 j26.21 3.81 j26.21 14.93 j58.38
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 43
Phase- to Sequence-Impedances
Consider a transmission line that is described by
the following voltage equation:
Va Zaa Zab Zac I
a
Vb = Zab Zbb Zbc Ib volts
Vc Zac Zbc Zcc Ic
or
Vabc ZabcIabc
From symmetrical components, we have
Vabc AV012 and Iabc A I012
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 44
22
Substitution gives
AV012 ZabcA I012
or
V012 A 1ZabcA I012
which implies that
Z012 A 1Zabc A
Performing the multiplication, we get
Z0 Zs0 2Zm0 Zs2 Zm2 Zs1 Zm1
Z1 = Zs1 Zm1 Zs0 Zm0 Zs2 2Zm2
Z2 Zs2 Zm2 Zs1 2Zm1 Zs0 Zm0
Note: Z012 is not symmetric.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 45
It can be shown that
Zs0 1
3
(Zaa Zbb Zcc )
Zs1 1
3
(Zaa aZbb a2Zcc )
Z s2 1
3
(Zaa a2Zbb aZcc )
Zm0 1
3
(Zab Zbc Zca)
Zm1 1
3
(a2Zab Zbc aZca )
Zm2 1
3
(aZab Zbc a2Zca )
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 46
23
If the line is completely transposed,
Zs0 Zs Zm0 Zm
Zs1 Zs2 0 Zm1 Zm2 0
The sequence impedance matrix reduces to
Z0 Zs 2Zm 0 0
Z1 = 0 Zs Zm 0
Z2 0 0 Zs Zm
Note: The sequence impedances are completely
decoupled.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 47
For a completely transposed line, the equation in
the sequence domain is
Va0 Z0 0 0 Ia0
Va1 = 0 Z1 0 I
a1
Va2 0 0 Z2 Ia2
where
Dm
Z1 Z2 ras jks ln
Ds
3
De
Z0 ras 3rds jks ln 2
DsDm
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 48
24
Example: For the same line and assuming a
complete transposition cycle, find the sequence
impedances of the line.
10’ 10’
In the previous example, a b c
we got
Zs 14.93 j58.38
Zm 3.81 j26.21
The sequence impedances are
Z0 Zs 2Zm 22.55 j110.80
Z1 Z2 Zs Zm 11.12 j32.17
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 49
Completely Transposed Line
For a three-phase transmission line that is
completely transposed:
1. The sequence impedances are completely
decoupled; that is
Va0 Z0 Ia0 Va1 Z1Ia1
Va2 Z2 Ia2
2. The application of balanced three-phase
voltages at the sending end results in
balanced three-phase line currents; that is
only positive-sequence components exist.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 50
25
Incomplete Transposition
The resulting circuit unbalance due to incomplete
transposition is measured in terms of the zero-
and negative-sequence line currents that arise
when positive-sequence voltages are applied at
the sending end.
For a partially-transposed transmission line,
Va zs zk1 zk 2 I
a
Vb = zk1 zs zk 3 Ib V/unit length
Vc zk 2 zk 3 zs Ic
or
Vabc zabcIabc
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 51
where
De
zs (ra rd ) jk ln
Ds
D D D
zk1 rd jk f1ln e f2 ln e f3 ln e
D12 D23 D31
D D D
zk2 rd jk f1ln e f2 ln e f3 ln e
D31 D12 D23
D D D
zk3 rd jk f1ln e f2 ln e f3 ln e
D23 D31 D12
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 52
26
Transform the phase impedances into sequence
impedances.
z012 A 1zabc A
which gives
z0 zs 2zm0 zm2 zm1
z1 = zm1 zs zm0 2zm2
z2 zm2 2zm1 zs zm0
where
zm0 1
3
(zk1 zk2 zk3 )
zm1 1
3
(a2zk1 azk 2 zk 3 )
zm2 1
3
(azk1 a2zk 2 zk 3 )
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 53
The elements of z012 can be shown to be
z00 zs 23 (zk1 zk2 zk3 )
z01 13 (azk1 a2zk 2 zk 3 )
z02 13 (a2zk1 azk 2 zk 3 )
z10 z02
z11 zs 13 (zk1 zk2 zk3 )
z12 2z01
z20 z01
z21 2z02
z22 z11
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 54
27
Assume that balanced voltages are applied at the
sending end;
that is
Va0 0 and Va2 0
We can re-write the voltage equation
Va0 z00 z01 z02 Ia0
Va1 = z10 z11 z12 I
a1
Va2 z20 z21 z22 Ia2
into
0 z00Ia0 z01Ia1 z02Ia2
Va1 z10Ia0 z11Ia1 z12Ia2
0 z20Ia0 z21Ia1 z22Ia2
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 55
The unbalanced
factor are definedas:
I I
m0 a0 and m2 a2
Ia1 Ia1
It can be shown that
z02z21 z01z22
m0
z00z22 z20z02
z20z01 z00z21
m2
z00z22 z20z02
Note: For the untransposed 40-mile line,
m0 1.05472.68o %
m2 6.624139.14o %
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 56
28
Lines with Overhead Ground Wire
Ia zaa
a
a’
Ib zbb zab zca
b
b’
+ Ic zcc zbc
c
c’
Va + Iw
zw w zad
- Vb + w w’
-
Vc +
zbd All wires
- Vw zcd grounded
- here
REF
Vd 0
d’
d
Id zdd
1 unit length
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 57
The primitive voltage equation is
Va Va' zaa zab zac zaw zad I
a
Vb Vb' zba zbb zbc zbw zbd Ib
V/unit
Vc Vc' = zca zcb zcc zcw zcd I
c length
0 Vw' zw a zw b zw c zw w zw d Iw
0 Vd' zda zdb zdc zdw zdd Id
From KCL, we get
Ia Ib Ic Iw Id 0
or
Id (Ia Ib Ic Iw )
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 58
29
The last equation may be written as
Vd' zdaIa zdbIb zdcIc zdwIw
zdd(Ia Ib Ic Iw )
or
Vd' (zda zdd)Ia (zdb zdd)Ib
(zdc zdd)Ic (zdw zdd)Iw
Following the same procedure, the equation for
phase a can be expressed as
Va Va' (zaa zad)Ia (zab zad)Ib
(zac zad)Ic (zaw zad)Iw
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 59
Subtracting the last equation from the first, we get
Va (Va' Vd' ) (zaa zad zda zdd)Ia
(zab zad zdb zdd)Ib
(zac zad zdc zdd)Ic
(zaw zad zdw zdd)Iw
Since Va' Vd' 0, the equation can be simplified
to
Va zaaIa zabIb zacIc zawIw
Note: The same procedure can be applied to the
equations describing phases b and c, and the
overhead ground wire w.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 60
30
We get
Va zaa zab zac zaw I
a
Vb zba zbb zbc zbw Ib
=
Vc zca zcb zcc zcw I
c
Vw zw a zw b zw c zw w Iw
where Vw 0 and
De
zxx (rx rd ) jk ln x=a,b,c,w
Dsx
De
z xy rd jk ln xy=ab,ac,aw,
Dxy bc,bw,cw
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 61
Kron’s Reduction
Consider the matrix equation
V1 Z1 Z2 I1
=
0 Z3 Z4 I2
where Z1, Z2, Z3 and Z4 are also matrices. Suppose
we want to eliminate the current vector I2.
Expanding, we get
V1 Z1I1 Z2I2 (1)
0 Z3I1 Z4I2 (2)
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 62
31
From eq. 2, we get
1
I2 Z4 Z3I1
which is substituted in eq. 1 to get
1
V1 Z1I1 Z2(Z4 Z3I1)
or
1
V1 (Z1 Z2Z4 Z3 )I1
Go back to the voltage equation of the line.
Va zaa zab zac zaw I
a
Vb zba zbb zbc zbw Ib
=
Vc zca zcb zcc zcw I
c
0 zw a zw b zw c zw w Iw
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 63
We wish to eliminate Iw , where
zaa zab zac zaw
T
Z1 = zba zbb zbc Z2 = zbw = Z3
zca zcb zcc zcw
Z4 zw w
We get
zawzw a z z zawzw c
zaa zab aw w b zac
zw w zw w zw w
z z z z z z
zabc = zba bw w a zbb bw w b
zw w zw w
zbc bw w c
zw w
z z z z z z
zca cw w a zcb cw w b zcc cw w c
zw w zw w zw w
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 64
32
Example: Find the equivalent impedance of the
69-kV line shown. The phase conductors are the
same as in the previous examples. The overhead
ground wires have the following characteristics:
rw=4.0 /mile @ 25oC w
Dsw=0.001 ft @ 60 Hz
For the ground wire, we get 15’
De
zw w (rw rd ) jk ln 10’ 10’
Dsw a b c
(4.0 0.095) j0.121 ln 2790
0.001
4.095 j1.8 /mile
Zw w 163.8 j72
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 65
De
zaw zcw rd jk ln
Daw
0.095 j0.121 ln 18.03
2790
/mile
Zaw Zcw 3.81 j24.47
zbw 0.095 j0.121 ln 2790
15
/mile
Zbw 3.81 j25.36
From a previous example, we got
14.93 j58.38 3.81 j27.33 3.81 j23.97
Z1= 3.81 j27.33 14.93 j58.38 3.81 j27.33
3.81 j23.97 3.81 j27.33 14.93 j58.38
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 66
33
Using the ground wire impedances, we also get
3.81 j24.47
Z2 = 3.81 j25.36 = Z3T
3.81 j24.47 Z4 163.8 j72
Performing the Kron reduction, we get
17.5 j56.11 6.48 j25.0 6.38 j21.7
Zabc = 6.48 j25.0 17.71 j55.97 6.48 j25.0
6.38 j21.7 6.48 j25.0 17.5 j56.1
Note: The self impedances are no longer equal.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 67
Current Division
How much current is flowing in the overhead
ground wire? Under zero-sequence condition,
Ia Ib Ic Ia0
The primitive voltage equation reduces to
Va Va' zaa zab zac zaw zad Ia0
Vb Vb' zba zbb zbc zbw zbd Ia0
V/unit
Vc Vc' = zca zcb zcc zcw zcd Ia0
length
0 Vw' zw a zw b zw c zw w zw d Iw
0 Vd' zda zdb zdc zdw zdd Id
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 68
34
From KCL, we get
Id Iw 3Ia0
The last equation may be written as
Vd' (zda zdb zdc )Ia0 zdwIw zddId
Similarly, for the overhead ground wire
Vw' (zw a zw b zw c)Ia0 zw wIw zw dId
Subtracting the two equations, we get
0 [(zw a zw b zw c) (zda zdb zdc )]Ia0
(zw w zdw)Iw (zw d zdd)Id
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 69
Since Id (3Ia0 Iw ) , we get
0 [(zw a zw b zw c) (zda zdb zdc )]Ia0
(zw w zdw)Iw (zw d zdd)(3Ia0 Iw )
Combine
common terms and get the ratio of Iw to
3Ia0 . We get
Iw (zw a zw b zw c) (zda zdb zdc ) 3(zdd zw d)
3Ia0 3(zw w zw d zdw zdd)
Recall that
zwx zwx zwd zdx zdd x=a,b,c,w
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 70
35
Substitution gives
Iw zw a zw b zw c
(a)
3Ia0 3zw w
From Id Iw 3Ia0 , we get
Id I
1 w
3Ia0 3Ia0
Substitute eq. (a) to get
Id z zw b zw c
(b) 1 wa
3Ia0 3zw w
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 71
Take the ratio of eq. (a) to eq. (b). We get
Iw zw a zw b zw c
Id 3zw w (zw a zw b zw c)
Define:
zag 13 (zwa zwb zwc )
Dag 3 DwaDwbDwc
We get
Iw zag
Id zw w zag
where
De
zag rd jk ln
Dag
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 72
36
Line Transposition
Consider a transmission line with one overhead
ground wire. Assume that the line is transposed.
Ground wire
Ia
Phase c
Pos.
Ib
Phase a
Pos.
Ic
Phase b
Pos.
s1 s2 s3
Section 1 Section 2 Section 3
The impedance matrix for each section can be
found using Kron’s reduction.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 73
For Sections 1 and 2, we get
z z z z z wzw
z w w z w w z
zw w zw w zw w
zwzw z z zwzw
z f 1 = z z w w z
z ww z ww zw w
z wzw z wzw z wzw
z z z
zw w zw w zw w
zwzw zwzw zwzw
z z z
zw w zw w zw w
z wzw z wzw z wzw
zf2 = z z z
zw w zw w zw w
z wzw z wzw z z
z z z w w
zw w zw w zw w
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 74
37
Similarly, for Sections 3, we get
z wzw z wzw z wzw
z z z
zw w zw w zw w
z wzw z z z wzw
z f 3 = z z w w z
zw w zw w zw w
zwzw z z zwzw
z z w w z
zw w zw w zw w
It can be shown that
Va I
a
Vb s(f1Zf1 f2Zf 2 f3Zf 3 ) Ib
Vc Ic
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 75
If the line is completely transposed, the impedance
matrix becomes symmetric.
z s zm zm
zabc = zm zs zm /unit length
zm zm z s
where the diagonal elements are
zs 13 (z z z )
z z z z z z
13 w w w w w w
zw w zw w zw w
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 76
38
The off-diagonal elements are
zm 13 (z z z )
z z z z z z
13 w w w w w w
zw w zw w zw w
The sequence impedance matrix will be diagonal.
z00 0 0
z012 = 0 z11 0 /unit length
0 0 z22
where
z00 zs 2zm and z11 z22 zs zm
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 77
Solving for the positive-sequence impedance,
z11 13 (z z z ) 13 (z z z )
z z z z z z
13 w w w w w w
zw w zw w zw w
z z z z z z
13 w w w w w w
zw w zw w zw w
Simplifying the first two terms, we get
D
1
3
(z z z ) (ra rd ) jk ln e
Ds
De
1
3
(z z z ) rd jk ln
Dm
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 78
39
The last two terms can be shown to be equal to
(k)2 M
1
3
zww
where
De 2 D D
M (ln ) (ln e )2 (ln e )2
Dw Dw Dw
D D D D
(ln e )(ln e ) (ln e )(ln e )
D w Dw Dw Dw
De D
(ln )(ln e )
Dw D w
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 79
Likewise,
De
zw w (rw rd ) jk ln
Dw w
For most transmission line configurations,
De Dw , Dw or Dw
This means M 0. Under this assumption,
Dm
z11 ra jk ln /unit length
Ds
Note: This is the formula for the positive sequence
impedance of a transposed line without ground
wires.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 80
40
The zero-sequence impedance can be shown to be
2
z0(m)
z00 z0(a) /unit length
z0(g)
where
3
De
z0(a) (ra 3rd ) jk ln 2
DsDm
De
z0(m) 3rd j3k ln
3 DwDwDw
z0(g) 3zww
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 81
Example: For the previous example, assume that
the line is completely transposed. Find the phase
and sequence impedances.
From the previous example, we got
17.5 j56.11 6.48 j25.0 6.38 j21.7
Zf1 = 6.48 j25.0 17.71 j55.97 6.48 j25.0
6.38 j21.7 6.48 j25.0 17.5 j56.1
Assuming a complete transposition cycle, we get
Zs 13 [2(17.5 j56.11) 17.71 j55.97]
17.57 j56.06
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 82
41
Zm 13 [2(6.48 j25.0) 6.38 j21.7]
6.45 j23.9
17.57 j56.06 6.45 j23.9 6.45 j23.9
Zabc= 6.45 j23.9 17.57 j56.06 6.45 j23.9
6.45 j23.9 6.45 j23.9 17.57 j56.06
For comparison, Zabc below is for a completely
transposed line without the overhead ground wire.
14.93 j58.38 3.81 j26.21 3.81 j26.21
Zabc= 3.81 j26.21 14.93 j58.38 3.81 j26.21
3.81 j26.21 3.81 j26.21 14.93 j58.38
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 83
The sequence impedances are
Z00 Zs 2Zm
30.47 j103.86
Z11 Z22 Zs Zm
11.12 j32.17
Note: When the effect of the ground wire was not
taken into account, we got
Z0 22.55 j110.8
Z1 11.12 j32.17
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 84
42
Steel Ground Wires
The overhead Grade E.B.B. 7 Strands
3/8 inch Diameter
ground wires are 10-3 15
Geometric Mean Radius (ft)
usually high- 13
10-5
strength steel or
Resistance (/mile)
10-7 11
some alloy of GMR
steel. This poses a 10-9 9
problem since the 10-11 7
resistance and 5
10-13
GMR of these Resistance
conductors vary 10-15 3
with current. 10-17 1
10-19
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Amperes per Cable
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 85
Example: For the previous example, assume that
the line is completely transposed. Find the phase
and sequence impedances. The overhead ground
wire is 3/8 inch E.B.B.
The zero-sequence impedance of the phase wire
3
De
z0(a) (ra 3rd ) jk ln 2
DsDm
27903
0.278 3(0.095) j0.121 ln
(0.017)(12.6)2
0.564 j2.77 /mile
or
Z0(a) 22.55 j110.8
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 86
43
The zero-sequence impedance of the ground wire
De
z0(g) 3zw w 3(rw rd ) j3k ln
Dw w
The resistance and GMR of the ground wire is a
function of the current. For 1A, 30A and 60A, we
get for E.B.B.
rw= 3.5 /mile at 1A
= 7.8 /mile at 30A
= 6.0 /mile at 60A
Dsw= 10-3 ft at 1A
= 5 x 10-12 ft at 30A
= 1.5 x 10-10 ft at 60A
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 87
For 1A, we get
2790
z0(g) 3(3.5 0.095) j3(0.121) ln
103
10.79 j5.4 /mile at 1A
or
Z0(g) 431.4 j216 at 1A
For 30A and 60A, we get
Z0(g) 947.4 j494 at 30A
Z0(g) 731.4 j410.8 at 60A
The GMD between the phase wires and the ground
wire is
Dag 3 (18.03)2 (15) 16.96 ft
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 88
44
The zero-sequence mutual impedance is
De
z0(m) 3rd j3k ln
Dag
2790
3(0.095) j3(0.121) ln
16.96
0.29 j1.86 /mile
Z0(m) 11.43 j74.28
The zero-sequence impedance is found from
2
Z0(m)
Z00 Z0(a)
Z0(g)
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 89
Substitution gives
Z00 31.0 j102.65 at 1A
Z00 18.86 j107.06 at 30A
Z00 27.21 j105.89 at 60A
Note: For comparison, we got the following zero-
sequence impedances from previous examples:
No overhead ground wire:
Z00 22.55 j110.8
Non-ferrous overhead ground wire:
Z00 30.47 j103.86
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 90
45
Parallel Multicircuit Lines
Consider the double-circuit transmission line
shown. One circuit is designated abc and the
other a’b’c’. Each circuit may be untransposed or
partially transposed.
m Iabc n
Zabc
Ia'b'c'
Za'b'c'
Let us determine the unbalance factors for this
transmission line configuration.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 91
The voltage equation that describes the line is
Va Zaa Zab Zac Zaa' Zab' Zac' I
a
Vb Zba Zbb Zbc Zba' Zbb' Zbc' Ib
Vc Z Zcb Zcc Zca' Zcb' Zcc' I
= ca c
Va' Za'a Za'b Za'c Za'a' Za'b' Za'c' I
a'
Vb' Zb'a Zb'b Zb'c Zb'a' Zb'b' Zb'c' Ib'
Vc' Zc ' a Zc'b Zc'c Zc'a' Zc'b' Zc ' c ' Ic'
Note: The effect of earth and any overhead
ground wire has already been incorporated in the
equation.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 92
46
Using matrix notation, we get
Vabc Zaa Zaa' I
= abc
Va'b'c' Za'a Za'a' Ia'b'c'
The unbalance factors are expressed in terms of
the ratio of sequence currents. Thus, the above
equation must be inverted. Doing so, we get
I Y Yaa' Vabc
abc = aa
Ia'b'c' Ya'a Ya'a' Va'b'c'
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 93
It can be shown that
1
Yaa Zaa KL1 Kt Yaa' KL1
t
Ya'a Yaa' Ya'a' L1
where
1 1
K Zaa Zaa' Kt Za'a Zaa
1
L Za'a' Za'a Zaa Zaa'
From symmetrical components, we get
I A 0 I
abc = 012
Ia'b'c' 0 A I0'1'2'
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 94
47
Performing the transformation, we get
I A 1Y A A 1Yaa'A V012
012 = 1 aa
I0'1'2' A Ya'aA A 1Ya'a'A V0'1'2'
Assume that the voltages at both ends of the line
contain positive sequence components only. We
get
0 0
Va1 1
V012 0 0
= = Va1
V0'1'2' 0 0
Va'1 1
0 0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 95
Note that Va1 Va'1 since the lines are bused at
both
ends. Substitution gives
Ia0 Y00 Y01 Y02 Y00' Y01' Y02' 0
I Y10 Y11 Y12 Y10' Y11' Y12' 1
a1
I Y Y21 Y22 Y20' Y21' Y22' 0
a2 = 20 Va1
Ia'0 Y0'0 Y0'1 Y0'2 Y0'0' Y0'1' Y0'2' 0
I Y1'0 Y1'1 Y1'2 Y1'0' Y1'1' Y1'2' 1
a'1
Ia'2 Y2'0 Y2'1 Y2'2 Y2'0' Y2'1' Z2'2' 0
Solving for the sequence currents, we get
Ia0 (Y01 Y01' )(Va1 )
Ia2 (Y21 Y21' )(Va1 )
Ia1 (Y11 Y11' )(Va1 )
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 96
48
Ia'0 (Y0'1 Y0'1' )(Va1 )
Ia'2 (Y2'1 Y2'1' )(Va1 )
Ia'1 (Y1'1 Y1'1' )(Va1 )
Define the net through unbalance factors as
Ia0 Ia'0
m0t per unit
Ia1 Ia'1
I I
m2t a2 a'2 per unit
Ia1 Ia'1
Define the net circulating current unbalance factors
as Ia0 Ia'0
m0c per unit
Ia1 Ia'1
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 97
Ia2 Ia'2
m2c per unit
Ia1 Ia'1
Solving for the unbalance factors, we get
m0t (Y01 Y01' Y0'1 Y0'1' ) / Y1
m2t (Y21 Y21' Y2'1 Y2'1' ) / Y1
m0c (Y01 Y01' Y0'1 Y0'1' ) / Y1
m2c (Y21 Y21' Y2'1 Y2'1' ) / Y1
where
Y1 Y11 Y11' Y1'1 Y1'1'
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 98
49
Electric Field of a Long Conductor
Consider a long, isolated cylindrical conductor with
a uniform positive charge density q and located in
a homogeneous medium.
The flux density at a distance x from the center is
q q
D âr Coul/m2 +
2x x
âr
The electric field intensity is
D q
E âr Volt/m
2x
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 99
Transmission & Distribution Lines
Sequence Capacitance
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 100
50
Voltage Due to Charged Conductor
Consider two points P1 and P2 which are located at
distances D1 and D2 from the center of the
conductor.
D1 P1
The voltage drop from
P1 to P2 is P2
D2 D2
v12 D1
E dx
q
D2
D1 2x dx
q D
ln 2 Volts
2 D1
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 101
Capacitance of a Two-Wire Line
The capacitance between two conductors is defined
as the charge on the conductors per unit of
potential difference between them.
Consider the two cylindrical conductors shown.
qa qb
Due to charge qa, we get the voltage drop vab.
qa D
v ab ln
2 ra
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 102
51
Due to charge qb, we also get the voltage drop vba.
qb D
vba ln
2 rb
or q D q r
vab b ln b ln b
2 rb 2 D
Applying superposition, we get the total voltage
drop from charge qa to charge qb.
qa D q r
vab ln b ln b
2 ra 2 D
Since qa+qb=0, we get
qa D2
v ab ln Volts
2 rarb
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 103
In general, ra=rb. We get
qa D
vab ln Volts
r
The capacitance between conductors is
qa
Cab Farad/meter
Vab D
ln
r
The capacitance to neutral is
2
Can Cbn 2Cab Farad/meter
D
ln
r
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 104
52
Three-Phase Line
Consider a three-phase trans- qb
mission line with equilateral
spacing. Assume identical
phase conductors and neglect D D
the effect of ground. Assume
qa qb qc 0 qa D qc
The voltage drop from a to b is
1 D r D
v ab q ln q ln q ln
D
a b c
2 r D
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 105
Likewise, the voltage drop from a to c is
1 D D r
v ac qa ln r qb ln D qc ln D
2
Adding the two equations, we get
1 D r
v ab v ac 2q ln (q q ) ln
D
a b c
2 r
Since qa=-(qb+qc), we get
3qa D
vab vac ln Volts
2 r
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 106
53
Phasor Diagram:
Vca Vcn Vab
Vab Van( 330o )
Vac Van( 3 30o ) Van
Vab Vac 3Van
Vbn Vac
We get
qa D
van ln
2 r Vbc
The capacitance to neutral is
qa 2 Farad/meter,
Can Cbn Ccn
van D to neutral
ln
r
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 107
Capacitance of a Transposed Line
Consider a three-phase transmission line with
unsymmetrical spacing. Assume that the line is
completely transposed.
qa Phase c
Pos.1
qb Phase a
Pos.2
qc Phase b
Pos.3
1
3
s 1
3
s 1
3
s
Section 1 Section 2 Section 3
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 108
54
For section 1, we get b
D12 D23
a D31 c
1 D12 r D
vab1 qa ln qb ln qc ln 23
2 r D12 D31
1 D31 D r
vac1 qa ln qb ln 23 qc ln
2 r D12 D31
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 109
For section 2, we get a
D12 D23
c D31 b
1 D23 r D31
vab2 q
a ln qb ln qc ln
2 r D23 D12
1 D12 D31 r
vac2 q
a ln qb ln qc ln
2 r D23 D12
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 110
55
For section 3, we get c
D12 D23
b D31 a
1 D31 r D
vab3 qa ln qb ln qc ln 12
2 r D31 D23
1 D23 D r
vac3 qa ln qb ln 12 qc ln
2 r D31 D23
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 111
The average voltage from phase a to phase b
vab 13 (vab1 vab2 vab3 )
Substitution gives
1 D12D23D31 r3
v ab (qa ln qb ln
6 r3 D12D23D31
D D D
qc ln 12 23 31 )
D12D23D31
which simplifies to
1 Dm r
vab q
a ln qb ln
2 r Dm
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 112
56
Similarly, we get
1 Dm r
vac q
a ln qc ln
2 r Dm
Taking summation, we get
1 Dm r
vab vac 2qa ln (qb qc ) ln
2 r Dm
Since vab+vac=3van and qa=-(qb+qc), we get
3 D
3van qa ln m Volts
2 r
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 113
or
1 D
van qa ln m Volts
2 r
The capacitance of phase a to neutral is
qa 2 Farad/meter,
Can
v an D to neutral
ln m
r
Since the line is completely transposed,
Can Cbn Ccn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 114
57
Capacitive Reactance
1
xc
2fC
2.862 D -meter,
x 109 ln m to neutral
f r
1.779 D -mile, to
x 106 ln m neutral
f r
Note: To get the total capacitive reactance, divide
xc by the total length of the line.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 115
Equivalent Circuit
A lumped-parameter representation is used for
short and medium-length lines. For long lines, a
distributed-parameter model is used.
Short Line: Up to 80 kilometers (50 miles)
Z=R+jL
+
+
Vs Is VR
- -
Vs Z Is VR
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 116
58
Medium-Length Line: From 80 km (50 mi) to
240 km (150 mi)
Z=R+jL
+ +
I IR
Vs s 1
2
YC jC
1
2
1
2
YC VR
- -
It can be shown that
Vs ( 12 ZYc 1)VR Z IR
Is Yc ( 14 ZYc 1)VR ( 12 ZYC 1)IR
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 117
Example: A single-circuit 60-Hz 3-phase line is
100 miles long. The phase conductors are Drake
with flat horizontal configuration and 23.8 feet
between conductors. Determine the positive-
sequence equivalent circuit of the line.
Drake: 795 MCM ACSR 26/7
ra=0.1284 /mi @50oC
GMR=0.0373 ft.
diameter=1.108 in.
2(23.8)3 30 ft
Dm 3
30
x1 0.121 ln 0.812 /mi
0.0373
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 118
59
Z1 0.1284 j0.812 /mi
Z1 12.84 j0.81.16
1.779 D -mile, to
xC x 106 ln m neutral
f r
1.779 30
x 106 ln 1
60 24 (1.108)
192,034 -mile, to neutral
XC 1,920.34, to neutral
1
YC j j520.74 x 10-6 -1
XC
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 119
Mutual Capacitance
In capacitance calculations, the earth is assumed
as a perfectly conducting plane. The electric field
that results is the same if an image conductor is
used for every conductor above ground.
+qb
Dab +qc
Dac
Dan +qn
+qa
Haa
Hab Hac Han
-qa
-qn
-qc
-qb
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 120
60
The voltage drop from conductor a to ground is
va vaa'
1
2
1 H H H
(qa ln aa qb ln ab ... qn ln an
4 ra Dab Dan
r D D
qa ln a qb ln ab ... qn ln an )
Haa Hab Han
Combining common terms, we get
1 H H H
va (qa ln aa qb ln ab ... qn ln an )
2 ra Dab Dan
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 121
In general, for the kth overhead conductor
1 H H H
vk (qa ln ak qb ln bk ... qk ln kk
2 Dak Dbk rk
H
... qn ln nk )
Dnk
Using matrix notation, we get
va Paa Pab Pac ... Pan qa
vb Pba Pbb Pbc ... Pbn qb
=
…
…
…
vn Pna Pnb Pnc ... Pnn qn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 122
61
where
1 H
Pkk ln kk
2 rk
1 H
Pkj ln kj
2 Dkj
Inversion of matrix P gives
Caa Cab Cac ... Can
Cba Cbb Cbc ... Cbn
C =
…
Cna Cnb Cnc ... Cnn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 123
Recall the definition of the admittance of a
capacitor.
Yc jC
The bus admittance matrix is defined as
Yaa Yab Yac ... Yan
Yba Ybb Ybc ... Ybn
Ybus =
…
Yna Ynb Ync ... Ynn
Ykk=sum of admittances connected to bus k
Ykj=negative of admittance connected from node
k to node j
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 124
62
For a purely capacitive system, we get
jCaa jCab jCac ... jCan
jCba jCbb jCbc ... jCbn
Ybus =
…
jCna jCnb jCnc ... jCnn
Thus, we can conclude that for the C matrix
Ckk=sum of capacitances connected to node k
Ckj=negative of the capacitance connected from
node k to node j
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 125
The difference between the magnitude of a
diagonal element and its associated off-diagonal
elements is the capacitance to ground. For
example, the capacitance from a to ground is
Cag Caa Cab Cac ... Can
Can
Equivalent n
Circuit
Cab b Cbn
Cbc
a Cac Ccn
c Cng
Cag Cbg
Ccg
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 126
63
Transposed Three-Phase Line
qa Phase c
Pos.1
qb Phase a
Pos.2
qc Phase b
Pos.3
1
3
s 1
3
s 1
3
s
Section 1 Section 2 Section 3
The voltage equation for section 1 is
va Paa Pab Pac qa
vb = Pba Pbb Pbc qb Volts
vc Pca Pcb Pcc qc
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 127
Using matrix inversion, we get the capacitance.
Caa Cab Cac
Cabc = P-1 = Cba Cbb Cbc
Cca Ccb Ccc
The equivalent circuit is shown below.
b
Cab
Cbc
a Cac
c
Cag Cbg
Ccg
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 128
64
Since the line is completely transposed, the mutual
and ground capacitances are averaged values.
Average Mutual Capacitance
Cm0 13 (Cab Cbc Cac) Farad/meter
Average Capacitance to Ground
Cg0 13 (Cag Cbg Ccg ) Farad/meter
or
Cg0 13 [(Caa Cab Cac) (Cbb Cab Cbc )
(Ccc - Cac - Cbc )]
13 (Caa Cbb Ccc ) 23 (Cab Cbc Cac)
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 129
The average capacitance to ground can be
expressed as
Cg0 Cs0 2Cm0
where
Cs0 13 (Caa Cbb Ccc )
Cm0 13 (Cab Cbc Cac) b
Cm0
Cm0
The equivalent circuit Cm0
a
is shown. c
Cg0 Cg0
Cg0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 130
65
Sequence Capacitance
Using matrix notation, we have
Iabc YabcVabc
Iabc jCabcVabc
From Vabc AV012 and Iabc A I012, we get
A I012 jCabcAV012
or
I012 jA 1CabcAV012
Thus, we have
C012 A 1Cabc A
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 131
If the line is completely transposed,
Cs0 Caa Cbb Ccc
Cm0 Cab Cbc Cac
Substitution gives
(Cs0 2Cm0 ) 0 0
C012 = 0 (Cs0 Cm0 ) 0
0 0 (Cs0 Cm0 )
or
C0 Cs0 2Cm0
C1 C2 Cs0 Cm0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 132
66
Example: Determine the phase and sequence
capacitances of the transmission line shown. The
phase conductors are 477 MCM ACSR 26/7 whose
radius is 0.0357 ft. The line is 50 miles long and is
completely transposed.
14’ 14’
Calculate distances
a b c
Haa=Hbb=Hcc=80 ft
Hab=Hbc=81.2 ft 40’
Hac=84.8 ft
Find the P matrix
1 H
Paa Pbb Pcc ln aa
2 0 ra
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 133
For air,
1
0 x 10-9 Farad/meter
36
Substitution gives
80
Paa 18 x 109 ln
0.0357
138.86 x 109 Meter/Farad
86.29 x 106 Mile/Farad
Similarly, we get
1 H
Pab Pbc ln ab
2 0 Dab
19.66 x 106 Mile/Farad
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 134
67
The P matrix can be shown to be
86.29 19.66 12.39
P= 19.66 86.29 19.66 x 106 mi/F
12.39 19.66 86.29
Using matrix inversion, we get the C matrix.
12.34 2.54 1.19
C = 2.54 12.75 2.54 x 10-9 F/mi
1.19 2.54 12.34
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 135
For 50 miles, we get
6.17 1.27 0.60
C = 1.27 6.38 1.27 x 10-7 F
0.60 1.27 6.17
The capacitances to ground are
Cag Caa Cab Cac 0.43 F
Cbg Cbb Cab Cbc 0.38 F
Ccg Ccc Cbc Cac 0.43 F
Since the line is transposed,
Cg0 13 (Cag Cbg Ccg ) 0.41 F
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 136
68
The self- and mutual capacitances are
Cs0 13 (Caa Cbb Ccc ) 0.62 F
Cm0 13 (Cab Cbc Cca) 0.105 F
The sequence capacitances are b
Cm0
C0 Cs0 2Cm0 Cm0
a Cm0
0.41 F c
Cg0 Cg0
C1 C2 Cs0 Cm0 Cg0
0.725 F
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 137
Transposed Line with Ground Wires
Consider a three-phase transmission line with one
overhead ground wire. Assume that the line is
completely transposed.
qw Ground wire
qa Phase c
Pos. 1
qb Phase a
Pos. 2
qc Phase b
Pos. 3
1
3
s 1
3
s 1
3
s
Section 1 Section 2 Section 3
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 138
69
The voltage equation for section 1 is
va Paa Pab Pac Paw qa
vb Pba Pbb Pbc Pbw qb
=
vc Pca Pcb Pcc Pcw qc
vw Pw a Pw b Pw c Pw w qw
where vw=0 and the elements of P are
1 H
Pkk ln kk k=a,b,c,w
2 rk
1 H kj=ab,ac,aw,
Pkj ln kj
2 Dkj bc,bw,cw
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 139
Using Kron’s reduction, we get
PawPw a P P P P
Paa Pab aw w b Pac aw w c
Pw w Pw w Pw w
PbwPw a PbwPw b PbwPw c
P’ = Pba Pbb Pbc
Pw w Pw w Pw w
P P P P P P
Pca cw w a Pcb cw w b Pcc cw w c
Pw w Pw w Pw w
Since the P matrix is real, the elements of the P’
matrix are smaller compared to the P matrix.
Since the C matrix is the inverse of P’, the
resulting capacitances are bigger compared to the
case where there is no ground wire.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 140
70
Example: Determine the phase and sequence
capacitances of the transmission line shown. The
phase conductors are 477 MCM ACSR 26/7 whose
radius is 0.0357 ft. The overhead ground wires
are 3/8 inch E.B.B. steel. The line is 50 miles long
and is completely transposed. w u
In a previous example, we 14’
got the P matrix without 15’
14’ 14’
the ground wires.
86.29 19.66 12.39 a b c
P = 19.66 86.29 19.66 x 106 mi/F 40’
12.39 19.66 86.29
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 141
With the ground wires, we get
86.29 19.66 12.39 Paw Pau
19.66 86.29 19.66 Pbw Pbu
P = 12.39 19.66 86.29 P Pcu
cw
Pw a Pw b Pw c Pw w Pw u
Pua Pub Puc Puw Puu
where rw ru 0.5( 38 )(12
1
) 0.016 ft
1 110
Pw w Puu ln
2 0 0.016
99.1 x 106 Mile/Farad
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 142
71
It can be shown that the P matrix is
86.3 19.7 12.4 14.8 19.6
19.7 86.3 19.7 19.6 19.6
P=
14.8 x 10 Mi/F
6
12.4 19.7 86.3 19.6
14.8 19.6 19.6 99.1 23.1
19.6 19.6 14.8 23.1 99.1
The P matrix can be expressed as
P1 P2
P=
P3 P4
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 143
where
86.3 19.7 12.4
P1 = 19.7 86.3 19.7 x 106 mi/F
12.4 19.7 86.3
14.8 19.6
P2 = P3T = 19.6 19.6 x 106 mi/F
19.6 14.8
99.1 23.1
P4 = x 106 mi/F
23.1 99.1
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 144
72
Using Kron’s reduction,
1
Pabc P1 P2P4 P3
or
81.30 14.15 7.69
Pabc = 14.15 80.02 14.15 x 106 mi/F
7.69 14.15 81.30
Inverting the P matrix, we get
12.75 2.11 0.84
Cabc = 2.11 13.24 2.11 x 10-9 F/mi
0.84 2.11 12.75
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 145
For 50 miles, we get
0.64 0.11 0.04
Cabc = 0.11 0.66 0.11 x 10-6 F
0.04 0.11 0.64
Capacitances to ground
Cag Caa Cab Cac 0.49 F
Cbg Cbb Cab Cbc 0.45 F
Ccg Ccc Cbc Cac 0.49 F
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 146
73
Assuming a complete transposition cycle,
Cg0 13 (Cag Cbg Ccg ) 0.48 F
Cs0 13 (Caa Cbb Ccc ) 0.65 F
Cm0 13 (Cab Cbc Cca) 0.084 F
The sequence capacitances are
C0 Cs0 2Cm0 0.48 F
C1 C2 Cs0 Cm0 0.73 F
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 147
Electrostatic Unbalance
In the system shown, assume Van , Vbn and Vcn
are positive-sequence voltages. The line is not
transposed.
a
Ia
a’
+
Van Ib Cab
b
Vcn - -
Vbn b’
+ + Cbc Cca
c
Ic
c’
+
+ + +
Vn Va Vb Vc C cg Cbg C ag
- - -
-
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 148
74
The charging
current
at no-load
condition
Iabc jCabcVabc jBabcVabc
Transforming to sequence components, we get
I012 jA 1CabcAV012 jB012V012
From KVL, we get
Van Va Vn Vbn Vb Vn
Vcn Vc Vn
or
Va n 1
Vabc = V
bn
+ 1 Vn
Vcn 1
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 149
Pre-multiply by A-1. We get
V
n Note: Vn is a zero-sequence
V012 = Van voltage.
0 There is no negative-
sequence voltage.
From I012 jB012V012, we get the sequence
charging currents.
Ia0 B00 B01 B012 Vn
Ia1 = j B10 B11 B12 Van
Ia2 B20 B21 B22 0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 150
75
Expanding, we get
Ia0 jB00Vn jB01Van
Ia1 jB10Vn jB11Van
Ia2 jB20Vn jB21Van
Case 1: Neutral Ungrounded
If the neutral is ungrounded, Ia0 0. Electrostatic
unbalance is defined in terms of the sequence
voltages. It can be shown that
V V C
d0 a0 n 00
Va1 Van C01
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 151
It can be shown that
C00 Cs0 2Cm0
C01 Cs2 Cm2
where
Cs0 13 (Caa Cbb Ccc )
Cs2 13 (Caa a2Cbb aCcc )
Cm0 13 (Cab Cbc Cca)
Cm2 13 (aCab Cbc a2Cca )
Substitution gives
Cag a2Cbg aCcg
d0
3Cg0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 152
76
Case 2: Neutral Grounded
If the neutral is grounded, Vn 0. Electrostatic
unbalance is defined in terms of the sequence
currents. It can be shown that
2
Ia0 Cag a Cbg aCcg
d0
Ia1 3(Cg0 3Cm0 )
Note: Electrostatic unbalance may be reduced by
1. addition of ground wires
2. increase spacing between wires
3. Phase conductor arrangement
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 153
Transformers
Sequence Impedance
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 154
77
Ideal Two-Winding Transformer
NH NX
+ +
I IX
VH H VX
_ _
VH N
Voltage Equation: H
VX NX
The voltage drop from the polarity-marked
terminal to the non-polarity-marked terminal of
the H winding is in phase with the voltage drop
from the polarity-marked terminal to the non-
polarity-marked terminal of the X winding.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 155
Ideal Two-Winding Transformer
NH NX
+ +
I IX
VH H VX
_ _
Current Equation: NH IH NX IX
The current that enters the H winding through the
polarity-marked terminal is in phase with the
current that leaves the X winding through the
polarity-marked terminal.
Note: Balancing ampere-turns must be satisfied at
all times.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 156
78
Ideal Autotransformer
IH nS
VH nC
IC IX VX
NH=nS+nC=number of turns of the H side
NX=nC=number of turns of the X side
From voltage division, we get
VH n nC N
S H
VX nC NX
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 157
In order for ampere-turns to be balanced
nS IH nC IC
But from KCL, we get
IC IX - IH
Substitution gives
nS IH nC (IX - IH )
which simplifies to
(nS nC )IH nC IX
or NH IH NX IX
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 158
79
Transformer Polarity
H1 H2 H1 H2
Subtractive Additive
X1 X2 X2 X1
“Single-phase transformers in sizes 200 kVA and
below having high-voltage ratings 8660 volts and
below (winding voltage) shall have additive
polarity. All other single-phase transformers shall
have subtractive polarity.” (ANSI/IEEEC57.12.00-
1993)
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 159
Practical Transformer
1. The H and X coils have a small resistance.
2. There are leakage fluxes in the H and X coils.
3. There is resistance loss in the iron core.
4. The permeability of the iron is not infinite.
iH iX
+ +
vH eH eX vX
- NH NX -
iron
core
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 160
80
Equivalent Circuit
RH jXH Iex NH NX R X jXX
+ + + +
IH R IX
VH c jXm EH EX VX
- - - -
H winding Ideal X winding
RH, XH=resistance and leakage reactance of H coil
RX, XX=resistance and leakage reactance of X coil
Rc, Xm=core resistance and magnetizing
reactance
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 161
Approximate Equivalent Circuit
RH jXH NH N R X jXX
X
+ + + +
IH IX
VH EH EX VX
- - - -
Referred to the H side, we get
R eq jX eq NH
a
+ + NX
I 1I
VH H a X aVX R eq RH a2R X
- - Xeq XH a2XX
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 162
81
Three-Winding Transformer
NX
NH +
+ IX VX
IH _
VH +
_
NY IY VY
_
VH N VH N VX N
H H X
VX NX VY NY VY NY
NH IH NX IX NY IY
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 163
Three-Winding Autotransformer
+
IY V
NY
IH _Y
VH NH
NX IX VX
VH N VH N VX N
H H X
VX NX VY NY VY NY
NH IH NX IX NY IY
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 164
82
Equivalent Circuit
From 3 short-circuit tests, get
ZHX=impedance measured at the H side when the
X winding is short-circuited and the Y winding
is open-circuited
ZHY=impedance measured at the H side when the
Y winding is short-circuited and the X winding
is open-circuited
ZXY=impedance measured at the X side when the
Y winding is short-circuited and the H winding
is open-circuited
Note: When expressed in ohms, the impedances
must be referred to the same side.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 165
ZX
ZH +
+
ZY +
VX
VH
- VY -
-
ZHX ZH ZX
ZXY ZX ZY
ZHY ZH ZY
or
ZH 1
2
(ZHX ZHY ZXY )
ZX 12 (ZHX ZHY ZXY )
ZY 1
2
(ZHX ZHY ZXY )
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 166
83
Example: A three-winding three-phase transformer
has the following nameplate rating:
H: 30 MVA 140 kV
X: 30 MVA 48 kV Y:
10.5 MVA 4.8 kV
Short circuit tests yield the following impedances:
ZHX = 63.37 @ the H side
ZHY = 106.21 @ the H side
ZXY = 4.41 @ the X side
Find the equivalent circuit in ohms, referred to the
H side.
ZXY (140
48
)2 (4.41) 37.52
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 167
With all impedances referred to the H side, we get
ZH 12 (63.37 106.21 37.52) 66.03
ZX 12 (63.37 106.21 37.52) 2.66.
ZY 12 (63.37 106.21 37.52) 40.18
2.66
66.03 +
+
+
VX
VH 40.18
- VY -
-
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 168
84
Angular Displacement
ANSI/IEEEC57.12.00-1993: The angular displace-
ment of a three-phase transformer is the time
angle (expressed in degrees) between the line-to-
neutral voltage of the high-voltage terminal
marked H1 and the the line-to-neutral voltage of
the low-voltage terminal marked X1.
The angular displacement for a three-phase trans-
former with a - or Y-Y connection shall be 0o.
The angular displacement for a three-phase trans-
former with a Y- or -Y connection shall be 30o,
with the low voltage lagging the high voltage.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 169
Vector Diagrams
H2 X2 H2
X2
X1
X1 X3
H1 H3 H1 H3 X3
- Connection Y- Connection
H2 X2 H2 X2
X1
X1 X3 X3
H1 H3 H1 H3
Y-Y Connection -Y Connection
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 170
85
Wye-Wye Connection
HV side LV side
H2 X2
N n
H1 H3 X1 X3
VH2N
VX2n
VX1n VX3n
VH1N VH3N
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 171
The choice of phases A, B and C is arbitrary. Let
H1=A, H2=B, H3=C. Also let X1=a, X2=b, X3=c.
VH2N VBN
VH1N VH3N VAN VCN
VX2n Vbn
Van and VAN
are in phase.
VX1n VX3n Van Vcn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 172
86
Let H1=A, H2=B and H3=C. Also let X1=c, X2=a
and X3=b.
VH2N VBN
VH1N VH3N VAN VCN
VX2n Van
V
Van lags AN
by 120o.
VX1n VX3n Vcn Vbn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 173
Let H1=A, H2=B and H3=C. Also let X1=b, X2=c
and X3=a.
VH2N VBN
VH1N VH3N VAN VCN
VX2n Vcn
Van lags VAN
by 240o.
VX1n VX3n Vbn Van
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 174
87
Wye-Wye Connection
HV side LV side
H2 X2
N n
H1 H3 X1 X3
VH2N
VX3n VX1n
VH1N VH3N VX2n
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 175
The choice of phases A, B and C is arbitrary. Let
H1=A, H2=B, H3=C. Also let X1=a, X2=b, X3=c.
VH2N VBN
VH1N VH3N VAN VCN
VX3n VX1n Vcn Van
Van lags VAN
by 180o.
VX2n Vbn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 176
88
Let H1=A, H2=B and H3=C. Also let X1=c, X2=a
and X3=b.
VH2N VBN
VH1N VH3N VAN VCN
VX3n VX1n Vbn Vcn
V
Van lags AN
by 300o.
VX2n Van
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 177
Let H1=A, H2=B and H3=C. Also let X1=b, X2=c
and X3=a.
VH2N VBN
VH1N VH3N VAN VCN
VX3n VX1n Van Vbn
Van lags VAN
by 60o.
VX2n Vcn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 178
89
IEC Designation
The International Electrotechnical Commission
(IEC) uses the face of a clock in identifying the
phase shift. 0
IEC Designation for -
10 2
Dd0 Dd2 Dd4
Dd6 Dd6 Dd10
8 4
IEC Designation for Y-Y
Yy0 Yy6 6
Note: The first letter defines the connection of the
H winding; the second letter defines the connection
of the X winding; the number designates the angle.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 179
Phase and Line Voltages
Consider a set of balanced 3-phase line-to-neutral
voltages with asequence a-b-c. From
Vbn
Vab Van Vnb
we get
Vab Van Vbn V an
Similarly, we get Vbc Vbn Vcn V
cn
Vca Vcn Van Vbc
Van lags Vab by 30 o V bn
Vbn lags Vbc by 30o Van
Vcn lags Vca by 30o Vab V
Vcn ca
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 180
90
Consider a set of balanced 3-phase line-to-neutral
voltages with asequence
a-c-b. From
Vab Van Vnb Vcn
we get
Vab Van Vbn
Van
Similarly, weget
Vbc Vbn Vcn Vbn
Vca Vcn Van
Vab Vcn Vca
Van leads Vab by 30o
Van
Vbn leads Vbc by 30o
Vbn
Vcn leads Vca by 30o
Vbc
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 181
When the sequence is a-b-c, we define the line-to-
line voltages as Vab, Vbc and Vca. When the
sequence is a-c-b, we must define the line-to-line
voltages as Vac, Vcb and Vba. V cb
Vab Vcn Vca Vcn
Van Van
Vac V
Vbn Vbn ba
Vbc Van lags Vac by 30o
Vbn lags Vba by 30o
Vcn lags Vcb by 30o
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 182
91
Y- and -Y Transformers
H2 H2
X2 X2
X1 X1
H1 H3 X3 X3
H1 H3
HV Y – LV
H2 X2
H2 X2
X1
X1
X3
H1 H3
H1 H3
X3
HV - LV Y
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 183
HV Wye – LV Delta
H1 X1
H2 X2
N
H3 X3
VH2N
VX1X2 VX2n
Sequence
1-2-3 VX1n
VX2X3
VX3X1
VH1N VH3N
VX3n
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 184
92
The choice of phases A, B and C is arbitrary. Let
H1=A, H2=B, H3=C. Also let X1=a, X2=b, X3=c.
VH2N VBN
VH1N VH3N VAN VCN
VX2n Vbn
VX1X2 Vab
VX1n Van lags VAN
VX2X3 Van Vbc by 30o
VX3X1 Vca
VX3n Vcn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 185
Let H1=A, H2=B, H3=C. Also let X1=b, X2=c,
X3=a.
VH2N VBN
VH1N VH3N VAN VCN
VX2n Vcn
VX1X2 Vbc
VX1n
V Van lags VAN
VX2X3 bn Vca by 270o
VX3X1 Vab
VX3n Van
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 186
93
Let H1=A, H2=B, H3=C. Also let X1=c, X2=a,
X3=b.
VH2N VBN
VH1N VH3N VAN VCN
VX2n Van
VX1X2 Vca
VX1n Van lags VAN
VX2X3 Vcn Vab by 150o
VX3X1
Vbc
VX3n Vbn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 187
HV Wye – LV Delta
H1 X1
H2 X2
N
H3 X3
VH3N VX3n
Sequence VX3X2
3-2-1 VX1X3 VX2n
VH1N VH2N VX2X1
VX1n
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 188
94
The choice of phases A, B and C is arbitrary. Let
H1=C, H2=B, H3=A. Also let X1=c, X2=b, X3=a.
VH3N VAN
VH1N VH2N VCN VBN
VX3n
Van
VX3X2
Vab
VX1X3 Van leads VAN
VX2n Vca Vbn by 30o
VX2X1
VX1n Vbc
Vcn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 189
Let H1=C, H2=B, H3=A. Also let X1=a, X2=c,
X3=b.
VH3N VAN
VH1N VH2N VCN VBN
VX3n Vbn
VX3X2 Vbc
VX1X3 VX2n Vab V
Vcn an leads V AN
by 150o
VX2X1 Vca
VX1n Van
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 190
95
Let H1=C, H2=B, H3=A. Also let X1=b, X2=a,
X3=c.
VH3N VAN
VH1N VH2N VCN VBN
VX3n Vcn
VX3X2 Vca
Van lags VAN
VX1X3 VX2n Vbc Van by 90o
VX2X1 Vab
VX1n Vbn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 191
Phase Shift for Y- or -Y
C H3 X3 c A H3 X3 a
B H2 X2 b B H2 X2 b
A H1 X1 a C H1 X1 c
Van lags VAN by 30o Van lags VAN by 330o
C H3 X3 b A H3 X3 b
B H2 X2 a B H2 X2 c
A H1 X1 c C H1 X1 a
Van lags VAN by 150o Van lags VAN by 210o
A H3 X3 c C H3 X3 a
B H2 X2 a B H2 X2 c
C H1 X1 b A H1 X1 b
Van lags VAN by 90o Van lags VAN by 270o
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 192
96
IEC Designation
The International Electrotechnical Commission
(IEC) uses the face of a clock in identifying the
phase shift.
11 1
IEC Designation for Y-
Yd1 Yd5 Yd7 Yd11 9 3
IEC Designation for -Y
Dy1 Dy5 Dy7 Dy11 7 5
Note: The first letter defines the connection of the
H winding; the second letter defines the connection
of the X winding; the number designates the angle.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 193
HV Delta– LV Wye
H3 X3
H2 X2
n
H1 X1
VH2N VX2n
Sequence
VH1H2
1-2-3 VH2H3 VX n
1
VH1N
V
VH3H1 H3N VX3n
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 194
97
HV Delta– LV Wye
H3 X3
C c
H2 X2
B b
n
H1 X1
A a
VBN Vbn
VAB VBC Van Van lags VAN
by 30o
VAN VCA VCN Vcn
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 195
Positive–Sequence Voltages
Consider a Y- transformer with a 30o phase shift.
B b
H2 X2
X1
N
A H3 X3 c
H1
C a
VBN1 Vbn1
(A-B-C) Vab1
Van1 lags VAN1
Van1 Vbc1
by 30o
Vca1
VAN1 VCN1
Vcn1
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 196
98
Negative–Sequence Voltages
Consider a Y- transformer with a 30o phase shift.
B b
H2 X2
X1
N
A H3 X3 c
H1
C a
VCN2 Vcn2
Van2 leads VAN2
(A-C-B) Vcb2
by 30o
Vac2 Vbn2
Vba2
VAN2 VBN2 Van2
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 197
Positive–Sequence Currents
Consider a Y- transformer
with a 30o phase shift.
B H2
Iba1 b
X2
IB1 X1
Ib1
Icb1
IA1 Ic1
A H3 Iac1 X3
c
IC1 H1 Ia1
C a
Icb1 Ib1
IB1 (A-B-C)
Ia1 lags IA1
Ia1 by 30o
IA1 IC1 Iba1 Iac1
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute
Ic1 EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 198
99
Negative–Sequence Currents
Consider a Y- transformer
with a 30o phase shift.
B H2
Iba2 b
X2
Ib2
IB2 X1
Icb2
IA 2 Ic2
A H3 Iac2 X3
c
IC2 H1 Ia2
C a
Ic2 Iac2
IC2
(A-C-B) Ia2 leads IA 2
Ib2 by 30o
IA 2 IB2 Iba2 Icb2
Ia2
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 199
Example: Consider a 100 MVA 230YG-20 kV
transformer. A single line-to-ground fault at the
230-kV side results in the following line currents:
IA 753 A IB IC 0
Find the line currents in the 20-kV side. Use 100
MVA and 230 kV as bases in the HV side.
Ib B
b X2 H2
IB
Ia
a X IC
Ic 1 C
c H1 H3
X3 A
IA
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 200
100
The Base Currents
Base MVA3 x 1000
Base I
3 Base kVL
100,000
251 A at the 230 kV side
3 (230)
100,000
2,887 A at the 20 kV side
3 (20)
The Per-Unit Phase Fault Currents
IA 3.0 p.u.
IB IC 0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 201
The Per-Unit Sequence Fault Currents
IA0 3 (IA IB IC ) 1.0 p.u.
1
2
IA1 3 (IA a IB a IC ) 1.0 p.u.
1
IA2 13 (IA a2 IB a IC ) 1.0 p.u.
The Sequence Fault Currents at the 20-kV side
Ia0 0
Ia1 IA1 30o 1.0 - 30o p.u.
Ia2 IA230o 1.030o p.u.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 202
101
The Line Currents at the 20-kV side
Ia Ia0 Ia1 Ia2 1.732 p.u.
Ib Ia0 a2 Ia1 a Ia2 1.732 p.u.
2
Ic Ia0 a Ia1 a Ia2 0
The Line Currents in Amperes
Ia Ib 5,000 A I 0
c N
Check ampere turns: NH IH NX IX or H IH IX
NX
230 / 3
(753) 5,000 (Check)
20
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 203
Three-Phase Transformer Core
3-Legged Core Type
Shell Type
Note: Only the X
4-Legged Core Type windings are shown.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 204
102
Three-Legged Transformer Core
The 3-legged core type three-phase transformer
uses the minimum amount of core material. For
balanced three-phase condition, the sum of the
fluxes is zero.
Note: For positive- or
negative-sequence flux,
a b c
a b c 0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 205
Zero Sequence Flux
The 3-legged core type three-phase transformer
does not provide a path for zero-sequence flux. On
the other hand, a bank of single-phase units, the
4-legged core type and the shell-type three-phase
transformer provide a path for zero-sequence flux.
30
Note: The zero-sequence
flux leaks out of the core
and returns through the
0 0 0
transformer tank.
3-Legged Core Type
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 206
103
Positive Sequence Impedance
Whether a bank of single-phase units or a three-
phase transformer unit (core type or shell type),
the equivalent impedance is the same.
Using per-unit values, the positive-sequence
equivalent circuit is
Z1 R1 jX1
+ + Note: The negative-
I I sequence impedance is
VH H X VX equal to the positive-
- - sequence impedance.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 207
Zero Sequence Impedance*
Transformer Connection Zero-Sequence Network
Z0 Z1
+
+
VH VX
- -
Z0 Z1
+
+
VH VX
- -
*Excluding 3-phase unit with a 3-legged core.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 208
104
Zero Sequence Impedance*
Transformer Connection Zero-Sequence Network
Z0 Z1
+
+
VH VX
- -
Z0 Z1
+
+
VH VX
- -
*Excluding 3-phase unit with a 3-legged core.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 209
Zero Sequence Impedance*
Transformer Connection Zero-Sequence Network
Z0 Z1
+
+
VH VX
- -
Z0 Z1
+
+
VH VX
- -
*Excluding 3-phase unit with a 3-legged core.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 210
105
Zero Sequence Impedance*
Transformer Connection Zero-Sequence Network
XH XX
+
+
VH Xm VX
- -
XH
+
+
VH Xm VX
- -
*Three-phase unit with a 3-legged core.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 211
Zero Sequence Impedance*
Transformer Connection Zero-Sequence Network
XH
+
+
VH XX Xm VX
- -
XH XX
+
+
VH Xm VX
- -
*Three-phase unit with a 3-legged core.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 212
106
Zero Sequence Impedance*
Transformer Connection Zero-Sequence Network
XH XX
+
+
VH Xm VX
- -
XH XX
+
+
VH Xm VX
- -
*Three-phase unit with a 3-legged core.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 213
Example: Consider a two-winding three-phase
transformer with the following nameplate rating:
25 MVA 69 -13.8 YG kV (Dyn1) Z=7%. Draw the
positive and zero-sequence equivalent circuits. Use
the transformer rating as bases.
Positive/Negative Zero Sequence
Sequence impedance impedance
Z0=j0.07 Z0=j0.07
+
+
+
+
VH VX VH VX
- - - -
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 214
107
Example: A three-winding three-phase transformer
has the following nameplate rating: 150/150/45
MVA 138YG-69YG-13.8 kV (Yy0d1).
H-X @ 150 MVA = 14.8%
H-Y @ 45 MVA = 21.0%
X-Y @ 45 MVA = 36.9%
Draw the positive and zero-sequence equivalent
circuits. Use 100 MVA and the transformer voltage
ratings as bases.
At the chosen MVA base,
ZHX 0.148(100 / 150) 0.10 p.u.
ZHY 0.21(100 / 45) 0.47 p.u.
ZXY 0.369(100 / 45) 0.82 p.u.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 215
We get
ZH 12 (0.10 0.47 0.82) 0.125 p.u.
ZX 12 (0.10 0.47 0.82) 0.225 p.u.
ZY 12 (0.10 0.47 0.82) 0.595 p.u.
Positive/Negative Zero Sequence
Sequence Network Network
ZX ZX
ZH + ZH +
+ +
ZY + VX ZY + VX
VH VH
-
VY - -
VY -
- -
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 216
108
Generators
Sequence Impedance
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 217
Generator Sequence Impedances
Positive-Sequence Impedance:
Xd”=Direct-Axis Subtransient Reactance
Xd’=Direct-Axis Transient Reactance
Xd=Direct-Axis Synchronous Reactance
Negative-Sequence Impedance:
X2 12 (X d "X q " ) for a salient-pole machine
X2 Xd" for a cylindrical-rotor machine
Zero-Sequence Impedance:
0.15Xd" X0 0.6Xd"
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 218
109
Negative Sequence Impedance
IEEE Std 115-1995: Determination of the negative-
sequence reactance (Method 1)
The machine is operated at rated speed with its
field winding short-circuited. Symmetrical
sinusoidal three-phase currents of negative phase
sequence are applied to the stator. Two or more
tests should be made with current values above
and below rated current, to permit interpolation.
The line-to-line voltages, line currents and electric
power input are measured and expressed in per-
unit.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 219
Let E = average of applied line-to-line voltages, p.u.
I = average of line currents, p.u.
P = three phase electric power input, p.u.
E
Z2 =Negative Sequence Impedance, p.u.
I
P
R 2 2 =Negative Sequence Resistance, p.u.
I
2 2
X2 Z2 R 2
=Negative Sequence Reactance, p.u.
Note: The test produces abnormal heating in the
rotor and should be concluded promptly.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 220
110
Zero Sequence Impedance
IEEE Std 115-1995: Determination of the zero-
sequence reactance (Method 1)
The machine is operated at rated speed with its
field winding short-circuited. A single-phase voltage
is applied between the line terminals and the
neutral point.
Measure the applied
voltage, current and V
electric power.
E A W
Field
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 221
Let E = applied voltage, in p.u. of base line-to-
neutral voltage
I = test current, p.u.
P = wattmeter reading, in p.u. single-phase
base volt-ampere
3E
Z0 =Zero Sequence Impedance, p.u.
I
2
P
X 0 Z0 1
EI
=Zero Sequence Reactance, p.u.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 222
111
Positive Sequence Impedance
The AC RMS component of the current following a
three-phase short circuit at no-load condition with
constant exciter voltage and neglecting the
armature resistance is given by
E E E t
I(t) exp
Xds Xd ' Xds '
d
E E t
exp
X
d " X '
d "
d
where E = AC RMS voltage before the short circuit.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 223
The AC RMS component of the short-circuit current
is composed of a constant term and two decaying
exponential terms where the third term decays
very much faster than the second term.
If the first term is subtracted and the remainder is
plotted on a semi-logarithmic paper versus time,
the curve would appear as a straight line after the
rapidly decaying term decreases to zero.
The rapidly decaying portion of the curve is the
subtransient portion, while the straight line is the
transient portion.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 224
112
IEEE Std 115-1995: Determination of the transient
and subtransient direct axis reactances (Method 1)
The direct-axis transient reactance is determined
from the current waves of a three-phase short
circuit suddenly applied to the machine operating
open-circuited at rated speed. For each test run,
oscillograms should be taken showing the short
circuit current in each phase.
The direct-axis transient reactance is equal to the
ratio of the open-circuit voltage to the value of the
armature current obtained by the extrapolation of
the envelope of the AC component of the armature
current wave, neglecting the rapid variation during
the first few cycles.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 225
IEEE Std 115-1995: Determination of the transient
and subtransient direct axis reactances (Method 1)
The direct-axis subtransient reactance is deter-
mined from the same three-phase suddenly applied
short circuit. For each phase, the values of the
difference between the ordinates of Curve B and
the transient component (Line C) are plotted as
Curve A to give the subtransient component of the
short-circuit current.
The sum of the initial subtransient component, the
initial transient component and the sustained
component for each phase gives the corresponding
value of I”.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 226
113
Example: Calculation of transient and subtransient
reactances for a synchronous machine
Phase 1 Phase 2 Phase 3 Ave
(1) Initial voltage 1.0
(2) Steady-state Current 1.4 1.4 1.4
(3) Initial Transient Current 8.3 9.1 8.6
(4) I’ = (2)+(3) 9.7 10.5 10.0 10.07
(5) Xd’ = (1)(4) 0.0993
(6) Init. Subtransient Current 3.8 5.6 4.4
(7) I” = (4)+(6) 13.5 16.1 14.4 14.67
(8) Xd” = (1)(7) 0.0682
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 227
14
12 +
10 +++ Curve B
Current in phase 1 (per unit)
+
8 ++
+ ++
++
6 + ++
Line C
++
5 ++
++
+ +
4 ++
+ +
+ + ++
3
+
2.0
+ Line A
1.5
+
+
1.0
+
0.8
0.6 +
+ Curve A
0.4 +
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Time in half-cycles
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 228
114
Average Generator Reactances
Reactance Turbo Water-Wheel Synchronous
Generators Generators Motors
Xd 1.10 1.15 1.20
Xq 1.08 0.75 0.90
X d‘ 0.23 0.37 0.35
X q‘ 0.23 0.75 0.90
X d” 0.12 0.24 0.30
X q” 0.15 0.34 0.40
X2 0.12 0.24 0.35
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 229
Ungrounded Generator
If the generator is connected ungrounded-wye or
delta, no zero-sequence current can flow. The
sequence networks for the generator are shown
below.
F1 F2 F0
jX1
+ jX2 jX0
Eg
-
N1 N2 N0
Positive Negative Zero
Sequence Sequence Sequence
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 230
115
Grounded-Wye Generator
The sequence networks for the grounded-wye
generator are shown below.
F1 F2 F0
jX1
+ jX2 jX0
Eg
-
N1 N2 N0
Positive Negative Zero
Sequence Sequence Sequence
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 231
If the generator neutral is grounded through an
impedance Zg, the zero-sequence impedance is
modified as shown below.
F1 F2 F0
jX1 jX0
+ jX2
Eg 3Zg
-
N1 N2 N0
Positive Negative Zero
Sequence Sequence Sequence
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 232
116
Electric Utility (Power Grid)
Thevenin Equivalent Circuit
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 233
Thevenin’s Theorem
Any linear active network with output terminals AB can
be replaced by a single voltage source Vth in series with
a single impedance Zth
A A
Linear + Zth
Active Vth
Network -
B B
The Thevenin equivalent voltage Vth is the open circuit voltage
measured at the terminals AB. The equivalent impedance Z th is the
driving point impedance of the network at the terminals AB when
all sources are set equal to zero.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 234
117
Utility Fault MVA
Electric Utilities conduct
Electric short circuit analysis at the
Utility Connection Point of their
Grid customers
IF
Fault Customers obtain the Fault
Data at the Connection Point
to represent the Utility Grid
for their power system
analysis
Customer
Facilities
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 235
Utility Fault MVA
Electric Utility provides the Fault MVA and X/R ratio at
nominal system Voltage for the following types of fault:
• Three Phase Fault
Fault MVA3 X/R3
• Single Line-to-Ground Fault
Fault MVALG X/RLG
System Nominal Voltage in kV
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 236
118
Equivalent Circuit of Utility
Positive & Negative Sequence Impedance
From Three-Phase Fault Analysis
I TPF
Vf
S TPF V f I TPF
V
f
2
Z1 Z1
Where, Z1 and Z2 are the
equivalent positive-
Z1
kV
2
sequence and
Z 2 negative-sequence
Fault MVA3 impedances of the
utility
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 237
Equivalent Circuit of Utility
Zero Sequence Impedance
From Single Line-to-Ground Fault Analysis
I SLGF
3V f
S SLGF V f I SLGF
3Vf
2
Z1 Z 2 Z0 2Z 1 Z 0
Z1 Z 2
2Z 1 Z 0
3Vf
2
Resolve to real and imaginary
S SLGF components then solve for Zo
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 238
119
Equivalent Circuit of Utility
Example:
Determine the equivalent circuit of the Utility in per
unit quantities at a connection point for the following
Fault Data:
System Nominal Voltage = 69 kV
Fault MVA3 = 3500 MVA, X/R3 = 22
Fault MVALG = 3000 MVA, X/RLG = 20
The Base Power is 100 MVA
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 239
Equivalent Circuit of Utility
Base Power: 100 MVA
Base Voltage: 69 kV
Base Impedance: [69]2/100 = 47.61 ohms
Z1 Z 2
kV 2
69
2
1.3603
Fault MVA3 3500
In Per Unit,
Z actual 1.3603
Z1 Z 2 0.0286 p.u.
Z base 47.61
or
100MVABASE
Z1 Z 2 0.0286 p.u.
3500MVAFAULT
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 240
120
Equivalent Circuit of Utility
Solving for the Resistance and Reactance,
[(1 + (X/R)2] tan1 X / R
Z X X/R R Z cos
X Z sin
R 1
R1 0.0286 costan 22 -1
+
0.0013+j0.028571
0.0013 p.u. R2 +
X 1 0.0286 sintan-1 22
V f 10
-
-
0.028571 p.u. X 2
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 241
Equivalent Circuit of Utility
For the Zero Sequence Impedance,
3000MVASLGF( actual )
SLGFP .U . 30 p.u .
100MVABASE
69kV
VoltageP .U . 1.0 p .u .
69kV
2Z 1 Z 0
3Vf
2
31.0
2
0.1
S SLGF 30
Re al2 Z 1 Z 0 0.1cos tan -1 20 0.004994 p.u.
Im ag2 Z 1 Z 0 0.1sintan -1
20 0.099875 p.u.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 242
121
Equivalent Circuit of Utility
2 Z 1 Z 0 0.004994 j0.099875
Z 0 0.004994 j0.099875 20.0013 j0.028571
0.003694 j0.042733 p.u.
+ + +
0.0013+j0.028571
+ 0.0013+j0.028571 0.003694 j0.042733
V f 10
-
- - -
Positive Negative Zero
Sequence Sequence Sequence
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 243
Equivalent Circuit of Utility
Example:
Determine the equivalent circuit of the Utility in per
unit quantities at a connection point for the following
Fault Data:
Pos. Seq. Impedance = 0.03 p.u., X/R1 = 22
Zero Seq. Impedance = 0.07 p.u., X/R0 = 22
System Nominal Voltage = 69 kV
Base Power = 100 MVA
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 244
122
Equivalent Circuit of Utility
The equivalent sequence networks of the Electric
Utility Grid are:
+ + +
R1 +jX1
+ R2 +jX2 R0 +jX0
Eg
-
- - -
Positive Negative Zero
Sequence Sequence Sequence
Utility Thevenin Equivalent Circuits
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 245
Electric Circuit Theory
Two-Port Network
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 246
123
Two-Port Network
I1 I2
+ RLC +
V1 V2
-
Network -
I1 I2
Impedance or Z parameters
V1 z11 z12 I1
= or V = ZI
V2 z21 z22 I2
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 247
I1 I2
+ RLC +
V1 V2
- Network -
I1 I2
Admittance or Y parameters
I1 y11 y12 V1
=
I2 y 21 y 22 V2
or
I = YV
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 248
124
I1 I2
+ RLC +
V1 V2
- Network -
I1 I2
Hybrid or H parameters
V1 h11 h12 I1
=
I2 h21 h22 V2
or
U = HW
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 249
Example: For the electric circuit shown, find the Z
parameters.
2 4
+ +
I1 I2
V1 5 V2
- -
From the defining equations,
V1 z11I1 z12I2 and V2 z21I1 z22I2
we get
V1
z11 7
I1 I2 0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 250
125
V2
z21 5
I1 I2 0
Similarly, we get
V1
z12 5
I2 I1 0
V2
z22 9
I2 I1 0
Note: z12=z21
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 251
We can also write voltage equations for the input
and output ports. For the input side, we get
V1 2I1 5(I1 I2 ) 7I1 5I2
Compare with V1 z11I1 z12I2 . We get
z11 7 and z12 5
Similarly for the output side, we get
V2 4I2 5(I1 I2 ) 5I1 9I2
Compare with V2 z21I1 z22I2. We get
z21 5 and z22 9
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 252
126
Example: For the electric circuit shown, find the Y
parameters.
2 4
+ +
I1 I2
V1 5 V2
- -
From the defining equations,
I1 y11V1 y12V2 and I2 y21V1 y22V2
we get
I1 I2
y11 and y21
V1 V2 0
V1 V2 0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 253
Let V2=0.
2 4
+ +
I1 I2
V1 5 V2=0
- -
V1 5(4) 38
zin 2
I1 54 9
or
9 1
y11
38
Using current division, we get
5 5
I2 I1 I1
54 9
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 254
127
Since I1=y11V1 when V2=0, we get
5
I2 y11V1
9
or
I2 5 5 1
y21 y11
V1 9 38
Also from the defining equations, we get
I1 I2
y12 and y22
V2 V1 0
V2 V1 0
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 255
Let V1=0.
2 4
+ +
I1 I2
V1=0 5 V2
- -
V2 5(2) 38
zout 4
I2 52 7
or
7 1
y22
38
Using current division, we get
5 5
I1 I2 I2
52 7
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 256
128
Since I2=y22V2 when V1=0, we get
5
I1 y22V2
7
or
I1 5 5 1
y12 y22
V2 7 38
We can also get the Y parameters by taking the
inverse of the matrix of the Z parameters.
7 5 1 9 5
Z= Y=Z-1= -1
5 9 38 5 7
Note: y12=y21
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 257
Two-Port Network with Sources
I1 I2
+ RLC & +
V1 V2
-
Sources -
I1 I2
Assume all internal sources are independent. With
all sources set to zero, the network is described by
either (1) V = ZI
(2) I = YV
(3) U = HW
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 258
129
With all sources active, the network will be
described, respectively, by
(1) V = ZI + Vs
(2) I = YV + Is
(3) U = HW + Us
where
(1) Vs = V when I = 0 (open circuit)
(2) Is = I when V = 0 (short circuit)
(3) Us = U when W = 0 (open/short)
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 259
Example: For the electric circuit shown, find the Z
parameters.
- V1 +
I1 I1 I2
j0.1 j0.5 - j0.12
j0.12 j0.15
+ V2 +
EG1 EG2
+
- -
EG1 1.130o I2 EG2 1.00o
First, re-draw the circuit so that it looks like a two-
port network.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 260
130
+
EG1 - +
I1 EG2 I2
V1 + V2
I1 j0.27 I2
- -
Next, reduce the sources to zero and find the Z
parameters.
+
+
I1 I2
V1 j0.27 V2
I1 I2
- -
V1 z11 I1 z12 I2 and V2 z21 I1 z22 I2
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 261
V1
z11 j(0.5 0.27 0.22) j0.99
I1 I 0
2
V
z21 2 j0.27
I1 I 0
2
V
z22 2 j0.27
I2 I 0
1
We get z11 z12 j0.99 j0.27
Z= =
z21 z22 j0.27 j0.27
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 262
131
When the sources are active, we get
V1 z11 z12 I Vz1
= 1 +
V2 z21 z22 I2 Vz2
If I1 I2 0, then Vz1 V1 and Vz2 V2 . By
inspection, we get
Vz1 EG2 EG1 1.0 1.130o
0.552 85.08o
Vz2 EG2 1.00o
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 263
Series Connection
Two two-port networks are connected in series if
their input currents are the same and their output
currents are likewise the same.
+ Network +
I1 V1a V2a I2
A
V1 V2
I1 Network I2
- V1b V2b -
B
Problem: Find the over-all Z parameters.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 264
132
For two-port network A, we get
V1a z11(a) z12(a) I1
=
V2a z21(a) z22(a) I2
Similarly for two-port network B, we get
V1b z11(b) z12(b) I1
=
V2b z21(b) z22(b) I2
The terminal conditions are
V1=V1a+V1b and V2=V2a+V2b
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 265
Adding the two-port network equations, we get
V1 (z11(a) z11(b) ) (z12(a) z12(b) ) I1
=
V2 (z21(a) z21(b) ) (z22(a) z22(b) ) I2
Remarks:
(1) For two two-port networks in series, the
over-all Z parameters is the sum of the
individual Z parameters.
(2) This result applies to any number of two-
port networks in series.
(3) Series-connected two-port networks must
be described using the Z parameters.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 266
133
Parallel Connection
Two two-port networks are connected in parallel if
their input voltages are the same and their output
voltages are likewise the same.
+ Network +
I1 I1a I2a I2
A
V1 V2
I1 Network I2
- I1b I2b -
B
Problem: Find the over-all Y parameters.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 267
For two-port network A, we get
I1a y11(a) y12(a) V1
=
I2 a y21(a) y22(a) V2
Similarly for two-port network B, we get
I1b y11(b) y12(b) V1
=
I2b y21(b) y22(b) V2
The terminal conditions are
I1=I1a+I1b and I2=I2a+I2b
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 268
134
Adding the two-port network equations, we get
I1 (y11(a) y11(b) ) (y12(a) y12(b) ) V1
=
I2 (y21(a) y21(b) ) (y22(a) y22(b) ) V2
Remarks:
(1) For two two-port networks in parallel, the
over-all Y parameters is the sum of the
individual Y parameters.
(2) This result applies to any number of two-
port networks in parallel.
(3) Parallel-connected two-port networks must
be described using the Y parameters.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 269
Hybrid Connection
Two two-port networks are connected in hybrid if
one port is connected in series and the other port
is connected in parallel.
+ Network +
I1 V1a I2a I2
A
V1 V2
I1 Network I2
- V1b I2b -
B
Problem: Find the over-all H parameters.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 270
135
For two-port network A, we get
V1a h11(a) h12(a) I1
= h h22(a)
I2a 21(a) V2
Similarly for two-port network B, we get
V1b h11(b) h12(b) I1
=
I2b h21(b) h22(b) V2
The terminal conditions are
V1=V1a+V1b and I2=I2a+I2b
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 271
Adding the two-port network equations, we get
V1 (h11(a) h11(b) ) (h12(a) h12(b) ) I1
=
I2 (h21(a) h21(b) ) (h22(a) h22(b) ) V2
Remarks:
(1) For two two-port networks in hybrid
connection, the over-all H parameters is
the sum of the individual H parameters.
(2) This result applies to any number of two-
port networks in hybrid connection.
(3) Hybrid-connected two-port networks must
be described using the H parameters.
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 272
136
Electrical & Electronics Engineering Institute EE 251 – Fault Studies
University of the Philippines Diliman 273
137
You might also like
- Power Systems 1 Transmission Lines Hand Out Summer 2017No ratings yetPower Systems 1 Transmission Lines Hand Out Summer 201713 pages
- EE251 Note 2 - Sequence Impedance of Transmission LinesNo ratings yetEE251 Note 2 - Sequence Impedance of Transmission Lines96 pages
- Lecture 2 Sequence Impedance of Transmission LinesNo ratings yetLecture 2 Sequence Impedance of Transmission Lines48 pages
- Design of Transmission Lines:: Cyrus Wekesa Associate Professor School of EEENo ratings yetDesign of Transmission Lines:: Cyrus Wekesa Associate Professor School of EEE28 pages
- Lecture 9: Transmission Lines: Instructor: Dr. Gleb V. Tcheslavski ContactNo ratings yetLecture 9: Transmission Lines: Instructor: Dr. Gleb V. Tcheslavski Contact55 pages
- Spring 2008: ELEN 3441 Fundamentals of Power EngineeringNo ratings yetSpring 2008: ELEN 3441 Fundamentals of Power Engineering37 pages
- 'EX 6 Measurement of Insulation Resistance-1No ratings yet'EX 6 Measurement of Insulation Resistance-111 pages
- Power System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line ModelsNo ratings yetPower System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line Models40 pages
- ECE 476 Power System Analysis: Lecture 6: Transmission Line ParametersNo ratings yetECE 476 Power System Analysis: Lecture 6: Transmission Line Parameters33 pages
- 'EX 6 Measurement of Insulation ResistanceNo ratings yet'EX 6 Measurement of Insulation Resistance16 pages
- Power System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line Models Tom Overbye and Ross BaldickNo ratings yetPower System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line Models Tom Overbye and Ross Baldick29 pages
- Power System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line Models Tom Overbye and Ross BaldickNo ratings yetPower System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line Models Tom Overbye and Ross Baldick29 pages
- Chapter 4 Transmission Line Paramters - pptx1No ratings yetChapter 4 Transmission Line Paramters - pptx116 pages
- 17 - Dielectrics and Electrical InsulationNo ratings yet17 - Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation417 pages
- Transmission Lines:: EE4123: Electrical Power TransmissionNo ratings yetTransmission Lines:: EE4123: Electrical Power Transmission17 pages
- Power System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line Models Tom Overbye and Ross BaldickNo ratings yetPower System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line Models Tom Overbye and Ross Baldick29 pages
- Transmission Distribution and Protection of Electrical Power SystemNo ratings yetTransmission Distribution and Protection of Electrical Power System22 pages
- Transmission Lines:: EE4123: Electrical Power TransmissionNo ratings yetTransmission Lines:: EE4123: Electrical Power Transmission17 pages
- Calculation of Positive Sequence ImpedanceNo ratings yetCalculation of Positive Sequence Impedance14 pages
- Module 1 - Transmission Line ParametersNo ratings yetModule 1 - Transmission Line Parameters39 pages
- Transmission Line Parameter CalculationsNo ratings yetTransmission Line Parameter Calculations37 pages
- Power System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line Models Tom Overbye and Ross BaldickNo ratings yetPower System Analysis: Development of Transmission Line Models Tom Overbye and Ross Baldick29 pages
- Power System, Fault Analysis and Equipment100% (1)Power System, Fault Analysis and Equipment23 pages
- Transmission and Distribution System Engineering (EE-555) : Muhammad Bilal Shams LecturerNo ratings yetTransmission and Distribution System Engineering (EE-555) : Muhammad Bilal Shams Lecturer31 pages
- Guide To Transmission Line Constants Calculations SynchroGridNo ratings yetGuide To Transmission Line Constants Calculations SynchroGrid6 pages
- D6 Transmission Model Parameter Draft1-2 - 9!3!2010No ratings yetD6 Transmission Model Parameter Draft1-2 - 9!3!201038 pages
- Feynman Lectures Simplified 2C: Electromagnetism: in Relativity & in Dense MatterFrom EverandFeynman Lectures Simplified 2C: Electromagnetism: in Relativity & in Dense MatterNo ratings yet
- k12 Grade 8 - Physical Education (Curriculum Guide)89% (45)k12 Grade 8 - Physical Education (Curriculum Guide)5 pages
- 17 Equations That Changed The World - Business InsiderNo ratings yet17 Equations That Changed The World - Business Insider10 pages
- Advanced External Procedure TransformationNo ratings yetAdvanced External Procedure Transformation14 pages
- Gateways to Art Understanding the Visual Arts 1st Edition Debra Dewitte download100% (6)Gateways to Art Understanding the Visual Arts 1st Edition Debra Dewitte download57 pages
- (B6) 113668-2002-People - v. - Dela - Cerna PDFNo ratings yet(B6) 113668-2002-People - v. - Dela - Cerna PDF13 pages
- LAS Gen - Chem2 - MELC - 20 22 - Q3 Week 8No ratings yetLAS Gen - Chem2 - MELC - 20 22 - Q3 Week 811 pages
- PsyElec1 - Introduction To Guidance CounsellingNo ratings yetPsyElec1 - Introduction To Guidance Counselling14 pages
- TEC-031100P-MET-DoR-001 (Method Statement For De-Shuttering Work For Peri)0% (1)TEC-031100P-MET-DoR-001 (Method Statement For De-Shuttering Work For Peri)7 pages
- Abb - Fuses - Ato Katalog - Eng Lo-Res 09.2015No ratings yetAbb - Fuses - Ato Katalog - Eng Lo-Res 09.201556 pages
- Two Important Elements in This Definition of Moral TheologyNo ratings yetTwo Important Elements in This Definition of Moral Theology18 pages
- Calculate Numbers of Plate/Pipe/Strip Earthings (Part-1)No ratings yetCalculate Numbers of Plate/Pipe/Strip Earthings (Part-1)3 pages
- Development of Autonomous Bucket Wheel Reclaimer With LaserNo ratings yetDevelopment of Autonomous Bucket Wheel Reclaimer With Laser5 pages
