2.0 Lecture -Financial Sustainability
2.0 Lecture -Financial Sustainability
Sustainable
Finance Manager
(CSFM)
Stephen Snider
CSFM: Principles of Financing Sustainability
Let’s explore the foundations of sustainability.
These key concepts will improve your work.
Agenda:
1. Key Ideas of Sustainable Finance
2. History of the Industry
3. Net Zero
4. Going Beyond Carbon
5. Business Risks & Opportunities
6. Performance and Growth
7. Additional Resources
3
Key Ideas of Sustainable Finance
Evolution of What’s Important
EHS = Environment, Health, and Safety
CSR =Corporate Social Responsibility
SRI = Sustainable Responsible Investing or Socially Responsible Investing
ESG = Environmental, Social, and Governance
4
Key Ideas of Sustainable Finance
Green and Social Investing
Finance or Investment?
Investment is a subset of Finance. Finance refers to whole range of activities in financial system. Investment is an
asset purchased to provide income in the future or will later be sold for a profit.
Green Finance (sometimes also Environmental Finance) is focused on environmental sustainability specifically,
although the boundaries between social and environmental sustainability are very blurred, e.g. SDGs.
Responsible Investment is an approach to investing that aims to incorporate ESG factors into investment decisions,
to better manage risk and generate sustainable, long-term returns (PRI, 2018) but no specific issues. .
Socially Responsible Investment (SRI) (sometimes Ethical Investment) introduces ethical preferences to exclude
certain companies and sectors (e.g. arms, tobacco, fossil fuel etc) - this has a lot of history
Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) are a set of standards and criteria for a company’s operations that
investors use to screen potential investments. (Investopedia, 2018)
Impact Investing actively seeks to make a positive impact through investing. Often see themselves as a very distinct
community because of the focus on positive impact, community development, and engagement.
Climate Finance is focused on climate mitigation and climate adaptation. It is often used to refer to North-South flows
and is sometimes in the form of aid or funding for specific climate related projects.
Sustainable finance brings all these terms together - green and social
5
Key Ideas of Sustainable Finance
Different Social and Environmental Agendas
6
History of the Industry
Sustainable Finance is not a new story.
7
History of the Industry
History
Understand that Sustainable FInance has been evolving over decades and recent acceleration is rooted in the foundations of religious and
social movements that recognized that finance and money have power to shape the world in which we live. It is helpful to see how different
groups and networks have advocated for different directions, to understand the formation of key stakeholders, and to see how the acronyms
we use continue to multiply and to change.
The evolution has seen it move from being mostly religious investing based on values like Catholic, Islamic Tradition, or the Quakers, to used for
social issues. The collapse of the South African Apartheid was in part due to the divestment movement many people and institutions agreed to
pressure. Consider the recent divestment from Russia for the Ukrainian invasion. And consider how the industry continues to respond to major
issues like the Me Too Movement, the Amazon Fires and Deforestation, to concern with fossil fuels and nuclear energy.
We’ve seen the explosion of financial analysis and modern finance theory includes • Modern portfolio theory (MPT) – 1950s • Capital Asset
Pricing Model (CAPM) – 1960s • ABSs – 1970s • Black–Scholes (options pricing) – 1970s • Black–Litterman model (asset allocation) – 1992 •
Bloomberg Terminal – 1980s • Passive investment and ETFs – 1990s. All of this possible:
- regulation - increase need, technical capacities, & trust
- consolidation - major centralization of location and products
- standardization - ISO (standards), IFRS (fin.), BIS (central banks), OICV (securities)
There are some helpful articles you can check out and useful videos to learn more
- Morningstar’s History of Sustainable Investing
8
History of Finance, Swiss Learning Exchange Sustainable Banking, Weber 2016
History of the Industry
Key Dates
1700s - John Wesley's novel idea
Methodist movement encouraged conscious investment practice urging followers to refrain from investments in 'sin stocks' such as weapons and tobacco.
2030 - On Target?
When action must happen by with emissions halved. Will we rise to the occasion?
10
Time for an Activity
12
Net Zero
This is a goal that we need to achieve
to avoid the worst impacts of climate
change. A low carbon economy will
protect people and planet.
13
13
Net Zero
What is it?
To limit global warming to 1.5°C, the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change)
stresses that the world needs to halve CO2 emissions by around 2030 and reach Net Zero
CO2 emissions by mid-century.
The IPCC emphasizes the need for deep reductions in non-CO2 emissions across the
economy to achieve this limit.
The IPCC defines net-zero as that point when “anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases
to the atmosphere are balanced by anthropogenic removals over a specified period”. The
Paris Agreement sets out the need to achieve this balance by the second half of this century
The concept of net-zero has risen in prominence ever since, as countries, cities, companies
and others are increasingly committing to reaching this ambitious goal. As of July 2020, a
quarter of global CO2 emissions and more than half of the global economy were covered by
net-zero commitments, according to the Race to Zero campaign led by the High-Level
Climate Action Champions in the run up to COP 26.
14
Net Zero
Beyond CO2 there are other emissions that also cause climate change. These include and these all occur naturally
● Methane (CH4)
● Water Vapour (H2o)
● Nitrous Oxide (N2O)
Others emissions do not occur naturally and are being added to the atmosphere by human activity.
● Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs)
● Perfluorocarbons (PFCs)
● Sulphur hexafluoride (SF6)
The IPCC is an intergovernmental body of the United Nations and was created to provide policymakers with regular
scientific assessments on climate change, its implications and potential future risks, as well as to put forward
adaptation and mitigation options.
The 2022 IPCC report summarises our current understanding of the interdependencies between climate, ecosystems,
biodiversity and human societies, and assesses the risks and impacts of climate change, adaptation, and resilience.
The IPCC reports are the best place to go for clear explanations of
climate change impacts and how changes are possible.
15
Net Zero
POLL
A. Methane (CH4)
B. Oxygen (O)
C. Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs)
D. Nitrous Oxide (N2O)
16
Net Zero
The Net Zero Bathtub
17
Net Zero on Campus Interactive, 2022
Net Zero
Who’s Pledging
Earth Index
Check out the following rankings and ratings to see who’s acting and making changes:
The Earth Index 2022 top 100 companies taking action but we’re still not on target for most
sectors and industries. See more here.
NOTE: While all ranking systems and methodologies do have their criticisms it is useful to
review the rationale, see where you disagree, and notice what stands out as useful.
18
Net Zero
Are we doing enough?
While many see Net Zero and Carbon Neutral as buzzwords or
greenwashing, limiting emissions is the ultimate goal. Organizations should
set meaningful and actionable targets and really mean it when pledging to
be Net Zero.
Some criticisms exist. The validation and accountability with Net Zero is yet
to be seen. Many organizations have set unrealistic and unachievable
goals. Private companies are not jumping on the bandwagon. Interim
targets that accelerate to meet the 2030 goals are lacking.
The Observer, R. McKie, Aug. 2021
1. Human-induced global warming of 1.1°C has already caused major changes to the Earth.
2. Climate impacts on people and ecosystems are more widespread and severe than
expected, and future risks will escalate rapidly with every fraction of a degree of warming.
3. Adaptation measures can effectively build resilience, but more finance is needed to scale.
4. Some climate impacts are already so severe they cannot be adapted to and are very costly.
5. Global GHG emissions are expected to peak before 2025 in 1.5°C-aligned pathways.
6. The world must rapidly shift away from burning fossil fuels — the number one cause.
8. Carbon removal and natural solutions are essential to limit global temperature rise to 1.5°C.
9. Climate finance for both mitigation and adaptation must increase dramatically this decade.
10.Climate change — as well as our collective efforts to adapt to and mitigate it — will
exacerbate inequality should we fail to ensure a just transition.
20
Net Zero
24
Going Beyond Carbon
The Paris Agreement
A key global agreement on climate change was the 2016 Paris Climate Agreement at the
United Nations’ Conference of the Parties (COP)
- Agreement to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions
- Keep the global temperature rise below 1.5°C, compared to the pre-industrial levels
- Work together to avoid the catastrophic impacts of climate change
- Meet regularly and increase commitments and speed up action over time
Almost every country in the world has signed and ratified the agreement and in 2021
President Biden had the United States rejoin after President Trump withdrew the USA
Enhancing NDCs to Achieve the Paris Agreement - WRI, 2020 The Paris Climate Agreement Summary - Environa, 2021
25
Going Beyond Carbon
Global Associations and Partnerships
Sustainable investing is a large & growing investment trend. Almost one third of assets under management in the U.S.
are now categorized as sustainable investing. Expect to see continued evolution in ESG strategies, investment products,
and reporting standards.
Two ESG investing themes—climate change and racial equity—came sharply into focus in 2020 in shaping ESG
investing, and are expected to continue to play a prominent role.
Companies will increasingly be held accountable for ESG risks and will be expected to disclose them in more detail as
consumers, NGOs, employees, and investors push industry towards “stakeholder capitalism.” Finance managers need
to understand how to identify, measure, and evaluate ESG risk exposure.
UN Global Compact
Check out the UN Global Compact Accenture CEO
Study on ESG that surveyed 1,000 CEOs across 103
countries and 27 industries:
● 93% see ESG as important to the future of their
business
We're shaping a sustainable future.
● 78% see ESG as an opportunity for growth and
You need to be part of it. Long-term
innovation business success matters and so do
● 80% see ESG as an area for gaining a your workers, communities, and the
competitive advantage in their industry planet. The UN Global Compact
● 84% believe their business should lead efforts to helps you do business right for all.
define and deliver ESG goal - UN Global Compact
26
Going Beyond Carbon
Recognition of Many Issues
May different projects and roadmaps to get us to alignment with the Paris Agreement and the fundamental
transformation within organizations that need to happen in the next 10, 20, 30 years to meet 2050 Net Zero and keep
average global warming below the 1.5 degrees. UN SDGs and others advocate that carbon is just one piece.
27
A healthy economy should be… | Kate Raworth Doughnut Economics + Planetary Boundaries
Going Beyond Carbon
Consequences
Remember there are many different perspectives to this - we face many complex, major, and systemic issues.
Conversation with:
Chai Locher, Institute of Social Banking
30
Business Risks & Opportunities
Risks and Implications
Access to Capital - exposure to specific ESG issues will mean a flight of capital. Look at the pressure put on investors
to divest from Russia over the invasion of Ukraine. According to Russell Investments‘ annual asset manager survey,
“the integration of environmental, social and governance (ESG) is now universally recognized as a significant
consideration when analyzing long-term investment opportunities.”
Stranded Assets - because of the transition to renewable energy, oil, coal, and other nonrenewable materials may be
written off and devalued plus many investors are actively divesting from fossil fuels. There is pressure for managers
holding these investments to change. Example NY State Pension divesting.
Exposure to Liabilities - investors are requiring disclosure of ESG risks to identify potential liabilities that their
investments face. Example of where investors forcing funds to consider environmental issues in observance of
climate change and other impacts. Fund forced to act.
Reputation Risk - the public is becoming more aware of social and environmental issues. Public opinion and the
potential risk of controversy has led to Governance improvements around #MeToo issues and many banks have
pledged to not drill in the Arctic after pressure from NGOs.
Talent attraction and retention - ESG scrutiny can shine a light on issues like workplace safety, employee health and
wellness, diversity and inclusion, executive compensation, business ethics, and corruption. In additional there is a gold
rush for ESG Investing skills with competence greenwashing.
31
ESG Risk Management: Key Aspects You Need To Know
Business Risks & Opportunities
Opportunities and Market Growth
Flow of Money - The attraction of money to ESG and Sustainability is real and continues to accelerate. With a coming
generational shift in savings, millennials have much sway in what comes next for the economy. A Morgan Stanley
survey reports 95% of millennials are interested in sustainable investing. In 2020 alone, 53 new ESG funds opened in
the U.S., bringing the number to 367. In the USA, since the 1982 Calvert Social Investment Fund, many new products
have been added like the Hartford Climate Opportunities Fund, Invesco WilderHill Clean Energy ETF, and the BNP
Paribas Easy ECPI Global ESG Blue Economy ETF.
Data and Analytics - the business of ESG has explored. Ratings, data collection, and screening have become big
business with major vendors like MSCI and Morningstar. Or aggregators like Bloomberg, Refinitiv, and Factset. There
have also been advances in using artificial intelligence to review company reports, and collect ESG data.
Reporting and Assurance - the major consulting firms have all offered services to facilitate business needs. Large
firms have developed their own frameworks. And global associations are advocating for common approaches like
the Global Reporting Initiative, TCFD, Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), and CDP.
Energy Transition - the financing and investment in renewable energy has been an investment boon with major
asset managers and banks directing financing to growing industries. Some sectors that are expected to bloom are
related to climate transition, including clean energy, sustainable transportation, and sustainable food and agriculture.
Sustainable Bonds - green bonds are fixed-income financial instruments that have positive environmental benefits
and allocate proceeds to climate mitigation or adaptation projects. Similar products like transition bonds,
sustainability linked bonds, and blue bonds provide unique financing opportunities. More to discuss in later modules.
Impact Investing - This is a range of strategies aimed at generating social and environmental “returns” in addition to
financial objectives (which can range from philanthropic to commercial rates of return). The philanthropy, foundation,
and institutional investment communities are increasingly interested in and creative about devising impact investing
products that are growing in popularity.
32
Business Risks & Opportunities
POLL
From a risk standpoint, climate change will impact business most in terms of:
A. Physical Risk
B. Transition Risk
C. Legal Risk
33
Performance and Growth
Sustainable finance is here to stay.
34
Performance and Growth
Sustainable finance continues to grow
From the flow of funds, number of products, growth in research, profitable “Over the next 10 years, Goldman
investments, or measurable impact, the industry garners attention globally. Sachs will target $750bn of financing,
In 2015, Friede et al. found that 90% of studies on ESG had a non-negative investing and advisory activity to nine
performance of funds. areas that focus on climate transition
and inclusive growth.” -
Others question the link to performance but make explicit the connection to David Solomon, CEO, Goldman Sachs
the cost of capital and the benefits- Kölbel and Busch, 2017. Financial Times, Dec. 15, 2019
Mark Carney, Bank of England, suggests that in theory, the more that society values the transition
to Net Zero, the more valuable companies that are part of the solution will be, because of greater
demand for their products as well as because of developments in regulation and carbon pricing
that support society’s objectives - UNEP FI.
38
38
Additional Resources
Useful Trainings
Two very good books to learn more with:
Sustainable Investing. A Path to a New Horizon – edited by Herman Bril, Georg Kell and
Andreas Rasche
This book tells the story of how the convergence between corporate sustainability and
sustainable investing is now becoming a major force, driving systemic market changes.
The idea and practice of corporate sustainability is no longer a niche movement; investors
are increasingly paying attention to sustainability factors in their analysis and decision-
making, thus reinforcing market transformation. Aimed at both investment professionals
and academics, this book gives the reader access to more practitioner-relevant
information, and it also discusses implementation issues. The reader will gain insights into
39
how ‘mainstream’ financial actors relate to sustainable investing.
Additional Resources
Useful Trainings
Principles of Sustainable Finance
One of the best and most comprehensive courses out there to get a background understanding of the theory, history, and mechanics of the
industry of sustainable finance. Brought to you by Dirk Schoenmaker, Professor of Banking and Finance at Rotterdam School of Management,
and other lectures. The course provides explores finance in terms of the UN Sustainable Development Goals, how social and environmental
factors should not be regarded as externalities, sustainable banking & asset management, effective shareholder and stakeholder engagement,
sustainable scenario analysis, and long-term value creation.
Free Canva course - can pay about $30 to get a certificate
Very useful book
Stephen
[email protected]