1 s2.0 S0196890424013189 Main
1 s2.0 S0196890424013189 Main
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: The carbon dioxide capture and compression processes represent the most energy-intensive stages in the carbon
CO2 capture capture and storage (CCS) process, which are usually treated independently in the existing studies. Integrating
Electrochemically mediated amine the CO2 capture and compression stages is a possible way to effectively reduce the compressor size and the total
regeneration (EMAR)
energy consumption of the CCS process. The recent development of electrochemically mediated amine regen
Thermodynamic model
eration (EMAR) technology provides a promising approach for this integration due to the strong driving force of
Integrated system
Energy consumption the electrochemical reaction and the copper–amine complexation reaction. In this paper, we propose an
electrochemical-mediated integrated system for CO2 capture and compression and verify its pressurized opera
tion performance both theoretically and experimentally. A thermodynamic model was developed to analyze the
energy performance of the system and a bench-scale flow-cell system was designed to verify its ability to output
CO2 under pressurized conditions. The thermodynamic modelling results indicated that the energy consumption
of the integrated system is significantly affected by different operational paths. At lower pressures, CO2 bubbles
are easier to form and the system tends to operate in 3-steps, higher pressures lead the system to function in 4-
steps. Furthermore, the total energy consumption of the CCS process can be reduced by releasing CO2 at a
suitable pressure. The results of the bench-scale flow system indicated that a 40% increase in release pressure
resulted in a nearly constant driving voltage and released CO2 amount, thereby demonstrating its capacity to
release pressurized CO2. In conclusion, the results demonstrate the feasibility of the electrochemical-mediated
integrated system, which provide an innovative low-energy pathway to support the achievement of global
carbon neutrality.
* Corresponding authors.
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (Z. Zhang), [email protected] (X. Wu).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enconman.2024.119377
Received 10 September 2024; Received in revised form 4 December 2024; Accepted 4 December 2024
Available online 16 December 2024
0196-8904/© 2024 Elsevier Ltd. All rights are reserved, including those for text and data mining, AI training, and similar technologies.
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
Fig. 1. Flowsheet for the CCS process. (a) Conventional CCS process; (b) Electrochemical CO2 capture and compression based on EMAR technology for CCS.
2
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
CO2 is typically pressurized to a range of 7–15 MPa for refrigerants and Table 1
15 MPa for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) or geological sequestration The main reactions in the electrochemical-mediated integrated system.
[33–35]. As illustrated in Fig. 1, if the CO2 can be pressurized at the Reaction types Reaction equilibrium equation
capture stage, it could partially replace the function of compressor, ( )
Electrochemical Cu2(aq)
+
+ 2e ⇌Cu(s)
− RT C0
thereby reducing the energy consumption of the compression equip E = E0 −
nF
ln
CCu2+
ment, which is important for reducing the total energy consumption of Amine-CO2 formation EDA + CO2 ⇌EDACO2 KCO2 =
( )
the full-chain CCS project. Moreover, the high-pressure inlet gas can CEDACO2 P0
streamline the compression process, reduce the compression stages and CEDA PCO2
Cu-Amine Cu2+ + C Cu(EDA) 2+
minimize the size of the compressor, which is crucial for the operational [ 2]
complexation [
2EDA⇌ Cu(EDA)2
]2+ β = 2
CEDA CCu2+
stability of the compressor. It is fortunate that the EMAR technology is [ ]2+
Overall Cu(EDA)2 + 2e− + 2CO2 ⇌Cu(s) + 2EDACO2
characterized by pressurized operation. The electrochemical reaction
occurs in solution, and thus the reaction of metals to metal ions is nearly
unaffected by the ambient pressure. Moreover, the driving force of the
equilibrium equations.
reaction R(2) is significantly greater than R(1), facilitating the release of
In these equilibrium equations, Ci represents the concentration of
CO2 under pressure with only a small increase in the physically dissolved
species i. The Cu(s) is the solid Cu electrode, and its concentration (C0) is
CO2 in the solution [11]. Nevertheless, there is still a paucity of research
constant at a value of 1. The standard equilibrium potential (E0 ) of Cu/
investigating the performance of pressurized operation of EMAR system.
Cu2+ is 0.34 V vs. SHE, the Faraday constant (F) is 96485C⋅mol− 1 and
The concept of electrochemical compressor has inspired the inves
the gas constant (R) is 8.314 J⋅mol− 1⋅K− 1. P0 is the reference pressure,
tigation of an electrochemical-mediated integrated system for CO2
which is equivalent to 0.1 MPa.PCO2 represents the partial pressure of
capture and compression based on the EMAR process. The electro
CO2, which is determined by the operating conditions. The values of
chemical compressor technology employs electrochemical reactions to
these equilibrium constants can be found in reference [31].
pressurize gases, which has been widely studied in the fields of hydrogen
These equilibrium equations can be solved to determine the con
(H2) compression [36]. Currently, the electrochemical H2 compressors
centration of each substance in the solution and its corresponding po
can compress H2 from atmospheric pressure to over 5.0 MPa [37–39]. In
tential. In order to solve those equations, it is necessary to define the
contrast, the electrochemical NH3 compressors and electrochemical CO2
mass conservation equations for EDA, CO2 and Cu as follows:
compressors have received less attention. Existing studies used NH+ 4 and
CO2–3 as medium to achieve gas pressurization, requiring the assistance CEDA,tot = CEDA + CEDACO2 + 2C Cu(EDA) 2+ (1)
[ 2]
of H2 or O2 to complete the electrochemical reaction. Furthermore, the
2–
reverse diffusion of NH+ 4 and CO3 reduces the efficiency of the process CCO2,tot = CCO2 + C[EDACO2 ] (2)
and makes it more challenging to operate at high pressures [40,41].
Nevertheless, the aforementioned studies provided a comprehensive CCu,tot = CCu2+ + C Cu(EDA) 2+ (3)
theoretical framework and a valuable experimental basis for studying [ 2]
3
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
2.1.2. The energy consumption of pump and compressor where ΔnCO2 represents the amount of CO2 desorbed (mole); I is the
In the CO2 utilization or geological sequestration process, it is applied current (A) and U is the cell voltage (V); t is the desorption time
commonly necessary to increase its pressure to 15.0 MPa. The energy (s).
consumption of both compressors and pumps plays a significant role and
must be considered in energy consumption calculations. The energy 3. Results and discussion
consumption of compressors is related to the inlet pressure Pin, and the
formula is given as follows [45]: 3.1. Thermodynamic analysis of the electrochemical-mediated integrated
system
Wcomp = − 3.48lnPin + 14.85, 1 bar⩽Pin ⩽20bar (16)
Assuming the operation of the pump is a simple isothermal process, Based on the thermodynamic model established in Section 2.1, a
the power consumed by the pump for capturing each mole of CO2 is comprehensive study was conducted to analyze the relationship be
given by the following empirical formula [46]: tween the energy consumption and its operating pressure of the
electrochemical-mediated integrated system. The realistic benefits of
Pop − PCO2 the system were validated by comparing the total energy consumption of
Wpump = (17)
CEDA,tot × ΔxCO2 a full-chain CCS process witch capture CO2 and pressurized to 15 MPa
for geological utilization or sequestration.
where Pop is operating pressure, MPa; PCO2 is the partial pressure of CO2
in flue gas, MPa;ΔxCO2 is the difference of CO2 loading between the 3.1.1. Model validation
anolyte and catholyte. Before calculation, model validation should be carried out to
demonstrate the accuracy of the calculation process. While theoretical
models of compressor and pump have been widely applied, the
2.2. Experimental electrochemical-mediated integrated system model based on the EMAR
process still requires comparative validation. The accuracy of EMAR
2.2.1. Materials process was validated through the simulation of the classical process
In the experiment, EDA (AR, 99 %), copper sulfate pentahydrate
4
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
Fig. 2. The electrochemical-mediated integrated system. (a) Process schematic diagram; (b) experimental system.
proposed by Wang et al [25]. As shown in Fig. 3, the computational recent years, the energy demand of the EMAR technology has been
result of 16.2 kJ/mol CO2 aligns with the value of 16.0 kJ/mol CO2 progressively decreasing, steadily approaching its theoretical energy
reported by Sara et al. [47], thereby validating the accuracy of our consumption. This trend provides confidence in the practical application
model. For comparison, we analyzed the thermodynamic limit con of this system.
sumption for separating CO2 from a mixed gas containing 15 % CO2
under ambient conditions, which was determined by Eq. (15) to be 4.7 3.1.2. The energy consumption the electrochemical-mediated integrated
kJ/mol CO2. Considering a separation efficiency of 90 %, the minimum system
energy consumption for CO2 separation from flue gas is 6.4 kJ/mol CO2. Based on the thermodynamic model established in Section 2.1.1, a
The theoretical energy consumption of the EMAR process is only 2.5 theoretical evaluation of the thermodynamic energy consumption of the
times the minimum energy requirement, highlighting the substantial electrochemical-mediated integrated system was carried out. During the
advantages of this technique. Additionally, Fig. 3 also illustrates the calculation process, the concentration of EDA was set at 4 mol/kg H2O,
energy consumption for CO2 desorption as reported in current labora the temperature was maintained at 50 ◦ C, and the Cu2+ loading was
tory systems. Due to the continuous research and improvements in varied between 0.2 and 0.8.
5
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
Fig. 4. Thermodynamic paths of the electrochemical-mediated integrated system. (a) 4-step process; (b) 3-step process. (The red dashed line represents a constant
CO2 loading line, the horizontal dashed line signifies a constant CO2 partial pressure line, and the curved line delineates the operation process of the integrated
system). (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)
6
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
actual operation of the EMAR system falls between the 3-step and 4-step
processes. At lower releasing pressures, CO2 bubbles are more likely to
form, causing the system to behave more like the 3-step operation, with
the energy consumption increasing significantly as the pressure rises. As
the pressure continues to increase, CO2 bubbles become difficult to form
in the solution, and the system prefers to the 4-step operation, with
energy consumption remaining relatively stable. Further increasing the
pressure results in the complete dissolution of CO2 in the solution,
causing the system to malfunction, as observed at a maximum pressure
of 12.4 MPa in the 4 M EDA absorbent. In this study, calculations were
conducted for both limiting cases. While the energy consumption of the
3-step process increases with rising pressure below 5 MPa, the energy
consumption of subsequent compression equipment must be considered,
which will be discussed in detail in Section 3.1.3.
Fig. 7. The total energy consumption of the integrated system at different release pressure. (a) 4-step process; (b) 3-step process.
7
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
8
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
Fig. 9. The performance of the flow-cell with different applied current at 0.1 MPa. (a) The V-t curve at the current density of 50 A/m2; (b) the cell voltage at steady
state; (c)the electron efficiency; (d) the desorption energy consumption. (200 mL CO2-saturated solution serves as electrolyte, which contain 4 mol/kg H2O EDA and
0.5 mol/kg H2O Na2SO4. The initial Cu2+ loading is 0.2 and 0.8 in the anolyte and catholyte, respectively. The experiment was conducted at a temperature of 50 ◦ C
for 1 h).
electron utilization. However, in practice, the generation of CO2 bub 0.14 MPa. Increasing the desorption pressure poses a significant chal
bles, the re-saturation of the solvent, and the enthalpy change of the lenge to the liquid flow at the inlet of the anode electrolysis reservoir,
EDA-CO2 reactants consume some electrons, reducing the electrons especially under low liquid flow rate. Therefore, the peristaltic pump
available for CO2 release. Fig. 9 (d) demonstrates that the desorption speed during the pressurization operation was set at 80 rpm (the elec
energy consumption increases from 86.4 kJ/mol CO2 at 50 mA/m2 to trolyte flow rate of approximately 20 ml/min).
153.67 kJ/mol CO2 at 100 mA/m2 as a consequence of the cell voltage To evaluate the performance of pressurized operation, the response
rise and the electronic efficiency decrease at high current density. voltage–time curve, the mount of CO2 desorbed and desorption energy
In summary, increasing the current density has a negative impact on consumption were recorded. Fig. 10 (a) illustrates the response volta
the overall performance of the flow-cell, although it does accelerate the ge–time curves under different system pressure. It is evident that the
rate of CO2 release. Therefore, the operating current density should be response voltages at different pressures are highly similar. The response
selected carefully to ensure an appropriate balance between the reaction voltage changes by only 5 mV when the pressure increases by 40 %. This
rate and the flow-cell performance. Furthermore, it is important to note indicates that the proposed system can achieve stable CO2 output under
that the flow rate in the experiment is not optimized. The high liquid pressurized conditions. Fig. 10 (b) compares the CO2 release perfor
flow rate results in a limited electrochemical reaction window, leading mance at different release pressure. The results show that the
to poor electron efficiency. Optimizing the liquid flow can effectively electrochemical-mediated integrated system can effectively release CO2,
improve the performance of the flow-cell. However, the objective of this and the pressure has almost no effect on the CO2 desorption perfor
study is to evaluate the viability of the electrochemical-mediated inte mance. As shown in Fig. 10 (c), the energy consumption performance at
grated system. The optimization of the various parameters will be different output pressures is compared using the 0.1 MPa as a bench
considered in our future research plan. mark. It was observed that an increase in output pressure does not cause
a significant rise in energy consumption, confirming the stability of the
3.2.3. Bench-scale validation of the electrochemical-mediated integrated integrated system.
system
As indicated in Section 3.2.2, a high current density leads to signif 4. Conclusions and outlooks
icantly higher energy consumption of the flow-cell. Consequently, the
applied current density in the pressurization experiments was set at 50 Based on the high-pressure operational capability of the EMAR
mA/m2. The operating absolute pressures were 0.1 MPa, 0.12 MPa and technology and the innovative concept of electrochemical compression,
9
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
10
Y. Mao et al. Energy Conversion and Management 325 (2025) 119377
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence [23] Wang CH, Jiang KQ, Yu H, Yang SH, Li KK. Copper electrowinning-coupled CO2
capture in solvent based post-combustion capture. Appl Energ 2022;316.
the work reported in this paper.
[24] Zhang MH, Liu YY, Zhu YM, Wu KJ, Lu HF, Liang B. Cu(II)-assisted CO2 absorption
and desorption performances of the MMEA-H2O system. Energ Fuel 2021;35:
Acknowledgement 9509–20.
[25] Wang M, Herzog HJ, Hatton TA. CO2 capture using electrochemically mediated
smine regeneration. Ind Eng Chem Res 2020;59:7087–96.
Financial supports of the National Natural Science Foundation of [26] Wu XM, Mao YH, Fan HF, Sultan S, Yu YS, Zhang ZX. Investigation on the
China (Nos. 52106209 and 52376208) are gratefully acknowledged. performance of EDA-based blended solvents for electrochemically mediated CO2
This work is also supported by the China Postdoctoral Science Founda capture. Appl Energ 2023;349.
[27] Ahmad Hassan AR, Aleta Prince, Afshari Mohsen, Kalantari Elmira, Yuanyuan
tion (2023M742785), State-funded Postdoctoral Researcher Program of Fang M, Rahimi Mim. Reviving the absorbent chemistry of electrochemically
China (GZC20232094), and the Programme of Introducing Talents of mediated amine regeneration for improved point source carbon capture. Chem Eng
Discipline to Universities (B23025). J 2024;484:149566.
[28] Rahimi M, Zucchelli F, Puccini M, Hatton TA. Improved CO2 capture performance
of electrochemically mediated amine regeneration processes with ionic surfactant
Data availability additives. Acs Appl Energ Mater 2020;3:10823–30.
[29] Wu XM, Fan HF, Mao YH, Zhang T, Sultan S, Yu YS, et al. Comparative
performance evaluation of absorbents for the electrowinning-coupled competitive
Data will be made available on request. separation CO2 capture process. Acs Sustain Chem Eng 2024;12:2080–91.
[30] Wang M, Hatton TA. Flue gas CO2 capture via electrochemically mediated amine
References regeneration: desorption unit design and analysis. Ind Eng Chem Res 2020;59:
10120–9.
[31] Wang M, Hariharan S, Shaw RA, Hatton TA. Energetics of electrochemically
[1] Yang N, Kang F, Zhang K, Zhou YL, Lin WF. A strategy for CO2 capture and
mediated amine regeneration process for flue gas CO2 capture. Int J Greenh Gas
utilization towards methanol production at industrial scale: an integrated highly
Con 2019;82:48–58.
efficient process based on multi-criteria assessment. Energ Convers Manage 2023;
[32] Wang M, Shaw R, Gencer E, Hatton TA. Technoeconomic analysis of the
293.
electrochemically mediated amine regeneration CO2 capture process. Ind Eng
[2] Hu X, Liu L, Luo X, Xiao G, Shiko E, Zhang R, et al. A review of N-functionalized
Chem Res 2020;59:14085–95.
solid adsorbents for post-combustion CO2 capture. Appl Energ 2020;260.
[33] Gelpi M, García-Ben J, Rodríguez-Hermida S, López-Beceiro J, Artiaga R,
[3] IEA. CO2 Emissions in 2023. Paris: IEA; 2024.
Baaliña A, et al. Empowering CO2 eco-refrigeration with colossal breathing-caloric-
[4] Witze A. Earth boiled in 2023-will it happen again in 2024? Nature 2024;625:
like effects in MOF-508b. Adv Mater 2023.
637–9.
[34] Malekli M, Aslani A. A novel post-combustion CO2 capture design integrated with
[5] Klinsky S, Sagar A. Build capacity for climate action. Science 2023;382:979.
an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC). Process Saf Environ 2022;168:942–52.
[6] Leclaire J, Heldebrant DJ, Grubel K, Septavaux J, Hennebelle M, Walter E, et al.
[35] Nguyen TBH, Zondervan E. Ionic liquid as a selective capture method of CO2 from
Tetrameric self-assembling of water-lean solvents enables carbamate anhydride-
different sources: comparison with MEA. Acs Sustain Chem Eng 2018;6:4845–53.
based CO2 capture chemistry. Nat Chem 2024.
[36] Pivac I, Pavasovic AS, Barbir F. Recent advances and perspectives in diagnostics
[7] Liu L, Chen H, Shiko E, Fan X, Zhou Y, Zhang G, et al. Low-cost DETA impregnation
and degradation of electrochemical hydrogen compressors. Int J Hydrogen Energ
of acid-activated sepiolite for CO2 capture. Chem Eng J 2018;353:940–8.
2024;54:387–96.
[8] Kim S, Lim YI, Lee D, Cho W, Seo MW, Lee JG, et al. Perspectives of oxy-coal power
[37] Chu XM, Liu ZQ, Gao H, Geng K, Liu SJ, Xing XT, et al. Promising candidates of
plants equipped with CO2 capture, utilization, and storage in terms of energy,
ether-free backbone comb-shaped sulfonated poly (oxindole biphenylene)
economic, and environmental impacts. Energ Convers Manage 2022;273.
membranes for enhanced electrochemical hydrogen compression performance.
[9] Lee WH, Kin G, Kin JO. Performance of a novel CO2 absorption and reverse
J Membrane Sci 2024;698.
electrodialysis system with different amine solutions for simultaneous energy and
[38] Lee J, Yoon S, Park H, Ju H. Influence of key design variables on the performance
bicarbonate recovery. Energ Convers Manage 2024;314.
and mechanical behavior of an electrochemical hydrogen compressor. J Power
[10] Hu X, Luo X, Xiao G, Yu Q, Cui Y, Zhang G. Low-cost novel silica@polyacrylamide
Sources 2024;594.
composites: fabrication, characterization, and adsorption behavior for cadmium
[39] Prokopou GI, Mödden ML, Mitsos A, Bongartz D. Optimal sizing and operation of
ion in aqueous solution. Adsorption 2020;26:1051–62.
electrochemical hydrogen compression. Chem Eng Sci 2024;293.
[11] Hane MM, Diederichsen KM, Hatton TA. Engineering redox-active
[40] Chouhan A, Aryal UR, Sivakumar PO, Bahar B, Prasad AK. Challenges in the
electrochemically mediated carbon dioxide capture systems. Nat Chem Eng 2023;
electrochemical compression of an ammonia-hydrogen blend. Int J Hydrogen
1:35–44.
Energ 2021;46:37965–76.
[12] Zito AM, Clarke LE, Barlow JM, Bím D, Zhang ZS, Ripley KM, et al. Electrochemical
[41] Tao Y, Hwang YH, Radermacher R, Wang CS. Experimental study on
carbon dioxide capture and concentration. Chem Rev 2023;123:8069–98.
electrochemical compression of ammonia and carbon dioxide for vapor
[13] Sun KG, Tebyetekerwa M, Zhang HX, Zeng XK, Wang ZY, Xu Z, et al. Electrode,
compression refrigeration system. Int J Refrig 2019;104:180–8.
electrolyte, and membrane materials for electrochemical CO2 capture. Adv Energy
[42] Shaw RA, Hatton TA. Electrochemical CO2 capture thermodynamics. Int J Greenh
Mater 2024.
Gas Con 2020;95.
[14] Sharifian R, Wagterveld RM, Digdaya IA, Xiang C, Vermaas DA. Electrochemical
[43] Li KK, van der Poel P, Conway W, Jiang KQ, Puxty G, Yu H, et al. Mechanism
carbon dioxide capture to close the carbon cycle. Energ Environ Sci 2021;14:
investigation of advanced metal-ion-mediated amine regeneration: a novel
781–814.
pathway to reducing CO2 reaction enthalpy in amine-based CO2 capture. Environ
[15] Seo H, Nitzsche MP, Hatton TA. Redox-mediated pH swing systems for
Sci Technol 2018;52:14538–46.
electrochemical carbon capture. Accounts Chem Res 2023;56:3153–64.
[44] Sander R, Acree WE, De Visscher A, Schwartz SE, Wallington TJ. Henry’s law
[16] Xu Y, Zheng MZ, Musgrave CB, Zhang LY, Goddard WIII, Bukowski BC, et al.
constants (IUPAC Recommendations 2021). Pure Appl Chem 2022;94:71–85.
Assessing the kinetics of quinone-CO2 adduct formation for electrochemically
[45] Hasanzadeh A, Holagh SG, Janbazvatan M, Rashidpour H, Chitsaz A, Khalilian M.
mediated carbon capture. Acs Sustain Chem Eng 2023;11:11333–41.
Electrochemically mediated amine regeneration and proton concentration
[17] Bilal M, Li JJ, Guo H, Landskron K. High-voltage supercapacitive swing adsorption
modulation processes for flue gas CO2 capture: comparison and artificial
of carbon dioxide. Small 2023;19.
intelligence-based optimization. J CO2 Util 2023;67.
[18] Zhang G, Liu L, Shiko E, Cheng Y, Zhang R, Zeng Z, et al. Low-price MnO2 loaded
[46] Shaw RA. Modeling and design for electrochemical carbon dioxide capture
sepiolite for Cd2+ capture. Adsorption 2019;25:1271–83.
systems. Ph.D. Thesis. Massachusetts Institute of Technology; 2019.
[19] Li KK. Power generation from acid-gas pollutants treatment. ChemEng J 2023;462.
[47] Renfrew SE, Starr DE, Strasser P. Electrochemical approaches toward CO2 capture
[20] Martell AE. Critical Stability Constants: Volume 2. 2011.
and concentration. Acs Catal 2020;10:13058–74.
[21] Wu XM, Fan HF, Mao YH, Sharif M, Yu YS, Zhang ZX, et al. Systematic study of an
[48] Stern MC, Hatton TA. Bench-scale demonstration of CO2 capture with
energy efficient MEA-based electrochemical CO2 capture process: From mechanism
electrochemically-mediated amine regeneration. Rsc Adv 2014;4:5906–14.
to practical application. Appl Energ 2022;327.
[22] Fan HF, Mao YH, Wang HX, Yu YS, Wu XM, Zhang ZX. Performance comparation of
MEA and EDA in electrochemically-mediated amine regeneration for CO2 capture.
Sep Purif Technol 2023;311.
11