MT4761 Lecture Note 3 2024
MT4761 Lecture Note 3 2024
Point defects in metals are electrically neutral whereas in ionic oxides, these are
electrically charged. The migration of the ionic defects plays a crucial role in the
conduction in ceramic materials that happens via an atomistic process called as
diffusion. Diffusivity of species in the materials is also related to their physical properties
such as electrical conductivity and mobility.
The conductivity in ceramics is a sum of ionic and electronic conductivity and the ratio
of the two determines the applicability of ceramic materials for applications. Understanding
the temperature dependence of conductivity via a simple atomistic model leading to
the same conclusions as predicted by the diffusivity model.
The conducting glasses and fast ion conductors are important materials of for a variety
of applications. Presence of charged defects in ceramics also means the existence of
electrical potential gradients, in addition to the chemical gradient, which results in a
unified equation for electrochemical potential called Nernst Equation which is used to
design oxygen sensors in automobile exhaust.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 1
DEFECTS
Materials in general consist of defects which can be divided into a variety of categories such as point
defects or 0-D defects, line defects or 1-D defects and 2-D or surface defects. These defects play
an important role in determining the properties of ceramic materials and in this context, the role of
point defects is extremely important.
Point Defects :
Point defects are caused due to deviations from the perfect atomic arrangement or
stoichiometry. These could be missing lattice ions from their positions, interstitial ions or
substitutional ions (or impurities) and valence electrons and/or holes.
Usually, point defects in metals are electrically neutral whereas in ionic oxides, these are
electrically charged.
Ionic defects
• Occupy lattice positions
• Can be either of vacancies, interstitial ions, impurities and substitutional ions
Electronic defects
• Deviations from a ground state electron orbital configuration give rise to such defects when
valence electrons are excited into higher energy orbitals/ levels and lead to formation of
electron or holes. MT4760/ SUA/2024 2
Kroger–Vink notation in a metal oxide, (MO)
Regular Sites
MT4760/ SUA/2024 3
MT4760/ SUA/2024 4
Defect Reactions
Rules for writing defect reactions
• Ratio of regular cation and anion sites is always constant.
• Mass balance to be preserved.
• Electrical neutrality is to be always preserved.
Both ionic and electronic defect compensations are possible determined by the energetics.
Assume complete ionization of defects.
Among all of these, the first two are most important as these are regularly seen in many important
oxides. The first is called Schottky disorder while the second is called as Frenkel disorder.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 5
MT4760/ SUA/2024 6
Schottky Disorder
This defect normally forms at the outer or inner surfaces or dislocations.
It eventually diffuses into the crystal unit as equilibrium is reached.
The defect reaction is written as 0 (or Null) VM‘’+ V0••
This defect is preferred when cations and anions are of
comparable sizes.
Examples are rocksalt structured compounds such as NaCl, MgO,
Corundum, Rutile etc..
Schottky Disorder
Frenkel Disorder
This defect can form inside the crystal.
It forms where cations are appreciably smaller than anions.
Defect reaction is written as
0 VM'' + Mi••
In cases where anions form the disorder, then it is called as Anti-
Frenkel. The corresponding defect reaction in that case would be
0 V0•• + Oi''
Examples of compounds showing this defect are AgBr type
Frenkel Defect
compounds such as AgBr, AgI etc. MT4760/ SUA/2024 7
Extent of Non-Stoichiometry
In highly stoichiometric pure oxides such as MgO, Al2O3, ZrO2, the extent of oxidation or
reduction is very small. These are often characterized by large energy for oxidation or reduction.
Changes in oxygen pressure have very little effect on the defect concentration. When cations are of
fixed valence, the tendency for retaining the stoichiometry is even larger.
Oxides containing multivalent cations, such as transition elements, are much more prone to
be non-stoichiometric. Examples are TiO2+x, BaTiO3-x and SrTiO3-x , where Ti4+ ions can be easily
reduced to Ti3+ creating oxygen deficiency of order 1% within the limits of the stability of oxide i.e.
before decomposition and phase change.
Transition metal mono-oxide series Ni1-xO, Co1-xO, Mn1-xO and Fe1-xO are the oxides in which a
fraction of the divalent cations is easily oxidized to the divalent state resulting in cation deficiency, x .
The deficiency is ~5x10-4 % for Ni1-xO, ~1% for Co1-xO, ~0.1% for Mn1-xO and ~0.15% for Fe1-xO.
FeO is seldom stoichiometric, and it has a minimum nonstoichiometric of 0.05%.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 8
Defect Structures in Non - Stoichiometric Oxides
Mainly of two types Metal Deficient Oxides
i. Oxygen deficient (or excess metal) Formation of either metal vacancies or
ii. Metal deficient (or excess oxygen) oxygen interstitials (excess oxygen)
Nonstoichiometry necessitates presence Formation occurs typically at the surface.
of point defects and extent of non-
stoichiometry determines the
concentration of Defects.
In such oxides, electrical neutrality is
preserved via the formation of point
defects and electronic changes.
Intrinsic ionization is always a possibility.
Oxygen Deficient Oxides
Formation of oxygen vacancies or
metal interstitials or both are In FeO crystal, some of the Fe2+ ions are missing
possible. from the crystal lattice. To maintain the electrical
Formation occurs only at the surface. neutrality, twice the number of other Fe2+ ions in
the crystal is oxidized to Fe3+ ions. In such
cases, overall number of Fe2+ and Fe3+ ions is
less than the O2- ions.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 9
Oxygen Deficient Oxides
Formation of oxygen vacancies or metal interstitials or both are possible. Formation occurs only at the
surface.
Depicted by MO2-x (x is the extent of non-stoichiometry) and overall reaction as MO2 ↔ MO2-x+ x/2 O2↑
MT4760/ SUA/2024 10
If metal interstitials are the dominating defects, then :
M ↔ M Mi •••• + 4 M'M OR
• Electronic compensation leading to the formation of metal interstitials and free electrons
M ↔ MMi•••• + 4e'
Creation of quasi-free electrons (extra charge is represented as M’)
Conduction occurs due to transport of electrons
MT4760/ SUA/2024 11
Electronic Disorder
Unlike intrinsic point defeats, intrinsic electronic defects are optically or thermally created.
This occurs in materials having a forbidden energy gap between conduction and the valence band
and are categorized as semiconductors and insulators.
Defect density is in number per unit volume of the crystal.
Disorder implies elevation of electrons into higher energy levels creating vacant states in
lower energy bands which are called as holes.
• Excitation of electrons across the bandgap into conduction band
• Bandgap (Eg) for semiconductors is typically below 2.5 eV e.g. Si has bandgap of ~1.1
eV whereas for insulators it is typically above 2.5-3 eV.
• The band diagram for a semiconductor or insulator can be seen below.
Diffusion is also related to transport of defects or electronic charge carriers giving rise to
electrical conduction in ceramics. Ionic conductors are used in variety of applications such as
chemical and gas sensors, solid electrolytes and fuel cell. For example, an oxygen sensor
made of ceramic ZrO2 is used in automobiles to optimize the fuel/air ratio in the engines.
Atomic diffusion rates and electrical conductivity are largely governed by defect types and
their concentration where concentration is a function of temperature, partial pressure of
oxygen or pO2 and composition.
Typically diffusion is explained on the basis of compositional gradients in an alloy which act as driving
force for diffusion. Thermodynamically speaking, this amounts to gradient in the chemical potential
which drives the migration of species from regions of higher chemical potential to lower chemical
potential so that system reaches a chemical equilibrium. The atomic flux as a result of driving force is
expressed in terms of chemical composition gradient, also called as Fick’s law(s).
MT4760/ SUA/2024 13
Fick's First Law of Diffusion
It states that atomic flux, under steady-state conditions, is proportional to the concentration
gradient. It can be stated as,
The negative sign on the right-hand side indicates that diffusion takes place from regions of
higher concentration to lower concentration i.e. down the concentration gradient.
Diffusivity is a temperature dependent parameter and is expressed as D = D0 exp (-Q/kT) where Q is the
activation energy, k is Boltzmann's constant and D0 is the pre-exponential factor in cm2 /s.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 14
Fick's Second Law of Diffusion :
Strictly speaking it is not a law, but rather a derivation of the first law itself. It predicts how the
concentration changes as a function of time under non-steady state conditions . It can be derived
from Fick's first law easily.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 15
Temperature Dependence of Diffusivity
Equation explains the thermally activated nature of diffusivity showing an exponential temperature
dependence resulting in significant increase in the diffusivity upon increasing the temperature.
In addition, NaCl will also have certain intrinsic sodium and chlorine vacancy concentration (VNa' and VCl• )
due to Schottky dissociation, depending on the temperature.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 16
In such a scenario, the diffusivity of sodium ions is governed by vacancy diffusion and can be worked
out as,
Electrical mobility
Chemical mobility
MT4760/ SUA/2024 18
For atomic transport, Einstein first pointed out that the most general driving force is the virtual force
that acts on a diffusing atom or species and is due to negative gradient of the chemical potential or
partial molar free energy. It is expressed as,
Where μi is the chemical potential of i and NA is the
Avogadro's Number.
To obtain the relation between mobility and diffusivity of species, i, we need to write the flux in a
general form as a product of concentration, ci, and velocity, vi, i.e.
If we compare the above equation with Fick's first law, diffusivity of species I can be written as,
As a result, conductivity in the ionic systems also follows a temperature dependent Arhenious
type behavior. MT4760/ SUA/2024 19
Conduction in Ceramics vis-à-vis metallic conducators: General Information
While it is possible to apply Nernst-Einstein's relation to express the motions of both ions and electrons to state the
similarity between electrons and ions, in reality the motion of electrons is quite different.
In metals, semiconductors and high mobility ceramics, the electrons and holes are considered as quasi-free
particles with a drift velocity, vd , acquired under an applied electric field. The extent of this drift velocity is
governed by various scattering phenomenon such as scattering from the lattice.
Effective mass can be taken as equal to that of a free electron i.e. me* = mfree electron. Large polarons typically
depict weak interaction between carries and ions and hence electronic mobility expressions can be valid for the
polaron. MT4760/ SUA/2024 20
In a number of ionic systems such as LiNbO3, COFe2O4, FeO etc., carrier-ion interaction is strong and these
are called as strongly-correlated-systems, In such cases, polarons are of smaller sizes and the effective
mass tends to be larger than that of a free electron.
In such systems, motion of carriers is thermally activated i.e. via hopping mechanism.
For example, Li2O doping in NiO under oxidizing conditions gives rise to oxidation of Ni2+ ions to Ni3+ ions (write
the defect reaction yourself). Mixed presence of Ni ions in +2 and +3 states leads to hopping type conduction of
electrons between two states.
Ni3+ acts as a perturbing charge which polarizes the lattice surrounding it leading the formation of Polaron.
The movement of carrier between these differently charged states can happen by hopping which is a
thermally activated phenomenon.
Conduction in such cases is determined by dopant concentration and hence higher the dopant concentration
(within appropriate limits), higher the conductivity. In contrast, in the band model, carrier concentration is
determined by temperature.
In ionic solids, while carrier concentration is independent of temperature (within extrinsic region), mobility
is strongly affected by temperature
Typically carrier mobilities in strongly interacting ionic systems are of the order of ~0.1 cm2/Vs which are
about 3-4 orders of magnitude smaller as compared to the weakly interacting systems where carrier
mobilities can be between 100-1000 cm2/Vs.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 21
Characteristics of Ionic Conduction
Long range migration of ionic charge carriers, the most mobile species, through the lattice under
application of an electric field for example migration of Na+ ions in soda-silicate glasses.
Dependent on the presence of vacant sites in neighbourhood of mobile defects/ions.
Can occur through grain boundaries such as in polycrystalline ceramics or through the lattice
as in fast ion conductors.
When external field is absent, the thermal energy, kT, is required for counter migration of ions
and vacancies overcoming the migration energy Ea, as shown in Figure, which is nothing but
process of self diffusion.
Ionic conductivity is promoted by
Small ionic size
Small charge i.e. less Coulomb interaction between ions
Favourable lattice geometry
Cations are usually smaller than anions and hence,
they diffuse faster. For example, incase of NaCl,
smaller size of Na+ ion (102 pm) as compared to Cl- ions
(181 pm) makes them diffuse faster.
Schematic diagram showing the lattice ions and
vacancies in a potential well with and without
applied electric field MT4760/ SUA/2024 22
Conduction in Glasses
Glasses have a random 3-D network and contain glass forming agents such as SiO2 , B2O3
,and Al2O3
Interstitial positions are occupied by modifier ions such as Na+ , K+, and Li+ or blocking
ions such as Ca2+ and Mg2+.
Conductivity increases as the temperature increased as barrier for migration for mobile
modifier ions is easily overcome by thermal activation.
Usually as the size of the modifier ion decreases, the conductivity increases.
As the concentration of blocking ions increases, the conductivity decreases.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 23
Fast Ion Conductors
Materials showing very high conductivities, several orders of magnitude higher than normal
ionic solids are called Fast Ion Conductors.
Conductivities greater than 10-2 (W-cm)-1 at temperatures much lower than melting points.
Number of charge carriers is a very large fraction of potentially mobile ions which is significantly
larger than in a normal ionic compound hence ion diffusion is solely governed by the diffusion
energy and hence defect formation energy need not be provided resulting in overall low activation
energy for migration.
Intrinsic FICs
• Halides and Chalcogenides of silver and copper, e.g. - AgI is a silver ion (Ag+ ) conductor
• Alkali metal conductors such as non-stoichiometric aluminates e.g. ß-Al2O3 or Na2O.11Al2O3.
Extrinsic FICs
• Oxides with fluorite structure such as ZrO2 are doped with aliovalent oxides creating a large
number of oxygen vacancies and are called as fast ion conductors such asY2O3.ZrO2. In these
materials the enthalpy of migration, ΔHm , can be as low as ~0.01-0.2.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 24
Ionic conduction in cubic ZrO2
Zirconia, ZrO2, is made stable in cubic form by doping with small amounts, ~8-10%, of aliovalent (the
valence of the substituting ion is different from that required by the site) CaO or type of impurities. Cubic ZrO2 is
considered as a very good and fast ion conductor. Oxygen vacancies, the prevailing defects in Cubic
ZrO2 are created according to,
Small energy of migration (Zi)e of oxygen vacancies results in an unusually high diffusion of oxygen
vacancies in ZrO2
Example: Take the case of Ca0.14 ,Zr0.86, O1.86 . Bandgap of ZrO2 is ~5.2 eV. At high temperatures, the
diffusion coefficient is given as,
You can show that 14% molar concentration of CaO in ZrO2 gives rise to an oxygen vacancy
concentration of ~ 3.9*1021 cm-3.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 25
MT4760/ SUA/2024 26
Now, ionic conductivity can be written as
At 1823 K, electron concentration, ne , using band model, is estimated to be 1.32*1013 cm-3 and electron
mobility, μe , is 24 cm2/V.s
Hence, the electronic conductivity is
From the above analysis it turns out that sionic >> selec
sionic increases only until about 12-13% of CaO doping
MT4760/and then decreases due to increased defect interactions
SUA/2024 27
Conductivity in SrTiO3
Perovskite oxides SrTiO3 and BaTiO3 have two cation sub-lattices onto which aliovalent ions can
substitute. These oxides can also be easily reduced in reducing atmospheres leading creation of
mobile defects. Typically, Ba/Ti or Sr/Ti is approximately very close to 1. Maximum deviation occurs at
temperatures lower than 1200°C and is of the order of ~100ppm.
To promote n-type conductivity in these materials, solutes such La3+, Nb5+, and Ta5+ are added to
BaTiO3, giving rise to shallow donor levels in the bandgap. The defect reaction upon doping with
La or Nb is expressed as,
(3)
In such a situation, either SrO is accepted or TiO2 is rejected to maintain the stoichiometric cation ratio.
The above equation is ionically compensated reaction. It follows that [AlTi'] = 2[V0•] and thus
The electrochemical potential of spices i , denoted as ηi, is the sum of the chemical potential
μi, and electric potential f acting upon it and can be written as,
where Zi is the effective charge and F is Faraday's constant (=96500 Coulomb/mol). Now, virtual force
on the particle is negative gradient of ηi i.e.
MT4760/ SUA/2024
This shows that flux, Ji , is a function of electric field, (df/dx). 30
Nernst Equation and Application of Ionic Conductors
We have seen that the electrochemical potential is a combination of chemical potential and
electrical potential.
Applied chemical potential gradient gives rise to a voltage which is useful in the operation of devices
like batteries, fuel cells, sensors.
Ionic transport is essential for the imposed oxygen pressure gradient to establish a gradient in
the oxygen concentration. Simultaneously, electronic conduction must be avoided to prevent short
circuiting which requires ti ˜ 1. (ti -ionic transference number)
Consider two sides separated by an electrolyte. At equilibrium, the chemical potential of both the
sides is equal, i.e.
Electrical potential across the electrolyte is related to the chemical potential difference by,
MT4760/ SUA/2024 31
Chemical potential can be expressed as
Example:
In automotive applications, usually on one side is air i.e., pO2 is 0.21 atm and the other side is at pO2
of 10-9 - 10-21atm. From the Nernst equation, one can calculate that at 350°C, a voltage
difference, Δf , between 0.25-0.6V will be developed which can be easily monitored and can be
used as the feedback in control system toMT4760/
regulate the fuel supply to the engine.
SUA/2024 32
Examples of Ionic Conductors in Engineering Applications
While heating elements and varistors utilize the electronic conduction properties of the
ceramics, fuel cells and sensors typically utilize ionic conductivity characteristics.
Typically used materials are ZnO and SiC powders bonded in a matrix with an intergranular
layer that is highly resistive. The current-voltage characteristics are governed by the electrical
nature of grain and intergranular layers.
The basic principle of operation is that the material's resistance is high at low voltages and
decreases when voltage is increased, allowing excess currents to pass through thereby
protecting the circuit.
This results in the formation of a space charge depletion layer in the ZnO grains in
the region adjacent to the grain boundaries as shown in the figure. These boundaries
between each grain and its neighbor forms a junction showing diode like
characteristics and allowing flow of current in one direction only.
In the figure ( next slide), the left-hand grain is forward biased by a voltage VL, and the
right side is reverse biased to VR. The respective barrier heights are fL and fR while
the zero biased barrier height is f0. As the voltage bias is increased, fL is decreased
and fR increased, leading to a lowering of the barrier and an increase in conduction.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 35
The whole mass of material resembles an
electrical circuit network with back to back
pair of diodes, with each pair of diode in
parallel with many others. Very small current
flows when a small voltage is applied across
the electrodes which is mainly caused by
reverse leakage through the diode
junctions. When voltages are high enough
to cause break down of the diode junction,
large currents flow due to thermionic
emission as well as tunneling, as seen in the
Schematic of the electronic above graph.
structure of ZnO grain and
intergranular layer (note the bias on
the grains)
MT4760/ SUA/2024 36
Solid Oxide Fuel Cells (SOFC)
SOFCs are useful as electrochemical conversion devices in which oxidation of fuel leads to
production of electricity.
Schematic of such a device is shown in Figure where two electrodes, anode and cathode,
are separated by an electrolyte e.g. CSZ (cubic stabilized Zirconia with 8-10 mol% Y2O3).
This device can usually work with an efficiency of ~60% at 1000 oC with an output power of
100 kWh.
The device can be used in a wide range of oxygen partial pressures (~1 atm to 10-20 atm) and
can work at temperatures between 700-1000oC with areal resistance of ~ 15μΩm-2 .
Anode material is typically porous Ni and cathode is a porous p-type semiconducting oxide
such as La1-x Srx MnO3+y .
One needs to connect many of these devices together to obtain substantial power and for that
purpose, interconnects are used which are typically made of Ca, Mg or Sr doped LaCrO3 or
stainless steel depending upon the operation temperature.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 37
Ceramic Electrolyte
The electrolyte is ZrO2 (zirconia) doped with 8-10 mole% of Y2O3 (yittria).
When yittria is mixed with zirconia, some Y 3+ replaces Zr 4+ in the fluorite type crystal
structure.
Number of oxide ion sites become vacant because three O2- replace four O2- when two Zr4+
are replaced by two Y3+ in the lattice.
The mobile ionic species within the electrolyte in the SOFC system are the O2- ions. At
high temperatures, the O 2- ions move across the electrolyte via vacant lattice sites.
Processing Techniques
• Dry pressing
• Tape Casting
• Screen printing
• Slurry Coating
MT4760/ SUA/2024 38
Schematic of (a) a SOFC
device and (b) operation
of a SOFC device
In case of H2 and CO gases
as fuels, the following
reactions take place at two
electrodes, as shown in
Figure.
Conductivity in the ionic systems also follows a temperature dependent Arhenious type behavior. In ionic
systems, to utilize the ionic conduction of materials, it is essential that ionic conductivity is a dominant
contribution towards the total conductivity which typically happens at either higher temperatures or at
reasonably high doping levels unless the electron concentration is extremely low. The examples of
ceramic materials with high ionic conductivity are materials like fast ion conductors and a few ceramic glasses.
The presence of composition gradients of charged defects also leads to electrical potential gradients and
this when combined with the chemical potential gradients, gives rise to an expression for electro chemical-
potential, called Nernst equation. This equation is often employed in designing the sensors for use in
automotives where differential pO2 gives rise to a voltage which can be used as a feedback to regulate the
fuel/air supply in the engines. Ceramic conductors are used in a variety of applications, for example, ZnO as
varistors, doped ZrO2 as solid electrolytes in fuel cells and as oxygen sensors in the automobile exhaust.
MT4760/ SUA/2024 43