5.Pre-Sankara Philosophy B
5.Pre-Sankara Philosophy B
Pre-Sankara Philosophy
Gaudapāda (600 A.D.)
• There are four stages of the Atman: Waking condition, dream state, dreamless
sleep and non-dual intuitive self.
• It sleeps under the influence of beginningless Maya or cosmic nescience and belive
itself to be real.
•Gaudapada argues that empirical objects are the subjective creations of the mind.
Negatively, it means that the world, being only an appearance, is in fact never
created. Positively, it means that the absolute, being self-existent, is never created.
• Gaudapada examines the various theories of creation and rejects them all.
Gaudapāda (600 A.D.)
• Reality is the Pure Self which is Pure Consciousness and which is at the
background of everything.
• Those who see the creation of the individual self or of the external object see the
foot-prints of birds in the sky.
• God is Brahman associated with Maya. He imagines the multiple world and
souls by his own power of Maya.
Prasthana Trayi
•The texts comprising the Prasthana Trayi are the Upanishads, the Bhagavadgita and
the Brahma Sutra.
•The Upanishads are the sruti prasthana, the revealed texts (sruti - that which is
heard)
•The Bhagavadgita is the smriti prasthana, composed by sages based on their
understanding of the Vedas (smriti - that which is remembered).
•The Brahma Sutra is the nyaya prasthana, the logical text that sets forth the
philosophy systematically (nyaya - logic/order)
•No study of Vedanta is considered complete without a close examination of the
Prasthana Trayi.
•The systematic treaties is written in short aphorisms called Sutras.
• Sutra should be concise and unambiguous, give the essence of the arguments on a
topic but at the same time deal with all aspects of the question, be free from
repetition and faultless.
•Sutra gave rise of various kind of literary writings like Vakyas, Vrttis, Karikas and
Bhasyas, each of them being more and more elaborate than the previous ones.
Brahma-Sutra
•The Upanisads do not contain any ready-made consistent system of thought.
• Sankara: Monism
• Ramanuja: Visistadvaita or qualified monism
• Nimbarka: Bhedabhedavada or theory of difference and non-difference
• Madhva: Dualism
• Vallabha: Suddhadvaitavada
Brahma-Sutra
Athato Brahmajijnasa
Atha: now, then, afterwards; Atah: therefore; Brahmajijnasa: a desire for the
knowledge of Brahman (the enquiry into the real nature of Brahman).
Brahma-Sutra
•Atha i.e., after the attainment of certain preliminary qualifications such as the four
means of salvation.
•(1) Nitya-anitya-vastuviveka (discrimination between the eternal and the non-
eternal)
•(2)Ihamutrarthaphalabhogaviraga (in difference to the enjoyment in this life or in
heaven, and of the fruits of one’s actions)
•(3) Shatsampat (Sama—control of mind, Dama—control of the external senses,
Uparati—cessation from worldly enjoyments or not thinking of objects of senses or
discontinuance of religious ceremonies, Titiksha—endurance of pleasure and pain,
heat and cold, Sraddha—faith in the words of the preceptor and of the Upanishads
and Samadhana—deep concentration)
• (4) Mumukshutva (desire for liberation).
•