Solution Manual for Database Concepts, 6/E 6th Edition : 0132742926 - Read Now Or Download For A Complete Experience
Solution Manual for Database Concepts, 6/E 6th Edition : 0132742926 - Read Now Or Download For A Complete Experience
http://testbankbell.com/product/solution-manual-for-fundamentals-of-
database-systems-6-e-6th-edition-0136086209/
http://testbankbell.com/product/solution-manual-for-database-
concepts-9th-edition-kroenke/
http://testbankbell.com/product/test-bank-for-database-concepts-6th-
edition-kroenke/
http://testbankbell.com/product/test-bank-for-sociology-13th-edition-
by-macionis/
Test Bank for Project Management: Achieving Competitive
Advantage 4th Edition Pinto
http://testbankbell.com/product/test-bank-for-project-management-
achieving-competitive-advantage-4th-edition-pinto/
http://testbankbell.com/product/solution-manual-for-earth-portrait-of-
a-planet-sixth-edition-sixth-edition/
http://testbankbell.com/product/corporate-finance-the-core-4th-
edition-berk-test-bank/
http://testbankbell.com/product/c-programming-from-problem-analysis-
to-program-design-8th-edition-malik-solutions-manual/
http://testbankbell.com/product/society-the-basics-macionis-13th-
edition-test-bank/
Test Bank for Principles of Auditing and Other Assurance
Services, 17th Edition: Whittington
http://testbankbell.com/product/test-bank-for-principles-of-auditing-
and-other-assurance-services-17th-edition-whittington/
Solution Manual for Database Concepts, 6/E
6th Edition : 0132742926
full chapter at:
https://testbankbell.com/product/solution-
manual-for-database-concepts-6-e-6th-edition-
0132742926/
Database Concepts
Sixth Edition
David M. Kroenke • David J. Auer
Instructor’s Manual
Prepared by David J. Auer
CHAPTER TWO
THE RELATIONAL MODEL
Page 1 of 35
Page 2 of 35
Instructor’s Manual to accompany:
© 2013, 2011, 2010, 2008 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall
Page 3 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
Learn the conceptual foundation of the relational model
Understand how relations differ from nonrelational tables
Learn basic relational terminology
Learn the meaning and importance of keys, foreign keys, and related terminology
Understand how foreign keys represent relationships
Learn the purpose and use of surrogate keys
Learn the meaning of functional dependencies
Learn to apply a process for normalizing relations
CHAPTER ERRATA
There are no known errors at this time. Any errors that are discovered in the future will
be reported and corrected in the Online DBC e06 Errata document, which will be
available at http://www.pearsonhighered.com/kroenke.
TEACHING SUGGESTIONS
The Art Course database discussed in Chapter 1 is a good database to use for an in-
class demo of the concepts in this chapter. The DBMS screenshots in Chapter 2 use
that database as the example database. For example, see Figure 2-7, 2-8 and 2-9.
See the list, data and database files supplied, and use the following:
MS Access:
DBC-e06-Art-Course-Database-CH01.accdb
DBC-e06-MSSQL-Art-Course-Database-Create-Tables.sql
DBC-e06-MSSQL-Art-Course-Database-Insert-Data.sql
Page 4 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
DBC-e06-ODB-Art-Course-Database-Create-Tables.sql
DBC-e06-ODB-Art-Course-Database-Insert-Data.sql
DBC-e06-ODB-Art-Course-Database-SQL-Queries-CH01.sql
MySQL 5.5:
DBC-e06-MySQL-Art-Course-Database-Create-Tables.sql
DBC-e06-MySQL-Art-Course-Database-Insert-Data.sql
The goal of this chapter is to present an overview of the major elements of the
relational model. This includes the definition of a relation, important terminology, the
use of surrogate keys, and basic design principles.
Students often misconstrue the statement that only a single element is allowed in a
cell to mean that the cells must be fixed in length. One can have a variable length
memo in a cell but that is considered, semantically, to be one thing. By the way,
there are a number of reasons for this restriction. Perhaps the easiest to explain is
that SQL has no means for addressing sub-elements in a cell.
When students execute SQL SELECTs, they may generate relations with duplicate
rows. Such results do not fit the definition of relations, but they are considered
relations nonetheless. This is a good example of “theory versus practice”.
You may want to emphasize that foreign keys and the primary key that they
reference need not have the same name. They must, however, have the same
underlying set of values (domain). This means that the values not just look the
same; it means that the values mean the same thing. A foreign key of CatName and
a foreign key of ValentineNickName might look the same, but they do not mean the
same thing. Using ValentineNickName as a foreign key to Name in the relation CAT
would result in some weird results.
Referential integrity constraints are important. You might ask the students to think of
an example when a foreign key does not have a referential integrity constraint
(answer: whenever a parent row is optional, say, STUDENTs need not have an
ADVISER).
We favor the use of surrogate keys. Unless there is a natural, numeric ID (like
PartNumber), we almost always add a surrogate key to our database designs.
Sometimes a surrogate key will be added even if there is a natural, numeric ID for
consistency. Surrogate keys can cause problems (primarily patching up foreign
keys) if the database imports data from other databases that either do not employ a
surrogate key or use a different one. In some cases, institutions have developed
policies for ensuring that surrogate keys are unique globally. It’s probably best for
the students to get into the habit of using them and consider not using them as an
exception. Professional opinions vary on this, however.
Page 5 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
If you’re using Oracle Database, then you’ll need to teach the use of sequences to
implement surrogate keys. Sequences are an awkward solution to this problem,
however, and may be why surrogate keys are less used in the Oracle-world. Maybe
there will be a better solution to them from Oracle in the future.
The discussion of functional dependencies is critical—maybe the most important in
the book. If students can understand that all tables do is record “data points” of
functional dependencies, then normalization will be easier and seem more natural.
In physics, because there are formulae like F = ma, we need not store tables and
tables of data recording data points for force, mass, and acceleration. The formula
suffices for all data points. However, there is no formula for computing how much a
customer of, say, American Airlines, owes for his or her ticket from New York to
Houston. If we could say the cost of an airline ticket was $.05 per mile, then we
could compute the cost of a ticket, and tables of airline flight prices would be
unnecessary. But, we cannot; it all depends on … So, we store the data points for
functional dependencies in tables.
This chapter presents the design principle that every determinant should be a
candidate key. This is, of course, the definition of Boyce-Codd Normal Form. This
leaves out 4NF, 5NF, and domain/key normal form. At this level, we do not think
those omissions are critical. See the normalization discussion in Chapter 5 for more
on this topic.
If we use domain/key normal form as the ultimate, then, insofar as functional
dependencies are concerned, the domain/key definition that “every constraint is a
logical consequence of domains and keys,” comes down to Boyce-Codd Normal
Form. Therefore, we proceed on good theoretical ground with the discussion as
presented in this chapter.
Students should understand three ambiguities in a null value. This understanding
will help them comprehend the issues addressed by INNER and OUTER joins in the
next chapter.
Exercises 2.40 and 2.41 deal with multivalued dependencies and fourth normal form
(4NF). These are instructive as they show students how to deal with situations
where the value of one column in a table is associated with several values of another
attribute in (at least initially) the same table. This is an important concept, and after
BCNF it is the next important concept students need to understand about
normalization.
Page 6 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
It is the single most important standard in database processing and is used for the design and
implementation of almost every commercial database worldwide.
2.2 Define the term entity and give an example of an entity (other than the one from this
chapter).
Entity is the formal name for a “thing” that is being tracked in a database, and is defined as
something of importance to the user that needs to be represented in the database.
Example: TEXTBOOK
2.5 Give an example of a table that is not a relation (other than one from this chapter).
A table is not a relation when there are multiple author names in the Authors column.
It can be of a variable length, if that attribute is considered to be a single thing like a memo or
other variable length data item.
2.7 Explain the use of the terms file, record, and field.
These terms are synonyms for table, row, and column. These terms, however, generally refer to
pre-relational bases.
Page 7 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
2.8 Explain the use of the terms relation, tuple, and attribute.
These terms are synonyms for table, row, and column. These terms, however, are the ones
used in relational database theory.
When manipulating a relation with a DBMS we may end up with duplicate rows. Although in
theory we should eliminate the duplicates, in practice this is often not done.
A unique key is a column whose values identify one and only one row.
A nonunique key not only identifies a row, but it potentially identifies more than one row.
2.13 Explain the difference between a primary key and a candidate key.
Both are unique identifiers. One is chosen to be the identifier for the relation and for foreign
keys based on the relation. The other could be chosen as well, but since it is not, it is called a
candidate.
to identify a row.
to represent the row in foreign keys.
to organize storage for the relation.
as a basis for indexes and other structures to facilitate searching in storage.
Page 8 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
2.15 What is a surrogate key, and under what circumstances would you use one?
A surrogate key is a unique, numeric identifier that is appended to a relation to serve as the
primary key.
2.17 Why are the values of surrogate keys normally hidden from users on forms, queries, and
reports?
Surrogate keys are normally hidden because they usually have no meaning to the users.
A foreign key creates the relationship between the tables; its key value corresponds to a primary
key in a relation other than the one where the key is a primary key.
2.19 Explain how primary keys and foreign keys are denoted in this book.
2.20 Define the term referential integrity constraint and give an example of one.
Referential integrity constraint is a rule specifying that every value of a foreign key matches a
value of the primary key.
Page 9 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
2.22 Give an example of a null value (other than one from this chapter), and explain each of
the three possible interpretations for that value.
An example of null value would be: Null value for the attribute DeceasedDate in the table
SUBSCRIBER.
The subscriber may be a corporation and a value is inappropriate.
The subscriber may be alive, and the value is known to be blank.
The subscriber may be dead, but the date of death is unknown, and the value is
appropriate, but not none.
2.23 Define the terms functional dependency and determinant, using an example not from
this book.
A functional dependency is a logical relationship in which the value of one item in the
relationship can be determined by knowing the value of the other item.
This means that if the ISBN (of a textbook) is known, then we will also know (can determine) the
title. The item on the left—the one whose value is known—is called the determinant.
2.24 In the following equation, name the functional dependency and identify the
determinant(s):
Note this is different than saying “Length and Width are the determinants”.
A → (B, C)
A→B
and
A→C
Page 10 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
A → (B, C)
A → B and A → C
(D, E) → F
Given this expression, tell if it is also true that:
D→F
and
E→F
The functional dependency:
(D, E) → F
means that values of the pair (D, E) determine the value of F.
No, it is not true that
D → F and E → F
2.27 Explain the differences in your answers to questions 2.25 and 2.26.
Page 11 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
A primary key is one or more attributes that functionally determines all of the other attributes.
2.29 If you assume that a relation has no duplicate data, how do you know there is always at
least one primary key?
Because the collection of all the attributes in the relation can identify a unique row.
2.30 How does your answer to question 2.29 change if you allow a relation to have duplicate
data?
It doesn’t work—such tables do not have a primary key.
2.31 In your own words, describe the nature and purpose of the normalization process.
The purpose of the normalization process is to prevent update problems in the tables (relations)
in the database. The nature of the normalization process is that we break up relations as
necessary to ensure that every determinant is a candidate key.
2.32 Examine the data in the Veterinary Office List—Version One in Figure 1-30 (see page
52), and state assumptions about functional dependencies in that table. What is the
danger of making such conclusions on the basis of sample data?
PetName → (PetType, PetBreed, PetDOB, OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName,
OwnerPhone, OwnerEmail)
OwnerEmail → (OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName, OwnerPhone)
OwnerPhone → (OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName, OwnerEmail)
The danger is that there may be possibilities not apparent from sample data. For example, two
owners might have pets with the same name.
2.33 Using the assumptions you stated in your answer to question 2.32, what are the
determinants of this relation? What attribute(s) can be the primary key of this relation?
Attributes that can be the primary key are called candidate keys.
Determinants: PetName, OwnerEmail, OwnerPhone
Candidate keys: PetName
2.34 Describe a modification problem that occurs when changing data in the relation in
question 2.32 and a second modification problem that occurs when deleting data in this
relation.
Page 12 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
2.35 Examine the data in the Veterinary Office List—Version Two in Figure 1-31 (see page
52), and state assumptions about functional dependencies in that table.
2.36 Using the assumptions you stated in your answer to question 2.35, what are the
determinants of this relation? What attribute(s) can be the primary key of this relation?
Determinants: PetName, OwnerEmail, OwnerPhone, (PetName, Date)
Candidate keys: (PetName, Date)
2.37 Explain a modification problem that occurs when changing data in the relation in
question 2.35 and a second modification problem that occurs when deleting data in this
relation.
Same as 2.34:
Changes to owner data may need to be made in several rows.
Deleting data for the last pet of an owner deletes owner data as well.
ANSWERS TO EXERCISES
2.38 Apply the normalization process to the Veterinary Office List—Version One relation
shown in Figure 1-30 (see page 52) to develop a set of normalized relations. Show the
results of each of the steps in the normalization process.
STEP ONE:
PET-AND-OWNER (PetName, PetType, PetBreed, PetDOB, OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName,
OwnerPhone, OwnerEmail)
Functional Dependencies:
PetName → (PetType, PetBreed, PetDOB, OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName,
OwnerPhone, OwnerEmail)
OwnerEmail → (OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName, OwnerPhone)
OwnerPhone → (OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName, OwnerEmail)
PET-AND-OWNER Candidate Keys: PetName
Page 13 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
STEP TWO:
Break into two relations: OWNER and PET
OWNER (OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName, OwnerPhone, OwnerEmail)
PET (PetName, PetType, PetBreed, PetDOB, {Foreign Key})
FOR OWNER:
Functional Dependencies:
OwnerEmail → (OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName, OwnerPhone)
OwnerPhone → (OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName, OwnerEmail)
OWNER Candidate Keys: OwnerPhone, OwnerEmail
Is every determinant a candidate key?
YES—OwnerEmail and OwnerPhone are candidate keys—Normalization complete!
We can choose either candidate key as primary key.
(A) IF WE USE OwnerPhone as primary key, THEN:
OWNER (OwnerPhone, OwnerLastName, OwnerFirstName, OwnerEmail)
PET (PetName, PetType, PetBreed, PetDOB, OwnerPhone)
Functional Dependencies:
PetName → (PetType, PetBreed, PetDOB, OwnerPhone)
PET Candidate Keys: PetName
Is every determinant a candidate key?
YES—PetName is a candidate key—Normalization complete!
FINAL NORMALIZED REALTIONS:
Page 14 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
STEP ONE:
PET-AND-OWNER (PetName, PetType, PetBreed, PetDOB, OwnerLastName,
OwnerFirstName, OwnerPhone, OwnerEmail, Service, Date, Charge)
Functional Dependencies:
Page 15 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
Page 16 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
Assume that the values of SiblingName are the names of all of a given student’s
brothers and sisters; also assume that students have at most one major.
A. Show an example of this relation for two students, one of whom has three
siblings and the other of whom has only two siblings.
D. Explain why this relation does not meet the relational design criteria set out in
this chapter (i.e., why this is not a well-formed relation).
Some attributes are functionally dependent on a part of the composite primary key.
Page 17 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
E. Divide this relation into a set of relations that meet the relational design criteria
(that is, that are well formed).
A. Show an example of this relation for two students, one of whom has three
siblings and the other of whom has one sibling. Assume that each student has a
single major.
Page 18 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
B. Show the data changes necessary to add a second major for only the first
student.
C. Based on your answer to part B, show the data changes necessary to add a
second major for the second student.
Page 19 of 35
Chapter Two – The Relational Model
We had to add three rows in the first case—one major for each of the siblings of the
student. If we didn’t do that, it would appear the student has a sibling with one major,
but doesn’t have the sibling as a second major. This is nuts!
If we split STUDENT into two relations, STUDENT and STUDENT-SIBLING, then we get:
Page 20 of 35
Another Random Scribd Document
with Unrelated Content
"Luncheon!" she said, cheerfully, "with strawberries as big as a
teacup, and clotted cream."
I think my mind was on the clotted cream, for I followed her past
one dining-room to a second, a long, low room, full of men. She
pushed me in ahead.
"I—I think it's the wrong room, Poppy," I said. "There's the——"
It was the wrong room, and she knew it. The Sheriff was at the
centre table and near him was a great serving stand, with hot and
cold roasts and joints.
I tried to back out, but at that moment Poppy slammed the door and
locked it.
"Don't yell!" she said to me under her breath, and dropped
something ice-cold down my back. The key!
About half the men started to their feet. Poppy raised a hand.
"Gentlemen," she said, "you need not rise! I have a few things I
would like to say while you finish luncheon. I shall be entirely
orderly. The question of the Suffrage——"
They dodged as if she had been loaded with shrapnel instead of a
speech. They shouted and clamored. They ordered us out. And all
the time the door was locked and the key was down my back.
"Poppy!" I said, clutching her arm. "Poppy, for the love of heaven
——"
She had forgotten me absolutely. When she finally turned her eyes
on me, she never even saw me.
"The door is locked, gentlemen," she said. "Locked and the key
hidden. If you will give me five minutes——"
But they would not listen. The Sheriff sat still and ate his luncheon.
Time might come and time might go, tides flow and ebb, old eras
give way to new—but the British lion must be fed. But once I caught
his eye, and I almost thought it twinkled. Perish the thought! The
old order wink at the new!
They demanded the key. The lunch hour was over. The Assizes
waited. In vain Poppy plead for five minutes to talk.
"After that, I'll turn over the key," she promised.
The only way she could have turned over the key was, of course, to
take me into a corner, stand me on my head and jounce it out! I was
very nervous, I'll confess. No one had laid a hand on Poppy as yet.
She was so young and good looking, and the minute anybody
loomed very close, she turned her baby profile to him and he looked
as if he'd been caught gunning for butterflies.
Finally, however, the noise becoming a tumult, and Poppy and I
forced back against the door; the Lord High Sheriff—which sounds
like Gilbert & Sullivan—approached. The crowd made respectful way
for him.
"Now, young ladies," he said, "this has been an agreeable break in
our long day. But—all pleasant things must end. Open the door,
please."
"Will you give me five minutes?" Poppy demanded. "I'm a tax-payer.
I help to pay the people in this room. I have a right to be heard."
"Open the door," said the Sheriff.
"No."
"Then give up the key, and one of my men——"
I caught his arm. I couldn't stand it another minute. It is all well
enough for Poppy to say it was cowardly, and that the situation was
ours until I gave it away. The key was not down her back.
"Break the lock," I said frantically. "The—the key is where I can't get
it."
He was really twinkling now, but the crowd around was outraged for
him and his dignity.
"You didn't swallow it, did you?" he asked in an undertone.
"It's down the back of my frock," I replied.
Poppy said afterwards that I cried and made a scene and disgraced
her generally. It is not true. If tears came, they were tears of rage.
It is not true that I cried on the Sheriff's breast. I only leaned my
head against his arm for a minute, and he was not angry, for he
patted my shoulder. I am terribly fond of Poppy, but she is not
always reasonable, as you will see.
There had been a great deal of noise. I remember hearing echoes of
the dining-room excitement from the hallway beyond the door, and
some one pounding. They were breaking the lock from the outside.
All the time Poppy was talking in her lovely soft voice. She said:
"Since woman is called on to obey the laws, she ought to have a
voice in making them——"
"Hear, hear!" cried somebody.
"Since she doesn't make them, why should she obey them?"
demanded Poppy, lifting violet eyes to the crowd.
"I didn't make the Ten Commandments," said a voice from the rear
of the room, "but I'll get hell just the same if I break them. What
have you got to say about that?"
Poppy was stumped for once. I believe it was the most humiliating
moment of her public life.
Luckily the lock broke just then, and we were hustled out of the
room. There was a crowd in the hall, and it was most disagreeable. I
expected to be arrested, of course—although I'd been arrested
before, and if one is sensible and eats, it is not so bad—but the
crowd, feeling it had the best of things with the Ten
Commandments, was in high good humor. They let us by without a
word and the Sheriff himself stood on the steps while we got into
our car.
Just as Poppy's chauffeur got the engine started, the landlord ran
out and demanded the key. Poppy told the chauffeur to go on, in a
frantic voice, but he hesitated. All the majesty of British law was
there on the steps, and the gold coach was waiting. Of course, to be
arrested for disturbing the peace with a suffrage speech is one thing,
but theft is another. I threw a pleading glance at the Sheriff, and he
came slowly down the steps. Men with wands kept the crowd back.
The fat coachman with the wig did not turn his head, but the
footman at the coach door leered and avenged his calves. Even
Poppy went a little pale.
"Quick," said the Sheriff, ferociously, in a low tone, "give me
something that looks like a key, and then get away as quickly as you
can."
I opened my pocketbook. The only thing that was even the size of a
key was my smelling salts bottle. So I gave him that, and he covered
it with his big hand. Then, still frowning savagely, he made us a
lordly gesture to move on.
(Have you ever been in the Forum Club building that Poppy
decorated? The staircase walls are wonderful—crowds of women,
poor and old, young and rich with clouds around them and so on, all
ascending toward a saintly person with a key—Saint Peter, or
somebody. Well, the saint is the Sheriff at Guildford, and the key is a
salts bottle, if you look closely.)
We slept at Bournemouth that night. Or rather, we didn't sleep.
Poppy sat up half the night trying to think of an answer to the ten
commandment thing. She said she'd get that again—she felt it—and
what was she to say? I had recovered the key and my good humor
by that time, but I could not help much. Seeing her so disturbed, I
had not the heart to tell her what I suspected. But I was sure that I
had seen Vivian Harcourt on the edge of the crowd at Guildford. It
would have made her furious to think that she was under any sort of
espionage. But Vivian was following us, I felt confident, with enough
money to bail us out if she did anything reckless. He knew her, you
see.
That is why all the rest of it seems so silly. Vivian knew Poppy; he
knew her convictions, and her courage. For him to do the baby thing
later was stupid. And anyhow, if it was hard on him, what was it for
me?
Poppy slept late in the morning, and I got up and went down to the
pier, a melancholy place, wet with morning mist and almost
deserted. There were rows of beach chairs, and bathing machines
and overturned boats littering the beach, and not a soul in sight but
a few fishermen. I sat there and thought of Newport on a bright July
morning, with children and nurses on the sand, and throngs of
people, and white sailboats and nice young men in flannels——I was
awfully homesick for a minute. And it came over me, too, that I had
no particular business helping the Cause in England, and having keys
put down my back, and giving up my gold-topped salts bottle, which
was a present from Basil Ward, when all the time the Cause at home
was fighting just as grimly and much more politely.
Vivian was on the pier, at the very end. He was sitting looking out,
with his finger hooked around his cigarette (which is Cambridge
fashion, I believe, or may be the King does it) and looking very
glum.
"Where is she? In jail?" he demanded.
"She's asleep, poor thing," I said.
He snorted.
"Lots of sleep I've had," he said. "Look here, Madge, is she going to
take her vacation by locking up Sheriffs all along the route? Because
if she is, I'm going back to London."
"I think it very likely," I replied, coldly. "You'd better go back
anyhow; she'll be murderous if she knows she's followed."
He groaned.
"I can't leave her alone, can I?"
"I'm along."
He laughed. It was rude of him.
"You!" he said. "Madge, tell me honestly—where was the key?"
"She put it down my back."
He fairly howled with joy. I hated him. But he calmed before long,
and offered me a cigarette as a peace offering. I declined.
"You'd better go along," he said. "She may need the—back again.
Madge, is there any chance for me with her?"
"Well, she likes you, when you are not in the way."
"I'd be in the way now, I suppose, if I turned up to-night at—where
do you stop?"
"At Torquay. Look here, Vivian, I've just thought of something. She's
put out about a thing a man said yesterday. She wants an answer.
She's got arguments, but what she wants is a retort—about six
words and smart. If you could give her one, she'd probably forgive
you hanging around, and all that."
So I told him about the ten commandments and Poppy knowing
she'd get it again and sitting up to worry it out. He said it was easy.
He'd have something to break his appearance at Torquay. But it
wasn't as easy as it seemed at first. I left him sitting there, looking
out to sea, with a notebook on his knee. He called after me that he'd
follow us, a few miles behind, but he wouldn't turn up until he had
thought of something worth while.
According to Basil, it was he who finally thought of something. It
seems that Vivian wrote out pages of a reply, saying that if the
questioner compared man-made law with the ten commandments,
then he made Parliament and the House of Lords divine, and that
this was a reductio ad absurdum, which is Greek or something for
ridiculous. But he almost went mad trying to make it short, and it
wasn't funny at all. Whereas, as he knew very well, the only chance
the speaker had, in such a case, was to get a laugh. What he really
needed was a retort, not a reply.
We made rather slow progress. In the first place, Poppy learned that
the chauffeur, who was a new one and quite intelligent, was not in
favour of suffrage, and for hours we crawled along, while she argued
with him. And in the second place, we stopped frequently to nail up
posters along the roadside. Vivian said later that he trailed us quite
easily, and that there were times when he was only one curve in the
road behind. He used to get out and putter over the engine to pass
the time and let us get ahead. He did not appear at Torquay, so I
knew he wasn't getting along well with the ten commandments.
But except being put out of a hotel at Exeter for discovering a
member of Parliament there, in bed with the gout, and flinging some
handbills in through the transom, the rest of the trip was very
peaceful. Dartmoor put Poppy into a trance; the heather was in
bloom, and she made sketches and colour bits, and lay back in the
car in a sort of dream, planning the next winter's work.
She was irritable when she was disturbed, too. The creative instinct
is a queer thing. Once Bootles, the chauffeur, asked her a question
when she was trying to catch some combination or other, and she
answered him sharply.
"When the women go to vote, Miss," he said, turning around and
touching his cap, "who is going to mind the children?"
"We intend to establish a messenger service," said Poppy, with a
crayon in her mouth.
"A messenger service?" Bootles' eyes stuck out.
"Yes. To summon the fathers home from the pubs to hold the
babies."
(A "pub" of course is an English saloon.)
The T. C. matter was still bothering Poppy at intervals. She knew as
well as anyone that she needed a laugh in her retort, and as you
have seen, Poppy is too earnest to be funny. I said this to Basil Ward
the night we got to Tintagel.
Poppy was tired, and went to bed early. I walked out on the terrace,
and Basil was there. He said Viv had sent for him on the T. C. matter,
and he had something in view.
"He gave it up, poor chap," he said. "He isn't humorous, you know.
As a matter of fact, he and Poppy are both so bally serious that it
makes me wonder how they'll hit it off."
"If she's as earnest about matrimony as she is about Suffrage," I
said, "she'll be a sincere wife."
Basil said nothing. We had walked out to the edge of the cliff, and
were leaning against the rough stone parapet.
"It's rather nice, isn't it," he said suddenly. "Here we are, almost at
Land's End, and the old Atlantic—Madge, will you give me a perfectly
honest answer to a question?"
I braced myself.
"Yes."
"Did you stay over here in England because your whole heart is in
the Cause?"
"Ye—es."
"Your whole heart?"
"Our motives are always mixed, Basil," I said kindly. "It would have
been awfully silly to have endured that miserable spring and not
have stayed for June and July."
"You get a great many cablegrams from America."
"That," I said, with dignity, "is of course my own affair."
"About the Cause?"
"Not—always."
"From a man, of course."
"Yes," I said sweetly, and went back to the hotel.
I broke the news to Poppy about Vivian and she stormed. But
suddenly she stopped, with a calculating gleam in her eye.
"He's a fool to follow me," she said, "but he has gleams of
intelligence, Madge. I shall put the T. C. matter up to him!"
So I sent Viv a note that night. You see one must manage Poppy.
"Dear Viv: She knows and the worst is over. Breakfast early and
keep out of the way until noon. She is going to work, and
anyhow, it will make her curious. If you have a good retort to
the T. C. business, don't give it at once. It would humiliate her.
Then, when you've given it to her, if she's pleased, you can ask
her the other. She's silly about you, Viv, but she won't
acknowledge it to herself.
"Madge.
"P. S. Don't make any stipulation about Suffrage, but make her
promise to let you do and think as you like. Be sure. Get her to
write it, if you can. I happen to know that if she marries you,
she hopes you'll take alternate Sundays with her at the
Monument, so she can speak at Camberwell.
"M."
After all, it was Daphne who came to the rescue. She came over to
luncheon the day after and found Poppy in bed with cold cloths on
her head, and her wedding ring off. Daphne sniffed.
"You and Viv are two children," she said. "You're a silly for thinking
you can beat the government at its own game, which is taxation,
and Viv's a fool for letting you be one."
Poppy is not placid of disposition, and she flung the cold cloths at
Daphne and ordered her out. But Daphne only wrung out the cloths
and hung them up, and raised the shades.
"You haven't got a headache; you have a pain in your disposition,"
she said. "Put this on again."
And Poppy put on her wedding ring.
"Now," said Daphne. "You won't pay this money as a matter of
principle, and Viv won't, for the same reason. I won't because I
haven't got it: Madge probably ditto. But it must be paid. Have you
got it in the house?"
Poppy nodded.
"In notes?"
"Yes."
"Where?"
"In my jewel case."
"Very well. Now," said Daphne, "Madge and I are going to fix this
thing up. You are not to know anything about it. You can swear to
that later on, if the question comes up. Is there any place in your
studio where you keep money?"
"In the table drawer."
"Very well. To-night before you go to bed put that money there.
Early to-morrow morning send a maid to the drawer. If, by any
chance, it is not there, send for the police."
Poppy was sitting up in bed, her eyes narrowed.
"The door of that wing is always locked. Viv has one key; I have the
other."
"Never mind about the keys," said Daphne, loftily. "Now lie back and
take a nap. Madge and I are going to look at the new picture. And
I'm taking Madge home to dinner. I want her to go with me to the
Edgware Road meeting to-night."
We did not look at the picture very long. Daphne's lips were shut
tight, and I was feeling very queer. I knew what Daphne meant to
do—to have the exact amount of Poppy's tax stolen from the table,
and reported to the police. And later on in the day to have it sent to
the tax office in Poppy's name. Poppy could swear she had not done
it and point to the robbery. But by that time it would be credited to
her name, and Viv would be free.
"It's a knot," said Daphne, running her fingers through her hair. "It's
past un-tying. We have to cut it."
I know it sounds silly now and father has advised me never to tell
mother, but it seemed the only thing at the time. Here were Viv and
Poppy at an impasse, as one may say, and things getting worse
every day—Viv on a hunger strike, and Poppy's work waiting, and
the vote, which was our natural solution, as far off as ever.
"I'll unlock a window in Viv's study," said Daphne, "and you can
come back after midnight and crawl in. I'd do it, but I'm too fat.
Once in, you've only to go up the little staircase to the studio, and
get the money. The key's always in the side door. You can let
yourself out."
"But I don't like it, Daphne."
"A broken window," said Daphne, "would look a lot better. More
natural, you know. Here, hold a pillow."
She raised one of Viv's windows a little—we were in his study—and
she put her arm outside, with a paper weight in her hand. A smart
tap, and a pane fell in on my pillow. We listened but no servants had
come running and the house next door was closed and shuttered.
Daphne is very clever. She unlocked the window, drew the shade as
it had been before, and put the glass in a little heap on the floor.
The area was outside, about five feet below.
"I could never do it," I protested. "I—I haven't your courage, Daffie.
Be a dear and do it yourself."
"Have to be at Edgware Road," said Daphne. "After all, Poppy's your
friend. You made the match, didn't you?"
"But if I'm arrested——"
"You won't be. Jane Willoughby is going with me to-night. I'll lend
her some of your clothes and a veil. She can make a speech in your
name. There's an alibi for you!"
Now it sounded all right at the time, but looking back, it seems
queer. For of what use is an alibi if the police have you? But one
thing I would not do. I would not climb in the window. Daphne
finally put me behind one of Poppy's canvases in the studio on a
chair.
"They'll think you broke in, which answers as well," she said. "And
you can get the money and let yourself out the side door without
any trouble."
"I sha'n't have any dinner," I reminded her. But she said she'd have
something ready for me at home after I'd committed my crime, and
went down the staircase whistling.
I shall never forget that awful night. I was most uncomfortable.
There was a chance that the servants, locking up, would go into
Viv's study and find the glass, although it was behind the curtain.
But I'd seen Peters lock up before. He stood in a doorway and
looked at each window, and if the curtains did not blow the house
was safe. Luckily there was no wind that evening!
But I hated the whole thing. It got darker and darker and things
scrambled in the walls. Poppy brought the money and put it in a
drawer but of course I did not speak to her. She had to be able to
swear she knew nothing. She kissed Viv's picture which she had
painted, and trotted out again, sighing. Peters did not discover the
broken window in the den below, because he never even went to
look. And I felt very dreary, with no one really caring for me, and so
far from America, and men—like Basil, for instance—acting so
strange and uneasy.
Of course I could have taken the money and gone, as soon as it was
dark. But a policeman took up a position outside the area door, and
waited for somebody. He and Peters had a few words about Poppy's
maid, and the policeman said he would see her if he had to stay
there all night. He stayed for hours.
I got the money and put it in my handbag, and because I did not
wish to get it mixed with my own, I put it by itself in one of the
pockets. Then I think I dozed for two or three hours, for when
waking the street was quiet and the policeman had gone away. I
was stiff, tired, and out of humor, and I started down the little
staircase past Viv's study to the area door. As I reached the bottom,
somebody tried the lock outside. I nearly fainted. I turned and ran
up in the dark, and the door below opened. A man came in stealthily
and went directly to Vivian's den. And just then a church clock struck
two.
I was frightened. It seemed to me that as soon as he ransacked the
room below, he'd come up to the studio. Perhaps he knew about the
money. Burglars seem to be able to smell money. And the idea of
being caught in the studio, as in a cul de sac, made me panicky. I
clutched my bag, and slipped down the staircase, past Vivian's door.
The burglar was there, going through Viv's desk, with a light turned
on and a cap down over his eyes.
I forgot to be cautious then. I bolted for the door, flung it open—it
was a patent lock, with a knob inside—and stepped out into the
night air and the policeman's arms.
"Easy a bit, hold girl!" he said. "Hi'm 'ere and you're 'ere. What's the
'urry?" He held me off and looked at me. Luckily I'd never seen him
before. "Quick with your 'ands, ain't you! In you goes and in five
minutes out you pops!"
"If you think I'm a burglar," I said haughtily, "I'm nothing of the sort.
I'm——" It came over me, all at once, that I'd better not say I was a
friend of Poppy's. You see she was being watched very closely. If I
was searched, and the exact amount of her income tax in my
pocket, it would look very queer, and the whole thing would be out,
of course. "The burglar you followed is still in the house," I said.
"He's in Mr.—in the study, just beyond that door."
"None of that, young woman," he said, sternly. "You'll just come
along with me! 'Ouse-breaking it is; I watched you in and I watched
you hout."
He took me by the arm, and I went along. There was nothing else to
do. I tried to drop my hand bag as we went, but he heard it and
picked it up. I was rather dazed. The only thing I could think of was
that for the sake of the Cause and Poppy I must not tell who I was.
But I begged him to send an officer to Poppy's house, because there
was a burglar in it, probably after the idea of Vivian's new novel.
At the police station they telephoned Poppy, and here she made her
terrible mistake. She said afterwards that if Daphne had only
explained she'd have known. But she thought it was all a part of the
plot, and she went back to her studio and said she'd lost the money
out of a table drawer. She told how it was, in notes and gold, and, of
course, they found the exact amount in my bag. She says that when
they told her they had it and a young woman too, she almost
swooned. She tried to find Basil, but he was not in his rooms and
Daphne had been arrested at Edgware Road and was
incommunicado!
Poppy's position was pitiable. She didn't know what to do. If she
declared the plot and freed me, all London would laugh, and the
Cause would suffer. If she did not declare the plot, I would get a
prison sentence. I have drawn a poor picture of Poppy if you think I
stood a chance against The Cause.
That is how things stood the next morning; Daphne, Vivian and I in
jail, and Poppy in hysterics. Then a curious thing happened. The
evening papers announced that Vivian had paid the tax for Poppy
and was free. Viv repudiated the payment—said he had not done it,
and refused his liberty.
"Mr. Harcourt," said one paper, "is quite thin and shows the strain of
his confinement. He is apparently cheerful, but very feeble,
supporting himself by the back of a chair while he stood. His eyes
flashed, however, as he stated that the Income Tax office could not
legally accept the payment, as it was not his money. If any of his
supporters had, in mistaken zeal, taken a collection for this purpose,
he could only regret their action and refuse to profit by it."
At this time I had refused to talk and Poppy was in bed.
But on the next day the Times published a letter, signed "Only a
Man" which stirred the whole thing up again. The writer declared
that the tax had been paid with Vivian's own money, that the writer
himself had stolen it out of a desk in Mr. Harcourt's house, that it
had been sent by messenger to the proper authorities, and a receipt
issued, which was appended. And that, in other words, while Mr.
Harcourt was to be lauded for his principles, his refusal to accept his
liberty was now absurd. Also, the writer was under the impression
that an innocent person was being held for his crime.
This story being investigated by the authorities and Poppy's
recovering enough to come down and identify me, furiously
indignant at my detention and outraged that I had not told my name
and how I came to be leaving her house at that hour, which she said
was because we had had a long talk about the next campaign, I was
freed at last. It leaked out like this:
(a) Viv was free with no loss of principle.
(b) Poppy's tax was paid, with no loss of principle.
(c) "A Mere Man" was not apprehended.
(d) Basil reappeared, after a heavy cold.
I was not present when Viv and Poppy met, owing to some
formalities of my release. I drove to the house with Poppy's money
in my bag, and went up unannounced. Viv was not pale and wan. He
looked rested and fit, and Poppy was on his knee. When I went in
she moved to the arm of his chair, but no further, and she kept her
profile toward him.
They were very apologetic and said how sorry they were, and Poppy
said she knew Daphne and I meant well, but that one wrong would
never help another. I was speechless with rage, and I took from my
bag her money and held it out to her.
"Of course," I said, "Vivian has no idea of who 'A Mere Man' is?"
"None whatever," said Viv shamelessly.
"That's curious," I observed. "I saw him quite distinctly, you know,
as I went down the stairs."
(I had—his back!)
I went out, with my head up. They called to me, and I think Vivian
started to follow. But I got into a taxicab and drove to Daphne's. I
was very depressed.
Basil came to see me that night. Daphne was still in jail, and very
comfortable. She sent me word not to worry, as she was getting new
material for speeches, and had two ready.
I refused to see Basil, but he followed the maid back, and stood
looking down at me.
"Viv says you saw me," he began without any preamble.
"I did, but I didn't recognise you. You've committed yourself."
He changed colour.
"What else was there to do?" he demanded. "Those two geese
would have gone on forever. Viv had the money in his desk, but it
was my plan, not his."
As it happened, I had sent father a cablegram about Viv and Poppy
just before I was arrested, and now I saw his reply on the mantel.
"Sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander," he had cabled. Well, I
had had the jail, and Basil had had—a cold! Basil followed my eyes.
"More cablegrams!" he said. "Why doesn't that chap come over and
get you?"
"Because I am going back to him. I can't stand the pressure, Basil.
Viv and Poppy are all right for this year, but how about next? Is it to
be the same thing again?"
"They're going to Italy to live."
"A compromise?" I quoted, rather bitterly. "'Not victory but a truce.'
You and I made that marriage. It was the T. C. that did it."
Basil took the cablegram from the mantel and deliberately read it.
When he got to the signature he drew a long breath and then he
grinned.
"So that's that!" he said. "Well, Maggie, are you going back to father,
or—staying here with me?"
"You're afraid of me."
"I'll take the risk, Madge. I didn't tell you, Uncle Egbert died while
you were away."
"I've been in jail for stealing," I quavered. "And I'd do it again, Basil,
for the Cause."
"Bless the Cause," said Basil manfully. "Why shouldn't you vote, if
you want to? Aren't you cleverer, and lovelier, and more courageous
than any man that ever lived? Anyhow, you're right. Things are
rotten. What sane government would lock a man up because his
wife refuses to pay her taxes?"
I lifted my head from his shoulder.
"That wretched house at home——" I began.
But he was quite cheerful.
"We'll sell it," he said, "and you shall spend the money for pretties to
wear, that don't pay a tax."
It was compromise again. I knew it, but I yielded. After a time I
said:
"Basil, what was the retort you gave Poppy about the T. C.?"
"Nothing much," he replied complacently, "I told her, if any one
sprung it at her again, to say that if men had made the Ten
Commandments, they'd have added an eleventh amendment long
ago, or else have annulled them."
*** END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK AFFINITIES, AND
OTHER STORIES ***
1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also
govern what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most
countries are in a constant state of change. If you are outside
the United States, check the laws of your country in addition to
the terms of this agreement before downloading, copying,
displaying, performing, distributing or creating derivative works
based on this work or any other Project Gutenberg™ work. The
Foundation makes no representations concerning the copyright
status of any work in any country other than the United States.
1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form,
including any word processing or hypertext form. However, if
you provide access to or distribute copies of a Project
Gutenberg™ work in a format other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or
other format used in the official version posted on the official
Project Gutenberg™ website (www.gutenberg.org), you must,
at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a copy,
a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy
upon request, of the work in its original “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or
other form. Any alternate format must include the full Project
Gutenberg™ License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
• You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive
from the use of Project Gutenberg™ works calculated using the
method you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The
fee is owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg™ trademark,
but he has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to
the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty
payments must be paid within 60 days following each date on
which you prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your
periodic tax returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked
as such and sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive
Foundation at the address specified in Section 4, “Information
about donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive
Foundation.”
• You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
1.F.
Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.
testbankbell.com