International Journal of Advanced Engineering,

Management and Science (IJAEMS)

Peer-Reviewed Journal
ISSN: 2454-1311 | Vol-11, Issue-2; Mar-Apr, 2025
Journal Home Page: https://ijaems.com/
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.22161/ijaems.112.1

Integrating AI-Driven Automated Code Review in

Agile Development: Benefits, Challenges, and Best
Practices
Saad Ahmed

Department of Information Technology, Sir Syed University of Engineering and Technology

[email protected]

Received: 24 Jan 2025; Received in revised form: 26 Feb 2025; Accepted: 03 Mar 2025; Available online: 08 Mar 2025

Abstract— The integration of AI-powered automated code review tools has significantly transformed Agile
software development by improving efficiency, maintaining coding standards, and enhancing developer
productivity. These tools streamline repetitive tasks, identify potential issues early, and enforce consistency
in code quality. However, their adoption comes with challenges such as accuracy constraints, difficulties in
integrating with legacy systems, and hesitation among developers. This research employs a mixed-methods
approach, combining qualitative and quantitative techniques to examine the benefits, challenges, and best
practices associated with AI-driven code reviews. To gather insights, surveys and interviews were conducted
with software engineers, DevOps professionals, and Agile practitioners. Additionally, real-world case
studies analyzed how organizations have implemented AI-based code reviews, while an experimental study
measured performance indicators such as error detection rates, review efficiency, and developer workflow
improvements. The findings suggest that AI tools significantly reduce code review time, enhance
consistency, and allow developers to concentrate on complex problem-solving rather than manual review
processes. However, AI's inability to fully grasp context-sensitive issues, challenges in analyzing complex
code logic, and resistance from developers remain notable barriers. Concerns about job security and loss of
control over decision-making further contribute to adoption challenges. To overcome these issues, this study
emphasizes the importance of a balanced approach where AI tools assist rather than replace human reviewers.
Regular training and updates are crucial to improving AI accuracy and keeping pace with evolving coding
practices. Gradual integration with existing systems can mitigate compatibility challenges, while
transparent communication can help alleviate developer concerns. Additionally, establishing a validation
mechanism, where human reviewers verify AI-generated recommendations, can enhance reliability and trust
in these tools. In conclusion, while AI-driven automated code reviews offer substantial benefits for Agile
teams, their successful implementation depends on strategic deployment, ongoing refinements, and a well-
balanced collaboration between AI and human expertise. By following best practices, organizations can
optimize AI-assisted code reviews, ultimately improving software quality and streamlining development
workflows.
Keywords— AI-powered code review, Agile software development, developer productivity,
integration challenges, and best practices.

I. INTRODUCTION technological progress and the increasing complexity

The field of software engineering has undergone of software requirements. From its inception, software
significant advancements, driven by rapid development methodologies have evolved

This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 1

©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Ahmed International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science, 11(2) -2025

continuously, transitioning from the structured aspects of software development, leading to higher-
waterfall approach to more flexible and iterative quality software solutions. Another key advantage of
frameworks such as agile. These changes have been AI-driven code generation is its ability to optimize
geared toward improving efficiency, adaptability, and existing codebases. AI-powered tools assess code
software quality. The incorporation of DevOps, structures, pinpoint inefficiencies, and provide
continuous integration, and automated testing has recommendations or implement improvements
revolutionized the development, testing, and autonomously. For example, AI can eliminate
deployment processes. However, challenges such as redundant code, enhance loop efficiency, and improve
human errors in manual coding, inefficiencies in memory utilization, resulting in more efficient
feedback cycles, and resource management software performance. Additionally, AI-driven
constraints continue to persist, prompting ongoing analysis allows developers to evaluate how different
innovation. [1]. Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become optimization techniques impact overall system
a fundamental component of contemporary software functionality, enabling more informed decision-
development, providing transformative capabilities making. This continuous learning process ensures that
that enhance multiple stages of the development AI tools adapt to evolving coding standards and
lifecycle. In high-tech industries, where innovation industry best practices, maintaining optimized and
and efficiency are critical, utilizing AI-driven insights up-to-date code. [5].
plays a vital role in sustaining a competitive edge. [2]. The use of AI-driven automated code reviews in
AI's capacity to process extensive datasets, recognize Agile development is reshaping how software teams
patterns, and generate predictive recommendations enhance code quality, streamline workflows, and
empowers developers to optimize workflows, speed up software delivery. Agile development is
minimize errors, and expedite product deployment. built on iterative progress, teamwork, and continuous
The significance of AI insights for high-tech improvement, making AI-powered automation an
companies cannot be underestimated. These insights ideal addition to modern development processes. By
support well-informed decision-making, enhance utilizing machine learning (ML) and natural language
code quality, and streamline project management. By processing (NLP), AI-based code review tools can
automating repetitive tasks, AI enables developers to evaluate code structure, identify inefficiencies, and
concentrate on creative and complex problem-solving. offer instant feedback, reducing the reliance on
Furthermore, AI-powered analytics can anticipate manual reviews. These tools improve both the speed
potential challenges before they emerge, significantly and accuracy of code assessment, allowing Agile
lowering the likelihood of expensive post-release teams to maintain rapid development cycles while
corrections and improving overall product ensuring high software quality. AI-driven automated
dependability. [3]. code review tools function by scanning source code
AI-powered code generation is revolutionizing and detecting issues such as syntax errors, security
software development in high-tech industries by risks, performance inefficiencies, and deviations from
automating repetitive coding tasks, optimizing code coding best practices Traditional code reviews often
structure, and significantly boosting developer require experienced developers to manually examine
productivity. The automation of routine coding code, which is both time-consuming and susceptible
processes through AI represents a major advancement to human error. In contrast, AI-powered tools can
in software engineering. [4] Utilizing machine quickly analyze large codebases, offering instant
learning algorithms and natural language processing, recommendations and flagging potential problems
AI tools can recognize coding patterns, identify that might otherwise be overlooked. This consistency
common functionalities, and generate boilerplate code in enforcing coding standards across teams improves
automatically. This not only reduces the time software quality and simplifies maintenance.
developers spend on repetitive tasks but also lowers Additionally, these AI tools continuously evolve by
the likelihood of human errors associated with learning from extensive code repositories, improving
manual coding. Consequently, developers can their ability to recognize problems and suggest
concentrate on complex problem-solving and creative enhancements over time. [6].

This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 2

©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Ahmed International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science, 11(2) -2025

A key advantage of AI-driven code reviews in Agile a project’s unique requirements and coding standards
development is the reduction of technical debt. (Kwakye, Ekechukwu & Ogundipe, 2024). False
Technical debt arises when speed is prioritized over positives and false negatives can occasionally arise,
long-term code quality, resulting in inefficiencies that making human oversight necessary to validate AI-
complicate future development efforts. AI tools help generated recommendations. Additionally, some
mitigate this risk by detecting poor coding practices, developers may resist automation, preferring
outdated dependencies, and security vulnerabilities traditional peer reviews over AI-assisted suggestions.
early in the development process. Addressing these To successfully adopt AI-driven code reviews,
issues proactively ensures that software remains organizations must define clear guidelines on how
scalable, secure, and aligned with industry best automation complements manual reviews, ensuring a
practices. Furthermore, AI-powered reviews promote well-balanced approach that leverages both AI
consistency in coding guidelines across distributed efficiency and human expertise. [9].
Agile teams, minimizing inconsistencies that can 1.1 Benefits of AI-Driven Automated Code Review
occur in manual reviews conducted by different in Agile Development
developers. In Agile environments where continuous
AI-powered automated code reviews are
integration and continuous deployment (CI/CD) play
revolutionizing Agile development by enhancing
a crucial role, AI-driven code reviews optimize the
efficiency, improving code quality, and boosting
development pipeline by delivering real-time
overall productivity. One of the most notable
feedback. Integrating AI into CI/CD workflows
advantages is ensuring consistency in coding
allows developers to receive recommendations before
standards. AI-driven tools help maintain uniformity
merging code into production, reducing the chances
by enforcing best practices across development teams,
of introducing bugs or security vulnerabilities. This
reducing human errors and improving software
automation not only speeds up development cycles
reliability. By automating the detection of syntax
but also ensures that frequent software updates do not
errors, security vulnerabilities, and performance
compromise reliability. Additionally, AI-assisted
inefficiencies, these tools free up developers to focus
reviews ease the burden on senior developers,
on solving complex problems rather than spending
enabling them to focus on complex problem-solving
time on routine checks. Another key benefit is
and architectural decisions instead of spending time
increased developer productivity. [10] Traditional
on routine code evaluations. [7]
code reviews often require significant time and effort,
Beyond improving efficiency and code quality, AI- potentially slowing down development cycles. AI-
driven code review fosters collaboration and driven tools provide real-time feedback, allowing
knowledge-sharing among developers. Junior developers to promptly identify and fix issues,
developers, who may not yet have extensive thereby accelerating Agile workflows. This immediate
experience with writing optimized code, benefit from feedback is especially valuable in continuous
AI-generated suggestions that guide them toward integration and continuous deployment (CI/CD)
best practices and alternative coding approaches. This environments, where speed and quality must go hand
learning process enhances the overall skill level within in hand. AI-driven code review tools also play a
the team, leading to better productivity and stronger crucial role in minimizing technical debt. These tools
code quality over time. Moreover, AI tools do more proactively detect inefficient code patterns, outdated
than just highlight problems; they provide dependencies, and security risks before they become
explanations for flagged issues, helping developers major concerns. Addressing such issues early in the
understand their mistakes rather than just applying development process helps reduce rework, enhance
automatic fixes. This approach supports a culture of software maintainability, and ensure long-term
continuous learning, reinforcing Agile principles of scalability. [11].
adaptability and incremental progress. [8]. Despite its
many benefits, implementing AI-driven code review
in Agile development comes with challenges. AI tools
require proper training and fine-tuning to align with

This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 3

©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Ahmed International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science, 11(2) -2025

1.2 Challenges of AI-Driven Automated Code and nuanced decision-making that AI lacks.
Review in Agile Development Establishing a review process where AI suggestions
Despite its numerous advantages, integrating AI- are validated by experienced developers enhances
driven automated code reviews into Agile accuracy and reliability. [14]. Customizing AI tools to
development presents several challenges. One major align with specific project requirements is also
issue is the accuracy of AI-generated feedback. These essential. Organizations should fine-tune AI models
tools may produce false positives, flagging correct based on their development standards, industry
code as problematic, or false negatives, overlooking needs, and unique coding practices. Regular updates
actual issues, which can frustrate developers and and refinements to AI algorithms improve their
reduce trust in automation [12] . Additionally, AI tools effectiveness in detecting relevant issues and offering
often struggle with adapting to diverse coding styles meaningful recommendations. Encouraging
and domain-specific requirements. Since AI models collaboration between AI tools and development
are trained on general datasets, they may not fully teams fosters greater acceptance and efficiency.
understand unique project needs, leading to incorrect Developers should be trained on how to leverage AI-
or irrelevant suggestions . Another challenge is the driven insights effectively and understand how
potential over-reliance on automation, which may automated feedback complements traditional code
discourage developers from engaging in deep code reviews. A transparent approach that presents AI as
analysis and critical thinking. While AI can streamline an aid rather than a replacement helps build trust
code review, it cannot fully replace human judgment, among developers and facilitates smoother adoption .
particularly for complex architectural decisions and Finally, continuous monitoring and improvement of
nuanced code improvements. Moreover, AI tools are crucial for long-term success.
implementing AI-driven code review tools requires Organizations should gather feedback from
significant initial investment in terms of cost, training, developers on AI performance, analyze trends in AI-
and integration into existing workflows. Some generated reviews, and make necessary adjustments
developers may also resist AI adoption, fearing job to enhance accuracy. Regular evaluations of AI’s
displacement or perceiving automation as intrusive impact on code quality and development efficiency
rather than supportive. To overcome these challenges, help teams refine their processes and maximize the
organizations must establish a balanced approach value of AI-driven automated code reviews. [15]
where AI enhances, rather than replaces, human
expertise. Continuous monitoring and fine-tuning of II. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
AI models, along with clear guidelines on AI-human
2.1 Relvent Research
collaboration, can help ensure that AI-driven code
reviews contribute effectively to Agile development. The adoption of AI-driven automation in Agile
[13]. software development is rapidly transforming the
industry, with large language models (LLMs) playing
1.3 Best Practices of AI-Driven Automated Code
a key role in optimizing workflows. This research
Review in Agile Development
examines the effectiveness of multi-agent LLM
To maximize the benefits of AI-driven code review, systems in various software engineering tasks,
Agile teams should adopt best practices that enhance including code generation, bug detection,
efficiency and ensure code quality. One key practice is documentation, and project management. By utilizing
integrating AI tools into continuous integration and multiple AI agents that work collaboratively, we
continuous deployment (CI/CD) pipelines. This explore how automation enhances development
ensures that AI feedback is incorporated early in the efficiency while maintaining high code quality and
development process, preventing the buildup of adaptability. Our study implements and assesses a
technical debt and minimizing extensive rework. multi-agent framework, focusing on its impact on
Another crucial practice is maintaining a balance sprint planning, automated testing, and continuous
between AI automation and human oversight. While integration pipelines. The findings reveal that multi-
AI-driven tools efficiently detect coding issues, agent LLMs can significantly shorten development
human developers provide contextual understanding
This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 4
©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Ahmed International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science, 11(2) -2025

cycles, boost team productivity, and offer real-time deeper insights into both individual and team
decision-making support, making them valuable productivity while minimizing the biases associated
assets in Agile environments. However, challenges with manual assessments. These tools can identify
such as model interpretability, the risk of error productivity trends, pinpoint workflow bottlenecks,
propagation, and the need for seamless collaboration and highlight areas where additional support or skill
between AI and human developers remain key development is needed. Additionally, real-time
concerns. [16]. feedback mechanisms allow developers to make
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is transforming software informed adjustments, helping teams refine their
development in high-tech companies by providing processes and continuously improve efficiency. [18].
innovative tools and insights that enhance The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into
productivity, efficiency, and code quality. This review DevOps is transforming continuous integration and
examines the role of AI in modern software continuous deployment (CI/CD) pipelines by
development, focusing on its impact on key areas such automating repetitive tasks, minimizing manual
as code generation, bug detection, project effort, and enhancing overall efficiency. AI-driven
management, and testing. AI-powered tools enable automation accelerates development cycles, reduces
developers to automate repetitive tasks, optimize operational costs, and shortens time-to-market. By
code structure, and detect potential issues before they leveraging AI for automated code reviews, bug
escalate, ultimately reducing development time and detection, and security testing, software quality
improving software reliability. Machine learning improves while testing time is significantly reduced.
algorithms leverage data from previous projects to AI-powered fault detection enables proactive issue
offer predictive analytics, helping teams make identification and real-time resolution, minimizing
informed decisions and allocate resources effectively. downtime and ensuring system stability.
Additionally, natural language processing (NLP) Additionally, AI enhances deployment efficiency
improves interactions with development tools, through automated release management, intelligent
facilitating better communication and collaboration resource allocation, and predictive scaling. A
among team members. AI also plays a crucial role in comparison between traditional DevOps and AI-
enhancing continuous integration and continuous driven DevOps highlights substantial improvements
deployment (CI/CD) pipelines by automating testing in time-to-market and cost savings. With AI handling
and deployment processes. This minimizes human routine processes, DevOps teams can focus on
intervention while ensuring that code changes are strategic initiatives such as fostering innovation and
seamlessly integrated and deployed. By embracing streamlining software development. [19].
AI-driven automation, high-tech companies can adopt 2.2 The role and applications of Al in agile
more agile methodologies, quickly adapt to market workflows
demands, and deliver high-quality software solutions.
While Agile methodologies have proven highly
[17].
effective, the increasing complexity of software
Integrating AI-driven performance metrics into agile projects presents new challenges. Managing vast
software development can significantly enhance amounts of data and making rapid, informed
productivity, streamline workflows, and improve decisions has become more demanding. AI addresses
team collaboration. Traditional methods of evaluating these challenges by automating repetitive tasks,
developer performance often rely on outdated key providing predictive insights, and streamlining
performance indicators (KPIs) or subjective workflows within Agile environments. Specifically,
assessments that fail to capture real-time AI enhances various Agile phases, such as sprint
contributions accurately. AI-powered analytics planning, resource management, and automated code
provide a more objective and data-driven approach by reviews, all of which contribute to increased team
analyzing coding patterns, pull request activity, issue efficiency and faster value delivery. AI is also gaining
resolution times, and overall collaboration dynamics. traction in automating routine tasks within Agile
By utilizing machine learning models and natural pipelines. For example, AI-powered tools assist in
language processing (NLP), AI-driven metrics offer project tracking, bug detection, and code quality
This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 5
©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Ahmed International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science, 11(2) -2025

assurance. By handling these time-consuming To gather insights from industry professionals,

processes, AI allows Agile teams to focus on more structured surveys and semi-structured interviews
strategic and creative aspects of development, such as will be conducted with software developers, DevOps
problem-solving and feature enhancement. In AI- engineers, and Agile practitioners across different
augmented Agile environments, automation reduces sectors. The primary focus will be to understand their
manual effort, significantly boosting overall experiences, perceptions, and opinions on the
productivity. Furthermore, AI-driven tools enhance effectiveness of AI-powered code review tools.
team collaboration by integrating seamlessly with Case Studies
project management platforms, providing real-time
This study will examine real-world cases of
updates, and generating automated reports, ensuring
organizations that have incorporated AI-driven code
efficient communication across teams. [20]
review tools into their Agile workflows. The case
Another significant advantage of AI in Agile studies will track the adoption journey, assess the
development is its role in predictive analysis and influence on code quality, and evaluate its role in
decision-making. By analyzing historical project data, improving efficiency within Agile teams.
AI can identify potential bottlenecks, predict delays,
Experimental Evaluation
and optimize resource allocation. These forecasting
capabilities are particularly valuable in Agile projects, A controlled experiment will be carried out by
where flexibility and adaptability are crucial. AI- integrating an AI-based code review tool into an Agile
driven insights allow teams to plan sprints more team’s development process. Key performance
effectively, ensuring that tasks are assigned based on indicators, including defect detection rates, review
accurate effort and resource estimations. turnaround time, and developer productivity, will be
Additionally, AI integration enhances continuous measured and compared against traditional manual
integration and continuous delivery (CI/CD) code review methods.
pipelines in Agile workflows. AI-driven systems 3.3 Data Analysis Methods
streamline workflows by automating code testing and A. Qualitative Analysis
deployment, reducing the repetitive burden of
Data collected from interviews and case study reports
manual validation. This not only improves software
will undergo thematic analysis to identify common
quality but also accelerates the feedback loop,
patterns, challenges, and best practices related to AI-
allowing teams to deliver faster and more frequent
driven code reviews.
updates. By embedding AI into CI/CD processes,
organizations can enhance software reliability and B. Quantitative Analysis
provide customers with more timely and efficient Survey responses will be examined using statistical
system improvements. [21]. techniques such as descriptive analysis and inferential
testing. Additionally, experimental data will be
analyzed using hypothesis testing to compare the
III. METHODOLOGY
effectiveness of AI-driven and manual code review
3.1 . Research Design processes.
This research follows a mixed-methods approach,
integrating both qualitative and quantitative
IV. RESULTS
strategies to explore the advantages, challenges, and
best practices associated with AI-driven automated The integration of AI-driven automated code review
code reviews in Agile development. To ensure a well- tools into Agile development was assessed using both
rounded analysis, the study will utilize surveys, case qualitative and quantitative approaches. The findings
studies, and experimental evaluations. are grouped into three main areas: benefits,
challenges, and best practices.
3.2 Data Collection Methods
Surveys and Interviews

This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 6

©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Ahmed International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science, 11(2) -2025

1. Advantages of AI-Driven Automated Code remain relevant and improve their

Review performance.
The adoption of AI-powered code review tools • Transparent Communication: Clear
brought notable improvements in efficiency, code discussions about the role of AI in the
quality, and teamwork. The key benefits observed development process can help address
include: concerns and encourage smoother adoption.
• Faster Code Reviews: AI tools significantly 4.1 Benefits of AI-Driven Automated Code Review
reduced the time required for manual code One of the most significant advantages of AI-powered
evaluations by automating repetitive tasks. code review tools is the reduction in code review time.
• Better Code Quality: Automated suggestions Traditional code reviews often require extensive
ensured consistency, helping to identify manual effort, which can slow down the development
errors and security vulnerabilities early in the process. AI tools streamline this by automating
development cycle. repetitive tasks such as detecting syntax errors,
• Increased Developer Productivity: identifying coding standard violations, and
Developers were able to focus more on suggesting improvements. This automation allows
writing and refining code rather than developers to spend less time on reviews and more
spending excessive time on reviews. time on actual coding, leading to improved time
efficiency in the software development lifecycle.
2. Challenges Faced During Implementation
Another crucial benefit is improved code quality. AI-
Despite its benefits, integrating AI-driven code review
driven tools provide consistent and standardized code
tools came with certain challenges, such as:
analysis, reducing human errors and minimizing
• Accuracy Limitations: AI tools occasionally security vulnerabilities. By offering automated
struggled with identifying complex issues or suggestions based on best practices and coding
making suggestions within the broader standards, these tools help developers maintain high-
project context. quality code throughout the development process. As
• Compatibility with Legacy Systems: a result, the overall software quality improves,
Integrating AI-driven tools into existing reducing the chances of post-deployment issues and
workflows, particularly with older systems, ensuring quality improvement in the final product.
posed technical difficulties. Additionally, the integration of AI tools enhances
• Adoption Resistance: Some team members developer productivity. Since developers no longer
were hesitant to embrace AI-driven reviews, have to spend excessive time on tedious manual code
fearing reduced human involvement in the reviews, they can focus more on core development
development process. tasks such as designing new features, optimizing
performance, and resolving complex technical
3. Best Practices for Effective Integration
challenges. This shift enables teams to work more
To maximize the effectiveness of AI-driven automated efficiently, accelerating project timelines and
code review tools, the following best practices were increasing overall productivity in software
identified: development.
• Blended Approach: AI tools should support, By implementing AI-driven code review tools, Agile
rather than replace, human expertise to teams can achieve faster development cycles,
ensure the best outcomes. maintain high code quality, and enhance the
• Ongoing Training & Updates: Regular productivity of developers, ultimately leading to
updates and continuous training help AI tools better software outcomes.

This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 7

©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Ahmed International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science, 11(2) -2025

Table 1: Summary of Benefits from AI-Driven Automated Code Review

Benefit Description Impact Development
Reduction in Code Review AI tools reduced manual code review time
Time Efficiency
Time by automating repetitive tasks
AI tools provided consistent suggestions,
Improved Code Quality Quality Improvement
reducing errors and vulnerabilities.
Enhanced Developer Developers were freed from tedious reviews,
Productivity Increase
Productivity focusing more on feature development.

4.2 Key Challenges of AI-Driven Code Review consuming and resource-intensive. If not managed
Integration properly, this integration process can disrupt
One of the biggest challenges of AI-driven code workflows and slow down development, making it
review tools is accuracy. While these tools perform difficult to realize the full potential of AI assistance.
well in identifying syntax errors and enforcing coding Resistance to change is another common hurdle when
standards, they often fall short when handling adopting AI-driven code reviews. Some developers
complex code logic that requires contextual may be skeptical about AI’s role in the review process,
understanding. As a result, AI may generate false fearing job displacement or a loss of control over code
positives or miss critical issues, requiring developers quality decisions. This hesitation can create friction
to manually verify and refine its suggestions. This can within teams, slowing down adoption and reducing
impact overall code quality, making it essential to trust in AI-powered solutions. Without proper
combine AI assistance with human expertise to ensure training and clear communication, organizations may
more reliable code reviews. Another significant struggle to integrate these tools effectively, leading to
challenge is integration with legacy systems. Many adoption barriers that hinder progress. Overcoming
organizations still rely on older software these challenges requires a strategic approach—
infrastructures that are not fully compatible with leveraging AI as a supportive tool rather than a
modern AI-powered tools. Implementing AI-driven replacement, ensuring smooth system integration,
code reviews in these environments often requires and fostering a culture of adaptability within
extensive customization, which can be both time- development teams.
Table 2: Key Challenges of AI-Driven Code Review Integration
Challenge Description Impact on Development
AI tools occasionally missed complex issues or
Tool Accuracy Quality Limitations
failed to offer context-sensitive suggestions.
Integration with Difficulty in integrating AI tools with existing
Workflow Disruption
Legacy Systems or outdated systems.
Some team members were hesitant to adopt AI-
Resistance to
driven tools due to concerns over job Adoption Barriers
Change
displacement.

4.3 Best Practices for Successful Integration expertise, along with ongoing training and clear
Table 3 describes the best practices for integrating AI- communication, helps achieve the desired outcomes
driven automated code review tools. A hybrid in terms of efficiency, effectiveness, and team
approach that blends AI assistance with human acceptance.

This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 8

©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Ahmed International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science, 11(2) -2025

Table 3: Best Practices for Successful Integration

Best Practice Description Expected Outcome
Combining human oversight with AI tools ensures
Hybrid Approach Balanced Development
better decision-making and code quality.
Regular updates and training of AI tools for Improved tools
Continuous Training
adaptability and accuracy. Effectiveness
Clear Transparent discussions about AI tool integration to
Successful Adoption
Communication mitigate resistance.

V. CONCLUSION developers provide contextual insights, ensures

The use of AI-driven automated code review tools in higher code quality and better decision-making.
Agile development has brought noticeable 2. Invest in Continuous AI Training and Updates
improvements in efficiency, code quality, and Regular training and updates are essential to
developer productivity. By automating repetitive keep AI tools accurate, relevant, and aligned
tasks, these tools help streamline the review process, with evolving coding practices. Organizations
ensure consistency, and identify security should prioritize fine-tuning AI models based on
vulnerabilities early. However, some challenges real-world feedback to enhance their
remain, including occasional inaccuracies, difficulties performance over time.
in integrating with older systems, and resistance from
3. Ensure Smooth Integration with Existing
developers who may be hesitant to rely on AI-driven
Systems
evaluations. To fully leverage the advantages of AI-
powered code reviews, organizations should adopt a Compatibility with legacy infrastructure can be a
balanced approach that combines AI insights with challenge. Organizations should evaluate their
human expertise. This ensures that complex issues are current workflows and implement gradual
accurately identified and resolved within the integration strategies, such as using middleware
appropriate context. Regular training and updates or custom adapters, to avoid major disruptions
will help AI tools stay relevant and effective, while and ensure seamless adoption.
clear communication about their role can ease 4. Promote Team-Wide Acceptance through Clear
concerns and encourage team-wide adoption. When Communication
implemented strategically, AI-driven code reviews Developers may hesitate to adopt AI-powered
can enhance development workflows, improve tools due to concerns about job security or
software quality, and contribute to a more efficient reduced control over the review process.
and productive Agile environment. Transparent discussions about AI’s role as a
VI. RECOMMENDATIONS supportive tool can help ease these concerns.
To successfully integrate AI-driven automated code Hands-on training and clear demonstrations of
review tools into Agile development while AI’s benefits can further encourage adoption.
overcoming challenges, organizations should 5. Implement a Validation Process for AI
consider the following strategies: Suggestions
1. Combine AI with Human Expertise Since AI-generated recommendations may include
AI should enhance, not replace, human oversight false positives or miss context-specific issues,
in code reviews. While AI excels at detecting organizations should establish a review mechanism
syntax errors and enforcing coding standards, it where developers validate AI-suggested changes
may struggle with complex logic. A hybrid before implementation. This ensures accuracy and
approach, where AI handles repetitive tasks and prevents potential coding errors from being
introduced.

This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 9

©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Ahmed International Journal of Advanced Engineering, Management and Science, 11(2) -2025

REFERENCES Frontline Research in Science and Technology, 3(02), 001-

018.
[1] Gurcan, F., Dalveren, G. G. M., Cagiltay, N. E., & Soylu,
[13] Abdul-Azeez, O. Y., Nwabekee, U. S., Agu, E. E., &
A. (2022). Detecting latent topics and trends in software
Ijomah, T. I. (2024). Sustainability in product life cycle
engineering research since 1980 using probabilistic
management: A review of best practices and
topic modeling. IEEE Access, 10, 74638-74654.
innovations.
[2] Olatunji, A. O., Olaboye, J. A., Maha, C. C., Kolawole,
[14] Alenezi, M., & Akour, M. (2025). AI-Driven Innovations
T. O., & Abdul, S. (2024). Harnessing the human
in Software Engineering: A Review of Current Practices
microbiome: Probiotic and prebiotic interventions to
and Future Directions. Applied Sciences, 15(3), 1344.
reduce hospital-acquired infections and enhance
[15] Noor, R., & Talavera, G. (2025). AI-Driven Developer
immunity. International Medical Science Research
Performance Metrics: Enhancing Agile Software
Journal, 4(7), 771-787
Development.
[3] Maha, C. C., Kolawole, T. O., & Abdul, S. (2024).
[16] Khan, S., & Daviglus, M. (2025). AI-Driven Automation
Empowering healthy lifestyles: Preventing non-
in Agile Development: Multi-Agent LLMs for Software
communicable diseases through cohort studies in the
Engineering.
US and Africa. International Journal of Applied
[17] Jin, Z. (2024). Integrating AI into Agile Workflows:
Research in Social Sciences, 6(6), 1068-1083.
Opportunities and Challenges. Applied and
[4] Nwosu, N. T., Babatunde, S. O., & Ijomah, T. (2024).
Computational Engineering, 116, 49-54.
Enhancing customer experience and market
[18] Ajiga, D., Okeleke, P. A., Folorunsho, S. O., &
penetration through advanced data analytics in the
Ezeigweneme, C. (2024). Enhancing software
health industry
development practices with AI insights in high-tech
[5] Kwakye, J. M., Ekechukwu, D. E., & Ogundipe, O. B.
companies. IEEE Software Engineering Institute, Technical
(2024). Systematic review of the economic impacts of
Report TR-2024-003.
bioenergy on agricultural markets. International
[19] Vadde, B. C., & Munagandla, V. B. (2022). AI-Driven
Journal of Advanced Economics, 6(7), 306-318
Automation in DevOps: Enhancing Continuous
[6] Agu, E. E., Nwabekee, U. S., Ijomah, T. I., & Abdul-
Integration and Deployment. International Journal of
Azeez, O. Y. (2024). The role of strategic business
Advanced Engineering Technologies and Innovations, 1(3),
leadership in driving product marketing success:
183-193.
Insights from emerging markets. International Journal of
[20] Kuhrmann, M., Tell, P., Hebig, R., Klunder, J. A.-C.,
Frontline Research in Science and Technology, 3(02), 001-
Munch, J., Linssen, O., Pfahl, D., Felderer, M., Prause,
018.
C., Macdonell, S., Nakatumba-Nabende, J., Raffo, D.,
[7] Nwosu, N. T., Babatunde, S. O., & Ijomah, T. (2024).
Beecham, S., Tuzun, E., Lopez, G., Paez, N., Fontdevila,
Enhancing customer experience and market
D., Licorish, S., Kupper, S., & Ruhe, G. (2021
penetration through advanced data analytics in the
[21] Perkusich, M., Chaves e Silva, L., Costa, A., Ramos, F.,
health industry. World Journal of Advanced Research and
Saraiva, R., Freire, A., Dilorenzo, E., Dantas, E., Santos,
Reviews, 22(3), 1157-1170.
D., Gorgônio, K., Almeida, H., & Perkusich, A. (2020)
[8] Kwakye, J. M., Ekechukwu, D. E., & Ogundipe, O. B.
(2024). Systematic review of the economic impacts of
bioenergy on agricultural markets. International Journal
of Advanced Economics, 6(7), 306-318.
[9] Raji, E., Ijomah, T. I., & Eyieyien, O. G. (2024).
Integrating technology, market strategies, and strategic
management in agricultural economics for enhanced
productivity. International Journal of Management &
Entrepreneurship Research, 6(7), 2112-2124.
[10] Kumar, S. (2024). Artificial Intelligence in Software
Engineering: A Systematic Exploration of AI-Driven
Development.
[11] Alenezi, M., & Akour, M. (2025). AI-Driven Innovations
in Software Engineering: A Review of Current Practices
and Future Directions. Applied Sciences, 15(3), 1344.
[12] Agu, E. E., Nwabekee, U. S., Ijomah, T. I., & Abdul-
Azeez, O. Y. (2024). The role of strategic business
leadership in driving product marketing success:
Insights from emerging markets. International Journal of
This article can be downloaded from here: www.ijaems.com 10
©2025 The Author(s). Published by Infogain Publication, This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/