jwc2024445
jwc2024445
445
Shallow groundwater salinization risks under climate change: FEFLOW model application
in Cebala Borj-Touil irrigation zone, northern Tunisia
HR, 0000-0002-1667-6414
ABSTRACT
The Cebala Borj-Touil irrigation perimeter in the low valley of the Medjerda River is marked by a shallow saline groundwater rise. The seasonal
water salinity shows a high spatial and temporal variation. This study introduces a novel methodological approach dealing with the data scar-
city problem in a complex deltaic area, using only available data and numerical models. The numerical model FEFLOW was used to simulate
the shallow groundwater flow and salt transfer. Several simulations were run to explore future trends of groundwater salinity under different
climate change (CC) conditions. The results show a significant increase in water salinity under all the climatic scenarios. A 15% decrease in
precipitation leads to an average increase in salinity of 10–15 g/l. The significant rise in sea level also affects the salinization process. The
intrusion of seawater results in concentrations of salinity between 16 and 20 g/l. In addition, the quality of irrigation water has a marked
impact, contributing to a significant increase in salinity, reaching a maximum of 15 g/l. These concerning results are to be expected, as
the coastal study area is characterized by a semi-arid climate and is increasingly influenced by anthropogenic factors, including irrigation
practices and drainage deficiency.
Key words: climate change, irrigation perimeter, numerical modeling, salinity, shallow groundwater, Tunisia
HIGHLIGHTS
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Licence (CC BY 4.0), which permits copying, adaptation and
redistribution, provided the original work is properly cited (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
GRAPHICAL ABSTRACT
1. INTRODUCTION
Effects of climate change (CC) on the quality and quantity of water resources are becoming more and more visible (Barica
1972; Leavesley 1994; Colombani et al. 2016; Mastrocicco & Colombani 2021). Arid and semi-arid regions are very vulner-
able to these changes due to the high evaporation, which leads to a progressive depletion of aquifers, particularly shallow
groundwater (Barica 1972). Coastal aquifers are highly vulnerable because of changes in groundwater recharge and seawater
intrusion (Wang et al. 2023; Ansari et al. 2024). In the case of irrigated perimeters, the anthropogenic processes contributing
to the groundwater salinization are mainly summarized in the rise of the groundwater table due to inappropriate irrigation,
the failure of the drainage system, and the disturbance of the natural cycle of the soil leaching by the creation of wells (Foster
& Chilton 2003). Several studies analyze the relationship between irrigation water quality and groundwater salinization in
similar cases (El oumlouki et al. 2018; Sefiani et al. 2019). In addition, the choice of climate models is a major challenge.
Information about CC at the regional scale is essential to obtaining accurate results about the environmental impacts of
CC. Recently, scaling-down methods have enabled the extraction of results from global climate models at finer scales
(Giorgi 2008). The simulations of the different climatic scenarios confirm the high coastal groundwater vulnerability to sal-
inization (Barica 1972; Leavesley 1994; Colombani et al. 2016; Mastrocicco & Colombani 2021). The impact of the different
combined processes on water salinization can be analyzed with numerical modeling (Li et al. 2019), even for complex cases
or when observed data are scarce and poor (Baccouche et al. 2024). To analyze the salinization of the shallow groundwater,
the perimeter of Cebala Borj-Touil was selected, which is irrigated by treated wastewater. In Cebala Borj-Touil, it is not con-
firmed that irrigation is the origin of the groundwater salinization. Only a few studies have been conducted in this region due
to a lack of data on the salinity in the aquifer. However, all studies confirm the presence of extremely salty shallow ground-
water (Hachicha et al. 1990; Hachicha & Job 1994; Hassine 2005; Dahmouni et al. 2017; Rzigui et al. 2022a, 2022b). To
understand these developments, models are used to address data quality issues and create a reliable model of salinity that
can be used for predictive simulations. The FEFLOW model was selected for a 2D simulation of flow and salt transport
under complex initial and boundary conditions. The modeling approach is divided into two parts: the flow model and the
salt transport model. The transport model depends on the calibrated and validated flow model and has several uncertainties.
In the study of Bahri et al. (2015) and Rzigui et al. (2022a, 2022b), the numerical models MODFLOW and FEFLOW were
applied for the simulation and optimization of the Cebala Borj-Touil perimeter drainage system. The results confirmed that
the drainage system is not working anymore. Water quality and the impact of CC on groundwater salinization remain
unknown. The objectives of this paper are the modeling of the variation of the salinization of the shallow groundwater
and the estimation of its evolution under CC conditions. This research presents an innovative methodological framework
that addresses issues related to data scarcity by utilizing only the available data and numerical models to investigate the
impact of CC on a complex deltaic coastal shallow groundwater scenario.
Since 1990, irrigation and drainage systems have been installed. The efficiency of the drainage network has progressively
deteriorated over the last three decades. The natural drainage system is composed of two rivers, the Khelidj and the El Maleh
wadis. The climate of the study area is semi-arid, with an average annual rainfall of 450 mm and a potential evapotranspira-
tion of 1,300 mm·year1. The Cebala soils are composed of loamy clay on Quaternary alluvial deposits. The soil salinity varies
between 2.0 and 3.5 dS·m1 at the soil surface layer.
The shallow groundwater table ranges from 0.2 to 1.8 m above sea level (ASL), with a high electrical conductivity varying
from 10 to 20 dS·m1.
k
u¼ (rp þ rgrz)
m
where u is the Darcy’s velocity vector (m·s⁻¹), μ is the dynamic viscosity of the fluid (kg·m⁻¹·s⁻¹), k is the intrinsic permeability
of the medium (m2), p is the pressure (kg·m⁻2·s⁻2), ρ is the fluid density (kg·m⁻³), g is the gravitational acceleration (m·s⁻2), z is
the elevation defined along a vertical ascending axis (m).
According to Koskinen et al. (1996), the equations governing solute transport in saturated conductive media within
FEFLOW are defined by the model proposed by Huyakorn & Pinder (1983), which describes the concentration C
(kg·m1) as follows:
@c
r(Drc) r(qc) þ Qin cin Qout C ¼ ff
@t
where c is the concentration (kg·m3), D is the dispersion tensor (including convection and diffusion) (m2·s1), u is the Darcy
velocity (m·s1), Qin is the source term (l·s1), cin is the concentration of incoming water flow (kg·m3), Qout is the sink (or
drain) term (l·s1), wf is the porosity [].
In this research, a high-resolution mesh was generated for the drainage network. The small size of the elements is necessary
to achieve a more accurate solution at the nodes defined by drainage conditions (Rao 2011). Also, FEFLOW has the best per-
formance to interpolate maps within the finite elements using three interpolation methods with their respective property
settings: inverse distance, kriging, and Akima.
The results of the flow model simulation were presented in a previous paper that aimed to evaluate the drainage system
performance and the scenarios for the rehabilitation of the perimeter (Rzigui et al. 2022a, 2022b). The flow model simulation
shows that a water logging problem is present in the major parts of the perimeter due to the drainage system deficiency and
the low slope. Several management scheme scenarios were simulated. The three principal scenarios include: the drainage
system efficiency improvement by increasing the drain conductance from 105/s to 104/s (scenario 1), the reduction of
the water irrigation amount by applying a revised net recharge for the simulations where the new recharge rates are deter-
mined based on a 70% decrease in irrigation (scenario 2), and the third scenario illustrated the combination of the two
prior scenarios. The final scheme leads to resolving the problem, even in the lower parts.
The salt transport model is based on the flow model. Under transient conditions, the transport parameters are porosity,
molecular diffusion, and longitudinal and transverse dispersivity. Salt transport in the groundwater is considered non-reac-
tive. Boundary conditions are defined by a Dirichlet condition at the North boundaries (Medjerda wadi) and the east
boundary (sea) with a salinity of 1.5 and 35 g/l, respectively. A homogenous initial concentration of 3.5 g/l has been assigned
to the entire domain. This salinity corresponds to the salinity of the irrigation water. The aquifer porosity varies from 0.3 to
0.35. The α dispersion of the medium is defined by the ratio of dispersion to pore velocity. Two components of dispersivity are
distinguished: longitudinal dispersivity (αL: in the direction of flow) and transverse dispersivity (αT: perpendicular to the flow
direction). The ratio of transverse to longitudinal dispersivity is estimated to be 0.1. A longitudinal and transverse dispersiv-
ities of 100 and 10 m, respectively, have been used. Molecular diffusion coefficient values range from 10–10 to 1011 m2/s for a
non-reactive chemical species in clay placers.
3. RESULTS
3.1. Model calibration
Statistical parameters served as error criteria in the calibration and validation of the flow model, allowing for an evaluation of
the fit between observed and simulated groundwater data. The calibration process of the flow model was achieved with a
correlation coefficient of 0.98 and an root mean square (RMS) error of 0.51 m, indicating an appropriate match between
observed and calculated heads in 1949. A transient simulation was first run in 1990. The obtained correlation coefficient
of 0.85 shows a significant relationship between simulated and observed hydraulic levels all over 15 piezometers. After cali-
bration, the flow model was verified using a transient simulation from 1990 to 2017 showing a good agreement between the
computed and the observed heads of the transient models for the observation period 1990–2007 with a calculated mean RMS
error of 0.87 m. Due to the convective salt transport in the Cebala Borj-Touil aquifer, a steady-state solute transport model
calibration is not possible. The groundwater flux defined by the flow model is the main factor in the salinity distribution.
The calibration of the solute model was conducted using a transient calibrated flow model based on the reference salinity
map (Section 2.2).
The objective of this step was to calculate the salt concentration with the transient model and compare it with the measured
concentration. The model validation also included the spatial distribution of salt concentrations in 2018 (Figure 5). This sal-
inity map was used as the initial value map for the scenarios.
The water table salinity within the perimeter varies between 6.7 and 15 g/l. The salinity tends to increase from west to east
(boundary with the sea). The minimum salinity concentrations of 6.7 g/l are observed locally at the entrance of the Khelidj wadi.
Figure 6 | Calculated salinity (g/l) in 2050 with a 15% decrease in precipitation (scenario 1).
The absolute value of the increase depends on the distance of the observation point from the sea. Figure 7 shows the value
of two selected piezometers (piez) 2 and 17, located, respectively, 11 and 6.5 km from the sea.
The closer the piezometer is to the sea, the greater the impact of rising sea levels with an increase in water salinity of 66 and
74% for the observation points piez 2 and piez 17, respectively.
4. DISCUSSION
In this paper, the salinization of the shallow groundwater in the irrigation perimeter of Cebala Borj-Touil was analyzed. In
coastal areas, the salinization of aquifers is also linked to natural factors such as the impacts of CC (Greene et al. 2016).
The dynamics of the groundwater salinity in Cebala Borj-Touil are complex. In all scenarios, an increase in the salinity of
groundwater from 17 to 150% is observed. Simulation results show good agreement with the literature. In coastal areas,
groundwater salinity would increase by 14% in 2050, due to CC impacts (Islam et al. 2020). This alarming development is
caused by the coastal location, the semi-arid climate, and the increased anthropogenic factors. Several studies (Akbari
Figure 7 | Spatial distribution of salinity (a) and variation in salinity at piezometers piez 2 and piez 17 (b) with a sea level rise of 0.2 m
(scenario 2).
et al. 2020; Castaño-Sánchez et al. 2020; Soundala & Saraphirom 2022) highlight that the repercussions of sea level rise are
considerably more pronounced. The findings correspond with the outcomes observed in the Cebala case study. The impact of
reduced rainfall will be evident. The salinity of Cebala groundwater exceeds 10 g/l. An increase in the frequency and intensity
of rainfall enhances the downward movement of chemicals from the surface and vadose zone, leading to a greater influx of
suspended and dissolved solids into aquifers (Dao et al. 2024). CC will lead to an increase in soil and water salinity, which
will affect irrigation water quality. The decline in water irrigation quality highlights a crucial potential impact on the saliniza-
tion of the groundwater in the Cebala soil. Scenario 3 suggests that salinity could reach a maximum of 20 g/l by 2050.
Figure 8 | Calculated salinity in 2050 (a) and variation in salinity at piezometers piez 2, 28, and 41 (b) with irrigation water concentration of
5 g/l (scenario 3).
The combined scenarios (scenario 4) indicate that the maximum soil salinity reaches 25 g/l. Such a condition may result in
unrealistic findings, as the negative impact on production would necessitate the cessation of irrigation. Such a situation is
present in various deltaic areas across numerous semi-arid and arid areas. The Cebala case study exemplifies the complexities
involved. Therefore, these results should be generalized with caution. The distinct nature of the region and the selected model
may result in particular outcomes. Despite its limitations in illustrating salt chemistry in soils, the model is still a practical tool
to deal with data scarcity. The FEFLOW model demonstrates a strong capability to simulate groundwater salinization in var-
ious climate scenarios (Lam et al. 2021; Yang et al. 2023). The validation of the model’s results remains challenging because
of the issues of data scarcity. Also, in all studies concerning the impacts of CC, there is always an inherent uncertainty in
climate scenarios due to an insufficient understanding of greenhouse gas emissions (Xepapadeas 2024). According to Noua-
ceur & Mură rescu (2016), current climate data from Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia do not match the forecasts related to CC.
Figure 9 | Spatial distribution of salinity: (a) (scenario 1 þ 3), (b) (scenario 2 þ 3).
Nevertheless, the findings from this research on the Cebala Borj-Touil case remain pertinent and advantageous for the inves-
tigation of irrigation perimeter rehabilitation.
5. CONCLUSION
The main objective of this work is the development of a transport model for the salinization of the Cebala Borj-Touil per-
imeter and its future evolution under the impact of CC. The validated flow model made it possible to map the spatial
distribution of salinity in 2018, which confirms the persistence of widespread salinization throughout the perimeter. The
results of the climate scenarios simulations show that the salinity of the groundwater tends to increase particularly under
the effect of sea level rise. A decrease of 15% in precipitation leads to an increase in salinity across nearly the entire aquifer,
averaging 10–15 g/l. The rise in sea level has a pronounced effect on the salinization process. Seawater intrusion leads to a
water concentration between 16 and 20 g/l. The impact of irrigation is very pronounced. High salt concentrations in irrigation
accelerate the salinity levels in groundwater, with increases exceeding 100%. All combined scenarios involving the use of irri-
gation water at a concentration of 5 g/l show a groundwater salinity level greater than 20 g/l by 2050 in the entire area.
Although these results are alarming, they remain largely hypothetical, as irrigation is usually stopped when soil salinity
begins to affect plant growth negatively. These results can serve as a basis for decision-making about the rehabilitation of
the perimeter. However, it is recommended to conduct more sophisticated studies aimed at reducing uncertainties by exam-
ining additional factors and updating the groundwater salinity measurements.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to acknowledge DHI-WASY for providing a FEFLOW license for the current study.
FUNDING
No funding was received for conducting this study.
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS
R.H., M.H., and W.B. contributed to the study’s conception and design. Material preparation, data collection, and analysis
were performed by R.H. and H.G. The first draft of the manuscript was written by R.H. and all authors commented on pre-
vious versions of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors declare there is no conflict.
REFERENCES
Akbari, M., Alamdarlo, H. N. & Mosavi, S. H. (2020) The effects of climate change and groundwater salinity on farmers’ income risk,
Ecological Indicators, 110, 105893. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolind.2019.105893.
Ansari, A., Meera, V. & Vinod, P. (2024) Modelling of seawater intrusion in Munroe island, Kollam district, Kerala, India, Reference IOP
Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science IOP Publishing, p. 012141.
Baccouche, H., Lincker, M., Akrout, H., Mellah, T., Armando, Y. & Schäfer, G. (2024) Quantitative groundwater modelling under data
scarcity: The example of the Wadi El Bey coastal aquifer (Tunisia), Water-Sui, 16, 522.
Bahri, E., Zammouri, M. & Hachicha, M. (2015) Development of a flow and transport model for drainage network conception in northern
Tunisia, Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, 142 (1), 13. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)IR.1943-4774.0000934.
Barica, J. (1972) Salinization of groundwater in arid zones, Water Research, 6, 925–933.
Castaño-Sánchez, A., Hose, G. C. & Reboleira, A. S. P. S. (2020) Salinity and temperature increase impact groundwater crustaceans, Scientific
Reports, 10, 12328. DOI 10.1038/s41598-020-69050-7.
Colombani, N., Osti, A., Volta, G. & Mastrocicco, M. (2016) Impact of climate change on salinization of coastal water resources, Water
Resources Management, 30, 2483–2496. DOI 10.1007/s11269-016-1292-z.
Dahmouni, M., Hoermann, G., Jouzdan, O. & Hachicha, M. (2017) Export of salt and heavy metals in an area irrigated with treated
wastewater: A case study from Cebala Borj-Touil (Tunisia), Desalination and Water Treatment, 102, 61–70. DOI 10.5004/
dwt.2018.21825.
Dao, P. U., Heuzard, A. G., Le, T. X. H., Zhao, J., Yin, R., Shang, C. & Fan, C. (2024) The impacts of climate change on groundwater quality: A
review, Science of The Total Environment, 912, 169241. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.169241.
El oumlouki, K., Moussadek, R., Douaik, A., Iaaich, H., Dakak, H., Chati, M. T., Ghanimi, A., El Midaoui, A., El Amrani, M. & Zouahri, A.
(2018) Evaluation of the salinity of groundwater used for irrigation and risks of soil degradation: Case study of the ISSEN perimeter in
the Souss-Massa, Morocco, Irrigation and Drainage, 67, 38–51. https://doi.org/10.1002/ird.2209.
Foster, S. & Chilton, P. (2003) Groundwater: The processes and global significance of aquifer degradation, Philosophical Transactions of the
Royal Society of London Series B: Biological Sciences, 358, 1957–1972.
Giorgi, F. (2008) Régionalisation de l’information sur les changements climatiques pour les évaluations des incidences et l’adaptation,
Bulletin de L’Organisation Météorologique Mondiale, 57, 86–92.
Greene, R., Timms, W., Rengasamy, P., Arshad, M., Cresswell, R., (2016) Soil and aquifer salinization: Toward an integrated approach for
salinity management of groundwater. In: Jakeman, A. J., Barreteau, O., Hunt, R. J., Rinaudo, J.-D. & Ross, A. (eds.) Integrated
Groundwater Management: Concepts, Approaches and Challenges, Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp. 377–412.
Hachicha, M. & Job, J.-O. (1994) Suivi de la salure des périmètres irrigués de tunisie par conductivimétrie électromagnétique (1989–1993):
Rapport final. Soil direction. Ministry of Agriculture, Water Resources and Fisheries, Tunisia, 87 pp.
Hachicha, M., Trabelsi, A. & Daoud, F. (1990) [Salinity control in the ppi: Permeability and salinity studies in the pi of [sebala-irrigation using
sewage water]. [French].
Hassine, H. B. (2005) Effets de la nappe phréatique sur la salinisation des sols de cinq périmètres irrigués en tunisie, Étude et Gestion des
Sols, 12, 281–300.
Hernot, A. (1949) Hydraulic Study of the Lower Mejerda. Tunis: Reference DGRE, p. 33.
Huyakorn, P. & Pinder, G. (1983) Computational Methods in Subsurface Flow. Academic Press, New York, p. 473.
IPCC (2014) Core Writing Team, Pachauri, R. K. & Meyer, L. A. (eds). Climate change. Reference Synthesis Report. IPCC, Geneva,
Switzerland, 151, pp.
Islam, M. T., Duti, B. M., Hasan, M. R., Rahman, M. A. & Sahabuddin, S. (2020) Groundwater salinity modelling in the south west region of
Bangladesh considering climate change, Journal of the Indian Society of Coastal Agricultural Research, 38 (2), 7–84.
Koskinen, L., Laitinen, M., Lofman, J., Meling, K. & Meszaros, F. (1996) Feflow: A finite element code for simulating groundwater flow, heat
transfer and solute transport, Reference Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, 10, 287–296.
Lam, Q. D., Meon, G. & Pätsch, M. (2021) Coupled modelling approach to assess effects of climate change on a coastal groundwater system,
Groundwater for Sustainable Development, 14, 100633. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsd.2021.100633.
Leavesley, G. H. (1994) Modeling the effects of climate change on water resources – A review, Assessing the Impacts of Climate Change on
Natural Resource Systems, 28, 159–177 https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01094105.
Li, K., Liu, H., He, X. & Li, X. (2019) Simulation of water and salt transport in soil under pipe drainage and drip irrigation conditions in
Xinjiang, Water-Sui, 11, 2456. doi:10.3390/w11122456.
Luo, J., Monninkhoff, B., Schätzl, P., Seifert, S., Becker, J. K., Gmünder, C. & Jordan, P. (2013) Elaboration of groundwater models for deep
geological repository sites by using feflow, Paper Presented at the MODFLOW and More 2013: Translating Science Into Practice 2013.
Mastrocicco, M. & Colombani, N. (2021) The issue of groundwater salinization in coastal areas of the Mediterranean region: A review,
Water-Sui, 13, 90.
Nouaceur, Z. & Mură rescu, O. (2016) Rainfall variability and trend analysis of annual rainfall in north Africa, International Journal of
Atmospheric Sciences, 2016, 12. https://doi.org/10.1155/2016/7230450.
Rao, S. S. (2011) Discretization of the domain. In: Rao, S. S. (ed.) The Finite Element Method in Engineering, Butterworth-Heinemann, pp.
53–73. doi:10.1016/b978-1-85617-661-3.00002-7.
Rzigui, H., Bogacki, W., Hörmann, G. & Hachicha, M. (2022a) Groundwater modelling of a shallow aquifer for the assessment of water
logging: A case study of the Cebala Borj-Touil irrigation perimeter, northern Tunisia, Irrigation and Drainage, 71, 1379–1395.
Rzigui, H., Dahmouni, M., Hörmann, G., Bogacki, W. & Hachicha, M. (2022b) Assessment of soil salinity in Cebala Borj-Touil irrigated area
under different climate change scenarios (northeastern Tunisia): Application of SaltMod tool, Journal of New Sciences, 90 (6),
5122–5132.
Sefiani, S., El Mandour, A., Laftouhi, N., Khalil, N., Chehbouni, A., Jarlan, L., Hanich, L., Khabba, S., Kamal, S. & Markhi, A. (2019)
Evaluation of groundwater quality and agricultural use under a semi-arid environment: Case of Agafay, Western Haouz, Morocco,
Irrigation and Drainage, 68, 778–796.
Sinaba, B., Schüttrumpf, H. & Becker, B. P. J. (2009). Specific demands and solutions regarding the FEFLOW large scale groundwater model
“Erftscholle, Rurscholle and Venloer scholle”, Conference Paper. Paper Presented at the 2nd International FEFLOW User Conference.
Potsdam, Germany.
Soundala, P. & Saraphirom, P. (2022) Impact of climate change on groundwater recharge and salinity distribution in the Vientiane basin, Lao
PDR, Journal of Water and Climate Change, 13, 3812–3829. https://doi.org/10.2166/wcc.2022.161.
Wang, D., Li, P., He, X. & He, S. (2023) Exploring the response of shallow groundwater to precipitation in the northern piedmont of the
Qinling mountains, China, Urban Climate, 47, 101379. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.uclim.2022.101379.
Xepapadeas, A. (2024) Uncertainty and climate change: The IPCC approach vs decision theory, Journal of Behavioral and Experimental
Economics, 109, 102188. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socec.2024.102188.
Yang, H., Yang, T., Yang, F. & Yang, X. (2023) Assessment of groundwater salinization impact in coastal aquifers based on the shared
socioeconomic pathways: An integrated modeling approach, Environmental Research, 234, 116618. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.
2023.116618.
First received 1 June 2024; accepted in revised form 4 December 2024. Available online 20 December 2024