IFSA LSR Case Competition Guidebook
IFSA LSR Case Competition Guidebook
COMPETITIONS
THE ULTIMATE GUIDEBOOK
2024
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This booklet represents the collaborative effort of the entire IFSA LSR team. We extend our
heartfelt appreciation to the following individuals for their unwavering support and cooperation
which have been instrumental in crafting this comprehensive resource. This booklet draws from
a wealth of successful strategies, innovative solutions, and effective presentation techniques that
have proven triumphant in various prestigious case competitions. By compiling these insights, we
aim to provide students with a robust toolkit for tackling complex business problems, developing
compelling recommendations, and delivering persuasive presentations.
Written by:
1. Aanya Maheshwari
2. Akshata Kalyanaraman
3. Apoorva Jain
4. Asmi Chawla
5. Bhavya Agarwal
6. Dhaani Sood
7. Jiya Agarwal
8. Mishka Narang
9. Pakhi Priya
10. Rupali Bhalla
11. Sana Gupta
12. Sanya Rao
13. Unnati Hirwani
Designed by:
1. Aditi Gagrani
2. Gitan Chopra
3. Gunjan Arora
4. Navya Garg
5. Pakhi Priya
6. Saumya Gupta
7. Shreyanshi Khowal
8. Tamanna Sharma
9. Vaishnavi
IFSA-LSR
INDEX
Basic Frameworks 9
IFSA-LSR
INTRODUCTION TO CASE COMPETITIONS
REAL-WORLD SIMULATION
FAR-REACHING BENEFITS
Case competitions are popular not just for their academic value but also for
their capacity to develop strategic planning skills and critical thinking
necessary for success in today's competitive environment.
UNSTOP
Formerly known as Dare2Compete, Unstop is a platform
designed for individuals new to case events and hosts the
majority of college-level competitions.
CONSULTING COMPANIES
Firms such as EY, BCG, HSBC, etc have regular case
competitions. They use these case competitions to analyze
the contestants and hire them as interns.
LINKEDIN POSTS
Follow relevant business organizations on LinkedIn for
updates on case competitions they organize or sponsor.
MARKETING
Entails issues in marketing of a product/service, resulting in lesser sales or visitors, or issues in current
market strategy.
It is expected to devise the following strategies-
Marketing strategy for the launch of a new product/service OR revamping of an older one
Designing a marketing campaign for better outreach
Identifying the target customer segment, and proposing a tailored strategy
GROWTH
Entails issues in long/mid/short term growth, or aiming to reach X% of growth.
It is expected to -
Judge upon past performance
Identify factors affecting growth
Find ways to reach the target growth
Prepare a year-on-year comprehensive plan for achieving the target
Example: A mid-sized software startup seeks to overcome stagnant growth. The goal is to develop a
growth plan incorporating marketing and strategic partnerships.
PROFITABILITY
Entails issues in decline in revenue or rise in costs of a firm/company and finding ways to increase profits.
It is expected to analyse past performance and give strategies to-
Increase revenue (year-on-year & long term) or/and reduction in costs
Assessing whether a new product/diversification affects profits
Doing a cost-benefit analysis of any proposed solution
Example: A restaurant chain has seen profits stagnate recently despite an increase in customers,
what can be the reason?
PRICING
Entails issues of fixing a price for a newly launched product/service
It is expected to understand the product features and the industry to come up with a price, based on-
Competitor-based pricing- determining price based on
How competitors price it
Value-based pricing- determining price based on the
Demand of the product
Cost-based pricing- determining price based on the cost of the production
Example: A vaccine company recently launched COVID-19 vaccines. Devise a pricing strategy for the
same.
Entails cases where a company undertakes decisions to acquire/combine/merge with another company.
It is expected to do an analysis on the to-be acquired company and propose solutions like-
Feasibility of the strategic decision, in terms of costs and benefits
Relations with all the involved stakeholders
Risk assessment and mitigation
Example: A company named BGC., is planning to merge with a renowned AI startup, to increase its
potential in AI. Evaluate the same by identifying a rationale.
MARKET ENTRY
Entails cases of entering into a new market in terms of geography (new city/country), product (new
product/service or diversification), or customer segment (targeting a different customer base). It is
expected to do an analysis of the current market and the features of the company and see:
Feasibility of entering (in arenas described above)
The solution regarding the same and its short/long term impacts
Example: A leading car rental company wishes to expand into the Middle East. Is it feasible? Devise a
suitable strategy.
BUSINESS PLANS
Entails cases where one needs to lay out business’s details, like what the business does, the resources it
needs, its future trajectory, and the execution of the business plan.
It is expected to provide details on-
What the company does?
Analysis of the market the company functions in
Analysis of the competitors
How to market the existing/new products?
Long-term development plan, and feasibility of the solutions
Example: Devising a business plan for a Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) set to launch in Pune (or
any other tier 1 city of India).
SOCIAL IMPACT
Entails cases centering around creating a positive social, environmental, or economic impact. Solutions are
provided to private companies, NGOs, the government and authorities It is expected to research details
such as-
The stakeholders (international/national/state/district
level) and find the impact of the solutions
Clarify beforehand what success looks like to the company or authority facing the issue
Search for practical solutions that worked in the past. If an entirely new solution: implement on
smaller scale first
Example: Gender inequality in STEM persists across India. You have to devise a strategy for Ministry of
Education, Government of India to solve this problem.
UNCONVENTIONAL
Entails cases where the solution doesn't seem to fit in any conventional framework. These range over
broader topics like crisis management (PR disaster), climate change, CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility)
etc. It is expected to do an analysis and identify the following-
The core issue and analysis of the overall problem
Applying frameworks only if suitable (not trying to fit in any model uselessly)
Coming up with solutions keeping the MECE approach in mind
Example: A church in Mumbai is seeing decreased donations over the past three months. What can be the
cause?
FRAMEWORKS
Frameworks are structured approaches to analyzing problems. They typically consist of a set of steps or
questions that guide the analysis process.
MATRICES
Matrices are visual tools used to organize and analyze information. They are typically used to compare and
contrast different options or alternatives.
GOVERNANCE ADMINISTRATION
LEGITIMACY
AND SUPPORT
OPERATIONAL
CAPACITY
EXAMPLE
2
STRUCTURED APPROACH
By providing a structured approach to analysis, frameworks and matrices can help identify the
most critical issues and focus areas.
Where to use: industry analysis, market entry strategy, identifying areas for innovation or
understanding dynamics of profitability in an industry
It involves identifying external factors that can influence a company's growth and performance. It
examines the threats and opportunities arising from the same.
POLITICAL
P Fiscal policy
Government laws
Taxes
ENVIRONMENT Stability of the govt
Environmental policies
Consumption trends
E
Production processes
Climate change impact
S SOCIAL
Demographic variables
Cultural factors
Consumer lifestyle
TECHNOLOGY
T
Consumer attitudes
Technological access
Infrastructure
Research Cyber
L
security
LEGAL
Labour laws
Industry regulations
Job security and wages
ECONOMIC
E
License/permit rules
GDP
Employment rate
Exchange rate
Inflation
Where to use: Doing research on external factors influencing an industry, in market entry cases
(such as, launch of a new product), or in marketing strategy cases (how could these external factors
impact marketing)
S W
O T
Market expansion due to growing Illegal streaming
internet usage Competition from other
DVD purchase & rentals declining streaming platforms (like Hulu,
Telecom partnerships Prime, etc.)
Media company demanding
higher payment
Where to use: market entry cases (new opportunities/increase visibility in a new market), marketing
strategy cases (know where the company lacks, and what areas to focus on), growth cases (how
internal/external factors can impact a company's performance).
P RODUCT
Features like packaging, customer's expectations that differentiates it from a
competitor's product.
P LACE
P
Product’s location (offline/online) and of the outlet. Involves a distribution
system: which transportation or storage channel is suited for the company.
P RICE
The right price that consumers are willing to pay and that brings in the
maximum benefit to the company.
P ROMOTION
This involves strategy regarding advertisement, and making the product
cognitively available.
PRODUCT PRICE
A variety of caffeinated drinks and a Premium price because of the
distinct ambience unavailable before uniqueness of the American market and
Starbucks in the US. the willingness of people to pay.
PLACE PROMOTION
Establishing themselves as a coffee-to- Addresses its modern clientele using
go place, set up coffee shops in places mobile apps, social networks, and
with high frequency of customers other types of viral marketing.
Where to use: Gives overall understanding of the market landscape. However, if we go into
specifics, it is of use in marketing-related cases.
COMPANY CUSTOMERS
Internal factors, like: Segment base, like:
Core competency, mission & vision Target customers
Strengths and weakness Their needs and wants
Brand reputation Their purchasing behaviour
Details of product & value chains Their demography and lifestyle
Source of financial resources Customer psychographics
COMPETITORS
Focus on their profile, like:
Primary competitors
C COLLABORATORS
Multiple stakeholders, like:
Details of suppliers
Their strengths & weaknesses Details of distribution channels
Their market share Strategic partnerships
Their pricing strategy Relationship with stakeholders
Their marketing strategy Regulatory environment details
CONTEXT
Overall trends, like:
Market size and growth rate
Macroeconomic conditions
Industry trends
Technological level & access
Political and legal factors
Where to use: assess opportunities, competitive positioning and the potential collaborations in
developing marketing strategies.
CUSTOMER COMPETITOR
In-depth customer research, like- Competitors’ profile, like-
Different customer segments Market share of the competitors
Their needs and preferences Their revenue/growth strategy
Their purchasing behaviour Their competitive strategy
COMPANY PRODUCT
Analyzing own company, like- Details of the product, like-
Key strengths and weaknesses Product’s features & its cost
Structure of the business and its past Its substitutes and complements
performance Marketing strategy to be employed
Capability gaps
Where to use: gives overall understanding of the market landscape. However, if we go into
specifics, it is of use in marketing-related cases.
For external factors and collaboration opportunities, opt for 5C’s framework.
For a concise analysis concentrating on core market elements, opt for 3C's framework.
Invest in these as they have high future Invest or discard, depending on their chances of
?
LANCÔME
High
PARIS L’ORÉAL
ARMANI MEN EXPERT
beauty
Market growth rate
MAYBELLINE
NEW YORK
KÉRASTASE
GARNI eR
Low PARIS
High Low
Where to use: brand marketing and product management based on the growth potential and market
position of different products. However specifically, it is of use in marketing-related cases.
Increasing Risk
(like advanced AirPods)
iPhones within USA
Increasing Risk
Where to use: can be used to prioritize work, but specifically in growth cases, or market entry
ones as it helps evaluate and prioritize strategies.
Assesses tasks and prioritizes them based on potential impact and effort required. The matrix is
divided into four quadrants, each representing a different type of task.
- +
Upgrading of Only maintaining older
employee handbook recharge stations
Redesigning company Engaging in avoidable
logo disputes
-
IMPACT
Impact-Effort Matrix Example of an EV Company
Where to use: Help assess business’s current position and potential growth avenues, which
align well with growth-related case.
Read the problem statement or case prompt thoroughly first. Start by skimming
through the case study and carefully reading the first and last paragraph that will
offer you a gist of the case.
Highlight key information, take notes on unclear details, and read between the
lines of the case, including footnotes and exhibits.
Try to highlight the key question,the limitations and challenges (as mentioned in
the problem statement) and the prospective solutions that the case requires you
to develop. Determine the primary problems that require attention.
Gathering information:
Primary Data: In case of any gaps in the secondary data that can be bridged
through the availability of any additional information based on the opinions of
the general public, rely on the collection of primary data. Most common ways
of collecting such insights are online and offline surveys.
1.
2.
WHERE TO USE
It is versatile and adaptable to various cases. For example:
1. In market entry, it helps to analyze factors such as market demand, competitive landscape, regulatory
environment.
2. In profitability, it can help dissect cost and revenue structures.
3. In marketing strategy-related cases, it can help break down customer segmentation, pricing strategies,
distribution channels.
I FISFAS -AL-SLRS R B A S I CH O
FRWATO
M ESTRUC
W O R KTS
U RAENRDE SM
EAARTCH
RICES page 17
page 18
TYPES OF ISSUE TREES
PROBLEM-BASED TREES
Here, the aim is to determine the root cause of the problem, by breaking down the overarching issue
into smaller branches. The goal is to find out ‘why’ it's occurring.
SOLUTION-BASED TREES
Here, the aim is to determine recommendations for solving any problem, or rather focus on the ‘how’
to fix the issue at hand.
Continuous
Diverse Skill Research, Analysis,
Improvement
Sets and Innovative
& Positive Attitude
Thinking
Adaptability Effective
Attention to
and Communication
Detail
Flexibility and Clear Roles
Competition Requirements
Understand the requirements of the competition or project you're tackling. This includes knowing
the scope, objectives, deadlines, and any specific skills or expertise needed.
Open communication within the team. Encourage team members to share their ideas,
concerns, and progress regularly. Ensure everyone stays informed.
Once you know what skills are necessary, identify individuals who possess those skills or have
the potential to acquire them.
Set goals
Define clear and achievable goals for the team. These goals should be specific, measurable,
attainable, relevant, and time-bound.
I FISFAS -AL-SLRS R MA
BASIC FR AM
K ING
EWOTHE
R K IDE
S AANLDT EMAA
MT R I C E S page 17
page 20
ROLES OF TEAM MEMBERS
Industry Trends:
Discuss relevant trends (such as headwinds and
tailwinds) that affect the client’s business using charts or
graphs. In case of an analysis presented for a company,
discuss the business model, current pitfalls being faced,
USP, etc.
Market Analysis:
Market Analysis:
Then focus on the target market with visuals like market segmentation charts. One can also guesstimate
the market size (TAM, SAM, SOM) in case adequate data is not available.
Competitive Landscape:
After that analyze competitors using a SWOT matrix or other.
Tip: For Canva, You can use pre-designed SWOT matrix templates. In MS PowerPoint, you can create
tables with clear sections for strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. You can also use other
frameworks as specified such as Porter’s 5 Forces for deep risk analysis, etc. You can also use a
positioning map.
Financial Performance:
Review the financials with clear charts or graphs showing revenue, profitability, and cost structure.
Tip: Try to utilize and incorporate lots of pie charts, bar graphs, or line graphs to showcase the financial
data.
IFSA-LSR P R EPSRE
ENSENTATION
T A T I O N SSTTRU
UCCTTUU
RREE page 23
PRESENTATION STRUCTURE
Then state your preferred solution. You also have to justify it based on the analysis, highlight potential
challenges, and risk mitigation strategies. Create a table comparing solutions. Include columns for each
solution, outlining its key features, advantages, and disadvantages. Solutions can be evaluated based on
investment required, degree of impact, complexity of implementation, duration of implementation,
analysis method for impact calculation, and overall attractiveness.
IFSA-LSR P R EPSRE
ENSENTATION
T A T I O N SSTTRU
UCCTTUU
RREE page 24
PRESENTATION STRUCTURE
Utilize icons or checkmarks (such as pie charts, and heatmaps) for visual clarity. Explain why it
best addresses the concerned client's problem.
Tip: You can use a heatmap to show the degree of impact (impact and profitability on the X-Y axis
respectively) or to conduct a feasibility analysis of the solution by plotting the importance of a feature
to the company and the consumer on either axis respectively.
CONCLUSION
PRESENTATION STRUCTURE
IFSA-LSR P R E SENTATION S T R U C T U R E page 25
PRESENTATION STRUCTURE
TIP: Always mention the assumptions being made in such a case. Also, try to show the growth and
revenue projections before and after the recommended strategy was implemented to reflect
incremental impact.
APPENDIX
A section at the end of a paper that includes information that is too detailed for the text of the paper
itself and would "burden the reader" or be "distracting," or "inappropriate".
The proper presentation of the Appendix is equally important. In corporate competitions of massive
scale, the appendix might be more extensive than the actual pitch deck, which can indicate how
detailed and comprehensive the research is.
Include the financial data, all links (numbered), followed by pie charts/analyses cited in the
presentation through primary research.
IFSA-LSR P RPERSEE
SENTATION
N T A T I O N SSTT
RRUU
C TCUTRU
ER E page 26
HOW TO DEAL WITH FINANCIALS
SOURCES OF DATA
Government based
provides insightful gov. data, but
could be complex to comprehend
You need to be comfortable with financial modeling In Excel after gathering the data.
Future projections based on this data need to be added, therefore you often need to find the
market size and CAGR, say at least 5 years in the future (to show the feasibility of the solution).
GUESSTIMATES
Net present value (NPV) is the difference Revenue streams are the various sources
between the present value of cash from which a business earns money from
inflows and the present value of cash the sale of goods or the provision of
outflows over a period of time. services. Calculate this through your
revenue projections.
Click here for the video. Click here for the video.
The compound annual growth rate (CAGR) is the annualized average rate of revenue growth
between two given years, assuming growth takes place at an exponentially compounded rate.
Its formula is given by:
Therefore, the estimated market size of the tea industry after 5 years is approximately
$852.06 billion.
IFSA-LSR PNREECSESSARY
E N T A TFINA
I O NNS
CTI ARLUACST
PEUCRTE
S page 31
NECESSARY FINANCIAL ASPECTS
Now, let’s look at reverse calculation to arrive at the initial value using an
example.
PROBLEM: The bamboo toothbrush industry is projected to have a CAGR of 15% for the next 10
years. If the market size of the industry 10 years later is estimated to be $50 million, then
determine the current market size.
Therefore, the estimated market size of the bamboo toothbrush industry based on the
given information is $14.3 million approximately.
TYPES OF
TYPES OFPRESENTATION
PRESENTATIONS
SUBMISSION PRESENTATION
These kinds of presentations are viewed on These are displayed on a projector and are
a laptop by a single viewer. They have to be viewed by a large audience. They must be
made text-heavy so that the reader can made less text-heavy because the presenter
understand our main idea gives detailed explanations about the
comprehensively. Moreover, it is important central idea to the audience himself. Such
to mention your references in the notes presentations must include catchy visuals to
section because by citing sources we give make them look more attractive and
credit to the original author's ideas and engaging to the audience. Lastly, the
avoid the unethical act of presenting them presenter must always keep track of time,
as your own. This also helps to avoid which is the sole and most important
plagiarism. constraint of presentations of this sort.
GENERAL TIPS
1. ROUGH OUTLINE
Prepare a rough outline of the slide on a rough page to know how your slide will look. This will help you to
organize your thoughts and prevent you from forgetting important points.
2. BACKGROUND
ugh Outlin
o
Use a white background to make your presentation look more professional in style. Moreover, white
provides a neutral base that allows the reader to focus completely on the information and arguments
R
3. COLOR SCHEME
Make use of the same color scheme as that of the company being referred to. Doing so creates a sense of
cohesiveness and professionalism. It shows that you have paid attention to detail and have tried to
present your ideas in a way that complements the company's image.
STORYBOARDING
1
DRAFT STORYLINE
Draft a rough storyline and a flow of the presentation containing just the headings. This gives you
a clear vision of the content that has to be presented on the slide.
2
CLARITY AND FLOW
Use arrows to indicate flow in the PPT, and light dotted lines to demarcate zones and spaces in
the PPT.
3
HEADINGS AND TITLES
Storytelling is to be done through titles and subheadings, as headings break down complex
information into easily understandable points, which helps the audience to quickly grasp the main
ideas and follow the overall flow.
4
CONTENT
The description of the content must be to the point; time and content constraints must be kept
in mind. It must also be very professional. Proof of concepts must be included wherever
necessary, and quantification must be done wherever possible.
FORMATTING
USE WHITESPACES
1 Avoid making slides text-heavy and focus more on the backend research.
Making use of whitespace separates text and visuals, preventing clutter and providing a balanced
look to the audience. This makes your slides easier to read and absorb for the audience.
2
PROFESSIONAL
Keep the typography and graphic representation as professional as possible.
3 Proper page numbers are essential for referencing information within a document or from other
sources. This allows readers to easily locate specific sections of text.
CONTENT FORMATTING
4 Keep the size of the font uniform throughout. Bold important information to make this text
stand out from the rest of the slide. This helps to grab the audience's attention towards the main
points and helps them remember the core takeaways of your presentation. But do not bold
unnecessary information.
THE IDEAL
FLOW:
CONTEXT
SUPPORT
SOLUTION
RISKS
Type the number ‘1’ in square brackets to insert the first hyperlink, like - [1]
Select the number along with brackets and click on the link symbol displayed on the home tab.
The final hyperlink would appear in the following format - [1]
If your PPT has to be submitted and the same has to be presented, you can include a reference
CRAFTING A SINGLE
document with more content that enables the reader to know more. You must then hyperlink this
document and include it in the appendix.
In the 1960s, Barbara Minto, a former McKinsey consultant, developed the Pyramid Principle to
effectively disseminate business information. This revolutionized the presentation of information in the
corporate world.
According to the principle, information should be presented in the following logical order:
This technique is highly useful because it enables us to catch attention fast with the most important message
in the slide. The information is presented in a concise manner, the conclusion is highlighted, and the focus is
on the key takeaway.
1 Information has been conveyed in a clear and concise manner. The description must always be
specific, concise, and insightful.
2 In case there are two charts, one message must be written per chart. This allows the reader to
digest the information gradually.
3
The title should highlight the salient features of the chart. This reduces readers’ effort to look for
inferences. For example, if there is a decline in the graph, the title must indicate that. This will
further be evident in the graph and hence allow for clear takeaways.
In essence, the action title must mention the key takeaway given by the data, why you are using
4 that graph, and what the purpose of the graph is in the slide or the deck. These features allow the
action title to provide complete context.
Ensure that your slide The action title must Considering humans’
does not contain too aptly describe the key short attention spans,
much text. If this occurs, takeaway from that placing the most
you will not be able to slide, and the subtitles important takeaways at
effectively draw the must support the claim the top or left to ensure
reader's attention to the you made in the title. that they are noticed first
main points. would be effective.
The pyramid principle, All charts must have a Finally, you must use clear
which involves presenting description to help graphs, highlight relevant
the key takeaway followed explain it. insights, and ensure that the
by supporting points, must slide flows from left to right.
be followed for a clear Alignment must be proper,
overall flow and margins must be
to the slide. maintained.
Refer all your solutions to some existing theory or example that a company has already done.
Compare instead of explain.
EXUDE CONFIDENCE
Rightly quoted by Marcus Garvey “With confidence, you have won
before you have started.” Exhibit a sense of confidence in your speech
and body language. Project your voice with clarity. Maintain eye contact
with the judges and remember to rehearse multiple times to build that
confidence in your delivery.
After the competition is over, ensure that you make the extra effort to approach the judges
and ask for feedback. Competitions can also be a great time to network, so if you find a
particular pitch that appeals to you or something you would like to refer to, don’t hesitate to
go and talk to other participants. The real win lies in knowledge sharing.
1. LISTEN ATTENTIVELY
Pay attention to the details of the question asked, the segment of the presentation from which it is
asked, and why the question could have popped up in the first place. Do not hesitate to seek
clarification on the question asked in case you fail to comprehend it initially.
6. BE HONEST
Do not sound overconfident. If you’re unsure about knowing the answer to a question, admit it rather
than beating around the bush. Besides, you can offer to follow up with additional information if
needed, that you were not able to cover during your presentation. You can also highlight your zeal to
learn more about the topic that would bring you into the good books.