ROP guide - draft
ROP guide - draft
MODEL UN
RULES OF PROCEDURE
Sai Sreemayee Sistla
Some points to bear in mind
1. A delegate represents his/her assigned country’s present government.
2. Different countries will have different approaches to the same problem, and in the UN (and MUN),
they are all allowed to voice theirs freely. Thus, debate is the most important part of MUN. One would
be giving speeches throughout the conference with complete adherence to their country’s stance.
3. Any formal suggestion to the committee is raised as a motion. If a delegate wants the committee to
implement something, he/she should raise a motion and suggest the same.
4. All motions will be voted upon. Most motions in MUN require a simple majority (atleast half of all
delegates who vote should be in favour) in most cases. Some need two-thirds in favour, called a
qualified majority.
5. If a generic motion passes with above 50% votes in favour, the suggestion will be taken up. Otherwise,
the motion will fail. Then, the next motion on the floor will be taken up.
6. The ‘floor’ is basically the delegate’s right to speak. If a delegate ‘has the floor for 60 seconds’, it
means that they can speak for the next 60 seconds.
7. In some cases, the Chair may pass a motion by his/her own will. In this case, the motion will not be
voted upon. It is considered as passed by the EB’s discretion.
8. Certain motions need to be seconded. They are debatable and require two delegates each supporting
them (in favour) and opposing them (against) to speak on them, before they are put to vote in
committee.
The Roll Call Vote is like attendance in a MUN. Raise the motion!
The chair calls out the names of countries from Chair: Delegates, are there any points or motions
a list of all the attending members in the on the floor?
house. (delegate of Chile raises his/her placard)
Chair: Yes, delegate of Chile?
When their country’s name is called out, the Chile: Motion to begin roll call vote.
delegate must clarify his/her voting stance. Chair: That motion is passed by the Chair’s
Voting Stances discretion/ in order. (motion passes if voted upon)
Chair: Delegate of Afghanistan?
A delegate can have any of these voting stances—
Afghanistan: Present.
i. Present; Chair: Delegate of Argentina?
ii. Present and Voting; and Argentina: Present and Voting.
iii. Absent (Chair proceeds to call out every member’s country
in an alphabetical order, they clarify their stances.)
The majorities
A simple majority needs (1/2 × quorum)+1 of votes The agenda
in favour to pass. The agenda is the main subject the committee
A qualified majority needs (2/3 × quorum) of votes is discussing. Sometimes, there may be more
in favour to pass. than one agenda for a committee to discuss.
After the Roll Call Vote, the committee Raise the motion!
proceeds into debate by opening the
General Speakers’ List (GSL), which is Chair: Delegates, are there any points or motions
moderated by the Chair. on the floor?
(delegate of Georgia raises his/her placard)
The GSL is, as the name suggests, a long list
Chair: Yes, delegate of Georgia?
of delegates who wish to address the
Georgia: Motion to begin GSL.
committee on the agenda.
Chair: That motion is in order.
It has no particular topic, and a delegate (voting on the motion)
may speak about anything that he/she Chair: Delegates in favour? (placards raised)
believes to be of pertinence and importance (assuming this motion passes)
to the committee and agenda. Chair: This motion clearly passes. All the delegates
By default, the speaker has the floor (can wishing to speak in the GSL?
speak) for 11/2 minutes in the GSL. (assuming three delegates raise their placards first)
(the chair recognises them, calls out their name, and
A speaker can add themselves back to the adds them to the list)
GSL after finishing their speech, by officially (after all delegates who want to speak are recognised,
notifying the Chair. the speakers begin to give their speeches.)
Delegates generally use the GSL to clarify
their country’s stance on the agenda or to Yields
define a roadmap for the committee.
If some time is left after a delegate’s GSL speech, he/
Exhaustion of the Speakers’ List (i.e. after she can—
the last speaker on the GSL makes their 1. Yield (give up) the time to the Chair;
speech) automatically closes debate, and 2. Yield the time to Points of Information
the committee moves into voting procedure (discussed later); or
after this happens. 3. Yield the time to another delegate.
Points are arguments presented to committee, generally made at the end of a speech (in the GSL or
a moderated caucus), or when the floor is open to them.
They are of four types, among which one (the Point of Order) has two subdivisions.
They are—
i) Point of Personal Privilege,
ii) Point of order
a) Logical fallacy
b) Factual inaccuracy
iii) Point of Parliamentary Enquiry, and
iv) Point of Information.
The points are listed above in the decreasing order of importance. Thus, points of personal privilege
have priority over all other points. This sequence is called the Order of Precedence.
Please note that a delegate may not interrupt a speaker with a point, unless it is a point of personal
privilege.
The Chair reserves the right not to entertain a point, if the delegate raising it did not show proper
restraint while doing so. Also, the point may not be taken if it is dilatory in nature.
Points must always be addressed to the Chair and not to another delegate.
Points
Point of Point of
Point of Point of
Personal Parliamentary
Order Information
Privilege Enquiry
Factual
Logical Fallacy
Inaccuracy
Concerning Concerning
Concerning Concerning
delegate’s clarifications
errors in a doubts regarding
comfort and (basically
speech ROP/committee
safety questions) on a
speech/resolution
(delegate of Armenia wants the windows shut (the Delegate of France is making a speech)
due to noise and raises his/her placard) France: ...and so, the Delegate of France believes that
all illegal weaponry should be banned.
Chair: Yes, delegate of Armenia?
(after speech)
Armenia: Point of personal privilege. Could Chair: Delegates, are there any points on that speech?
the delegate shut the windows due to (delegate of UAE raises placard)
excessive noise? Chair: Yes, delegate of the UAE?
(obtains permission and shuts the windows) UAE: Point of Order, logical fallacy. In his speech, the
delegate of France stated, (quote unquote) “All illegal
weaponry should be banned”. This statement is
logically fallacious. ‘Illegal weaponry’ cannot be
Point of
banned, as by definition, something that is banned has
parliamentary
already been made illegal.
enquiry
Concerning doubts regarding ROP/committee
(delegate of Belarus making a speech)
If a delegate happens to have any doubt
Belarus: ...the current Prime Minister of the UK, Mr
regarding the Rules of Procedure, or wants to
Donald J Trump…
know something about how committee
(after speech)
works, he/she must raise a Point of
Chair: Delegates, are there any points on that speech?
Parliamentary Enquiry.
(delegate of India raises placard)
Chair: Yes, delegate of India?
(floor open to points, a delegate shows placard) India: Point of Order, factual inaccuracy. In his
Chair: Yes, delegate? speech, the delegate of France stated, (quote
Delegate: Point of parliamentary enquiry. unquote) “the current Prime Minister of the UK, Mr
When would the delegate have to speak? Donald J Trump”. This statement is factually
(chair clarifies delegate’s position on the list) inaccurate as the PM of the UK is Mr Boris Johnson.
Moderated General
Caucuses speakers’ list
Right to reply
Motion to
The Right to Reply is a provision which allows
begin formal
delegates to counter any remark which has
session
challenged their country’s sovereignty and
integrity. It may also be exercised in case of
personal affronts or challenges.
Roll Call Vote
Motion to table
the debate
A motion to table the debate is raised when
General Speakers’ debate on a particular subject is to be
List temporarily suspended and resumed later. It
(formal debate) requires a qualified majority to pass.
Motion to close
the debate
Moderated Unmoderated
Caucuses Caucuses A motion to close the debate is raised when
(formal-informal (informal-informal all discussions relating to the agenda have
debate) debate) been completed, and the committee must
begin with the voting procedure (explained
later). It requires a qualified majority to pass.
A Resolution—what is it?
Extensive debate in committee leads to arrival at solutions for the agenda. The main result of the
committee will be a document called a resolution.
A resolution, as the name suggests, is meant to resolve the problem at hand—the agenda.
Resolutions are documents used by the UN to make decisions, and are written by groups of member
states (blocs).
A resolution has two main functions—
i. Determine role of the UN in the issue
ii. Recommend what individual member states could do about the issue
Resolutions are first introduced as draft resolutions in committee. Every bloc works on its own draft
resolution.
(source)
Draft Resolution—parts
A resolution has three parts.
1. Heading—Contains the basic information about the draft resolution, like title, committee,
agenda, names of sponsors and signatories, etc. (explained shortly)
2. Preambular clauses—These clauses make up the former part of a resolution and introduce the
agenda. They explain why agenda is of pertinence and begin with preambular phrases.
3. Operative clauses—These clauses make up the latter part of a resolution and enlist solutions to
the agenda. They explain what can be done to solve the issue and begin with operative phrases.
Note that a resolution is essentially one long sentence split into clauses, a period occurs only at the end.
There is a very particular format for the writing of a draft resolution, find it here.
Operative clauses
Make up the body of the resolution
Explain what can be done to solve the agenda
Begin with operative phrases
Are numbered
End with semicolons, except the last one which ends with a period
Can have sub-clauses and/or sub-sub-clauses—
Sub-clauses begin with lowercase alphabets (a, b, c, etc.)
Sub-sub-clauses begin with lowercase Roman numerals (i, ii, iii, etc.)
Can be amended
Find sample operative phrases here.
Signatories
Can every delegate in the bloc be a sponsor? (contributors)
No. There’s a limit to the number of sponsors a
draft resolution can have. However, there’s no
limit to the number of signatories a bloc/draft
resolution can have. More signatories equates to
more support for a draft resolution.
who work
on a Draft Resolution
After all blocs submit their draft resolutions to the Raise the motion!
Chair, the committee moves into the Question and (assume that Resolution Aries is on the floor)
Answer session. Chair: Delegates, are there any points or
Firstly, the draft resolutions are introduced in motions on the floor?
committee in the order of their submissions. That (delegate of Azerbaijan raises placard)
is, the first draft resolution to be submitted is Chair: Delegate of Azerbaijan?
introduced first. Azerbaijan: Motion to begin a Question and
The sponsors of the first draft resolution on the Answer Session on Resolution Aries.
floor read out every clause of the same. Chair: That motion is in order. (voting, the
Then, the floor opens to questions on the draft motion passes)
resolution. Chair: This motion passes. All delegates wishing
Questions can be posed by any member in the to ask questions? (delegates of Burkina Faso,
committee (including signatories and the Chair) South Korea, and Canada raise their placards)
except the sponsors of the draft resolution. The (they are recognised, ask their questions, sponsors
sponsors must respond to all questions. US/Austria/Italy answer them)
8 Amendments
Modification
A modification amendment changes a clause in the
Modification draft resolution. For example, adding a few words
to the clause, removing a few words from the
clause, or altering sub- and sub-sub-clauses.
Deletion
Deletion
A deletion amendment eliminates a whole clause of
the draft resolution.
Unfriendly amendments
Friendly Unfriendly An amendment that seeks to make such a revision to the draft
(welcome) (unwelcome) resolution that is deemed unwelcome and unsolicited by the
sponsors, is called an unfriendly amendment. These are voted upon.
adopted directly voted upon If they secure a simple majority of votes in favour, they pass and are
adopted anyway. If they do not secure the required simple majority,
they fail and are not adopted.
Examples
Consider a draft resolution with 24 clauses, with the following tally of amendments.
3
/24 = 1/8 < 2/3 are friendly 6
/24 = 1/4 < 1/3 are unfriendly
Consider a second draft resolution with 21 clauses, with the following tally of amendments.
If a draft resolution has successfully come through the amendment session, it is put to a final vote.
Voting on draft resolutions happens in rounds (usually three). This means that all the delegates in
attendance are first called out, and give their vote. After the last delegate votes, the cycle repeats once
again, all the delegates are called to reaffirm their vote in the same order, until all rounds of voting are
complete.
The six possible votes on a draft resolution are,
If a delegate casts a different vote in any of the three rounds, his/her vote in the last round of voting
will override all previous votes.
If a draft resolution passes in the final round of voting, the rest of the draft resolutions on the floor, yet
to be debated, are considered to have failed automatically. They will not be introduced.
The press session is a period in committee when reporters, known as press spokespersons, will
question some delegates on matters like their country’s stance, policies, and actions on any issue.
Any and all motions on the floor are briefly suspended when the press enters the committee.
A delegate will generally be asked about a topic on which his/her country has a controversial stance.
The press member may also ask the delegate some general questions about their country, or their
country’s stance on the agenda.
Delegates must, at all times, defend their country’s stance on any issue, past actions, and policies of
their nation.
It is important to be well-researched and acquainted with current affairs to face the press.
The press may also question a delegate on controversial statements or actions made or done by them
in committee, which is why one must be mindful of what they say or do in committee. Care must be
taken to ensure that one’s words and actions are in complete accordance with their country’s stance
and ideology.
The press session can happen at any given time.
Presentation of
draft resolution
if any draft
if it fails:
resolution on the
process Q&A session floor passes
repeats for
next draft
Committee resolution Amendments
fails on the floor
There are some advanced motions which are also covered under the Rules of Procedure. These include—
Motion to set the agenda, raised when a committee has two or more agendas and one has to be set.
Motion to re-order draft resolutions
Proposes to alter the order in which draft resolutions are introduced, debated, amended, and
voted upon.
Usually, draft resolutions are introduced in the order of their submissions, but this motion can
alter the order.
Motion for the division of the question
Proposes that every clause of the draft resolution be voted upon individually, as opposed to the
whole of the draft resolution being voted upon.
Clauses that fail the vote will be discarded.
It is not a very common motion and procedure regarding it varies widely.
The given list contains the names of some motions and the majorities they require.