Heritage Studies
Heritage Studies
CULTURAL HERITAGE
IN ZIMBABWE
Needs analysis of the sector:
skills gaps & shortages
Research findings to inform the development of future
programmes in the Museums and Cultural Heritage
sector in Zimbabwe
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 2
MUSEUMS AND
CULTURAL HERITAGE
IN ZIMBABWE
Needs analysis of the sector:
skills gaps & shortages
Research findings to inform the development of future
programmes in the Museums and Cultural Heritage
sector in Zimbabwe
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
Contents
Terrazzo sculpture of tortoise depicted besides the front of the Human Sciences museum. Generally the
September 2016 4 in sculptures, folklore and literary works represent many values associated with
portrayal of a tortoise
ubuntu(humility, wisdom, patience, perseverance etc)
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
Foreword
Sam Harvey
September 2016 5
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 6
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
Background and
To respond to the preliminary identification
research aims of a potential opportunity in country, a
As part of the larger Cultural Skills researcher from Cultural Skills worked
research project in Sub Saharan alongside British Council colleagues in
Africa, research has been undertaken Zimbabwe to develop the research tools,
in Zimbabwe to explore the skills gaps aims, and methodology. This research will
and shortages in the museums and inform prioritisation of skills needs and
cultural heritage sector. This preliminary development of various programmes.
piece of research provides an initial
understanding to inform future skills
Mode of Transport: Young boys riding a tamed oxen
September 2016 7
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
The research methodology managers, curators, specialists, triangulating them. The number of surveys
marketing managers, and exhibition could be due to several reasons, including
designers. Additionally, we spoke to lack of access to internet connections and
22 young creative people over 3 focus computers, the small size of the sector,
The research includes four main strands; group discussions to understand their and the potential lack of knowledge of
desk research, face to face interviews, perspective of entering into the cultural how to engage with the sector.
focus group discussions, and an online sector and their opinions on the museums
survey. Each strand of the research is and heritage sector.
detailed below. Research limitations
A list of organisations who took part in the
Desk research research can be found in appendix 1. While every effort was made to include
This involved collating and analysing experts from across the museums sector,
relevant information, articles, and previous Online survey time and financial constraints made it
local and regional research to understand impossible to cover every profession and
In order to ensure that the research subsector. Nor was it possible to undertake
more about the museum sector in
covers a wide geographic area, we sent interviews in every key town and city.
Zimbabwe as well as the cultural sector in
out an online survey to a range of cultural While we did visit three of the five national
general. Additionally, it was an opportunity
practitioners from across Zimbabwe. The museums in Zimbabwe, we only spoke
to identify what, if any, previous research
survey sought to put some of the findings on the phone to professionals from the
had identified as skills gaps in the sector.
from the interviews to the test. In total, 51 ones we did not visit. Subsequently, while
individuals took part in the online survey Front view of Amagugu International Heritage
this report provides illustrative insights
While every effort was made to include Centre. Murals used as learning aids on
Face to face interviews into emerging skills gaps and shortages,
experts from across the museums sector, indigenous history
it is not a comprehensive mapping of the
time and financial constraints made it and culture.
We spent ten days in Harare, Bulawayo, heritage sector in Zimbabwe.
and Gweru conducting face to face impossible to cover every profession and
interviews. In total, we spoke to 27 subsector. Nor was it possible to undertake Finally, the final number of collected
individuals representing 20 organisations. interviews in every key town and city. surveys cannot be identified as a
Participants included policy makers, While we did visit three of the five national statistically significant number and
senior staff at national museums and museums in Zimbabwe, we only spoke will therefore be used as to illustrate
galleries, and organisational directors. on the phone to professionals from the the qualitative findings as opposed to
Additionally, we spoke to organisations ones we did not visit. Subsequently, while triangulating them. The number of surveys
affiliated with the sector through funding this report provides illustrative insights could be due to several reasons, including
or corporate portfolios. into emerging skills gaps and shortages, lack of access to internet connections and
it is not a comprehensive mapping of the computers, the small size of the sector,
heritage sector in Zimbabwe. and the potential lack of knowledge of
Focus group discussions
how to engage with the sector.
Finally, the final number of collected
We conducted a total of 5 group surveys cannot be identified as a
discussions with 35 technical staff of statistically significant number and
museums, galleries, and the national will therefore be used as to illustrate
archives. Participants included middle the qualitative findings as opposed to
September 2016 8
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 9
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
operations. However, within the current Gallery of Harare, the National Gallery works on documenting, preserving,
economic conditions, budget cuts have of Bulawayo, and the National Gallery and promoting the indigenous cultural
reduced their programme operations as of Mutare organise exhibitions, artist heritage of Zimbabwe by engaging
well as their training and development exchanges, artist development, and with the public through educational
budgets. While this is a challenge, it has educational programmes in a robust and cultural programmes[ Amagugu
also provided these well-established and regular manner. Additionally, the International Heritage Centre http://www.
institutions with the opportunity to work national galleries are able to establish amaguguheritage.org/who-we-are/ ]. That
collaboratively with various funders and collaborations and partnerships with being said, many research participants
has pushed them to seek out new and other galleries, both regionally and identified the need for more contemporary
sustainable methods of operations. internationally, as well as access funding readings of Zimbabwean heritage at
through various donor bodies. the national museums, some of which
The national museums in Zimbabwe carry information in exhibitions and
operate on a geographic and thematic displays from the pre-independence era.
When we talk about the museum sector, unless otherwise
approach, where each venue represents Additionally, some participants highlighted
View of a terrazzo sculpture stated, we include art galleries and sites of archaeological
a specific geographic region and theme. interest as part of this. the importance of telling the Zimbabwean
depicting a praying mantis
The southern region is looked after by story by and through Zimbabweans; the
besides the Human Sciences
Museum entrance
the Masvingo Great Zimbabwe museum, The role of Zimbabwe’s skill of effectively articulating this story is
the central region is looked after by the cultural heritage institutionally lacking. Indeed, the biggest
Military Museum of Gweru, the Museum strength in Zimbabwe is the rich and
of Natural History operates in Bulawayo The UNESCO World Heritage Convention diverse heritage itself.
What does the museum sector in the western region, Harare’s Museum lists five sites in Zimbabwe inscribed
look like? of Human Sciences looks after the on the World Heritage List. There are
northern region, and the Mutare Museum three cultural sites, the Great Zimbabwe
The museum sector in Zimbabwe is responsible for the eastern region of National Monument, Khami Ruins National We need home-grown ideas of how
has fallen successively under several Zimbabwe. The main challenge facing to collect our stories. Museums now
different ministries since the country’s the majority of the public institutions is, Monument, and Matobo Hills; as well as are just looking after what was given
independence in 1980. Newly created in according to research participants, the two natural sites, Mana Pools National to them, not finding our own stories.
September 2015, the Ministry of Rural inability to regularly change or enhance Park, and Mosi-oa-Tunya (Victoria Falls) There’s nothing post-independence or
Development, Promotion and Preservation current exhibitions, and the inability to [ UNESCO World Heritage Convention post 1975. They’re fire fighting, fixing,
of National Culture and Heritage aims to provide regular programming, both due to on Zimbabwe: http://whc.unesco.org/en/ instead of focusing on their main goals.
gather the culture and heritage portfolio decreased budgets in development and statesparties/zw ]. The country is trying to be someone
under a dedicated ministry. National training. The educational programming at else from a different perspective.’ –
Monuments and Museums of Zimbabwe museums is mostly comprised of school Despite on-going economic and political Research participant.
is the department directly associated with visits to the museum sites as part of challenges, all UNESCO sites were
all public heritage sites and museums. mandatory school activities. ratified successively between 1986 and
2003. While the tangible cultural heritage
Zimbabwe’s five world UNESCO heritage The National Galleries operate as quasi- of Zimbabwe is clear, much of the
sites, five National Museums, and three governmental institutions as they fall intangible heritage and indigenous culture
National Galleries all fall under this under the same ministry as the museums has scarcely been preserved. Locations
ministry, which has previously carried but have a larger degree of financial such as the Amagugu International
the sole financial responsibility of their and operational control. The National Heritage Centre in the Matobo region
September 2016 10
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 12
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 13
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
Figure 2 – How well qualified are school and university leavers for roles in different areas which survey participants gave. Similar to
of museum work? responses by interview and focus group
discussion participants, the following skills
were identified to be the most missing in
the sector: digital technologies, marketing
skills for the sector, business development
skills, audience development, project
management, and financial skills
(including budgeting and income
generation). While not a specific skill,
exposure to international best practice
was often highlighted as an important
missing area. Both interview and survey
participants identified that there are not
enough opportunities for professionals
in the sector to learn about professional
benchmarks around the world to enhance
their standards and reach an international
level.
Sample size: 39 respondents funding crisis for national institutions sector. They explained that while jobs at
means that while the museums, archives, these institutions seemed stable and had
Supporting recent and galleries are able to take on unpaid good benefits as they are governmental
or stipend-based work attachments for jobs, they identified that they lacked
graduates students for up to a year, they are unable the knowledge of what the career paths
to retain that knowledge and build on look like outside of being a historian or
While attachments and work placements their investment due to a lack of available ethnographer.
are common and often mandatory for vacancies and a shortage of funding
university students, research participants
explained that the low quality of learning
opportunities. Skills gaps and
which happens at the attachments Young people with whom we spoke at shortages
affects their impact. Additionally, the group discussions also identified that The research sought to understand
real disconnect happens when students it was often difficult to understand the exactly where the gaps lay with regards
graduate and are unable to find jobs due sub-sectors and the different professions to skills in the museum sector. The
to the small size of the sector as well as involved in the museums and heritage following figure illustrates the responses
the hiring freeze at all museums. The
September 2016 14
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 15
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
Figure 4 – Which skills are over and under-subscribed within the – means that some professionals in the
museum sector, and which are about right? sector were quick to highlight self-reliant
business modelling as being more vital
Digital technologies than fundraising and proposal writing.
Marketing
International exposure to best practice Many respondents identified that while
Audience development business skills are important, financial skills
Entrepreneurship in budgeting, forecasting, and accounting
Project management were often missing. Professionals in the
field learned about financial skills often
Finance (including budgets and income…
through on the job training or studied
Business skills
finance but not in a way that is directly
Restoration related to the museums and heritage
Creativity sector. Some respondents explained that
Under-subscribed
Exhibition design it was time to think seriously about income
Management and leadership Over-subscribed generation as part of the move towards
Policy Supply meets demand treating museums as businesses.
Communication
Archiving Additionally, it was highlighted throughout
Curating all interviews that learning marketing
skills specific to the sector were needed.
Team-working
Many marketing professionals who are
General museum management currently based at museums develop their
Other technical skills skills by learning what it means to market
Other soft skills a museum on the job as they mostly
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% come from a background in corporate
marketing. Participants identified that
Percentage of Respondents digital skills should work hand in hand with
marketing skills to move museums into
the use of modern technologies, including
Sample size: 28-33 respondents and galleries, were keen to highlight also highlighted the need for all staff
social media and relevant communication
the necessity in establishing a business members to understand how to look at
Interview participants and technical staff technologies. The majority of institutions
mind set within their organisations. They museums as businesses – from front of
who participated in group discussions in Zimbabwe currently do not employ the
believe that as places which have relied house staff, to shop staff, to the curators
were able to expand further on the skill use of social media or digital technologies
on governmental financial support in the and exhibition developers.
gaps and shortages, explained further in their work and marketing professionals
past, they need to move away from this
below. are still learning about its effective use,
model into an income generating model. The decrease in funding opportunities
especially within promotion and collections
This includes the need to learn skills in through traditional sources due to
Business related skills departments. This includes skills such
proposal writing, fundraising, financial economic and political difficulties –
as website development and database
Research participants, especially management, business planning, and including foreign funding bodies like the
management. The Museum of Natural
technical staff within established museums effective resource management. They Norwegian and Danish funding bodies
History in Bulawayo provides a good
September 2016 16
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 17
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 18
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 19
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
Alliance Francaise
Amagugu International Heritage Centre
Culture Fund
Delta Beverages
EU Delegation, Governance Section
Great Zimbabwe Museum
Midlands State University, Department of Archaeology, Museums and Heritage
Military Museum in Gweru
Museum of Natural History in Bulawayo
Mutare Museum of Antiquities
National Archives
National Arts Council of Zimbabwe, Gweru
National Gallery of Zimbabwe
National Gallery of Zimbabwe in Bulawayo
National Museum of Human Sciences
National Railways of Zimbabwe
National University of Science and Technology, Dept. of Records and Archives Management
Railway Museum
Village Unhu
Zimbabwe German Society
References
Bertelsmann Stiftung, BTI 2016 — Zimbabwe Country Report. Gütersloh: Bertelsmann Stiftung, UNESCO World Heritage Convention: Zimbabwe. http://whc.unesco.org/en/statesparties/zw
2016. Retrieved on 1 September 2016.
Chitiyo, Knox and Kibble, Steve. Zimbabwe’s International Re-engagement: The Long Haul to World CP International Database of Cultural Policies: Zimbabwe. http://worldcp.org/zimbabwe.
Recovery. Chatham House, The Royal Institute of International Affairs, 2014. php IFACCA 2015.
GRM International Zimbabwe Ltd. Young Urban Artists Needs: Assessment Report. 2015.
September 2016 20
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
Men drinking traditional beer - beer drinking was, and still is, a group process in tandem with the communal nature of African societies.
September 2016 21
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 22
Cultural Skills Research Zimbabwe, Sub Saharan Africa www.britishcouncil.org
September 2016 23