3345 South Beach Towers Singapore
3345 South Beach Towers Singapore
org/papers
Subjects: Architectural/Design
Building Case Study
© Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat / Roland Schnizer; Irene Gallou; Adam Davis; Wah Kam Chia;
Weng Hin Ho
South Beach Towers, Singapore
Figure 1. The innovative canopy shades the walkways and public spaces below.
“
Marina Bay area have been re-established,
revitalizing an important connection in the
city that had been lost over time.
Rather than attempting to achieve integration
through a totalizing approach to parametric
Environmental Design Strategy modeling on a single software platform, the
South Beach’s design aimed for the highest project exposed different interfaces and outputs
environmental rating – BCA Green Mark Plati-
num – for both residential and commercial
based on the team members involved and their
components by introducing holistic immediate goals: visualization, physical
”
approaches to environmental design. The
modeling, and construction documentation.
CTBUH Journal | 2017 Issue II South Beach Towers, Singapore | 13
sustainability criteria driving the project were
developed in three discrete strategic tiers: pas-
sive, active, and power generating.
Level 3–17
Level 2–10 Luxury Hotel
Offices
4.2 m Floor to Floor
3.6 m Floor to Floor The Two Towers
The two towers also comprise a series of The south tower consists of a hotel topped The design of the canopy is the central focus
vertical sky gardens, planters, and balconies by residential units on the upper floors (see of the project’s sustainable approach. Its
that help protect the building from the sun Figure 6). It also has several sky gardens, form was driven by solar and wind studies
and filter sunlight to reduce glare. These sky located on levels 18, 22, and 32, with the and is orientated to protect the avenue and
gardens improve the microclimate by former serving hotel guests and the other retail areas from direct sun and rain, while
enhancing natural air movement, while also two meant exclusively for tower residents allowing daylight to filter through to the
minimizing energy consumption by (see Figure 7). The 654-room hotel also space below. The structure is made up of
optimizing heat exchange. They are irrigated features triple-volume sky terraces on levels ribbons of steel and aluminum louvers,
using stored rainwater, and their ceilings – 6, 9, 12, and 15, which are surrounded by which flex above the primary circulation
along with some other internal partitions clusters of hotel rooms. Above, there are 190 routes and public spaces and dip near the
within the towers – are made with local residential units, which include a mixture of edges to meet the existing buildings along
bamboo, a highly sustainable product. Apart two-, three- and four-bedroom units along Beach Road. The entrance to the canopy rises
from the benefits for the building and the with penthouses with private roof gardens. up to form an arc, which acts as a wind
internal spaces, these vertical gardens also scoop, drawing the prevailing breezes
continue the “city in a garden” ideal for The south tower also features a split core, i.e., through the space and promoting natural
Singapore and boost the aesthetic appeal of the lifts serving the hotel and residences ventilation (see Figure 8).
the building. travel through different vertical shafts,
enabling the residential units to be naturally The use of solar panels and optimally angled
The north tower is a multi-tenant office ventilated through an air-well located above louvers means that natural sunlight at once
building, currently occupied by international the hotel lift shaft. This has ensured that all can be harnessed to offset energy demand
companies such as Facebook, Instagram, units can meet or exceed the natural and be deflected to reduce heat gain.
Expedia, Sanofi, and Lego, among many ventilation targets required to achieve Green Average shading with the canopy is 57%,
others. Sky gardens, located at levels 11, 21, Mark Platinum rating. compared to 4.7% without. This rainproof
and 34, break up the building’s façade and “umbrella” also channels breezes,
also serve as communal break-out spaces encouraging ventilation flow, presenting no
need to install air-conditioning for visitor architects and environmental scientists using measured a wind speed of 1.5 m/s in an
comfort. Rainwater, too, collects at the lower specialized thermal imaging equipment and unsheltered space, while beneath the
points of the canopy, which serve as reservoirs microclimatic weather stations. The on-site canopy wind speed was on average 1.5 m/s.
that recycle water and irrigate the studies focused on the relations between the
development’s lush greenery. tropical urban microclimatic variables and In the end, the difference between the
thermal comfort criteria that were established design predictions and the actual readings
To achieve this, Foster + Partners and Arup for comparing the simulation results with on-site was very minimal – a testament to
embarked on an iterative design process, on-site measurements (see Figure 9). the rigorous analysis and modeling carried
which identified comfort requirements before out as part of the design process.
balancing the climatic elements. There were a These field studies showed that the “felt
number of predictions about the performance temperature” under the canopy at South
of the canopy that were made during the Beach was up to 13°C lower than other Parametric Modeling
design process. These predictions were tested canopied spaces in Singapore, and up to 17°C
after the building was occupied to verify their lower than unsheltered spaces in the city. The The design of the canopy was refined in
validity. ground surface temperatures also varied response to a variety of environmental and
drastically from 55°C on the streets to 30°C at structural factors that were mediated
It is relatively easy to analyze the performance South Beach. through a multifunctional parametric model.
of a building based on feedback from Building The use of parametric design on this project
Management Systems, measuring the The main reason for the success of the canopy was far more sophisticated than normal, so
consumption of electricity and water, and in keeping cool is that the solar gains much so that the in-house Applied Research
other such data. However, this does not hold associated with the daylight levels under the and Development team at Foster + Partners
true for outdoor spaces, such as the green canopy are kept low. During design, the team had to write its own software. The innovative
spine under the canopy at South Beach. The evaluated the thermal gains and illumination digital design platform used to develop the
canopy was designed to create an outdoor from direct solar radiation, and from diffuse canopy model integrated the work of the
space that was comfortable to use sources such as the sky dome and adjacent design team and consultants into a seamless
throughout the year by moderating five reflective surfaces, including the ground itself. and responsive workflow. This enabled the
separate elements – air movement, light It is important to consider aperture size of the development of a shared model capable of
levels, radiant temperature, and felt louvers as a function of light transmission and providing a full range of drawings and data
temperature. The designers and engineers its resultant thermal impacts under the – from design intent to information sheets
had made several predictions through canopy. Improperly designed apertures can for detailed design documentation.
simulations during the design stage, which result in overheating of the spaces under the
needed to be validated by measurements on canopy, visual discomfort from glare and In the canopy design, the environmental
the ground after the building had been built unwanted deterioration and fading of strategies are closely related to the geometry
to “close the loop” between design-stage furnishings and other materials. of the roof. Structural beams define the
predictions and delivered performance. massing form and orientation of the canopy
One additional reason for the success of the as well as the green spine along the main
The open spaces under the canopy of South canopy was also that it did not inhibit air public space. Columns and drainage panels
Beach were investigated by a team of movement to a great extent – the team are situated to satisfy structural constraints
Columns 12 m
spacing Y-shaped column
Figure 12. The beams of the canopy form a Vierendeel truss system. © Arup Figure 13. Louvers vary in opacity and orientation to aid ventilation, drainage, and shade.
© Foster + Partners
laterally than can be visually perceived (see Urban Context and Conservation the four former military buildings along Beach
Figure 12). Rainwater down-pipes are Road and interspersing them with conserved
optimized and hidden within arching The site overlooks the Padang (formerly the mature trees. The towers are then set back
ribbons and Y-columns. Padang Cricket Ground), home to many of from Beach Road, with only the recessed
Singapore’s leading institutions and landmarks, upper levels visible above. Designed to be a
A full-service 3D BIM model was developed including the National Gallery of Singapore, natural extension of the adjacent historic
to coordinate all services that are hidden The Old and New Supreme Court, St Andrew’s district, the key old buildings on-site were also
within the louvers and ribbons (see Figure Cathedral, Victoria Theatre, The Esplanade, and used to define the pedestrian routes through
13). The openings and stiffener plates in the the famed Raffles Hotel (see Figure 14). the development. The presence of the historic
ribbons for these services were optimized buildings, together with the overarching
with this visual tool. Abortive work resulting South Beach sensitively addresses the canopy, give the entire development a
from the clash of services with structural adjacent Raffles Hotel by carefully restoring distinctly low-rise pedestrian character.
elements or architectural louvers were hence
eliminated before fabrication.
Figure 14. Historic buildings along Beach Road, including the NCO Club in the corner and the Raffles Hotel across
the street.
There are four conservation buildings along character and scale of the surrounding Unless otherwise noted, all photography credits
Beach Road – Blocks 1, 9 (also known as the neighborhood across the street. The in this paper are to Nigel Young / Foster +
Straits Settlements Volunteer Force (SSVF) introduction of a sinuous microclimatic Partners.
Drill Hall), and 14 of the former Beach Road canopy that runs the entire length of the site
Camp, together with the neighboring also helped to mediate the stark contrast of Project Data
Singapore Armed Forces Non-Commissioned scale between the heritage structures and
Officer (SAF NCO) Club. These buildings the new-built towers (see Figure 15). Completion Date: November 2015
straddle the pre- and post-WWII eras, Height: 218 meters
embodying varied forms, technology, Stories: South Tower: 45; North Tower: 35
materials, and climatic design responses to Conclusion Total Area: 153,067 square meters
the tropical context. They are synonymous Use: South Tower: Residential/Hotel; North
with Singapore’s nation-building and The South Beach project represents a critical Tower: Office
defense history, being a Remembrance Day opportunity to realize a highly functional Owner: South Beach Consortium
memorial site for Volunteer Corps veterans, mixed-use development that meets Developers: City Developments Limited; IOI
as well as the birthplace of the SAF. The contemporary standards of environmental Group; South Beach Consortium
group also carries conservation significance performance and preserves important Architects: Foster + Partners (design); Aedas
as the first Modernist buildings to be historical buildings. Its intensively modeled (architect of record)
gazetted for conservation in Singapore, in design process resulted in an addition to the Structural Engineer: Arup (design)
2002. The Urban Redevelopment Authority neighborhood that fits well into Singapore’s MEP Engineer: Parsons Brinckerhoff
(URA) technical conditions required that emerging high-rise vernacular and actually Consultants Private Limited (design)
these structures be sensitively restored and improves the thermal dynamics of its site. In Main Contractor: Hyundai Engineering &
adapted for new use, as an integral part of this way, it embodies the “vertical city in a Construction
the new mixed development. garden” concept that distinguishes Other CTBUH Member Consultants: Arup
Singapore. (façade, geotechnical, sustainability); BMT
From an urban conservation viewpoint, the Fluid Mechanics Ltd. (wind); Davis Langdon
transformation of a former high-security and Some extracts relating to the conservation (quantity surveyor)
publicly inaccessible military site into a aspects of the project within this article Other CTBUH Member Suppliers: Hilti AG
commercial mixed-use development first appeared in an essay by Ho Weng Hin (cladding); KONE (elevator)
presents both great opportunities as well as published in The Singapore Architect
challenges. A key conservation priority was Journal, October 2016.
the preservation of the street frontage of Portions of this paper about the
Beach Road, long characterized by the environmental strategy and parametric
low-rise forms and heterogeneous façade design were previously published in the
designs of the four historic buildings. Their Conference Proceedings of Acadia 2011:
fine urban grain in turn informed the Integration through Computation, edited
massing design of the new podium blocks by Jason S. Johnson, Branko Kolarevic, Vera
behind, successfully integrating the new Parlac, and Joshua M. Taron.
urban form of the development with the