Women's Economic Empowerment Through Microfinance - Role of Cooperative Banks of Maharashtra and Karnataka: A Comparative Analysis
Women's Economic Empowerment Through Microfinance - Role of Cooperative Banks of Maharashtra and Karnataka: A Comparative Analysis
Email : [email protected]
Received: 05 Feb 2025; Received in revised form: 08 Mar 2025; Accepted: 12 Mar 2025; Available online: 18 Mar 2025
Abstract— Economic empowerment is a critical driver for achieving gender equality, poverty reduction,
and inclusive growth. This study examines the pivotal role of District Central Cooperative (DCC) Banks in
empowering women through Self-Help Groups (SHGs) in Maharashtra and Karnataka. By analyzing
secondary data from NABARD reports and other scholarly sources, the research compares the growth
trajectories, savings patterns, and loan disbursement trends across the two states from 2018-19 to 2022-23.
The findings reveal that Maharashtra experienced rapid SHG expansion and increased loan disbursement,
while Karnataka maintained higher per-group financial support despite slower growth. The study
underscores the importance of cooperative banks in enhancing financial access, promoting savings, and
facilitating credit for women SHGs, ultimately contributing to their economic empowerment.
Recommendations include targeted regional strategies, financial literacy programs, and digital banking
solutions to sustain and expand women’s financial inclusion.
Keywords— Economic Empowerment, Self-Help Groups (SHGs), Cooperative Banks, Women’s
Financial Inclusion, District Central Cooperative Banks
Dr Shurti 2019 India Bank initiatives in Banks, through various schemes, provide women
Jha India to promote with assistance for earning their livelihoods with
financial inclusion and the aim of making them self-sufficient.
women's
empowerment
Micro financing Micro financing has led to economic
delivered through empowerment of rural women in India. Results
Banks and MFI's have of the Anova model, T-test showed that
Rashmi India
2018 helped women to demographic factors like age, family income, had
Singel Haryana
achieve economic a positive and significant influence on economic
empowerment in rural empowerment of rural women availing micro
areas. financing.
reports. Other data have been collected from IV. DATA ANALYSIS AND
different journals and various publications from INTERPRETATION
other agencies. The Role of Cooperative Banks in Economic
Empowerment of Women through SHGs
50 16.9
12.44
-0.68 -4.73
0 5.87
2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23
-50
-48.12
-100
Number of Women SHGs YoY Growth (%) - Savings Amount YoY Growth (%) -
Fig.1 Year over Year Growth of No. of Women SHGs and Savings Amount in Percentage (2018-2023)
(₹ in Lakhs)
Source: Status of Microfinance Report of NABARD (2018-19 to 2022-2023)
Figure 01 illustrates the trends in the growth of Overall, while SHG membership experienced
Women Self-Help Groups (SHGs) and their collective moderate fluctuations, savings patterns displayed
savings over five financial years, from 2018-19 to more pronounced year-to-year variability, reflecting
2022-23. The number of SHGs initially grew from the dynamic economic environment and resilience of
13.08 lakh in 2018-19 to 13.85 lakh in 2019-20, women’s collective financial initiatives.
reflecting a 5.87% year-on-year (YoY) increase. Figure 02 depicts fluctuating trends in the number of
However, the following years saw slight fluctuations Women Self-Help Groups (SHGs) and the loan
— a minor decline of -0.68% in 2020-21 and a more amounts disbursed from 2018-19 to 2022-23. The
pronounced drop of -4.73% in 2021-22. By 2022-23, number of SHGs saw a modest rise in 2019-20 but
SHG numbers rebounded to 14.7 lakh, marking a declined in subsequent years, with a significant drop
strong 12.44% recovery. in 2021-22. Despite this, loan disbursements
Savings trends exhibited greater volatility. A exhibited consistent growth, culminating in a sharp
significant surge of 99.63% was observed in 2020-21, rise in 2022-23. That year saw a notable rebound,
followed by a sharp decline of -48.12% in 2021-22. with SHG numbers increasing by 21% and loan
The momentum shifted positively again in 2022-23, disbursements surging by 31.88%. This trend
with savings soaring by 127.29%, reaching indicates a continued emphasis on enhancing
₹5,70,417.10 lakh — signalling a robust revival. financial support to women’s groups, even as their
numbers experienced periodic declines.
20 15.42 14.21 21
15
7.02
10
5 2.23
0 -3.38
-5 2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23
-10
-15
-13.34
-20
Number of Women SHGs YoY Growth (%) - Loan Disbursed Amount YoY Growth (%) -
Fig.2 Year over Year Growth of No. of Women SHGs and Loan Disbursed Amount (2018-23) in Percentage
(Amount ₹ Lakh )
Source: Status of Microfinance Report of NABARD (2018-19 to 2022-2023)
15
11.98
10
4.81
5
0.77 0.33
0
2019-20 2020-21 2021-22 2022-23
Number of Women SHGs YoY Growth (%) - Loan outstanding Amount YoY Growth (%) -
Fig.3 YoY Growth of No. of Women SHGs and Loan Outstanding Amount in Percentage (2018-23) (Amount ₹ Lakh )
Source: Status of Microfinance Report of NABARD (2018-19 to 2022-2023)
Figure 03 showcases the growth in the number of SHG numbers reached 5.33 lakh, reflecting a more
Women Self-Help Groups (SHGs) and the loan substantial 4.81% increase.
outstanding amounts over five financial years from In parallel, the loan outstanding amounts grew
2018-19 to 2022-23. The number of SHGs steadily, starting from ₹4,96,511.84 lakh in 2018-19.
demonstrated consistent, albeit slowing, growth — Each year saw notable growth, with rates ranging
rising from 4.49 lakh in 2018-19 to 5.03 lakh in 2019- between 17.61% and 21.88%. By 2022-23, the total
20, marking an 11.98% year-on-year (YoY) increase. loan outstanding had more than doubled, reaching
Growth rates then tapered, with marginal rises of ₹10,10,288.48 lakh — underscoring sustained
0.77% in 2020-21 and 0.33% in 2021-22. By 2022-23,
expansion in credit availability to SHGs, even as the rise in group numbers slowed.
Table.1 the Role of DCC Banks in Number of SHGs and Saving Amount Comparative Analysis
(Amount ₹ Lakh)
Maharashtra State Karnataka State
Sr. Number of Saving Number Saving
Year Saving
No women Saving amount Amount Per of women Amount
amount
SHGs SHG SHGs Per SHG
1 2018-19 3,37,925 39,397.90 0.12 2,24,966 42,385.22 0.19
2 2019-20 3,99,613 42,028.52 0.11 2,35,356 42,748.68 0.18
3 2020-21 3,59,231 1,42,981.04 0.40 2,41,009 46,419.15 0.19
4 2021-22 3,67,754 37,362.85 0.10 2,42,771 50,382.02 0.21
5 2022-23 14,73,363 5,70,417.10 0.39 2,55,897 48,648.04 0.19
CAGR (%) 44.50 95.07 - 3.27 3.51 -
Average - - 0.22 - - 0.19
Source: Status of Microfinance Report of NABARD (2018-19 to 2022-2023)
Table 01 highlight contrasting growth trends in Maharashtra experienced remarkable growth in loan
Women Self-Help Groups (SHGs) and total savings disbursement per SHG, rising from ₹0.71 lakh in
between Maharashtra and Karnataka from 2018-19 to 2018-19 to ₹3.13 lakh in 2022-23, driven by an
2022-23. impressive Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)
Maharashtra witnessed remarkable expansion, with a of 123.6%. The number of SHGs expanded
Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 44.50%. significantly, from 42,369 in 2018-19 to 2,41,142 in
The number of SHGs surged from 3.37 lakh in 2018- 2022-23, reflecting a substantial increase in outreach
19 to 14.73 lakh in 2022-23, while total savings and financial inclusion. The average loan disbursed
skyrocketed from ₹39,397.90 lakh to ₹5,70,417.10 per SHG over the five years stood at ₹1.23 lakh.
lakh. Savings per SHG fluctuated during this period, Karnataka, on the other hand, showed moderate but
peaking at ₹0.40 lakh in 2020-21, with an overall steady growth. Loan disbursement per SHG
average of ₹0.22 lakh. increased from ₹2.75 lakh in 2018-19 to ₹4.49 lakh in
In contrast, Karnataka experienced slower growth, 2022-23, with a CAGR of 24.5%. Total loan
with a modest CAGR of 3.27%. SHG numbers rose disbursement rose from ₹82,646.59 lakh to
from 2.25 lakh in 2018-19 to 2.56 lakh in 2022-23, and ₹1,98,374.51 lakh over the period. Notably, Karnataka
total savings increased from ₹42,385.22 lakh to consistently maintained a higher loan amount per
₹48,648.04 lakh. Savings per SHG remained steady, SHG than Maharashtra, with an average loan
averaging ₹0.19 lakh throughout the years. disbursement per SHG of ₹3.62 lakh.
The data underscores Maharashtra’s rapid expansion The data underscores Maharashtra’s rapid expansion
in both SHG formation and savings accumulation, in SHG numbers alongside growing loan support,
while Karnataka maintained stability with gradual while Karnataka sustained a more stable, higher
growth. loan-per-group model, prioritizing larger credit
access to fewer groups.
Table 02 compares loan disbursement trends for
Women Self-Help Groups (SHGs) in Maharashtra
and Karnataka from 2018-19 to 2022-23, highlighting
contrasting growth patterns.
Table No. 02: The Role of DCC Banks in Number of SHGS and Loan Disbursed Comparative Analysis
(Amount ₹ Lakh )
Maharashtra State Karnataka State
Loan Loan
Sr. Loan
Year Number Loan disbursed Number disbursed
No disbursed
of women disbursed during the of women during the
during the
SHGs during the year year per SHGs year per
year
SHG SHG
1 2018-19 42,369 30,231.30 0.71 30,103 82,646.59 2.75
2 2019-20 48,966 33,832.39 0.69 34,271 1,13,792.19 3.32
3 2020-21 30,688 23,670.19 0.77 32,332 1,15,150.43 3.56
4 2021-22 32,585 27,558.46 0.85 32,136 1,27,555.45 3.97
5 2022-23 2,41,142 7,55,049.95 3.13 44,204 1,98,374.51 4.49
CAGR (%) 54.4 123.6 - 10.1 24.5 -
Average (Rs. In
- - 1.23 - - 3.62
Lakh)
Source: Status of Microfinance Report of NABARD (2018-19 to 2022-2023)
Table.3: The Role of DCC Banks in Number of SHGS and Loan Outstanding Comparative Analysis
(Amount ₹ Lakh )
Maharashtra State Karnataka State
Table 03 compares the total bank loan outstanding 2018-19 to 5,32,851 in 2022-23. Total bank loan
for Women Self-Help Groups (SHGs) in Maharashtra outstanding saw an extraordinary rise from
and Karnataka from 2018-19 to 2022-23, revealing ₹22,858.45 lakh to ₹10,10,288.48 lakh over the same
notable differences in growth patterns.In period. Loan per SHG increased sharply from ₹0.44
Maharashtra, SHG numbers surged from 52,042 in lakh in 2018-19 to ₹1.90 lakh in 2022-23, reflecting an
impressive Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) accumulating larger loan balances, possibly due
of 157.8%. The average loan outstanding per SHG to higher borrowing needs or increased lending
during this period stood at ₹1.02 lakh. In Karnataka, limits by cooperative banks, compared to
SHG numbers grew more gradually, from 65,801 in Karnataka.
2018-19 to 84,104 in 2022-23. Total loan outstanding • Comparison Between Maharashtra and
increased from ₹1,04,163.91 lakh to ₹2,39,176.62 lakh. Karnataka in SHG Savings and Loan
Loan per SHG rose from ₹1.58 lakh in 2018-19 to Disbursements
₹2.84 lakh in 2022-23, with a CAGR of 23.1%. The Maharashtra experienced a much higher growth
average loan outstanding per SHG was ₹2.17 lakh — rate in both SHG numbers and total savings
consistently higher than Maharashtra’s.The data compared to Karnataka. The savings per SHG in
highlights Maharashtra’s rapid expansion in SHG Maharashtra varied, peaking in 2020-21, while
numbers and total loan support, reflecting a large- Karnataka’s savings per SHG remained relatively
scale push for financial inclusion. Karnataka, by consistent. For loan disbursements,
contrast,maintained slower but stable growth, with Maharashtra’s growth rate in loan amounts per
higher loan outstanding per SHG, suggesting a focus SHG was markedly higher, indicating significant
on deeper financial backing for each group. expansion of financial services. However,
Karnataka consistently provided a higher loan
amount per SHG, suggesting stronger per-group
V. FINDINGS OF THE STUDY
financial support in Karnataka.
• Growth and Fluctuation in SHGs and Savings
• Loan Outstanding Comparison Between
Across Years
Maharashtra and Karnataka
From 2018-19 to 2022-23, Women Self-Help Groups Maharashtra saw substantial growth in total
(SHGs) demonstrated overall growth, despite yearly bank loan outstanding per SHG, with a high
fluctuations. SHG numbers initially increased, faced CAGR in loan per SHG over five years, reflecting
a slight decline, and then rebounded significantly by increasing financial dependency or banking
2022-23. Total savings followed a similarly volatile support. Karnataka’s growth was more
trajectory — showing notable growth in 2020-21, a moderate, yet it maintained a consistently higher
decline in 2021-22, and a strong recovery in 2022-23. loan per SHG, emphasizing quality over quantity
This pattern reflects resilient efforts to rebuild and in its support structure.
expand group savings after periods of instability.
• Loan Disbursement Trends VI. RECOMMENDATIONS
Loan disbursement amounts consistently • Enhance Cooperative Banks’ Support to Women
increased year-over-year, signaling growing SHGs for Economic Empowerment
financial support to women SHGs. The YoY Cooperative banks should strengthen their
growth in loans was especially pronounced in financial services for Women SHGs by providing
2022-23, demonstrating a marked increase in consistent and adaptable credit support,
access to credit for SHGs despite some volatility especially during periods of economic
in the number of SHGs. This suggests a focused uncertainty. Programs that offer flexible loan
attempt by cooperative banks to strengthen terms, repayment holidays, or lower interest
women's economic empowerment through rates during difficult times can stabilize savings
steady loan disbursements. and help SHGs manage financial volatility, as
• Growth in Loan Outstanding Amounts seen in the fluctuating savings and loan growth
Both Maharashtra and Karnataka saw growth in patterns from 2018-19 to 2022-23.
SHG loan outstanding amounts, although at • Adopt Targeted Approaches for Regional
differing rates. The total outstanding amounts in Growth in Maharashtra and Karnataka
Maharashtra grew significantly more rapidly Given the high growth in Maharashtra and the
than in Karnataka, with a much higher CAGR. slower, steady expansion in Karnataka,
This indicates that Maharashtra's SHGs are cooperative banks should implement customized
emphasizing a more concentrated financial Vol. 13 No. 2, 2021 pp. 142-161 © Emerald Publishing
empowerment strategy per group. Thus, while Limited 1756-6266
Maharashtra's DCC banks emphasize broad-based [10] Dr.Jutika Medhi, Role of Self Help Groups(SHGS) in
Economic Empowement of Women in India through
SHG growth, Karnataka's banks focus on providing
Shg Bank Linkage Programme, International Journal
substantial individual support per SHG.
of Multidisciplinary ISSN:2277-7881; IMPACT
In summary, cooperative banks, particularly DCC FACTOR :6.514(2020)
banks in both states, are vital for advancing the [11] Smt. Ranjitha B R, Dr. Devarajappa S, Cooperative
economic empowerment of women. While Movements And Economic Empowerment Of Rural
approaches vary between Maharashtra and Women In Karnataka, Juni Khyat ISSN: 2278-4632
(UGC Care Group I Listed Journal) Vol-10 Issue-5 No.
Karnataka, both regions show that increasing loan
12 May 2020
access, supporting savings growth, and providing
[12] Dr. S. Franklin John, Ms. Nilufar Sathiq, A Study on
significant loan amounts per SHG are effective
the Kudumbashree Activities of Ottapalam
strategies for strengthening women’s economic Municipality for the Economic Empowerment of
agency. This study underscores the important role of Women, Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode
cooperative banks in fostering financial resilience 04th International Conference on Marketing,
and empowerment among women SHGs in India. Technology & Society 2020
[13] Dr. Deepak S. Vede, Economic Empowerment of
Women in India, Turkish Journal of Computer and
REFERENCES Mathematics Education Vol.12 No.10 (2021), 7434-7437
[1] Gubhaju, R. (2023). Women Empowerment in Self [14] Sumeet Kaur ,Harneet Kaur ,Dr Navneet
Help Groups through Microfinance: A Case Study of Kaur,empowering Women Through Microfinance in
Rautahat District. Apex Journal of Business and India Globus An International Journal of
Management (AJBM). 1(1), 33-54. Management & IT A Refereed Research Journal Vol
[2] Kumar, S. MICRO FINANCE AND WOMEN 12 / No 1 / Jul-Dec 2020 ISSN: 0975-721X
EMPOWERMENT IN INDIA. [15] Status of Micro Finance in India by NABARD 2018-19
[3] Vede, D. D. S. . (2021). Economic Empowerment of to 2022-23
Women in India . Turkish Journal of Computer and
Mathematics Education (TURCOMAT), 12(10), 7434–
7437. https://doi.org/10.17762/turcomat.v12i10.5649
[4] Medhi, J.(2015) Role of Self Help Groups (Shgs) in
Economic Empowerment of Women in India Through
Shgs-Bank Linkage Programme.
[5] John, S. F. A Study on the Kudumbashree Activities of
Ottapalam Municipality for the Economic
Empowerment of Women.
[6] Dr.T. Ramanathan, J. Rajkumar(2013). ROLE OF CO-
OPERATIVES IN EMPOWERING RURAL WOMEN:
Shanlax International Journal of Commerce. ISSN :
2320-4168
[7] Madhumanjari Chakravorty, Empowerment of Poor
Women Living in Kolkata , The Mictrfonace Review
January –June 2015 ISSNNo-2229-3329
[8] Berhane Ghebermichale, (2013)the Role of
Cooperatives in Empowring Women, Journal of
Business Management & Social Sciences Research
(JBM&SSR) ISSN No: 2319-5614 Volume 2, No.5, May
2013
[9] Sandrine Bonin, Wafa Singh.et al, A priority action
roadmap for women’s economic empowerment
(PARWEE) amid COVID-19: a co-creation approach.
international Journal of Gender and Entrepreneurship