SEA 302 Project Paper (Eshaa Jit Kaur Dhaliwal-162465)
SEA 302 Project Paper (Eshaa Jit Kaur Dhaliwal-162465)
DATE: 05.07.2024
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Executive summary………………………………………………………..………………………1
1.0: Introduction……………………………………………………………………….…………..2
2.0: Conceptualizing Urban Poverty in Malaysia………………………………………...……..3-4
3.0: Causes of Urban Poverty in Malaysia………………………………………………….…5-10
3.1: Urbanisation………………………………………………………………….…….5-6
3.2: Lack of good governance…………………………………………………………..6-7
3.3: Exclusion of certain demographics…………………………………...……………7-8
3.4: Foreign workers……………………………………………………………………8-9
3.5: Inflation………………………………………………………………………...…9-10
4.0: Suggestions For Economic Policies To Overcome Urban Poverty…………………...…11-15
4.1: Higher minimum wage……………………………………………………...………11
4.2: Affordable housing……………...……………………………………….………12-13
4.3: Introducing compulsory savings for informal workers….………………………13-14
4.4: Creating equity for women………………………………………………………14-15
4.5: Infrastructural development... ………………………………………………………15
5.0: Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………..…16
References……………………………………………………………………………………17-20
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Urban poverty in Malaysia has increased from 1.0% to 4.5% in the span of ten years from
2012 to 2022. Urban poverty in Malaysia is caused by factors such as urbanisation, lack of good
governance, exclusion of certain demographics, foreign workers and inflation. This issue needs
to be addressed before it gets worse. Economic policies that can be implemented by the
government to solve the issue of urban poverty are higher minimum wage, affordable housing,
introducing compulsory savings for informal workers, creating equity for women and
infrastructural development. By implementing these policies, the government can reduce the
poverty rate and develop better human capital as well as encourage economic growth.
1
1.0: INTRODUCTION
Poverty is the situation or circumstance in which individuals or groups lack the financial
resources and other necessities for a basic level of living. As a result, they cannot meet their most
basic human requirements. Poverty leads to poor conditions and lack of necessities for the poor.
This includes food insecurity, limited employment opportunity, unequal opportunity for
education, poor housing, no access to quality healthcare as well as general insecurity, exclusion
and discrimination (Chung, 2012). Each country has its own specified criteria for setting the
poverty line and calculating how many people live in poverty. Based on the United Nations
Development Programme Trends Report, approximately 1.1 billion people are living in acute
Poverty itself is not just an individual problem but also represents a broader, structural
problem. High rates of poverty in a country can lead to other problems such as slow economic
growth, high mortality rates, violence, crime, mental illness and many other issues. This is why
institutions like the government need to intervene by taking calculated measures in an effort to
eradicate poverty. This will ensure the economic growth of a country as well as social welfare of
its people.
This paper aims to explore the concept of urban poverty and explain its relevance in the
context of Malaysia. This paper also discusses the multifaceted causes that contribute towards
the perpetuation of urban poverty. Lastly, it suggests policy solutions that can be implemented by
2
2.0: CONCEPTUALIZING URBAN POVERTY IN MALAYSIA
Urban poverty refers to the set of economic and social difficulties that are found in
industrialised cities and that are the result of a combination of processes such as the
fragmentation, and the dualization of the labour market, which translates into social dualization
(Cano, 2019). Urban poverty shares all the same basic characteristics as regular poverty with the
only main difference being that it happens in an urban setting. Therefore for the purposes of this
essay, urban poverty will be defined as the condition in which people or families in urban areas
endure substantial economic hardship and deprivation, as well as a lack of vital resources and
In Malaysia, household incomes are separated into three different income groups which
are T20, M40 and B40. B40 refers to the bottom 40% of household incomes, M40 being the
middle 40% and T20 is the top 20% of household incomes. According to the Household Income
& Basic Amenities Survey Report 2022 released by the Department of Statistics Malaysia
(DOSM) , the average household size was 3.8 persons with average income recipients being 1.8
persons. The mean income for B40, M40 and T20 were RM3,401, RM7,971 and RM19,752
respectively. Therefore, households in the B40 range are the ones who are most likely to
experience urban poverty in Malaysia. The report also stated that in 2022, the average poverty
line income (PLI) had experienced an increase to RM2,589 from RM2,208 in 2019. This
increase results in more households being classified as living under the poverty line.
3
Table 1: Incidents of poverty based on percentage of households in urban and rural areas
According to the DOSM, the rates of urban poverty in Malaysia have been inconsistent. It
experienced a decrease from 2012 to 2014 but then increased substantially from 2014 to 2016
followed by a slight drop in 2019. The urban poverty rate then increased from 3.8% in 2019 to
4.5% in 2022 which shows an increase of 0.7% in the span of 3 years. Based on the table, we can
see that from 2012 to 2022, the percentage of rural poverty is always higher than urban poverty.
Despite this being the case, the amount of people experiencing urban poverty is higher than that
of those experiencing rural poverty. This is because over 70% of Malaysia’s population is
located in cities. Based on statistics provided by DOSM for 2022, it can be seen that over 1.1
million people in Malaysia experience urban poverty compared to over 900 thousand who
4
3.0: CAUSES OF URBAN POVERTY IN MALAYSIA
3.1: URBANISATION
In the context of Malaysia, the recent process of rapid urbanisation has led to an increase
of urban poverty (Mok & Gan, 2007). Urbanisation is the process by which huge numbers of
people are permanently concentrated in relatively small regions, resulting in cities. This rapid
of Malaysians from rural areas into urban areas in search for better opportunities. People
typically move to urban areas as they assume that there are better job opportunities and better
As urbanisation increases, more people travel to cities for better quality of life, leading to
a rise in population. According to the Department of Statistics Malaysia, the urban population
rate in Malaysia as of 2023 is 77.7% . This means that the majority of Malaysians live in urban
areas. As urban populations grow, the cost of living rises due to increased demand for urban
commodities, which are becoming increasingly scarce (Olotuah & Adesiji, 2000). The
opportunities in urban areas are not able to keep up with the increasing migration of people. In
the Eleventh Malaysia Plan (2015), it was estimated that the urbanisation rate would increase to
80% by 2030.
Therefore , with the increasing flood of migrants into urban areas, this will increase the
competition for economic opportunities like jobs. With the government not taking any
substantial steps to cater to this, it will cause infrastructure in urban areas to be inadequate and
unable to keep up with urbanisation. The oversaturation and highly competitive nature of the job
5
market also results in joblessness or underemployment which traps urban residents in the cycle
of poverty.
perpetuation of this cycle. In terms of Malaysia, the government has constantly been criticised
for its lack of effective governance to solve the poverty issue. Even when they do take action, it
Firstly, in terms of a social safety net. Social security involves protecting people from
economic and social uncertainty that may be caused by disease, injuries, invalidity, maternity,
old age and many other reasons through government policies or programmes. While the
government does have some policies in place like the Employees' Provident Fund (EPF) and
Social Security Organization (SOCSO), they are still not enough. Roughly one third of
employees are not covered by EPF or SOCSO and the rest of the employed population including
self-employed people and informal sector workers are not covered by either (Mansoor & Awang,
2002). This is particularly unfair as informal sector workers are predominantly low-income
earners.
In addition to that, the public housing provided by the government is severely lacking. In
1998, the government introduced a public housing program called “Program Perumahan Rakyat”
(PPR). Over the recent years, the Malaysian property market was not balanced in terms of supply
and demand, where the demand is exceeding supply especially for low-cost housing. (Mohd-
Rahim et al., 2019). The increased urbanisation over the last few years have resulted in lack of
6
affordable housing for the urban poor. The government is incapable or just not putting enough
effort into creating easily accessible and affordable public housing which further exacerbates the
issue of poverty. Therefore, households with incomes that are already low have to now spend
poverty. Two main demographics that are excluded will be explored which are women and the
elderly.
Firstly, women face discrimination in the form of the gender wage gap. Despite having
higher enrolment rates than men in all three tiers of primary, secondary and tertiary education,
women still get paid significantly less than men entirely on the basis of gender. According to the
DOSM in the year 2022, for every RM100 of salary and wages received by men, women only
received RM66.67 comparatively. The average pay for men was RM63,117 while women only
received RM42,080, showing an almost 1:1.5 ratio. The DOSM also stated that in 2022, the rate
of unemployment for men was 3.8% while women’s was 4.1%. This highlights a clear structural
issue which must be addressed. The opportunity and income disparity between men and women
Besides that, those in old age who are unwell and no longer employed are among the
demographics thought to be most susceptible to poverty in Malaysia (Ahmad et al., 2016). The
elderly in Malaysia which is being referred to are individuals over the age of 65 who are retired.
An early retirement age, early EPF withdrawals, low salaries, rising cost of living and a flat
7
pension all raise the possibility that older Malaysians will not have enough funds and be driven
into poverty (Caraher, 2003). Most of the elderly rely on fixed amounts of money like pensions
or EPF saving which may not keep pace with inflation. With the cost of everything increasing
and the inability to work, the elderly face financial strain and a substantial risk of being in
poverty.
Malaysia has always been a hub for foreign workers to come and seek employment at.
Migration of foreign workers to the urban areas of Malaysia has become commonplace and has
The entry of foreign workers, especially illegal migrants in large numbers, has caused a
negative outcome towards the wage structure from continuously increasing because most foreign
workers are willing to accept any amount of wage and work any amount of long, flexible hours
compared to the locals (Ajis et al., 2014). Foreign workers are typically in more desperate
situations and are more easily exploited by corporations. They are more willing than their
Malaysian counterparts to accept low wages and poor working conditions. As a result, they are
more likely to be hired. Over time, this can also lead to declining wage rates for local workers
Without a doubt, the entrance of foreign labour was originally meant to cover gaps in the
plantation, construction, agricultural, services, and domestic worker sectors but as a result of
strong demand from regional companies, they are now beginning to control the local
employment market too (Hamzah et al., 2020). The market in urban areas is already
8
oversaturated by rural migrants within the country. The addition of foreign workers further
worsens this problem as the job opportunity to job seeker disparity becomes worse. Therefore,
local workers are less likely to gain employment and further susceptible to falling into the cycle
of poverty.
At the end of the day, migration of foreign workers into Malaysia can contribute towards
the increase in poverty rate. However, this is no fault of these workers themselves as they are
being exploited too. Due to the fact that they have lower wages and less legal protections to keep
them safe, companies hire them in an attempt to lower cost and increase profitability at the
3.5: INFLATION
Inflation refers to the rise of prices of goods and services over a certain period of time.
purchasing power and can disproportionately affect households with low incomes. Inflation rates
in urban areas are also increasing at higher rates than rural areas.
Housing, water, electricity, gas and other fuels 2.8 1.8 1.9
9
Furnishings, household equipment and routine 3.0 2.1 1.6
household maintenance
Based on the statistics provided by BNM above, it can be seen that the total rate for
inflation in highly urbanised states is higher at 2.5% compared to semi-urbanised states and less
urbanised states at 1.6% and 1.4% respectively. Therefore, the cost of living in these urban states
are relatively higher due to the price of goods and services increasing at higher rates. It can also
be seen that the inflation rate for essentials such as food and non-alcoholic beverages, health,
The highest of them all being food and non-alcoholic beverages at 4.6% for highly
urbanised states. Lower income, especially B40 groups are impacted most by higher prices of
food and food inflation resulting in reduced purchasing power and higher cost of living among
these groups. (Ismail et al., 2022). This is because low income households spend a high portion
of their wages on food. When the price of food increases, more of their already limited amount
of money has to be spent on food. This leaves them with less and less money as inflation
10
4.0: SUGGESTIONS FOR ECONOMIC POLICIES TO OVERCOME URBAN
POVERTY
Minimum wage refers to the minimum amount of compensation that an employer must
provide to wage earners for work completed within a specific time frame. This compensation
Currently, in Malaysia, the minimum wage set by the government is at RM1,500 for
companies with over 5 employees. With rising cost of living and inflation particularly in urban
areas, this is not enough for most low-income households to cover the cost of essentials such as
food and housing. For a single income household, this is not even close to the PLI determined by
the DOSM of RM2,589 in 2022. According to a report by the United Nations Children’s Fund
(UNICEF) Malaysia in 2024, taking into consideration key factors such as cost of living, the PLI,
median wage and productivity, their calculations show that the minimum wage for Malaysia
Based on the results of a study conducted by Saari et al. (2016), minimum wages were
found to be effective in reducing poverty among all ethnic groups in Malaysia. An increase in the
minimum wage helps to close the income gap between low-paid and high-paid workers. An
update to this policy will also help create an equal opportunity for all workers to receive a fair
11
compensation for their efforts, especially marginalised groups that are disproportionately
represented in low-paid jobs and are the groups who are most likely to be in poverty. It also
prevents the exploitation of employees by greedy corporations that also seek to increase profit
As discussed earlier, the government has tried to establish several forms of affordable
housing which have not been able to keep up with demand in recent years. With the current trend
of population growth and urbanisation, the incompatibility between supply and demand of
affordable housing will continue to worsen if action is not taken. Due to this, the government
should try to implement more initiatives to ensure the availability of affordable housing
The government should have more policies in terms of public private partnership to
address the problem of supply in affordable housing to meet demands of the increasing low-
income population (Masram & Misnan, 2019). Typically, in Malaysia, an affordable house refers
to one that is below RM250,000. The private sector should be incentivized by the government or
work together with them in order to create more affordable housing. The government could
provide subsidies, tax reductions or grants to private companies who specialise in construction to
incentivize them to build more affordable housing. They could provide land at reduced rates for
private developers who are willing to create affordable houses. These private partners would use
their expertise and financing to create housing, reducing the burden for the government to solve
12
In addition to that, the government should reinstate rent control measures in order to
protect people, particularly those in poverty from predatory rental practices. The Malaysian
government had initiated rent control in 1966 but it was subsequently repealed in 1997 as the
government thought the policy was negatively affecting landlords and preventing development.
Now more than ever, a rent control policy needs to be reintroduced to ensure that property
owners do not take advantage of renters by charging excessive amounts on rental properties
specifically in urban areas. Rent control will place a limit on the amount of rent that can be
charged ensuring that it is affordable and reasonably priced. This will prevent low-income
Informal workers refer to those working in the informal economy and typically do not
have any legal rights and are not monitored by the government. Many low-income households
are part of the informal economy and are not given access to any social protections such as EPF,
SOCSO or the Employment Insurance System (EIS). This means that they are left vulnerable if
Therefore, the government needs to implement a system in which workers from the
informal sector contribute to compulsory savings in order to provide a safety net for themselves.
The government should create an alternative savings outlet for informal workers excluded from
the mandatory contributions. (Bank Negara Malaysia, 2022). The government has already
implemented a similar system in which SOCSO introduced a mandatory contributory scheme for
taxi or on demand drivers. This system should be extended to other sectors to provide better
13
By implementing this, it creates more financial security for informal workers and enables
them to have a backup plan in case of unforeseen circumstances. They will ensure that they are
less likely to be driven to poverty. Most informal workers lack the financial literacy and
resources to plan for retirement.These contribution compulsory saving schemes also act as a
retirement fund for informal workers and ensure that they have enough money to survive even in
old age.
In recent years, the gender wage gap has been becoming worse in Malaysia. The
discrepancy between how much men and women make is one of the contributing factors towards
poverty. Women are also not provided with sufficient support to be integrated into the labour
market in terms of maternity and childcare. This is why the government needs to step in with
legislation, laws and policies to encourage the participation of women and prevent discrimination
based on gender.
The government’s labour laws must consider discriminatory issues in order to guarantee
gender equality and pay equity between men and women in Malaysia (Najib & Majid, 2021).
Malaysia should put a policy in place where companies are not allowed to pay women less than
men for the same job solely on the basis of gender. Equally as important, they should enforce
this policy and take action on companies that do have gender wage gaps by fining them.
Companies typically see women employees as lesser than their male counterparts and assume
they can get away with paying women less. This mechanism will ensure that women are not
14
The government should also consider subsidising childcare and providing longer
maternity leave. As women are typically seen as homemakers, after having children, women in
Malaysia are less likely to return to the workforce. This is one of the contributing factors towards
why the female labour force participation is only around 50%. Subsidising childcare will enable
women to return to the workforce with less financial burden placed on them. Longer maternity
leave also encourages women to be more active in the workforce as they will not be penalised for
having children. Therefore, implementing these policies can help integrate women into the
poverty. Comprehensive infrastructure in terms of roads, transport, health, education and others
are vital as they promote regional productivity growth and are a key part of poverty mitigation.
(Azam & Bakar, 2017). The government should place an emphasis on developing infrastructure
This can be done through accessible and reliable public transportation. The government
needs to emphasise transport development for the urban poor as the lack of it restricts their job
and education opportunities (Seetanah et al., 2009). Those in low-income households are not able
to spend a significant amount of money on transportation such as personal cars or bikes. This
means that they heavily rely on public transportation to get around as it is all that they can
households as it limits their mobility. Hence, the government should create accessible and
15
5.0: CONCLUSION
Urban poverty in Malaysia has been on the rise in recent years. This was due to causes
such as urbanisation which caused a massive shift in the Malaysian population from rural to
urban areas. Lack of good governance played an equally important role as it failed to provide a
sufficient safety net or adequate affordable housing. Other causes included exclusion of
demographics such as women and the elderly. Women have to deal with the gender wage gap
while the elderly struggle to survive with limited pension or savings. Foreign workers also
contribute towards poverty by oversaturating the labour market and creating competition for jobs
where they are favoured over local workers as they are easier to be exploited. Lastly, inflation
played a substantial role in causing poverty. Food inflation was particularly high and affected
In order to overcome these issues, several policy solutions were suggested. Firstly, higher
minimum wage to ensure employees are compensated fairly and are able to acquire necessities
with their income. Affordable housing by the government through public-private partnerships
and rent control were also emphasised to reduce the financial strain on low income households.
Compulsory savings for informal workers is also important as they represent a majority of low
low income households and need to be given an adequate safety net. Equity for women can also
help in the eradication of poverty by encouraging women to actively participate in the labour
16
market and decrease the likelihood of discrimination. In addition to that, infrastructural
development in terms of transportation is vital as urban poor rely on it for their livelihoods.
multitude of reasons. Its impacts are far reaching and primarily negative. This is why policy
REFERENCES
Ahmad, N. F., Mansor, M., & Paim, L. (2016). Income poverty and well-being among vulnerable
Ajis, M. N. E., Keling, M. F., Othman, Z., & Shuib, M. S. (2014). The dilemma of managing
foreign workers in Malaysia: opportunities and challenges. Global Journal of Human Social-
Bank Negara Malaysia. (2022). Rebuilding Retirement Savings and Financial Safety Nets in
https://www.bnm.gov.my/documents/20124/10150285/emr2022_en_box1.pdf.
https://www.bnm.gov.my/documents/20124/829207/cp01_003_box_updated.pdf.
17
Cano, A. B. (2019). Urban Poverty. The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of Urban and Regional
Caraher, K. (2003). Malaysia: Approaches to Income Security in Old Age. Social Policy and
Chung, C. (2012). Study on the Promotion of Human Rights of the Urban Poor: Strategies and
Best Practices, UN. A/HRC/AC/9/3 Right to food of the Human Rights Council Advisory
Committee.
Department of Statistics Malaysia. (2022). Household Income & Basic Amenities Survey Report
2022. https://open.dosm.gov.my/dashboard/household-income-expenditure
Domains. https://www.dosm.gov.my/uploads/release-content/file_20240110152207.pdf
https://www.ekonomi.gov.my/sites/default/files/2024-06/The_Malaysian_Economy_in_Figures_
2023.pdf
Economic Planning Unit Malaysia. (2015). Eleventh Malaysia Plan 2016-2020: Anchoring
18
Hamzah, I. S., Sarifin, M. R., Aziz, M. S. A., & Abdullah, M. F. A. (2020). Malaysia as
Ismail N. A., Ismail S. & Laidin J. (2022). The Impacts Of Food Inflation On Poverty In
Mansor, N., & Awang, H. (2002). The role of social safety nets in Malaysia: Trends and
prospects. Towards Asia’s sustainable development: The role of social protection, 197-214.
Masram, H., & Misnan, S. H. (2019). Evolution of policy for affordable housing programmes in
Malaysia. International Journal of Accounting, Finance and Business (IJAFB), 4(17), 86-98.
Mohd-Rahim, F. A., Zainon, N., Sulaiman, S., Lou, E., & Zulkifli, N. H. (2019). Factors
Mok, T. Y., Gan, C., & Sanyal, A. (2007). The determinants of urban household poverty in
Najib, N. I. M., & Majid, N. (2021). Analysis of gender income gap in Malaysia. Journal of
19
Olotuah, A. O., & Adesiji, O. S. (2005). Housing poverty, slum formation, and deviant
Saari, M. Y., Rahman, M. A. A., Hassan, A., & Habibullah, M. S. (2016). Estimating the impact
of minimum wages on poverty across ethnic groups in Malaysia. Economic Modelling, 54, 490-
502.
Seetanah, B., Ramessur, S., & Rojid, S. (2009). Does infrastructure alleviate poverty in
6(2), 31-36.
United Nations Development Programme (2024). 2024 UNDP Trends Report: The Landscape of
02/undp_trends_report_deck_2024.pdf
United Nations Children’s Fund Malaysia. (2024). Key Findings Living on the Edge
%20(key%20findings)(ENG).pdf
20