Scribd
Upload
2 views1 page

06.12.24

The document discusses why Bibi Fatima opened the door, highlighting cultural practices and religious teachings. It also addresses Imam Ali's silence during the incident, emphasizing his commitment to preserving Islam and avoiding conflict that could weaken the Muslim community. Imam Ali prioritized the safety of Islam over personal grievances, recognizing the potential consequences of standing up for his rights at that moment.

Uploaded by

zainulabideenmuhammadnaqvi
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as TXT, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
2 views1 page

06.12.24

The document discusses why Bibi Fatima opened the door, highlighting cultural practices and religious teachings. It also addresses Imam Ali's silence during the incident, emphasizing his commitment to preserving Islam and avoiding conflict that could weaken the Muslim community. Imam Ali prioritized the safety of Islam over personal grievances, recognizing the potential consequences of standing up for his rights at that moment.

Uploaded by

zainulabideenmuhammadnaqvi
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as TXT, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 1

-Last week Question-

-Why did She (bibi fatima) open the door


1. Bibi Fatima was already on the door,
2. She came all by herself, as seeing a woman there might be some mercy of the
people who came. She was pregnant, the strength Allah gave to a man was not given
to a woman
3. Culuture of Arabs that women used to open the door for people.
4. Surah Azhab ayat 53 - Believers, do not enter the house of nabi without
permission and must say salam.
Last week we discussed, despite of Imam Ali, being present in the house while Bibi
Fatima came up to answer those.

-Today-
Another Doubt or Ishkar --> Why Did Imam Ali remain silent after all this happened?
-He didnt want to remain silent, but he remembered the Wasiat of Rasullalah
-He hits the person that hit Bibi Fatima but remembers the hadith of Rasullalah "Oh
ali at that point, you have the remain silent" "Qabiltu wa samiltu" "What ever you
wrote for us, I accept it" "Oh Ali you have to be patient, you can not stand up for
yourself"
-If he stood up for his haqq, the muslims would have weakened, or the Islam would
have finished. As the most important thing at the time was to save Islam.
-There was a danger of people claiming to be the next caliph if a fight to break
out.
-When he was asked, For me the safety of Islam is the most important thing than
anything else
-In that situation, he did not have enough followers who could fight or support &
back him up.
-He would be held responsible for what had all happened to bibi Fatima if he fought
back.

You might also like