Chapter 1
Chapter 1
Instead of treating grammar as a fixed body of knowledge, grammaring Gradual Development of Grammar
emphasizes continuous learning and refinement.
Learners do not acquire grammar all at once but progressively refine
Learners develop their grammatical competence through active use and their understanding and use of grammatical structures.
experimentation.
Example: A learner may start with "He go" → then "He goes" → and
Form, Meaning, and Use
eventually use complex structures like "He has been going."
Grammaring integrates form (structure), meaning (semantics), and use
(pragmatics) to help students understand how grammar functions in real Grammar as a Cognitive Process
communication.
Grammar is not just learned but processed and reorganized in the
Example: Instead of memorizing past tense rules, students engage in brain over time.
storytelling using the past tense in a meaningful way.
Grammar in Context Learners often go through stages of approximation before reaching full
accuracy.
Teaching grammar in isolation is less effective than presenting it in
context. From Lexical to Grammatical Forms
Authentic materials (e.g., conversations, stories, articles) help learners
see grammar as a tool for communication. Many language elements start as vocabulary (lexical items) and later
become grammatical structures.
Dynamic Practice and Feedback
Example: "Going to" originally meant physical movement ("I am going
Grammaring encourages continuous practice through speaking and to the store") but has grammaticalized into a future marker ("I am
writing activities. going to study").
Instead of simply correcting errors, teachers guide students to notice
patterns and self-correct. Influence of Input and Interaction
Task-Based and Interactive Activities Learners acquire grammar through meaningful exposure to language
(listening, reading) and active use (speaking, writing).
Role-plays, storytelling, peer discussions, and problem-solving tasks
allow students to develop grammatical accuracy naturally.
Example: A child hears "Did you eat?" multiple times before
Technology (e.g., AI chatbots, grammar-checking tools) can support understanding and using "Did" as a past question marker.
interactive learning.
Errors as a Natural Part of Grammaticalization
Challenges in Teaching and Assessing Grammaring
Assessing Process Over Product: Traditional grammar tests Mistakes (e.g., "She goes" instead of "She went") show that learners
are internalizing patterns and experimenting with grammar.
often focus on correctness rather than development. Alternative
assessments like portfolios or reflective writing are needed.
Teachers should see errors as signs of progress rather than failure
Learner Anxiety: Some students may struggle with the and provide corrective feedback accordingly.
uncertainty of learning grammar through trial and error rather than
memorization. Challenges in Teaching and Assessing Grammaticalization
Traditional grammar tests assess correctness at a fixed point in time, o Student: He go to school yesterday.
but grammaticalizing is a gradual process.
o Teacher: Oh, he went to school yesterday?
Alternative assessments like journals, portfolios, and conversation Pros of Error Correction:
analysis can better capture grammatical development over time.
✅ Helps improve grammatical accuracy.
Teaching Strategies to Support Grammaticalizing ✅ Provides clear and immediate correction.
✅ Helps learners notice their mistakes.
Provide Rich Input Expose students to a variety of authentic materials
(stories, conversations, songs, videos). Cons of Error Correction:
Allow Time for Development Avoid overcorrecting small errors and 2. Feedback
instead guide students toward self-correction.
Feedback is broader than error correction and includes guidance on
overall language use, structure, style, and content. It focuses on
Use Scaffolding Techniques Start with simple structures and gradually
progress and improvement, not just fixing mistakes.
introduce more complex ones within a meaningful context.
Types of Feedback:
LESSON 3:
🔹 Explicit Feedback – Directly explains what was wrong and why.
ERROR CORRECTION VS. FEEDBACK IN LANGUAGE
LEARNING Example: You need to use the past tense here because the
action happened yesterday.
Error correction and feedback are both essential in language
teaching, but they differ in purpose, approach, and impact on learners. 🔹 Implicit Feedback – Subtle corrections through recasting or
modeling.
Error Correction Error correction is a specific type of feedback that
focuses on identifying and fixing mistakes in grammar, vocabulary, Example: Student: He go to school. → Teacher: Oh, he goes
pronunciation, or usage. It is often explicit and aims at accuracy. to school every day?
Types of Error Correction: 🔹 Evaluative Feedback – Provides praise or criticism (but may not
guide improvement).
Direct Correction – The teacher provides the correct form
immediately. Example: Good job! or This needs work.
Indirect Correction – The teacher indicates that there is an error but 🔹 Peer Feedback – Other students provide constructive comments.
does not provide the correct form.
Example: I think your sentence makes sense, but maybe you
Example: need a different verb tense.
o Teacher: There’s a mistake in the verb. Try again. ✅ Encourages self-correction and autonomy.
✅ Supports fluency and confidence.
Metalinguistic Correction – The teacher gives clues or explanations ✅ Helps learners focus on communication, not just accuracy.
about the error.
Cons of Feedback:
Example:
PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 | Page
❌ Can be vague if not specific. Teacher repeats the student’s sentence correctly, subtly
❌ Some students may struggle to interpret indirect feedback. modeling the right structure.
❌ Takes more time than direct correction. Example:
o Student: I goed to the park.
o Teacher: Oh, you went to the park? That sounds
fun!
Key Differences Between Error Correction and Feedback
Gestures & Visual Cues
Feature Error Correction Feedback
Accuracy (fixing Improvement (language Use hand signals, facial expressions, or written corrections on
Focus the board to indicate mistakes.
mistakes) development)
Example: Raising an eyebrow when a student makes an error
Comments on overall language use, in verb tense.
Explicit correction or
Method including strengths and areas to
indication of errors
improve
Best for basic grammatical errors. Ask the student to explain their sentence, making them
Example: rethink the grammar.
o Student: He go to school every day. Example:
o Teacher: He goes to school every day. (Pointing at o Student: Yesterday, I go to the store.
the verb) o Teacher: Yesterday? Can you say that again?
Encourage students to identify and correct each other’s 🔹 Best for: Essays, presentations, debates, real-world communication.
mistakes. 🔹 Avoid: Overemphasizing small errors that don’t affect meaning.
Example: After a group activity, students review each other's
writing and give constructive feedback.
Final Tips for Effective Error Correction:
3. Error Correction for Advanced Learners (C1-C2) Correction techniques should be adapted based on the skill being
developed. Speaking requires a balance between fluency and accuracy,
🔹 Goal: Fine-tune accuracy, develop complexity, and encourage self- while writing allows for more reflection and structured correction.
monitoring.
1. Error Correction Techniques for Speaking
Techniques:
🔹 Goal: Improve accuracy without disrupting fluency.
Delayed Correction (Post-Activity Review)
Techniques:
Instead of interrupting, note errors and discuss them
afterward. A. Immediate Correction (During Speaking Activities)
Example: In a speaking task, jot down errors and review them
as a class. Best for beginner learners or when accuracy is crucial.
Use symbols to indicate mistakes without providing Reformulate the student’s sentence correctly without directly
corrections (e.g., "VT" for verb tense, "WW" for wrong pointing out the error.
word). Example:
Example: o Student: He go to the market every day.
o She go to university in 2019. → She (VT) go to o Teacher: Oh, he goes to the market every day?
university in 2019.
The student must correct the errors independently.
Elicitation (Prompting Self-Correction)
Socratic Questioning (Deep Reflection on Errors)
Encourage the student to fix their own mistake.
Example:
Instead of giving the answer, ask leading questions.
o Student: Yesterday, she go shopping.
Example:
o Student: I am agree with you. o Teacher: Yesterday, she...?
o Teacher: Hmm... do we use "be" with "agree"? o Student: She went shopping!
Clarification Requests
Contrastive Analysis (Comparing Similar Structures)
Use body language to indicate an error. Best for intermediate and advanced learners to promote self-editing.
Example: Raising an eyebrow or pointing backward to
indicate a past tense mistake. Error Codes & Symbols
B. Delayed Correction (After Speaking Activities) Instead of fixing errors, the teacher marks them with
symbols (e.g., "VT" for verb tense errors).
Best for intermediate and advanced learners, when fluency is Example:
prioritized. o She go (VT) to the park last Sunday.
o The student must find and correct the mistake.
Recording & Self-Reflection Common Error Codes:
o VT = Verb Tense
Record students’ conversations and let them identify their o SP = Spelling
own mistakes. o WW = Wrong Word
Works well for pronunciation and grammar errors. o WO = Word Order
The teacher writes common mistakes made during a Underline or circle mistakes, but let students correct them.
discussion and reviews them as a class afterward. Example: She go to the store yesterday. (Student must
Example: revise.)
o After a debate, the teacher lists errors on the board:
He go to school late. (Verb tense) Peer Review & Self-Editing
I am agree with you. (Incorrect structure)
o Students correct them together. Students exchange drafts and provide constructive feedback.
Use guided questions:
7️Peer Correction o Can you spot any verb tense errors?
o Does the sentence structure look correct?
Pairs or small groups correct each other’s mistakes.
Works well in role-plays, discussions, and debates. C. Delayed Feedback (For Revision and Growth)
🔹 Best for: Conversations, debates, role-plays, storytelling. Best for long-term improvement in writing skills.
🔹 Avoid: Overcorrection during fluency activities—too much
correction can make students hesitant to speak.
Error Logs (Tracking Mistakes Over Time)
Modeling (Providing Examples) Key Differences in Correction for Speaking vs. Writing
Show students a correct version of the sentence to compare Feature Speaking Correction Writing Correction
with their own. Timing Immediate or delayed Delayed (more time for
PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 | Page
Feature Speaking Correction Writing Correction Spoken: I’m gonna call her later.
revision) Written: I am going to call her later.
Focus Fluency vs. accuracy Accuracy and structure
Recasting, elicitation, Direct/indirect correction, error 🔹 2. Ellipsis (Omission of Words)
Methods
gestures, self-reflection codes, self-editing
Conversations, discussions, Essays, reports, academic Spoken: Coming to the party?
Best for
presentations writing Written: Are you coming to the party?
SPOKEN VS. WRITTEN GRAMMAR: KEY DIFFERENCES & Spoken: Nice weather today!
FEATURES Written: The weather is nice today.
Grammar usage in spoken and written language differs significantly 🔹 6. Less Frequent Use of Passive Voice
due to context, formality, and communicative purpose. Spoken
grammar tends to be more flexible and informal, while written Spoken: They canceled the meeting.
grammar follows more structured and formal rules. Written: The meeting was canceled.
5. When Written Grammar Influences Speech Tests recognition of correct grammar forms.
Example: She ___ to the market every day. (a) go (b) goes (c)
In formal speech (presentations, news, speeches), written structures going (d) went
appear in spoken language:
✔ More complete sentences (Ladies and gentlemen, I would like to Fill-in-the-Blanks
introduce...)
✔ Fewer fillers (avoiding um, uh, like, you know)
✔ Passive voice (The findings were analyzed carefully.)
Evaluates knowledge of specific grammar points.
✔ Complex sentence structures
Example: If I ___ (be) taller, I would play basketball.
Error Correction
GRAMMATICAL ASSESSMENT: TYPES, METHODS, AND ✔️Best for: Intermediate and advanced learners.
BEST PRACTICES
Cloze Tests (Gap-Filling with Context)
Grammatical assessment is the evaluation of a learner’s grammar
knowledge, accuracy, and usage in both written and spoken language. It Tests grammar in meaningful sentences.
helps determine proficiency level, strengths, weaknesses, and areas Example: She has been working here ___ 2018. (since or
for improvement. for?)
Speaking Tasks
Final Thoughts