Simple Statistical Methods for Software Engineering Data and Patterns 1st Edition C. Ravindranath Pandian instant download
Simple Statistical Methods for Software Engineering Data and Patterns 1st Edition C. Ravindranath Pandian instant download
https://ebookfinal.com/download/simple-statistical-methods-for-
software-engineering-data-and-patterns-1st-edition-c-
ravindranath-pandian/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/statistical-methods-for-fuzzy-
data-1st-edition-reinhard-viertl/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/statistical-methods-for-spatial-data-
analysis-1st-edition-oliver-schabenberger/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/statistical-methods-for-microarray-
data-analysis-methods-and-protocols-1st-edition-andrei-y-yakovlev/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/statistical-mechanics-made-simple-a-
guide-for-students-and-researchers-daniel-c-mattis/
Nonparametric Statistical Methods For Complete and
Censored Data 1st Edition M.M. Desu (Author)
https://ebookfinal.com/download/nonparametric-statistical-methods-for-
complete-and-censored-data-1st-edition-m-m-desu-author/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/statistical-methods-for-psychology-
seventh-edition-david-c-howell/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/object-oriented-software-engineering-
using-uml-patterns-and-java-3rd-intern-edition-bruegge/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/statistical-methods-for-the-analysis-
of-biomedical-data-second-edition-robert-f-woolson/
C. Ravindranath Pandian
Murali Kumar S K
CRC Press
Taylor & Francis Group
6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300
Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742
© 2015 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business
This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reasonable
efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and publisher cannot
assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of their use. The authors and
publishers have attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced in this publication
and apologize to copyright holders if permission to publish in this form has not been obtained. If any
copyright material has not been acknowledged please write and let us know so we may rectify in any
future reprint.
Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced,
transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or
hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information stor-
age or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers.
For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copy-
right.com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222
Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that pro-
vides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photo-
copy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged.
Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are
used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe.
Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at
http://www.taylorandfrancis.com
and the CRC Press Web site at
http://www.crcpress.com
Contents
Preface..........................................................................................................xvii
Acknowledgment...........................................................................................xix
Introduction..................................................................................................xxi
Authors....................................................................................................... xxiii
Section I Data
1 Data, Data Quality, and Descriptive Statistics.......................................3
The Challenge That Persists..........................................................................3
Bringing Data to the Table Requires Motivation..........................................5
Data Quality.................................................................................................5
On Scales.............................................................................................5
Error....................................................................................................6
Data Stratification...............................................................................7
Visual Summary...........................................................................................7
Numerical Descriptive Statistics (Numerical Summary of Data)................10
Special Statistics................................................................................12
Three Categories of Descriptive Statistics...........................................12
Case Study: Interpretation of Effort Variance Descriptive Statistics............12
Application Notes.......................................................................................14
Concluding Remarks..................................................................................14
Review Questions.......................................................................................15
Exercises.....................................................................................................16
Appendix 1.1: Definition of Descriptive Statistics.......................................16
Number of Data Points......................................................................16
Sum...................................................................................................16
Variance.............................................................................................16
Standard Deviation............................................................................16
Maximum..........................................................................................17
Minimum..........................................................................................17
Range................................................................................................17
Mode.................................................................................................17
Median..............................................................................................17
Mean.................................................................................................18
Kurtosis (Flatness of Distribution).....................................................18
Skewness (Skew of Distribution)........................................................18
References...................................................................................................18
Suggested Readings....................................................................................19
2 Truth and Central Tendency.................................................................21
Mean..........................................................................................................21
Uncertainty in Mean: Standard Error................................................22
Median.......................................................................................................23
Mode..........................................................................................................25
Geometric Mean.........................................................................................25
Harmonic Mean.........................................................................................27
Interconnected Estimates............................................................................27
Weighted Mean..........................................................................................28
Robust Means.............................................................................................29
Trimmed Mean.................................................................................29
Winsorized Mean..............................................................................30
Midhinge...........................................................................................30
Midrange...........................................................................................30
Tukey’s Trimean................................................................................30
Mean Derived from Geometrical Perspectives...................................30
Two Categories...........................................................................................30
Category 1.........................................................................................30
Category 2.........................................................................................31
Truth..........................................................................................................31
Application Notes.......................................................................................32
Managing Software Projects Using Central Tendency Values............32
Making Predictions...........................................................................32
Case Study: Shifting the Mean...................................................................33
Review Questions...................................................................................... 34
Exercises.................................................................................................... 34
References.................................................................................................. 34
Suggested Reading..................................................................................... 34
3 Data Dispersion.....................................................................................35
Range-Based Empirical Representation......................................................35
Dispersion as Deviation from Center..........................................................38
Average Deviation..............................................................................39
Average Absolute Deviation...............................................................39
Median Absolute Deviation...............................................................39
Defect Density.................................................................................. 90
Defect Classification..........................................................................91
Reliability..........................................................................................91
Examples of Process Metrics.......................................................................91
Review Effectiveness..........................................................................91
Test Effectiveness...............................................................................91
Test Coverage....................................................................................92
Subprocess Metrics.....................................................................................92
Converting Metrics into Business Information...........................................93
Project Dashboard.............................................................................93
Product Health Report......................................................................95
Statistical Process Control Charts......................................................96
Case Study: Early Size Measurements.........................................................96
Project Progress Using Earned Value Metrics..............................................97
Tracking Progress..............................................................................97
Tracking Project Cost........................................................................98
Review Questions.....................................................................................100
Exercises...................................................................................................101
References.................................................................................................101
Suggested Readings..................................................................................102
7 Maintenance Metrics...........................................................................103
Fusion of Frameworks in Software Maintenance......................................103
Maintainability Index......................................................................105
Change Requests Count..................................................................105
Customer Satisfaction Index............................................................106
Resource Utilization........................................................................107
Service-Level Agreement Compliances............................................107
Percentage of On-Time Delivery......................................................109
Enhancement Size...........................................................................109
Bug Complexity............................................................................... 110
Effort Variance (EV)........................................................................ 111
Schedule Variance (SV)................................................................... 111
Quality............................................................................................ 111
Quality of Enhancement........................................................ 111
Quality of Bug Fix.................................................................. 111
Productivity.....................................................................................112
Time to Repair (TTR)....................................................................112
Backlog Index..................................................................................113
Bug Classification............................................................................113
Fix Quality......................................................................................113
Refactoring Metrics.........................................................................113
Reliability........................................................................................113
Metric-Based Dashboards.........................................................................113
Review Questions..................................................................................... 115
Exercises................................................................................................... 115
References................................................................................................. 115
Suggested Readings.................................................................................. 116
8 Software Test Metrics.......................................................................... 117
Project Metrics.......................................................................................... 117
Schedule Variance............................................................................ 117
Effort Variance................................................................................ 117
Cost................................................................................................. 118
Human Productivity........................................................................ 118
Requirement Stability...................................................................... 118
Resource Utilization........................................................................ 118
Customer Satisfaction...................................................................... 119
Test Effectiveness............................................................................. 119
Process Metrics......................................................................................... 119
Defect Removal Efficiency...............................................................120
Test Cases Count.............................................................................120
Test Coverage..................................................................................121
Functionality Coverage..........................................................121
Code Coverage.......................................................................121
Percentage of Bad Fix......................................................................122
Product Metrics........................................................................................122
Defect Counts.................................................................................122
Defect Arrival Rate.................................................................122
Defect Closure Rate...............................................................122
Component Defect Count......................................................123
Component Defect Density.............................................................123
Defect Classification........................................................................124
Testing Size: Test Case Point....................................................................124
Risk Metric...............................................................................................125
Predicting Quality....................................................................................126
Metrics for Test Automation.....................................................................126
Return on Investment......................................................................126
Percentage Automatable...................................................................126
Automation Progress........................................................................127
Case Study: Defect Age Data....................................................................127
Review Questions.....................................................................................128
Exercises...................................................................................................129
References.................................................................................................129
Suggested Readings..................................................................................129
9 Agile Metrics.......................................................................................131
Classic Metrics: Unpopular Science..........................................................132
Two Sides of Classic Metrics.....................................................................133
Metrics for Agile: Humanization..............................................................134
The Price of Humanization.......................................................................134
Common Agile Metrics............................................................................135
Velocity............................................................................................135
Story Point.......................................................................................135
Technical Debt................................................................................136
Tests................................................................................................136
Level of Automation........................................................................136
Earned Business Value (EBV)..........................................................136
Burn-Down Chart...........................................................................136
Burn-Up Chart................................................................................136
Burn Up with Scope Line................................................................137
Adding More Agile Metrics......................................................................139
Case Study: Earned Value Management in the Agile World.....................140
Review Questions..................................................................................... 141
Exercise..................................................................................................... 141
References................................................................................................. 141
Suggested Reading....................................................................................142
Exercises...................................................................................................229
References.................................................................................................229
Suggested Readings..................................................................................230
14 Law of Compliance: Uniform Distribution.........................................231
Bounded Distribution...............................................................................233
Random Number Generators....................................................................233
Shuttle Time............................................................................................ 234
Parkinson’s Law....................................................................................... 234
Censored Process......................................................................................235
Perfect Departure.....................................................................................235
Estimating Calibration Uncertainty with Minimal Information..............235
Review Questions.....................................................................................237
Exercises...................................................................................................237
References.................................................................................................237
Suggested Readings..................................................................................237
15 Law for Estimation: Triangular Distribution.....................................239
Bell Curve Morphs into a Triangle...........................................................240
Mental Model for Estimation...................................................................241
Mean........................................................................................................242
Median.....................................................................................................243
Other Statistics.........................................................................................245
Skew.........................................................................................................245
Three-Point Schedule Estimation..............................................................247
Beta Option..............................................................................................247
Triangular Risk Estimation......................................................................248
Parameter Extraction................................................................................249
Review Questions.....................................................................................250
Exercises...................................................................................................250
References.................................................................................................250
16 The Law of Life: Pareto Distribution—80/20 Aphorism....................253
Structure of Pareto....................................................................................254
An Example..............................................................................................257
The 80/20 Law: Vital Few and Trivial Many............................................257
Generalized Pareto Distribution.............................................................. 260
Duane’s Model..........................................................................................261
Tailing a Body..........................................................................................261
Review Questions.....................................................................................262
Exercises...................................................................................................262
References.................................................................................................262
This book is a tribute to great Statisticians, scholars, and teachers whose ideas are
quoted throughout this book in various contexts. These pearls of wisdom have
helped us to connect our book with the evolution of science, knowledge and engi-
neering. Eventhough there are many books on statistics, there are few dedicated
to the application of statistical methods to software engineering. Pure textbooks
provide scholarly treatment, whereas practitioners need basic understanding and
application knowledge. Very few statistical books provide application knowledge to
software engineers. We have been working toward bridging this gap for about two
decades and have come out with the current book.
Statistical methods are often discussed in the context of six sigma, Capability
Maturity Model Integrated (CMMI), establishing capability baselines, and con-
structing process performance models. Driven by CMMI auditors, such practices
have become rituals that rely heavily on automated statistical packages, which are
rarely well understood. We have been promoting excel-based solution to statistics
and have presented practical solutions, such as those achieved in this book.
Karl Pearson
We also realize that sophisticated statistics is not the ideal approach to solve
problems. Simpler techniques provide easy solutions that connect with the intu-
ition of problem solvers. Although sophisticated techniques sound impressive but
merely academic, simpler techniques are flexible and can easily penetrate to the root
of the problem. In this book, we have consciously selected simpler tools. We have
also simplified several standard techniques.
The techniques presented in this book appear to us as a minimum set of intel-
lectual tools for software engineers and managers. True software engineering
xvii
can happen only when data are collected and these statistical methods are used.
Moreover, the statistical management of processes is possible only when managers
master these techniques.
Learning these techniques in the context of software engineering will certainly
help budding engineers and fresh recruits. The examples provided in this book will
provide a deep insight into software engineering and management.
This book can be used extensively as a guidebook for training software engi-
neers and managers at different levels. It will be a very valuable asset in the hands
of quality professionals who collect data and create models.
This book also exposes practical software engineering problems and solutions to
aspiring engineering graduates and make them industry ready.
Generally, this book is a guide for professionals to think objectively with data.
It will help them to mine data and extract meanings. Some of the techniques pro-
vided in the book are excellent prediction tools, which would give foresight to those
who apply them.
This book would not have become a reality without fruitful feedback from several
software professionals, quality managers, and project managers who have taken
our training and consultancy services. We also acknowledge Software Process
Improvement Network (SPIN) for presenting some of these concepts through vari-
ous SPIN chapters in India in an attempt to propagate these methods. All the SPIN
coordinators we interacted with have provided excellent application suggestions.
We thank those organizations who have shared their metric problems with us
for analysis and resolution. They eventually provided us research opportunities that
helped us gain deeper knowledge. We also thank many research scholars who have
interacted with us and taken our research support in the context of data mining
and artificial neural network.
We thank the professors and correspondents of many colleges in India for help-
ing us interact with students. We also thank Project Management Institute (PMI)
chapters and project management institutes who gave us opportunities to present
quantitative techniques to managers.
Rathna and Samuel helped by offering a wonderful review and criticism of
Chapter 8. Swaminathan contributed to Chapter 21 by reviewing the chapter and
making valuable suggestions. Shanti Harry helped us with references and suggested
readings. We thank all these well wishers.
Finally, we thank Mr. John Wyzalek who provided moral support and editorial
help. He made serious decisions about the scope of this book and helped us make a
tough decision to leave some chapters for the future and focus on the few we have
selected for this publication.
xix
A Russian coal-miner
TOLSTOI—ODESSA—CONSTANTINOPLE
The second night after my arrival at the house where I was a guest I was
taken over to Yasnaya Poliana. Tolstoi had been informed of my presence in
the neighborhood, and had graciously suggested to my friend that she bring
me to see him. The fast-falling, late autumn night was settling over the
snow-fields and silver woods as we climbed the knoll upon which Yasnaya
Poliana house stands. In summer the place must have a fascinating charm,
for all the elements of a beautiful country park are there—flower-beds and
wildwood, orchards, groves and arbored walks, a bit of water, fields rolling
toward distant horizons, broad sky and vistas that hold one. Surmounting
the knoll, a pleasant house, large enough without being grand, comfortable
without pretension. At the door a black poodle barked a welcome. A man-
servant helped us to unload the heavy garments we wore against the cold of
a Russian November night. With not unexpected directness we were taken
straight to the count’s study. There he sat—near a table-desk which was
littered with piles of letters and papers. “Good evening,” he called cheerily
and quite as though I were an old friend. His hands, which were extended in
welcome, were warm as if the fires of his strong life and body still burned
fiercely, as when he commanded men on Sebastopol bastions, ranged over
the unconquered Caucasus, and hunted with the most daring of his
comrades through great Russian forests. He had been horseback-riding in
the afternoon, he told us. Surely few men carry the weight of seventy-eight
years with more vigor.
The first words of greeting over, he began to ask about his friends in
America, men whom he knows personally or by reputation. A conversation
with a neighbor from one’s own home town on a chance meeting in a
foreign land would scarcely have been different. There was a delightful
eagerness for word-of-mouth news. Names of men in New York slipped as
easily from his tongue as from one of their own circle.
Shelves of books in many languages walled the room from floor to eye
level, while above hung portraits of many thinkers who have, or should
have, influenced the world. Prominent among them Henry George and
William Lloyd Garrison.
“Do you read Garrison?” Tolstoi asked, as my wandering eyes rested on
the portrait of our own champion of liberty. “Do you read Channing,
Thoreau, Emerson? I always ask Americans about those four great men.
They should be read by the young men of to-day.”
A tall candle burning on the table by his right side threw its restless
gleams across the old man’s rugged face, and involuntarily my mind ran
incredulously over the intensely human career whose latter days are now
marked by such inspiring serenity.
We could not long keep off the subject of Russia and her troubles,
however, and at last I ventured to ask him what was his interpretation of the
movement of things in Russia at the moment.
Tolstoi pointed to an old volume of Rousseau’s “Émile” lying on a table
at the other side of the room, and asked me to bring it to him. Turning over
the pages of Book IV till he found the paragraph he sought, he paused, then
read very slowly and with emphasis, these sentences: “On dit qu’il falloit
une révélation pour apprendre aux hommes la manière dont Dieu vouloit
être servi; on assigne en préserve la diversité des cultes bizarres qu’ils ont
institué, et l’on ne voit pas que cette diversité même vient de la fantaisie des
révélations. Dès que les peuples se sont avisés de faire parler Dieu, chacun
l’a fait parler à sa mode et lui a fait dire ce qu’il a voulu; si l’on n’eût
écouté que ce que Dieu dit au cœur de l’homme, il n’y auroit jamais eu
qu’une religion sur la terre.” The last sentence he read twice, and then
handed the book across the table that I might absorb the passage. “That is
what we have all got to learn,” he said, “to listen to the words God speaks
to us in our hearts. We need no other religion or philosophy than this. We
need no institution like a church. This message is for the people of America
as well as for Russia, and the whole significance of the present terrible
situation in Russia is that the Russian people are being brought to the point
where every other channel will be closed and only by turning to God will
they be able to save themselves.” In other words, Tolstoi sees, as every one
in Russia must see, that the drift of things is toward an abyss, and Tolstoi
reads into this tendency a deeply religious meaning; he accepts it as part of
a Divine plan, and he firmly believes that the Russian people will come to
look upon their situation as a call from God to discard their ancient
superstitions and to inaugurate a new era in which each individual will
endeavor to readjust his life into conformity with the infinite.
Tolstoi appreciates, as does every one in Russia, that the Russian liberal
movement aims to effect a social revolution, and that a successful political
revolt will only mark the beginning of the struggle. Tolstoi does not view
this as do most Russian thinkers, however. He does not accept the
accomplishment of a socialistic state as a goal at all, for he distrusts the
economics of socialism, and as a philosophy he rejects socialism
vehemently. “It is not a second-rate, but a hundredth-rate philosophy,” he
says. “The present growth of socialism,” he went on in explanation, “is to
be accounted for in precisely the same way as the present popularity of
inferior literature, poetry, drama, and art. It is all part of a passing phase.”
“Monsieur Leroy Beaulieu, the French writer,” said Tolstoy, “was here
not long ago, and he said to me: ‘The Russian revolution? It is for fifty
years.’ That may be. But in the end—whether ten years or fifty years—a
new era of righteousness will be established in Russia.”
Late in the evening we adjourned to the dining-room, where were the
countess and a party of about a dozen. A more varied group one seldom
meets under one roof. There was the count, strong in his faith, confident in
the truth of his own philosophy of “Christian anarchism.” There was a son,
who, during the Japanese War, was a patriot, a loyal subject of the Czar, and
as such volunteered for service in arms and served in Manchuria. There was
the eldest brother of this soldier son, a Constitutional Democrat, or middle-
of-the-road-man, and next him a sister who is married to a man who is an
“Octoberist,” a conservative deputy to the first Duma, and she shares her
husband’s political opinions. Also there was a disciple of Count Tolstoi,
who believes not in war or parliaments at all; and a Social Revolutionist,
who believes ardently in revolution and even in terrorism. Each was true to
his own convictions and perfectly outspoken. When the count had drunk his
glass of tea, little heeding the babel of conversation around the board, he
pushed back his chair and for several moments slowly paced the room. The
huge dining-room, warm with hospitality, afforded a striking picture that
night. Against the high, dark walls stood out several life-size oil portraits. In
one corner a grand piano, near it a table on which were strewn a pack of
cards, and opposite a cozy-corner. In the center of the room, the long
dining-table around which were gathered the company; at one end a
steaming samovar. Slowly, back and forth, paced the count, now in the
shadow, now in the light, his shaggy gray beard against his dark-blue
peasant blouse. So stalwart, so vigorous, so keen to all things he seemed.
Above all, so serene in spirit; for he glories in the present dark hour of his
country, believing it harbingers the approach of dawn—the awakening of
the Russian people to a consciousness of a grander destiny than they have
dreamed of before, when as true sons of God they shall realize that heaven
of which the dogmatic preachers talk, only not in a distant future, but here
on earth.
However often it may be true that “a prophet is without honor in his own
country,” Tolstoi is honored and revered by the peasants in the villages of
Tula, and his own influence throughout Russia is very great. Curiously
enough, though, it is his unconscious influence which is greatest. Tolstoi,
above all living men, is the apostle of “non-resistance” and “passive
resistance.” But in Russia all resistance of necessity becomes active
resistance. Tolstoi pamphlets on the horrors and evils of war perhaps more
than any other influence have brought army service into disrepute with the
people. The Russian people hold their enforced military service as one of
their prime grievances, and to avoid such service every ruse and device is
resorted to from bribery and perjury to open “passive resistance,” that is,
stubborn refusal to carry arms. But the government views this attitude as
opposed to its interests and consequently revolutionary. Refusal to bear
arms in Russia is punished by imprisonment. Tolstoi told me of a peasant
thus imprisoned who replied to the court that sentenced him: “Very well,
imprison me. I shall pray for you and my unhappy country, whose rulers
make men do evil.” The beginnings of resistance have been inspired by
Tolstoi’s “peaceful” and “Christian” writings in thousands of cases, and
eventually fruited in revolutionaryism and insurrection. This unconscious
influence, which Tolstoi has exerted during the last decade, and more
especially during the last two years, is enormous. Peasants in every section
of Russia knew more or less about Tolstoi, and while not professing to be
“Tolstoians,” nevertheless admit that the beginning of their criticism of the
government, and the first inspiration to trust to their own thinking, came
from one or another of Tolstoi’s writings. Doubtless there are thousands of
people all over the world who owe, even if they do not recognize, a like
debt to this great, restive spirit, the dynamic of whose life has been both
innate and conscious moral earnestness. A moral leader of the force and
caliber of Tolstoi can not fail to impress a generation, and this is Tolstoi’s
contribution to life and the world: he has quickened men to thought and
action, and he has pointed a goal and standard above all others in the God
which dwells within each and every human being.
Upon leaving Tula I went south to the Crimea. On the train I read
Tolstoi’s “Sebastopol Sketches,” which contain about the most graphic
descriptions of war ever written. Curiously enough the season of the year
when I first saw Sebastopol was the same as Tolstoi describes upon his
arrival in the besieged city in 1854. During all my stay there I could not get
away from the remarkable coincidental similarity in conditions—December,
1854, and December, 1906. To be sure, Sebastopol was not besieged by
alien foes from without, but it was besieged by revolutionists from within.
This, like most ports and all naval stations, is a revolutionary stronghold.
Only the day before my arrival an admiral or port officer had been
assassinated. Sentinels patrolled the streets at intervals of one hundred feet.
The Hotel Kist was guarded. Small bodies of troops were moving in
different parts of the city, and when the early morning mist lifted, a half-
dozen warships were revealed lying at anchor. For several hours during the
forenoon large forces of cavalry and light artillery were kept manœuvering
in the plain across the narrow strip of water from the pristan. It might just
as well have been a besieged city. Save for the lack of wounded and dead
men, the outward aspects of the town were every whit as warlike, and
everywhere were the signs of martial law.
These indications of unrest and readiness for trouble did not deter me
from visiting Balaklava and lovely Yalta, or interesting Bakhtchi-Sarai, the
old Crimean Tartar capital, and Tchoufout-Kali, the two thousand-year old
Karaite[22] stronghold. After these visits I turned toward Odessa, which I
reached via Eupatoria.
Odessa being one third a Jewish city has long been a city of trouble—not
so much because of the Jews as on account of the powerful Black Hundred
organization made up of water-front laborers and the lowest elements of a
special city, who, under governmental tutelage, from time to time break
loose upon the Jews. Incipient and real massacres are apt to break out there
any time. The governor-general, Kaulbars, is a notorious reactionary, and
encourages every form of repression.
I had studied the Jewish question in many other places, and in Odessa as
in Warsaw, Vilna, and other Jewish centers, I became convinced that the
Russian government, by its extraordinarily blind and stupid policy, has
itself created the Jewish problem. If the 5,000,000 Jews who are now in
Russia were scattered among the 140,000,000 people of the Russian empire,
they would scarcely be noticed. But Russia chose the arbitrary part and
closed to the Jews all but a tiny strip of the empire. In only nine
governments and in Poland many Jews live, and these are the districts
which constitute “the pale”—South Russia, Poland, and the Baltic
provinces. Having corralled all the Jews over whom it has jurisdiction, the
Russian government then proceeded to enact a long series of special,
discriminative laws, and to inaugurate special Jewish taxes.
Stripped of every right and privilege of citizenship and manhood save
one—the right to pay taxes—the Jews of Russia have had no other recourse
than to develop their mental powers. This they have done most creditably
under circumstances quite as adverse as learning arithmetic from a
borrowed text-book, by the light of a rail fire during the hours between the
end of the workday and sleep time. And now, because he has given himself
devotedly up to the one thing left him and has been successful, he is feared.
Whatever may have been the original motives of the czars in the restrictions
they laid upon the Jews, the present attitude of Jew-baiting Russians is
based upon jealous fear.
One thing all observers mark—outspoken bitterness against the Jews on
the part of peasants flourishes in the parts where the Jews are not. Within
the pale most often does one find champions of the Jew. Nearly every
telegraph correspondent for the foreign press who hastened to Bielostok at
the time of the massacre commented on the testimony of the townspeople
that (to quote one of them) “the Jews and Christians had always lived
together like brothers.” The Jew is much more apt to be suspicious of the
Christian than is the non-Jew to nourish ill-will against the Jews whom he
comes into frequent contact with. If it is not literally true that to know is to
love, it at least may be said that to know is to tolerate, with regard to the
Jews in Russia. The persecution of the Jews in Russia originates with
official Russia, and the bitterness which their weakness and fears inspire is
passed on to the people through the government’s agents—often the priests
—through the government press, and through the scapegoat, underling
officials who are immediately above the actual perpetrators of the dire
deeds, and below the higher officials who are morally responsible.
The massacre of Bielostok was executed as a diabolical and fantastic
orgy by the police and the soldiers. They deliberately shot little children.
They ravished, then murdered, young girls, they tortured men by the wildest
and most excruciating devices. And the police and soldiers, incidentally,
looted Jewish shops and carried away pockets full of watches from
jewelers, and cash when they could get it.
The governor of the district was removed, but not in disgrace. The actual
perpetrators of these deeds still administer the “law” in Bielostok. The
children and the families of the murdered see them every time they go out. I
saw them when I was there. They walked about with heads in the air as if
they had done a noble thing and were worthy, like war-heroes. And the
story of Bielostok is practically the very same as the story of Gomel, of
Kishineff and Odessa, save that in Odessa there is a stronger Black Hundred
element of “hooligans” and rowdies, who, for a pittance, are glad to lend
themselves to the unscrupulous and murderous police.
Such conditions drive the older and weaker Jews to America, and the
more spirited of the younger generation to revolution. It is the height of
absurdity for the Russian government to excuse its Jewish oppression on the
ground that the Jews are revolutionary. By nature and by tradition they are
the opposite of aggressive and militant. They are revolutionary because the
Russian government is oppressive, and because they know no other course.
The Russian Jew is docile, domestically inclined, and peace-loving
naturally, but when exasperated beyond endurance he becomes a daring
antagonist. Surely it is no reflection against the Jewish race that the stronger
men and women resent the endless insults that Russia heaps upon them.
Even the passport of a Jew is differentiated. Fifteen thousand Jews gave up
their lives in Manchuria during the course of the late inglorious war, in
which they had no interest and for which they had no sympathy. Fifteen
thousand more were wounded in the same ignominious cause. And yet
Manchuria remains closed to the Jews as a place of settlement. Thirty
thousand Jewish victims in one war! Yet no Jew may
Cossacks on patrol duty
The man who gave me this circular then went on to say, that he himself
believed that an occasional pogrom was a good thing, because it increased
the restlessness of the Jews, and he hoped that by continuing this policy
Russia would soon be rid of them.
In response to my request for some printed matter, setting forth the aims
and objects of the organization, I was given a brochure which contained the
following definitions:
I. Aim—To develop the Russian national self-consciousness and
strengthen the union of Russian people of all classes, for the mutual
work and prosperity of their dear country.
II. The welfare of the country depends upon the complete
preservation of Russian unlimited orthodoxy, autocracy, and nationality.
III. The restoration of orthodoxy to its place of dominant influence.
IV. Autocracy consists in the union of Czar with Russian people
Further:
The Russian language for all nations living within the Empire.
The League takes upon itself the development of the national
consciousness through the political life in the spirit of autocracy and
spreading among the population Christian principles which strengthen
patriotism, and awaken the sense of duty toward government, society,
and home.
This to be done through the usual methods of propaganda—schools,
lectures, books, brochures, and journals.
Such is the League of Russian Men, to whom the Czar addressed himself
in December, 1905, when accepting for himself and the Czarevitch the
badge of the organization:
“Unite, Russian people! I reckon upon you. With your assistance I
believe I shall be able to conquer the enemies of Russia.”
These very words of the Czar are now used by “the League of Russian
Men” as a motto for their official electioneering platform, and there has
appeared no repudiation on the part of the imperial patron. This is a most
remarkable and quaint document. It consists of four pages set in large type,
but, curiously enough, one and a half pages thereof are devoted to the
Jewish question.
Although all other nationalities are to enjoy civic rights equally with
Russians, Jews are to be deprived of such rights and privileges. They are,
moreover, to be excluded from all professions (they can not be doctors,
lawyers, chemists, contractors, teachers, librarians, etc.) and public or
governmental services.
Under the heading Commerce, Industry, and Finance we find such a
curiosity as this:
The Union will strive to increase the amount of currency by
abolishing gold, and by the reintroduction of national paper currency.
Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.
ebookfinal.com