1y_FaneUnderstandingLoudspeakerDataBooklet
1y_FaneUnderstandingLoudspeakerDataBooklet
WWW.FANE-INTERNATIONAL.COM
THE SOUND EXPERIENCE
Fane loudspeaker technology is internationally renowned for delivering
the ultimate audio performance in theatre, club and concert hall sound
reinforcement systems, offering maximum efficiency, wide frequency range
and minimal distortion.
TIP: If you have any questions or doubts, our Fane appointed representatives, who
possess years of combined experience, are perfect to advise and guide you. Get in touch,
we’re happy to help! [email protected]
4
continuous output reaches beyond the heat wave output. At the peak of a sine wave, the
dissipation capabilities of the loudspeakers voice coil of a speaker is pushed out and
voice coil. Loudspeakers are very inefficient therefore if a square wave is applied, the
devices, on average 0.5-5% of power voice coil is spending more time out of the
supplied is converted to sound; the rest is coil gap. This leads to a poor heat distribution
converted to heat. If a loudspeaker is unable through the magnet, which overheats the
to dissipate that heat quickly enough
sin(x) thecos(x) voice coil and burns it.
speaker will soon fail. One of the main causes
of driver failure is a clipped or square-wave Other causes of thermal failure can
signal being sent from an amplifier. At the occur when a driver is sent a signal from
same voltage, a square wave represents a misconfigured system outside of its
double the power of a sine wave. Essentially,
3dB operationalPeak
bandwidth; input power is then
RMS
Voltage
Voltage
Voltage
Time Time Time
Fig. 1: Showing a 1W sine wave going into clipping. Notice that the voltage is sustained for longer periods at the waves peak as
becomes a square-wave.
as ‘DC burn’. That means that the speaker applied to the coil (most modern amplifiers
+120
has to dissipate twice the amount of heat. +120
have DC protection circuits so this kind of
+110
Amplifiers are rated at the power they can +110
fault is rare). Overheating may also damage
+100
provide with a sine wave type signal. When +100
adhesives and other parts that can also lead
that signal is pushed into a square wave, the to mechanical failures.
dB (1W-1m)
dB (1W-1m)
+90 +90
+80
amplifier can often output more than its rated +80
+70 +70
power. Mechanical Failure
+60 +60
Mechanical failure occurs when the
+50 +50
20 In most
50 cases,
100 200 this
(Hz) 500fault
1k is caused
2k 5k by
10kthe20k transducer
20 50 cone200or(Hz)diaphragm,
100 500 1k 2k voice
5k coil
10k or20k
amplifier ‘clipping’ the input signal due to the suspension systems are forced to physically
user trying to get more out of the amplifier move beyond their limits (Xmax / Xmech).
than it96isdBrated
(1W/1M)for.
avg. This causes an increase Typically, this99
isdB (1W/1M)
the avg. of amplifier peak
result
+120 +120
in input level to the speaker, therefore a voltage being too high. The result is over-
+110 +110
larger sine wave. If this sine wave is pushed excursion that can cause the coil to move
+100 +100
too hard, the amplifier will ‘clip’ the top and out of the voice coil gap completely, or hit
dB (1W-1m)
dB (1W-1m)
5
+90 +90
bottom of the wave and produce a square the back plate – known as ‘bottoming-out’.
+80 +80
+70 +70
+60 +60
This causes destruction of one or more For instance, a 35-350 Hz range, was used
of the software components or voice coil. when rating our 1300W (AES), FC-185F03 sub
Sometimes they may continue to work but bass driver.
performance is usually severely affected with
audible results such as hissing and rattling. Calculation: (P=V2 / Z min) Power shall be
Misconfigured cabinet designs can also determined as the square of applied RMS
cause excursion problems. voltage, as measured with a “true RMS”
voltmeter, divided by Zmin. The rated power
HOW WE DETERMINE POWER RATINGS of the device shall be that power the device
can withstand for 2 hours without permanent
How much power a speaker can handle gives change in acoustical, mechanical, or
no direct indication of its performance at full electrical characteristics greater than 10%.
power or how loud it will be. It just tells you
that’s how much power it can survive. Many The successful test conditions will
methods exist for determining the maximum therefore be derived AES nominal Power
input power. All of them have merits, and rating for all Fane Drivers. However, in a
similar attributes yet yield different results. correctly optimised enclosure featuring
Fane specified nominal power ratings are good cabinet assistance, Fane drivers
governed according to AES2-1984 standards often out-perform their nominal rated AES
that test both thermal and mechanical power ratings and also outperforming
properties of a driver to the limits. Key competitor’s offerings of the same nature
conditions of the test are as follows: even with their higher rated powers.
Time
Voltage
Time Time
the AC power to the equivalent DC power be able to produce the desired sound level
required to provide the same heating using as little power as possible. We feel it is
capacity into the load. In amplifiers and more impressive to get lots of quality sound
speakers this is usually measured with a with less applied power. Rather than reading
1kHz sine wave input. This is measured a specification sheet and saying, “Wow, that
as a constant input signal. In real sounds speaker handles 5000 watts!” we think it’s
+120
however, the levels change all the time so better to ask “Why do I have to use 5000
+110
this is the reason for quoting peak power. watts when Fane speakers can produce the
+100
But this refers to only short bursts of input same SPL level at 1000 watts?” Horn loading
dB (1W-1m)
+90
causing large outputs. An amplifier couldn’t and other enclosure design techniques are
+80
maintain a peak output constantly because methods of increasing loudspeaker efficiency,
+70
of power supply, and overheating problems. allowing more sound per the applied voltage
+60
power that a speaker can+80handle during compression’. It implies that the more power
typical music or ‘typical program’
+70 (if there you put into the driver, the less output you
were such a thing) where+60frequency content get out. For this reason, it is a mistake to
0 (Hz) 500 1k and2k power
5k constantly
10k 20k vary.20 Program
50 100power
+50
200 (Hz) 500 associate
1k 2k 5kthe10k
power
20k rating of the loudspeaker
is typically given as twice that of the nominal with its sonic performance.
power rating.
Higher power ratings simply mean that a
speaker is one of two things; firstly it is so
inefficient that it needs excessive power
to drive the coil. Or, secondly, it has such
an effective heat dissipation management
system that it is able to deliver high SPL 7
at the stated higher input power. Sadly, in AVERAGE SENSITIVITY
the vast majority of cases the first option
sin(x) cos(x)
Voltage
Voltage
Time Time
against a competitor’s equivalent model that truth to give a higher SPL figure. It’s only on
claimed 1500W. Both speaker specifications closer inspection in the darkest corners of
showed a sensitivity of 99 dB (1W/1M) over their some spec sheets that the true ‘reference
working bandwidth. On paper at least, many efficiency’, band limited, sensitivity figures
would pick the higher power rated speaker, but are found. Fane list average sensitivity figures
this could prove to be an unwise choice. that are calculated from the speaker’s Thiele/
+120
Small
+120
Parameters and take band limiting into
+110
In this particular instance, after incremental account
+110
so as to give a true reflection. Take
+100 +100
power tests, we discovered that in excess the graph below for example, it shows the
dB (1W-1m)
dB (1W-1m)
+90 +90
of 1000W the efficiency of the 1500W driver same speaker rated in two different ways,
+80 +80
actually began to slope-off as a result of 96dB to include it’s true working range and
+70 +70
power compression, producing lower SPL 99dB that includes upper frequency peaks to
+60 +60
while the lower power-rated PD model was increase the figure.
+50 +50
rising
20
in50SPL
100
to 200
a +3dB
(Hz) 500
difference.
1k 2k 5k 10k 20k 20 50 100 200 (Hz) 500 1k 2k 5k 10k 20k
+110 +110
+100 +100
dB (1W-1m)
dB (1W-1m)
+90 +90
+80 +80
+70 +70
+60 +60
+50 +50
20 50 100 200 (Hz) 500 1k 2k 5k 10k 20k 20 50 100 200 (Hz) 500 1k 2k 5k 10k 20k
Fig. 3: Spot the difference... The same speaker can be rated almost twice as loud. Sensitivity ratings can be manipulated depending
8 on the frequency bandwidth tested.
TIP: 3 dB of additional sound power CABINET DESIGN
from the same loudspeaker requires
double the number of amplifier watts. Loudspeaker drivers are typically housed
It is commonly accepted that 3 dB is within a speaker enclosure, cabinet, along
the smallest practical sound pressure with associated electronic hardware such as
difference detectable by the human ear. crossover circuits and, in the case of active
systems, internal power amplifiers.
If you want your sound system to be
noticeable louder, you will need at The primary role of an enclosure is to
least twice as much amplifier power prevent the sound waves generated by the
or loudspeakers at least 3 dB more reverse motion of an open chassis speaker’s
efficient. diaphragm from interacting with sound waves
generated from the forward motion. As the
That means if you have a 1500W front and rear sound waves are generated
amplifier and are considering replacing out-of-phase to each other, they travel
it with a 2000W amplifier you should different paths before finally converging at the
save your money, as that is only a 1.2 listener’s position.
dB difference. At least 3000W are
necessary for a significant improvement Any interaction in the listening space
in performance... if your current introduces interference and distortion to the
loudspeakers cannot handle that kind audio reproduction resulting in unintended
of power, you need loudspeakers with effects such as echo or reverberation etc.
either higher power handling, higher This is especially true in the case of low
efficiency or simply more loudspeakers. frequencies, on which enclosure design
mostly focuses. As such, a loudspeaker can’t
really be used without a cabinet of some
type, or by mounting it into a wall or ceiling.
Some designs attempt to take advantage of
this behaviour, using the opposing forces to
enhance sound and increase efficiency.
If you don’t feel like designing your own enclosure, don’t worry; Fane partners are able
to offer full cabinet and crossover design kits that have been developed for select Fane
loudspeaker drivers. Speak to your local representative for more information.
10
NEW
FC-152F01TC FULL RANGE DRIVER
TIP: Every part of the signal chain is important, and as such is only as strong as it’s
weakest link, so quality where possible is recommended. Consulting with a professional
is always recommended for those unsure of their mechanical or electrical abilities. Our
sales partners are able to provide excellent support and advice on amplifier selection
and setups.
13
Series Connection: enclosure sections - bass, midrange
Z Total = Z1(speaker 1) + Z2 + Z 3 etc… and treble - should individually have an
impedance of 8 ohms. If each individual
For Parallel Connection: section comprises of more than one drive
1 1 1 1 unit, the drive units in that section must
= + + etc.
Z Total Z1 Z1 Z1 be connected to present a total section
impedance if 8 ohms. There is, however,
For combined Series/ Parallel, calculate the an exception to this rule, in respect of the
impedance of each similarly placed group of treble, high frequency section only. At
loudspeakers and regard the total impedance frequencies above 3 kHz it is possible for
as being that of a single loudspeaker with the treble section to present a higher, but
a single impedance, calculate the total never lower, impedance than the other
combined impedance using the formulae sections. The effect of higher impedance
above. here is a decrease in sound output level but
an increase in power handling capability,
In multi-way systems using passive proportional to the miss-match ratio. If a 16
crossovers, it is important that each separate ohm compression driver were fitted into an 8
frequency bandwidth of the system should ohm system, as described above, the power
present the same impedance. For example, handling capability of the treble section would
in a system with 8 ohms total impedance, it therefore increase by a factor of two.
is important that each of the three divided
Z Z + +
ZTotal = Z x 2 Z
ZTotal = Z x 4 ZTotal = Z Z
+ + 2 +
Z Z Z
+
- - -
(PARALLEL WIRING) (SERIES / PARALLEL WIRING)
+ +
+ +
Z
+ + + + Z Z
ZTotal = Z Z Z Z ZTotal = Z
4 + + + + +
Z Z
- -
Fig. 4: Illustrating various wiring configurations and the formulae to calculate their load.
14
REPLACING AND UPGRADING PA SPEAKERS
Fane offer a wide range of loudspeakers suitable for the vast majority of sound reinforcement
enclosure designs, ideal for upgrades to stock loudspeakers, custom cab designs or
replacements for damaged drivers.
Identifying the correct driver or comparing two loudspeakers can be difficult, often with
manufacturers having different testing methods or figures that only become clear about how
they were achieved when delving deeper into the small print. While power rating is typically the
first parameter to be looked at, there are other parameters that probably bear more important
consideration such as Sensitivity and Impedance. Here are a few simple things to look out for
when choosing a replacement speaker:
• Look for power handling and impedance ratings that match closely to the driver you are
replacing, but beware of the figures.
• For best performance, try and select a driver that displays similar sensitivity (dB), Frequency
Response Range and also check excursion capabilities (Xmax / Xmech / peak-to-peak).
• Check the loudspeaker chassis fixing hole PCD positions and baffle cut-out match that your
enclosure (if you are not willing to cut new holes, that is!)
• Of course there are many more things that can be checked and compared; however, this list
serves as a quick starting point.
http://www.facebook.com/FANEGB http://twitter.com/FANE_INT_LTD