EAU Guidelines on Sexual and Reproductive Health
EAU Guidelines on Sexual and Reproductive Health
Sexual and
Reproductive Health
A. Salonia (Chair), L. Boeri, P. Capogrosso, G. Corona,
M. Dinkelman-Smith, M. Falcone, M. Gül, A. Kadioğlu,
J.I. Martinez-Salamanca, S. Minhas (Vice-chair),
E.C. Serefoğlu, P. Verze
Guidelines Associates: A. Cocci, C. Fuglesang Jensen,
A. Kalkanli, L.A. Morgado, U. Milenkovic, G. Russo
Guidelines Office: E.J. Smith
2. METHODOLOGY 12
2.1 Methods 12
2.2 Review 13
3.MALE HYPOGONADISM 13
3.1 Definition, epidemiology and classification of male hypogonadism 13
3.1.1 Definition 13
3.1.2 Epidemiology 13
3.1.3 Classification 14
3.2 Comorbidities associated with male hypogonadism 16
3.2.1 Obesity 16
3.2.2 Metabolic Syndrome/Type 2 Diabetes 16
3.2.3 Sars-CoV-2 / COVID-19 17
3.3 Late-onset hypogonadism 17
3.3.1 Clinical Diagnosis and Evaluation 17
3.3.2 History taking 17
3.3.3 Physical examination 18
3.3.4 Laboratory Diagnostics 18
3.3.5 Summary of evidence and recommendations for the diagnostic evaluation
and screening of LOH 19
3.4 Treatment of Classical and Late-onset Hypogonadism 22
3.4.1 Indications and contraindications for treatment of hypogonadism 22
3.4.2 Testosterone therapy outcomes 22
3.4.2.1 Sexual dysfunction 22
3.4.2.2 Vitality and physical strength 23
3.4.2.3 Mood and cognition 23
3.4.2.4 Body composition and metabolic profile 23
3.4.2.5 Bone 24
3.4.2.6 Summary of evidence and recommendations for testosterone
therapy outcome 24
3.4.3 Choice of treatment 25
3.4.3.1 Lifestyle factors 25
3.4.3.2 Medical preparations 25
3.4.3.2.1 Oral formulations 25
3.4.3.2.2 Parenteral formulations 25
3.4.3.2.3 Transdermal testosterone preparations 26
3.4.3.2.4 Transmucosal formulations 26
3.4.3.2.5 Subdermal depots 26
3.4.3.2.6 Anti-oestrogens 26
3.4.3.2.7 Gonadotropins 27
3.4.3.3 Summary of evidence and recommendations for choice of treatment
for LOH 28
6.DISORDERS OF EJACULATION 58
6.1 Introduction 58
6.2 Premature ejaculation 58
6.2.1 Epidemiology 58
6.2.2 Pathophysiology and risk factors 58
6.2.3 Impact of PE on quality of life 58
6.2.4 Classification 59
6.2.5 Diagnostic evaluation 59
6.2.5.1 Intravaginal ejaculatory latency time (IELT) 59
6.2.5.2 Premature ejaculation assessment questionnaires 59
6.2.5.3 Physical examination and investigations 60
6.2.5.4 Summary of evidence and recommendations for the diagnostic
evaluation of PE 60
6.2.6 Disease management 60
6.2.6.1 Psychological aspects and intervention 61
6.2.6.1.1 Summary of evidence and recommendations for the
assessment and treatment (psychosexual approach)
of PE 62
6.2.6.2 Pharmacotherapy 62
6.2.6.2.1 Dapoxetine 62
6.2.6.2.2 Off-label use of antidepressants 63
6.2.6.2.3 Topical anaesthetic agents 64
6.2.6.2.3.1 Lidocaine/prilocaine cream 64
6.2.6.2.3.2 Lidocaine/prilocaine spray 64
6.2.6.2.4 Tramadol 64
6.2.6.2.5 Phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors 64
6.2.6.2.6 Other drugs 65
10.
PRIAPISM 105
10.1 Ischaemic (Low-Flow or Veno-Occlusive) Priapism 105
10.1.1 Epidemiology, aetiology, pathophysiology and Diagnosis 105
10.1.1.1 Summary of evidence on the epidemiology, aetiology and
pathophysiology of ischaemic priapism 107
10.1.2 Diagnostic evaluation 107
10.1.2.1 History 107
10.1.2.2 Physical examination 107
10.1.2.3 Laboratory testing 107
10.1.2.4 Penile imaging 108
10.1.2.5 Summary of evidence and recommendations for the diagnosis of
ischaemic priapism 109
10.1.3 Disease management 110
10.1.3.1 Medical Management – first-line treatment 110
10.1.3.1.1 Penile anaesthesia/analgesia 110
10.1.3.1.2 Aspiration ± irrigation with 0.9% w/v saline solution 110
10.1.3.1.3 Aspiration ± irrigation with 0.9% w/v saline solution
in combination with intracavernous injection of
pharmacological agents. 111
11.
MALE INFERTILITY 125
11.1 Definition and classification 125
11.2 Epidemiology/aetiology/pathophysiology/risk factors 125
11.2.1 Introduction 125
11.2.2 Summary of evidence and recommendations on epidemiology and aetiology
of male infertility 126
2. METHODOLOGY
2.1 Methods
For the 2025 Sexual and Reproductive Health Guidelines, new and relevant evidence has been identified,
collated, and appraised through a structured assessment of the literature for Sections 5 Management of Erectile
Dysfunction and 11 Male Infertility. Databases searched included Medline, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Libraries,
covering a time frame between the 1st Jan 2023 and 1st May 2024. A total of 1,499 and 2,788 unique records
were identified, retrieved, and screened for relevance for Sections 5 and 11, respectively. Detailed search
strategies are available online: https://uroweb.org/guidelines/sexual-and-reproductive-health/publications-
appendices.
1. the overall quality of the evidence which exists for the recommendation [1];
2. the magnitude of the effect (individual or combined effects);
3. the certainty of the results (precision, consistency, heterogeneity and other statistical or study
related factors);
4. the balance between desirable and undesirable outcomes;
5. the impact and certainty of patient values and preferences on the intervention.
Strong recommendations typically indicate a high degree of evidence quality and / or a favourable balance
of benefit to harm and patient preference. Weak recommendations typically indicate availability of lower
quality evidence, and/or equivocal balance between benefit and harm, and uncertainty or variability of patient
preference [2].
Additional information can be found online at the EAU website: http://www.uroweb.org/guideline/. A list of
associations endorsing the EAU Guidelines can also be viewed online at this address.
2.2 Review
The EAU Sexual and Reproductive Health Guidelines were peer reviewed prior to publication in 2020. The new
priapism section was reviewed prior to publication in 2021. In 2023 the newly added section on penile size
abnormalities and dysmorphophobia was reviewed prior to publication.
3. MALE HYPOGONADISM
3.1 Definition, epidemiology and classification of male hypogonadism
3.1.1 Definition
Male hypogonadism is a clinical syndrome which comprises of symptoms with or without signs and
biochemical evidence of testosterone deficiency. Hypogonadism is associated with decreased testicular
function and production of androgens and/or impaired sperm production [3]. This may be caused by impaired
testicular function (hypergonadotropic hypogonadism or primary hypogonadism) or as a result of inadequate
stimulation of the testes by the hypothalamic-pituitary axis (hypogonadotropic hypogonadism or secondary
hypogonadism) (Table 3.1) or uncommonly by reduced ability of testosterone to stimulate the androgen
receptor at the cellular level. Hypogonadism can adversely affect multiple organ functions and quality of life
(QoL) [3, 4]. This chapter specifically addresses the management of adult male hypogonadism also called
late onset hypogonadism (LOH). Some insights related to congenital or pre-pubertal hypogonadism are also
provided.
3.1.2 Epidemiology
The prevalence of LOH increases with age, with the major causes being obesity, other co-morbidities (e.g.,
diabetes) and overall poor health [5]. The incidence of hypogonadism has been reported to be between 12.3
and 11.7 cases per 1,000 people per year [6, 7]. Aging accounts for a low percentage of hypogonadism, as there
is only a small gradual decline in testosterone, up to the age of 80 years, in healthy aging men [5]. In men aged
40-79 years, the incidence of symptomatic hypogonadism varies between 2.1 and 5.7% [6, 8, 9].
There is a high prevalence of LOH within specific populations, including patients with obesity, type
2 diabetes (T2DM), metabolic syndrome (MetS), cardiovascular diseases (CVD), chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease (COPD), renal disease and cancer [9]. In particular low testosterone levels are relatively common in men
with T2DM [10, 11] and in those with metabolic derangements.
Klinefelter syndrome, a trisomy associated with a 47,XXY karyotype, is the most prevalent genetic
cause of primary hypogonadism, with a global prevalence of 1/500-1,000 live male births [12-15]. However,
< 50% of individuals with Klinefelter syndrome are diagnosed during their lifetime [16].
The current guidelines maintain a classification of Primary and Secondary Hypogonadism, with special
reference to LOH. The classification, based on the aetiology of hypogonadism, allows clinicians to adequately
select appropriate treatment. In patients with secondary hypogonadism, both fertility and testosterone
normalisation can be theoretically achieved with adequate treatment, whereas in primary hypogonadism only
testosterone therapy can be considered, which eventually impairs fertility due to suppression of the HPT axis
[3, 17] (Table 3.1). It should also be recognised that symptoms and signs of hypogonadism can be similarly
independent of the site of origin of the disease. Conversely, the age of onset of hypogonadism can influence
the clinical phenotype [24]. Accordingly, for early onset, such as that occurring during foetal life, the clinical
phenotype can span from an almost complete female phenotype (e.g., complete androgen insensitivity or
enzymatic defects blocking androgen synthesis) to various defects in virilisation. In the case of a pre- or peri-
pubertal appearance of hypogonadism due to a milder central (isolated hypogonadotropic hypogonadism [IHH])
or a peripheral defect (such as in Klinefelter syndrome), there may be delayed puberty with an overall eunuchoid
phenotype. Finally, when hypogonadism develops after puberty and especially with ageing symptoms can be
mild and often confused the with ageing process [3, 24].
A brief discussion on the physiology of testosterone production can be found in Appendix 1, online supplementary
evidence (https://uroweb.org/guidelines/sexual-and-reproductive-health/publications-appendices).
Several randomised controlled trials (RCTs) have demonstrated that testosterone therapy may improve insulin
resistance and hyperglycaemia and lower total and low-density protein (LDL)-cholesterol [29-34]. Testosterone
therapy in hypogonadal T2DM improved glycaemic control in some RCTs and registry trials; however, there is no
conclusive evidence [30, 35, 36]. A large placebo-controlled RCT, including 1,007 patients with impaired glucose
tolerance or newly diagnosed T2DM and total testosterone < 14 nmol/L showed that testosterone therapy for
two years reduced the proportion of patients with T2DM regardless of a lifestyle programme [34]. Similarly, a
registry study reported that testosterone therapy was associated in time with remission of T2DM [35]. High-
density lipoprotein (HDL)-cholesterol may decrease, remain unchanged or increase with testosterone therapy.
Testosterone therapy in men with MetS and low testosterone has been shown to reduce mortality compared to
untreated men [37, 38], although no conclusive evidence is available.
Erectile dysfunction (ED) is common in men with MetS and T2DM (up to 70% of patients). The causes of ED
are multi-factorial and 30% of men with ED have co-existing testosterone-deficiency/hypogonadism. Some
evidence has suggested that ED is only found in men with T2DM and clearly reduced testosterone levels (< 8
nmol/L or 2.31 ng/mL) [39]. From a pathophysiological perspective, it has been reported that this is because
ED is predominantly caused by vascular and neuropathic disease, and therefore not likely in men who do not
have established vascular disease. Therefore, men presenting with ED should be screened for MetS. Likewise,
patients with ED and diabetes may be offered testosterone measurement.
Placebo-controlled RCTs of testosterone therapy in T2DM have demonstrated improved sexual desire and
satisfaction, but not erectile function [30, 39]. Similar results were derived from a meta-analysis of published
trials [40]. Accordingly, a large two-year RCT of testosterone undecanoate vs. placebo showed that testosterone
therapy significantly improved sexual function and ED in men with impaired glucose tolerance or newly
diagnosed T2DM low testosterone (< 14 nmol/L) [34].
Table 3.3: Main factors associated with an increase or reduction of SHBG circulating levels
3.3.5 Summary of evidence and recommendations for the diagnostic evaluation and screening of LOH
Summary of evidence LE
Sexual symptoms are the most specific symptoms associated with LOH. 1a
Diagnosis of LOH should be based on specific signs and symptoms of androgen deficiency, together 1a
with consistently low serum testosterone levels.
Total testosterone 12 nmol/L (3.5 ng/mL) represents a reliable threshold to diagnose LOH. 1a
Functional hypogonadism is a consequence of comorbidity/concomitant drugs, which can impair 4
testosterone production in adulthood. The diagnosis of functional hypogonadism is a diagnosis of
exclusion, after ruling out organic causes of hypogonadism.
Calculated free testosterone of < 220 pmol/L has been suggested as a possible cut-off to diagnose 3
LOH.
Self-reported questionnaires and structural interviews have been developed for screening of 2a
hypogonadism, but their specificity remains poor.
Check for drugs and substances that can interfere with T producon/acon
Check for concomitant metabolic diseases: obesity/metabolic syndrome/diabetes
Check for potenal testosterone therapy contraindicaons
TT > 12 nM/
TT < 12 nM TT > 12 nM
reduced cFT
hypogonadism hypogonadism
hypogonadism
possible unlikely
possible
TT < 12 nM
Repeat TT
(reduced cFT)
measurements
and LH reduced/
along with LH
inappropriate
PRL +/-SHBG cFT
normal
TT < 12 nM
Secondary
(reduced cFT)
hypogonadism
and LH elevated
Gonadotropin
Rule out testosterone therapy possible contraindicaons therapy
TT = total testosterone; cFT = calculated free testosterone; PRL = prolactin; SHBG = sex hormone-binding globulin;
LH = luteinising hormone; MRI = Magnetic resonance imaging.
Absolute contraindications are untreated breast and prostate cancer (PCa). Similarly conditions such
as cardiovascular events as well as uncontrolled or poorly controlled congestive heart failure should be
considered when prescribing testosterone therapy [78]. Conversely, severe lower urinary tract symptoms
(LUTS) [International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS) score > 19] represent a relative contraindication, as
there is insufficient data on the long-term effects of testosterone therapy in these patients [66]. A positive
family history for venous thromboembolism requires further analysis to exclude a condition of undiagnosed
thrombophilia-hypofibrinolysis [79]. These patients need to be carefully counselled prior to testosterone
therapy initiation. A haematocrit (HCT) > 54% should require testosterone therapy withdrawal, reduction in
dose, change of formulation and venesection depending on the clinical situation to avoid any potential cardio-
vascular complications. Lower baseline HTC (48-50%) should be carefully evaluated before testosterone therapy
initiation, to avoid pathological increases during treatment, especially in high-risk men such as those with COPD
or Obstructive Sleep Apnoea Syndrome (OSAS), likewise in natives living at high altitudes, since they may suffer
from secondary excessive erythrocytosis [80]. Accordingly, the Framingham Heart Study showed that HCT > 48%
represented a condition associated with increased risk of coronary artery disease (CAD) and mortality and was
associated with cardiovascular disorders [81]. Testosterone therapy suppresses gonadotropin and endogenous
testosterone secretion as well as spermatogenesis [82]; therefore, testosterone therapy is contraindicated in
individuals who desire fertility [83]. Secondary hypogonadism is characterised by low or inappropriately normal
gonadotropin levels; therefore, the rationale is to substitute the gonadotropin deficiency with simultaneously
FSH and LH analogues, if fertility is desired [84].
The Sexual Function Trial of the Testosterone Trials (TTrials) (one of the largest placebo-controlled trials on
testosterone therapy) documented consistent improvements in 10 of 12 measures of sexual activities in older
(≥ 65 years) hypogonadal men, particularly in frequency of intercourse, masturbation and nocturnal erections
(as measured by PDQ-Q4) [95]. The magnitude in improvement was shown to be proportional to the increase in
serum total testosterone, fT and E2 levels, it was not possible to demonstrate a threshold level [96]. A study of
220 men with MetS with or without T2DM also found that sexual function improved in men who reported sexual
problems with improvement in IIEF scores, with specific increases in libido and sexual satisfaction [30].
3.4.2.5 Bone
Evidence suggests that bone mineralisation requires circulating sex steroids within the normal range [111].
The possible association between mild hypogonadism and osteopenia/osteoporosis is weak, whereas severe
hypogonadism (total testosterone < 3.5 nM) is frequently associated with bone loss and osteoporosis,
independent of patient age [111]. Three independent meta-analyses showed a positive effect of testosterone
therapy on bone mineral density (BMD), with the highest effect at the lumber level [112-114]. Interestingly,
this latter meta-analysis has provided novel evidence that the role of testosterone on BMD was even higher
in patients with diabetes [114], who are themselves at a higher risk of hypogonadism and bone fracture [40,
115, 116]. Similarly, data derived from TTrials and the T4DM studies confirmed that testosterone therapy
increased BMD in hypogonadal ageing men [95, 117]. A subgroup analysis of the TRAVERSE study showed
that the fracture incidence was numerically higher amongst men in the testosterone therapy group vs. placebo;
however, it should be noted that this was not the primary outcome of the study [118]. Furthermore, when the
most clinically important fractures, such as bone and hip fractures, were considered no difference between
testosterone therapy and placebo was observed. Available data are insufficient to determine the effect of
testosterone therapy alone on the risk of fractures [111]. The use of testosterone therapy as an adjunct to anti-
resorptive treatment in hypogonadal patients at high risk of fractures has not been established. Therefore, anti-
resorptive therapy must be the first-choice treatment in hypogonadal men at high risk for bone fractures. The
combination of anti-resorptive treatment and testosterone therapy should be offered only in conjunction with
hypogonadism-related symptoms.
Summary of evidence LE
Testosterone therapy can improve:
• Milder forms of ED and libido in hypogonadal men. 1a
• Other sexual symptoms, including intercourse frequency, orgasm and overall satisfaction. 1b
• Body composition and insulin resistance. 1a
• Weight, waist circumference and lipid profile, but the evidence is conflicting. 3
• Mild depressive symptoms in hypogonadal men. 1a
• Bone mineral density, but information related to fracture risk is lacking. 1a
3.4.3.2.6 Anti-oestrogens
Anti-oestrogens, including selective oestrogen receptor (ER) modulators (SERMs) and aromatase inhibitors (AI)
have been suggested as off-label treatments to restore testosterone levels and fertility in men with functional
secondary hypogonadism or idiopathic infertility. They work by preventing down-regulation of the HPG axis by
oestrogens and for this reason are particularly useful in men with obesity and metabolic disorders [121, 128].
In the latter case, the hypothesis is that the excess of adipose tissue leads to increased aromatase activity
and oestrogens levels resulting in impairment of the HPG [119]. Due to their putative mechanism of action,
they require an intact HPG axis and cannot work in primary hypogonadism or secondary hypogonadism due
to organic damage of the HPG axis. Both types of SERMs, which bind ERs with an agonist or antagonist effect
depending upon the target tissue, and AIs, which prevent androgens from being converted into oestrogens
by aromatase, have been used in clinical practice [22, 123]. The evidence published so far is poor; all these
products are off-label treatments and SERMs, due to their agonistic effect on venous vessels, could predispose
men to the development of venous thromboembolism [22, 123]. In this context patients should be warned of the
potential increased risk of venous thromboembolism, although data are lacking. Long-term use of these agents
can lead to reduced bone density and development of osteoporosis, potentially increasing fracture risk.
3.4.3.3 Summary of evidence and recommendations for choice of treatment for LOH
Summary of evidence LE
Weight loss obtained through a low-calorie diet and regular physical activity results in a small 1a
improvement in testosterone levels.
Testosterone gels and long-acting injectable TU represent testosterone preparations with the optimal 1a
safety profiles.
Gonadotropins treatment can be used to restore fertility in men with secondary hypogonadism. 1a
With regards to PCa survivors, safety in terms of the risk of recurrence and progression has not yet been
established. Limited data are available in the literature, with most case series not providing sufficient data to
draw definitive conclusions (e.g., insufficient follow-up, small samples, lack of control arms, heterogeneity in
study population and treatment regimen, etc.) [147]. A meta-analysis derived from thirteen studies including
608 patients, of whom 109 had a history of high-risk PCa, with follow-up of 1-189.3 months [148], suggested
that testosterone therapy did not increase the risk of biochemical recurrence, but the available evidence is poor,
limiting data interpretation [148]. Similar considerations can be derived from another, larger meta-analysis of
21 studies [149]. However, it is important to recognise both meta-analyses showed high heterogeneity among
the different studies and included a limited number of subjects. An RCT assessing the safety/benefit ratio of
testosterone therapy in hypogonadal men successfully treated with prostatectomy for non-aggressive PCa is
currently ongoing [150].
In conclusion, recent literature does not support an increased risk of PCa in hypogonadal men undergoing
testosterone therapy. Although it is mandatory to avoid testosterone administration in men with advanced
PCa, insufficient long-term prospective data on the safety of testosterone therapy in PCa survivors [149],
should prompt caution in choosing to treat symptomatic hypogonadal men in this setting. Specifically, patients
should be fully counselled that the long-term effects of testosterone therapy in this setting are still unknown
and requires further investigation. Due to the lack of strong evidence-based data on safety, the possible use of
testosterone therapy in symptomatic hypogonadal men previously treated for PCa should be fully discussed
with patients and limited to low-risk individuals.
Published data show that LOH is associated with an increase in all-cause and CVD-related mortality [7, 154-
157]. These studies are supported by a meta-analysis that concluded that hypogonadism is a risk factor for
cardiovascular morbidity [141] and mortality [158]. Importantly, men with low testosterone when compared
to eugonadal men with angiographically proven coronary disease have twice the risk of earlier death [152].
Longitudinal population studies have reported that men with testosterone in the upper quartile of the normal
range have a reduced number of CV events compared to men with testosterone in the lower three quartiles
[154]. Androgen deprivation therapy for PCa is linked to an increased risk of CVD and sudden death [159].
Conversely, two long-term epidemiological studies have reported reduced CV events in men with high normal
serum testosterone levels [160, 161]. Erectile dysfunction is independently associated with CVD and may be the
first clinical presentation in men with atherosclerosis.
The knowledge that men with hypogonadism and/or ED may have underlying CVD should prompt individual
assessment of their CV risk profile. Individual risk factors (e.g., lifestyle, diet, exercise, smoking, hypertension,
diabetes and dyslipidaemia) should be assessed and treated in men with pre-existing CVD and in patients
receiving androgen deprivation therapy. Cardiovascular risk reduction can be managed by primary care
clinicians, but patients should be appropriately counselled by clinicians active in prescribing testosterone
therapy [85]. If appropriate, patients should be referred to cardiologists for risk stratification and treatment of
comorbidity.
No RCTs have provided a clear answer on whether testosterone therapy affects CV outcomes. The TTrial (n=790)
in older men [162], the TIMES2 (n=220) [30] and, the BLAST studies in men with MetS and T2DM and the pre-frail
and frail study in elderly men - all of one year duration and the T4DM 2-year study - did not reveal any increase
Data recently released from the TRAVERSE study confirm findings of the EMA [78]. The latter is the first double-
blind, placebo-controlled, noninferiority RCT with primary CV safety as an end point. The results showed that
testosterone therapy was noninferior to placebo with respect to the incidence of MACE. However, a mild higher
incidence of atrial fibrillation, of acute kidney injury, and pulmonary embolism was observed in the testosterone
group [78]. The latter observations, however, need to be confirmed since previous available data do not support
an increased risk of venous thromboembolism [79, 169] or major arrhythmias [170] after testosterone therapy.
Similarly, the long-term follow-up (median of 5.1 years since last injection) of the T4DM study showed no
differences in self-reported rates of new diagnosis of CVD [171].
In conclusion, current available data from interventional studies suggest that there is no increased risk up to
three years of testosterone therapy [172-176]. The currently published evidence has reported that testosterone
therapy in men with diagnosed hypogonadism has neutral or beneficial actions on MACE in patients with
normalised testosterone levels. The findings could be considered sufficiently reliable for at least a three-year
course of testosterone therapy, after which no available study can exclude further or long-term CV events [177,
178].
3.5.6 Erythrocytosis
An elevated haematocrit is the most common adverse effect of testosterone therapy. Stimulation
of erythropoiesis is a normal biological action that enhances delivery of oxygen to testosterone-sensitive
tissues (e.g., striated, smooth and cardiac muscle). Any elevation above the normal range for haematocrit
usually becomes evident between three and twelve months after testosterone therapy initiation. However,
polycythaemia can also occur after any subsequent increase in testosterone dose, switching from topical to
parenteral administration and, development of co-morbidity, which can be linked to an increase in haematocrit
(e.g., respiratory or haematological diseases).
There is no evidence that an increase of haematocrit up to and including 54% causes any adverse
effects. If the haematocrit exceeds 54% there is a testosterone independent but weak associated rise in CV
events and mortality [81, 182-184]. Any relationship is complex as these studies were based on patients with
any cause of secondary polycythaemia, which included smoking and respiratory diseases. There have been no
specific studies in men with only testosterone-induced erythrocytosis.
As detailed, the TRAVERSE study, which had included symptomatic hypogonadal men aged 45-80 years who
had pre-existing or a high risk of CVD, showed a mild higher incidence of pulmonary embolism, a component
of the adjudicated tertiary end point of venous thromboembolic events, in the testosterone therapy than in the
placebo group (0.9% vs. 0.5%) [78]. However, three previous large studies have not shown any evidence that
testosterone therapy is associated with an increased risk of venous thromboembolism [185, 186]. Of those,
one study showed that an increased risk peaked at six months after initiation of testosterone therapy, then
declined over the subsequent period [187]. In one study venous thromboembolism was reported in 42 cases
and 40 of these had diagnosis of an underlying thrombophilia (including factor V Leiden deficiency, prothrombin
mutations and homocysteinuria) [188]. A meta-analysis of RCTs of testosterone therapy reported that venous
Elevated haematocrit in the absence of comorbidity or acute CV or venous thromboembolism can be managed
by a reduction in testosterone dose, change in formulation or if the elevated haematocrit is very high by
venesection (500 mL), even repeated if necessary, with usually no need to stop the testosterone therapy.
3.5.8 Follow-up
Testosterone therapy alleviates symptoms and signs of hypogonadism in men in a specific time-dependent
manner. The TTrials clearly showed that testosterone therapy improved sexual symptoms as early as three
months after initiation [95]. Similar results have been derived from meta-analyses [79, 87]. Hence, the first
evaluation should be planned after three months of treatment. Further evaluation may be scheduled at six
months or twelve months, according to patient characteristics, as well as results of biochemical testing (see
below). Patients at high risk of developing elevated haematocrit should be evaluated every three months during
the first year of testosterone therapy and at least every six months thereafter. Accordingly, current guidelines
suggest that haematocrit should be maintained below 45% in patients with polycythaemia vera to avoid
thromboembolism risk [193]. Similarly, data derived using a multi-institutional database including a large cohort
of hypogonadal (total testosterone < 12 nmol/L) men who received testosterone therapy and subsequently
did (n=5,887) or did not (n=4,2784) develop polycythaemia (haematocrit > 52%) showed that men who had an
increased haematocrit had a higher risk of MACE or venous thromboembolism mostly during the first year of
therapy [194]. The risk was even higher when a haematocrit threshold of 54% was considered whilst no risk
was observed when a 50% threshold was applied [194]. Table 3.6 summarises the clinical and biochemical
parameters that should be monitored during testosterone therapy.
TTrials were designed to maintain the serum testosterone concentration within the normal range for young men
(280–873 ng/dL or 9.6-30 nmol/L) [95]. This approach resulted in a good benefit/risk ratio. A similar approach
could be considered during follow-up. The correct timing for evaluation of testosterone levels varies according
to the type of preparation used (Table 3.5). Testosterone is involved in the regulation of erythropoiesis [125]
and prostate growth [62], hence evaluation of PSA and haematocrit should be mandatory before and during
testosterone therapy. However, it is important to recognise that the risk of PCa in men aged < 40 years is low.
Similarly, the mortality risk for PCa in men aged > 70 years has not been considered high enough to warrant
monitoring in the general population [195]. Therefore, any screening for PCa through determination of PSA and
DRE in men aged < 40 or > 70 years during testosterone therapy should be discussed with the patients.
Baseline and, at least, annually glyco-metabolic profile evaluation may be a reasonable consideration,
particularly in the management of functional hypogonadism. Testosterone therapy may be beneficial for
hypogonadal men with low or moderate fracture risk [111]; therefore, dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA)
bone scan may also be considered at baseline and 18-24 months following testosterone therapy, particularly in
patients with more severe hypogonadism [111].
The decision to stop testosterone therapy or to perform prostate biopsy due to PSA increase or prostate
abnormalities should be based on local PCa guidelines. There is a large consensus that any increase of
haematocrit > 54% during testosterone therapy requires therapy withdrawal and phlebotomy to avoid potential
adverse effects including venous-thromboembolism and CVD, especially in high-risk individuals. In patients
with lower risk of relevant clinical sequelae, the situation can be alternatively managed by reducing testosterone
dose and switching formulation along with venesection. A positive family history of venous-thromboembolism
should be carefully investigated and the patient counselled with regard to testosterone therapy to avoid/prevent
thrombophilia-hypofibrinolysis [79]. Finally, caution should be exercised in men with pre-existing CVD or at
higher risk of CVD [78].
Table 3.6: Clinical and biochemical parameters to be checked during testosterone therapy
3.5.9 Summary of evidence and recommendations on safety and monitoring in testosterone treatment
Summary of evidence LE
Testosterone therapy is contraindicated in men with secondary hypogonadism who desire fertility. 1a
Testosterone therapy is contraindicated in men with active prostate cancer or breast cancer, as these 1a
patients are usually excluded from RCTs.
Testosterone therapy does not increase the risk of prostate cancer, but long-term prospective follow-up 1a
data are required to validate this statement.
The effect of testosterone therapy in men with severe lower-urinary tract symptoms is limited, as these 1a
patients are usually excluded from RCTs.
There is no substantive evidence that testosterone therapy, when replaced to normal levels, results in 1a
the development of major adverse cardiovascular events.
There is no evidence of a relationship between testosterone therapy and mild, moderate or CPAP- 1b
treated severe sleep apnoea.
Erectile dysfunction is also frequently associated with other urological conditions and procedures including
LUTS/BPH and surgery for LUTS/BPH [282-284], chronic pelvic pain syndrome (CPPS) and chronic prostatitis
[285], bladder pain syndrome/interstitial cystitis [286], premature ejaculation [287] and urethroplasty surgery for
posterior urethral strictures [288].
5.3 Pathophysiology
The pathophysiology of ED may be vasculogenic, neurogenic, anatomical, hormonal, drug-induced and/or
psychogenic (Table 5.1) [289]. In most cases, numerous pathophysiological pathways can co-exist and may all
negatively impact EF.
Vasculogenic
Recreational habits (i.e., cigarette smoking)
Lack of regular physical exercise
Obesity
Cardiovascular diseases (e.g., hypertension, coronary artery disease, peripheral vasculopathy)
Type 1 and 2 diabetes mellitus; hyperlipidaemia; metabolic syndrome; hyperhomocysteinemia
Major pelvic surgery (e.g., radical prostatectomy) or radiotherapy (pelvis or retroperitoneum)
The ProtecT trial randomised 1,643 patients to active treatment (RP or RT) or active monitoring for localised
PCa and assessed sexual function, including EF, using the EPIC-26 instrument [278]. At baseline, 67% of men
reported erections firm enough for sexual intercourse. At six-year follow-up assessment this fell to 30% in the
active monitoring group, 27%% in the RT group and 17% in the RP group, respectively. In a RCT comparing low-
to intermediate-risk PCa patients treated with either surgery or RT (without ADT), the sexual function scores of
EPIC-26 were significantly higher for men receiving RT at two years post-treatment [299].
Radical prostatectomy for the treatment of clinically localised intermediate- or high-risk PCa is a widely
performed procedure. Research has shown that 25-75% of men experience post-RP ED [279, 280, 295].
Conversely, the rate of unassisted post-operative EF recovery ranges between 20 and 25% in most studies.
These rates have not substantially improved or changed over the past two decades, despite growing attention
to post-surgical rehabilitation protocols and refinement of surgical techniques [280, 281, 300]. Overall, patient
age, baseline EF and surgical volume, with the subsequent ability to preserve the neurovascular bundles, are the
main factors in promoting the highest rates of post-operative EF [279, 296, 301, 302]. Regardless of the surgical
technique, surgeons’ experience clearly impacts on post-operative EF outcome [303]. Surgical approach may
also affect post-RP EF, but the current evidence is conflicting with one systematic review reporting a significant
advantage in favour of RARP compared to open retropubic RP for twelve-month potency rates [304] and two
RCTs reporting only a small improvement in EF for RARP or no different in EF between techniques [305, 306].
Erectile dysfunction is also a common problem after both external beam radiation therapy (EBRT) and
brachytherapy for PCa. A systematic review and meta-analysis including men treated with EBRT (65%),
brachytherapy (31%) or both (4%) showed that the post-treatment prevalence of ED was 34% at one year and
57% at 5.5 years, respectively [307, 308]. Similar findings have been reported for stereotactic radiotherapy with
26-55% of previously sexually functioning patients reporting ED at five years [309].
Recently other modalities have emerged as potential therapeutic options in patients with clinically-localised
PCa, including high-intensity focused US (HIFU), cryo-therapeutic ablation of the prostate (cryotherapy), focal
padeliporfin-based vascular-targeted photodynamic therapy and focal RT by brachytherapy or CyberKnife®.
All these approaches have been reported to have a less-negative impact on EF with many studies reporting a
complete recovery at one-year follow-up [310].
Summary of evidence LE
Erectile dysfunction is common worldwide. 2b
Erectile dysfunction shares common risk factors with cardiovascular disease. 2b
Lifestyle modification (regular exercise and decrease in BMI) can improve erectile function. 1b
Erectile dysfunction is a symptom, not a disease. Some patients may not be properly evaluated or 4
receive treatment for an underlying disease or condition that may be causing ED.
Erectile dysfunction is common after RP, irrespective of the surgical technique used. 2b
Erectile dysfunction is common after external radiotherapy and brachytherapy. 2b
Erectile dysfunction is less common after cryotherapy and high-intensity focused US. 2b
A detailed description should be made of the rigidity and duration of both sexually stimulated and morning
erections and of problems with sexual desire, arousal, ejaculation, and orgasm [312-314]. Validated
questionnaires, such as the IIEF [315] or its short version (i.e., Sexual Health Inventory for Men; SHIM) [316],
help to assess the different sexual function domains (i.e., sexual desire, EF, orgasmic function, intercourse
satisfaction, and overall satisfaction), as well as the potential impact of a specific treatment modality. Similarly,
structured interviews allow the identification and quantification of the different underlying factors affecting EF
[317].
Psychometric analyses also support the use of the Erectile Hardness Score (EHS) for the
assessment of penile rigidity in practice and in clinical trials research [318]. Patients should always be screened
for symptoms of possible hypogonadism, including decreased libido and energy, and fatigue (see Table 3.3:
Specific symptoms associated with LOH).
Laboratory tests
Over time, the Princeton Consensus (Expert Panel) Conferences were dedicated to optimising sexual function
and preserving cardiovascular health [329-333]. The current EAU Guidelines on the diagnosis and treatment of
men with ED have been adapted from the recommendations from the Princeton Consensus conferences on
sexual dysfunction and cardiac risk published in 2024 [334].
The Princeton Consensus Conference IV aimed to critically evaluate the current evidence for the relationship
between ED and CV health, to update the CV work-up in the ED patient, to reassess when and how to treat ED
patients with known CVD, and to reassess the accuracy and relevance of previous Princeton management
algorithms [334, 335]. Accordingly, the Princeton Consensus Conference IV recommended the use of the 2019
American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association atherosclerotic CVD (ASCVD) risk score for all
men undergoing evaluation for predominantly vasculogenic ED [336]. As a whole, the ASCVD risk assessment
Standard CVD
YES NO
risk assessment
Calculate 10-year ASCVD risk, assess risk enhancing factors, patient-clinician risk discussion
es in terms of:
eatment invasiveness LI-SWT
mprovement of erecle (with/without
Low risk PDE5Is) Borderline to intermediate risk High risk
effects
asfacon
(<5%) (5-20%) (>20%)
Re-evaluate ED
CAC testing
pathophysiology:
Definitive
vasculogenic YES CAC = O CAC 1 to 100 CAC > 100
reatment opons mechanism?
and counselling
sfacon NO
nave or combined
Lifestyle modification
High intensity statin,
+ moderate to high
Emphasise LDL goal < 70 mg/dL,
ment outcome Standard ED intensity statin to
lifestyle consider aspirin, refer
management bring LDL < 70 mg/dL
interventions to preventive
+ consider preventive
cardiology
ses implant cardiology
Intermediate or
Low risk indeterminable High risk
apeuc outcomes in terms of: risk
self-perceived treatment invasiveness LI-SWT
ent-associated improvement of erecle (with/without
Elective risk
n PDE5Is)
assessment
ent-related side effects Stress test
ent-associated sasfacon
PASS FAIL
Advise, treat ED Cardiologist referral
(Low risk) (High risk)
Table 5.2: Indications for specific diagnostic tests for ED and the specific diagnostic tests
Summary of evidence LE
Medical and sexual history, physical examination and laboratory testing including metabolic and 3
hormonal profile may identify risk factors for ED and may help in defining the ED aetiology.
Validated psychometric questionnaires (e.g. IIEF; EHS) are reliable tools to assess ED severity. 3
Specific diagnostic tests could be of help in discerning between vasculogenic, hormonal or 3
psychogenic causes of ED.
The majority of men with ED are not treated with cause-specific therapeutic options. This results in a tailored
treatment strategy that depends on invasiveness, efficacy, safety and costs, as well as patient preference
[362]; therefore, physician-patient dialogue is essential throughout the management of ED. A systematic
review has shown a consistent discontinuation rate for all available ED treatment options [363]. This highlights
the importance of clinicians understanding patient’s beliefs about ED treatment, therapeutic ineffectiveness,
adverse effects, quality of intimate relationships and treatment costs all of which were shown to be the most
prevalent barriers to treatment use [363].
Inadequate treatment
outcome
5.6.3.1 Sildenafil
Sildenafil is administered in doses of 25, 50 and 100 mg. The recommended starting dose is 50 mg and should
be adapted according to the patient’s response and adverse effects [385]. The window of effectiveness ranges
from 30-60 minutes after administration [385] up to 12 hours [386]. In a 24-week dose-response study, improved
erections were reported by 56%, 77% and 84% of general ED patients taking 25, 50 and 100 mg sildenafil,
respectively, compared to 25% of men taking placebo [387]. Sildenafil also significantly improved patient scores
for IIEF, sexual encounter profile question 2 (SEP2), SEP question 3 (SEP3), General Assessment Questionnaire
(GAQ) and treatment satisfaction [387]. Furthermore, an orally disintegrating tablet (ODT) of sildenafil citrate at
doses of 25, 50, 75 and 100 mg has been developed, mainly for patients who have difficulty swallowing solid
dosage forms [388]. Likewise, a sildenafil oral suspension treatment has been developed, with clinically relevant
results [2000, 2001].
5.6.3.2 Tadalafil
Tadalafil is administered in on-demand doses of 10 and 20 mg or a daily dose of 5 mg. The recommended
on-demand starting dose is 10 mg and should be adapted according to the patient’s response and adverse
effects [389, 390]. The window of effectiveness ranges from 30 minutes after administration (peak efficacy
after approximately 2 hours) up to 36 hours [389]. In a 12-week dose-response study improved erections were
reported by 67% and 81% of men with ED taking 10 and 20 mg tadalafil, respectively, compared to 35% of men
taking placebo [389]. Tadalafil has also been shown to have a net clinical benefit in the short-term on ejaculatory
and orgasmic functions in ED patients [391].
Data have also shown that 40% of men aged > 45 years were combined responders for ED and LUTS/
BPH when treated with tadalafil 5 mg once daily, with symptom improvement after 12 weeks [392]. Therefore, its
use may be considered in both patients with ED only and in patients also complaining of concomitant LUTS, and
wishing to benefit from a single therapy [393].
5.6.3.4 Avanafil
Avanafil is administered in on-demand doses of 50, 100 and 200 mg [381]. The recommended starting dose
is 100 mg taken as needed 15-30 minutes before sexual activity and the dose may be adapted according to
efficacy and tolerability [381, 382, 400]. In a general ED population the mean percentage of successful sexual
attempts resulting in intercourse were 47%, 58% and 59% for the 50, 100 and 200 mg groups, respectively, as
compared with 28% for the placebo group [381, 382]. A meta-analysis confirmed that avanafil had comparable
efficacy with sildenafil, vardenafil and tadalafil [401].
Table 5.3: Pharmacokinetics data for PDE5Is EMA approved for the treatment of ED*
Table 5.4: Common adverse events of the four PDE5Is currently EMA-approved to treat ED*
5.6.3.6.2 Contraindications for the concomitant use of organic nitrates and nicorandil
An absolute contraindication to PDE5Is is the concomitant use of any form of organic nitrate or NO donors
including recreational use of amyl nitrite or nitrate (poppers). Concomitant use results in cGMP accumulation
and unpredictable falls in blood pressure and symptoms of hypotension [408-411]. Concurrent use of nicorandil
and PDE5Is is contraindicated due to the potential of the nitric oxide donating properties of nicorandil to
increase cGMP levels [412].
Studies have demonstrated that hypogonadal patients not responding to PDE5Is may improve their response
to PDE5Is after initiating testosterone therapy [87, 366, 425]. Therefore, if diagnostic criteria suggestive for
testosterone deficiency are present, testosterone therapy may be more appropriate even in ED patients [3, 87].
Limited data suggest that some patients might respond better to one PDE5I than to another [426], raising the
possibility that, despite an identical mode of action, switching to a different PDE5I may be beneficial. However,
no evidence for this has been reported in the available RCTs [427, 428].
5.6.7.1 Alprostadil
Alprostadil (CaverjectTM, Edex/ViridalTM) was the first and only drug approved for intracavernous treatment
of ED [424, 453]. Intracavernous alprostadil is most efficacious as a monotherapy at a dose of 5-40 μg (40
μg may be offered off label in some European countries). The erection appears after 5-15 minutes and lasts
according to the dose injected, but with significant heterogeneity among patients. An office-training programme
is required for patients to learn the injection technique. Efficacy rates for intracavernous alprostadil of > 70%
have been found in the general ED population, as well as in patient subgroups (e.g., men with diabetes or CVD),
with reported satisfaction rates of 87-93.5% in patients and 86-90.3% in partners after the injections [424, 452].
Complications of intracavernous alprostadil include penile pain (50% of patients reported pain only after 11%
of total injections), excessively prolonged and undesired erections (5%), priapism (1%), and fibrosis (2%) [424,
Overall, despite high efficacy rates, 5-10% of patients do not respond to combination intracavernous injections.
As a whole, despite a number of promising results that have been obtained for the treatment of primary
organic ED in terms of both efficacy and safety of PRP, the available evidence is still insufficient to provide a
recommendation regarding the use of PRP for ED treatment in clinical practice [505]. In this context, there is
heterogeneity among studies in terms of timing and dosing regimens, with no consensus regarding the optimal
activation method and platelet concentration for each PRP injection, and the need to measure qualitative and
quantitative composition of growth factors and cytokines [505, 506]. Therefore, intracavernous injection of PRP
should be used only in a clinical trial setting, as larger trials are needed to confirm original findings and define
the efficacy and safety of PRP for ED.
5.6.8.1.3 Stem-cells
The use of stem cells as a regenerative treatment for ED is currently under investigation. A systematic review
summarising the results of 18 phase I and II clinical trials reported a large heterogeneity in terms of the type of
stem cells used, treatment protocols and patients’ characteristics [507]. The overall number of included patients
was 373 and the results confirmed the safety of intracavernous injection of stem cells. No definitive conclusions
can be drawn in terms of efficacy given that only four small trials were placebo-controlled and their findings
were conflicting. To date, data are still insufficient for providing a clinical recommendation.
In this context, PDE5Is have been considered as the first-line therapy in patients who have undergone NS
surgery, regardless of the surgical technique used [296, 301]. Several clinical parameters have been identified as
potential predictors of PDE5Is outcomes in men undergoing RP, i.e., patient age, baseline EF, and quality of NS
technique are key factors in preserving post-RP EF [301, 304, 520].
A Cochrane review analysing data from eight RCTs showed that scheduled PDE5Is may have little or no effect
on short-term (up to 12 months) self-reported potency when compared to placebo or no treatment [521]. In this
study, a daily PDE5I made little to no difference in short- and long-term EF. The authors conclude that penile
rehabilitation strategies using PDE5I following RP do not increase self-reported EF compared to on-demand use.
Conversely, an updated meta-analysis including 22 trials comparing 16 different rehabilitation protocols, showed
that daily administration of sildenafil 100 mg was the most effective strategy to recover EF after RP [522].
Intracavernous injections and penile implants had been suggested as second- and third-line treatments,
respectively, when oral PDE5Is are not adequately effective or not suitable for post-operative patients [296, 523].
A meta-analysis showed that the early use of VED has an excellent therapeutic effect on post-RP patients and
no serious adverse effects, therefore it should be considered as a therapeutic alternative [524]. Findings from
two network meta-analyses showed that combination therapy with VED and PDE5is offers clear advantages
over monotherapy, even in post-RP patients; therefore, this combined approach should be considered in the
clinical management of ED after RP [525]. A novel penile traction device yielded positive results compared to no
treatment in preserving penile length after RP [526].
Findings from a systematic review had suggested that pelvic floor muscle training (PFMT) combined with
bio-feedback is a promising alternative to pharmacological treatments, although there is a need for future well-
powered, rigorously designed RCTs to draw strong conclusions [527].
The two currently available classes of penile implants include inflatable (two- and three-piece) and semi-rigid
devices (malleable, mechanical and soft flexible) [301, 530-533]. There are currently no head-to-head studies
comparing the different manufacturers’ implants, demonstrating superiority of one implant type over another
[534]. Patients may prefer the three-piece inflatable devices due to the more “natural” erections obtained,
although no prospective RCTs have compared satisfaction rates with both types of implants. The two-piece
inflatable prosthesis can be a viable option among patients who are deemed at high-risk of complications with
There are two main surgical approaches for penile prosthesis implantation: peno-scrotal and infrapubic [531,
532, 535, 536]. A systematic review comparing the satisfaction and complication rates of the different surgical
approaches has shown that there is no specific advantage between the two, but rather it is recommended that
surgeons have knowledge of both techniques and are capable of tailoring the incision strategy for complex
cases [537]. Regardless of the indication, prosthesis implantation has one of the highest satisfaction rates
(92-100% in patients and 91-95% in partners) among the treatment options for ED with appropriate counselling
[301, 530, 531, 538-546]. Focused psychosexual counselling may improve sexuality and sexual well-being in
both patients and their partners after penile implant surgery [547]. There is sufficient evidence to recommend
this approach in patients who do not respond to less-invasive treatments due to its high efficacy, safety and
satisfaction rate [548].
The two main complications of penile prosthesis implantation are mechanical failure and infection. Several
technical modifications of the most commonly used three-piece prostheses (e.g., AMS 700CX/CXR™ and
Titan Zero degree™) resulted in mechanical failure rates of < 5% after 5 years of follow-up [530, 549, 550]. A
meta-analysis showed implant durability or survival rates of 93.3% at 1 year, 91.0% at 3 years, 87.2% at 5 years,
76.8% at 10 years, 63.7% at 15 years, and 52.9% at 20 years [551]. Careful surgical techniques with appropriate
antibiotic prophylaxis against Gram-positive and negative bacteria reduced infection rates to 2-3% with primary
implantation in low-risk patients and in high-volume centres [552-555]. The infection rate may be further reduced
to 1-2% by implanting an antibiotic-impregnated prosthesis (AMS Inhibizone™) or hydrophilic-coated prosthesis
(Coloplast Titan™) [530, 552, 556-559]. Methods that appear to decrease infection rates include using coated
prostheses and strictly adhering to surgical techniques and protocols that avoid prolonged wound exposure
and minimise skin contact (i.e., no-touch technique). Techniques that might prevent penile prostheses infection
but lack definitive evidence include the use of prolonged post-operative antibiotics (> 24 hours), shaving with
clippers, and preparation with chlorhexidine-alcohol [560, 561]. Identification and pre-treatment of patients who
are colonised with nasal Staphylococcus aureus with mupirocin and chlorhexidine prior to surgery has been
shown to reduce the incidence of post-operative surgical site infection from 4.4% to 0.9% RCT [562].
A large database-study has shown that diabetes mellitus is a risk factor for penile prostheses infection,
highlighting the need for optimal patient selection [667]. Unfortunately, there are no RCTs determining the
ideal and/or correct threshold of glycated haemoglobin that is acceptable prior to implant surgery in diabetic
patients [563]. A large-cohort, multicentre, retrospective analysis in men with diabetes who received a Coloplast
Titan™ implant demonstrated that vancomycin plus gentamicin was the most efficacious combination of
antibiotics used for implants dipping in terms of preventing postoperative infection and subsequent explantation
and revision [564]. A retrospective analysis of a large insurance claim database in the US, showed that
hypogonadism was independently associated with infection of the implant [565]. Patients with spinal cord injury
had higher risk of complications with up to 16% of cases reporting prosthesis infection in published series [566].
Prosthetic infection requires removal of the prosthesis and antibiotic administration. Alternatively, removal
of the infected device with immediate salvage and replacement with a new prosthesis has been described
using a wash-out protocol with successful salvages achieved in > 80% of cases [553, 567-569]. An absolute
recommendation on how to proceed after explantation in this setting cannot be given and must be focused on
the pros and cons of salvage therapy after full consultation with the patient.
Besides infection and mechanical failure, impending implant erosion involving the distal corpora, urethra, or
glans can occur in 1-6% of cases after surgery [570]. Moreover, non-infectious reservoir complications including
injury to pelvic structures such as bladder, bowel, and blood vessels have been described [571]. Similarly, glans
ischaemia and necrosis have been reported in about 1.5% of patients [570, 572]. Risk factors for these serious
complications are higher in those patients with significant vascular impairment, such as patients with diabetes,
or who have undergone concomitant lengthening procedures.
For penile prostheses models available on the market please see Appendix 3 online supplementary evidence
(https://uroweb.org/guidelines/sexual-and-reproductive-health/publications-appendices).
Summary of evidence LE
Lifestyle changes can lead to ED improvement in specific populations. 1a
PDE5Is are associated with significant improvement of EF with a good overall safety profile. 1a
There is no demonstrated differences among different PDE5Is in terms of treatment efficacy. 1a
Topical/intraurethral alprostadil is effective in improving EF but data are still limited. 1b
Vacuum therapy is able to improve EF with a wide range of treatment satisfaction rate. 2b
Intracavernous injection with alprostadil is an effective treatment of ED; however, it has relatively high 1a
treatment drop-out rates.
Low-intensity shockwave therapy is able to induce a mild improvement in EF among patients with 1a
vasculogenic ED.
Intracavernous injections of PRP have led to a mild improvement of EF among patients with organic ED, 1b
but the available evidence is still insufficient to provide a recommendation regarding its use.
BoNT-A has been shown to improve response rate to medical treatment for ED in patients who were 1b
non-responsive to oral or injective therapies, but data are still limited.
Penile rehabilitation with PDE5Is after RP does not increase the chance of spontaneous EF recovery. 1a
There is no difference in terms of efficacy and safety among different penile implants available or 3
surgical approach used.
5.7 Follow-up
Follow-up is important in order to assess efficacy and safety of the treatment provided. It is also essential to
assess patient satisfaction since successful treatment for ED goes beyond efficacy and safety. Physicians
must be aware that there is no single treatment that fits all patients or all situations as described in detail in the
previous section.
6. DISORDERS OF EJACULATION
6.1 Introduction
Ejaculation is a complex physiological process that comprises emission and expulsion processes and is
mediated by interwoven neurological and hormonal pathways [573]. Any interference with those pathways
may cause a wide range of ejaculatory disorders. The spectrum of ejaculation disorders includes premature
ejaculation (PE), retarded or delayed ejaculation, anejaculation, painful ejaculation, retrograde ejaculation,
anorgasmia and haemospermia.
A significant proportion of men with ED also experience PE [210, 601]. High levels of performance anxiety
related to ED may worsen PE, with a risk of misdiagnosing PE instead of the underlying ED. According to
the National Health and Social Life Survey (NHSLS), the prevalence of PE is not affected by age [202], unlike
ED, which increases with age. Premature ejaculation is not affected by marital or income status [202, 602].
However, PE is more common in Black men, Hispanic men, and men from regions where an Islamic background
is common [202, 603, 604] and the prevalence may be higher in men with a lower educational level [202, 210].
Other reported risk factors for PE include genetic predisposition [592, 605-608], poor overall health status
and obesity [202], prostate inflammation [609-613], hyperthyroidism [597], low prolactin levels [614], high
testosterone levels [615], vitamin D and B12 deficiency [616, 617], diabetes [618, 619], MetS [620, 621], lack
of physical activity [622], emotional problems and stress [202, 623, 624], depressive symptoms [624], and
traumatic sexual experiences [202, 210].
This definition includes four categories: male early ejaculation, lifelong generalised and situational, acquired
generalised and situational, and unspecified. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders V
(DSM-V) [212] and the International Society for Sexual Medicine (ISSM) [639] published definitions for lifelong
and acquired PE. These definitions are overlapping, with 3 shared factors (1. Time to ejaculation assessed by
IELT; 2. Perceived control; and, 3. Distress, bother, frustration, interpersonal difficulty related to the ejaculatory
dysfunction), resulting in a multi-dimensional diagnosis [639].
In everyday clinical practice, self-estimated IELT is sufficient [654]. Self-estimated and stopwatch-measured IELT
are interchangeable and correctly assign PE status with 80% sensitivity and 80% specificity [655].
Measurement of IELT with a calibrated stopwatch is mandatory in clinical trials. For any drug treatment study of
PE, Waldinger et al. suggested using geometric mean instead of arithmetic mean IELT because the distributed
IELT data are skewed. Otherwise, any treatment-related ejaculation delay may be overestimated if the arithmetic
mean IELT is used instead of the geometric mean IELT [656].
• Premature Ejaculation Diagnostic Tool (PEDT): A five-item questionnaire based on focus groups and
interviews from the USA, Germany, and Spain assesses control, frequency, minimal stimulation, distress
and interpersonal difficulty [657]. A total score of > 11 suggests a diagnosis of PE, 9 or 10 suggests a
probable diagnosis, and < 8 indicates a low likelihood of PE.
Other questionnaires used to characterise PE and determine treatment effects include the Premature
Ejaculation Profile (PEP) [649], Index of Premature Ejaculation (IPE) [659] and Male Sexual Health Questionnaire
Ejaculatory Dysfunction (MSHQ-EjD) [660]. Currently, their role is optional in everyday clinical practice. The
Masturbatory Premature Ejaculation Diagnostic Tool (MPEDT) has also been recently proposed [661], due to fact
that PE patients report longer IELTs and lesser bother/distress during masturbation than partnered sex [662];
however, further validation studies are required before the routine use of this questionnaire in this population.
Summary of evidence LE
A comprehensive medical history and a thorough physical examination can serve as valuable tools for 3
clinicians in identifying the underlying medical factors contributing to PE.
PE can negatively impact self-confidence, strain partner relationships, and potentially lead to emotional 2a
distress, anxiety, shame, and depression.
Several questionnaires can be used for the diagnosis of PE (PEDT, AIPE) and for assessing the 2b
therapeutic outcomes of PE interventions (PEP).
Although relying on IELT is inadequate for characterizing PE, self-reported IELT proves satisfactory in 3
routine clinical contexts.
Decide on referral to
(sexual)psychotherapy;
include partner actively
6.2.6.1.1 ummary of evidence and recommendations for the assessment and treatment
S
(psychosexual approach) of PE
Summary of evidence LE
The incorporation of psychosexual approach, alongside psycho-educational guidance and mindfulness 2b
techniques, ameliorate symptoms of PE and alleviate the associated distress, anxiety, and depression.
The combination of psychosexual approaches and pharmacological treatments yields superior 3
outcomes compared to pharmacological interventions alone.
6.2.6.2 Pharmacotherapy
6.2.6.2.1 Dapoxetine
Dapoxetine hydrochloride is a short-acting SSRI with a pharmacokinetic profile suitable for on-demand
treatment for PE [678]. It has a rapid Tmax (1.3 hours) and a short half-life (95% clearance rate after 24 hours)
[679, 680]. It is approved for on-demand treatment of PE in European countries and elsewhere, but not in
the USA. Both available doses of dapoxetine (30 mg and 60 mg) have shown 2.5- and 3.0-fold increases,
respectively, in IELT overall, rising to 3.4- and 4.3-fold in patients with a baseline average IELT < 30 seconds [681].
In RCTs, dapoxetine, 30 mg or 60 mg 1-2 hours before intercourse, was effective at improving IELT and
increasing ejaculatory control, decreasing distress, and increasing satisfaction [681]. Dapoxetine has shown a
similar efficacy profile in men with lifelong and acquired PE [681, 682]. Treatment-related adverse effects were
dose-dependent and included nausea, diarrhoea, thirst, headache and dizziness [682]. Treatment-emergent
adverse events (TEAEs) were responsible for study discontinuation in 4% (30 mg) and 10% (60 mg) of subjects
[654]. There was no indication of an increased risk of suicidal ideation or suicide attempts and little indication
of withdrawal symptoms with abrupt dapoxetine cessation [681, 682]. Dapoxetine is safer than formal anti-
depressant compounds used for treatment of PE [683].
Many patients and physicians may prefer using dapoxetine in combination with a PDE5I to extend the time
until ejaculation and minimise the risk of ED due to dapoxetine treatment. Phase 1 studies of dapoxetine have
confirmed that it has no pharmacokinetic interactions with PDE5Is (i.e., tadalafil 20 mg and sildenafil 100 mg)
[688]. When dapoxetine is co-administered with PDE5Is, it is well tolerated, with a safety profile consistent with
previous phase 3 studies of dapoxetine alone [689]. An RCT, including PE patients without ED, demonstrated that
a combination of dapoxetine with sildenafil could significantly improve IELT values and PROs compared with
dapoxetine alone or sildenafil alone, with tolerable adverse events [690]. The efficacy and safety of dapoxetine/
sildenafil combination tablets for the treatment of PE have also been reported [691].
The discontinuation rates of dapoxetine seem moderate to high [692]. The cumulative discontinuation rates
increase over time, reaching 90% at 2 years after initiation of therapy. The reasons for the high discontinuation
rate are cost (29.9%), disappointment that PE was not curable and the on-demand nature of the drug (25%),
adverse effects (11.6%), perceived poor efficacy (9.8%), a search for other treatment options (5.5%), and
unknown (18.3%) [693]. Similarly, it was confirmed that many patients on dapoxetine treatment spontaneously
discontinued treatment, while this rate was reported at 50% for other SSRIs and 28.8% for paroxetine,
respectively [694]. In a Chinese cohort study, 13.6% of the patients discontinued dapoxetine due to lack of
efficacy (62%), adverse effects (24%), and low frequency of sexual intercourse (14%) [695].
Clomipramine, the most serotoninergic tricyclic antidepressant, was first reported in 1977 as an effective
PE treatment [702, 703]. In a recent RCT, on-demand use of clomipramine 15 mg, 2-6 hours before sexual
intercourse was found to be associated with IELT fold change and significant improvements in PRO measures in
the treatment group as compared with the placebo group (4.66 ± 5.64 vs. 2.80 ± 2.19, P < 0.05) [704, 705]. The
most commonly reported TEAEs were nausea in 15.7% and dizziness in 4.9% of men, respectively [704, 705].
Several meta-analyses suggest SSRIs may increase the geometric mean IELT by 2.6-13.2-fold [706]. Paroxetine
is superior to fluoxetine, clomipramine and sertraline [707, 708]. Sertraline is superior to fluoxetine, whereas
the efficacy of clomipramine is not significantly different from that of fluoxetine and sertraline. Paroxetine was
evaluated in doses of 20-40 mg, sertraline 25-200 mg, fluoxetine 10-60 mg and clomipramine 25-50 mg [706-
708].
Ejaculation delay may start a few days after drug intake, but it is more evident after one to two weeks as
receptor desensitisation requires time to occur. Although efficacy may be maintained for several years,
tachyphylaxis (decreasing response to a drug following chronic administration) may occur after six to twelve
months [702]. Common TEAEs of SSRIs include fatigue, drowsiness, yawning, nausea, vomiting, dry mouth,
diarrhoea and perspiration; TEAEs are usually mild and gradually improve after two to three weeks of treatment
[702, 709]. Decreased libido, anorgasmia, anejaculation and ED have also been reported.
Due to the risk of suicidal ideation or suicide attempts, caution is suggested in prescribing SSRIs to young
adolescents aged ≤ 18 years with PE, and to men with PE and a comorbid depressive disorder, particularly when
associated with suicidal ideation. Patients should be advised to avoid sudden cessation or rapid dose reduction
of daily-dosed SSRIs, which may be related to SSRI withdrawal syndrome [654]. Moreover, PE patients trying to
conceive should avoid using these medications because of their detrimental effects on sperm cells [710-714].
Several studies have demonstrated the efficacy of lidocaine/prilocaine spray in improving both IELT and PROs
three sprays administered 5 min before sexual intercourse [725, 726]. Published data showed that lidocaine/
prilocaine spray increases IELT over time up to 6.3-fold over 3 months, with a month-by-month improvement
through the course of the treatment in long-term studies [727]. A low incidence of local TEAEs in both patients
and partners has been reported, including genital hypoaesthesia (4.5% and 1.0% in men and female partners,
respectively) and ED (4.4%), and vulvovaginal burning sensation (3.9%), but is unlikely to be associated with
systemic TEAEs [728, 729]. Lidocaine-only sprays are also available and found to be effective in the treatment of
PE [730, 731].
6.2.6.2.4 Tramadol
Tramadol is a centrally-acting analgesic agent that combines opioid receptor activation and serotonin and
noradrenaline re-uptake inhibition. Tramadol is a mild-opioid receptor agonist, but it also displays antagonistic
properties on transporters of noradrenaline and 5-HT [732]. This mechanism of action distinguishes tramadol
from other opioids, including morphine. Tramadol is readily absorbed after oral administration and has an
elimination half-life of 5-7 hours.
Several clinical trials evaluated the efficacy and safety of tramadol ODT (62 and 89 mg) and tramadol HCI in
the treatment of PE [733]. Up to 2.5-fold increases in the median IELT have been reported among patients who
received on demand tramadol treatment [734, 735].
Adverse effects were reported at doses used for analgesic purposes (≤ 400 mg daily) and included constipation,
sedation and dry mouth. In May 2009, the US FDA released a warning letter about tramadol’s potential to cause
addiction and difficulty in breathing [736]. The tolerability during the twelve-week study period in men with
PE was acceptable [737]. Several other studies have also reported that tramadol exhibits a significant dose-
related efficacy along with potential adverse effects during the treatment of PE [734, 735]. The Guidelines Panel
considers tramadol as a potential alternative treatment to established first-line therapeutic options in men with
PE; however, it should be clearly outlined that the use of tramadol has to be considered with caution since there
is a lack of data on the long-term safety of the compound in this setting.
Considering the importance of central oxytocin receptors in the ejaculation reflex, several researchers have
assessed the efficacy and safety of oxytocin receptor antagonists in the treatment of PE [756]. Epelsiban [757]
and cligosiban [758-761] have been found to be safe and mildly effective in delaying ejaculation, but further
controlled trials are needed [760, 761]. Delayed ejaculation was associated with the use of pregabalin, a new
generation of gapapentinoid, as a side-effect. On-demand oral pregabalin 150 mg was found to increase the
IELTs of patients 2.45 ± 1.43-fold. Treatment-emergent side effects (blurred vision, dizziness, vomiting) were
minimal and did not lead to drug discontinuation [762].
The role of other proposed treatment modalities for the treatment of PE, such as penis-root masturbation
[763], vibrator-assisted start-stop exercises [675], transcutaneous functional electric stimulation [764, 765],
transcutaneous posterior tibial nerve stimulation [766], acupuncture [767-769] and practicing yoga [770] need
more evidence to be considered in the clinical setting.
Summary of evidence LE
Pharmacotherapy includes either dapoxetine on-demand (an oral short-acting SSRI) and eutectic 1a
lidocaine/prilocaine spray (a topical desensitising agent), which are the only approved treatments for
PE, or other off-label antidepressants (daily/on-demand SSRIs and clomipramine).
Both on-demand dapoxetine treatment and daily SSRI treatment improve IELT values significantly. 1a
Both on-demand dapoxetine treatment and daily SSRI treatment have generally tolerable side effects 1a
when used for treatment of PE.
Daily/on-demand clomipramine treatments improve IELT values significantly and have generally 1a
tolerable side effects when used for treatment of PE.
Cream and spray forms of lidocaine/prilocaine improve IELT values significantly and have a safe profile. 1b
Tramadol is effective in the treatment of PE but the evidence is still inadequate for its long-term safety 1a
profile including addiction potential.
Combination of PDE5Is and SSRIs overtakes SSRI monotherapy in effectiveness. 1a
Hyaluronic acid injections are effective in decreasing penile sensitivity. 2b
6.3.3.2 Pharmacotherapy
Several pharmacological agents, including cabergoline, bupropion, alpha-1-adrenergic agonists
(pseudoephedrine, midodrine, imipramine and ephedrine), buspirone, oxytocin, testosterone, bethanechol,
yohimbine, amantadine, cyproheptadine and apomorphine have been used to treat DE with varied success
[674]. Unfortunately, there is no FDA or EMA-approved medications to treat DE, as most of the cited research is
based on case-cohort studies that were not randomised, blinded, or placebo-controlled. Many drugs have been
used as primary treatments and/or antidotes to other medications that can cause DE. A survey of sexual health
providers demonstrated an overall treatment success of 40% with most providers commonly using cabergoline,
bupropion or oxytocin [787]. However, this survey measured the anecdotal results of practitioners. There was no
proven efficacy or superiority of any drug due to a lack of placebo-controlled, randomised, blinded, comparative
trials [781]. In addition to pharmacotherapy, penile vibratory stimulation (PVS) is also used as an adjunct
therapy for DE [788]. Another study that used combined therapy of midodrine and PVS to increase autonomic
stimulation in 158 men with spinal cord injury led to ejaculation in almost 65% of the patients [789].
Summary of evidence LE
Delayed ejaculation can be caused by several aetiologies including congenital, anatomic, neurogenic, 3
infective, hormonal, drug-related and psychological.
There is not enough evidence to support a definitive treatment for DE. 3
Any factor that disrupts this reflex and inhibits contraction of the bladder neck (internal vesical sphincter) may
lead to retrograde passage of semen into the bladder. These can be broadly categorised as pharmacological,
neurogenic, anatomic and endocrinal causes of retrograde ejaculation (Table 6.2).
An RCT randomised patients to receive one of four α-adrenergic agents (dextroamphetamine, ephedrine,
phenylpropanolamine and pseudoephedrine) with or without histamine. The patients suffered from failure
of ejaculation following retroperitoneal lymphadenectomy. They found that four days of treatment prior to
ejaculation was the most effective and that all the adrenergic agonists restored antegrade ejaculation [819]. In a
systematic review, the efficacy of this group of medications was found to be 28% [216]. The adverse effects of
sympathomimetics include dryness of mucous membranes and hypertension.
The use of antimuscarinics has been described, including brompheniramine maleate and imipramine, as well
as in combination with sympathomimetics. The calculated efficacy of antimuscarinics alone or in combination
with sympathomimetics is 22% and 39%, respectively [216]. Combination therapy appears to be more effective,
although statistical analysis is not yet possible due to the small sample sizes.
1. Centrifugation and resuspension. In order to improve the ambient conditions for the sperm, the patient is
asked to increase their fluid intake or take sodium bicarbonate to dilute or alkalise the urine, respectively.
Afterwards, a post-orgasmic urine sample is collected by introducing a catheter or spontaneous voiding.
This sample is then centrifuged and suspended in a medium. The types of suspension fluids are
heterogeneous and can include bovine serum albumin, human serum albumin, Earle’s/Hank’s balanced
salt solution and the patient’s urine. The resultant modified sperm mixture can then be used in assisted
reproductive techniques. A systematic review of studies in couples in which male partner had retrograde
ejaculation found a 15% pregnancy rate per cycle (0-100%) [216].
2. Hotchkiss method. The Hotchkiss method involves emptying the bladder prior to ejaculation, using a
catheter, and then washing out and instilling a small quantity of Lactated Ringers to improve the ambient
condition of the bladder. The patient then ejaculates, and semen is retrieved by catheterisation or voiding
[821]. Modified Hotchkiss methods involve variance in the instillation medium. Pregnancy rates were 24%
per cycle (0-100%) [216].
3. Ejaculation on a full bladder. The patient is encouraged to ejaculate on a full bladder and semen is
suspended in Baker’s Buffer. The pregnancy rate in the two studies, which included only five patients,
have described results using this technique [822, 823].
6.7 Anorgasmia
6.7.1 Definition and classification
Anorgasmia is the perceived absence of orgasm and can give rise to anejaculation. Regardless of the presence
of ejaculation, anorgasmia can be a lifelong (primary) or acquired (secondary) disorder [213].
6.7.3.2 Pharmacotherapy
Several drugs have been reported to reverse anorgasmia, including cyproheptadine, yohimbine, buspirone,
amantadine and oxytocin [827-832]. However, these reports are generally from case-cohort studies and drugs
have limited efficacy and significant adverse effect profiles. Therefore, current evidence is not strong enough to
recommend drugs to treat anorgasmia.
6.8 Haemospermia
6.8.1 Definition and classification
Haemospermia is defined as the appearance of blood in the ejaculate. Although it is often regarded as a
symptom of minor significance, blood in the ejaculate causes anxiety in many men and may indicate underlying
pathology [236].
Category Causes
Congenital Seminal vesicle (SV) or ejaculatory duct cysts
Inflammatory Urethritis, prostatitis, epididymitis, tuberculosis, CMV, HIV, Schistosomiasis,
hydatid, condyloma of urethra and meatus, urinary tract infections
Obstruction Prostatic, SV and ejaculatory duct calculi, post-inflammatory, seminal
vesicle diverticula/cyst, urethral stricture, utricle cyst, BPH
Tumours Prostate, bladder, SV, urethra, testis, epididymis, melanoma
Vascular Prostatic varices, prostatic telangiectasia, haemangioma, posterior
urethral veins, excessive sex or masturbation
Trauma/ iatrogenic Perineum, testis, instrumentation, post-haemorrhoid injection, prostate
biopsy, vaso-venous fistula
Systemic Hypertension, haemophilia, purpura, scurvy, bleeding disorders, chronic
liver disease, renovascular disease, leukaemia, lymphoma, cirrhosis,
amyloidosis
Idiopathic -
The risk of any malignancy in patients presenting with haemospermia is approximately 3.5% (0-13.1%) [835,
837]. In a study in which 342 patients with haemospermia were included, the most relevant aetiology for
haemospermia was inflammation/infection (49.4%) while genitourinary cancers (i.e., prostate and testis) only
accounted for 3.2% of the cases [838].
6.8.3 Investigations
As with other clinical conditions, a systematic clinical history and assessment is undertaken to help identify the
cause of haemospermia. Although the differential diagnosis is extensive, most cases are caused by infections
or other inflammatory processes [236].
Most authors who propose an investigative baseline agree on the initial diagnostic tests, but there is no
consensus in this regard [833, 834, 837, 839]. Urinalysis should be performed along with sending the urine
for culture and sensitivity testing, as well as microscopy. If tuberculosis or schistosomiasis is the suspected
cause, the semen or prostatic secretions should be sent for analysis. A full sexually-transmitted disease
screen, including first-void urine as well as serum and genitourinary samples, should be tested for Chlamydia,
Ureaplasma and Herpes Simplex virus. Using this strategy, it may be possible to find an infectious agent among
cases that would have been labelled as idiopathic haemospermia [843].
Serum PSA should be taken in men aged > 40 years who have been appropriately counselled [237]. Blood work,
including a full blood count, liver function tests, and a clotting screen should be taken to identify systemic
diseases. The question of whether further investigation is warranted depends on clinician judgment, patient age
and an assessment of risk factors [833]. Digital rectal examination should also be performed, and the meatus
re-examined after DRE for bloody discharge [844]. Detection of a palpable nodule in the prostate is important
because an association between haemospermia and PCa has been postulated, although not completely proven.
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is being increasingly used as a definitive means to investigate
haemospermia. The multiplanar ability of MRI to accurately represent structural changes in the prostate,
seminal vesicles, ampulla of vas deferens, and ejaculatory ducts has enabled the technique to be particularly
useful in determining the origin of midline or paramedian prostatic cysts and in determining optimal surgical
management [845]. The addition of an endorectal coil can improve diagnostic accuracy for identifying the site
and possible causes of haemorrhage [846].
Cystoscopy has been included in most suggested investigative protocols in patients with high-risk features
(patients who are refractory to conservative treatment and who have persistent haemospermia). It can provide
valuable information as it allows direct visualisation of the main structures in the urinary tract that can be
attributed to causes of haemospermia, such as polyps, urethritis, prostatic cysts, foreign bodies, calcifications
and vascular abnormalities [847, 848].
With the advancement of optics, the ability to create ureteroscopes of diameters small enough to allow
insertion into the ejaculatory duct and seminal vesicles has been made possible [849]. In a prospective study,
106 patients with prolonged haemospermia underwent transrectal US and seminal vesiculoscopy. With both
methods combined, the diagnosis was made in 87.7% of patients. When compared head-to-head, the diagnostic
yield for TRUS vs. seminal vesiculoscopy was 45.3% and 74.5%, respectively (P < 0.001) [850].
Melanospermia is a consequence of malignant melanoma involving the genitourinary tract and is a rare
condition that has been described in two case reports [851, 852]. Chromatography of the semen sample can be
used to distinguish the two by identifying the presence of melanin if needed.
Middle-aged patients with recurrent haemospermia warrant more aggressive intervention. Appropriate antibiotic
therapy should be given to patients who have urogenital infections or STIs. Urethral or prostate varices or
angiodyplastic vessels can be fulgurated, whereas cysts, either of the seminal vesicles or prostatic urethra, can
be aspirated transrectally [236]. Ejaculatory duct obstruction is managed by transurethral incision at the duct
opening [853, 854]. Systemic conditions should be treated appropriately [837, 840, 855, 856].
Presentaon of haemospermia
Men < 40 years old, isolated Men ≥ 40 years old or man of any
haemospermia, and no other age with persistent haemospermia,
symptoms or signs of disease or haemospermia associated with
symptoms or signs of disease
STI = Sexually transmitted infections; PSA = Prostate specific antigen; DRE = Digital rectal examination;
US = Ultrasonography; TRUS = Transrectal ultrasonography; MRI = Magnetic resonance imaging.
Summary of evidence LE
While haemospermia has traditionally been attributed to benign causes, it is a potential indicator 3
warranting thorough diagnostic evaluation and, if necessary, targeted treatment.
The principal objective of treatment is to rule out malignancies, while addressing any other underlying 3
causes as well.
Table 7.1: Common causes of low sexual desire in men [861, 870]
Figure 7.1: Flow-diagram of psychological evaluation of patients with low sexual desire
7.4.2 Pharmacotherapy
Low sexual desire secondary to low testosterone levels can be treated with different formulations of
testosterone. The favourable effect of testosterone therapy on sexual motivation and the presence of sexual
thoughts was shown in a meta-analysis [874]. The aim of treatment should be to reach the physiological range
of testosterone (see section 3.3).
Hyperprolactinaemia can also cause LSD and one of the most relevant aetiological factors is prolactin-secreting
pituitary adenomas. These adenomas can be easily diagnosed with MRI of the pituitary gland and can be treated
with dopamine agonist agents [878]. The other accompanying endocrine disorders, such as hypothyroidism,
hyperthyroidism and diabetes, should be treated accordingly.
Pharmacotherapy can also be used to treat major depression; however, it should be remembered that
antidepressants may negatively affect sexual functioning; therefore, antidepressant compounds with less effect
on sexual function should be chosen. Psychotherapy can increase the efficacy of pharmacotherapy, especially
for patients whose LSD is due to depression [879].
8.1.4 Summary of evidence and recommendation for diagnosis and treatment of congenital penile
curvature
Summary of evidence LE
Medical and sexual history are usually sufficient to establish a diagnosis of CPC. Physical examination 3
and photographic documentation during erection (preferably after ICI of vasoactive drugs) are
mandatory to document the curvature.
Surgery is the only treatment option for CPC, which should be deferred until after puberty and 3
performed at any time in adult life in individuals with significant functional impairment during
intercourse.
8.2.1 Epidemiology
Epidemiological data on PD are limited. Prevalence rates of 0.4-20.3% have been reported, with a higher
prevalence in patients with ED and diabetes [898-906]. A recent survey has indicated that the prevalence of
definitive and probable cases of PD in the USA is 0.7% and 11%, respectively, suggesting that PD is an under-
diagnosed condition [907]. Peyronie’s disease often occurs in older men with a typical age of onset of 50-60
years. However, PD also occurs in younger men (< 40 years), with a reported prevalence of 1.5-16.9% [902, 908,
909].
Clinicians should take a focused history to distinguish between active and stable disease, as this will influence
medical treatment and the timing of surgery. Patients who are still likely to have active disease are those with
a shorter symptom duration, pain on erection, or a recent change in penile deformity. Resolution of pain and
stability of the curvature for at least three months are accepted criteria of disease stabilisation as well as
patients’ referral for specific medical therapy [911, 912] or surgical intervention, if indicated [913].
The examination should start with a focused genital assessment that is extended to the hands and feet
for detecting possible Dupuytren’s contracture or Ledderhosen scarring of the plantar fascia [914]. Penile
examination is performed to assess the presence of a palpable nodule or plaque. There is no correlation
between plaque size and degree of curvature [915]. Measurement of the stretched or erect penile length is
important because it may have an impact on the subsequent treatment decisions and potential medico-legal
implications [916-918].
An objective assessment of penile curvature with an erection is mandatory. This can be obtained by several
approaches, including home (self) photography of a natural erection (preferably), using a vacuum-assisted
erection test or an ICI using vasoactive agents. However, it has been suggested that the ICI method is superior,
as it is able to induce an erection similar to or better than that which the patient would experience when sexually
aroused [919-921]. Computed tomography and MRI have a limited role in the diagnosis of the curvature and are
not recommended on a routine basis. Erectile function can be assessed using validated instruments such as
the IIEF although this has not been validated in PD patients [922]. Erectile dysfunction is common in patients
with PD (30-70.6%) [923, 924]. The presence of ED and psychological factors may also have a profound impact
on the chosen treatment strategy [925]. Ultrasound measurement of plaque size is not accurate but may be
helpful to assess the presence of the plaque and its calcification and location [926, 927]. Doppler US may be
used for the assessment of penile haemodynamics and ED aetiology [924]. In particular to assess penile arterial
inflow in the context of the interventional modality to be undertaken (eg plaque incision and grafting) to exclude
arteriogenic ED.
Summary of evidence LE
Ultrasound measurement of plaque size is inaccurate and operator dependent. 3
Doppler US may be used to assess penile haemodynamic and vascular anatomy. 2a
Intracavernous injection method is superior to other methods to provide an objective assessment of 4
penile curvature with an erection.
The results of the studies on conservative treatment for PD are often contradictory, making it difficult to provide
recommendations in everyday, real-life settings [928]. The Guidelines does not recommend the use of oral
treatments for PD including pentoxifylline, vitamin E, tamoxifen, procarbazine, potassium para-aminobenzoate
(potaba), omega-3 fatty acids or combination of vitamin E and L-carnitine because of their lack of proven
efficacy [913, 929-931]. Studies of these treatments have numerous methodological problems including their
uncontrolled nature, the limited number of patients treated, the short-term follow-up and the different outcome
measures used [932, 933]. Even in the absence of adverse events, treatment with these agents may delay the
use of other more efficacious treatments.
Oral treatments
Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs)
Phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors (PDE5Is)
Intralesional treatments
Verapamil
Nicardipine
Clostridium collagenase
Interferon a2B
Hyaluronic acid
Botulinum toxin
Topical treatments
H-100 gel
Other
Traction devices
Multimodal treatment
Extracorporeal shockwave treatment
Vacuum Erection Device
The original treatment protocol in all studies consists of two injections of 0.58 mg of CCH 24-72 hours apart
every 6 weeks for up to four cycles. Data from IMPRESS (Investigation for Maximal Peyronie´s Reduction
Efficacy and Safety Studies) II and II studies [976], as well as post approval trials [954], which demonstrated
the efficacy and safety of this treatment, and are summarised in Table S8.2 online supplementary evidence
Appendix 4.
The average improvement in curvature was 34% compared to 18.2% in the placebo group. Three adverse events
of corporeal rupture were surgically repaired. The greatest chance of curvature improvement was for curvatures
between 30° and 60°, longer duration of disease, IIEF > 17, and no calcification [912]. An 18.2% improvement
from baseline in the placebo arm was also observed. These findings raise questions regarding the proposed role
of plaque injection and penile modelling, regardless of the medication, in improving outcomes in men with PD as
the placebo or modelling arm resulted in relatively high curvature reduction compared to the treatment arm.
The conclusion of the IMPRESS I and II studies is that that CCH improves PD both physically and psychologically
[955]. A post hoc meta-analysis of the IMPRESS studies demonstrated better results in patients with curvatures
< 60o, > 2 years of onset, no calcification in the plaque and good erectile function [954].
Thereafter, a modified short protocol consisting of administration of a single (0.9 mg, one vial) injection per
cycle distributed along three lines around the point of maximum curvature up to three cycles, separated by
4-weekly intervals, has been proposed and rapidly popularised replacing physician modelling with a multi-
modal approach through penile stretching, modelling and VED at home [956]. The results from this modified
protocol were comparable to the results of the IMPRESS trials and appeared to decrease the cost and duration
of treatment, although these studies were non-randomised. However, these results were further explored in a
prospective non-randomised multi-centre study [982]. In another large single-arm multi-centre clinical study
using the shortened protocol, longer PD duration, greater baseline PC and basal and dorsal plaque location were
identified as clinically significant predictors of treatment success [957]. Accordingly, a nomogram developed
to predict treatment success after CCH for PD showed that patients with longer PD duration, greater baseline
penile curvature and basal plaque location had a greater chance of treatment success [957]; however, these
findings need to be externally validated.
Regarding safety concerns, most PD patients treated with CCH experienced at least one mild or moderate
adverse event localised to the penis (penile haematoma (50.2%), penile pain (33.5%), penile swelling (28.9%) and
injection site pain (24.1%), which resolved spontaneously within 14 days of injection [916]. The adverse reaction
profile was similar after each injection, regardless of the number of injections administered. Serious treatment-
emergent adverse events (TEAEs) (0.9%) included penile haematoma and corporeal rupture that require surgical
treatment. According to IMPRESS data and the shortened protocol, to prevent serious TEAEs men should be
advised to avoid sexual intercourse in the four weeks following injection. Recent preliminary data suggest that
treatment in the acute phase of the disease is effective and safe [880, 917-921].
In conclusion, CCH is a safe and established treatment for stable-phase disease with more recent evidence
suggesting that CCH also has a role in affecting the progression of active-phase disease. It should also be noted
that there is a large effect of traction or modelling in controlled studies, whilst studies reporting on modified
protocols have small numbers of patients and are largely uncontrolled. Therefore, patients should be counselled
fully on the efficacy of collagenase and the high cost of treatment.
It has been suggested that those patients with severe curvature may also benefit from CCH injections because
of a potential downgrading of the penile curvature: a decrease in curvature may allow for a penile plication
procedure instead of a plaque incision and grafting procedure, therefore avoiding the more negative impact on
erectile function from plaque incision and grafting. However, further studies are required to validate these initial
findings [922, 963].
Interferon α-2b
Intralesional injections (5x10^6 units of IFN-α2b in 10 mL saline every 2 weeks over 12 weeks for a total of six
injections) significantly improved penile curvature, plaque size and density, and pain compared to placebo.
Additionally, penile blood flow parameters are benefited by IFN-α2b [953, 964, 965]. Regardless of plaque
location, IFN-α2b is an effective treatment option. Treatment with IFN-α2b provides a > 20% reduction in
curvature in most men with PD, independent of plaque location [966]. Given the mild adverse effects, which
include sinusitis and flu-like symptoms, which can be effectively treated with NSAIDs before IFN-α2b injection,
and the moderate strength of data available, IFN-α2b is currently recommended for treatment of stable-phase
PD.
Four RCTs and one meta-analysis [983-987] assessed the efficacy of ESWT for PD. Three were sham-controlled
trials while one compared ESWT with the combination of ESWT and PDE5I (tadalafil) [988].
All trials showed positive findings in terms of pain relief, but no effect on penile curvature and plaque size.
Inclusion criteria varied widely among studies and further investigation is needed. Therefore, ESWT should
not be used a primary treatment for penile curvature in men with PD. The results are summarised in Table
S8.4 online supplementary evidence Appendix 4 (https://uroweb.org/guidelines/sexual-and-reproductive-health/
publications-appendices).
The stated clinical goals of PTT are to non-surgically reduce curvature, enhance girth, and recover lost length,
which are attractive to patients with PD. However, clinical evidence is limited due to the small number of
patients included (267 in total), the heterogeneity in the study designs, and the non-standardised inclusion and
exclusion criteria which make it impossible to draw any definitive conclusions about this therapy [991-995].
Most of the included patients will need further treatment to ameliorate their curvature for satisfactory sexual
intercourse. Moreover, the effect of PTT in patients with calcified plaques, hourglass or hinge deformities which
are, theoretically, less likely to respond to PTT has not been systematically studied. In addition, the treatment
can result in discomfort and be inconvenient as the device needs to be used for an extended period (2-8 hours
daily), but has been shown to be tolerated by highly-motivated patients. There were no reported serious adverse
effects, including skin changes, ulcerations, hypo-aesthesia or diminished rigidity [993, 996]. A summary of
the clinical evidence for PTT can be found in in Table S8.5 online supplementary evidence Appendix 4 (https://
uroweb.org/guidelines/sexual-and-reproductive-health/publications-appendices).
In conclusion, PTT seems to be effective and safe for patients with PD [997], but there is still lack of
evidence to give any definitive recommendation in terms of its use as a monotherapy for PD.
Multimodal treatment
There are some evidence suggesting that a combination of different oral agents can be used for treatment of
the acute phase of PD. However, there does not seem to be a consensus on which drugs to combine or the
optimum drug dosage; nor has there been a comparison of different drug combinations.
A long-term study assessing the role of multimodal medical therapy (injectable verapamil associated
with antioxidants and local diclofenac) demonstrated that treatment was efficacious to treat PD patients. It
concluded that combination therapy reduced pain more effectively than verapamil alone, making this specific
combination treatment more effective compared to monotherapy [999]. Furthermore, combination protocols
including injectable therapies, such as CCH, have been studied in controlled trials. The addition of adjunctive
PTT and VED has been described; however, limited data are available regarding their use [1002].
8.2.3.1.5 Summary of evidence and recommendations for conservative treatment of Peyronie’s disease
Summary of evidence LE
Conservative treatment for PD is primarily aimed at treating patients in the early stage of the disease in 3c
order to relieve symptoms and prevent progression.
There is no convincing evidence supporting oral treatment with acetyl esters of carnitine, vitamin E, 3c
potassium para-aminobenzoate (potaba) and pentoxifylline.
Due to adverse effects, treatment with oral tamoxifen is no longer recommended. 3c
Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs can be used to treat pain in the acute phase. 4
Contradictory evidence is available for intralesional treatment with calcium channel antagonists: 4
verapamil and nicardipine.
Intralesional treatment with Collagenase Clostridium histolyticum showed significant decreases in 1b
penile curvature, plaque diameter and plaque length in men with stable disease.
Intralesional treatment with interferon may improve penile curvature, plaque size, density, and pain. 2b
Intralesional treatment with steroids have been shown to have adverse effects, including tissue atrophy, 3c
thinning of the skin and immunosuppression.
No high-level evidence is available to support treatment with intralesional hyaluronic acid or botulinum 3c
toxin.
Intralesional hyaluronic acid may be used to improve pain, penile curvature and IIEF scores. 2b
Combination of oral and intralesional hyaluronic acid treatment improves penile curvature and plaque 1b
size.
There is no evidence that topical treatments applied to the penile shaft result in adequate levels of the 3c
active compound within the tunica albuginea.
There is no efficacy data for the use of iontophoresis. 3c
Extracorporeal shockwave treatment may be offered to treat penile pain, but it does not improve penile 2b
curvature and plaque size.
Treatment with penile traction therapy alone or in combination with injectable therapy as part of a 3c
multimodal approach may reduce penile curvature and increase penile length, although the available
studies have considerable limitations.
Before considering reconstructive surgery, it is recommended to document the size and location of penile
plaques, the degree of curvature, complex deformities (hinge or hourglass), the penile length and the presence
or absence of ED. The potential aims and risks of surgery should be fully discussed with the patient so that he
can make an informed decision [1008]. Specific issues that should be mentioned during this discussion are:
risk of penile shortening; ED, penile numbness; and delayed orgasm, the risk of recurrent curvature, potential
for palpation of knots and stitches underneath the skin, potential need for circumcision at the time of surgery,
residual curvature and the risk of further penile wasting with shortening procedures [913, 1011]. Selection
of the most appropriate surgical intervention is based on penile length assessment, curvature severity and
erectile function status, including response to pharmacotherapy in cases of ED [913]. Patient expectations from
surgery must also be included in the pre-operative assessment. The main objective of surgery is to achieve
a “functionally straight” penis, and this must be fully understood by the patient to achieve the best possible
satisfaction outcomes after surgery [1008, 1012].
Three major types of reconstruction may be considered for PD: (i) tunical shortening procedures; (ii) tunical
lengthening procedures; and, (iii) penile prosthesis implantation, with or without straightening techniques in the
presence of concomitant ED and residual curvature [1013, 1014].
Penile degloving with associated circumcision (as a means of preventing post-operative phimosis) should be
considered the standard approach for all types of procedures, although modifications have been described.
Only one study has suggested that circumcision is not always necessary (e.g., in cases where the foreskin is
normal pre-operatively) [1015]. Non-degloving techniques have been described that have been shown to prevent
ischaemia and lymphatic complications after subcoronal circumcision [1016, 1017].
There are no standardised questionnaires for the evaluation of surgical outcomes. Data from well-designed
prospective studies are scarce, with low levels of evidence. Data are mainly based on retrospective single-centre
studies, typically non-comparative and non-randomised, or on expert opinion [913, 1018]. Therefore, surgical
outcomes must be treated with caution.
The Yachia technique is based on a completely different concept, as it utilises the Heinke-Mikowitz principle
for which a longitudinal tunical incision is closed transversely to shorten the convex side of the penis. This
technique, initially described by Lemberger in 1984, was popularised by Yachia in 1990, when he reported a
series of 10 cases [1021-1026].
Pure plication techniques are simpler to perform. They are based on single or multiple plications performed
without making excisions or incisions on the tunical albuginea, to limit the potential damage to the veno-
occlusive mechanism [916, 1027-1043]. Another modification described the ’16-dot’ technique that consists of
application of two pairs of parallel Essed-Schroeder plications tensioned more or less depending on the degree
of curvature [1044-1047]. Results and satisfaction rates are similar to both incision/excision techniques.
In general, using these tunical shortening techniques, complete penile straightening is achieved in > 85% of
patients. Recurrence of the curvature and penile hypo-aesthesia is uncommon (~10%) and the risk of post-
operative ED is low. Penile shortening is the most commonly reported adverse outcome of these procedures.
Shortening of 1-1.5 cm has been reported for 22-69% of patients, which is rarely the cause of post-operative
sexual dysfunction and patients may perceive the loss of length as greater than it actually is. It is therefore
strongly advisable to measure and document the penile length peri-operatively, both before and after the
straightening procedure, whichever the technique used (Table 8.2).
As mentioned above, there are multiple techniques with small modifications and all of them have been reported
in retrospective studies, most of them without appropriate comparison between techniques and therefore the
level of evidence is not sufficient to recommend one particular method over another.
Table 8.2: Results of tunical shortening procedures for PD (data from different, non-comparable studies)
[916, 1021-1044, 1048-1051]
A large number of different grafts have been used. The ideal graft should be resistant to traction, easy to
suture and manipulate, flexible (although not too much, to avoid aneurysmal dilations), readily available, cost-
effective, and morbidity should be minimal, especially when using autografts. No graft material meets all of
these requirements. Moreover, the studies performed did not compare different types of grafts and biomaterials
and were often single-centre retrospective studies so there is not a single graft that can be recommended for
surgeons [1055]. The use of geometric principles introduced by Egydio may help to determine the exact site of
the incision, and the shape and size of the defect to be grafted [1056].
All the autologous grafts have the inconvenience of possible graft harvesting complications. Dermal grafts are
commonly associated with veno-occlusive ED (20%) due to lack of adaptability, so they have not been used in
contemporary series [1055, 1058-1069]. Vein grafts have the theoretical advantage of endothelial-to-endothelial
contact when grafted to underlying cavernosal tissue. The saphenous vein has been the most commonly used
vein graft [1070-1085]. For some extensive albuginea defects, more than one incision may be needed. Tunica
albuginea grafts have perfect histological properties but have some limitations: the size that can be harvested,
the risk of weakening penile support and making future procedures (penile prosthesis implantation) more
complicated [1086-1088]. Tunica vaginalis is easy to harvest and has little tendency to contract due to its low
metabolic requirements, although better results can be obtained if a vascular flap is used [1089-1093]. Under the
pretext that by placing the submucosal layer on the corpus cavernosum the graft feeds on it and adheres more
quickly, the buccal mucosal graft has recently been used with good short-term results [1094-1100].
Cadaveric dura mater is no longer used due to concerns about the possibility of infection [1101, 1102].
Cadaveric pericardium (Tutoplast©) offers good results by coupling excellent tensile strength and
multidirectional elasticity/expansion by 30% [992, 1054, 1065, 1103, 1104]. Cadaveric or autologous fascia lata
or temporalis fascia offers biological stability and mechanical resistance [1105-1107].
Xenografts have become more popular in recent years. Small intestinal submucosa (SIS), a type I collagen-
based xenogenic graft derived from the submucosal layer of the porcine small intestine, has been shown to
promote tissue-specific regeneration and angiogenesis, and supports host cell migration, differentiation and
growth of endothelial cells, resulting in tissue structurally and functionally similar to the original [1108-1117].
As mentioned above, pericardium (bovine, in this case) has good traction resistance and adaptability, and good
host tolerance [1085, 1118-1121]. Grafting by collagen fleece (TachoSil©) in PD has some major advantages
such as decreased operating times, easy application and an additional haemostatic effect [1122-1127].
It is generally recommended that synthetic grafts, including polyester (Dacron®) and polytetrafluoroethylene
(Gore-Tex®) are avoided, due to increased risks of infection, secondary graft inflammation causing tissue
fibrosis, graft contractures, and possibility of allergic reactions [1024, 1128-1131].
Post-operative penile rehabilitation to improve surgical outcomes has been suggested with a number of
studies describing the use of VED and PTT to prevent penile length loss of up to 1.5 cm [1132]. Daily nocturnal
administration of PDE5I enhances nocturnal erections, encourages perfusion of the graft, and may minimise
post-operative ED rates [1133]. Massages and stretching of the penis have also been recommended once
wound healing is complete.
It must be emphasised that there have been no RCTs comparing surgical outcomes in PD. The risk of ED
seems to be greater for penile lengthening procedures [913]. Recurrent curvature is likely to be the result
of failure to wait until the disease has stabilised before surgery is undertaken, re-activation of the condition
following the development of stable disease, or the use of early re-absorbable sutures (e.g., Vicryl) that lose
their tensile strength before ensuing fibrosis has resulted in acceptable strength of the repair. Accordingly, it is
recommended that only non-absorbable sutures or slowly re-absorbed absorbable sutures (e.g., polydioxanone)
should be used. With non-absorbable sutures, the knot should be buried to avoid troublesome irritation of the
penile skin, but this issue may be alleviated by the use of slowly re-absorbable sutures (e.g., polydioxanone)
[1136]. Penile numbness is a potential risk of any surgical procedure, involving mobilisation of the dorsal
neurovascular bundle. This is usually a temporary neuropraxia, due to bruising of the dorsal sensory nerves.
Given that the usual deformity is a dorsal deformity, the procedure most likely to induce this complication is a
lengthening (grafting) procedure, or the association with (albeit rare) ventral curvature [1013].
Most patients with mild-to-moderate curvature can expect an excellent outcome simply by cylinder insertion
[1083, 1141]. If the intra-operative curvature after placement of the prosthesis is < 30° no further action is
indicated, since the prosthesis itself will act as an internal tissue expander to correct the curvature during the
subsequent 6-9 months. If, the curvature is > 30°, the first-line treatment should be modelling with the prosthesis
maximally inflated (manually bent on the opposite side of the curvature for 90 seconds, often accompanied by
an audible crack) [1142, 1143]. If, after performing this manoeuvre, a deviation > 30° persists, subsequent steps
In selected cases of end-stage PD with ED and significant penile shortening, a lengthening procedure, which
involves simultaneous PP implantation and penile length restoration, such as the “sliding” technique has been
proposed [1152]. However, the “sliding” technique is not recommended due to reported cases of glans necrosis
because of the concomitant release of the neurovascular bundle and urethra, new approaches for these patients
have been recently described, such as the MoST (Modified Sliding Technique), MUST (Multiple-Slit Technique)
or MIT (Multiple-Incision Technique) techniques, but these should only be used by experienced high-volume
surgeons and after full patient counselling [1153-1156].
While patient satisfaction after IPP placement in the general population is high, satisfaction rates have been
found to be significantly lower in those with PD. Despite this, depression rates decreased after surgery in PD
patients (from 19.3%-10.9%) [1157]. The main cause of dissatisfaction after PPI in the general population is
shortening; therefore, patients with PD undergoing PP surgery must be counselled that the prostheses are not
designed to restore the previous penile length [1157, 1158].
8.2.3.2.4 Summary of evidence and recommendations for surgical treatment of Peyronie’s disease
Summary of evidence LE
Surgery for PD should only be offered in patients with stable disease and with functional impairment. 2b
In patients with concomitant PD and ED without response to medical treatment, penile prosthesis 2a
implantation with or without additional straightening manoeuvres is the technique of choice.
In other cases, factors such as penile length, rigidity of erection, degree of curvature, presence 3
of complex deformities and patient choice must be taken into account when deciding whether to
undertake tunical shortening or lengthening procedures.
No ED ED
Response
Yes to ED
treatment
Residual
> 30°
curvature
Manual
modeling
Residual
> 30° < 30°
curvature
Overall, cosmetic surgery has the potential to restore self-esteem, reduce anxiety, social phobia and depressive
mood states regarding body concerns, increasing individuals’ well-being and quality of life (QoL) [1165, 1166].
Yet, some candidates for cosmetic surgery may have psychopathological conditions and surgery may result in
negative outcomes [1166, 1167].
In the real-life setting, it is interesting to note that 84% women report being satisfied with their male partners’
penile size whereas 55% of the male partners were satisfied with their penile size and 45% of them report
that they would like to have a larger penis [1168]. In this context, men with a high level of social-desirability
were more likely than others to self-report having a larger penis [1169]. A recent study also demonstrated that
reducing the depth of penetration led to a statistically significant 18% reduction of overall sexual pleasure with
an average 15% reduction in length of the penis [1170].
Additionally, the subjective impression of penile size may have a negative effect on sexual functioning and QoL,
impacting sexual life in about 10% of men [1171-1173]. This prevalence sharply rises in patients seeking penile
augmentation procedures [1174, 1175].
Furthermore, the fact that a subgroup of men does not achieve reasonable levels of satisfaction and emotional
adjustment after penile augmentation procedures, underlines that with certain psychopathological conditions
men will not benefit from such invasive procedures [1176]. These men may represent a psychologically
vulnerable group of individuals in whom penile augmentation procedures will have negative effects and, as
such, require clinical and psychological support. Clinicians should be adept to anticipate and address such
vulnerability through a tailored psychological evaluation and further consider cultural standards enabling an
understanding of patient expectations [1177].
With the increased use of penile augmentation procedures worldwide, either medical or surgical, it becomes
crucial to create evidence-based recommendations to guide clinicians in this challenging and controversial area.
9.1.2 Definition
To date short penis condition represents both a diagnostic and treatment challenge [1178, 1179]. An accurate
measurement of the penile shaft is a mandatory step in the assessment of patients complaining of a short
penis and defining the norm [1180]. Indeed, a standard tool to address penile measurements and to counsel
patients seeking penile augmentation procedures is needed. To date, the standard penile size has yet to be
clearly defined. Even though several investigators have attempted to provide objective measurements to define
a normal penile size, there is still no consensus on this (Table S9.1 online supplementary evidence Appendix 5).
The other factor that strongly affects penile measurements is the interobserver variability and the
underestimation of the stretched penile length (SPL) when compared to the erect state [1181].
Despite the aforementioned limitations, SPL, defined as the distance between the pubic symphysis
and the apex of the glans, represents the most overlapping measurement of the erect penis. Accordingly, a
SPL of less than 2.5 standard deviations (SD) below the mean for the male’s age and race is considered as
micropenis [1182, 1183].
Table 9.1: Classification of the clinical conditions underlying a short penis condition or dysmorphophobia in
adults
The aetiology underlying the development of AABP is deemed to be related to a chronic inflammatory state of
the penile dartos which leads to a progressive retraction and scarring of the peri-genital teguments [1191, 1192].
The progressive entrapment of the phallus causes a moist environment which facilitates bacterial and fungal
growth causing chronic inflammation [1193]. The ensuing fibrosis results in further entrapment of the penile
shaft in the peri-genital tissue [1192, 1193].
Although the exact prevalence of AABP is unknown, its incidence seems to be increasing along with the
growing prevalence of obesity, which represents the main risk factor [1194]. Other factors contributing to AABP
include aggressive circumcision, following surgical treatment in the obese or penile cancer (PC), or chronic
dermatological conditions such as lichen sclerosis (LS) [1195].
The AABP is commonly associated with erectile and voiding dysfunctions, difficulties in maintaining
adequate genital hygiene and a poor QoL [1195-1197]. A summary of risk factors for AABP and
underlying issues requiring surgery is detailed in Table S9.2 online supplementary evidence Appendix 5
(https://uroweb.org/guidelines/sexual-and-reproductive-health/publications-appendices).
The aim of AABP treatment is to restore the functional genital anatomy and to improve QoL [1195, 1196]. So far,
different authors have proposed a number of classifications for AABP based upon both clinical presentation and
the surgical procedure required [1190, 1198].
Table 9.2: Classification of the clinical conditions underlying intrinsic penile shortness in adults
Amongst the pre-existing clinical entities associated with micropenis, the bladder exstrophy–epispadias
complex (BEEC) is the most studied [1195, 1196, 1201]. It represents a spectrum of genitourinary malformations
ranging in severity from epispadias to bladder exstrophy or exstrophy of the cloaca. It is considered as a rare
disease, with a prevalence at birth of 1/10,000 [1199, 1201, 1203, 1206]. Even though surgical reconstruction
aims to improve body image, this clinical entity is frequently burdened by psychosocial and psychosexual
dysfunctions in the long term [1207-1213]. Additionally, male infertility is frequently associated due to poor
sperm quantity or quality and hormonal impairment [1214].
Traumatic genital injuries may commonly result from traffic accidents and gunshot wounds [1217]. Rarely, a
penile amputation can be the result of circumcision and genital surgical procedures such as hypospadias repair,
penile prosthesis implantation or urethroplasty, and may result in a decrease in penile length [1218-1222].
Among chronic causes of penile shortening, PD, treatments for prostate cancer, particularly radical
prostatectomy (RP) and radical cystectomy represent the most common [1174, 1215, 1216, 1223-1231].
These psychopathological entities must be differentiated from Gender Dysphoria, i.e., the clinical distress
associated with the incongruence between gender identity and the gender assigned at birth; and from Koro, i.e.,
sudden anxiety about the penis falling back into the abdomen [1232].
Summary of evidence LE
Male genital malformations represent a rare clinical entity with an overall prevalence between 0.9% and 3
2.1%.
Obesity, lichen sclerosis and penile cancer treatment are risk factors for AABP. 4
Adult acquired buried penis is commonly associated with erectile and voiding dysfunctions, difficulties 3
in maintaining adequate genital hygiene and a poor quality of life.
Adult acquired buried penis condition can be staged upon both clinical presentation and the surgical 3
procedure required according to available classification systems.
Bladder exstrophy–epispadias complex (BEEC) is a rare clinical condition frequently associated with 2b
male genital malformations, particularly micropenis.
Penile traumatic or surgical amputation due to penile cancer are the most common acute causes of 3
intrinsic penile shortening.
The most frequent aetiologies leading to a chronic intrinsic penile shortening are PD, treatments for 2b
prostate cancer (RP, radiation therapy and androgen-deprivation therapy) and radical cystectomy.
Body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) is a clinical entity associated with a significant distress or impairment 2b
in important areas of the individual’s life.
Penile Dysmorphic Disorder (PDD) can be used as a shorthand concept to describe BDD patients 4
mainly focused on penile size/shape.
Body dysmorphic disorder/PDD can be revealed in patients requiring cosmetic surgery. 3
9.2 Diagnosis
9.2.1 Medical history, physical examination and psychological assessment
9.2.1.1 Medical History
The first step in the evaluation of short penis is a detailed medical history [1237]. Common causes of penile
shortness should be screened and observed (e.g., history of phimosis, priapism, hypospadias/epispadias, penile
trauma, penile cancer, prostate cancer, penile pain with or without acquired penile curvature suggestive of PD). A
past or present diagnosis of BDD should also be noted.
Moreover, penile girth should be noted in every patient. As for girth, both distal (coronal) and mid-shaft
measurements should be recorded. Furthermore, both measures of circumference can be compared to the
head-to-base ratio. The former can help classify penile shape which can be documented through photography
[1243]. Although used as a surrogate, STT clearly underestimates erect penile length by about 20% [918,
1244]. Nonetheless, it is important to note that BTT seems to have a better correlation with erect penile length,
especially in overweight and obese men [918].
Length
State
Erect, stretched or flaccid
Anatomic Landmarks
Dorsal and/or ventrally from the penopubic skin junction-to-glans tip (STT)
Dorsally from the pubic bone-to-glans tip (BTT)
Girth
State
Erect or flaccid
Anatomic Landmarks
Proximal (penopubic skin junction)
Middle shaft
Distal (Coronal or subcoronal)
Shape
Head-to-base ratio
Standardised photography
Other well-known self-reported psychosexual questionnaires may be considered: the IIEF-15 and the Male
Sexual Health Questionnaire (MSHQ) should be administered to record baseline sexual function status and can
also be used to assess its changes after treatment; the Erectile Dysfunction Inventory of Treatment Satisfaction
(EDITS) can also be helpful to assess patient and partner's treatment satisfaction [315, 1251, 1252].
9.2.2 Imaging
There is a lack of evidence regarding the use of imaging techniques in the assessment of patients complaining
about penile shortness. Although a penile Doppler ultrasound or a penile magnetic resonance imaging may
provide additional data regarding the penile anatomy and the extent of penile burying, there is no evidence that
this additional information could contribute to the physical examination to justify its routine use in this clinical
scenario [1180, 1253-1256].
9.3 Management
9.3.1 Non-surgical Treatments
9.3.1.1 Psychotherapy
Penile augmentation is often motivated by the desire to improve self-perception and self-esteem [1257].
Cosmetic treatments may help increase individuals’ well-being and QoL, improving self-esteem and emotional
states [1165, 1166, 1180]. Still, psychotherapy is recommended when psychopathological comorbidities are
detected, or when aversive relationship dynamics may underly the request for penile augmentation. Addressing
patients’ and partners’ motivations and expectations regarding penile augmentation seems to be a key
psychotherapeutic target while no other empirical evidence is described. Similarly, men with BDD and SPA
present a significant discrepancy between the perceived and ideal size of the penis, internalising the belief
they should have a larger penis [1258]. Cognitive behaviour therapy for BDD could be applied to cases of
anxiety regarding penis size, although no clinical trials have been reported [1259]. In all, it is worth noting
that psychotherapy should normalise the great variability of genital shape and size [1175]. Managing patient
expectations could be a means to improve results and well-being associated with the surgery process.
Overall, PTT seems effective in lengthening the penis both in the flaccid and stretched state with minimal side
effects. Yet it is not effective for penile girth enhancement. However, the quality of evidence is poor due to the
lack of RCTs, and the availability of only heterogenous and small cohorts PTT has also been proven effective in
the restoration of length or correction of deformities due to several diseases, including PD, or post-RP conditions
[526, 997, 1263, 1264].
Author (year) n Study Device Treatment protocol Mean age Mean gain in penile
design ± SD dimensions cm (SD)
Nowroozi 54 Prospective AndroPenis 4-6 hours per day for 6 30.1 ± 4.8 Flaccid length: 1.7 ± 0.8
et al. [1265] months Stretched length: 1.3 ± 0.4
Erected length: 1.2 ± 0.4
Nikoobakht et 23 Prospective Golden Erect 4–6 hours per day during 26.5 ± 8.1 Flaccid length: 1.7
al. [1262] the first 2 weeks and then 9 Stretched length: 1.71
hours per day until the end of Circumference: -0.22
the third month Glans penis
circumference: -0.35
Gontero et al. 21 Prospective Golden Erect at least 4 h/day for 6 months 45.7 ± 11.1 Flaccid length: 2.3
[1261] Stretched length: 1.7
Circumference: NR
NR = not reported.
9.3.1.5 Summary of evidence and recommendations for the non-surgical management of short penile size
Summary of evidence LE
Psychotherapy should not be undertaken in the realm of preventing individuals’ legitimate choice 3
to improve their lives. Conversely, psychotherapy is recommended when psychopathological
comorbidities are detected, or when aversive relationship dynamics may underlie the request for penile
augmentation.
Cognitive behaviour therapy for BDD could be applied to cases of anxiety regarding penis size. 3
Penile traction therapy proved to be an effective treatment to achieve penile lengthening. 3
Vacuum erection devices proved to be an ineffective treatment in achieving penile lengthening. 3
Testosterone therapy, transdermal dihydrotestosterone and recombinant gonadotropins can restore 2b
penile size in boys with micropenis or disorders of sex development.
Testosterone therapy does not increase penile size in adult men and in men with late-onset 3
hypogonadism.
The purpose of any surgical approach is to unbury the penile shaft, reconstruct genital teguments and eventually
remove peri-genital or excess abdominal tissue in order to reduce the risk of recurrence. The goal is to balance
an effective surgical procedure aiming to improve patient QoL, while minimising the incidence of postoperative
complications. Lifestyle changes and risk factors modification, particularly weight loss, are widely considered
as a proactive approach to minimise AABP surgical complications and should be encouraged before surgical
intervention is undertaken. The broad spectrum of surgical interventions described to manage AABP is
summarised in Table S9.3 in online supplementary evidence Appendix 5.
The current evidence highlights the efficacy of AABP surgical treatment which has a low incidence of recurrence
and satisfactory functional outcomes, as shown in Table S9.4 in online supplementary evidence Appendix 5,
yet there is a significant incidence of post-operative complications (up to 3.5% of grade V according to Clavien-
Dindo Classification) [1276].
The current evidence highlights the efficacy of AABP surgical treatment which has a low incidence of recurrence
and satisfactory functional outcomes, as shown in Table 26, yet there is a significant incidence of post-operative
complications (up to 3.5% of grade V according to Clavien-Dindo Classification) [1277].
Summary of evidence LE
Various surgical procedures may be considered to restore genital anatomy in AABP patients. 3
Adult acquired buried penis surgery is burdened by a significant incidence of postoperative 3
complications.
Lifestyle changes and risk factors modification, particularly weight loss, are widely considered as a 4
proactive approach to minimise AABP surgical complications.
Adult acquired buried penis surgery may provide satisfactory functional outcomes with a low incidence 3
of recurrence.
Littara et al., conducted penile elongation in 21 patients, enlargement in 33 and combined elongation and
enlargement in 301, respectively [1279]. The technique was based on penile lipofilling combined with V-Y
infrapubic skin plasty and SLR. At 12 months following the surgical procedure, length at rest significantly
increased from 8.8 cm to 11.4 cm, SPL significantly increased from 12.4 cm to 13.5 cm and circumference at
rest significantly increased from 8.3 cm to 11.06 cm. The IIEF-5 also increased from 21.5 to 23. The outcomes
of SLR are summarized in Table S9.5 online supplementary evidence Appendix 5.
Ghanem et al., performed liposuction in ten patients using a 50-cc syringe with a 3- and 6-mm liposuction
needle [1281]. The amount of fat removed ranged from 325 to 850 mL with a mean of 495.50 ± 155.39 mL.
Three (30%) of the patients were very satisfied with the post-operative result, five (50%) patients were satisfied,
one patient (10%) was neither satisfied nor dissatisfied, and one (10%) patient was dissatisfied. No patients
were very dissatisfied. Shaeer’s monsplasty technique was investigated in 20 patients [1282]. At 3 months
post-operatively, the flaccid visible length was 7.1 ± 2.1cm, with a 57.9% improvement in length, and erect
visible length was 11.8 ± 2.1cm, with a 32% improvement in length. At final follow-up (18 months) a 73.1%
improvement in satisfaction rate was detected.
Lumen et al., treated seven male patients (aged 15 to 42 years) with phalloplasty (6 with radial forearm
free flap and 1 with anterolateral thigh flap) and implant surgery was offered approximately 1 year after the
phallic reconstruction [1283]. There were no complications after surgical formation of the neophallus. Two
complications were reported in the early post-operative period. Two patients developed urinary complications
(stricture and/or fistula). Patient satisfaction after surgery was high in six cases and moderate in one case. Four
patients underwent penile implant surgery and 50% were subsequently removed.
Perovic et al., conducted TPR using musculocutaneous latissimus dorsi (MLD) in 12 patients [1284]. The mean
(range) follow-up was 31 (6–74) months, and the penile size was 16 (14–18) cm long and 13 (11–15) cm in
circumference. There was no flap loss or partial skin necrosis.
Garaffa et al., reported a series of TPR using the radial artery forearm free flap in 16 patients with bladder/
cloacal exstrophy and micropenis-epispadias complex [1285]. In one patient the distal third of the phallus
was lost due to acute thrombosis of the arterial anastomosis immediately post-operatively. Almost all (93%)
were fully satisfied in terms of cosmesis and size. Urethral stricture and fistula were the most common
complications, which developed only at the native neourethral anastomosis. They were successfully managed
by revision surgery. Sexual intercourse was achieved in 11 of the 12 patients who underwent PPI.
Summary of evidence LE
Considering the wide spectrum and the complexity of surgical interventions aimed to address penile 4
shortness, this surgery should be reserved to high volume centres.
Suspensory ligament release, ventral phalloplasty and suprapubic lipoplasty/liposuction/lipectomy 3
provide an objective increase in penile length.
Suspensory ligament release, ventral phalloplasty and suprapubic lipoplasty/liposuction/lipectomy are 3
associated with a significant incidence of complications.
Total phallic reconstruction provides satisfactory surgical and functional outcomes in men with 3
micropenis.
Some authors have evaluated the erect penile length following PPI. In a prospective study where patients
with PD were excluded, erect penile length was compared from baseline achieved by intracavernosal injection
and after PPI inflation. The authors demonstrated that there were 0.83 ± 0.25, 0.75 ± 0.20 and 0.74 ± 0.15 cm
decreases in erect penile length 6 weeks, 6 months, and one year post-operatively, respectively [1288]. A study
where patients with PD were excluded confirmed these results as the median pre-operative pharmacologically
induced length (14.25 ± 2 cm) was decreased to median post-prosthesis penile length (13.5 ± 2.13 cm) [1289].
9.3.2.3.5 Summary of evidence and recommendations for surgical treatment of acquired penile shortness
Summary of evidence LE
Penile prosthesis implantation is not effective in increasing penile length. 3
The evidence for the use of penile disassembly manoeuvres and the sliding technique are limited. 3
Total phallic reconstruction yields to satisfactory outcomes despite the high incidence of post- 3
operative complications.
Polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA)
Polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) microspheres have been injected as a wrinkle filler. An average increase in
penile circumference of 3.5 cm was reported in two studies using PMMA for penile girth enhancement [1302,
1303]. The authors reported that post-operative swelling and inflammatory reaction resolved within a few days
and no pattern of PMMA microspheres migration to neighbouring regions was seen.
Poly-l-lactic acid
Poly-l-lactic acid (PLA) is another widely used soft tissue filler. Poly-l-lactic acid has enhanced effects by
stimulating fibroblast proliferation and increasing collagen deposition in tissue. An average increase of 1.2 to
2.4 cm has been reported in the penile girth with PLA injection. No complications other than temporary local
pain and swelling were reported in the treated patients [1298, 1304].
In a study of 69 patients using the porcine dermal acellular matrix graft (InteXen; American Medical Systems,
Minnetonka, MN, USA) a 3.2 cm increase in flaccid state and 2.4 cm in erect state was reported at one year
following surgery. The procedure was performed with an infrapubic incision, and 68 of 69 patients reported
significant satisfaction using the Augmentation Phalloplasty Patient Selection and Satisfaction Inventory. Graft
fibrosis has been observed in up to 13% of patients, and a mean reduction in penile length of 0.5 cm has been
reported in patients with fibrosis [1317].
Techniques using venous grafts for penile girth enhancement have also been described [1318]. Initial results are
encouraging, but better designed RCTs are needed.
Dermal fat grafts are free only grafts composed of deepithelialized dermis and subcutaneous fat. An area of
approximately 10 x 5 cm is required for graft harvesting. An increase in penile girth of 1.67 to 2.3 cm has been
reported in studies with the dermal fat graft technique. Penile oedema up to 27%, painful erection up to 27%,
and curvature due to graft fibrosis up to 9% have been reported. Side effects such as penile hypoesthesia, skin
necrosis, and infection were not reported [1250, 1319, 1320].
Summary of evidence LE
Various surgical approaches with specific outcomes and complications have been considered to 3
address penile girth enhancement, with limited benefit.
Hyaluronic acid (HA), Poly-l-lactic acid (PLA), hydroxyethyl methacrylate, polyalkylamide hydrogel 3
(PAAG), polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA), calcium hydroxyapatite are used as injectable materials for
penile girth enhancement.
Patient satisfaction with soft tissue fillers (especially HA, PMMA and PLA) is high (> 78%). 3
No complications other than temporary local pain and swelling were reported in patients treated with 3
soft tissue fillers.
Using silicone, paraffin and petroleum jelly (Vaseline) in penile girth enhancement causes a range of 3
complications ranging from oedema up to infection to Fournier’s gangrene.
Not enough long-term data are available on autologous fat injection for penile girth enhancement. 4
Not enough long-term data are available on grafting procedures (dermal acellular matrix graft, venous 4
grafts or dermal fat grafts).
Grafting procedures are associated with high complication rate and low rate of patient’s satisfaction. 3
Not enough long term data are available on biodegradable scaffolds and subcutaneous penile implant 4
(Penuma®) .
* Penile length should be measured stretched both from the penopubic skin junction-to-glans tip (STT) and from
the pubic bone-to-glans tip (BTT).
* Penile length should be measured stretched both from penopubic skin junction-to-glans tip (STT) and from the
pubic bone-to-glans tip (BTT).
# There is lack of evidence to recommend one treatment over another.
** Hyaluronic acid (HA), poly-l-lactic acid (PLA), hydroxyethyl methacrylate, polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA),
polyalkylamide hydrogel (PAAG) and calcium hydroxyapatite are considered as injectable materials for penile
girth enhancement. Although the level of evidence is low, there is more evidence for HA, PLA and PMMA. Do not
use silicone, paraffin or Vaseline (Strong evidence against).
Strength of recommendations is depicted between brackets where appropriate.
9.3.2.5 Functional outcomes: sexual function, sensitivity, impact on quality of life and emotional adjustment
Cosmetic treatments, including surgery, help to restore self-esteem, reduce anxiety, social phobia, and
depressive mood states regarding body concerns, increasing individuals’ well-being and QoL [1165, 1166].
Therefore, we can expect men with genuine short penis to use available resources to adjust the length or girth
of their penis as a mean to improve their sense of identity and fit cultural standards regarding penile size and
function. Currently, the results of penile augmentation techniques seem mixed. The use of fillers resulted in
improved genital self-image and self-esteem, lower PDD symptoms, but no effects were found regarding self-
confidence or sexual relationship satisfaction [1257]. Likewise, penile lengthening or girth enhancement surgery
seem to result in poor satisfaction, poor erectile function and sensitivity in men with normal penis size [1176].
Despite those negative outcomes, cases of increased satisfaction have been registered [1326]. Male genital
self-image has been related to IIEF domains: sexual desire, orgasmic and erectile function, intercourse and
overall satisfaction [1247]. Similarly, perceived penis size seems to predict erectile function more than objective
size [1172]. In addition, reduced penetrative and receptive oral sex are associated with men’s dissatisfaction
regarding their penis [1327]. For these reasons, more efforts should be made in order to clarify the impact of
penile augmentation treatments on men’s and partners’ well-being and QoL. As for men with BDD, they have
shown reduced erectile and orgasmic function, as well as less intercourse satisfaction as compared with
10. PRIAPISM
Priapism is a persistent or prolonged erection in the absence of sexual stimulation that fails to subside. It can
be divided into ischaemic, non-ischaemic and stuttering priapism. The guidelines are based on three systematic
reviews addressing the medical and surgical management of ischaemic and non-ischaemic priapism and the
overall management of priapism related to sickle cell disease [1329-1331].
Ischaemic priapism that lasts beyond 4 hours is similar to a compartment syndrome and characterised by the
development of ischaemia within the closed space of the corpora cavernosa, which severely compromises
the cavernosal circulation. Emergency medical intervention is required to minimise irreversible consequences,
such as smooth muscle necrosis, corporal fibrosis and the development of permanent erectile dysfunction
(ED) [1336, 1337]. The duration of ischaemic priapism represents the most significant predictor for irreversible
consequences, thus including ED. In this context, interventions beyond 48-72 hours of onset may help to relieve
the erection and pain, but have little clinical benefit in preventing long-term ED [1338].
No specific pathophysiological causes of ischaemic priapism can be identified in most cases [1332, 1339],
although the common aetiological factors include sickle cell disease (SCD), haematological dyscrasias,
neoplastic syndromes, and several pharmacological agents (e.g., intracavernosal PGE1 therapy) (Table 10.1).
Ischaemic priapism may occur (0.4-35%) after intracavernosal injection of erectogenic agents [1332, 1336,
1340-1342]. The risk is higher with papaverine-based combinations [1343], while the risk of priapism is < 1%
following prostaglandin E1 injection [1344].
Second-generation antipsychotics (33.8%), other medications (11.3%), and alpha-adrenergic antagonists (8.8%)
accounted for the greatest percentage of published drug-induced priapism cases [1345]. Isolated cases of
priapism have been described in men who have taken PDE5Is [1332]. Data from the FDA Adverse Reporting
System Public Dashboard showed that PDE5Is-induced priapism accounted for only 2.9% of drug-induced
priapism. However, most of these men also had other risk factors for priapism, and it is unclear whether PDE5Is
per se can cause ischaemic priapism [1332, 1346]. Since most men who experience priapism following PDE5I
treatment have additional risk factors for ischaemic priapism, PDE5Is use is usually not regarded as a risk factor
in itself. In terms of haemoglobinopathies, SCD is the most common cause of priapism in childhood, accounting
for 63% of cases. It is the primary aetiology in 23% of adult cases [1344].
Mechanisms of SCD-associated priapism may involve derangements of several signalling pathways in the penis
[1347]. Contrary to traditional belief, maintenance of physiological testosterone levels does not cause priapism,
but rather preserves penile homeostasis and promotes normal erectile function [1348, 1349]. Testosterone
deficiency is considered a controversial risk factor: it is prevalent in patients with SCD, but recent evidence
indicates that it may not be a risk factor for priapism [1350].
Partial priapism, or idiopathic partial segmental thrombosis of the corpus cavemosum, is a rare condition. It
is often classified as a subtype of priapism limited to a single crura without ischaemia, but rather a thrombus
is present within the corpus cavernosum. Its aetiology is unknown, but bicycle riding, trauma, drug use, sexual
intercourse, haematological diseases and α-blocker intake have all been associated with partial segmental
thrombosis [1353]. The presence of a congenital web within the corpora is also a risk factor [1354].
Idiopathic
-
Haematological dyscrasias, vascular and other disorders
• SCD
• thalassemia
• leukaemia
• multiple myeloma
• haemoglobin Olmsted variant
• fat emboli during hyperalimentation
• haemodialysis
• glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency
• factor V Leiden mutation
• vessel vasculitis
• (e.g., Henoch-Schönlein purpura; Behçet's disease; anti-phospholipid antibodies syndrome)
Infections (toxin-mediated)
• scorpion sting
• spider bite
• rabies
Metabolic disorders
• amyloidosis
• Fabry’s disease
• gout
Neurogenic disorders
• syphilis
• spinal cord injury
• cauda equina
• syndrome
• autonomic neuropathy
• lumbar disc herniation
• spinal stenosis
• cerebrovascular accident
• brain tumour
• spinal anaesthesia
Neoplasms (metastatic or regional infiltration)
• prostate
• urethra
• testis
• bladder
• rectal
• lung, kidney
10.1.1.1 Summary of evidence on the epidemiology, aetiology and pathophysiology of ischaemic priapism
Summary of evidence LE
Ischaemic priapism is the most common type, accounting for more than 95% of all cases. 1b
Ischaemic priapism is identified as idiopathic in most patients, while sickle cell disease is the most 1b
common cause in childhood.
Ischaemic priapism occurs relatively often (about 5%) after intracavernous injections of papaverine- 2a
based combinations, while it is rare (< 1%) after prostaglandin E1 monotherapy.
Priapism is rare in men who have taken PDE5Is, with only sporadic cases reported. 4
Table 10.2: Key findings in priapism (adapted from Broderick et al. [1332])
Ultrasound of the penis should be performed before corporal blood aspiration in ischaemic priapism to prevent
aberrant blood flow which can mimic a non-ischaemic or reperfusion picture after intervention for low-flow
priapism [1362].
Penile MRI can be used in the diagnostic evaluation of priapism and may be helpful in selected cases of
ischaemic priapism to assess the viability of the corpora cavernosa and the presence of penile fibrosis. In cases
of refractory priapism or delayed presentation (> 48 hours), smooth muscle viability can be indirectly assessed.
In a prospective study of 38 patients with ischaemic priapism, the sensitivity of MRI in predicting non-viable
smooth muscle was 100%, when correlated with corpus cavernosum biopsies [1362]. All patients with viable
smooth muscle on MRI maintained erectile function on clinical follow-up with the non-viable group being offered
early prosthesis.
Table 10.3: Typical blood gas values (adapted from Broderick et al. [1332])
Prolonged erecon
For > 4 hours
Ischaemic Non-ischaemic
priapism priapism
Penile Penile
Penile Penile
History blood gas History blood gas
Doppler US Doppler US
analysis analysis
Normal arterial
Perineal or
Dark blood; Bright red flow and
Sluggish or penile trauma;
Painful, rigid hypoxia, blood; may show
non-existent painless,
erecon hypercapnia arterial blood turbulent flow
blood flow fluctuang
andacidosis gas values at the site of
erecon
a fistula
10.1.2.5 Summary of evidence and recommendations for the diagnosis of ischaemic priapism
Summary of evidence LE
Medical history including the assessment of known haematological abnormalities (e.g., SCD), history of 3
pelvic/perineal/genital trauma, prior drug treatment or recreational drug use is essential to identify the
possible etiology and the type of priapism.
Blood gas analysis performed before blood aspiration from the corpora is able to differentiate between 3
ischaemic and non-ischaemic priapism. Full blood count and haemoglobinopathy screen could reveal
haematological alterations.
Penile Colour Doppler US can differentiate from ischaemic and non-ischaemic priapism when 3
performed before corporal blood aspiration.
Penile MRI is able to predict non-viable smooth muscle in patients with ischaemic priapism. 3
Historically, several first-line treatments have been described including exercise, ejaculation, ice packs, cold
baths, and cold water enemas [1332]. However, there is limited evidence for the benefit of these measures and
they may even exacerbate the condition in SCD patients. Success rates for these conservative measures alone
have rarely been reported. In a small series, cold water enemas have been reported to induce detumescence in
six out of ten cases [1363]. In another study 24.5% of 122 patients achieved detumescence following priapic
episodes lasting for more than 6 hours by cooling of the penis and perineum, and walking upstairs [1364].
Some clinicians advocate using two angiocatheters or butterfly needles at the same time to accelerate drainage,
as well as aspirating and irrigating simultaneously with a saline solution [1364]. Aspiration should be continued
until bright red, oxygenated blood is aspirated.
Several case series have reported outcomes for first-line treatments; however, although in most cases,
aspiration and irrigation were combined with intracavernosal injection of sympathomimetic agents [1330], thus
making it difficult to draw conclusions about the success rate of aspiration + irrigation
alone [1330]. Overall, case series and retrospective studies reported a success rate ranging from 0 to 100%
of cases [1330]. In a RCT, 70 patients with ischaemic priapism lasting more than 6 hours secondary to
intracavernosal injection and were treated with aspiration plus saline irrigation at different temperatures [1364].
The study reported an 85% success rate with the optimum results achieved using a 10°C saline infusion after
blood aspiration.
There are insufficient data to determine whether aspiration followed by saline intracorporeal irrigation is more
effective than aspiration alone.
The potential treatment-related adverse effects of intracavernous phenylephrine (and other sympathomimetic
agents) include headache, dizziness, hypertension, reflex bradycardia, tachycardia and palpitations and
sporadic subarachnoid haemorrhage [368]. Monitoring of blood pressure and pulse should be performed during
intracavernous administration of sympathomimetic agents. As intracavernous sympathomimetic agents can
cause hypertension, the Guidelines Panel is of the opinion that these agents are contraindicated in patients
with malignant or poorly controlled hypertension, as there are case reports of significant cardiovascular and
neurological complications following the use of these pharmacological agents for priapism [1368, 1376, 1377].
Similarly, there are data suggesting that sympathomimetic agents cause a hypertensive crisis when given with
monoamine oxidase inhibitors, hence these medications should not be used together [1378].
• Phenylephrine
Phenylephrine is a selective α-1-adrenergic receptor agonist that has been observed in small case series to be
effective at producing detumescence in priapism, when given as an intracavernosal injection, with few adverse
effects [1373, 1379]. Phenylephrine is the recommended adrenergic agonist drug of choice due to its high
selectivity for the α-1-adrenergic receptor, without concomitant β-mediated inotropic and chronotropic cardiac
effects [1367, 1371, 1372].
Phenylephrine has potential cardiovascular adverse effects [1332, 1365, 1367, 1368, 1371, 1372] and it is
recommended that blood pressure and pulse are monitored every fifteen minutes for 1 hour after injection. This
is particularly important in older men with pre-existing cardiovascular diseases. After injection, the puncture site
should be compressed and the corpus cavernosum massaged to facilitate drug distribution.
• Etilephrine
Etilephrine is also an adrenergic agonist that directly stimulates both and adrenergic receptors [1366]. Most
of the literature describing the use of etilephrine for treatment of priapism is related to men with SCD but there
are small retrospective case series that have reported its benefits for priapism secondary to iatrogenic causes
[1380, 1381]. Etilephrine is the second most widely used sympathomimetic agent [1368].
• Methylene blue
Methylene blue is a guanylate cyclase inhibitor, that may be a potential inhibitor of endothelial-mediated
cavernous smooth muscle relaxation. Small retrospective case series have reported its successful use for
treating short-term pharmacologically-induced priapism [1382, 1383]. Treatment-related adverse effects include
a transient burning sensation and blue discolouration of the penis.
• Adrenaline
Adrenaline produces both -adrenergic receptor agonist and -adrenergic receptor activity. Intracavernosal
adrenaline has been used in patients with ischaemic priapism due to an intracavernous injection of vasoactive
agents. The limited literature [1375, 1384] suggests that adrenaline can achieve detumescence in short-term
priapism, with one small case series reporting a success rate of over 50% after a single injection, with an overall
success rate of 95% with repeated injections [1375, 1384].
Urgent intervention is essential and the general approach is similar to that described for other cases of
ischaemic priapism and should be co-ordinated with a haematologist [1390-1392].
However, as with other haematological disorders, other therapeutic interventions may also need to be
implemented [1390, 1392, 1393]. Specific measures for SCD-related priapism include intravenous hydration and
narcotic analgesia while preparing the patient for aspiration and irrigation. Additionally, supplemental oxygen
administration and alkalinisation with bicarbonate can be helpful [1347, 1391].
Haemoglobin S (HbS) percentage should be measured in all SCD patients with acute priapism. Exchange
blood transfusion has also been proposed, with the aim of increasing tissue delivery of oxygen [1394]. The
transfused blood should be sickle cell haemoglobin negative and Rh and Kell antigen matched [1395]; however,
the evidence is inconclusive as to whether exchange transfusion itself helps to resolve priapism. A systematic
review reported that the mean time to detumescence was eleven days with exchange transfusions compared to
eight days with conventional treatment. Moreover, there were 9 cases of ASPEN syndrome (association of SCD,
priapism, exchange transfusion and neurological events) as a consequence of blood transfusion [1396].
A series of 10 patients with SCD-related priapism showed that it was safe to perform exchange transfusion
[1394]; however, several reports suggest that exchange transfusion may result in serious neurological sequelae
[1396]. Therefore, routine use of exchange transfusion is not recommended as a primary treatment intervention
in this group unless there is a risk of SCD-related symptoms. However, in patients who failed medical
management, transfusion may be required to enable general anaesthesia to be safely administered prior to
definitive surgery [1397].
A number of clinical indicators suggest failure of first-line treatment including continuing corporal rigidity,
cavernosal acidosis, anoxia, severe glucopenia, absence of cavernosal artery inflow by penile colour duplex US,
and elevated intracorporal pressure [1398].
The type of shunt procedure is chosen according to the surgeon’s preference and familiarity with the procedure.
It is conventional practice for distal shunt procedures to be tried before considering proximal shunting.
It is important to assess the success of surgery by direct observation of penile rigidity or by repeated testing
(e.g., cavernous blood gas testing) [1332, 1365, 1400, 1401]. The use of penile colour US may not give
appropriate information because of the hyperaemic (reperfusion) period that follows decompression after the
ischaemic state [1402].
The recovery rates of erectile function in men undergoing shunt surgery following prolonged episodes of
priapism are low and are directly related to the duration of priapism, pre-operative erectile status and age
[1400, 1401, 1403]. If ischaemic priapism resolves within 24 hours of onset, it has been reported that 78-100%
of patients regain spontaneous functional erections (with or without PDE5Is use). In contrast, other studies
have shown that priapism for more than 36-48 hours appears to result in both structural and functional effects
on corporal smooth muscle, with poorer outcomes (ED > 90%) [1400, 1404]. In general, shunt procedures
undertaken after this time period (36-48 hours) may only serve to limit pain without any beneficial effects on
erectile function and early penile prosthesis insertion can be considered [1338, 1405].
Procedures for shunting require incision through the tunica albuginea and expose collagen to coagulation
factors in the penile blood and thus activate the blood-clotting cascade. Peri-operative anti-coagulation is
advocated to facilitate resolution of the priapism. There was an 84% decrease in priapism recurrence in the
shunt group that received peri-procedural anti-thrombotic treatment (325 mg acetylsalicylic acid pre-operatively,
and 5000 IU intraoperative heparin, 81 mg acetylsalicylic acid and 75 mg clopidogrel post-operatively for 5 days)
compared with the group that did not receive peri-procedural anti-thrombotic treatment after failed aspiration
[1406].
Four categories of shunt procedures have been reported [1332, 1366, 1399, 1405]. The limited data available
does not allow one procedure to be recommended over another. However, distal shunts are less invasive
and associated with lower rates of post-operative ED and therefore are recommended as the first surgical
intervention of choice (Appendix 6 online supplementary evidence Table S10.1).
Ebbehoj’s technique involves making multiple tunical incision windows between the glans and each tip of the
corpus cavernosum by means of a size 11 blade scalpel passed several times percutaneously [1332, 1366,
1402, 1409, 1410].
Burnett’s technique (Snake manoeuvre) is a modification of the Al-Ghorab corpora-glanular shunt. It involves
retrograde insertion of a 7/8 Hegar dilator into the distal end of each corpus cavernosum through the original
Al-Ghorab glandular excision. After removal of the dilator from the corpus cavernosum, blood evacuation
is facilitated by manual compression of the penis sequentially from a proximal to distal direction. After
detumescence, the glans penis is closed as in the Al-Ghorab procedure [1332, 1366, 1402, 1415, 1416]. Reported
complications include wound infection, penile skin necrosis and urethrocutaneous fistulae [1416].
• Peno-scrotal decompression
More recently a proximal decompression technique with the aim to spare the glans with high success rates
has been described. The technique is based upon opening of the proximal corpus cavernosum combined with
proximal and distal tunnelling using a suction tip [1418]. In a cohort of 25 patients, 12 had undergone previous
corpora-glanular shunt surgery. Recurrence was observed in two of 25 patients with unilateral peno-scrotal
decompression. In the 15 patients who had follow-up data, 40% had ED. Whilst, representing a promising
technique, PSD in cases of refractory priapism may further delay penile prosthesis insertion with potential
detrimental effects on surgical outcomes including penile shortening and prosthetic infection.
• Vein anastomoses/shunts
Grayhack’s procedure mobilises the saphenous vein below the junction of the femoral vein and anastomoses the
vein end-to-side onto the corpus cavernosum. Venous shunts may be complicated by saphenofemoral thrombus
formation and by pulmonary embolism [1332, 1366, 1419-1421].
Refractory, therapy-resistant, acute ischaemic priapism or episodes lasting more than 48 hours usually result
in complete ED, and possibly significant penile deformity in the long-term. In these cases, immediate penile
prosthesis implantation surgery is advocated [1422-1425].
Gadolinium-enhanced penile MRI [1362] and cavernosal smooth muscle biopsy have been used to diagnose
smooth muscle necrosis (which, if present, would suggest that shunting is likely to fail) and may help in
decision-making and patient counselling in cases of refractory or delayed presentation (> 48 hours) that may be
considered for immediate penile prosthesis insertion.
The decision on which type of implant to insert is dependent on patient suitability, surgeons’ experience,
and availability and cost of the equipment. The immediate insertion of a malleable penile prosthesis is
recommended to avoid the difficulty and complications of delayed prosthetic surgery in the presence of corporal
fibrosis.
There are no randomised trials comparing the efficacy and complication rates of malleable and inflatable penile
prostheses. Despite the higher infection rate in priapism patients compared to those with virgin prosthesis, in
patients who are well-motivated and counselled prior to the procedure, immediate inflatable penile prosthesis
implantation may be undertaken, although in most cases a semi-rigid implant is more suitable as it is easier to
implant and reduces operative time and hence the risk of prosthetic infection. A further issue with immediate
insertion of an inflatable penile prosthesis is that the patient must begin cycling the device immediately to
avoid a fibrous capsule forming and contracting. Early cycling of an inflatable penile prosthesis prevents penile
curvature and shortening [1338].
Currently, there are no clear indications for immediately implanting a penile prosthesis in men with acute
ischaemic priapism, although this can be considered in men with delayed or refractory priapism [1365].
The optimal time for implantation is within the first three weeks from the priapism episode [1338, 1398, 1427].
If shunt surgery has been performed, penile prosthesis implantation can be further delayed in order to allow
reduction of oedema, wound healing and risk of prosthetic infection. A vacuum device to avoid fibrosis and
penile shortening may be used during this waiting period [1428].
Penile prosthesis implantation is occasionally indicated in SCD patients with severe ED because other
therapeutic options, such as PDE5Is and intracavernous injections are avoided as they may provoke a further
priapism event [1332, 1365]. In severe corporal fibrosis, narrow-based prosthetic devices are preferable because
they are easier to insert and need less dilatation [1422]. After severe priapism that has resulted in penile
destruction with complicated deformities or even loss of penile tissue, it may be necessary to make changes
to the surgical technique. Multiple corporotomies, corporal excavation, optical corporotomy-Shaeer technique,
dilatation with Carrion-Rosello cavernotome, Uramix or Mooreville cavernotome, excision of scar tissue, and use
of small-diameter prosthesis, or penile reconstruction using grafts can be utilised, if concomitant prosthesis
implantation is considered [1404, 1432].
Cavernosal irrigaon
• Irrigate with 0.90% w/v saline soluon
Intracavernosal therapy
• Inject intracavernosal adrenoceptor agonist
• Current first-line therapy is phenylephrine* with aliquots of 200 µg being injected every 3-5 minutes
unl detumescence is achieved (maximum dose of phenylephrine is 1mg within 1 hour) *
Surgical therapy
• Surgical shunng
• Consider primary penile implantaon if priapism has been present for more than 48 hours
(*) Dose of phenylephrine should be reduced in children. It can result in significant hypertension and should be
used with caution in men with cardiovascular disease. Monitoring of pulse and blood pressure is advisable in all
patients during administration and for one hour afterwards. Its use is contraindicated in men with a history of
cerebro-vascular disease and significant hypertension.
Aspiraon and
injecon failed IP
failure Peno-scrotal
decompression
MRI = Magnetic resonance imaging; PPI = penile prosthesis implantation; IP = ischaemic priapism.
Summary of evidence LE
Ischaemic priapism is a medical emergency and immediate intervention is mandatory. 2b
Erectile function preservation is directly related to the duration of ischaemic priapism, age and pre- 2b
operative erectile status.
Medical treatment is variably effective in case of priapism lasting less than 48 hours 2b
Aspiration ± irrigation with 0.9% results in over 80% success rate when combined with intracavernous 2b
injection of sympathomimetic drugs
Phenylephrine is the recommended drug due to its favourable safety profile in the cardiovascular 2b
system compared to other drugs. Phenylephrine is usually diluted in normal saline with a concentration
of 100-500 μg/mL and given in 200 μg doses every three to five minutes directly into the corpus
cavernosum. Maximum dosage is 1 mg within one hour. Patient monitoring is highly recommended.
Oral terbutaline has a success rate in up to 60% of cases when priapism is associated with 1b
intracavernous injection of erectogenic agents.
Exchange transfusion in patients with priapism associated with SCD may result in serious neurological 2b
sequelae.
Shunt procedures are effective to resolve priapism and provide pain relief. No clear recommendation 2b
of the superiority of one type of shunt over another can be given. Distal shunts are less invasive and
associated with lower rate of erectile dysfunction.
Peri- and post-operative anticoagulant prophylaxis (325 mg acetylsalicylic acid pre-operatively, 5,000 3
IU heparin intra-operatively and 81 mg acetylsalicylic acid and 75 mg clopidogrel five days post-
operatively) may prevent priapism recurrence.
Erectile dysfunction is almost inevitable in prolonged cases or ischaemic priapism. Early implantation 2b
of penile prosthesis is associated with lower infection rates and complications compared to late
implantation.
Robust epidemiological studies of stuttering priapism are lacking [1434, 1435]. However, recurrent priapism
episodes are common in men with SCD (42-64%) [1436, 1437] while in adolescents and young men the
incidence of priapism is 35%, of whom 72% have a history of stuttering priapism [1434].
The aetiology of stuttering priapism is similar to that of ischaemic priapism. Whilst SCD is the most common
cause, idiopathic cases and cases due to a neurological disorder have been reported. Men who have acute
ischaemic priapism, especially which has been prolonged (for more than 4 hours) are at risk of developing
stuttering priapism [1431].
Several studies have proposed alternative mechanisms for stuttering priapism including inflammation, cellular
adhesion, NO metabolism, vascular reactivity and coagulation [1332, 1348, 1391, 1433, 1438-1441]. Although
debated, androgens have also been observed to have an association with priapism [1442]. Therefore, one of
the options for the treatment of stuttering priapism is to reduce serum testosterone levels to hypogonadal
levels, which then suppresses androgen-associated mechanisms believed to be involved in triggering recurrent
priapism.
Recommendations for the diagnosis of stuttering priapism are the same as those described in section 10.1.2.5
The duration of hormonal treatment for effective suppression of recurrent priapism is problematic. It is not
possible to draw any conclusions on the dose, duration of treatment and the efficacy. Caution is strongly
advised when prescribing hormonal treatments to pre-pubertal boys and adolescents, and specialist advice
from paediatric endocrinologists should be sought. Likewise, hormonal agents have a contraceptive effect
and interfere with normal sexual maturation and spermatogenesis and affect fertility. Therefore, men who are
trying with their partner to conceive should be comprehensively counselled before using hormonal treatment.
Moreover, sperm cryopreservation may be considered to mitigate any potential effects of anti-androgen therapy
on fertility.
10.2.1.2.3 Digoxin
Digoxin is a cardiac glycoside and positive inotrope that is used to treat congestive heart failure. Digoxin
regulates smooth muscle tone through several different pathways leading to penile detumescence [1347, 1391,
1454]. The use of maintenance digoxin doses (0.25-0.5 mg/daily) in idiopathic stuttering priapism reduces the
number of hospital visits and improves QoL [1391]. In a small, clinical, double-blind, placebo-controlled study,
digoxin decreased sexual desire and excitement with a concomitant reduction in penile rigidity, regardless of
any significant change in plasma levels of testosterone, oestrogens and LH [1454]. Adverse effects include
decreased libido, anorexia, nausea, vomiting, confusion, blurred vision, headache, gynaecomastia, rash and
arrhythmia.
10.2.1.2.5 Gabapentin
Gabapentin has anticonvulsant, antinociceptive and anxiolytic properties and is widely used as an analgesic
and anti-epileptic agent. Its proposed mechanism of action is to inhibit voltage-gated calcium channels, which
attenuates synaptic transmission [1448], and reduces testosterone and FSH levels [1455]. It is given at a dose
of 400 mg, four times daily, up to 2,400 mg daily, until complete penile detumescence occurs, with subsequent
maintenance administration of 300 mg/daily [1456]. Adverse effects include anorgasmia and impaired erectile
function.
10.2.1.2.6 Baclofen
Baclofen is a gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) derivative that acts as a muscle relaxant and anti-muscle
spasm agent. It can inhibit penile erection and ejaculation through GABA activity and prevents recurrent
reflexogenic erections or prolonged erections from neurological diseases [1347]. Oral baclofen has little efficacy
and it is not usually used in stuttering priapism but intrathecal administration is more effective [1391, 1457-
1459]. Adverse effects include drowsiness, confusion, dizziness, weakness, fatigue, headache, hypotension and
nausea.
10.2.1.2.7 Hydroxyurea
Hydroxyurea blocks the synthesis of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) by inhibiting ribonucleotide reductase,
which has the effect of arresting cells in the S-phase [1448, 1460]. Hydroxyurea is an established treatment
for ameliorating SCD and improving life expectancy [1390, 1461]. For patients with recurrent priapism, there is
limited evidence to suggest a prophylactic role of hydroxyurea, [1448, 1460, 1462]. Adverse effects include oligo-
zoospermia and leg ulcers.
Tissue plasminogen activator (TPA) is a secreted serine protease that converts the pro-enzyme plasminogen to
plasmin, which acts as a fibrinolytic enzyme. Limited clinical data have suggested that a single intracavernous
injection of TPA can successfully treat patients with recalcitrant priapism [1448, 1468]. Mild bleeding is the most
commonly observed adverse effect.
Summary of evidence LE
The primary goal in the management of patients with stuttering priapism is prevention of future 2b
episodes, which can generally be achieved pharmacologically.
Hormonal therapy with GnRH agonists or antagonists or anti-androgens is able to reduce the risk of 3
recurrent priapism episodes although it is associated with adverse events (hot flushes, gynaecomastia,
ED, loss of libido, asthenia and infertility).
Phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors have a paradoxical effect in alleviating and preventing stuttering 3
priapism, mainly in patients with idiopathic and sickle cell disease-associated priapism.
The evidence for other systemic drugs (digoxin, α-adrenergic agonists, baclofen, gabapentin and 3
terbutaline, hydroxyurea) is limited.
10.2.1.4 Follow-up
Follow-up for stuttering priapism includes history and clinical examination to assess the efficacy of treatment in
preventing or alleviating erectile events as well as assessing erectile function and penile fibrosis.
10.3.1 Epidemiology/aetiology/pathophysiology
Epidemiological data on non-ischaemic priapism are almost exclusively derived from small case series [1332,
1360, 1474-1476]. Non-ischaemic priapism is significantly less common than the ischaemic type, comprising
only 5% of all priapism cases [1332]. The most frequent cause of non-ischaemic priapism is blunt perineal or
penile trauma [1477]. The injury results in a laceration in the cavernosal artery or branches, leading to a fistula
between the artery and the lacunar spaces of the sinusoidal space [1476]. The resultant increased blood flow
results in a persistent and prolonged erection [1478].
Non-ischaemic priapism can occur after acute spinal cord injury, presumably due to loss of sympathetic input,
leading to predominant parasympathetic input and increased arterial flow [1482]. It has also been reported to
occur following internal urethrotomy [1483], Nesbit procedure [1484], circumcision [1485], transrectal prostate
biopsy [1486], and brachytherapy for prostate cancer [1487]. Some cases have also been described following
shunting procedures performed for ischaemic priapism due to a lacerated cavernosal artery (conversion of
low-flow to high-flow priapism) [1488-1490]. Although SCD is usually associated with ischaemic priapism,
occasional cases of high-flow priapism have been reported; however, the pathophysiological mechanism
remains unclear [1491]. Finally, metastatic malignancy to the penis can also rarely cause non-ischaemic
priapism [1492, 1493].
Selective pudendal arteriography can reveal a characteristic blush at the site of injury in arterial priapism [1497,
1498]. However, due to its invasiveness, it should be reserved for the management of non-ischaemic priapism
when embolisation is being considered [1332, 1355].
The role of MRI in the diagnostic evaluation of priapism is controversial. Its role in non-ischaemic priapism is
limited because the small penile vessels and fistulae cannot be easily demonstrated [1499].
Summary of evidence LE
Non-ischemic priapism is less common than ischemic and is usually associated with blunt perineal or 2b
penile trauma leading to the development of intracavernosal fistula.
Medical history and blood gas analysis are able to differentiate between ischemic and non-ischemic 2b
priapism.
Blood aspiration from the corpora in case of non-ischemic priapism reveal bright red arterial blood with 2b
normal arterial gas values.
Penile duplex US is able to identify intracavernosal fistula responsible for non-ischemic priapism. 2b
Blood aspiration is not helpful for the treatment of arterial priapism and the use of α-adrenergic antagonists
is not recommended because of potential severe adverse effects (e.g., transfer of the drug into the systemic
circulation).
10.3.3.4 Summary of evidence and recommendations for the treatment of non-ischaemic priapism
Summary of evidence LE
Non-ischaemic priapism can cause erectile dysfunction over time and early definitive management 3
should be undertaken.
Conservative management applying ice to the perineum or site-specific perineal compression is an 3
option in all cases. The use of androgen deprivation therapy may enable closure of the fistula reducing
spontaneous and sleep-related erections.
Selective artery embolisation, using temporary or permanent substances, has high success rates. No 3
definitive statement can be made on the best substance for embolisation in terms of sexual function
preservation and success rate.
Repeated embolisation is a reasonable option for the treatment of non-ischaemic priapism. 2b
Selective surgical ligation of the fistula is associated with high risk of erectile dysfunction. 3
Idiopathic non-ischaemic priapism can be found in a significant percentage of children [1514]. Perineal
compression with the thumb may be a useful manoeuvre to distinguish ischaemic and non-ischaemic priapism,
particularly in children, where it may result in immediate detumescence, followed by the return of the erection
with the removal of compression [1480]. Conservative management using ice applied to the perineum or site-
specific perineal compression may be successful, particularly in children [1515, 1516]. Although reportedly
successful, embolisation in children is technically challenging and requires treatment within a specialist
paediatric vascular radiology department [1370, 1517].
In 30-40% of cases, no male-associated factor is found to explain the underlying impairment of sperm
parameters and historically was referred to as idiopathic male infertility. These men present with no previous
history of diseases affecting fertility and have normal findings on physical examination and endocrine, genetic
and biochemical laboratory testing, although semen analysis may reveal pathological findings (see Section
10.3.2). It is now believed that idiopathic male infertility may be associated with several previously unidentified
pathological factors, which include but are not limited to endocrine disruption as a result of environmental
pollution, generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS)/sperm DNA damage, or genetic and epigenetic
abnormalities [1519]. Unexplained male infertility is defined as infertility of unknown origin with normal sperm
parameters and partner evaluation. Between 20 and 30% of couples will have unexplained infertility.
Male fertility can be impaired as a result of many different conditions, thus including [1518]:
• congenital or acquired urogenital abnormalities;
• genetic abnormalities;
• malignancies;
• urogenital tract infections;
• varicocele;
• increased scrotal temperature (e.g., as a consequence of varicocele);
• endocrine disturbances;
• immunological factors.
• iatrogenic factors (e.g., previous scrotal surgery);
• gonadotoxic exposure (e.g., radiotherapy or chemotherapy).
Advanced paternal age (APA) has emerged as one of the additional risk factors associated with the progressive
increase in the prevalence of male factor infertility [1522-1529].
Likewise, advanced maternal age must be considered in the management of every infertile couple, and in the
subsequent decisions in the diagnostic and therapeutic strategy of the male partner [1530, 1531]. This should
include the age and ovarian reserve of the female partner, since these parameters might determine decision-
making in terms of timing and therapeutic strategies (e.g., assisted reproductive technology [ART] vs. surgical
intervention) [1522-1525]. Earlier evaluation is still a matter of debate in couples in with female partners
older than 35 years who have not conceived for 6 months as ovarian reserve may fall [1532-1534]. Table 11.1
summarises the main male-infertility-associated factors.
11.2.2 Summary of evidence and recommendations on epidemiology and aetiology of male infertility
Summary of evidence LE
Infertility affects 15% of couples of reproductive age. 3
A male factor infertility can be identified in about 50% of infertile couples. 2a
A pure male factor infertility can be identified in about 20% of infertile couples. 2a
Several risk factors such as genetic factors, urogenital abnormalities, endocrine disorders, malignant 2a
diseases and gonadotoxic treatments can cause male infertility.
Typical findings from the physical examination of a patient with characteristics suggestive for testicular
deficiency include:
• abnormal secondary sexual characteristics;
• abnormal testicular volume and/or consistency;
• testicular masses (potentially suggestive of cancer);
• absence of testes (uni-bilaterally);
• gynaecomastia;
• varicocele.
Extended examinations
This chapter contains procedures to detect leukocytes and markers of genital tract inflammation, sperm
antibodies, indices of multiple sperm defects, sequence of ejaculation, methods to detect sperm aneuploidy,
semen biochemistry and sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF).
Moreover, more complex testing than classic semen analysis may be required in everyday clinical practice,
particularly in men belonging to couples with recurrent pregnancy loss from natural conception or ART and in
men with unexplained male infertility. Although definitive conclusions cannot be drawn, given the heterogeneity
of the studies, increased sperm DNA damage is associated with pregnancy failure [1519, 1551, 1552].
Table 11.2: Lower reference limits (5th centiles and their 95% CIs) for semen characteristics
If semen analysis is normal according to WHO criteria, a single test is sufficient. If the results are abnormal on at
least two tests, further andrological investigation is indicated.
None of the individual sperm parameters (e.g., concentration, morphology and motility), are diagnostic per se of
infertility. According to WHO 5th edition reference criteria it is important to differentiate between the following
[1553]:
• oligozoospermia: < 16 million sperm/mL;
• asthenozoospermia: < 32% progressive motile sperm;
• teratozoospermia: < 4% normal forms.
According to the WHO 6th edition reference criteria this subdivision is not reported, although the EAU Guidelines
panel considers this further segregation still clinically relevant in the everyday clinical practice.
Often, all three anomalies occur simultaneously, which is defined as oligo-astheno-terato-zoospermia (OAT)
syndrome. As in azoospermia (namely, the complete absence of spermatozoa in semen), in severe cases of
oligozoospermia (spermatozoa < 5 million/mL) [1554], there is an increased incidence of obstruction of the
male genital tract and genetic abnormalities. In case of azoospermia, full andrological investigation should be
warranted to classify obstructive azoospermia versus non-obstructive azoospermia. A recommended method to
diagnose absolute azoospermia versus cryptozoospermia is semen centrifugation at 3,000 g for 15 minutes and
a thorough microscopic examination by phase contrast optics at ×200 magnification of the pellet. All samples
can be stained and re-examined microscopically [1555]. This is to ensure that small quantities of sperm are
detected, which may be potentially used for intra-cytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI); therefore removing the
need for surgical intervention.
Advanced examinations
Obsolete tests such as the human oocyte and human zona pellucida binding and the hamster oocyte
penetration tests have been completely removed. Research tests include assessment of ROS and oxidative
stress, membrane ion channels, acrosome reaction and sperm chromatin structure and stability, computer-
assisted sperm analysis (CASA).
Several assays have been described to measure SDF. It has been suggested that current methods for assessing
sperm DNA integrity still do not reliably predict treatment outcomes from ART and there is controversy whether
to recommend them routinely for clinical use [1563, 1568, 1569]. Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase
mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate nick end labelling (TUNEL) and the alkaline comet test (COMET) directly
measure DNA damage. Conversely, sperm chromatin structure assay (SCSA) and sperm chromatic dispersion
test (SCD) are indirect tools for SDF assessment. The SCSA is still the most widely studied and one of the
most commonly used techniques to detect SDF [1570, 1571]. In SCSA, the number of cells with DNA damage
is indicated by the DNA fragmentation index (DFI) [1572], whereas the proportion of immature sperm with
defects in the histone-to-protamine transition is indicated by high DNA stainability [1573]. It is suggested
that a threshold DFI of 25% as measured with SCSA, is associated with reduced pregnancy rates via natural
conception or intra-uterine insemination (IUI) [1571]. Furthermore, DFI values > 50% on SCSA are associated
with poorer outcomes from in vitro fertilisation (IVF). More recently, the mean COMET score and scores for
proportions of sperm with high or low DNA damage have been shown to be of value in diagnosing male infertility
and providing additional discriminatory information for the prediction of both IVF and ICSI live births [1563].
In terms of a practical approach, urologists may offer the use of testicular sperm in patients with high SDF on
a case-by-case basis and after a full discussion including reproductive specialists. However, patients should be
counselled regarding the low levels of evidence for this. Furthermore, testicular sperm should only be used in
this setting once the common associations of SDF have been excluded, including varicoceles, modifications of
dietary/lifestyle factors, treatment of accessory gland infections and reduction of abstinence time. Additionally,
any confounding female factors must also be taken into consideration before using TESE in this setting.
Based on the frequencies of chromosomal aberrations in patients with different sperm concentration, karyotype
analysis is currently indicated in men with azoospermia or oligozoospermia (spermatozoa < 10 million/mL)
[1594]. Notwithstanding, the clinical value of spermatozoa < 10 million/mL remains a valid threshold until further
studies, evaluating the cost-effectiveness, in which costs of adverse events due to chromosomal abnormalities
(e.g., miscarriages and children with congenital anomalies) are performed [1597].
The presence of germ cells and sperm production are variable in men with Klinefelter syndrome and are more
frequently observed in mosaicism, 46,XY/47,XXY. In patients with azoospermia, TESE or mTESE are therapeutic
options as spermatozoa can be recovered in up to 50% of cases [1602, 1603]. Although the data are not unique
[1603], there is some evidence that TESE or mTESE yields higher sperm recovery rates when performed at a
younger age, although an age threshold cannot be provided [1595, 1604].
Testicular sperm extraction in peri-pubertal or pre-pubertal boys with Klinefelter syndrome aiming at
cryopreservation of testicular spermatogonial stem cells is still considered experimental and should only be
performed within a research setting [1608]. The same applies to sperm retrieval in older boys who have not
considered their fertility potential [1609]. Although the data are not unique [1603], there is growing evidence that
TESE or mTESE yields higher sperm recovery rates when performed at a younger age [1595, 1604].
The most frequently found mutations are F508, R117H and W1282X (according to their traditional definitions),
but their frequency and the presence of other mutations largely depend on the ethnicity of the patient [1618,
1619]. Given the functional relevance of a DNA variant (the 5T allele) in a non-coding region of CFTR [1620], it
is now considered a mild CFTR mutation rather than a polymorphism and it should be analysed in each CBAVD
patient. Men with CBAVD often have mild clinical stigmata of CF (e.g., history of chest infections). When a man
has CBAVD, it is important to test his partner for CF mutations. If the female partner is found to be a carrier of
CFTR mutations, the couple must consider carefully whether to proceed with ICSI, as the risk of having a child
with CF or CBAVD will be 50%, depending on the type of mutations carried by the parents. If the female partner is
negative for known mutations, the risk of being a carrier of unknown mutations is ~0.4% [1621].
The specificity and genotype/phenotype correlation reported above means that Y-deletion analysis has both a
diagnostic and prognostic value for testicular sperm retrieval [1636].
With the contribution of the European Academy of Andrology (EAA) guidelines and the European Molecular
Genetics Quality Network external quality control programme (http://www.emqn.org/emqn/), Yq testing has
become more reliable in different routine genetic laboratories. The EAA guidelines provide a set of primers
capable of detecting > 95% of clinically relevant deletions [1638].
11.3.6.1 Scrotal US
Scrotal US is widely used in everyday clinical practice in patients with oligo-zoospermia or azoospermia, as
infertility has been found to be an additional risk factor for testicular cancer [1649, 1650]. It can be used in
the diagnosis of several diseases causing infertility including obstructive azoospermia (see section 11.4),
testicular neoplasms and providing specific radiological metrics e.g. venous diameter, reflux for the diagnosis of
varicoceles.
A dichotomous cut-off of certainty in terms of lesion size that may definitely distinguish benign from malignant
testicular masses is currently not available. A systematic review and meta-analysis was carried out by the
Testicular Cancer and the Sexual and reproductive health EAU Guidelines panels to to define which scrotal US
or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) characteristics can predict benign or malignant disease in pre- or post-
pubertal males with indeterminate testicular masses [1654]. Benign and malignant masses were classified
using the reported reference test: i.e., histopathology, or 12 months progression-free radiological surveillance.
A total of 32 studies were identified, including 1692 masses of which 28 studies and 1550 masses reported
scrotal US features, 4 studies and 142 masses reported MRI features. Meta-analysis of different scrotal US
(B-mode) values in post-pubertal men demonstrated that a size of ≤0.5 cm had a significantly lower OR of
malignancy compared to masses of > 0.5 cm (p < 0.001). Comparison of masses of 0.6-1.0 cm and masses of
> 1.5 cm also demonstrated a significantly lower OR of malignancy (p = 0.04). There was no significant
difference between masses of 0.6-1.0 and 1.1-1.5 cm. Scrotal US in post-pubertal men also had a
significantly lower OR of malignancy for heterogenous masses compared to homogenous masses (p = 0.04),
hyperechogenic vs. hypoechogenic masses (p < 0.01), normal vs. increased enhancement (p < 0.01), and
peripheral vs. central vascularity (p < 0.01), respectively. There were limited data on pre-pubertal SUS, pre-
pubertal MRI and post-pubertal MRI [1654].
Small hypoechoic/hyperechoic areas may be diagnosed as intra-testicular cysts, focal Leydig cell hyperplasia,
fibrosis and focal testicular inhomogeneity after previous pathological conditions. Hence, they require careful
periodic US assessment and follow-up, especially if additional risk factors for malignancy are present (i.e.,
infertility, bilateral TM, history of cryptorchidism, testicular atrophy, inhomogeneous parenchyma, history of
testicular tumour, history of/contralateral tumour) [1546].
Other studies have suggested that if a testicular lesion is hyperechoic and non-vascular on colour Doppler US
and associated with negative tumour markers, the likelihood of malignancy is low and consideration can be
given to regular testicular surveillance, as an alternative to radical surgery. In contrast, hypoechoic and vascular
lesions are more likely to be malignant [1656-1660]. However, most lesions cannot be characterised by US
(indeterminate), and histology remains the only certain diagnostic tool. A multidisciplinary team discussion
(MDT), including invasive diagnostic modalities, should therefore be considered in these patients.
The role of US-guided intra-operative frozen section analysis in the diagnosis of testicular cancer in
indeterminate lesions can be considered, and several authors have proposed its value in the intra-operative
diagnosis of indeterminate testicular lesions [1661]. Although the default treatment after patient counselling and
MDT discussion may be radical orchidectomy, an US-guided biopsy with intra-operative frozen section analysis
may be offered as an alternative to radical orchidectomy and potentially obviate the need for removal of the
testis in a patient seeking fertility treatment. In men with azoospermia a concurrent TESE with sperm banking
can also be performed at the time of surgical intervention.
11.3.6.1.2 Varicocele
At present, the clinical management of varicocele is still mainly based on physical examination; nevertheless,
scrotal colour Doppler US is useful in assessing venous reflux and diameter, when palpation is unreliable and/or
in detecting recurrence/persistence after surgery [1546]. Definitive evidence of reflux and venous diameter may
be utilised in the decision to treat (see Section 11.4.3.1 and 11.4.3.2).
11.3.6.1.3 Other
Scrotal US is able to detect changes in the proximal part of the seminal tract due to obstruction. Especially
for CBAVD patients, scrotal US is a favourable option to detect the abnormal appearance of the epididymis.
Given that, three types of epididymal findings are described in CBAVD patients: tubular ectasia (honeycomb
appearance), meshwork pattern, and complete or partial absence of the epididymis [1662, 1663].
11.3.6.2 Transrectal US
For patients with a low seminal volume, acidic pH and severe oligozoospermia or azoospermia, in whom
obstruction is suspected, scrotal and transrectal US are of clinical value in detecting CBAVD and presence or
absence of the epididymis and/or seminal vesicles (SV) (e.g., abnormalities/agenesis). Likewise, transrectal
US (TRUS) has an important role in assessing obstructive azoospermia (OA) secondary to CBAVD or anomalies
related to the obstruction of the ejaculatory ducts, such as ejaculatory duct cysts, seminal vesicle dilatation or
hypoplasia/atrophy, although retrograde ejaculation should be excluded as a differential diagnosis [1546, 1664].
11.3.7 Summary of evidence and recommendations for the diagnostic work-up of male infertility
Summary of evidence LE
Semen analysis alone cannot distinguish fertile from infertile men. 2a
Diagnosis of male infertility is associated with an increased risk of malignant and non-malignant 2a
comorbidities.
Male infertility evaluation should include a medical, reproductive and family history, assessment of 2a
lifestyle and behavioural risk factors, physical examination, semen analysis and hormonal evaluation.
Genetic analysis and imaging may be required depending on the clinical features and semen 2a
parameters.
Testicular volume can be measured with a Prader’s orchidometer or using testicular ultrasound. 2a
11.4.1.1 Classification
The classification of cryptorchidism is based on the duration of the condition and the anatomical position of
the testes. If the undescended testis has been identified from birth then it is termed congenital while diagnosis
of acquired cryptorchidism refers to men in whom testes were situated within the scrotum. Cryptorchidism is
categorised as bilateral or unilateral and the location of the testes (inguinal, intra-abdominal or ectopic).
Studies have shown that treatment of congenital and acquired cryptorchidism results in similar hormonal
profiles, semen analysis and testicular volumes [1666, 1667]. However, testicular volume and hormonal function
are reduced in adults treated for congenital bilateral cryptorchidism compared to unilateral cryptorchidism
[1668].
There is increasing evidence to suggest that in unilateral undescended testis, the contralateral normal
descended testis may also have structural abnormalities, including smaller volume, softer consistency and
reduced markers of future fertility potential (spermatogonia/tubule ratio and dark spermatogonia) [1666, 1678].
This implies that unilateral cryptorchidism may affect the contralateral testis and patients and parents should be
counselled appropriately.
Summary of evidence LE
Cryptorchidism is multifactorial in origin and can be caused by genetic factors and endocrine disruption 2a
early in pregnancy.
Cryptorchidism is often associated with testicular dysgenesis and is a risk factor for infertility and 2b
GCTs and patients should be counselled appropriately.
Paternity in men with corrected unilateral cryptorchidism is almost equal to men without 1b
cryptorchidism.
Bilateral cryptorchidism significantly reduces the likelihood of paternity and patients should be 1b
counselled appropriately.
Men with TGCT have decreased semen quality, even before cancer treatment. Azoospermia has been observed
in 24% of men with TGCT [1706] and oligospermia in 50% [1707]. Given that the average 10-year survival rate for
testicular cancer is 98% and it is the most common cancer in men of reproductive potential, it is mandatory to
include counselling regarding fertility preservation prior to any gonadotoxic treatment [1707, 1708]. All patients
should be offered ejaculated semen preservation as the most cost-effective strategy for fertility preservation,
or sperm extracted surgically (e.g., c/mTESE). Indeed, treatment for TGCT, including orchidectomy because of
Rates of under-utilisation of semen analysis and sperm cryopreservation have been reported to be high;
resulting in the failure to identify azoospermic or severely oligozoospermic patients at diagnosis who may
benefit from advanced fertility-preserving procedures such as oncoTESE. The argument that performing
cryopreservation prior to orchidectomy may delay subsequent treatment is not supported by contemporary
clinical practice, indeed adverse impact on survival has not been investigated. In this context, orchidectomy
should not be unduly delayed if there are no facilities for cryopreservation or there is a potential delay in
treatment.
Since chemotherapy and RT are teratogenic, contraception must be used during treatment and for at least
six months after completion [1711]. Both chemotherapy and radiation treatment (RT) can impair fertility.
Long-term infertility is rare after RT and dose-cumulative-dependent with chemotherapy. Treatment of TGCT
can result in additional impairment of semen quality [1712] and increased sperm aneuploidy up to two years
following gonadotoxic therapy [1713]. Spermatogenesis usually recovers one to four years after chemotherapy
[75]. Chemotherapy is also associated with DNA damage and an increased SDF rate [1714]. However, sperm
aneuploidy levels often decline to pre-treatment levels 18-24 months after treatment [1713]. Several studies
reviewing the offspring of cancer survivors have not shown a significant increased risk of genetic abnormalities
in the context of previous chemotherapy and radiotherapy [1715].
In addition to spermatogenic failure, patients with TGCT have Leydig cell dysfunction, even in the contralateral
testis [1716]. The measurement of pre-treatment levels of testosterone, SHBG, LH and oestradiol may help
to stratify those patients at increased risk of hypogonadism and provide a baseline for post-treatment
hypogonadism. The risk of hypogonadism may be increased in men treated for TGCT. Likewise, the risk of
hypogonadism is increased in the survivors of testicular cancer and serum testosterone levels should be
evaluated during the management of these patients [1717]. However, this risk is greatest at 6-12 months
post-treatment and suggests that there may be some improvement in Leydig cell function after treatment.
Therefore, it is reasonable to delay initiation of testosterone therapy, until the patient shows continuous signs
or symptoms of testosterone deficiency [1693]. The risk of low libido and erectile dysfunction is also increased
in TGCT patients [1718]. Patients treated for TGCT are also at increased risk of CVD [1714]. Therefore, patients
may require a multi-disciplinary therapy approach and, in this context, survivorship programmes incorporating
a holistic view of patients considering psychological, medical and social needs could be beneficial. In patients
who place a high value on fertility potential, the use of testosterone therapy in men with symptoms suggestive
for TDS needs to be balanced with worsening spermatogenesis. In these patients consideration can be given to
the use of selective oestrogen receptor modulators (SERMs; e.g., clomiphene) or gonadotrophin analogues (e.g.,
hCG), although these are off-label treatments in this particular clinical setting.
Testicular microcalcification should therefore be considered pre-malignant in this setting and patients
counselled accordingly. Testicular biopsies from men with TM have found a higher prevalence of GCNIS,
especially in those with bilateral microcalcifications [1725]. However, TM can also occur in benign testicular
conditions and the microcalcification itself is not malignant. Therefore, the association of TM and TGCT is
controversial and the challenge is to identify those men at risk of harbouring GCNIS and future risk of TGCT.
Decastro et al. [1727] suggested that testicular cancer would not develop in most men with TM (98.4%) during a
5-year follow-up. As such, an extensive screening programme would only benefit men at significant risk. In this
context it would be prudent to advise patients with TM and risk factors for testicular cancer to at least undergo
regular testicular examination. It has been suggested that these patients could also be offered annual physical
examination by a urologist and US follow-up, although follow-up protocols may be difficult to implement in this
invariably young cohort of patients [1670]. As testicular atrophy and infertility have an association with testicular
cancer, some authors recommend biopsy or follow-up US if TM is seen [1697]. However, most patients who
are azoospermic will be undergoing therapeutic biopsy (i.e., with the specific purpose of sperm retrieval) and
therefore a definitive diagnosis can be made and there is a lack of evidence demonstrating a higher prevalence
of testicular cancer in patients with both TM and testicular atrophy. In patients with incidental TM, the risk of
GCNIS is low and a logical approach is to instruct patients to perform regular testicular self-examination.
11.4.2.3 Summary of evidence and recommendations for germ cell malignancy and testicular microcalcification
Summary of evidence LE
Testicular germ cell tumour (TGCT) affects approximately 1% of sub-fertile men. 2b
Men with TGCT frequently have impaired sperm parameters at diagnosis. 2a
Semen analysis and sperm cryopreservation before orchidectomy allows the identification of TGCT 2b
patients with azoospermia, who may benefit from concomitant surgical sperm retrieval (i.e., onco-
TESE).
Treatment of TGCT can result in decreased sperm quality, sperm aneuploidy, increased SDF, 2a
hypogonadism, sexual dysfunction and cardiovascular diseases.
Testicular microcalcifications can be found in men with benign conditions (e.g., cryptorchidism, 2a
infertility, testicular torsion and atrophy, Klinefelter syndrome, hypogonadism, DSD, varicocele) and
(pre)malignant (GCNIS) or malignant conditions (TGCT).
Testicular microcalcifications are associated with a higher risk of testicular cancer in infertile men. 1a
Men potentially at risk for harbouring or developing GCNIS include those with bilateral TM, infertility, 2a
atrophic testes, undescended testes, history of TGCT, and contralateral TM.
Since TGCT will not develop in most men with TM, an extensive screening programme or invasive 2b
testicular biopsy is not indicated without additional risk factors.
11.4.3 Varicocele
Varicocele is a common congenital abnormality, that may be associated with the following andrological
conditions:
• failure of ipsilateral testicular growth and development;
• male sub-fertility;
• symptoms of pain and discomfort;
• hypogonadism.
11.4.3.1 Classification
The following classification of varicocele [1518] is useful in clinical practice:
• Subclinical: not palpable or visible at rest or during Valsalva manoeuvre, but can be shown by
special tests (Doppler US).
• Grade 1: palpable during Valsalva manoeuvre.
• Grade 2: palpable at rest.
• Grade 3: visible and palpable at rest.
The exact association between reduced male fertility and varicocele is unknown. Increased scrotal temperature,
hypoxia and reflux of toxic metabolites can cause testicular dysfunction and infertility due to increased overall
survival and DNA damage [1732, 1734].
11.4.3.3.2 Varicocelectomy
Varicocele repair has been a subject of debate for several decades. A meta-analysis of RCTs and observational
studies in men with only clinical varicoceles has shown that surgical varicocelectomy significantly
improves semen parameters in men with abnormal semen parameters, including men with NOA with hypo-
spermatogenesis or late maturation (spermatid) arrest on testicular pathology [1732, 1736-1739]. A meta-
analysis showed that improvements in semen parameters are usually observed after surgical correction in
men with abnormal semen parameters [1740-1742]. Varicocelectomy can also reverse sperm DNA damage
and improve OS levels [1732, 1734]. Pain resolution after varicocelectomy occurs in 48-90% of patients [1743].
A systematic review has shown greater improvement in higher-grade varicoceles and this should be taken into
account during patient counselling [1744].
A Cochrane review from 2012 concluded that there is evidence to suggest that treatment of a varicocele in men
from couples with otherwise unexplained subfertility may improve a couple’s chance of spontaneous pregnancy
[1748]. Similarly, a Cochrane review from 2021 including 5,384 participants showed that varicocele treatment
may improve pregnancy rates compared to delayed or no treatment (RR 1.55, 95% CI 1.06 to 2.26) [1749]. Two
meta-analyses of RCTs comparing treatment to observation in men with a clinical varicocele, oligozoospermia
and otherwise unexplained infertility, favoured treatment, with a combined OR of 2.39-4.15 (95% CI: 1.56-3.66)
and (95% CI: 2.31-7.45), respectively [1739, 1748]. Average time to improvement in semen parameters is up
to two spermatogenic cycles [1750, 1751] with spontaneous pregnancy occurring between 6 and 12 months
after varicocelectomy [1752, 1753]. A further meta-analysis has reported that varicocelectomy may improve
outcomes following ART in oligozoospermic men with an OR of 1.69 (95% CI: 0.95-3.02) [1754].
There is now increasing evidence that varicocele treatment may improve DNA fragmentation and outcomes
from ART [1754, 1755]. As a consequence, more recently it has been suggested that the indications for
varicocele intervention should be expanded to include men with raised DNA fragmentation. If a patient has failed
ART (e.g., failure of implantation, embryogenesis or recurrent pregnancy loss) there is an argument that if DNA
damage is raised, consideration could be given to varicocele intervention after extensive counselling [1765], and
exclusion of other causes of raised SDF [1755, 1766].The dilemma remains as to whether varicocele treatment
is indicated in men with raised SDF and normal semen parameters. This decision would need a full and open
discussion with the infertile couple, taking into consideration the female partners ovarian reserve and the
surgical risks and potential delays in ART associated with varicocele intervention.
In a meta-analysis of non-azoospermic infertile men with clinical varicocele by Estevez et al., four retrospective
studies were included of men undergoing ICSI, and included 870 cycles (438 subjected to ICSI with prior
varicocelectomy, and 432 without prior varicocelectomy). There was a significant increase in the clinical
pregnancy rates (OR 1.59, 95% CI: 1.19-2.12, I2 = 25%) and live birth rates (OR 2.17, 95% CI: 1.55-3.06, I2 =
0%) in the varicocelectomy group compared to the group subjected to ICSI without previous varicocelectomy.
A further study evaluated the effects of varicocele repair and its impact on pregnancy and live birth rates in
infertile couples undergoing ART in male partners with oligo-azoospermia or azoospermia and a varicocele
[1754]. In 1,241 patients, a meta-analysis demonstrated that varicocelectomy improved live birth rates for the
oligospermic (OR = 1.699) men and combined oligo-azoospermic/azoospermic groups (OR = 1.761). Pregnancy
rates were higher in the azoospermic group (OR = 2.336) and combined oligo-azoospermic/azoospermic groups
(OR 1.760). Live birth rates were higher for patients undergoing IUI after intervention (OR 8.360).
Complications
Microsurgical repair results in fewer complications and lower recurrence rates compared to the other
techniques [1749, 1768, 1769]; however, this procedure, requires microsurgical training. The various other
techniques are still considered viable options, although recurrences and hydrocele formation appear to be
higher [1769].
Radiological techniques (sclerotherapy and embolisation) are minimally invasive approaches
for varicocele treatment. Although higher recurrence rates have been reported compared to microscopic
varicocelectomy [1754], a meta-analysis showed that the incidence of varicocele recurrence was similar
after surgical ligation and sclero-embolisation [1770]. In terms of complications, a meta-analysis of twelve
studies comparing 738 cases of surgical ligation vs. 647 cases of sclero-embolisation, showed that overall
complications rate did not differ significantly between the groups (OR 1.48; 95% CI 0.86–2.57, p = 0.16) [1770].
The incidence of post-operative hydrocele is significantly higher after surgical ligation than sclero-embolisation,
but radiological techniques are associated with higher incidence of post-operative orchiepidydimitys [1770].
Table 11.3: Recurrence and complication rates associated with treatments for varicocele
Summary of evidence LE
The presence of varicocele in some men is associated with progressive testicular damage from 2a
adolescence onwards and a consequent potential reduction in fertility.
Although the treatment of varicocele in adolescents may be effective, there is a significant risk of over- 3
treatment as the majority of boys with a varicocele will have no fertility problems later in life.
Varicocele repair may be effective in men with abnormal semen parameters, a clinical varicocele and 1a
otherwise unexplained male factor infertility.
Varicocele repair may improve pregnancy rates and sperm concentration in adult infertile men with 1a
abnormal semen analyses, while benefits in sperm motility and normal morphology are less clear.
Although there are no prospective randomised studies evaluating this, meta-analyses have suggested 2
that varicocele repair is associated with sperm appearing in the ejaculate of men with non-obstructive
azoospermia.
Microscopic approach (inguinal/subinguinal) may have lower recurrence and complications rates than 2a
non-microscopic approaches (retroperitoneal and laparoscopic), although no RCTs are available yet.
Varicocele is associated with raised sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF) and intervention has been shown 2a
to reduce SDF and may improve the outcomes from ART.
A meta-analysis indicated that Ureaplasma parvum and Mycoplasma genitalium were not associated with
male infertility, but a significant relationship existed between U. urealyticum (OR: 3.03 95% CI: 1.02–8.99)
and Mycoplasma hominis (OR: 2.8; 95% CI: 0.93– 3.64) [1798]. For these reasons, the treatment is not always
recommended.
Human papilloma virus (HPV) is commonly found in semen samples, with a reported prevalence of 20% in
infertile populations and 8% in men from the general population [1799]. Systematic reviews have reported
an association between male infertility, poorer pregnancy outcomes and semen HPV positivity [1799-1802].
However, data still needs to be prospectively validated to clearly define the clinical impact of HPV infection in
semen. Additionally, seminal presence of Herpes Simplex virus (HSV)-2 in infertile men may be associated with
lower sperm quality compared to that in HSV-negative infertile men [1788]. However, it is unclear if anti-viral
therapy improves fertility rates in these men.
Asymptomatic presence of C. trachomatis and M. hominis in the semen can be correlated with impaired sperm
quality, which recovers after antibiotic treatment. However further research is required to confirm these findings
[1821].
11.4.4.3 Epididymitis
Inflammation of the epididymis causes unilateral pain and swelling, usually with acute onset. Among sexually
active men aged < 35 years, epididymitis is most often caused by C. trachomatis or N. gonorrhoea [1825, 1826].
Sexually transmitted epididymitis is usually accompanied by urethritis. Non-sexually transmitted epididymitis is
associated with UTIs and occurs more often in men aged > 35 years [1827].
Patients with epididymitis known or suspected to be caused by N. gonorrhoeae or C. trachomatis must be told to
also refer their sexual partners for evaluation and treatment [1830].
11.4.4.4 Summary of evidence and recommendation for male accessory gland infections
Summary of evidence LE
Male accessory gland infections are not clearly associated with impaired natural conception. 3
Antibiotic treatment often only eradicates micro-organisms; it has no positive effect on inflammatory 2a
alterations and cannot reverse functional deficits and anatomical abnormalities.
Although antibiotic treatment for MAGIs may result in improvement in sperm quality, it does not 2a
enhance the probability of conception.
Data are insufficient to conclude whether antibiotics and antioxidants for the treatment of infertile men 3
with leukocytospermia improve fertility outcomes.
11.5.2 Summary of evidence and recommendation for Non-Invasive Male Infertility Management
Summary of evidence LE
In infertile men life style factors including obesity, low physical activity, smoking and high alcohol 2a
intake are associated with decreased sperm quality.
In men with idiopathic oligo-astheno-teratozoospermia, life-style changes including weight loss and 2a
increased physical activity, smoking cessation and alcohol intake reduction may improve sperm quality
and the chances of conception.
No conclusive data are available regarding the beneficial treatment with antioxidants in men with 1b
idiopathic infertility, although they may improve semen parameters.
No conclusive data is available regarding the beneficial treatment with prebiotic/probiotic in men with 1b
idiopathic infertility; although, they may improve semen parameters.
No conclusive data are available regarding the use of selective oestrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) 1b
in men with idiopathic infertility.
No conclusive data are available regarding the use of steroidal (testolactone) or nonsteroidal 1b
(anastrozole and letrozole) aromatase inhibitors in men with idiopathic infertility.
Greater baseline testicular volume is a good prognostic indicator for response to gonadotrophin treatment
while previous testosterone therapy can have a negative impact on gonadotropin treatment outcomes in men
with hypogonadotropic hypogonadism [1853]. However, this observation has been subsequently refuted by a
meta-analysis that did not confirm a real negative role of testosterone therapy in terms of future fertility in this
specific setting [126].
11.5.3.5 Summary of evidence and recommendations for treatment of male infertility with hormonal therapy
Summary of evidence LE
Follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) promotes spermatogenesis and testicular growth during puberty. 2b
Human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) acts like luteinizing hormone (LH) and is used to stimulate
intratesticular testosterone production and spermatogenesis in men with hypopituitarism after puberty.
Prepubertal secondary hypogonadism requires the association of FSH and hCG or pulsatile GnRH, even 1b
if its use is limited by the difficult administration.
Intratesticular (15%)
Epididymis (30-67%)
Infection (acute/chronic epididymitis)
Trauma
Post-surgical iatrogenic obstruction (i.e., MESA, hydrocelectomy or other scrotal surgery)
Congenital epididymal obstruction (usually manifests as congenital bilateral absence of the vas deferens
[CBAVD])
Other congenital forms of epididymal obstruction (Young’s syndrome)
When semen volume is low, or absent a search must be made for spermatozoa in urine after ejaculation.
Absence of spermatozoa and immature germ cells in the semen pellet suggest complete seminal duct
obstruction.
Epididymal obstruction
Microsurgical epididymal sperm aspiration (MESA) or percutaneous epididymal sperm aspiration (PESA) [1875]
is indicated in men with CBAVD. Testicular sperm extraction and percutaneous testicular sperm aspiration
(TESA), are also options [1876]. The source of sperm used for ICSI in cases of OA and the aetiology of the
obstruction do not affect the outcome in terms of pregnancy or miscarriage rates [1877, 1878]. Usually, one
Summary of evidence LE
Obstructive lesions of the seminal tract are frequent in azoospermic or severely oligozoospermic 3
patients, usually with normal-sized testes and normal reproductive hormones.
Concomitant hypogonadism, has been found in about 30% of patients with NOA [295, 1908, 1909]. Biochemical
evaluation should be performed to differentiate the types of hypogonadism (i.e., hypogonadotropic
hypogonadism vs. hypergonadotropic vs. compensated hypogonadism) as this will determine different
therapeutic strategies to treat the hypogonadal male [1910].
Scrotal US may show signs of testicular dysgenesis (e.g., non-homogeneous testicular architecture and/or
microcalcifications) and rare testicular tumours can be identified. Testicular volume may be a predictor of
spermatogenic function [1546] and is usually, but not invariably, low in patients with NOA. Some authors have
advocated that testicular perfusion detected at US Doppler assessment can predict surgical sperm retrieval at
TESE and guide testicular biopsies [1911]; however, to date, data are inconsistent to support a routine role of
testicular Doppler evaluation before TESE in order to predict sperm retrieval outcome.
As discussed (see Section 11.3), patients should undergo karyotype analysis [1805, 1806], along with a
screening of Y-chromosome micro-deletions [1631, 1912]. In patients with clinical suspicion of CBAVD
assessement of mutations in the gene coding for CFTR is also to be recommended [1618, 1619]. Genetic
counselling for eventual transmissible and health-relevant genetic conditions should be provided to couples.
mTESE is performed with an operative optical microscope to inspect seminiferous tubules at a magnification
of 20-25x and it allows to find and extract those tubules which were larger, dilated and opaque as these were
more likely to harbour sperm [1931]. The rationale of this technique is to increase the probability of retrieving
sperm with a lower amount of tissue sampled and a subsequent lower risk of complications. Lower rates of
complications have been observed with mTESE compared to cTESE, both in terms of haematoma and fibrosis
[1934]. Both procedures have shown a recovery of baseline testosterone levels after long-term follow-up [1935,
1936]. Therefore, it would be reasonable to provide long-term endocrinological follow-up after TESE (any type) to
detect hypogonadism.
A meta-analysis that pooled data of case-control studies comparing cTESE with mTESE showed a lower
unadjusted SRR of 35% (95% CI: 30-40) for TESE and 52% (95% CI: 47-58) for mTESE [1914]. A meta-analysis
comparing cTESE and mTESE in patients with NOA showed a mean overall SRR of 47% (95% CI: 45;49%).
No differences were observed when mTESE was compared with cTESE (46 [range 43-49] % for cTESE vs. 46
[range 42-49] % for mTESE, respectively) [1923]. Meta-regression analysis demonstrated that the SRR per cycle
was independent of age and hormonal parameters at enrolment. However, the SRR increased as a function of
testicular volume. Retrieved sperms resulted in a live-birth rate of up to 28% per ICSI cycle [1912]. The difference
in surgical sperm retrieval outcomes between the two meta-analyses may be explained by the data studied; one
analysed only case control studies [1914] whilst the other also included the single RCT [1912]; however, it is
important to note that all studies directly comparing cTESE and mTESE have shown that the latter is superior in
retrieving sperm.
In a study assessing the role of salvage mTESE after a previously failed cTESE or TESA, sperm were
successfully retrieved in 46.5% of cases [1937]. In studies reporting SSR by mTESE for men who had failed TESE
or cTESE the SRR was 39.1% (range 18.4-57.1%) [1938, 1939]. Hypospermatogenesis might be a predictor for
successful salvage mTESE after a failed cTESE, but this is based on retrospective studies with a limited number
of patients [1940]. Similarly, a variable SRR has been reported for salvage mTESE after a previously failed
mTESE (ranging from 18.4% to 42.8%) [1941, 1942].
A recent meta-analysis investigated the risk of hypogonadism after TESE due to testicular atrophy [1943];
patients with NOA experienced a mean 2.7 nmol/L decrease in total testosterone 6 months after cTESE, which
recovered to baseline within 18-26 months. Lower rates of complications have been observed with mTESE
compared to cTESE, both in terms of haematoma and fibrosis [1934]. Both procedures have shown a recovery of
baseline testosterone levels after long-term follow-up [1935, 1936].
To date only one RCT has investigated surgical sperm retrieval in 100 men with NOA, mTESE was compared to a
modified TESA using a large biopsy needle (18G) with multiple needle passes [1944]. The SRR was significantly
higher in mTESE compared to multiple needle pass TESA (43% vs. 22%; rate difference -0.21; 95% Cl -0.39 to –
0.03; p = 0.02). A salvage mTESE was offered to men who failed multiple needle-pass TESA and the combined
SRR from the two procedures was 29%. This was not significantly different from the SRR achieved by mTESE,
but the study was not powered for this comparison. Taken together this study shows that the SRR from mTESE
is superior to TESA.
Most available studies on surgical sperm retrieval in men with NOA are limited by their observational designs,
heterogeneity in NOA diagnostic criteria, surgical techniques, and reporting of outcomes. However, the main
limitation to contemporary literature is the paucity of randomised controlled studies comparing cTESE and
mTESE. Although no difference in SSR was observed between cTESE/mTESE techniques in patients with NOA
in the latest and most comprehensive meta-analysis [1923], it is important to note that in all the individual
trials comparing cTESE and mTESE the latter was superior in retrieving sperm. Furthermore, the current data
suggests that mTESE has less complications than cTESE and therefore the consensus opinion of the guidelines
panel is that mTESE is the optimum approach for surgical sperm retrieval procedures. However, this is based
on low-quality evidence and larger RCTs comparing SSR, risks and costs between the two techniques are
urgently needed. Such trials should report the specifics of the surgical technique, the procedure followed by the
embryologists, clinical outcomes including quantity and quality of retrieved sperm, and detailed ART outcomes
including live birth rates [1945].
No RCT has shown a benefit of hormonal treatment to enhance the chances of sperm retrieval among patients
with idiopathic NOA [1949]. A meta-analysis has suggested that hormone stimulation prior to TESE might
improve SRR in eugonadal but not in hypergonadotropic hypogonadal patients [1950]; however, the included
studies had moderate or severe risk of bias and randomised studies are needed to confirm these findings.
Hormonal therapy has also been proposed to increase the chance of sperm retrieval at salvage surgery after
previously failed cTESE or mTESE. Only small retrospective studies with conflicting results have been conducted
[1859, 1950-1952]. The histological finding of hypo-spermatogenesis emerged as a predictor of sperm retrieval
at salvage surgery after hormonal treatment [1952]. Patients should be counselled that the evidence for the role
of hormone stimulation prior to sperm retrieval surgery in men with idiopathic NOA is limited [1953]. Currently, it
is not recommended in routine practice.
Summary of evidence LE
Patients with NOA are at increased risk of long-term cardio-metabolic diseases, cancer and mortality. 3
Hypogonadism is present in about one third of men with non-obstructive azoospermia (NOA), before 3
surgical for sperm retrieval.
Surgery for sperm retrieval is mandatory in NOA men before ART. 1b
Fine needle aspiration (FNA) and testicular sperm aspiration (TESA) have lower sperm retrieval rates 1b
compared to TESE in patients with NOA.
FNA requires a secondary therapeutic surgical approach, which may increase the risk of testicular 2a
damage, and without appropriate cost-benefit analysis it is not justifiable.
No definitive predictors of positive sperm retrieval before TESE have been identified. 1b
Microdissection TESE has been associated with higher rates of sperm retrieval and lower 2a
complications than conventional TESE.
No conclusive data are available regarding the benefit of use of medical therapy before TESE (e.g., 2a
recombinant follicle-stimulating hormone [rFSH]; highly purified FSH; human chorionic gonadotrophin;
aromatase inhibitors or selective oestrogen receptor modulators [SERMs]) in patients with NOA.
A systematic literature search for original English-language publications and review articles published up to
December 2019 and a further search up to December 2020 were performed using both Pubmed and Google,
yielding only a limited number of papers addressing the role of health care professionals in supporting male
patients who have suffered from cancers in terms of sexual and reproductive health, or the concept of Men’s
Health programmes.
Despite considerable public health initiatives over the past few decades, the Panel has observed that there is
still a significant gender gap between male and female in life expectancy [1958]. The main contributors to male
mortality in Europe are non-communicable diseases (namely CVDs), cancer, diabetes and respiratory disease)
and injuries [1679], as highlighted in a recent WHO report disproving the prevailing misconception that the higher
rate of premature mortality among men is a natural phenomenon [1958, 1959]. The recent pandemic situation
linked with SARS-CoV-2 infection associated diseased (COVID-19) further demonstrates how the development
of strategies dedicated to male health is of fundamental importance [1960].
The WHO report also addresses male sexual and reproductive health which is considered under-reported, linking
in particular male infertility, as a proxy for overall health, to serious diseases in men [1902, 1903, 1961-1964].
These data suggest that health care policies should redirect their focus to preventive strategies and in particular
pay attention to follow-up of men with sexual and reproductive complaints [1905, 1965]. [1965]. Considering
that infertile men seem to be at greater risk of death, simply because of their inability to become fathers, is
unacceptable [1906]. The Panel aims to develop a concept of a more streamlined and holistic approach to men’s
health.
For these guidelines, the Panel aimed to challenge clinicians to look beyond the pathology of disorders alone
and consider the potential associations with other health disorders. Men with varicoceles have a higher
incidence of heart disease and higher risk of diabetes and hyperlipidaemia following diagnosis [1965]. A
diagnosis of infertility may have a profound psychological impact on men (and their partners), potentially
resulting in anxiety, enduring sadness, anger, and a sense of personal inadequacy and “unmet masculinity”
[1966]. A combination of factors, personality, sociocultural background, and specific treatments/professional
support, will determine how men cope with this diagnosis [1955].
The most common cancer among European men (excluding non-melanoma skin cancer) is PCa [1967]. Due to
new therapeutic approaches, survival rates have improved significantly [1968] and as men live longer, health-
related quality of life and related sexual well-being will become increasingly important [295]. Regardless of the
type of treatment used [1692], sexual dysfunction and distress are common post-treatment complications [296,
1969-1971].
Finally, the relationship between ED and heart disease has been firmly established for well over two decades
[1979-1985]. Cadiovascular disease is the leading cause of both male mortality and premature mortality
[1986-1989]. Studies indicate that all major risk factors for CVD, including hypertension, smoking and elevated
cholesterol are more prevalent in men than women [1990-1996]. Given that ED is an established early sign
of atherosclerotic disease and predicts cardiovascular events as an independent factor [1981], it provides
urologists with the unique opportunity for CVD screening and health modification and optimise CVD risk factors,
while treating men’s primary complaint (e.g., ED). Currently, both the EAU and AUA guidelines recommend
screening for CVD risk factors in men with ED and late onset hypogonadism [1997-1999] (see Sections 3.5.5 and
5.2).
There is clearly a need to prospectively collect data addressing all aspects of male health, including CVD
screening protocols and assess the impact of primary and secondary preventive strategies. The EAU Sexual and
Reproductive Health Guidelines Panel aims to promote and develop a long-term strategy to raise men’s health at
a global level.
495. Banno JJ, et al. The efficacy of platelet-rich plasma (PRP) as a supplemental therapy for the
treatment of erectile dysfunction (ED): Initial outcomes. J Sex Med, 2017. 14.
496. Chalyj, M.E., et al. [the Effectiveness of Intracavernous Autologous Platelet-Rich Plasma in the
Treatment of Erectile Dysfunction]. Urologiia, 2015: 76.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26665770
497. Ruffo, A., et al. Effectiveness and safety of Platelet rich Plasma (PrP) cavernosal injections plus
external shock wave treatment for penile erectile dysfunction: First results from a prospective,
randomized, controlled, interventional study. European Urology Supplements, 2019. 18: e1622.
https://urosource.uroweb.org/resource-centres/EAU19/187172/abstract
498. Matz, E.L., et al. Safety and feasibility of platelet rich fibrin matrix injections for treatment of common
urologic conditions. Investig Clin Urol, 2018. 59: 61.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29333517
499. Alkhayal, S., et al. PO-01-091 Platelet Rich Plasma Penile Rejuvenation as a Treatment for Erectile
Dysfunction: An Update. The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 2019. 16: S71.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsxm.2019.03.228
500. Poulios, E., et al. Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) Improves Erectile Function: A Double-Blind, Randomized,
Placebo-Controlled Clinical Trial. J Sex Med, 2021. 18: 926.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33906807
501. Oudelaar, B.W., et al. Concentrations of Blood Components in Commercial Platelet-Rich Plasma
Separation Systems: A Review of the Literature. Am J Sports Med, 2019. 47: 479.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29337592
502. Shaher, H., et al. Is Platelet Rich Plasma Safe and Effective in Treatment of Erectile Dysfunction?
Randomized Controlled Study. Urology, 2023. 175: 114.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36736914
503. Masterson, T.A., et al. Platelet-rich Plasma for the Treatment of Erectile Dysfunction: A Prospective,
Randomized, Double-blind, Placebo-controlled Clinical Trial. Reply. J Urol, 2023. 210: 734.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37811758
The EAU accepts no responsibility for the content, quality, or performance of materials, applications and
products derived from the EAU Guidelines and does not endorse or warrant their use. In the event of any
discrepancies the original language version shall be considered authoritative.