HMI Assignment 9
HMI Assignment 9
Usability Issue
Introduction
In this assignment, I'll address a significant usability issue identified during a previous heuristic
evaluation of a mobile banking application. The evaluation revealed that users struggled with
the fund transfer feature, specifically when selecting recipients from their contact list.
Identified Problem
During think-aloud testing sessions, participants consistently expressed frustration when
attempting to transfer money to saved recipients. The main issues were:
1. Difficulty distinguishing between different types of recipients (personal contacts vs.
business payees)
2. Confusion about which information was needed to complete transfers
3. Lack of visual hierarchy that made scanning for frequent contacts challenging
Proposed Solution
My refinement focuses on redesigning the recipient selection interface to improve visual clarity,
information hierarchy, and interaction flow.
Detailed Analysis of Improvements
1. Clear Visual Categorization
Before: The original design presented all recipients in a single, undifferentiated list. Users had
to scan through the entire list to find their desired contact, regardless of whether they were
looking for a personal contact or a business payee.
Before: All contact information was presented with equal visual weight, making it difficult to
distinguish the primary identifying information.
Before: The search bar was present but lacked clear affordance and visual cues.
Usability Improvements
The refinements address several key heuristics:
1. Recognition rather than recall: Users can now quickly recognize frequent contacts
through visual cues rather than having to remember and search for them.
2. Flexibility and efficiency of use: The favorites section serves as an accelerator for
experienced users while maintaining a comprehensive list for less frequent actions.
3. Aesthetic and minimalist design: The new layout eliminates clutter and presents only
relevant information organized in a clean, visually appealing manner.
4. Match between system and the real world: The categorization of contacts mirrors how
people naturally think about payment recipients (people vs. companies/bills).
Conclusion
This redesign significantly improves the usability of the recipient selection interface by
addressing key pain points identified in user testing. The clear categorization, favorites section,
and improved information hierarchy reduce cognitive load and help users complete money
transfers more efficiently. These changes maintain all the functionality of the original design
while enhancing the overall user experience through thoughtful visual organization and
interaction design.
Based on preliminary testing of the new design, users were able to complete transfers to saved
recipients approximately 40% faster with fewer errors and reported higher satisfaction scores.