FIX a Strategic Approach to Writing and Revision for Students With Learning Disabilities
FIX a Strategic Approach to Writing and Revision for Students With Learning Disabilities
TEACHING Exceptional Children, Vol. 50, No. 4, pp. 233–242. Copyright 2015 The Author(s). DOI: 10.1177/0040059918757944
FIX
A Strategic Approach to Writing
and Revision for Students With
Learning Disabilities
Cindy K. Sherman and Susan De La Paz
This article is a reprint. A full reference to the original work is as follows: Sherman, C. K., & De La Paz, S. (2015). A strategic
approach to writing and revision for students with learning disabilities. TEACHING Exceptional Children, 48, 93-101. doi:
10.1177/0040059915605823
Teaching students in upper elementary I think my neighborhood is more on generating relevant content, it
school to revise their papers effectively great, it also help the ecnomy, is difficult for them to monitor their
requires a three-pronged approach. because my neighborhood has revising (Midgette, Haria, & MacArthur,
First, teachers provide instruction on a many small buinessies around it. 2008). In short, novice and struggling
relevant genre or writing form (using In January, everyone on the writers do not know enough about the
the Common Core State Standards for block wacths the super bowl. revising process to make “big-picture”
English language arts or other relevant
standards as a guide). Second, teachers
help students to use four basic Novice and struggling writers do not know enough
revising tactics (add, move, delete,
and rewrite) in order to make changes
about the revising process to make “big-picture”
to words, phrases and sentences, and changes.
longer portions of text. Third, using the
FIX strategy, a metacognitive routine,
helps students to manage the revising One day later, Isaiah used a red pen changes. Therefore, we developed a
process. FIX uses the self-regulated to revise his paper. His revisions metacognitive strategy to teach students
strategy development (SRSD; Harris, included three capitalizations: like Isaiah a more effective approach to
Graham, Mason, & Friedlander, 2008) Halloween rather than holloween; revising that emphasizes both reflection
model of instruction. FIX works by When to start the second sentence, and and problem solving.
teaching students to identify and Super. He then inserted in the winter
solve “big-picture” problems in their after storm to explain when people
writing rather than focusing on minor shoveled, added s to help, and finally, FIX: A Metacognitive Strategy for
issues. In prior research, we found that after two attempts, correctly spelled Revising
students with and without learning economy. Our writing strategy is called FIX (De
disabilities who learned FIX made La Paz & Sherman, 2013). It is based
meaningful changes that improved Isaiah’s changes are typical of on prior work on effective approaches
their papers (De La Paz & Sherman, novice writers in many ways. First, his to revising (e.g., Graham, 1997) and
2013). With this strategy, students can changes improve the quality of his has three steps (see Figure 1) intended
learn to effectively revise their essays essay but only slightly. Second, his to guide students through the revising
and stories. changes are the kind most teachers process: (1) Focus on essay elements,
report seeing: all but one of Isaiah’s (2) Identify problems, and (3) eXecute
Isaiah, an African American sixth changes focus on surface features (e.g., changes. Each step in the process is
grader who attends a public charter spelling, punctuation, word choice) indicated using different color cards
school in the Mid-Atlantic, has a instead of the overall meaning of his and coding: Red indicates that students
learning disability. His reading is text (Rijlaarsdam, Couzijn, & van den should “stop” and focus on essay
judged as proficient according to an Bergh, 2004). Although there may be elements, yellow cautions students to
annual high-stakes test; however, he many reasons for this, students often consider and identify problems by
struggles when it comes to writing. His lack adequate genre knowledge to searching for differences between what
performance on the Test of Written make effective global revisions (De La they intended to write versus what was
Language (Hammill & Larsen, 1996) Paz, Swanson, & Graham, 1998). In actually written, and green prompts
indicates problems with conventions, addition, students may have difficulty students to execute changes in
language, spelling, and impoverished recognizing inferred versus explicit response to specific problems.
ideas. Isaiah’s teacher observes that he information (De La Paz & McCutchen,
enjoys talking about ideas but struggles 2011), being able to identify problems
to organize elements in his writing. When that actually exist (MacArthur, 2007),
Prerequisite Skills
asked to write an essay about “highlights or realizing what has actually been
that he would explain to someone who written (i.e., the existing text) versus Before learning how to revise using the
was new to his town,” he writes what was intended (Graham, 1997). FIX strategy, students need information
Research has shown that novice on important elements of the target
writers make more changes rather than genre in order to understand what it
If someone was new to my
neighborhood, I would tell them making better changes, and many means to write a specific type of essay
about a park a block away, I students’ underlying difficulties in (e.g., expository). To do this, teachers
would also talk about holloween, executing basic revising tactics (i.e., add, can locate exemplars of the genre for
many kids come to the house’s on move, delete, rewrite) interfere with students to read from grade-appropriate
our block around hollween time. their ability to manage the overall textbooks. Student work samples from
when we got hit with a snow storm revising process (De La Paz et al., 1998). prior classes or web sites, such as
everyone help clear the streets. Further, because young writers focus http://www.thewritesource.com, are
Step 2: Identify Problems (copy on yellow paper, and use with highlighters)
Add
Move
Delete
Rewrite
also helpful resources. For example, the Isaiah and his fellow students began models for teaching writing in that
Common Core State Standards for writing expository essays the year before students learn specific steps to
English Language Arts (National learning FIX; however, when given a accomplish writing tasks as teachers
Governors Association Center for Best prompt, most students wrote a single scaffold students’ learning. However,
Practices & Council of Chief State paragraph that was no more than four with SRSD, teachers focus more on
School Officers, 2010) suggest that to five sentences in length. Isaiah wrote helping students self-regulate their use
expository essays include a claim, two paragraphs, each containing only of the writing strategy. Self-regulated
reasons, and a conclusion. two sentences. After reviewing students’ procedures include goal setting, self-
After learning about the elements of preassessment prompts, Isaiah’s teacher instruction, and self-monitoring. There
the target genre, students can introduced FIX as a powerful way to are six instructional stages in the SRSD
incorporate their knowledge of revise expository essays. instructional framework (Harris et al.
important elements when applying FIX 2008), and teachers can reorder,
to make decisions about what is combine, modify, or reteach them as
SRSD
working and what needs to be changed needed. The six stages of instruction as
in their papers. Finally, prior to Students should learn about revising as they relate to FIX are as follows:
teaching FIX, teachers should ask part of an overall writing program—
students to write and revise an essay as one that provides students with •• Stage 1: Discuss it. Teachers
a preassessment. This assessment can extended time to write for authentic provide an overview of FIX, explain
serve as a baseline as well as highlight purposes. When teaching Isaiah and what it means to make meaningful
specific areas that need to be targeted his peers FIX, we used SRSD (Harris changes, and give a rationale for
during instruction. et al., 2008). SRSD is similar to other each step of the strategy.
Weeks 5–6 Model the strategy M: Model how to use FIX, make meaningful changes, use
Support and practice the strategy self-statements
W: Students use FIX as a class with teacher guidance
F: S
tudents use FIX in small groups of 2–3 with teacher
guidance
M: Students use FIX in small groups with teacher guidance
W: Students use FIX in small groups with teacher feedback
F: Students use FIX in small groups with teacher feedback
Weeks 7–8 Independent practice Students use FIX, make self-statements, and chart
meaningful changes until they reach criterion (e.g., across
five sessions)
Discuss how to use FIX to revise stories and other genres
aStudents should integrate revising skills (e.g., adding and deleting text) as they learn new tactics.
two questions on the red card: “Does my and highlighting problematic across phrases and sentences that
statement [claim] answer the prompt? sentences. He reminds students that need to be changed.” During this step,
Yes! Do I have enough support? Yes! I there are four ways to make changes, he looks at each question from the
have three [supporting ideas]!” He then
asks, “Do I have enough examples? I
need more details!” then adds, “I can When teaching FIX, it is important to develop
read without listening to my sister and students’ knowledge and skills related to the four
her friends run around making noise.”
basic tactics for revision (add, move, delete,
He ends Stage 1 with a reflection about
his conclusion: “Does my conclusion rewrite).
sum up my ideas? My conclusion does
not sum up my ideas—it seems like I
repeated my statements, [so I will rewrite referring to the green cards for yellow card (see Figure 3) and begins
and] write more! Then he adds several guidance. He begins by saying, “Now I Stage 3 of FIX by executing changes
ideas to “the library is great . . . .” need to identify less obvious (add, move, delete, rewrite) in
When beginning Stage 2 of FIX, he problems—I am going to go through response to each problem. He uses
models how to identify problems, each statement on my yellow cards “+” to indicate where he plans to add
using the questions on the yellow card and use my highlighter when I come text and writes “Out of all my favorite
places” to show the actual text that is Although other changes could have been using short, rapid-fire drills in game-
going to be added. made to make the essay even stronger, like exercises. Allow students to
Throughout Stages 2 and 3, he asks, he ended the lesson at this point paraphrase strategy steps as long as the
“Did I execute changes to make my believing that further changes would meaning of the red, yellow, and green
paper better?” and models coping and have been hard for students to follow cards remains intact. Asking students
self-reinforcement by saying, “This isn’t and above their skill level. It is important to memorize at least one self-
hard, I can do this” and “I like this for teachers to know that before instruction (choosing goal setting,
change; my essay is better than before.” modeling, they should plan what to say self-monitoring, or managing the
He then rereads his essay, modeling how and do so that they can comfortably strategy) when using the strategy helps
to check that changes to his essay made demonstrate the steps and self-regulation students adapt self-statements to meet
sense. Last, Isaiah’s teacher corrects a procedures in FIX in front of students. their individual needs.
spelling and a punctuation error before
finishing for the day, explaining that During Stage 4, Isaiah’s teacher
editing was done after revising. Stage 4: Memorize it. In this stage, quizzes students about the strategy steps
teachers ask students to commit to and self-regulatory statements for 5 to 10
Revising is a highly individualized learning the meaning of FIX, its steps, minutes once or twice a week until most
process (no two revisions look the same) and the metacognitive statements that students can remember the mnemonic.
and is messy to describe. Figure 4 shows are most helpful for each individual. He reviews each of the strategy steps on
the essay Isaiah’s teacher revised. Memorization can be encouraged by flash cards a few times during
Out of all my favorite places, I choose to go to the library. I can sit in the library and read books in peace and quiet.
There are also book fairs where I can win prizes and have a good excuse to spend my time reading. A day at the library is
one of the most exciting and relaxing ways to spend an afternoon.
First, the library is packed with an endless amount of great books. Fantasies and science fiction can be found on one
shelf. You can also find books on tape, CDs, and documentaries throughout the library. I enjoy reading books about dino-
saurs, devils, and mythical characters, which are all easy to find in the library.
Another reason I like going to the library is that it’s quiet and when I read I’m not interrupted. I can read without listen-
ing to my sister and her friends run around making noise. I also can’t be asked to do chores around the house.
Last of all, there are book fairs at the library that are a lot of fun. I can win prizes for answering questions correctly.
There are also treasure hunts where kids win prizes for finding information from certain books. When I need a break from
the fun and games, I find a cozy place to sit and read.
The library is great. It is the most productive way to spend an afternoon. It has more books and information than you
can imagine. It provides the peace and quiet that everyone needs from time to time. Most importantly, it creates an atmo-
sphere where learning is fun. No wonder this is the place I always want to be.
for students to revise their work work, we established the following During Stage 6, Isaiah puts his colored
independently. Ask students to use the criterion for ending independent cards face down under his essay as he
strategy and self-regulation procedures practice: Students needed to (a) recall revises his essay. His teacher has
on their own, but allow them to ask the strategy; (b) use the strategy twice suggested that each child write down and
questions (and monitor their progress) without relying on red, yellow, or green cross out the letters F, I, and X while
as they work. After students make cards; (c) generate essays that included working through each step of the strategy.
meaningful changes independently, they all the elements of an expository essay; That way, he can monitor their progress
may be encouraged to use the strategy and (d) make at least five meaningful without asking them to stop working.
without using the colored cards. In our changes. Later, after students finish revising, they
www.cec.sped.org/LCE
For more information: Email [email protected] or call 1-888-232-7733
242 Council for Exceptional Children