Rebellious Wives, Neglectful Husbands: Controversies in Modern Qur'anic Commentaries Hadia Mubarak PDF Download
Rebellious Wives, Neglectful Husbands: Controversies in Modern Qur'anic Commentaries Hadia Mubarak PDF Download
https://ebookmass.com/product/rebellious-wives-neglectful-
husbands-controversies-in-modern-quranic-commentaries-hadia-
mubarak/
Robots Husbands
https://ebookmass.com/product/robots-husbands/
https://ebookmass.com/product/stuffed-the-sandwich-cookie-book-
heather-mubarak/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-temporality-of-determinacy-
functional-relations-in-metaphysics-and-science-conor-husbands/
https://ebookmass.com/product/three-single-wives-gina-lamanna/
Three Single Wives Gina Lamanna
https://ebookmass.com/product/three-single-wives-gina-lamanna-2/
https://ebookmass.com/product/three-single-wives-gina-lamanna-3/
https://ebookmass.com/product/three-single-wives-gina-lamanna-4/
https://ebookmass.com/product/sports-in-society-issues-and-
controversies-12th-ed-edition-coakley/
https://ebookmass.com/product/our-wives-under-the-sea-julia-
armfield-2/
Rebellious Wives, Neglectful Husbands
Rebellious Wives,
Neglectful Husbands
Controversies in Modern Qurʾanic
Commentaries
HA D IA M U BA R A K
1
3
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers
the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education
by publishing worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University
Press in the UK and certain other countries.
ISBN 978–0–19–755330–5
DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780197553305.001.0001
1 3 5 7 9 8 6 4 2
Printed by Integrated Books International, United States of America
To my beloved Omar, Jinan, and Ibrahim
and to my parents,
Fatima and Hashem.
My success was built
on the backs of your sacrifices.
Contents
Introduction 1
1. Ruptures and Continuities in Modern Islamic Thought 19
2. Deflecting the Colonial Gaze: Women in Modern Qurʾanic
Exegesis 51
3. Modern Approaches to Qurʾanic Interpretation 69
4. Sexually Neglectful Husbands: Classical and Modern
Interpretations of Q. 4:128 98
5. Rebellious Wives: Medieval and Modern
Interpretations of Q. 4:34 126
6. A New Rationalization for Polygyny: Medieval and Modern
Interpretations of Q. 4:3 162
7. Men’s “Degree”: An Unconditional Privilege? 198
Conclusion 237
Notes 253
Bibliography 315
Index 333
Note on Translation, Transliteration,
and Dates
I felt I had nothing left to give. My father, Hashem Mubarak, has provided un-
wavering encouragement. My siblings, Mona, Mohammad, Samia, Nusaiba,
and Abdullah, and my husband’s parents, Azhar and Zainab, gifted me with
motivation and empathy throughout my writing. To my children, Ibrahim
and Jinan, I hope that you will one day read this book and recognize within it
your own invaluable contribution as sources of my daily joy and inspiration.
Thank you for everything.
The impetus for examining the impact of modernity on exegetes’ gender
interpretations comes from my conversations with the late Professor Barbara
Stowasser (d. 2013), one of my first mentors in tafsīr studies during my grad-
uate and doctoral studies. Although she tragically passed away in the midst
of my doctoral studies, her critical mentorship pushed me to appreciate
the exegetical tafsīr tradition as a genre of its own with an intellectual his-
tory. Stowasser’s work on women and tafsīr was important not just because
of its contribution to the field of gender in Islamic studies but also because
it brought attention to the important role of hermeneutics in the produc-
tion of religious knowledge. As such, my book builds upon her scholarly
contributions to this field by working within the boundaries of the exegetical
tradition while simultaneously paying appropriate attention to the historical
and intellectual contexts of the modern Qurʾanic commentaries I examine.
A first-rate scholar, Stowasser is dearly missed.
Introduction
Nowhere has the question of divine intent been as pressing for Muslims in
the past two decades than in the field of women and gender in the Qurʾan.
In the twenty-first century, Muslim women are caught in a polarity of inter-
pretations regarding their position and rights within a religious tradition
that spans fifteen centuries. The status of Muslim women in the world today
is by no means monolithic. In some Muslim-majority countries, women
have been elected as heads of state and have a higher percentage of higher
education compared to men.1 In other Muslim-majority states, however,
women still struggle with an unequal standard of citizenship, character-
ized by restrictions on travel, divorce, and custody rights.2 To what extent
are current practices—or their justifications—embedded in religious texts?
Is the Qurʾan, Islam’s primary scripture, inherently patriarchal and even
misogynist, as reflected by the actions of extremists, or is it egalitarian and
empowering to women, as a new wave of Muslim activists and scholars have
argued?3 While this question lies at the center of a fierce academic debate
among scholars in the twenty-first century, this debate was first inaugurated
at the eve of modernity.
One of the most urgent theological issues for Muslims in the modern pe-
riod is the search for divine will, free of the fallibilities of human interpreta-
tion. The return to the Qurʾan as the primary source for Muslims is partially
informed by the quest for divine meaning, divorced from meanings imposed
and projected on it from centuries of human interpretation. Amid the rapidly
changing contexts of modernity, the Qurʾan has served as an unchanging,
stable anchor for Muslims in their quest to both withstand and overcome
the uncertainties of the modern world. Yet the project of determining the
Qurʾan’s meaning, known as Qurʾanic exegesis, has been far from monolithic,
static, or conclusive. While Muslims universally agree upon the Qurʾan’s
primacy in guiding Muslim affairs, modernity has produced a multiplicity
of approaches to Qurʾanic interpretation. I define modernity primarily as
it is understood in the field of sociology, as a set of social conditions, pro-
cesses, and discourses that encompass new structures of power, specifically
2 Rebellious Wives, Neglectful Husbands
The qualities that distinguish one mufassir [exegete] from another lie less
in their conclusions as to what the Qurʾanic text means than in their devel-
opment and display of techniques which mark their participation in and
mastery of a literary discipline. Just as the skill of, say, a football player can
be recognized only in relation to a complex body of rules (variously con-
stituted by such things as white lines on grass or a complex and developing
off-side rule), so too the literary skills of a mufassir must be assessed not
in terms of the end product (the Qurʾan explained), but in terms of their
skillful participating in a rule-governed activity.24
rebellious wives, and the liability for a husband’s disinterest or neglect of his
wife. Rather than make sweeping and often unsubstantiated generalizations
about a scholarly genre that spans several centuries, I find it more construc-
tive to identify the ways in which patriarchal readings emerge and become
entrenched in this genre.
What is the origin of androcentrism or patriarchal readings in the genre
of Qurʾanic exegesis? Is androcentrism a function of exegetes’ methods,
conclusions, or worldviews, or are they inherent in the Qurʾanic text? If pa-
triarchal interpretations are a function of the methods that medieval exegetes
used, then do modern exegetes’ use of new hermeneutical tools disrupt pa-
triarchal interpretations of the Qurʾan? Chapters 4 through 7 interrogate the
origins of textual androcentrism in the Qurʾan by identifying the ways in
which exegetes introduce patriarchal readings of the Qurʾan and pointing
out moments in which they challenge patriarchal readings within the tafsīr
tradition. I define androcentrism as the privileging of the male and mas-
culinity as the normative self against which the female and the feminine is
measured. I employ the notion of patriarchy not simply as a system of hier-
archy that favors men but as the very processes of thought that justify male
privilege, authority, and power over women.
Language: English
WORKS OF
BRET HARTE
## SELECTED STORIES
## MARUJA
## CONDENSED NOVELS
## NEW BURLESQUES
## DEVIL'S FORD
## SNOW-BOUND AT EAGLE'S
## URBAN SKETCHES
## CLARENCE
## CRESSY
## A SAPPHO OF GREEN SPRINGS
## FRONTIER STORIES
## SALOMY JANE
## GABRIEL CONROY
THANKFUL BLOSSOM
DICKENS IN CAMP
EXCELSIOR
TENNESSEE'S PARTNER
THE QUEEN OF THE PIRATE ISLE
TABLES OF CONTENTS OF
VOLUMES
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
THE RIGHT EYE OF THE
THE LUCK OF ROARING COMMANDER
CAMP
NOTES BY FLOOD AND FIELD
THE OUTCASTS OF POKER
AN EPISODE OF FIDDLETOWN
FLAT
BARKER'S LUCK
MIGGLES
A YELLOW DOG
TENNESSEE'S PARTNER
A MOTHER OF FIVE
THE IDYL OF RED GULCH
BULGER'S REPUTATION
BROWN OF CALAVERAS
IN THE TULES
HIGH-WATER MARK
A CONVERT OF THE MISSION
A LONELY RIDE
THE INDISCRETION OF ELSBETH
THE MAN OF NO ACCOUNT
THE DEVOTION OF ENRIQUEZ
MLISS
CONTENTS
CONTENTS
CONTENTS
CHAPTER I CHAPTER V
CHAPTER II CHAPTER VI
CHAPTER III CHAPTER VII
CHAPTER IV CHAPTER VIII
MARUJA
By Bret Harte
CONTENTS
CONTENTS
CONDENSED NOVELS
By Bret Harte
CONTENTS
NEW BURLESQUES
By Bret Harte
CONTENTS
CONTENTS
A MILLIONAIRE OF ROUGH-
AND-READY
By Bret Harte
CONTENTS
CONTENTS
DEVIL'S FORD
by Bret Harte
CONTENTS
SNOW-BOUND AT EAGLE'S
by Bret Harte
CONTENTS
CHAPTER
SNOW-BOUND AT CHAPTER VI
III
EAGLE'S CHAPTER
CHAPTER VII
CHAPTER I IV CHAPTER
CHAPTER II VIII
CHAPTER V
CONTENTS
CHAPTER I.
CHAPTER V CHAPTER VIII
CHAPTER II.
CHAPTER VI CHAPTER IX
CHAPTER III.
CHAPTER VII CHAPTER X
CHAPTER IV
ebookmasss.com