92311
92311
https://ebookmeta.com/product/the-violent-hero-heracles-in-the-
greek-imagination-1st-edition-katherine-hsu-lu/
i
Also available from Bloomsbury
ii
The Violent Hero
Heracles in the Greek Imagination
Katherine Lu Hsu
iii
BLOOMSBURY ACADEMIC
Bloomsbury Publishing Plc
50 Bedford Square, London, WC1B 3DP, UK
1385 Broadway, New York, NY 10018, USA
29 Earlsfort Terrace, Dublin 2, Ireland
BLOOMSBURY, BLOOMSBURY ACADEMIC and the Diana logo are trademarks of
Bloomsbury Publishing Plc
First published in Great Britain 2021
This edition published in 2022
Copyright © Katherine Lu Hsu, 2021
Katherine Lu Hsu has asserted her right under the Copyright, Designs and
Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as Author of this work.
For legal purposes the Acknowledgments on p. x–xi constitute an extension of
this copyright page.
Cover design: Terry Woodley
Cover image: Hercules and Nessus, Florence, Italy. Photography by Jeremy Villasis/Getty
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted
in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying,
recording, or any information storage or retrieval system, without prior
permission in writing from the publishers.
Bloomsbury Publishing Plc does not have any control over, or responsibility for, any third-party
websites referred to or in this book. All internet addresses given in this
book were correct at the time of going to press. The author and publisher regret
any inconvenience caused if addresses have changed or sites have ceased
to exist, but can accept no responsibility for any such changes.
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Hsu, Katherine Lu, author.
Title: The violent hero : Heracles in the Greek imagination / Katherine Lu Hsu.
Description: New York : Bloomsbury Academic, 2020. | Includes bibliographical references and
index. | Summary: “This book uses the mythological hero Heracles as a lens for investigating the
nature of heroic violence in archaic and classical Greek literature, from Homer through to
Aristophanes. Heracles was famous for his great victories as much as for his notorious failures.
Driving each of these acts is his heroic violence, an ambivalent force that can offer communal
protection as well as cause grievous harm. Drawing on evidence from epic, lyric poetry, tragedy,
and comedy, this work illuminates the strategies used to justify, constrain, and deflate the
threatening aspects of violence. The mixed results of these strategies also demonstrate how the
figure of Heracles inherently – and stubbornly – resists reform. The diverse character of Heracles’
violent acts reveals an enduring tension in understanding violence: is violence a negative
individual trait, that is to say, the manifestation of an internal state of hostility? Or is it one
specific means to a preconceived end, rather like an instrument whose employment may or may
not be justified? Katherine Lu Hsu explores these evolving attitudes towards individual violence in
the ancient Greek world while also shedding light on timeless debates about the nature of
violence itself”— Provided by publisher.
Identifiers: LCCN 2020024299 (print) | LCCN 2020024300 (ebook) | ISBN 9781350153714
(hardback) | ISBN 9781350153721 (ebook) | ISBN 9781350153738 (epub)
Subjects: LCSH: Heracles (Greek mythological character) | Violence in literature. |
Greek literature—History and criticism.
Classification: LCC PA3015.R5 H448 2020 (print) | LCC PA3015.R5 (ebook) |
DDC 398.20938/02—dc23
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020024299
LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2020024300
ISBN: HB: 978-1-3501-5371-4
PB: 978-1-3501-9170-9
ePDF: 978-1-3501-5372-1
eBook: 978-1-3501-5373-8
Typeset by RefineCatch Limited, Bungay, Suffolk
To find out more about our authors and books visit www.bloomsbury.com
and sign up for our newsletters
For Dave,
coniugi caro
v
vi
Contents
List of Figures ix
Acknowledgments x
Introduction 1
On Violence 2
On Myth 6
On Heracles 10
vii
viii Contents
Notes 183
References 215
Index 237
Figures
1.1 Heracles and Apollo vie for the Delphic tripod. East pediment of
the Siphnian Treasury, c. 525 bce . 31
1.2 Athena leads Heracles to Zeus. Attic black-figure lip-cup,
Vulci, 555–550 bce . 43
2.1 Winged Geryon duels Heracles. Chalcidian black-figure neck
amphora, Vulci, 540–530 bce . 57
2.2 Heracles aims an arrow at Geryon from behind a stone.
Attic black-figure lekythos, c. 500–480 bce . 65
2.3 Heracles crowned. Niobid Crater, Attic red-figure calyx crater,
Orvieto, c. 460–450 bce . 70
4.1 Heracles’ Labor at the Stables of Augeas. Metope from the Temple
of Zeus at Olympia, c. 475 bce . 118
4.2 Heracles and the Stymphalian Birds. Attic black-figure lekythos,
c. 500–480 bce . 120
5.1 Heracles among satyr performers. Pronomos Vase, Attic red-figure
volute crater, c. 400 bce . 137
ix
Acknowledgments
I owe a huge debt of gratitude to many people for their guidance and support in
bringing this book to publication. I remain forever grateful to Ruth Scodel, who
advised me at the University of Michigan and supervised the dissertation from
which this book evolved. Richard Janko has challenged me since my first
semester at Michigan and has continued to support me since. Special thanks are
due to Johanna Hanink, whose questions and insights pushed me to improve the
work at crucial moments.
At Brooklyn College, David Schur and Brian Sowers showed me the ropes of
being an academic and taught me what it means to be a colleague. I have been
supported in various ways by the members of the Classics Department at
Brooklyn College, including Dee Clayman, Danielle Kellogg, JoAnn Luhrs, Gail
Smith, Philip Thibodeau, John Van Sickle, and Liv Yarrow. I honor the memory
of Jim Pletcher, a friend and kind colleague whose wit and brilliant teaching will
be missed. The faculty and staff of the Latin/Greek Institute have inspired and
encouraged me throughout the years: Collomia Charles, Caleb Dance, Carlo
DaVia, Daniel Dooley, Rita Fleischer, Patrick Glauthier, Zachary Hayworth,
Benjamin King, Katia Kosova, Aramis Lopez, Jeremy March, Geoffrey Moseley,
Bill Pagonis, Suklima Roy, Akiva Saunders, Aaron Shapiro, Christopher Simon,
Jeff Ulrich, and Alice Phillips Walden. I will always be indebted to the mentorship
of Hardy Hansen, who taught me Greek, then taught me how to teach Greek, and
then modeled for me how to lead the Institute.
I received helpful feedback and criticisms from audiences at College of the
Holy Cross, Rutgers University, Smith College, Columbia University, Brown
University, Wellesley College, the CUNY Graduate Center, Butler University,
Brooklyn College, Baylor University, Trinity College, Reed College, and Tulane
University. I have also benefited greatly from conversations about this work with
a wide range of colleagues and friends, including Sarah Barbrow, Shuen Chai, Joy
Connolly, Susan Deacy, Elda Granata and Alex Conison, Kathryn Hampton,
Joseph Howley, Athena Kirk, Isabel Köster, Mary Jean McNamara, Amy
Burghardt Muehlbauer, Julie Park, and Jessica Seidman.
I am thankful to Alice Wright, who steered my manuscript through the review
process at Bloomsbury, as well as her colleagues Lily Mac Mahon and Georgina
x
Acknowledgments xi
In the ancient Greek world, violence defined the actions of its heroes. This is
demonstrated nowhere else as clearly as in the myths of Heracles. He was by far
the most popular of all mythological heroes; his fame was widespread,
encompassing the whole of the Greek world, preceding the origin of writing
and lasting for centuries. Narratives about Heracles form a rich and varied
mythological tradition. At its core are the Labors: he defeats threatening beasts
and grotesque monsters, punishes law-breaking villains, and imposes order
upon a chaotic world. Through his incredible skill, endurance, and courage, he
accomplishes seemingly impossible acts that exceed mortal limitations. For
these victories and for his strength, he was celebrated in literature, the arts,
politics, philosophy, and cult. And as the only hero to obtain immortality and an
afterlife on Mount Olympus with his father Zeus, Heracles occupies a uniquely
lofty place in Greek mythology. He comes to take on a position as an aspirational
figure in, for example, the genre of epinician poetry, his role as the patron of
athletes and the gymnasium, and his status as alexikakos, or “averter of evils.”
But the vast range of Heracles’ myths also includes stories in which he wields
his strength towards less celebrated ends: he murders his own family in a fit of
madness, destroys an entire city on a dubious pretext, and dares to attack the
gods themselves. He also frequently plays the buffoon, a stupid glutton enslaved
to a voracious appetite for food, drink, and sex; this Heracles is ripe for mockery
and subject to laughter that brings him low. In these myths, his violence can be
presented as troubling and problematic, making Heracles an example to avoid.
Heracles is thus a figure of great contrast, characterized by excessiveness in all
directions.
His exploits share in common a reliance on heroic violence. Just as Heracles’
myths illustrate the extremities of heroic behavior, they also reveal the unsettled
nature of heroic violence. In the hands of extraordinary individuals like heroes,
violence can bring about communal benefit, through the elimination of threats
to safety and harmony. Yet it can also result in grievous harm, through anti-social
1
2 The Violent Hero
On Violence
Bureeja, 165
Burrh, 157
Burruntaaki, 171
Buryara, 170
Bussunti, 180
Butaer, 137
Butch, 146
Butchudder, 142
Butela, 136
Byll, 196
Bylla, 197
Byrumbseerjella, 168
C.
Catoombura, 37
Chaab, 340
Chakoth, 347
Chakussoo, 342
Chalkurie, 348
Changerie, 349
Cheebook, 350
Cheedah, 426
Cheehuræ, 421
Cheel, 430
Cheenah, 427
Cheenuk, 423
Cherie, 408
Cherkund, 416
Cheetul, 428
Chehtaon, 404
Chellwuk, 376
Chereela, 414
Chermbærie, 386
Chesteymud, Chestee, also Chitemud, 364
Chetuck, 352
Cheylchish, 377
Chikara, 366
Chillie, 378
Chirchirra, 358
Chirownjee, 361
Chirpoota, 359
Chirr, 413
Chœkurk, 370
Chohara, 412
Choke, 396
Choocheroo, 418
Chouch, 403
Chukadana, 374
Chukeerka, 369
Chukond, 371
Chukora, 367
Chukotrah, 372
Chukunder, 365
Chumbeley, 384
Chumbuck, 389
Chumgader, 382
Chunderkanth, 390
Chundun, 392
Chundunsarba, 393
Chundurseha, 417
Chundsoor, 391
Chuttra, 354
Coochilla, 712
D.
Dabeh, 441
Dakh, 445
Daoodie, 440
Darhuld 438
Darum, 442
Deomun, 476
Dhadahwun, 462
Dhaie, 470
Dhak, 467
Dhatura, 465
Dhaw, 463
Dhawa, 464
Dhawnie, 472
Dheerukmola, 473
Dhendus, 474
Dholkudum, 468
Dhumaha, 469
Dhunia, 466
Dhunjawasa, 461
Doodee, 457
Doodka, 459
Doódputeya, 458
Dooparia, 447
Dukdoka, 452
Dundundana, 454
Durba, 449
Durbhur, 450
Dusmool, 451
G.
Gajur, 676
Geerehti, 816
Geerguth, 726
Gehoon, 850
Geroo, 851
Ghafis, 660
Ghar, 661
Ghareekoon, 663
Ghasool, 662
Gheyd, 835
Ghirb, 664
Ghoghaie, 658
Ghora, 820
Gillo, 754
Godoon, 793
Goh, 801
Gomenduk, 788
Goodhul, 718
Googul, 809
Gooha, 811
Goolkhairoo, 756
Goolur, 812
Gooma, 789
Goondinie, 810
Goond, 768
Goondur, 776
Goonma, 813
Goongchee, 828
Goor, 731
Goorcha, 786
Gota, 805
Gowrbaghan, 792
Gowreh, 659
Gowrohun, 671
Gowruk, 794
Goww, 790
Gowdunta, 804
Gudha, 716
Gudloon, 717
Gugundool, 751
Gulbar, 755
Gumbhar, 764
Gundheel, 775
Gundhka, 783
Gundhur, 782
Gunduk, 780
Gunyar, 769
Gurehri, 723
Gyndha, 837
H.
Habooka, 1052
Haimowtie, 1051
Haloon, 1025
Harun, 1031
Heeng, 1047
Heera, 1050
Heeraclokhi, 1048
Heerakussees, 1049
Hhoobaer, 1046
Hingool, 1053
Hingote, 1042
Hingpootrie, 1044
Hoolhool, 1040
Hoorhoora, 1027
Hudbjora, 1026
Huldia, 1039
Huldoo, 1041
Huns, 1045
Hunspeedie, 1043
Hurbarbeorhi, 1033
Hurr, 1032
Hurtaal, 1029
Husthal, 1035
Husthchinkhar, 1037
Husthkool, 1034
Husthuk, 1036
Hyrbee, 1030
I.
Inderain, 74
J.
Jaal, 345
Jaiey, 346
Jaiphill, 343
Jamalgotay, 383
Jamin, 338
Jatie, 339
Jawakhar, 402
Jawansa, 395
Jeengha, 409
Jeepaul, 431
Jeewuk, 422
Jest, 363
Jhirberie, 419
Jholputtur, 405
Jhow, 415
Jillpeelbuka, 375
Jojakhar, 411
Joonk, 400
Jooqunoo, 373
Juhan, 401
Juhi, 398
Jungliechuha, 388
Junkar, 410
Junth, 394
Junthmook, 387
Jutamaasie, 353
Juwar, 399
Jyaphupp, 420
K.
Kakjunga, 665
Kakolie, 667
Kaksaag, 668
Kalakora, 685
Kalizeerie, 679
Kalseenbie, 682
Kanakutchoo, 674
Kandagolhi, 690
Kangeerug, 681
Kanghi, 689
Kanjee, 670
Kans, 666
Kansi, 682
Kapithar Jug, 696
Kapoor, 691
Kapoorbile, 693
Kapoorie, 699
Karela, 733
Kareyl, 721
Karunj, 722
Karownda, 720
Kasht, 680
Kastipadile, 687
Katchloon, 686
Kathmanda, 684
Kawaal, 798
Kawul, 765
Kawulguth, 766
Kela, 846
Keloondha, 760
Kenkra, 838
Keora, 843
Kethki, 844
Kewanch, 845
Khand, 825
Khaperia, 823
Khelowrie, 829
Kherboozah, 436
Khergosh, 435
Kherie, 817
Khesoo, 833
Khewumberie, 832
Khopra, 831
Khorasanee (Adjwain), 25
Khull, 830
Khutmnl, 821
Khylakhylie, 826
Khynth, 834
Kinchua, 836
Kobhee, 791
Kokla, 800
Kookra, 748
Kookrie, 749
Kooktunduk, 819
Kookurbangra, 807
Kookurchundie, 806
Kooleejan, 758
Koolunta, 759
Koonch, 796
Koondoorie, 773
Koonj, 795
Koonja, 778
Kootki, 701
Kora, 735
Korund, 730
Kowadoorie, 802
Kowla, 767
Kowrie, 797
Krishndaan, 724
Kudum, 715
Kujoor, 822
Kukora, 747
Kukrie, 750
Kukrownda, 753
Kukrownela, 746
Kulownjee, 761
Kulumbuk, 757
Kumbeela, 779
Kundurdolie, 772
Kunghi, 784
Kungni, 774
Kunkole, 770
Kunoocha, 781
Kurkund, 734
Kurkura, 727
Kurna, 719
Kurni, 736
Kurr, 732
Kurrukphill, 737
Kurwanuk, 725
Kussees, 745
Kussoombh, 743
Kutai, 704
Kutara, 702
Kutchaloo, 709
Kutcherie, 713
Kutchnar, 708
Kutchoor, 714
Kutchua, 711
Kuteera, 703
Kuth, 707
Kuthael, 700
Kutoonbur, 705
Kutputrie, 706
Kyloot, 842
Kyrnie, 818
Kyte, 840
Kytiputtrie, 841
L.
Laak, 852
Lahi, 853
Lahsun, 875
Lahusoonia, 877
Langullie, 854
Lasora, 876
Lawa, 855
Lichmiphill, 860
Lichmuna, 859
Lobaan, 869
Lobeia, 874
Lodh, 864
Loha, 867
Lolie, 871
Lomrie, 872
Long, 868
Longmushk, 873
Loni, 870
Loodh’phup, 863
Loonia, 866
Lubhera, 855
Lublie, or Lolie, 856
Lydoaloo, 858
M.
Maachik, 884
Maad, 882
Maankund, 886
Maat, 889
Madhooie, 879
Mahameed, 961
Mahaneem, 957
Mahasutawurie, 959
Mahawunth, 960
Mahawur, 962
Mahesingie, 888
Mahkee, 955
Mahwa, 954
Maien, 883
Malknagnie, 878
Malook, 887
Maoarowbnee, 880
Mayoorabuka, 965
Mayursuka, 964
Meed, 971
Meetanioboo, 972
Mendha, 966
Mendi, 958
Merch, 909
Merchai, 910
Merg, 906
Mernal, 912
Methie, 968
Mogra, 951
Mohoka, 956
Mohuk, 936
Mokhun, 937
Moocherae, 935
Moodukpurnie, 901
Moogtaphill, 927
Moojkuod, 896
Mookul, 944
Moom, 943
Moondie, 927
Moondookpurnie, 930
Moong, 938
Moonga, 947
Moonjee, 933
Moora, 905
Moorhurrie, 904
Moorhuttee, 908
Moorsheka, 950
Mooser, 934
Morba, 941
More, 940
Moth, 939
Motha, 942
Motie, 946
Mowlserie, 899
Muchechi, 898
Mucheli, 893
Mudden, 894
Muddenphill, 948
Mudh, 900
Mudhkurkuttie, 903
Mudhoolka, 902
Mudhraa, 897
Muggur, 918
Mujeeth, 895
Muko, 919
Mukoond, 917
Mullagheer, 924
Mulleen, 926
Mulleka, 925
Mundar, 931
Munn, 928
Munmal, 929
Murdok, 979
Murorphillie, 913
Mursa, 911
Murua, 907
Musakunie, 952
Musoor, 915
Mustchagundka, 916
Muttreegurba, 892
Muttur 891
Mydhasingie, 969
Mynphill, 967
Myoorjung, 970
N.
Naaœ, 983
Nadey, 980
Nagermotha, 981
Nagbulla, 982
Nagdown, 977
Nagdumnie, 978
Nagesur, 976
Nainjooth, 1018
Naringee, 975
Naryit, 974
Neeb, 1015
Neel, 1013
Neelgau, 1017
Neelasabood, 1014
Neelkant, 1008
Neelkunti, 1019
Neelobe, 1016
Neenboo, 1013
Neendie, 1009
Neenuk, 1006
Neeturbala, 1004
Nergoondie, 986
Nerkutchoor, 985
Newarrie, 1001
Newla, 1007
Neyrmellie, 987
Nirbissie, 984
Niswut, 988
Nowllee, 1003
Nowsader, 1002
Nuk, 989
Nukchecknie, 990
Nullwa, 991