Behavior of Nested Z-shaped Purlins
Behavior of Nested Z-shaped Purlins
Scholars' Mine
International Specialty Conference on Cold- (1986) - 8th International Specialty Conference on
Formed Steel Structures Cold-Formed Steel Structures
Nov 11th
Carl E. Kurt
Recommended Citation
Robertson, Gergory W. and Kurt, Carl E., "Behavior of Nested Z-shaped Purlins" (1986). International Specialty Conference on Cold-
Formed Steel Structures. 3.
http://scholarsmine.mst.edu/isccss/8iccfss/8iccfss-session2/3
This Article - Conference proceedings is brought to you for free and open access by Scholars' Mine. It has been accepted for inclusion in International
Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures by an authorized administrator of Scholars' Mine. This work is protected by U. S. Copyright
Law. Unauthorized use including reproduction for redistribution requires the permission of the copyright holder. For more information, please contact
[email protected].
Eighth International Specialty Conference on Cold-Formed Steel Structures
St. Louis, Missouri, U.S.A., November 11-12, 1986
By
1 2
Gregory W. Robertson, and Carl E. Kurt
SUMMARY
INTRODUCTION
LITERATURE REVIEW
1
Designer, Butler Manufacturing Company, Kansas City, Missouri;
formerly, graduate student, Civil Engineering Department, University
of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas 66045.
2
Associate Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, University of
Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas 66045.
95
96 EIGHTH SPECIALTY CONFERENCE
Purlin depths of 8 and 9 1/2 inches (203 and 241 mm) with a web
and flange thickness of 0.061 inches (1.5 mm) were tested. For each
purlin depth, basic overlap tests were conducted on four specimens
with varying overlap lengths (See Table 1). Each specimen is desig-
nated by two numbers separated by the letter 8 e.g. 9.5836. Numbers
before the B refer to the purlin depth, in inches, while the numbers
after the B refer to twice the overlap length, in inches. The over-
lap length is the distance between the centerline of the overlapped
purlin to the bolt line in the overlapped section (See Figure 1).
Initially, single purlins, designated 8.0BS and 9.5BS, were tested to
set a baseline for strength and stiffness properties.
The bolt line shear specimens tested are shown in Table 1. The
addition to the normal specimen designation includes the material
type (B-Brass and S-Steel) and the bolt size in inches. An 8 inch
(203 mm) deep purlin with a 16 1/2 inch (419 mm) overlap was chosen
for all bolt line shear tests.
attached to either side of the purlin web to prevent the purlin ends
from twisting during tests. The rollers are supported on two 5 by 5
by 1/4 inch (127 x 127 x 6.35 mm) structural tubes spanning 13 feet
(3.96 m). These tubes served as a support for the end connections
and a base for the entire test fixture. The building frame was
simulated with a W-section having a 5 1/4 inch (133 mm) flange width.
Lateral support was provided by a brace attached to the simulated
building frame and the bottom flange of the purlin.
The results of the basic overlap tests indicate that the ul-
timate frame force, or ultimate strength, of the 8 inch (203 mm) deep
purlins is approximately equal to the ultimate strength of the 9 1/2
inch (241 mm) deep purlins. This result occurred for the following
two reasons. First, the 9.5B specimens experienced additional dis-
tortions, or buckles, in the web areas, possibly reducing the
ultimate strength of the purlin. Second, the ultimate tensile
strength of the 8 inch (203 mm) deep purlins was found to be higher
than the ultimate tensile strength of the 9 1/2 inch (241 mm) deep
purlins. The coupon test results for the 8 inch (203 mm) deep pur-
lins gave an average yield stress of 70.1 ksi (483 MPa) and an
average ultimate stress of 89.2 ksi (615 MPa). The results for the 9
1/2 inch (241 mm) deep purlins gave an average yield stress of 57.7
ksi (398 MPa) and an average ultimate stress of 80.1 ksi (552 MPa).
The ultimate moment for each basic overlap test, (M u )' is non-
dimensionalized by dividing by the corresponding single purlin
ultimate moment, (M s )' A plot of the ultimate moment ratio versus
the overlap length to purlin depth ratio, Lid, is presented in Figure
3. The capac it Y 0 f the nes ted pur 1 ins increased as the LI d ratio
increased. At an Lid ratio of 2, the moment capacity of the nested
purlin is approximately 1.5 times the capacity of a single purlin.
The strength of nested purlins equals the strength of a single purlin
when an Lid ratio of 0.5 is reached.
(1)
12 eff
where
12 eff Effective moment of inertia in the overlapped
.
sectIon (.In,
4 mm 4)
11 eff Effective moment of inertia for single purlin
(in 4 , mm 4 )
p Frame load (lbs, kN)
t.M Measured deflection at frame load P (in, mm)
~ Total length of test purlin (in, mm)
L Overlap length (in, mm)
A Overlap length to purlin length ratio (L/~)
e (0.5 - X)
E Modulus of elasticity (ksi, MPa).
To determine the correlation between the bolt line force and the
frame force, bolt line shear tests were conducted on 8 inch (203 mm)
deep purlins with a 16 1/2 inch (419 mm) overlap length. A tabula-
tion of the results from the bolt line shear tests are presented in
Table 4. Each test is designated by it's bolt type, material and
size, followed by the bolt test number. The ultimate frame load in
the second column refers to the frame load on the purlin at the time
of either a beam failure or bolt failure. The third column is the
total bolt shear capacity in each bolt line of the overlapped
section. This quantity is twice the capacity of the single bolt
since two bolts lie in each bolt line. The failure mode is desig-
nated as either a beam or bolt failure.
The results of the bolt line shear tests indicate that the
ultimate frame load for the 8.0B33 specimen is approximately 2830
pounds (12.6 kN). From the results of the B312 tests, a range of
bolt line forces at ultimate load was established. This range is
between 2948 and 3122 pounds (13.1 and 13.9 kN). Thus, the load
through each bolt line at purlin failure is approximately 3035 pounds
(13.5 kN). Therefore, the bolt shear in each bolt line is equal to
3035/2830 (13.5/12.6), or 1.07, times the frame force.
Based on the experimental data from the bolt line shear tests, a
simple computer model was developed that predicted the bolt line
force. Simple planeframe elements were chosen to simulate the 8 inch
(203 mm) deep purlin and the 16 1/2 inch (419 mm) overlap length used
in the bolt line shear tests. A stiff link was chosen to approximate
the centerline connection between the purlin and building frame. Two
additional links were used to represent overlap bolt line. A
schematic of the computer model is shown in Figure 5.
CONCLUSIONS
The results of the bolt line shear tests indicated that the
ultimate force through each bolt line was slightly higher than the
ultimate frame force for the 8 inch (203 mm) deep purlin with a 16
1/2 inch (419 mm) overlap length. The computer model closely es-
timated the bolt line forces measured experimentally. The computer
model also indicated that the bolt line forces may approach 1.5 times
the frame force when larger diameter bolts are used.
The results of the basic overlap tests indicated that under high
loading conditions, web buckling was more severe for the 9 1/2 inch
(241 mm) deep purlins than for the 8 inch (203 mm) deep purlins. For
purlins of higher depth to web thickness ratios, web buckling over
the building frame could become more severe.
Z·SHAPED PURLINS 103
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
REFERENCES
APPENDIX - NOTATIONS
B (0.5 - I.)
I 112" (TY~)
1~ ____'-:tti:=~~~~4~+~fk=~~~===:R:=:V2~t*l:='
P/2
6'-0" 6'-d'
2.0r-~-----------------------------------------------'
-e--- _----e-
~
.. 1.0
::J
;:;; (3 - 1'1.0 IN. PURUN
-----TIGHT BOLlS
- - - FINGER-TIGHT BOLlS
0.0 '---'---L-'---'---'------'--'--'--'--'--'--'--'---'----'----'---'---'---'---'---'---'---'---'
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
OVERLAP LENGTH/PURUN DEPTH (LId)
1.5
(3 - B.O IN. PURUN
-----TIGHT BOLTS
1.0
:::II
H
-......
:::u'
N 0.5
H
0.0 LJLJ---L---L-L--L-L---L....L-L--L-...l-..l.-.L-.L-L-'--'---'--'---'---'--'---'--'
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
~l'I:"--------t--ib'-1:'":
2 REPRESEN1l~
LINK
BOLT LINES
PLANEFRAME ELEMENTS
NOTE: 8.0 IN. PURUN WITH 16.5 IN. OVERlAP.
1.50r---------------------------------------~--------_,
0.50
o 2 3 7 8 9 10
Table 1
TEST MATRIX
'"
..-;
H
<!J
9.589 9.5 4.5 1/2 A307 T
> -- -- ---- -----
0 8.08S 8.0
u
.'-;
til 8.0833 8.0 16.5 1/2 A307 T
ro
"'" 8.0815 8.0 7.5 1/2 A307 T
H
8.0833825-1 8.0 16.5 1/4 B FT
ro
<!J
T = TIGHT BOLTS
FT FINGER-TIGHT 80LTS
8 = 8RASS BOLTS
S = STEEL 80LTS
Z-SHAPED PURLINS 109
Table 2
Table 3
--
Bolt Bolt Bolt Average
Number Diameter Material Ultimate
(in. ) Shear (lbs.)
Table 4
r------- --
Bolt Ultimate Frame Total Bolt Shear Failure
Type Load (lbs.) Capacity (lbs.) Mode
===-:~ ~-
B25-1 2980 2626 Bolts
- - - r-" --
S25-1 2850 2948 Beam *
'------- -
B25-1 2800 2948 Bolts
r--.----- r---- --
B25-1 2675 3122 Beam
-
* HOLE LOCATED 2.75 INCHES FROM TOP FLANGE.
NOTE: ALL TESTS ON 8.0 IN. PURLIN WITH 16.5 IN. OVERLAP.