paper
paper
ASSIGNMENT INFORMATION
Full/ Part
Full
Assignment
Assignment brief IV
Dr.Vivek Mohan
by
Assessor
Assignment due
date
1|Page
ASSESSMENT FEEDBACK
TO BE FILLED BY THE ASSESSOR
Assessment type Marks Marks Awarded
Executive Summary 5
Introduction 15
Literature Review 20
Application of knowledge and understanding 20
Change Implementation Plan 30
Recommendations and Conclusions 10
Overall Score 100
Overall Marks achieved
GRADE ACHIEVED
Summative Feedback by Assessor for further improvement
2|Page
Learning Outcome 1: Critically analyze the significance of Strategic Human Resources
Management and its changing landscape in organizations.
PC 1.1 Critically analyze the purpose and functions of Human Resources Management in
organizations.
PC 1.2 Review the scope of Staffing, Development and Compensation HRM activities in your
chosen organization.
PC 1.4 Critically discuss the paradigm shift in various perspectives on Strategic Human
Resources Management affecting the contemporary HRM issues of organizations.
PC 2.1 Critically discuss the link between Human Resources Management activities and
Organizational Performance.
PC 2.2 Apply critical analysis of the contributions of Human Resources Management activities
to the Organizational Performance Outcomes in an organization.
PC 2.3 Explore and discuss the impact of Human Resources Management on Organizational
development.
PC 3.1 Evaluate a range of Leadership theories and models for organizational management.
PC 3.2 Explore and discuss application of various leadership theories and models for
organizational management.
PC 3.3 Conceptualize the best/most suited leadership styles for organizational development for
your chosen organization.
Module description
The purpose of this module is to discuss and explain the role of strategic HRM and
leadership practices in an organization and their influence on the overall performance and
competence of the organization. This module is designed to develop an understanding about the
contemporary practices of strategic human resource management and the paradigm shift in the
approaches and methods related to various functions of HRM like strategic recruitment and
selection, strategic leadership, strategic performance management and employee development to
name a few. It also highlights the role and significance of leadership styles and practices during
the planning and implementation of change in the organization. Upon successfully completing
the module, the participants will be able to have comprehensive knowledge about the wider
business context in which the manager has to lead, perform, and make effective decisions.
Learning outcomes
Expectations
4|Page
1. Materials Access
All learning materials are provided in the form of a module kit and can be accessed from
the Learning Management system (LMS)
2. Learning Hours
3. Re-sit
If you do not secure a pass, please read closely the feedback and speak with your Course
leader(s) or faculty. After consulting the feedback, close attention is essential to rework
on the areas of weakness, and then resubmit the work at the next opportunity. As per the
QAA requirements, only one REDO is allowed where the marks will be capped at a Pass.
4. Plagiarism
All forms of plagiarism are taken seriously, and any suspected cases will be investigated
thoroughly. If a case is found proven then the work will be graded as a fail and the case
will be reviewed by the academic committee.
5|Page
5. Student appeals
There are no re-evaluations as the marks are graded and internally verified before release.
However, as per our appeals policy, a student can make an appeal to the course leader
which will be then reviewed by the academic committee (please check our academic
policies and procedures manual for more information)
General Guidelines
6|Page
Checklist
✘ The contents of my assignment have been submitted to Turnitin and I have attached
the Turnitin report
I acknowledge and adhere to the institution's AI Policy Statement, ensuring the ethical
and responsible use of AI tools, and confirm that all my submissions will reflect
✘
✘ I declare that all websites and AI tools utilized during the preparation of this
assignment comply with the AI Policy.
7|Page
can choose your own organization or another other organisation of your choice for writing this
report. Your report must be based in the following format:
Performance Descriptors
Performance descriptors indicate how marks will be arrived at against each of the above
criteria. The descriptors indicate the likely characteristics of work that is marked within the
percentage bands indicated.
(70-100%) (60-69%) (50-59%) D (40-49%) E (0-39%)
Work of an Work of a good Work of a pass Fail Fail
outstanding standard standard (Resubmission (Resubmission
standard allowed) not allowed)
Executive Exemplary Competent Basic compilation Weak compilation Poor compilation
Summary and compilation with compilation with with sufficient with sufficient with sufficient
Introduction detailed sufficient background on background on background on
(20%) background on background on concepts of HRM, concepts of HRM, concepts of HRM,
concepts of HRM, concepts of HRM, its functions, its functions, its functions,
its functions, its functions, linkage to SHRM linkage to SHRM linkage to SHRM
linkage to SHRM linkage to SHRM and organizational and organizational and organizational
and organizational and organizational performance. performance. performance.
performance. performance. Average links Superficial links Sketchy links
8|Page
Mature links made Sound links made made between made between made between
between relevant between relevant relevant ideas, relevant ideas, relevant ideas,
ideas, theories and ideas, theories and theories and theories and theories and
practice. Extensive practice. A practice. A very practice. An practice. No
range of relevant sufficient range of limited range of insufficient range relevant sources;
sources; those relevant sources; relevant sources; of relevant from among those
identified beyond from among those from among those sources; none from identified in
classroom identified in identified in among those classroom
sessions; are used. classroom classroom identified in sessions; are used.
An argumentative sessions; are used. sessions; are used. classroom No perspective is
perspective is An evocative A descriptive sessions; are used. presented in the
presented perspective is perspective is A vague interpretation of
demonstrating presented in the presented in the perspective is scope of staffing,
originality and interpretation of interpretation of presented in the development and
creativity in the scope of staffing, scope of staffing, interpretation of compensation. Too
interpretation of development and development and scope of staffing, many errors in
the scope of compensation. compensation. development and referencing or
staffing, Negligible errors Evident errors in compensation. grammar or
development and in referencing or referencing or Repeated errors in syntax.
compensation. No grammar or grammar or referencing or
obvious errors in syntax. syntax. grammar or
referencing or syntax.
grammar or
syntax.
Affect of SHRM An exceptional A good analysis of A basic analysis of A weak analysis of A poor analysis of
& HRM on Org analysis of the the literature is the literature is the literature is the literature is
Performance literature is developed. developed. developed. Mere developed. No
(20%) developed. Summarizes and Descriptive compilation of synthesis of the
Summarizes and shows sound presentation of the information. literature
shows insightful synthesis of the literature Includes no information.
synthesis of the literature information. identification and Identification and
literature information, Limited analysis of gaps. analysis of gaps is
information including identification but No linkage is absent. No linkage
including identification and no analysis of established among is established
identification and analysis of gaps. gaps. Average all the among all the
analysis of gaps. Good linkage is linkage is organizational organizational
Strong linkage is established among established among performance performance
established among all the few of the outcomes like outcomes like
all the organizational organizational growth, growth,
organizational performance performance profitability, ROI, profitability, ROI,
performance outcomes like outcomes like competitive competitive
outcomes like growth, growth, advantage, legal advantage, legal
growth, profitability, ROI, profitability, ROI, compliance, compliance,
profitability, ROI, competitive competitive strategic objectives strategic objectives
competitive advantage, legal advantage, legal attainment, and attainment, and
advantage, legal compliance, compliance, key stakeholder key stakeholder
compliance, strategic objectives strategic objectives satisfaction. satisfaction. Too
strategic objectives attainment, and attainment, and Repeated errors in many errors in
attainment, and key stakeholder key stakeholder referencing or referencing or
key stakeholder satisfaction. Dr. satisfaction. Dr. grammar or grammar or
satisfaction. Dr. Dave Ulrich’s Dave Ulrich’s syntax. syntax.
Dave Ulrich’s Strategic HR Strategic HR
Strategic HR Model is well Model is loosely
Model is clearly resonated. referred to.
synthesized. No Negligible errors Evident errors in
obvious errors in in referencing or referencing or
referencing or grammar or grammar or
grammar or syntax. syntax.
syntax.
Leadership The work The work A reasonably well The examination The examination
Practices (20%) thoroughly examines the examination of the of the scenario at of the scenario at
examines the scenario at the scenario at the the chosen the chosen
scenario at the chosen chosen organization is not organization is not
chosen organization. The organization. The well done. The well done. The
organization. The outcomes are outcomes are outcomes are outcomes are poor.
use of the good. The use of obvious and sketchy. The use The leadership
leadership models the leadership average. The use of the leadership models are not
9|Page
clearly bring out models clearly of the leadership models are evident used and hence the
the alignment of bring out the models are evident but the outcomes outcomes fail to
the strategic HR alignment of the but the outcomes somewhat fail to present the
activities to strategic HR are descriptive present the alignment of the
organizational activities to about the alignment of the strategic HR
goals and organizational alignment of the strategic HR activities to
objectives. Highly goals and strategic HR activities to organizational
practical objectives. Some activities to organizational goals and
justifications are sound organizational goals and objectives. Failure
provided. justifications are goals and objectives. Weak to provide
Illustrations and provided. objectives. justifications are justifications.
Tables are Illustrations and Considerable provided.
properly Tables are justifications are Illustrations and
captioned. captioned. provided. Tables are not
Illustrations and captioned.
Tables are not
necessarily
captioned.
Change An ability to The work The work There may be little No application of
Implementation successfully demonstrates a demonstrates a evidence of an theoretical
Plan (30%) synthesize willingness to competence to ability to apply principles to the
theoretical issues question and to explore issues and theoretical case scenario or a
into practice and explore issues and to synthesize principles to the wider context of
evaluate the to synthesize theoretical case scenario or a SHRM and
possible theoretical perspectives and wider context of Change Mgmt.
implications and perspectives and practical SHRM and Conclusions
lessons of SHRM practical application within Change Mgmt. unrelated and
and Change Mgmt. application within chosen case Conclusions confused or
Ideas are presented chosen context context of SHRM unrelated to the illogical and
in a succinct SHRM and and Change Mgmt. scenario. Lessons unsubstantiated.
manner and Change Mgmt. Some helpful learned either Lessons learned
conclusions are Some meaningful conclusions and superficial or either superficial
well reasoned well-reasoned acknowledgement lacking. or lacking.
which have conclusions and of lessons learned. Possibly no real
relevance to the attention given to attempt to address
scenario. lessons learned assignment brief in
which have respect of actual
relevance to the questions asked.
scenario.
Recommendation Well-organised, Well-organised, Reasonably well- Poor organisation; Assertions little
s and Conclusions logical, fully logical, supported organised, logical, gaps in reasoning; related to
(10%) supported by by evidence, generally some obvious evidence,
evidence, conclusions fairly supported by conclusions frequently illogical
conclusions clear clear and arise evidence, omitted for the list; or arbitrary;
and arise from from results & conclusions fairly other conclusions conclusions if
results/discussion; discussion; clear and arise not especially presented are
practical and practical and from results & driven by the disorganized;
feasible, with clear feasible, with clear discussion; findings but from alternatives not
consideration of consideration of practical and ‘common sense’. considered; no real
SHRM issues. SHRM issues. feasible, with No real understanding of
Recommendations Recommendations unclear or weak implications and the need to draw
driven by good driven by decent consideration of recommendations conclusions,
deductions from deductions from SHRM issues. weak and implications and
findings. findings. Recommendations incoherent. recommendations
not always driven from results.
by good
deductions.
10 | P a g e
(START WRITING YOUR ANSWER HERE…..)
11 | P a g e
Leadership plays a crucial role in Tesla’s success, with its CEO, Elon Musk, being a highly
influential and controversial figure. His leadership style is often described as visionary and
transformational, driving Tesla’s aggressive expansion and technological breakthroughs.
Unlike traditional automotive companies, Tesla follows an unconventional business model,
emphasizing direct sales, software-driven vehicle operations, and continuous innovation. Musk's
ability to inspire employees and push the limits of what is possible has positioned Tesla as one of
the most valuable companies in the world. However, his leadership approach has also been
criticized for being intense, demanding, and sometimes unpredictable, creating both
opportunities and challenges for the organization.
Tesla’s Human Resource Management (HRM) practices also contribute significantly to its
competitive edge. The company prioritizes talent acquisition, seeking highly skilled individuals
who can thrive in a fast-paced and innovation-driven environment. Tesla’s workforce is
encouraged to think creatively and challenge conventional industry norms. The HRM strategy
aligns with Tesla’s culture of continuous improvement, fostering an environment where
employees are expected to adapt to rapid changes and contribute to technological advancements.
However, the organization has faced criticism regarding employee burnout, high turnover rates,
and workplace culture challenges. Balancing innovation with employee well-being remains a
critical aspect of Tesla’s HR strategy.
Another key aspect of Tesla’s management is its approach to change and adaptation. The
automotive industry is evolving rapidly, with increasing demand for electric vehicles, stricter
environmental regulations, and advancements in autonomous driving technology. Tesla’s ability
to navigate these changes through strategic leadership and HRM practices has been a defining
factor in its success. The company’s willingness to take risks, implement new technologies, and
disrupt traditional market structures has solidified its reputation as an industry pioneer. However,
such rapid innovation also requires effective change management strategies to ensure smooth
transitions and employee alignment with organizational goals.
This report will explore Tesla’s strategic leadership and HRM practices in depth, analyzing how
the company leverages leadership theories, workforce management strategies, and change
management principles to maintain its competitive advantage. It will also examine the challenges
Tesla faces in terms of leadership decisions, employee relations, and organizational change.
12 | P a g e
Finally, recommendations will be provided to enhance Tesla’s HR strategies and leadership
approaches, ensuring sustainable growth and long-term success.
21 | P a g e
To mitigate resistance, Tesla must focus on better communication, employee engagement
initiatives, and leadership involvement in addressing concerns. Change should be positioned
as an opportunity for growth rather than a disruption to stability.
2. Operational and Production Bottlenecks
Tesla’s fast-paced innovation cycles sometimes lead to operational challenges, particularly in
manufacturing. The company has experienced production bottlenecks, supply chain
disruptions, and quality control issues, especially during the mass production phase of Model
3 and Model Y.
Addressing these challenges requires better supply chain management, enhanced automation,
and strategic partnerships with suppliers. Tesla must also adopt agile change management
frameworks, allowing it to adapt quickly without compromising quality.
3. Leadership-Driven Change and Communication Gaps
Tesla’s change initiatives are often driven by CEO Elon Musk, whose bold decisions and
ambitious goals shape the company’s direction. While his leadership inspires innovation and
rapid progress, it also creates communication gaps and challenges in aligning mid-level
management and employees with these changes.
To enhance change management effectiveness, Tesla should implement structured
communication strategies, ensuring that employees at all levels understand and embrace the
company’s vision. Leadership should also encourage employee feedback to improve workplace
morale.
4.4 Strategies for Effective Change Management at Tesla
To successfully manage change, Tesla implements several key strategies, including:
1. Agile Change Management Approach
Tesla follows an agile change management model, allowing it to adapt quickly to industry
trends and technological advancements. This approach ensures that incremental changes can
be made without disrupting overall operations.
2. Employee Training and Upskilling
As Tesla introduces new technologies and automation, it invests in employee training
programs to equip its workforce with the necessary skills. Continuous learning opportunities
help reduce resistance to change and enhance employee adaptability.
22 | P a g e
3. Transparent Communication
Tesla has improved its internal communication channels, ensuring that employees are aware
of upcoming changes, their impact, and how they can contribute. Regular town hall
meetings, internal newsletters, and leadership updates help align the workforce with Tesla’s
evolving goals.
4. Customer-Centric Change Management
Tesla’s change initiatives are always aligned with customer expectations and market
demands. Whether it's enhancing vehicle features, expanding service networks, or
improving battery technology, Tesla ensures that all transitions benefit the end consumer.
4.5 Conclusion
Tesla’s approach to change management has been instrumental in its rise as a market leader in
the electric vehicle and renewable energy industries. While the company has successfully
implemented major transformations, it has also faced challenges related to employee
resistance, operational bottlenecks, and communication gaps.
By adopting agile change management strategies, investing in workforce training, and
improving leadership communication, Tesla can navigate future transitions more
effectively. As the company continues to innovate and expand globally, managing change in a
structured and employee-friendly manner will be crucial for sustaining long-term success.
24 | P a g e
Reports indicate that some employees have experienced excessive workload pressure, minimal
work-life balance, and limited job security. Additionally, there have been allegations of harsh
disciplinary actions, where employees who fail to meet Tesla’s high standards face sudden
terminations or demotions.
2. Legal and Ethical Controversies
Tesla has been involved in multiple legal disputes and employee-related controversies. The
company has faced lawsuits regarding workplace discrimination, racial harassment, and
unfair labor practices. In some cases, employees have accused Tesla of fostering a toxic work
environment, where issues of gender inequality and racial bias have not been adequately
addressed.
Additionally, Tesla has been criticized for its stance on labor unions. Unlike many other
automotive companies, Tesla discourages unionization efforts, leading to conflicts with labor
advocacy groups. Critics argue that Tesla’s resistance to unions prevents employees from
negotiating better wages, working conditions, and job protections.
Conclusion
While Tesla remains a pioneering force in the EV and sustainable energy sectors, its
leadership and HRM practices have drawn criticism for being high-pressure, demanding,
and controversial. Addressing these challenges by fostering better employee relations,
improving workplace policies, and balancing innovation with employee well-being will be
essential for Tesla’s long-term sustainability and growth.
Conclusion
27 | P a g e
Tesla has established itself as a pioneer in the electric vehicle (EV) and renewable energy
industries, demonstrating an unwavering commitment to technological advancement,
innovation, and sustainability. Under the leadership of Elon Musk, the company has
revolutionized the automotive market by popularizing electric mobility, direct-to-consumer
sales, and cutting-edge manufacturing techniques. However, Tesla’s rapid growth and
unconventional strategies have brought challenges in leadership, human resource
management (HRM), and change management, all of which impact the company’s long-term
stability and success.
This report has analyzed Tesla’s leadership strategies, HRM practices, and change
management approaches, while also addressing challenges, criticisms, and potential
improvements. The key takeaways highlight Tesla’s strengths, areas of concern, and the
necessity for strategic refinements to maintain its competitive edge in a rapidly evolving
market.
7.1 Key Findings from Tesla’s Leadership and HRM Practices (200 words)
Tesla’s leadership is visionary yet controversial, driven by Elon Musk’s ambitious, high-
pressure management style. While his leadership has accelerated Tesla’s growth, it has also
led to concerns regarding workplace stress, high employee turnover, and executive
instability. The company’s rapid decision-making and aggressive production goals have
fostered an environment of innovation but also increased workforce strain.
In terms of HRM, Tesla has implemented non-traditional workforce management strategies,
prioritizing high-performance expectations and direct engagement with employees.
However, criticisms surrounding employee well-being, diversity, and labor relations indicate
that improvements are needed to enhance job satisfaction and organizational stability.
Tesla’s change management strategies have allowed the company to adapt to market trends,
optimize production, and expand globally. However, challenges such as employee resistance,
supply chain disruptions, and inconsistent communication have posed obstacles to seamless
transitions. Strengthening leadership transparency, employee engagement, and structured
HR policies can improve workplace morale and operational efficiency.
7.2 Recommendations for Tesla’s Future Growth (200 words)
28 | P a g e
To sustain its market dominance and organizational success, Tesla must adopt a more
balanced leadership and HRM approach. Implementing a structured leadership framework
with defined communication strategies and leadership development programs will help
ensure stability during transitions and minimize internal conflicts. Additionally, allowing
greater managerial autonomy will reduce over-reliance on Musk’s leadership, fostering a
more resilient organizational structure.
Tesla’s HRM practices should emphasize employee well-being, work-life balance, and
diversity initiatives. Introducing flexible work arrangements, structured performance
evaluation systems, and comprehensive training programs will enhance employee retention
and job satisfaction. Additionally, Tesla should actively address concerns related to labor
relations, anti-discrimination policies, and ethical workplace practices to create a more
inclusive and fair work environment.
Furthermore, improving change management strategies by integrating employee-driven
initiatives, proactive communication, and structured transition planning will help Tesla
navigate industry shifts more effectively. Establishing a stronger internal support system
will encourage employees to embrace change rather than resist it, improving long-term
adaptability.
7.3 Final Thoughts (100 words)
Tesla has disrupted the global automotive and energy industries, but sustaining long-term
growth and success requires a more structured and employee-centric approach. By refining
its leadership strategies, improving HRM practices, and enhancing change management
frameworks, Tesla can build a more sustainable, inclusive, and adaptive organization.
As the company continues to push the boundaries of innovation, prioritizing organizational
stability, ethical workforce management, and proactive leadership development will be
crucial in securing Tesla’s future as an industry leader. A well-balanced approach will enable
Tesla to drive both technological progress and employee satisfaction, ensuring continued
excellence in the years ahead.
References
29 | P a g e
Khan, M.A., 2021. A critical analysis of Elon Musk’s leadership in Tesla motors. Journal of
Innovation and Entrepreneurship, 10(1), pp.1-17. Available at:
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40497-021-00284-z.SpringerLink+1ResearchGate+1
Alshmrani, H.M., 2021. Tesla between challenges, opportunities and Human Resource
Management. Academia Arena, 13(9), pp.43-56. Available at:
http://www.sciencepub.net/academia/aaj130921/05_37436aaj130921_43_56.pdf.
Wessel, M., 2020. Lessons from Tesla’s Approach to Innovation. Harvard Business Review.
Available at: https://hbr.org/2020/02/lessons-from-teslas-approach-to-innovation.
Sacconaghi, A.M. Jr. and Wang, C., 2019. TSLA: Executive turnover at Tesla -- how bad is it
REALLY? Bernstein Research. Available at:
https://assets.empirefinancialresearch.com/uploads/2019/08/Executive-turnover-at-Tesla-how-
bad-is-it-REALLY.pdf.
Hawkins, A.J., 2023. Tesla’s ‘ultra hardcore’ work culture — as told by its employees. The
Verge. Available at: https://www.theverge.com/2023/8/16/23833447/tesla-elon-musk-ultra-
hardcore-employees-land-of-the-giants.
Meyer, P., 2019. Tesla’s Global Talent Strategy Research and Prospects. In: Proceedings of the
International Conference on Management Science and Industrial Engineering. Springer,
Singapore, pp. 1-6. Available at: https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-19-7826-
5_105.
Schreiber, M., 2021. The Toxic Culture at Tesla. The Nation. Available at:
https://www.thenation.com/article/society/tesla-racism-sexual-harassment/.
Wessel, M., 2020. How Tesla Sets Itself Apart. Harvard Business Review. Available at:
https://hbr.org/2020/02/how-tesla-sets-itself-apart.
30 | P a g e