oer03
oer03
Anthropology:
Holistic and Applied
Research on Being
Human
ISBN: 9798858723769
CONTENTS
Acknowledgments i
1 What is Anthropology 1
3 Research Methods 55
5 Primates 118
18 Religion 494
55
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
ethnography isn’t just a scientific method; it’s also an art form. Ethnography
teaches mindfulness, critical thinking, self-awareness, and cultural
relativity. We learn to be aware of our cultural lenses as we build
relationships, and we explore human creativity, experience, and meaning,
which involves the art of translation and interpretation. By documenting,
analyzing, writing about, and connecting or collaborating with people who
are culturally both similar to and different from ourselves, we learn about
human diversity while challenging our assumptions about “just the way things
are.”
Let’s start with a recent example of culture change: the use of masks
during the COVID-19 pandemic in communities across the United
States. Masks are interesting, because they show the ways in which elements
of culture, including symbols, values, beliefs, and behaviors, can be tangled
up together. For most people in the United States, wearing masks was
something new in our daily routines. We also had to fit them into our habits
and navigate a complex social world of meaning in spaces where masks were
either required, optional, or somewhere in between. During the pandemic,
one small article of clothing became a powerful and polysemic
symbol. Polysemic refers to multiple layers of meaning that symbols can
have. Over the course of the pandemic in 2020, battles over mask-wearing
symbolized a battle over values, identities, and norms during a time of
profound societal changes and challenges.
56
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
people’s social worlds. Starting with people also means approaching research
with cultural relativism, which is the idea that cultures must be understood
on their own terms and based on their own contexts instead of being judged
by the standards of a different culture. Often the things that are designed for
people (policies, products, or programs) don’t connect with the lived
experience of different people. Ethnography shifts focus towards peoples’
lived experiences and the ways they understand and interact with the world.
Anthropologists ask questions, and the kind of questions we ask, and who
we ask them of, varies depending on the research design. The ethnographer
figures out what details to record, and what questions to ask, because it
simply isn’t possible to notice, investigate, and describe everything. Early
fieldworkers in anthropology sought to understand as much as they could
about culture groups by investigating how different parts of culture and
society, such as religion, political organization, or kinship, all fit
together. Another primary focus of early fieldwork was salvage
ethnography: documenting and recording the practices and cultural beliefs
of groups threatened with assimilation or extinction by colonialism. While
the seeds of fieldwork methods began in these early contexts, anthropologists
have shifted away from conducting fieldwork that views cultures as isolated,
homogenous, and traditional. Today, most cultural anthropology is what we
call problem-oriented; that is, ethnographic research focused on a particular
issue or conflict.
57
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Preparation for research is an important step to help you figure out what
to focus on. Conducting a literature review involves investigating and
synthesizing existing scholarship, often for the purpose of clarifying your
own research questions, methods, and goals. Identifying the major findings
and debates on topics related to your work helps to refine a project’s focus.
58
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Identifying gaps in the scholarship is also useful for thinking about the
significant contributions your own research might make. For example, in
reviewing the literature on refugee education, Poole and Riggan discovered
that anthropologists who worked with refugee communities typically didn’t
focus on schools, so there wasn’t much ethnography done in these
settings. At the same time, the growing literature on refugee education from
other disciplines provided important insight on how many refugee youth
lacked access to schools, but ethnographic questions such as “What does
school mean for refugees?” weren’t really being asked. In the case that
refugee students did have access to schools, why weren’t they all going?
59
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
60
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
themselves (see Figures 3.1 & 3.2). Interview questions are often open-
ended. Instead of asking for yes-no responses to specific questions, they ask
interviewees to share their thoughts and experiences. For example: rather
than asking, “Has your life as a student changed during the pandemic?”; you
would instead ask, “How has your life as a student changed during the
pandemic? Can you share an example?” The first question would elicit a
simple yes or no answer, the second questions would potentially elicit a
response with more detail and reflection.
A survey involves asking the same set of questions to everyone that you
sample, often in the form of a questionnaire. If it is not possible to survey
everyone in the population, a random sample with enough participants can
produce data that can be generalized to the entire group. For example,
anthropology students in the Indiana University of Pennsylvania’s
Environmental Anthropology class worked with the local community garden
for one year. The Indiana Borough community garden is comprised entirely
of volunteers who apply for garden plots each season. Students did
participant observation at the garden to learn about the use of this space, and
the kind of community that took shape around it. They interviewed garden
leaders and members about why they participated in the garden, how it was
meaningful to them, and what their aspirations were. They then conducted
a survey to see how widespread these ideas were across all garden
members. The survey also gave students a portrait of how diverse the garden
61
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
members were across social class, race, ethnicity, and gender. This data
helped inform the garden leadership in their efforts to diversify their
members and deepen their role within the community.
62
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
63
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
64
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
65
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Video 3.2. Check out the video about TED talk featuring
Chimamanda Adichie discussing the dangers of a single
story online for more details!
66
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
67
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Telling Time
68
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
element—Carbon 12—such that over time, there is more C12 than C14 in
the sample relative to the atmosphere today. While there are a few things
that can complicate radiometric dating, such sample contamination and
modern fossil fuel emissions, it remains a reliable and dependable way to date
archaeological sites. Radiometric dating can be expensive, however, and so
archaeologists often depend on relative dating as well. Relative dating
means that we can determine the age of an archaeological layer or artifact
based on whether it is older or younger relative to something else. Below,
we describe two common methods of relative dating: stratigraphy and
seriation.
Beneath the ground surface, there are layers of soil that correspond with
different times in the past. Stratigraphy is the study of sediment layers in
the ground. Developed in geology, this technique allows archaeologists to
recognize different cultural and natural events in the past. You can identify
past ground surfaces, old fire hearths, the remnants of cellars, old walls and
structures, and natural events like flooding or volcanic activity. By excavating
into the soil, layers of dirt are revealed by different colors, thicknesses,
textures, and artifact contents. These layers resemble layers of a cake with
multiple layers of icing and cake (see Figure 3.5). These stratigraphic layers
act as time capsules of past activities that retain information of both cultural
and non-cultural events.
69
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
70
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Figure. 3.6. Schematic battleship curves for station wagons and SUVs (a)
and hypothetical curves and accompanying frequencies for archaeological
ceramic vessels (b). Adapted from Homsey-Messer et al. (2020: Figure 13.1)
Figure 3.7. Evolution of the BMW 5 series over time. Adapted from
Homsey-Messer et al. (2020: Figure 13.1).
71
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Theoretical Perspectives
72
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
underlying processes that shape culture. For example, they may be interested
in revealing the general process societies undergo that lead to social inequality
or the development of farming. Processual methods use the scientific
method: stating a hypothesis, testing the hypothesis with scientific
techniques, and using that to interpret past behaviors. We’ll discuss a critique
to processual archaeology later called post-processualist, but first, let’s look
at two processual approaches that have made a significant impact on the field
as a whole: ethnoarchaeology and experimental archaeology.
Ethnoarchaeology
73
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
74
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Rapa Nui, also known as Easter Island, is one of the most remote islands
in the world. It is 2,300 miles west of South America, and 1,100 miles from
the next closest island (see Figure 3.8). Yet, Polynesian explorers reached the
volcanic island more than 1,200 years ago. They settled on the island, and
human populations and cultures thrived for hundreds of years. They had no
industrialized or mechanized labor, yet there are engineering feats at Rapa
Nui that elude researchers to this day.
Figure 3.8. Location of Rapa Nui in the Pacific Ocean (left) and the famous
moai statues (right). Images from Wikimedia Commons.
75
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
One of the most intriguing mysteries of Rapa Nui is the large moai
statues. The moai are anthropomorphic statues made of stone that stand, on
average, 13-ft tall (range 3.8-71.9 ft) and weigh 14-tons (maximum 165
tons). They were carved from stone originating at the main quarry on the
island, and nearly 900 moai can be found across the island. Some are still at
the quarry, while others are located along the coast, facing inland with their
backs to the water. Still, others are “in transit” between the quarry and the
coast.
Researchers have long been puzzled about how the local populations were
able to move these massive statues across the island with limited tools and
materials. The island is not flat, and even the most optimal routes from the
quarry to the coast include miles of rough, hilly terrain. According to local
oral histories, the gods ordered the moai to walk to the coast. Researchers
initially discounted these beliefs and, instead, employed experimental
archaeology and tried various methods using rope and wood. For example,
one study included dragging a moai on wooden sleds. While 180 people
could move a smaller, 10-ton moai this way, researchers estimated that 1,500
people would have been required to move the largest moai. Would so many
people have been available to move the moai? Another study involved using
tree trunks as rollers, and this method provided a way to move the moai up
hills. Finally, several researchers decided to try to walk a statue, as described
in folklore, by using ropes to balance the moai upright and rocked the statue
in a walking motion, like a seesaw. These experimental archaeological
approaches allow researchers to engage with archaeological materials, relate
to them on a more personal level, and find creative ways to help interpret the
mysteries of the past.
76
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
adoption of farming. Rather, they argue that every culture has its own
historic context and, therefore, must be studied on its own merits. They also
focus more on the lived human experience, often seeking to find the voices
of groups marginalized or underrepresented in the written record such as
illiterate groups, poor or low-status individuals, or minorities. If history is
written by the victors, then what was never recorded or misrepresented about
other groups? Archaeologists seek to expose the untold truths behind
written records or stereotypical beliefs about people and cultures. A good
example of such a perspective in the Market Street Chinatown Archaeology
Project mentioned previously.
For several decades, archaeologists debated the pros and cons of the
processual and post-processual perspectives. This debate was often heated,
with folks squarely landing on one side or the other. Today, most
archaeologists recognize that this dichotomy is an over-simplification, and
many argue that we need to keep both perspectives in mind. They also note
that a post-processual approach need not preclude using the scientific
method. Today, many archaeologists would argue that they practice a blend
of these two approaches that some have dubbed the “processual-plus”
approach.
Ethics in Archaeology
77
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Summary
78
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Review Questions
Discussion Questions
• Can you think of ways you are an anthropologist in your daily life,
or a time when you’ve had to talk to people different from
you? Maybe you participated in a new activity like a church event or
sport. In what way did talking to people and participating help give
you an emic perspective?
• Why are ethical considerations and practices like informed consent
important in ethnographic research?
• An issue that arises with ethnoarchaeology is that anthropologists
cannot directly observe the past. Instead, we must hope that the
living people they observe are good surrogates for the archaeological
culture. Discuss the pros and cons of using ethnoarchaeology to
understand the past. Think about the geographic distance between
cultures, the difference in time, and the fact that no culture is static
but constantly changing.
• What are some dangers in using seriation to relatively date
artifacts? Think about how the popularity of styles may vary
geographically, even within a single culture? What happens if an
item has a second wave of popularity, decades, or centuries after the
first wave?
79
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Activities
80
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
2. Material Culture
• Stratigraphic Analysis: Go to
https://la.utexas.edu/users/denbow/labs/lab1-
strat2.htm(opens in a new tab) and arrange the strata
from oldest to youngest. Then, answer the questions
provided about the features and artifacts present.
• Seriation: Think of three “artifacts” popular during your
lifetime. These can be physical items (e.g., iPhone),
social media apps (e.g., Snapchat), items of clothing (e.g.,
skinny jeans), vehicles (e.g., Tesla), etc. On a piece of
paper, label a vertical axis with date ranges, starting
about ten years before you were born, and going every
year (or every five years if space is limited). For artifact
one, draw a line to approximate the popularity of that
artifact. If it is very popular, draw a long line. If it is
unpopular, draw a short line, or none if appropriate.
Make the lines relative, such that they get longer the
more popular an artifact is, and shorter the less popular
an artifact is. When done, do you see the battleship
curve, or at least a portion of it?
• Campus Garbology: Download or sketch a map of your
campus. Over the next couple days, record the
provenience (i.e., location) of “artifacts”—that is,
trash—that you encounter as you move around campus
(you do NOT have to pick it up!). As you find it, record
the type of raw material (e.g., plastic, paper, metal, glass,
Styrofoam etc.), and note whether it is trash related to
subsistence (e.g., food consumption), domestic life,
academic life, and any other category you might think of
(e.g., pet, beauty/health). Even better, have several
friends do this. Then compile your data onto the map.
Imagine you are excavating this “site” millennia from
now, long after physical colleges and universities have
81
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
82
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Key Terms
Ethnoarchaeology: The study of material artifacts of the past along with the
observation of modern peoples who have knowledge of the use and symbolic
meaning of those artifacts, to interpret archaeological patterns.
83
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
84
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
85
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
86
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Survey: Asking the same set of questions to a selected group often in the
form of a questionnaire.
87
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Suggested Readings
Cultural Anthropology
Chin, E., Cox, A.M., Davis, D.A., Marshall, A., Marshall, R. and
Ramsey, K., 2014. Katherine Dunham: Recovering an Anthropological
Legacy, Choreographing Ethnographic Futures. SAR Press.
Emerson, R.M., Fretz, R.I. and Shaw, L.L., 2011. Writing ethnographic
fieldnotes. University of Chicago Press.
Vivanco, L.A., 2016. Field notes: A guided journal for doing anthropology.
Oxford University Press.
Archaeology
88
Introduction to Anthropology: Holistic and Applied Research on Being Human
Videos
Doing Anthropology.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BhCruPBvSjQ
89